1. Engaging African Women & Girls in Technology
Web Gathering
12 December 2012
Empowering African women for the
future through ICT
Aida Opoku-Mensah
Director
ICT, Science and Technology Division
United Nations Economic Commission for Africa
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
2. Contents
Context
Gender / Performance in MDGs
Women in Decision Making & Economic Fields
ICTs & Women’s Empowerment
ECA’s Mandate and Activities in Gender and ICTs
Conclusions
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
3. Context
Women constitute
Women constitute
over 50 per cent of
over 50 per cent of
the population
the population
Gender inequalities
Gender inequalities
in income
in income
and asset
and asset
Do 60 per cent
Do 60 per cent
of the work
of the work distribution of
distribution of
remunerated
remunerated
& unremunerated
& unremunerated
work
work
Earn 1/10 of the income
Earn 1/10 of the income lack of recognition
lack of recognition
of women contributions
of women contributions
In household
In household
and care economies
and care economies
Own 1/100
Own 1/100
of the assets
of the assets
Are some of the causes of Marginalisation of Women
Are some of the causes of Marginalisation of Women
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
4. Where are we on MDGs
African continent well positioned
African continent well positioned
to meet universal primary education, gender equality and empowerment goals;
to meet universal primary education, gender equality and empowerment goals;
Gender parity in primary education likely to be achieved by most countries;
Gender parity in primary education likely to be achieved by most countries;
Parity decreases in secondary education,
Parity decreases in secondary education,
& gap is widest in tertiary education;;
& gap is widest in tertiary education;;
In primary and secondary education, The Gambia,
In primary and secondary education, The Gambia,
Guinea, Mauritania, and Senegal made the greatest progress in achieving gender parity. .
Guinea, Mauritania, and Senegal made the greatest progress in achieving gender parity
In tertiary education, North Africa continues to lead the continent.
In tertiary education, North Africa continues to lead the continent.
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
5. Women in decision-making
Increased proportion of women in decision making
( increased number of women parliamentarians
& at senior positions )
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
6. Under-representation of women in most
economic fields
In the formal economy, women are predominantly
In the formal economy, women are predominantly
employed in the agricultural sector ––
employed in the agricultural sector
especially in West, Central and Eastern
especially in West, Central and Eastern
and Southern Africa
and Southern Africa
60-80 %
60-80 %
of the agricultural
of the agricultural
labour force
labour force
70-80 %
70-80 %
of the food production
of the food production
20% of the labour
20% of the labour
force in non-agricultural
force in non-agricultural
employment in North Africa &
employment in North Africa &
37% in sub-Saharan Africa
37% in sub-Saharan Africa
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
7. Gender disparity in secondary and tertiary
education
Gender disparity in tertiary education have shown a slowly
decreasing trend, however, it is highly unlikely that African countries
will reach the gender parity for tertiary level target by 2015
Gender parity index in tertiary education, in selected African countries for selected African countries,
1991 and 2008
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
8. ICTs & women’s empowerment
ICTs can reduce discrimination and
empower women for all type of activities
Information, education, ability to
communicate and to enroll in decision-
making processes are the basic pillars of
empowerment
Empowered women would be one of the
most effective drivers of development
As clearly stated in the Beijing Declaration
“ICT is a powerful tool that women could use
for mobilization, information exchange and
empowerment."
