SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 58
Larkspur Financial Advisors
 Asset Management & Financial Planning



B E H AV I O R A L F I NA NC E & YOU R C L I E NTS

               P R E S E N TAT I O N T O :
                             A
          C A L I F O R N I A C PA S F / M A R I N
               DISCUS SION GROUP

                          P R E S E N T E D B Y:
                     VINCENT J. CRIVELLO
            F I N A NC I A L A DV I S O R & P R I NC I PA L

                          J U LY 1 6 , 2 0 0 8
Agenda
                                                                       2

     Background
          g
     Introduction to Behavioral Finance
     Managing Clients & Expectations
           gg              p
     Q&A




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Background
                                                                     3




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Background: About Me
                                                                     4

     Current
           Financial Advisor and Owner with Larkspur Financial
           Advisors—an independent advisory firm founded in 1968
           Comprehensive Financial Planning and Asset Management for
                p                             g              g
           individuals, families, and small businesses
           Target Market: “Millionaire next door” and the mass affluent
     Past
           NorthStar Systems: Wealth Management Consulting
           Charles Schwab: Business & Product Management in Schwab’s
           retail advisory di i i (P i
               il d i      division (Private Cli
                                             Client, M
                                                     Managed P f li )
                                                           d Portfolios)
           Marketing & Industry Research: Multi-channel consumer
           marketing strategies with an emphasis in financial services


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Background: About Investors
                                                                             5

     A 2003 Schwab consumer survey found that “Despite the
     warnings of economists and money management experts
     that Americans need to pay more attention to their
     finances…”
           93 percent said they planned to have an annual medical or dental check-up.
                                                                              check up.
           Nearly half (47 percent) of those polled would rather do laundry than
           carefully read their investment statement even though many investors may
           be seeing some improvement in their portfolios.
           Only 38 percent of those surveyed said they planned an annual face-to-face
                                                                          face to face
           meeting with their broker or financial advisor.
           Investors who work with a financial advisor are almost twice as likely to
           cancel an appointment with their advisor (22 percent) than they are to
           cancel a car service appointment ( 3 p
                                 pp          (13 percent).
                                                        )
           Only 22 percent of respondents ranked quot;investmentsquot; as among their top
           three priorities in 2004.
     Source: http://www.businesswire.com/portal/site/schwab/index.jsp?ndmViewId=news_view&ndmConfigId=1009915&newsId=20050916005258&newsLang=en




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Background: The Results
                                                                                          6


                                                    EQUITY MARKET RETURNS VS VS.
                                                   EQUITY MUTUAL FUND INVESTOR
                                                        RETURNS* (1985-2004)

                                                                 13.2%




                                                                                                    3.7%


                                                              S&P 500                       Average
                                                               Index                       Equity Fund
                                                                                            Investor
                                       *SOURCE: Dalbar, Inc. Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior - 2005. Represents average
                                       annually compounded returns of equity indices vs equity mutual fund investors; based on the
                                       length of time shareholders actually remain invested in a fund and the historic performance of the
                                       funds appropriate index. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investors cannot
                                       invest directly in an index.

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Behavioral Finance
                                                                     7




                          quot;SHARE PRICES ARE DRIVEN BY
                               FEAR AND GREED.quot;
                                     - JOHN MAYNARD KEYNES




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz
                                                                        8

     I would rate my driving abilities as…
                   y       g
           Below average
           Average
           Better than average
           B       h
     Please jot down your answer—we’ll come back to this
     later in the session




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Standard Theory of Finance (Efficient Markets)
                                                                     9

     The Standard Theory of Finance states:
           Investors
           I
             Are rational beings
             Consider all information and accurately assess its meaning
             Make decisions that maximize wealth while minimizing risk
           Markets
             Quickly incorporate all known information
             Reflect the collective actions of rational investors
             Represent the true value of all securities
     Industry Developments over the past few decades:
           Diversification through Asset Allocation
                                g
           Portfolio Design & Efficient Frontier (MPT)
           Mutual Funds
           Index funds and ETFs


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Why Behavioral Finance?
                                                                     10

     If we always behaved rationally…
           Nobody would ever sell stocks in a panic at the first sign of trouble
           Nobody would ever buy stocks (or other investments) based on
           hunches, hot tips or media hype
                    ,     p              yp
           Nobody would ever keep money in the bank instead of using it to pay
           off high-interest credit card balances
     Harvard found that humans are not “wired” to make
                                        wired
     rational decisions:
           Human beings are simply not good at accurately calculating odds
           Left to our own regards, we make the same mistakes over and over
           again.



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Behavioral Finance
                                                                     11

     Behavioral Finance provides an ‘overlay’ to the Standard
     Theory.
     Theory It provides a framework to understand
     ‘non-rational’ investor and market behaviors…
     Investors
           Are
           A not totally rational
                       ll   i   l
           Often act based on imperfect information
           Make “non-rational” decisions in predictable ways
     Markets
     M kt
           May be difficult to beat in the long term
           In the short term, there are anomalies and excesses
     The t
     Th two aspects of b h i l fi
                 t f behavioral finance are:
           The behavior of investors
           The behavior of markets


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Our Brains…
                                                                      12
                        Dough v. Dope                                               Greed vs. Gain




                                                                           Source: Hans Breiter, Harvard Medical School Brian Knutson, Sanford University, Jason
                                                                           Zweig (Author) Your Money & Your Brain



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Guess Who?
                                                                     13




           “Greed, for l k of a
            G d f lack f
       better word, i good.”
       b         d is    d

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Answer: Gordon Gecko
                                                                     14




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Behavioral Characteristics
                                                                     15
     Loss aversion                                                        Media response
     Disposition effect
      i     ii    ff                                                      Herding
                                                                             di
     Narrow framing                                                       Optimism
     Mental
     M t l accountingti                                                   Overconfidence
                                                                          O       fid
     Regret                                                               Anchoring
     Hindsight bias                                                       Recency




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Loss Aversion: Pop Quiz
                                                                     16

     A friend wants to make a bet with you. If y accept
                                       y       you     p
     the bet you will have a 50% chance of losing $10,000
     and a 50% chance of winning $_______.
     How much would you want to have a chance of
     winning before you would take the bet?

     Please right down your number




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Loss Aversion: The Disproportion of Gain & Loss
                                                                                                                    17

     Most people want to g
           pp             gain between 2 and 2.5 times as
                                               5
     much as they put at risk. So most people will want a
     chance to win $20,000 before they will play.
     Practical Example:
           Between 1926 and 2000*                                                                                                                            Question: Why would
                                                                                                                                                             anyone invest in bonds?
                                                                                                                                                               y
                   Stocks returned 8% (real)
                   Bonds returned 2% (real)
           The answer is loss aversion: The less frequently you evaluate
           stocks, the less risky they appear. People tend to evaluate
           stocks as if they had a short time horizon.
           *Source of data: Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation 2001 Yearbook. Ibbotson Associates, Chicago (annually updates work by Roger G. Ibbotson and Rex a Sinquefield). Used with permission. All rights reserved. Stocks are
           represented by the S&P 500 C
                      db h              Composite S k I d
                                                i Stock Index, an unmanaged i d widely regarded as an i di
                                                                               d index id l       dd          indicator of d
                                                                                                                         f domestic stock performance. S&P 500 performance i l d reinvestment of di id d b d
                                                                                                                                  i     k    f                      f         includes i            f dividends but does not take sales
                                                                                                                                                                                                                               k    l
           charges or taxes into consideration. Bonds represented by long-term government bonds are measured using a one-bond portfolio with a maturity near twenty years. Cash represented by U.S. Treasury bills is measured by
           rolling over each month a one-bill portfolio containing, at the beginning of each monthly, the bill having the shortest maturity not less than one month. An investment in common stocks will fluctuate with changes in market
           conditions. An investment in government bonds and Treasury bills are guaranteed by the U.S. Government and, if held to maturity, all bonds offer both a fixed rate of return and fixed principal value. Past performance of stock
           and bond indexes is no indication of their future results.



