Country case studies from Kyrgyzstan: presentation by Zulfia Kochorbaeva, Association of Women’s Legal Initiative (AWLI) presented at UNDP Regional Forum on Equal participation in decision-making, Istanbul, 16 November, Session 7: Enhancing women’s participation trough Parliamentary Mechanisms

1. Promoting gender-sensitive
political reforms in the
Parliament
Zulfia Kochorbaeva
Alliance of Women’s Legislative Initiatives,
Kyrgyzstan
www.awli-kg.org

2. Impact on the Parliaments
Agenda of Kyrgyzstan
Impact strategies differ:
In conditions when women MPs are in small
numbers or their complete absence (untill
2007)
In conditions broad representation of
women in the parliament members
www.awli-kg.org

3. Kyrgyzstan experience when women MPs
in small numbers and lack of MPs
• Introduction of the draft law “Social and Law
Protection from Domestic Violence” by the
women’s NGOs in the Parliament through the
legislative right of peoples initiative. The
Parliament accepted in 2003.
• Law “On Basic Guarantees of Gender Equality
State” was initiated by female MP and taken
together with the above law in 2003.
Note: at that moment Legislative Chamber of Parliament
had only 4 women out of 60 members (6,6 %)
www.awli-kg.org

4. Challenges, year 2005
• Strengthening of the traditional stereotypes about women
in society
• Failing to record implicit barriers for women’s participation
in politics, unfriendly to women majoritarian system of
elections to Parliament
• “Wash-out” of women from the government
• Rhetorical strategy of State towards gender equality
One of the consequences – zero representation of women in
the Parliament in 2005 Elections.
www.awli-kg.org

5. The Answer Of Women’s Movement
Revision of the strategy at the National Forum of
Women’s Organizations in April 2005.:
Joint Platform of Action
Strategy for lobbying of institutional changes,
including in the legislation
Using of symbolic actions to attract the attention
of politicians and the public
www.awli-kg.org

6. Results:
 Established the post of Special Representative of the
President on gender development in Parliament and
appointed the candidate from women’s organizations.
 Promoting the procedures of gender expertise of draft laws
to Parliament through Special Representative.
 In 2008, Gender Expertise approved in the Parliament as a
mandatory procedure for all laws.
www.awli-kg.org

7. Anara Niyazova, Special Representative of the President on Gender
development in Parliament, 2005-2007
www.awli-kg.org

8. “Alternative March 8, 2007»
www.awli-kg.org

9. “For the Secular Kyrgyzstan!”
www.awli-kg.org

10. www.awli-kg.org

11. “For the Secular Kyrgyzstan!”: Results
• Preservation of criminal responsibility for
Polygamy.
• Updating and Identification of return of the
definition of “Secular State”.
• Managed to discuss explicitly the issues of
gender equality in a month through the “Hot”
topic.
www.awli-kg.org

12. Lobbying for Gender Quotas in the Electoral
Code, 2007
• Development, discussion of proposals for the law in the
target groups
• Support for special measures at regional public hearings
• Meetings with committees, factions of the Parliament,
“Fleeting Press Conference”
• Action “Mom need all, and important in parliament!”
• Pressure on the electorate MPs
• Parliament Hearings on Election Code
• Action “Zebra”
www.awli-kg.org

13. www.awli-kg.org

14. www.awli-kg.org

15. www.awli-kg.org

16. The Action of 1 June 2007
“Mom need all, and important in parliament!”
www.awli-kg.org

17. www.awli-kg.org

18. www.awli-kg.org

19. A Meeting of the Organizing Committee of NGO
Forum with the President of Kyrgyzstan,
September 5, 2007
www.awli-kg.org

20. “Gender Quotas”: Results
• The draft laws includes special gender
measures. In the following referendum in
2007, gender quotas have become a
reality
• Women’s participation in politics – ideas
are shared and promoted by not only
women’s groups, but also included in the
agenda of NGOs with highest priority
www.awli-kg.org

21. Art. 72 of the Election Code of Kyrgyz
Republic:
In determining the list of candidates political party
should take in account the representation:
• No more 70 % persons of the same sex, meanwhile
the difference in the order of candidate lists for
women and men, nominated by political parties,
should not exceed three position;
• At least 15 % of those under the age of 35;
• At least 15 % of citizens representing different
nationalities.
www.awli-kg.org

22. A Campaign “The New Face of
Kyrgyzstan!”
o The inclusion of “our” women in the lists of parties:
panel discussions, letters to parties with the list of
contacts women’s network in the regions (10 of “our”
women entered in the list of top 5 parties, many of
our partners)
o 18 informational meetings in the regions with women
leaders, advising them
o Forum with the women-candidates from all 12
registered parties, November 29, 2007
o TV program in live, December 14, 2007
www.awli-kg.org