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
9. Gender Barriers to Accessing and Using
ICTs
Lack of time and infrastructure
Lack of time and infrastructure
Social norms
Social norms
Cultural constraints
Cultural constraints
Education and employment
Education and employment
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
10. How are ICTs empowering women?
Information and
Information and Economic //
Economic
knowledge is
knowledge is Governance
Governance
power
power Empowerment
Empowerment
Networking
Networking
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
11. Is there a Digital Gender Divide?
ICTs access and usage shows gender
imbalance as shown in the example from
Benin and Ghana
Percent female Internet users in Ghana Percent female Internet users in Benin
40 12
35 10
30
25 8
Percent female Internet Percent female Internet
20 6
users users
15 4
10
5 2
0 0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2004 2005 2006 2007
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
12. Mobile phone ownership, selected
African countries
Country Female Male
Botswana (2005) 55.8% 44.2%
Cameroon Urban 49% 52%
areas 39% 61
Rural areas
Ethiopia (of 1793 0.2% of women 0.4% of men
households surveyed)
(2005)
South Africa (2007) 46% 54%
Tanzania (2005) 48.40% 50.50%
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
13. Findings: recent ECA-FOSSFA quick survey on
women and ICT
Priority areas that need to be considered to promote women software
developers:
• Mentorship - this came out in almost all of the replies
• Funding
• Market share, contracts, paying jobs
• Meeting with software legends
• Establishing a professional Association
• Media coverage of women's efforts
• Segregated (women only) training and coding rooms
• Business skills and culture
• Management skills
• Professional certification
• Up-to-date information on cutting edge technology and how to benefit from it
• Hands-on practical workshops
• Personality lessons: self esteem, confidence etc
• Communication and Public speaking capacity building
• Marketing and public relations capacity building
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
14. ECA’s role in gender and ICTs
AISI
AISI
Guided by the African Information Society Initiative launched in 1996,
Guided by the African Information Society Initiative launched in 1996,
with the aim of supporting and accelerating socio-economic development
with the aim of supporting and accelerating socio-economic development
across the region through the use of ICT s,E CAand partners supported
s, CA
across the region through the use of ICT E and partners supported
countries in Africa with the formulation of national ICT policies, commonly
countries in Africa with the formulation of national ICT policies, commonly
known as NICIs
known as NICIs
A number of countries mainstreamed gender in their national ICT policies
A number of countries mainstreamed gender in their national ICT policies
NICI Strategies
NICI Strategies
Over 43 countries have adopted their NICIs by end of 2010 and a further six
Over 43 countries have adopted their NICIs by end of 2010 and a further six
countries in the process of developing one
countries in the process of developing one
In the last over five years, many countries have moved from policy formulation
In the last over five years, many countries have moved from policy formulation
to implementation by putting in place sectoral strategies in key priority sectors
to implementation by putting in place sectoral strategies in key priority sectors
such as e-government, education, health, etc.
such as e-government, education, health, etc.
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
15. Gender mainstreaming in selected NICI
Policies in Africa
Mainstreaming statement
Ghana
Ghana
Put in place a mechanism to ensure the participation of women
Put in place a mechanism to ensure the participation of women
in developing the information society and to ensure that
in developing the information society and to ensure that
ICT policies at all levels are engendered,
ICT policies at all levels are engendered,
and geared toward meeting specific developmental needs of women
and geared toward meeting specific developmental needs of women
Zambia
Zambia
Promote the use of ICTs as tools to eliminate
Promote the use of ICTs as tools to eliminate
all forms of inequalities between sexes
all forms of inequalities between sexes
Pillar
Cameroon
Cameroon
Gender and Social Development
Gender and Social Development
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
16. Gender mainstreaming in selected NICI
Policies in Africa…contd
Vision Objectives
Gambia
Gambia
Cameroon To make ICT access affordable to all Gambian women
Cameroon To make ICT access affordable to all Gambian women
The information society should be
The information society should be
garanteed and anchored on the realities of the
garanteed and anchored on the realities of the Ghana
day. ItIt ICT policies at all levels are engendered,
day. ICT policies at all levels are engendered, Ghana
and geared toward meeting To accelerate the dev of women and eliminate gender
and geared toward meeting To accelerate the dev of women and eliminate gender
specific developmental needs of women inequalities in education, employment, decision making
specific developmental needs of women inequalities in education, employment, decision making
through the deployment and exploitation of IVICTs by
through the deployment and exploitation of IVICTs by
building capacities and providing opportunities
building capacities and providing opportunities
for girls and women
Lesotho
Lesotho
for girls and women
Government is committed to deploying ICTs
Government is committed to deploying ICTs
as tools in the process of ensuring
as tools in the process of ensuring Swaziland
Swaziland
gender equality, empowering and recognising Ensure that the benefits of ICTs are utilized in addressing
gender equality, empowering and recognising Ensure that the benefits of ICTs are utilized in addressing
women and youth in the development process gender (disadvantaged groups) inequalities in education,
women and youth in the development process gender (disadvantaged groups) inequalities in education,
employment opportunities, and decision making. ICT
employment opportunities, and decision making. ICT
capacity building for the girl child and women iis aa must
capacity building for the girl child and women iis must
Zambia
Zambia
There is need to address youth and women
There is need to address youth and women Zambia
as special groups in society that can
as special groups in society that can Zambia
positively contribute to the growth of ICTs To increase employment opportunities through ICTs,
positively contribute to the growth of ICTs To increase employment opportunities through ICTs,
as well as the use of ICTs as empowerment tools and the participation of youth and women
as well as the use of ICTs as empowerment tools and the participation of youth and women
in their daily activities in national development; etc.