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Loss Aversion: How Investors see risk
                                                                     18

     Clients view risk differently than p
                                 y      professionals
     Focus on fear of losing money, not mathematics or
     abstract concepts like ‘time-weighted returns’
     Client’s risk profile changes over time
     Two time horizons
           Long-term (an abstraction)
           Short-term (the real standard)
     Self-assessed vs. actual risk t l
     S lf        d       t l i k tolerance



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Loss Aversion: The Importance of Time
                                                                     19




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Disposition Effect
                                                                     20

     The disposition effect refers to p p
            p                         people’s tendency to:
                                                      y
           Hang on to losers
           Sell the winners
     This allows them to enjoy the feeling of winning and
     defer the pain of loss
     Investors are about 1.5 times more likely t sell
     I     t        bt       ti           lik l to ll
     winning stocks as they are to sell losing stocks
     Behaviors:
           “I’m going to wait for the stock to come back to $15/share.”



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Narrow Framing: Trees vs. Forest
                                                                     21

     Would you accept this gamble…
           50% chance to win $15,000
           50% chance to lose $10,000
     Most people would say “no” because they want a
                              no
     chance to win at least twice what they might lose.
     Assume you have a net worth of $ million. Would
             y                       $2
     you accept the gamble now?
           50% chance that your wealth increases $15,000
           50% chance that your wealth decreases $10 000
                                                 $10,000
     Most people say “yes.” They become less risk averse
     as their frame of reference broadens.

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Narrow Framing: Aggregation
                                                                     22

     Would you flip a coin if…
           You get $15,000 if you win
           You pay $10,000 if you lose
     Again,
     Again most people would say “no ” but
                                  no, but…
           What if you got to flip the coin 100 times?
           Most people would say “yes.” Loss aversion is diminished by
           aggregation.
                    i
     Implications:
           Time ‘in the market’ is critical.
                 in     market
           100 months in the market (like 100 flips of a coin) creates a
           quasi-aggregation effect


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Mental Accounting: The “House Money Effect”
                                                                     23

           You have just won $30. Choose between:
                    j         3
1.
           A. 50% chance to win $9 and
              50% chance to lose $9
           B. No further bets
           BNf h b
                           70% of participants chose A
2 You have not won anything. Choose between:
                          anything
2.
   A. 50% chance to win $39 and
      50% chance to win $21
   B. A sure gain of $30
                     43% of participants chose A


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Mental Accounting: 401k Plans
                                                                     24

     In retirement plans that do not offer company stock
     as an option, the average allocation is:
           49% stocks
                                                                          49% Equities
           51% fixed income
     In plans that do offer company stock, the average
     allocation is:
           42% company stock
                                                                          71% Equities
           29% other stock
           29% fixed income
     Company stock is placed in a separate “mental
     account” from the other options

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Regret: Omission vs. Commission
                                                                     25

     Q
     Question: Who is more upset, Mr. Q or Ms. R?
                            p,
           Omission: Mr. Q owns shares of Company A. He considers
           selling his shares and buying stock in Company B, but decides
           against it He now finds he would have been better off by
                    it.
           $20,000 if he had switched to Company B.
           Commission: Ms. R owns shares in Company B, but switched
           to Company A She fi d she would h
           tC            A. Sh finds h       ld have b
                                                     been b tt off b
                                                          better ff by
           $20,000 if she had kept her shares of Company B.
     Answer: Ms. R. People typically regret errors of
                       p yp        yg
     commission more than errors of omission.


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Regret & Hindsight Bias
                                                                     26

     The inevitability of past events
           Events that happen seem predictable
           Events that do not happen will seem unlikely
     People distort their own past beliefs
           “I always knew…”
           Past beliefs are reconciled with actual
           events
     People take credit for good outcomes
     and blame others for bad outcomes
     (this is also related to optimism and
     overconfidence)

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Media Response
                                                                     27




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Media Response
                                                                     28

     Investors often feel the need to react to new information
     Study of the effects of news on investment decisions:
           Two groups: one received news and one did not
           The
           Th groups with no news outperformed th group th t received news
                       ith            tf       d the     that    id
     News is often irrelevant to long-term performance and is
     often misinterpreted
                   p
     News sources are often perceived as ‘authoritative’
     sources which impacts behavior
     Real World: “Put my entire portfolio in cash—this
     hurricane season is going to kill the market.”


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Media Response: Market Timing
                                                                     29




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Herding
                                                                       30

     Investors have a tendency toward “herd behavior”
                               y
     They may even disregard their own beliefs to follow
     the herd
     Study of the effects of herd behavior:
           Participants were asked to answer easy questions about the
           lengths of li
           l   th f lines
           About 1/3 changed their answers to be part of the herd
     Real World: Disproportionate flow of money into
     top-rated funds despite ratings’ lack of predictive
     abilities

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Herding: Reading the ‘stars’
                                                                             31


             5-Year Performance                                                         Next 5-Year Period
               6/30/92 – 6/30/97                                                        6/30/97 – 6/30/02


                                                                               21%       Top Quartile
                Top Quartile
                                                                               14%       2nd Quartile
                                                                               14%        3rd Quartile
                2nd Quartile
                                                                               50%     Bottom Quartile
                 3rd Quartile

            Bottom Quartile                                          Past performance is a very poor predictor of future
                                                                     results.
                                                                     Odds are against top quartile managers performing
                                                                     in top quartile during the next period and only 50/50
                                                                          pq              g          p             y   /
                                                                     to be above the median for the next 5 years.


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Optimism & Overconfidence
                                                                     32

     People believe it is likely that:                                     People are overconfident
                                                                           about what they know
           Good things will h
           G d thi       ill happen t
                                    to
           them                                                            Even when “certain,” they are
                                                                           often wrong…
           Bad things will happen to
           others                                                                20% e d up be g incorrect
                                                                                  0% end p being co ec
     Others are more likely to:                                                  (@ 98% certainty level)*
                                                                                 10%-15% end up being
           Become an alcoholic
                                                                                 incorrect when “absolutely
           Have a heart attack
                                                                                 sure
                                                                                 sure”*
           Develop
           D l cancer
                                                                           They underestimate the
     Others are less likely to:                                            uncertainty of events
           Become rich
                                                                           “This time it’s different.”
           Become famous
                                                                           –1999 B bbl Investor
                                                                                  Bubble I
     Warren Buffet once said,
     “Optimism is the enemy of the                                        A related tendency is that of overconfidence. Fact is, people are often

     rational buyer”                                                      unjustifiably overconfident in assessing their abilities and what they know
                                                                          about the world around them. Studies show that people are wrong about 20%
                                                                          of the time when asked to estimate things with a 98% confidence level and by
                                                                          10% to 15% when asked to be “absolutely sure” of their answers. The result is
                                                                          that people often underestimate the uncertainty of events and believe that
                                                                          they are much better at assessing future possibilities than they really are.


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Overconfidence: “We’re all above average”
                                                                     33

     People tend to overestimate their abilities
     90% believe they are above average in…
                 Driving ability
                 Sense of humor
                 Getting along with others
     They misperceive their ability to control events
     They seek confirmation of their abilities and find it in
     random events
     Whoever first said, “Don’t confuse brains with a bull
     market” probably was a student of behavioral finance.
     Real World: “Rising tide floats all boats.” The real test of
     ability is in a sideways or down market
                                      market.

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Overconfidence: Real World
                                                                     34

     Two types of client
           Trader: Speculated on price. Traded often.
           Investor: Buy & Hold. Fundamental focus.
     Stocks sold outperformed those purchased by:

                      “Trader”                                                   “Investor”
     After 12 months:      3.2%
                           3 2%                                                      5.0%
                                                                                     5 0%
     After 24 months:      3.6%                                                      8.6%


     The higher the turnover, in general, the worse the results.