23. www.awli-kg.org

24. Forum with women-candidates
November 29, 2007
www.awli-kg.org

25. www.awli-kg.org

26. www.awli-kg.org

27. www.awli-kg.org

28. TV Program in live, December 14, 2007
www.awli-kg.org

29. “The New Face of Kyrgyzstan!”: results
• Women in parliament – 25,5 %
• Vice-speaker - women
• 5 of 12 committees are in the management of women:
• Defense, Security, Law Enforcement and Judicial
Reform
• Land and Agrarian issues, Ecology and Emergency
Situation
• Education, Science, Culture and Information Politics
• Youth, Gender Policy, Sport
• Ethics and Regulation of the Jogorku Kenesh KR
• In the Government – 22 %
www.awli-kg.org

30. Women face of the Kyrgyzstan Parliament
www.awli-kg.org

31. Women in the parliamentary deputies of
Kyrgyzstan
Years Total MPs Women’s share
(person)
Person %
1995 105 5 4,7
2000 105 7 6,8
2005 75 0 0
2007 90 23 25,5
2010 120 28 23,3
www.awli-kg.org

32. Women and Men Access to Managerial Positions in the
Parliament of Kyrgyzstan (2010-2011)
Position Total, per. Number of Number of
women, per. men, per
Speaker 1 0 1
Vice-speaker 5 2 3
Chairman of the 16 4 12
Committee
Deputy Chairman of the 30 7 23
Committee
Total, per. (%) 52 13 (25%) 39 (75%)
www.awli-kg.org

33. Gender quotas  ascension in parliament of large
number of women  women-deputies in managerial
positions in parliament
Position Number of women, per
 In 2007,15 of women-deputies
2007 2010 held managerial positions in
Speaker parliament, nowadays – every
0 0 second.
Vice-speaker 1 2  In 2007, 12 committees in
Chairman of the 1 4 parliaments, in 2010-2011 – 16
Committee committees.
Deputy Chairman 4 7
of the Committee
Total 6 13
www.awli-kg.org

34. According to Inter-Parliamentary
Union (IPU)
In 2007, Kyrgyzstan recognized as
the country, where the progress in
political promotion accomplished
most dynamically
www.awli-kg.org

35. Kyrgyzstan’s experience in a broad
representation of women of MPs
• Joining of women MPs on in the Alliance of
Women’s Legislative Initiatives
• The use of parliamentary procedures:
– Gender Expertise of Legislation
– Parliament Proceedings
– Meetings of the Committees
• Addresses, statements on current issues
www.awli-kg.org

36. May 2008
Joining of women MPs, women ministers, women’s
organizations and gender experts in
The Alliance Of Women’s Legislative
Initiatives
www.awli-kg.org

37. www.awli-kg.org

38. Achievements of the joint work with
women MPs
• A new revision of the Law “On State guarantees of Equal Rights
and Equal Opportunities for men and women” (No. 184, dated
August 4, 2008)
• Introduced amendments to the gender of more than 15 laws,
including Constitution, Family Code, Penal Code, The election
laws, the laws on the judicial system, etc..
• Gender Quotas of 30% admitted in the formation of the auditors of
the Accounting Chamber, the Supreme Court, the Constitutional
Court and Central Election Commission
• In the draft Regulations of Parliament enshrined procedures
Gender Expertise of the legislation, the requirements for gender
composition of the employees of the parliament (no more than 70
number of one sex)
www.awli-kg.org

39. Achievements of the joint work with
women MPs (2)
• Annually, 2-3 Parliament Proceedings on the issue of gender
equality and gender based violence
• The methodology of gender expertise of legislation is applied in
common regulations (Regulation adopted by the Government on
December 8, 2010)
• A Section of “Policy of Gender Equality” is included in the Country
Development Strategy 2007-2011 and noted that National Action
Plan on gender equality is an integrated part of Strategy
• Due to the decision of meeting of relevant committees of parliament,
initiated by the Alliance of Women’s Legislative Initiatives, a decision
on the need to develop a national strategy to achieve gender by
2020 and National Action Plan for 2012-2014.
www.awli-kg.org

40. Challenges, difficulties in promotion of
the gender agenda in Parliament
• Non-compliance with the law approved by
Parliament rules and procedures
• The large number of MPs who separates gender
stereotypes and sexist attitudes
• Active promotion of “religious” patriarchal
discourse in the Parliament
• Low capacity and lack of motivation among the
staff of the Parliament Administration
www.awli-kg.org

41. Thank you!
www.awli-kg.org