                                                                      *Source: American Economic Review 1999, Terrance Odean, Associate
                                                                      Professor of Finance at the University of California at Davis


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Anchoring
                                                                     35

     Take the last three numbers of your Social Security
     number and add 400. Insert the sum i place of [d ]
         b      d dd              h       in l      f [date]
     below.

     Attila and the Huns invaded Europe and penetrated deep
     into what is now France where they were defeated and
     forced to return eastward
                      eastward.

     1. Did these events occur before or after [date] AD?
        ______ Before       ______ After

     2 .In what year did Attila s defeat occur? ______
        In               Attila’s

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Anchoring
                                                                       36

     Answer: 451 AD
             45

     Research Results:
     Anchor                                                          Mean Answer
       400-599                                                             626
       600-799
       600 799                                                             660
       800-999                                                             789
       1000-1199                                                           865
       1200-1399                                                           988
                                                                            88




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Anchoring
                                                                         37

     “Anchors” affect an investor’s frame of reference
     Can you think of common investment anchors?
           S&P 500 Index
           Dow Jones Industrials
           Performance benchmarks
           CNN
           Cocktail party chatter
     Behaviors
           “I’ll sell the stock when it gets back to $20”
           “I’m t i to ll
           “I’ not going t sell my h    home f THAT price!”
                                              for           i !”
           “I’ll sell the real estate now to lock in the long-term capital gains rate
           prior to the election.”


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Recency Effect
                                                                     38

     When do people buy burglar alarms?
              pp      y    g
     Behaviors
           Acting on momentum or a run-up in price (aka chasing
           returns)
                 Real Estate (2002-2006)
                 Gold
                 Oil
                 BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China)
           Wanting to go to cash in volatile markets the markets will
                                             markets—the
           keep going down.
           Client has to get into the action


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Recency & Overconfidence
                                                                                         39

     For the period between 1986 and 2006, which asset classes
     represent Investments A and B:
                                                                                                                                                    End value of
                                                                                                                                                       $
                                                                                                                                                       $100
                                                 Return                           Inflation                      Real Return                        investment
        Investment A                               11.9%                               3.0%                               8.9%                               $951
        Investment B                                55
                                                    5.5%                               3
                                                                                       3.0%                               2.5%
                                                                                                                            5                               $9
                                                                                                                                                            $292

     Clue #1: In 2006, the ‘herds’ wanted a piece of this action—
     many jumped into these markets we’re now hearing about.
     Clue #2: Homeowners would have answered this wrong
     back in 2006.

                                                                     Source: JP Morgan, BEA, S&P. S&P includes dividends. Past performance is not indicative of future results.


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Behavioral Finance: Key points
                                                                     40

     Anticipation of gain (greed) is more satisfying than the
     actual gain
     Pain of loss has a larger emotional impact than the pleasure of gain
     Investors lose confidence in markets due to the media response,
     herding, and anchoring effects
            g,               g
     Excessive conservatism and aversion to risk is exacerbated by
     narrow framing, mental accounting and short time horizons
     Investor overconfidence, optimism and minimization of
     uncertainties create i fl t d egos
           t i ti       t inflated
     Investors often repeat predictable, destructive behaviors and don’t
     learn from past mistakes

     Bottom line: These behaviors and reacting to ‘recency’ events leads
     to lower overall returns over the long-term.



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Guess who?
                                                                     41




            “I got my mind on my
             I
            money and my money
                on my mind ”
                       mind.

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Answer: Snoop Dogg
                                                                     42




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Managing Clients
                                                                     43




                               GOALS, OBJECTIVES, &
                                  EXPECTATIONS




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Look Inward First
                                                                     44

     Recognize that behavioral issues affect us all—
           g
     including financial advisors, institutional money
     managers, and individual investors
     Do a self-assessment to determine what behaviors
     you’ve exhibited and how it may impact the advice
     you provide clients or the advice your clients have
                   clients—or
     received from other advisors
     Challenge the financial advisors you work with—see
                                                 with see
     if their advice and recommendations are influenced
     by latent behavioral biases

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Helping your Clients: Questions to Ask
                                                                     45

     When your clients ask…
           “How do you think my account did last year?
            How                                  year?”
           “What do you think of the job my financial advisor has done?”
           “How do I know if my investment advisor is doing a good job?”
           “The market is tanking—should I fire my advisor? Do it on my own?”
     You should answer…
           If they’re working with an advisor:
                 What’s does your financial plan state? What are the assumptions?
                 What are your return requirements to meet your financial goals?
                 What are your portfolio’s objectives? What are the return and risk parameters in your IPS?
           If they’re managing their own investments:
                 What are your benchmarks? How do you define success? How do you know when you’re doing
                 well?
                 Are you using time-weighted returns to measure progress?
                 Do you have a sell strategy in p
                    y                     gy place?
     Ask to take a look at your client’s other financial documents:
           Financial Plan
           Investment Policy Statement (IPS)
           Q
           Quarterly Performance Report
                   y                p
           Consolidated Net Worth Statement

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Reviewing their Financial Plan
                                                                     46




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Reviewing the IPS
                                                                     47
     A well-formed Policy Statement
     should include these items:
           Goals & Objectives
           Time Horizon
           Risk tolerance
           Liquidity or distribution needs
           Tax rates
           Asset Allocation requirements
           Client preferences or constraints
           Return Expectations (often inflated):
                 Consumers: 10.4%-14%
                 Institutional Mgrs: 8.0%
           Expected volatility/risk
           Methodologies and selection criteria
           Monitoring, benchmarks, & evaluation
           criteria
     The advisor should also factor in
     other assets:
           401k/Qualified Plans
           Investment Real Estate
           Non-correlated Assets such as
           Managed Futures
For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Monitoring the Plan
                                                                     48
What’s relevant:
           What’s are the return/risk
                                  /
           objectives of the portfolio?
           What’s “time-weighted
           performance” (TWR) since
           inception (net of all fees and
           expenses)?
           How has the portfolio
           performed vs. its benchmark?
           How are the assets performing
                      h             f   i
           vs. the financial plan?
What’s irrelevant:
           Monthly statements
           Gain/loss reporting
           Specific winners or losers



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Sample Performance Reports
                                                                     49




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Sample Performance Reports
                                                                     50




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
A word about Benchmarks…
                                                                     51

     Benchmarks are a contentious topic in the industry. There’s
     no clear accepted means of benchmarking financial or
     portfolio performance for individual investors (despite what
     the academics say).
     The following benchmarks are generally the best ones to help
     you answer your client’s question, “How am I doing?”:
           Financial Plan: rate of return required to achieve goal
           Portfolio’s Expected Return (e.g. CPI + 6%) vs. actual Time-weighted
           return
           Standard Deviation or Volatility
           Composite benchmark (e.g. S&P500, Lehman Aggregate, MSCI EAFE)
           which could include peers or a ‘passive’ p
                                p           p       portfolio of index funds and
           ETFs
     Remember the ‘qualitative’ benchmark—how a client feels
     about his or her portfolio is also important. In other words,
     how is the j
     h   i th journey?  ?

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Getting from point A to point B…
                                                                                        52

                   Mr. Smith’s                                                                                        Mr. Jones’
             American Funds Portfolio                                                                           American Funds Portfolio

Washington Mutual                                                    60%                         Growth Fund of Amer.                         60%

Intermediate Bond of Am.                                             40%                         High Income Fund                             40%

Beta:                                                                0.43                        Beta:                                       0.74

Standard Deviation:                                                  7.81                        Standard Deviation:                        12.81

Worst year return:                                           -7.14%                              Worst Year Return:                         -21.50%



 Extra Credit: Based on what you’ve learned, Is Mr. Smith or Mr. Jones more
 likely to give up on their plan?
Analysis based on Morningstar Principia Data from 09/30/1996-9/30/2006. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Summary: Managing Clients
                                                                     53

           The Financial Plan: Helps clients focus on the big picture
1.
                 Strategic, Long-term
                 Strategic Long term goals
                 Reorients them towards goal attainment not reactive portfolio tinkering or trading
                 Achieving the financial goal(s) is ultimately what matters to clients
           Investment Policy & Design: Drives disciplined, rational decision-making
2.
                 Provides rational guidance and parameters that drive investment decision making and
                 changes
                 Provides a framework through which one can measure ‘success’
                 Allows the incorporation of strategies or products that mitigate downside volatility
                 (hedging, absolute return, non-correlated assets) and/or approaches that allow for
                 ‘satellite’ or speculative opportunities (e g have your cake and eat it too)
                  satellite                               (e.g.
           Plan Monitoring: Tracking towards objectives
3.
                 Consistent, risk-adjusted performance net of fees, expenses, and taxes is presumed—this
                 is not a differentiator. Investment advisors must deliver over the long-term
                 How does the client ‘feel’ about the plan? Can they sleep at night?
                                        feel
                 Check-in periodically to determine if their goals and objectives have changed (e.g. annual
                 tax review with the financial advisor). If not, there’s no reason to diverge from the plan.

           Ultimately, Financial Planning and Asset Management is a process that should factor in both
           quantitative reviews as well as qualitative (b h i
                ii         i         ll       li i (behavioral) f
                                                              l) factors.


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Pop Quiz: Guess who?
                                                                        54




      “I made a big mistake in not selling several of our
       larger holdings during The Great Bubble. If these
      stocks are fully priced now, you may wonder what I
        was thinking four years ago when their intrinsic
          value was lower and their prices f hi h
            l        l        d th i   i    far higher.

                                                                     So d I.”
                                                                        do ”



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Answer: Warren Buffett
                                                                     55




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
For further reading…
                                                                     56

     Wikipedia: A great starting point
     http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavioural_economics
     h    //     iki di      / iki/B h i     l        i
     Money.com Quiz: A view inside the brain
     http://money.cnn.com/quizzes/2007/moneymag/wiredforwealth/inde
     x.html
       hl
     Slate.com: A layman’s guide and something to send your clients
     http://www.slate.com/id/2110977/
     UC Berkeley Haas School of Business: Academic perspective
     http://faculty.haas.berkeley.edu/odean/papers/returns/returns.html
     Your Brain from CNN Money: Test yourself
     http://money.cnn.com/pf/features/popups/brain_popup/1.frame.html




For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
57




                                                     Thank you.
                                                           y
                                                          Vincent J. Crivello
                                                                  J
                                                           415.924.6703 x5

                    vcrivello@larkspurfinancialadvisors.com


For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
Disclosures
                                                                                            58
Before investing in any of the funds or strategies listed in this report, investors should carefully consider a fund’s investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Fund prospectuses
contain this and other information about the funds, and may be obtained by calling us at 1.415.924.6703 or visiting our website at www.larkspurfinancialadvisors.com. Investors should
read prospectuses carefully before investing.

Investments are not deposits or obligations of any bank, are not guaranteed by any bank, are not insured by the FDIC or any other agency, and involve investment risks, including the
possible loss of the principal amount invested.

For Institutional Use Only. This material has been prepared by Vincent J. Crivello of SFA for institutional use only. It has not been filed with NASD and may not be reproduced, shown or
quoted to, or used with, members of the public.

 Stocks, Commodities, Real Estate, and Gold
International stocks, real estate, commodities, and gold have traditionally served to l
         i   l    k      l               di i     d ld h         di i   ll       d lower the overall risk of a d
                                                                                            h        ll i k f domestic portfolio.
                                                                                                                     i      f li
This image illustrates the hypothetical growth of a $1 investment in domestic stocks, international stocks, commodities, real estate, and gold over the time period January 1, 1988 to
December 31, 2007. The best performing asset class over this 20-year period was domestic stocks, with $1 growing to approximately $9.33.

International stocks, commodities, real estate, and gold are often overlooked in an investor’s asset allocation decision. These assets can be excellent vehicles for diversification purposes,
because their returns have demonstrated low or even negative correlation with more traditional assets. In other words, when traditional assets have done poorly, these alternative assets
may have done well, thereby reducing the overall volatility (risk) of your portfolio. Commodities, real estate, and gold can also be an effective hedge against rising inflation rates.
Diversification does not eliminate the risk of investment losses. Returns and principal invested in stocks are not guaranteed. International investments involve special risks such as
fluctuations i currency, f i taxation, economic and political risks, and diff
fl       i    in            foreign      i           i   d li i l i k       d differences i accounting and fi
                                                                                          in        i      d financial standards. The smooth slope of the real estate i d li seems to
                                                                                                                   il      dd      h         hl       fh      l       index line
indicate stable returns. However, these returns are based on appraisal values rather than actual prices. This method of valuing real estate assets tends to smooth price fluctuations that
would be more readily apparent if more frequent transaction data were available. The real estate industry is highly cyclical, and the value of securities issued by companies doing business
in that sector may fluctuate widely. The commodities index represents a passive unleveraged investment in commodity futures. The risk of loss in trading commodity futures and options
can be substantial. Investors could lose the full balance of their account when trading commodities. Gold like any other coin or bullion is subject to investment risks like perceived
scarcity of coin, its quality, current demand, market sentiment, and economic factors.

About the data
U.S.
U S stocks i this example are represented b the S d d & P ’ 500®, which i an unmanaged group of securities and considered to b representative of the stock market i general.
         k in hi          l               d by h Standard Poor’s        ® hi h is                d         f     ii     d    id d be                i   fh       k     k in       l
International stocks are represented by the Morgan Stanley Capital International Europe, Australasia, and Far East (EAFE®) Index, commodities by the Goldman Sachs Commodity
Index, real estate by the NCREIF Property Index, and gold by the Federal Reserve (2nd London fix) from 1977–1987 and Wall Street Journal London P.M. closing price thereafter. An
investment cannot be made directly in an index.

Past performance is no guarantee of future results. The information in this document is for illustrative purposes only and not indicative of any investment. An investment cannot be made
directly in an index.

Securities and advisory services offered th
S    iti     d di           i     ff d through Th Strategic Fi
                                             h The St t i Financial Alli
                                                                  i l Alliance, Inc. (SFA), member FINRA/SIPC which is otherwise unaffiliated with Larkspur Financial Ad i
                                                                                I    (SFA)     b FINRA/SIPC, hi h i th       i      ffili t d ith L k       Fi    i l Advisors or
Tributary Advisors, Inc. Ronald Murphy (CA Insurance #0290052) is a Registered Principal and Investment Advisor Representative and Vincent Crivello (CA Insurance #0F54430) is a
Registered Representative and Investment Advisor Representative of SFA.



For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting
Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting
Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting Eric Kuo
 
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капитала
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капиталаПодход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капитала
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капиталаRTS Stock Exhange
 
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1Bob Sloma
 
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your Business
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your BusinessBest Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your Business
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your BusinessMikhail Demidov
 
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012Omkumar Pagarani
 
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...Bourbon Financial Management, LLC
 
New Oak Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...
New Oak   Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...New Oak   Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...
New Oak Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...Ron D'Vari
 
Bcspl Corporate Presentation Final Ppt
Bcspl   Corporate Presentation Final PptBcspl   Corporate Presentation Final Ppt
Bcspl Corporate Presentation Final Pptyadavp1986
 
Ankit project report final
Ankit project report finalAnkit project report final
Ankit project report finalakii22
 
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012Omkumar Pagarani
 
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011Raddon Financial Group
 
Edmonton - Role of the investment bank
Edmonton - Role of the investment bankEdmonton - Role of the investment bank
Edmonton - Role of the investment bankAdam Nicolopoulos
 
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relations
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor RelationsNordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relations
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relationsnordicirconference
 
Hedge funds - Quick Overview
Hedge funds - Quick OverviewHedge funds - Quick Overview
Hedge funds - Quick OverviewRod Medallion
 

Was ist angesagt? (18)

Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting
Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting
Banking credit concentration management -limiting setting
 
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капитала
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капиталаПодход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капитала
Подход к IR с позиции специалиста по рынкам акционерного капитала
 
Startup Funding
Startup FundingStartup Funding
Startup Funding
 
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1
The Secrets to Long Term Investing Success - Session 1
 
Ratio Analysis
Ratio AnalysisRatio Analysis
Ratio Analysis
 
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your Business
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your BusinessBest Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your Business
Best Practices in Raising Venture Capital to Grow Your Business
 
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012
DSP BlackRock MIP Fund - April 2012
 
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...
Bfm newsletter Challenges in Financial Advising From the Scope of Behavioral ...
 
New Oak Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...
New Oak   Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...New Oak   Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...
New Oak Creating An Effective Risk Modeling Framework (Pensions Risk Manage...
 
Bcspl Corporate Presentation Final Ppt
Bcspl   Corporate Presentation Final PptBcspl   Corporate Presentation Final Ppt
Bcspl Corporate Presentation Final Ppt
 
Ankit project report final
Ankit project report finalAnkit project report final
Ankit project report final
 
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012
DSP Blackrock MIP Fund - June 2012
 
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011
Raddon Chart of the Day, December 7, 2011
 
Irda July09
Irda July09Irda July09
Irda July09
 
Edmonton - Role of the investment bank
Edmonton - Role of the investment bankEdmonton - Role of the investment bank
Edmonton - Role of the investment bank
 
Valuation Puzzles
Valuation PuzzlesValuation Puzzles
Valuation Puzzles
 
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relations
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor RelationsNordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relations
Nordic IR conference Stockholm Strengthening the role of Investor Relations
 
Hedge funds - Quick Overview
Hedge funds - Quick OverviewHedge funds - Quick Overview
Hedge funds - Quick Overview
 

Ähnlich wie Behavioral Finance & Client Expectation Management Cal Cpa Presentation For July 16 2008

Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...
Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...
Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...Sanjay Uppal
 
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In India
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In IndiaPersonal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In India
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In IndiaArthaYantra
 
mutual fund in india
mutual fund in indiamutual fund in india
mutual fund in indiakeyursavalia
 
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...Liberteks
 
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9Proactive Advisor Magazine
 
Careers in finance
Careers in financeCareers in finance
Careers in financeSupportGCI
 
Endowments & Foundations 2011
Endowments & Foundations 2011Endowments & Foundations 2011
Endowments & Foundations 2011Aneil Luhan
 
Private Equity: Digital Reputation Management
Private Equity: Digital Reputation ManagementPrivate Equity: Digital Reputation Management
Private Equity: Digital Reputation ManagementTiffany Chan
 
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation)
Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation)bandonfunds
 
final project viraj 2016 - Copy
final project viraj 2016 - Copyfinal project viraj 2016 - Copy
final project viraj 2016 - CopyViraj Kansara
 
SJA Destination Club White Paper
SJA Destination Club White PaperSJA Destination Club White Paper
SJA Destination Club White PaperScottJordan
 
Investment portfolio ppt
Investment portfolio pptInvestment portfolio ppt
Investment portfolio pptsupriyanayyar
 
Presentation of training project
Presentation of training projectPresentation of training project
Presentation of training projectsupriyanayyar
 
Presentation of training project
Presentation of training projectPresentation of training project
Presentation of training projectsupriyanayyar
 
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research Report
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research ReportCrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research Report
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research ReportEarlyIQ, Inc.
 
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrum
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrumThe emerging changes in the wealth management spectrum
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrumDeepak Jain
 

Ähnlich wie Behavioral Finance & Client Expectation Management Cal Cpa Presentation For July 16 2008 (20)

Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...
Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...
Investor Relations and Shareholder Communication : Linking internal aspiratio...
 
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In India
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In IndiaPersonal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In India
Personal Finance Habits Of Salaried Professionals In India
 
mutual fund in india
mutual fund in indiamutual fund in india
mutual fund in india
 
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...
2012 plan sponsor presentation l0212240551 exp0213 all states dc gu mp pr vi ...
 
journals public
journals publicjournals public
journals public
 
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9
Robert Kinnun – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 4, Issue 9
 
Careers in finance
Careers in financeCareers in finance
Careers in finance
 
Endowments & Foundations 2011
Endowments & Foundations 2011Endowments & Foundations 2011
Endowments & Foundations 2011
 
Private Equity: Digital Reputation Management
Private Equity: Digital Reputation ManagementPrivate Equity: Digital Reputation Management
Private Equity: Digital Reputation Management
 
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation)
Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation)
 
final project viraj 2016 - Copy
final project viraj 2016 - Copyfinal project viraj 2016 - Copy
final project viraj 2016 - Copy
 
Fundraisers
Fundraisers Fundraisers
Fundraisers
 
SJA Destination Club White Paper
SJA Destination Club White PaperSJA Destination Club White Paper
SJA Destination Club White Paper
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Waddell & Reed
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Waddell & ReedQ1 2009 Earning Report of Waddell & Reed
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Waddell & Reed
 
Investment portfolio ppt
Investment portfolio pptInvestment portfolio ppt
Investment portfolio ppt
 
Presentation of training project
Presentation of training projectPresentation of training project
Presentation of training project
 
Presentation of training project
Presentation of training projectPresentation of training project
Presentation of training project
 
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research Report
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research ReportCrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research Report
CrowdfundIQ Benchmark Study - Equity Crowdfunding Investor Research Report
 
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrum
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrumThe emerging changes in the wealth management spectrum
The emerging changes in the wealth management spectrum
 
Business Plan
Business PlanBusiness Plan
Business Plan
 

Behavioral Finance & Client Expectation Management Cal Cpa Presentation For July 16 2008

  • 1. Larkspur Financial Advisors Asset Management & Financial Planning B E H AV I O R A L F I NA NC E & YOU R C L I E NTS P R E S E N TAT I O N T O : A C A L I F O R N I A C PA S F / M A R I N DISCUS SION GROUP P R E S E N T E D B Y: VINCENT J. CRIVELLO F I N A NC I A L A DV I S O R & P R I NC I PA L J U LY 1 6 , 2 0 0 8
  • 2. Agenda 2 Background g Introduction to Behavioral Finance Managing Clients & Expectations gg p Q&A For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 3. Background 3 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 4. Background: About Me 4 Current Financial Advisor and Owner with Larkspur Financial Advisors—an independent advisory firm founded in 1968 Comprehensive Financial Planning and Asset Management for p g g individuals, families, and small businesses Target Market: “Millionaire next door” and the mass affluent Past NorthStar Systems: Wealth Management Consulting Charles Schwab: Business & Product Management in Schwab’s retail advisory di i i (P i il d i division (Private Cli Client, M Managed P f li ) d Portfolios) Marketing & Industry Research: Multi-channel consumer marketing strategies with an emphasis in financial services For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 5. Background: About Investors 5 A 2003 Schwab consumer survey found that “Despite the warnings of economists and money management experts that Americans need to pay more attention to their finances…” 93 percent said they planned to have an annual medical or dental check-up. check up. Nearly half (47 percent) of those polled would rather do laundry than carefully read their investment statement even though many investors may be seeing some improvement in their portfolios. Only 38 percent of those surveyed said they planned an annual face-to-face face to face meeting with their broker or financial advisor. Investors who work with a financial advisor are almost twice as likely to cancel an appointment with their advisor (22 percent) than they are to cancel a car service appointment ( 3 p pp (13 percent). ) Only 22 percent of respondents ranked quot;investmentsquot; as among their top three priorities in 2004. Source: http://www.businesswire.com/portal/site/schwab/index.jsp?ndmViewId=news_view&ndmConfigId=1009915&newsId=20050916005258&newsLang=en For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 6. Background: The Results 6 EQUITY MARKET RETURNS VS VS. EQUITY MUTUAL FUND INVESTOR RETURNS* (1985-2004) 13.2% 3.7% S&P 500 Average Index Equity Fund Investor *SOURCE: Dalbar, Inc. Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior - 2005. Represents average annually compounded returns of equity indices vs equity mutual fund investors; based on the length of time shareholders actually remain invested in a fund and the historic performance of the funds appropriate index. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investors cannot invest directly in an index. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 7. Behavioral Finance 7 quot;SHARE PRICES ARE DRIVEN BY FEAR AND GREED.quot; - JOHN MAYNARD KEYNES For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 8. Pop Quiz 8 I would rate my driving abilities as… y g Below average Average Better than average B h Please jot down your answer—we’ll come back to this later in the session For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 9. Standard Theory of Finance (Efficient Markets) 9 The Standard Theory of Finance states: Investors I Are rational beings Consider all information and accurately assess its meaning Make decisions that maximize wealth while minimizing risk Markets Quickly incorporate all known information Reflect the collective actions of rational investors Represent the true value of all securities Industry Developments over the past few decades: Diversification through Asset Allocation g Portfolio Design & Efficient Frontier (MPT) Mutual Funds Index funds and ETFs For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 10. Why Behavioral Finance? 10 If we always behaved rationally… Nobody would ever sell stocks in a panic at the first sign of trouble Nobody would ever buy stocks (or other investments) based on hunches, hot tips or media hype , p yp Nobody would ever keep money in the bank instead of using it to pay off high-interest credit card balances Harvard found that humans are not “wired” to make wired rational decisions: Human beings are simply not good at accurately calculating odds Left to our own regards, we make the same mistakes over and over again. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 11. Behavioral Finance 11 Behavioral Finance provides an ‘overlay’ to the Standard Theory. Theory It provides a framework to understand ‘non-rational’ investor and market behaviors… Investors Are A not totally rational ll i l Often act based on imperfect information Make “non-rational” decisions in predictable ways Markets M kt May be difficult to beat in the long term In the short term, there are anomalies and excesses The t Th two aspects of b h i l fi t f behavioral finance are: The behavior of investors The behavior of markets For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 12. Our Brains… 12 Dough v. Dope Greed vs. Gain Source: Hans Breiter, Harvard Medical School Brian Knutson, Sanford University, Jason Zweig (Author) Your Money & Your Brain For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 13. Pop Quiz: Guess Who? 13 “Greed, for l k of a G d f lack f better word, i good.” b d is d For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 14. Answer: Gordon Gecko 14 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 15. Behavioral Characteristics 15 Loss aversion Media response Disposition effect i ii ff Herding di Narrow framing Optimism Mental M t l accountingti Overconfidence O fid Regret Anchoring Hindsight bias Recency For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 16. Loss Aversion: Pop Quiz 16 A friend wants to make a bet with you. If y accept y you p the bet you will have a 50% chance of losing $10,000 and a 50% chance of winning $_______. How much would you want to have a chance of winning before you would take the bet? Please right down your number For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 17. Loss Aversion: The Disproportion of Gain & Loss 17 Most people want to g pp gain between 2 and 2.5 times as 5 much as they put at risk. So most people will want a chance to win $20,000 before they will play. Practical Example: Between 1926 and 2000* Question: Why would anyone invest in bonds? y Stocks returned 8% (real) Bonds returned 2% (real) The answer is loss aversion: The less frequently you evaluate stocks, the less risky they appear. People tend to evaluate stocks as if they had a short time horizon. *Source of data: Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation 2001 Yearbook. Ibbotson Associates, Chicago (annually updates work by Roger G. Ibbotson and Rex a Sinquefield). Used with permission. All rights reserved. Stocks are represented by the S&P 500 C db h Composite S k I d i Stock Index, an unmanaged i d widely regarded as an i di d index id l dd indicator of d f domestic stock performance. S&P 500 performance i l d reinvestment of di id d b d i k f f includes i f dividends but does not take sales k l charges or taxes into consideration. Bonds represented by long-term government bonds are measured using a one-bond portfolio with a maturity near twenty years. Cash represented by U.S. Treasury bills is measured by rolling over each month a one-bill portfolio containing, at the beginning of each monthly, the bill having the shortest maturity not less than one month. An investment in common stocks will fluctuate with changes in market conditions. An investment in government bonds and Treasury bills are guaranteed by the U.S. Government and, if held to maturity, all bonds offer both a fixed rate of return and fixed principal value. Past performance of stock and bond indexes is no indication of their future results. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 18. Loss Aversion: How Investors see risk 18 Clients view risk differently than p y professionals Focus on fear of losing money, not mathematics or abstract concepts like ‘time-weighted returns’ Client’s risk profile changes over time Two time horizons Long-term (an abstraction) Short-term (the real standard) Self-assessed vs. actual risk t l S lf d t l i k tolerance For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 19. Loss Aversion: The Importance of Time 19 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 20. Disposition Effect 20 The disposition effect refers to p p p people’s tendency to: y Hang on to losers Sell the winners This allows them to enjoy the feeling of winning and defer the pain of loss Investors are about 1.5 times more likely t sell I t bt ti lik l to ll winning stocks as they are to sell losing stocks Behaviors: “I’m going to wait for the stock to come back to $15/share.” For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 21. Narrow Framing: Trees vs. Forest 21 Would you accept this gamble… 50% chance to win $15,000 50% chance to lose $10,000 Most people would say “no” because they want a no chance to win at least twice what they might lose. Assume you have a net worth of $ million. Would y $2 you accept the gamble now? 50% chance that your wealth increases $15,000 50% chance that your wealth decreases $10 000 $10,000 Most people say “yes.” They become less risk averse as their frame of reference broadens. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 22. Narrow Framing: Aggregation 22 Would you flip a coin if… You get $15,000 if you win You pay $10,000 if you lose Again, Again most people would say “no ” but no, but… What if you got to flip the coin 100 times? Most people would say “yes.” Loss aversion is diminished by aggregation. i Implications: Time ‘in the market’ is critical. in market 100 months in the market (like 100 flips of a coin) creates a quasi-aggregation effect For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 23. Mental Accounting: The “House Money Effect” 23 You have just won $30. Choose between: j 3 1. A. 50% chance to win $9 and 50% chance to lose $9 B. No further bets BNf h b 70% of participants chose A 2 You have not won anything. Choose between: anything 2. A. 50% chance to win $39 and 50% chance to win $21 B. A sure gain of $30 43% of participants chose A For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 24. Mental Accounting: 401k Plans 24 In retirement plans that do not offer company stock as an option, the average allocation is: 49% stocks 49% Equities 51% fixed income In plans that do offer company stock, the average allocation is: 42% company stock 71% Equities 29% other stock 29% fixed income Company stock is placed in a separate “mental account” from the other options For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 25. Regret: Omission vs. Commission 25 Q Question: Who is more upset, Mr. Q or Ms. R? p, Omission: Mr. Q owns shares of Company A. He considers selling his shares and buying stock in Company B, but decides against it He now finds he would have been better off by it. $20,000 if he had switched to Company B. Commission: Ms. R owns shares in Company B, but switched to Company A She fi d she would h tC A. Sh finds h ld have b been b tt off b better ff by $20,000 if she had kept her shares of Company B. Answer: Ms. R. People typically regret errors of p yp yg commission more than errors of omission. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 26. Regret & Hindsight Bias 26 The inevitability of past events Events that happen seem predictable Events that do not happen will seem unlikely People distort their own past beliefs “I always knew…” Past beliefs are reconciled with actual events People take credit for good outcomes and blame others for bad outcomes (this is also related to optimism and overconfidence) For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 27. Media Response 27 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 28. Media Response 28 Investors often feel the need to react to new information Study of the effects of news on investment decisions: Two groups: one received news and one did not The Th groups with no news outperformed th group th t received news ith tf d the that id News is often irrelevant to long-term performance and is often misinterpreted p News sources are often perceived as ‘authoritative’ sources which impacts behavior Real World: “Put my entire portfolio in cash—this hurricane season is going to kill the market.” For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 29. Media Response: Market Timing 29 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 30. Herding 30 Investors have a tendency toward “herd behavior” y They may even disregard their own beliefs to follow the herd Study of the effects of herd behavior: Participants were asked to answer easy questions about the lengths of li l th f lines About 1/3 changed their answers to be part of the herd Real World: Disproportionate flow of money into top-rated funds despite ratings’ lack of predictive abilities For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 31. Herding: Reading the ‘stars’ 31 5-Year Performance Next 5-Year Period 6/30/92 – 6/30/97 6/30/97 – 6/30/02 21% Top Quartile Top Quartile 14% 2nd Quartile 14% 3rd Quartile 2nd Quartile 50% Bottom Quartile 3rd Quartile Bottom Quartile Past performance is a very poor predictor of future results. Odds are against top quartile managers performing in top quartile during the next period and only 50/50 pq g p y / to be above the median for the next 5 years. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 32. Optimism & Overconfidence 32 People believe it is likely that: People are overconfident about what they know Good things will h G d thi ill happen t to them Even when “certain,” they are often wrong… Bad things will happen to others 20% e d up be g incorrect 0% end p being co ec Others are more likely to: (@ 98% certainty level)* 10%-15% end up being Become an alcoholic incorrect when “absolutely Have a heart attack sure sure”* Develop D l cancer They underestimate the Others are less likely to: uncertainty of events Become rich “This time it’s different.” Become famous –1999 B bbl Investor Bubble I Warren Buffet once said, “Optimism is the enemy of the A related tendency is that of overconfidence. Fact is, people are often rational buyer” unjustifiably overconfident in assessing their abilities and what they know about the world around them. Studies show that people are wrong about 20% of the time when asked to estimate things with a 98% confidence level and by 10% to 15% when asked to be “absolutely sure” of their answers. The result is that people often underestimate the uncertainty of events and believe that they are much better at assessing future possibilities than they really are. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 33. Overconfidence: “We’re all above average” 33 People tend to overestimate their abilities 90% believe they are above average in… Driving ability Sense of humor Getting along with others They misperceive their ability to control events They seek confirmation of their abilities and find it in random events Whoever first said, “Don’t confuse brains with a bull market” probably was a student of behavioral finance. Real World: “Rising tide floats all boats.” The real test of ability is in a sideways or down market market. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 34. Overconfidence: Real World 34 Two types of client Trader: Speculated on price. Traded often. Investor: Buy & Hold. Fundamental focus. Stocks sold outperformed those purchased by: “Trader” “Investor” After 12 months: 3.2% 3 2% 5.0% 5 0% After 24 months: 3.6% 8.6% The higher the turnover, in general, the worse the results. *Source: American Economic Review 1999, Terrance Odean, Associate Professor of Finance at the University of California at Davis For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 35. Pop Quiz: Anchoring 35 Take the last three numbers of your Social Security number and add 400. Insert the sum i place of [d ] b d dd h in l f [date] below. Attila and the Huns invaded Europe and penetrated deep into what is now France where they were defeated and forced to return eastward eastward. 1. Did these events occur before or after [date] AD? ______ Before ______ After 2 .In what year did Attila s defeat occur? ______ In Attila’s For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 36. Pop Quiz: Anchoring 36 Answer: 451 AD 45 Research Results: Anchor Mean Answer 400-599 626 600-799 600 799 660 800-999 789 1000-1199 865 1200-1399 988 88 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 37. Anchoring 37 “Anchors” affect an investor’s frame of reference Can you think of common investment anchors? S&P 500 Index Dow Jones Industrials Performance benchmarks CNN Cocktail party chatter Behaviors “I’ll sell the stock when it gets back to $20” “I’m t i to ll “I’ not going t sell my h home f THAT price!” for i !” “I’ll sell the real estate now to lock in the long-term capital gains rate prior to the election.” For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 38. Recency Effect 38 When do people buy burglar alarms? pp y g Behaviors Acting on momentum or a run-up in price (aka chasing returns) Real Estate (2002-2006) Gold Oil BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China) Wanting to go to cash in volatile markets the markets will markets—the keep going down. Client has to get into the action For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 39. Pop Quiz: Recency & Overconfidence 39 For the period between 1986 and 2006, which asset classes represent Investments A and B: End value of $ $100 Return Inflation Real Return investment Investment A 11.9% 3.0% 8.9% $951 Investment B 55 5.5% 3 3.0% 2.5% 5 $9 $292 Clue #1: In 2006, the ‘herds’ wanted a piece of this action— many jumped into these markets we’re now hearing about. Clue #2: Homeowners would have answered this wrong back in 2006. Source: JP Morgan, BEA, S&P. S&P includes dividends. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 40. Behavioral Finance: Key points 40 Anticipation of gain (greed) is more satisfying than the actual gain Pain of loss has a larger emotional impact than the pleasure of gain Investors lose confidence in markets due to the media response, herding, and anchoring effects g, g Excessive conservatism and aversion to risk is exacerbated by narrow framing, mental accounting and short time horizons Investor overconfidence, optimism and minimization of uncertainties create i fl t d egos t i ti t inflated Investors often repeat predictable, destructive behaviors and don’t learn from past mistakes Bottom line: These behaviors and reacting to ‘recency’ events leads to lower overall returns over the long-term. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 41. Pop Quiz: Guess who? 41 “I got my mind on my I money and my money on my mind ” mind. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 42. Answer: Snoop Dogg 42 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 43. Managing Clients 43 GOALS, OBJECTIVES, & EXPECTATIONS For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 44. Look Inward First 44 Recognize that behavioral issues affect us all— g including financial advisors, institutional money managers, and individual investors Do a self-assessment to determine what behaviors you’ve exhibited and how it may impact the advice you provide clients or the advice your clients have clients—or received from other advisors Challenge the financial advisors you work with—see with see if their advice and recommendations are influenced by latent behavioral biases For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 45. Helping your Clients: Questions to Ask 45 When your clients ask… “How do you think my account did last year? How year?” “What do you think of the job my financial advisor has done?” “How do I know if my investment advisor is doing a good job?” “The market is tanking—should I fire my advisor? Do it on my own?” You should answer… If they’re working with an advisor: What’s does your financial plan state? What are the assumptions? What are your return requirements to meet your financial goals? What are your portfolio’s objectives? What are the return and risk parameters in your IPS? If they’re managing their own investments: What are your benchmarks? How do you define success? How do you know when you’re doing well? Are you using time-weighted returns to measure progress? Do you have a sell strategy in p y gy place? Ask to take a look at your client’s other financial documents: Financial Plan Investment Policy Statement (IPS) Q Quarterly Performance Report y p Consolidated Net Worth Statement For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 46. Reviewing their Financial Plan 46 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 47. Reviewing the IPS 47 A well-formed Policy Statement should include these items: Goals & Objectives Time Horizon Risk tolerance Liquidity or distribution needs Tax rates Asset Allocation requirements Client preferences or constraints Return Expectations (often inflated): Consumers: 10.4%-14% Institutional Mgrs: 8.0% Expected volatility/risk Methodologies and selection criteria Monitoring, benchmarks, & evaluation criteria The advisor should also factor in other assets: 401k/Qualified Plans Investment Real Estate Non-correlated Assets such as Managed Futures For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 48. Monitoring the Plan 48 What’s relevant: What’s are the return/risk / objectives of the portfolio? What’s “time-weighted performance” (TWR) since inception (net of all fees and expenses)? How has the portfolio performed vs. its benchmark? How are the assets performing h f i vs. the financial plan? What’s irrelevant: Monthly statements Gain/loss reporting Specific winners or losers For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 49. Sample Performance Reports 49 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 50. Sample Performance Reports 50 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 51. A word about Benchmarks… 51 Benchmarks are a contentious topic in the industry. There’s no clear accepted means of benchmarking financial or portfolio performance for individual investors (despite what the academics say). The following benchmarks are generally the best ones to help you answer your client’s question, “How am I doing?”: Financial Plan: rate of return required to achieve goal Portfolio’s Expected Return (e.g. CPI + 6%) vs. actual Time-weighted return Standard Deviation or Volatility Composite benchmark (e.g. S&P500, Lehman Aggregate, MSCI EAFE) which could include peers or a ‘passive’ p p p portfolio of index funds and ETFs Remember the ‘qualitative’ benchmark—how a client feels about his or her portfolio is also important. In other words, how is the j h i th journey? ? For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 52. Getting from point A to point B… 52 Mr. Smith’s Mr. Jones’ American Funds Portfolio American Funds Portfolio Washington Mutual 60% Growth Fund of Amer. 60% Intermediate Bond of Am. 40% High Income Fund 40% Beta: 0.43 Beta: 0.74 Standard Deviation: 7.81 Standard Deviation: 12.81 Worst year return: -7.14% Worst Year Return: -21.50% Extra Credit: Based on what you’ve learned, Is Mr. Smith or Mr. Jones more likely to give up on their plan? Analysis based on Morningstar Principia Data from 09/30/1996-9/30/2006. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 53. Summary: Managing Clients 53 The Financial Plan: Helps clients focus on the big picture 1. Strategic, Long-term Strategic Long term goals Reorients them towards goal attainment not reactive portfolio tinkering or trading Achieving the financial goal(s) is ultimately what matters to clients Investment Policy & Design: Drives disciplined, rational decision-making 2. Provides rational guidance and parameters that drive investment decision making and changes Provides a framework through which one can measure ‘success’ Allows the incorporation of strategies or products that mitigate downside volatility (hedging, absolute return, non-correlated assets) and/or approaches that allow for ‘satellite’ or speculative opportunities (e g have your cake and eat it too) satellite (e.g. Plan Monitoring: Tracking towards objectives 3. Consistent, risk-adjusted performance net of fees, expenses, and taxes is presumed—this is not a differentiator. Investment advisors must deliver over the long-term How does the client ‘feel’ about the plan? Can they sleep at night? feel Check-in periodically to determine if their goals and objectives have changed (e.g. annual tax review with the financial advisor). If not, there’s no reason to diverge from the plan. Ultimately, Financial Planning and Asset Management is a process that should factor in both quantitative reviews as well as qualitative (b h i ii i ll li i (behavioral) f l) factors. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 54. Pop Quiz: Guess who? 54 “I made a big mistake in not selling several of our larger holdings during The Great Bubble. If these stocks are fully priced now, you may wonder what I was thinking four years ago when their intrinsic value was lower and their prices f hi h l l d th i i far higher. So d I.” do ” For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 55. Answer: Warren Buffett 55 For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 56. For further reading… 56 Wikipedia: A great starting point http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavioural_economics h // iki di / iki/B h i l i Money.com Quiz: A view inside the brain http://money.cnn.com/quizzes/2007/moneymag/wiredforwealth/inde x.html hl Slate.com: A layman’s guide and something to send your clients http://www.slate.com/id/2110977/ UC Berkeley Haas School of Business: Academic perspective http://faculty.haas.berkeley.edu/odean/papers/returns/returns.html Your Brain from CNN Money: Test yourself http://money.cnn.com/pf/features/popups/brain_popup/1.frame.html For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 57. 57 Thank you. y Vincent J. Crivello J 415.924.6703 x5 vcrivello@larkspurfinancialadvisors.com For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution
  • 58. Disclosures 58 Before investing in any of the funds or strategies listed in this report, investors should carefully consider a fund’s investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Fund prospectuses contain this and other information about the funds, and may be obtained by calling us at 1.415.924.6703 or visiting our website at www.larkspurfinancialadvisors.com. Investors should read prospectuses carefully before investing. Investments are not deposits or obligations of any bank, are not guaranteed by any bank, are not insured by the FDIC or any other agency, and involve investment risks, including the possible loss of the principal amount invested. For Institutional Use Only. This material has been prepared by Vincent J. Crivello of SFA for institutional use only. It has not been filed with NASD and may not be reproduced, shown or quoted to, or used with, members of the public. Stocks, Commodities, Real Estate, and Gold International stocks, real estate, commodities, and gold have traditionally served to l i l k l di i d ld h di i ll d lower the overall risk of a d h ll i k f domestic portfolio. i f li This image illustrates the hypothetical growth of a $1 investment in domestic stocks, international stocks, commodities, real estate, and gold over the time period January 1, 1988 to December 31, 2007. The best performing asset class over this 20-year period was domestic stocks, with $1 growing to approximately $9.33. International stocks, commodities, real estate, and gold are often overlooked in an investor’s asset allocation decision. These assets can be excellent vehicles for diversification purposes, because their returns have demonstrated low or even negative correlation with more traditional assets. In other words, when traditional assets have done poorly, these alternative assets may have done well, thereby reducing the overall volatility (risk) of your portfolio. Commodities, real estate, and gold can also be an effective hedge against rising inflation rates. Diversification does not eliminate the risk of investment losses. Returns and principal invested in stocks are not guaranteed. International investments involve special risks such as fluctuations i currency, f i taxation, economic and political risks, and diff fl i in foreign i i d li i l i k d differences i accounting and fi in i d financial standards. The smooth slope of the real estate i d li seems to il dd h hl fh l index line indicate stable returns. However, these returns are based on appraisal values rather than actual prices. This method of valuing real estate assets tends to smooth price fluctuations that would be more readily apparent if more frequent transaction data were available. The real estate industry is highly cyclical, and the value of securities issued by companies doing business in that sector may fluctuate widely. The commodities index represents a passive unleveraged investment in commodity futures. The risk of loss in trading commodity futures and options can be substantial. Investors could lose the full balance of their account when trading commodities. Gold like any other coin or bullion is subject to investment risks like perceived scarcity of coin, its quality, current demand, market sentiment, and economic factors. About the data U.S. U S stocks i this example are represented b the S d d & P ’ 500®, which i an unmanaged group of securities and considered to b representative of the stock market i general. k in hi l d by h Standard Poor’s ® hi h is d f ii d id d be i fh k k in l International stocks are represented by the Morgan Stanley Capital International Europe, Australasia, and Far East (EAFE®) Index, commodities by the Goldman Sachs Commodity Index, real estate by the NCREIF Property Index, and gold by the Federal Reserve (2nd London fix) from 1977–1987 and Wall Street Journal London P.M. closing price thereafter. An investment cannot be made directly in an index. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. The information in this document is for illustrative purposes only and not indicative of any investment. An investment cannot be made directly in an index. Securities and advisory services offered th S iti d di i ff d through Th Strategic Fi h The St t i Financial Alli i l Alliance, Inc. (SFA), member FINRA/SIPC which is otherwise unaffiliated with Larkspur Financial Ad i I (SFA) b FINRA/SIPC, hi h i th i ffili t d ith L k Fi i l Advisors or Tributary Advisors, Inc. Ronald Murphy (CA Insurance #0290052) is a Registered Principal and Investment Advisor Representative and Vincent Crivello (CA Insurance #0F54430) is a Registered Representative and Investment Advisor Representative of SFA. For Professional Use Only—Not intended for the public distribution