in their daily activities in national development; etc.
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
17. ECA support in the area of gender and
ICT/STI
Mainstreaming Gender in ICT/STI policies;
Mainstreaming Gender in ICT/STI policies;
Capacity building ( (Gambia under the leadership of VP);
Capacity building Gambia under the leadership of VP);
Support to women innovators
Support to women innovators
ICT applications for women (Mobile apps for women entrepreneurs in Mozambique);
ICT applications for women (Mobile apps for women entrepreneurs in Mozambique);
Improving access through tele innovation centers (Ghana, Rwanda & Knowledge networks);
Improving access through tele innovation centers (Ghana, Rwanda & Knowledge networks);
Gender and E-government;
Gender and E-government;
TIGA Awards: promoting apps such as eSoko.
TIGA Awards: promoting apps such as eSoko.
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
18. E-government improving women’s
lives & incomes
Women
Government Services Supporting
Information livelihoods
• Registration services • Utilities
payment • Market access
• Access to information, • Medical services • Produce pricing e.g. for
e.g. electoral process • Education farmers
• Government policies • Government payments • Training for enhancing
and programs esp. in rural areas in productivity
absence of addressing • Money transfer
access
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
19. ICT increases Government Efficiency and
Transparency
ECA facilitated dialogue
among ICT and gender
experts in Africa to
analyse and evaluate the
efforts put in place by
African countries to
include a gender
dimension in e-
Government policies and
programmes
Produced a handbook
for policy makers on
gender sensitive e-
government strategies
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
20. ICTs at grassroots
Rural telecentre can support access to information and
services relevant for households for intensifying
agricultural production, adopting diversified livelihoods,
facilitate migration, or in enabling a combination of these.
A Community Telecentre
in Ugunja, Kenya (One
of ECA’s KN hub) is
using ICTs to tap the
farmers’ indigenous
knowledge on climate
change
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
21. E-Soko – one of the 2011 TIGA awarded
projects
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
22. E-Soko’s roles on women’s
empowerment
It reduced influence of information brokers who have formed strong market cartels;
It reduced influence of information brokers who have formed strong market cartels;
The information gathered and distributed by E-soko empowers farmers/growers in the
The information gathered and distributed by E-soko empowers farmers/growers in the
negotiation process that shifted the power equilibrium from buyers back to the farmers ; ;
negotiation process that shifted the power equilibrium from buyers back to the farmers
It reduced risk of loss through spoilage of goods in the search of suitable markets;
It reduced risk of loss through spoilage of goods in the search of suitable markets;
Increased the incomes of traders, farmers and their dependents.
Increased the incomes of traders, farmers and their dependents.
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
23. Conclusion
Encouraging girls towards science and technology
fields is critical;
African policy makers need to realise and ensure the
importance of mainstreaming gender in ICTs and STI
policies and strategies;
Investing on institutional and leadership capacities is
key for realising gender-sensitive policies;
Critical for women, the issue of digital divide in
education goes beyond the issue of access to
technology. The changing needs of economic and
social development require a wide range of new skills
and competences, known as the 21st century
competences key enablers of responsible
citizenship in a knowledge-based and technology-
pervaded economy
ICTs, Science & Technology Division (ISTD), UNECA www.uneca.org/istd / www.uneca.org/aisi
Progresses in MDGs in Africa assessed in 2010 by ECA, AUC, AfDB and UNDP shows: In primary and secondary education, the West African countries of The Gambia, Guinea, Mauritania, and Senegal made the greatest progress in achieving gender parity. In tertiary education, although data are scant, North Africa continues to lead the continent, as Tunisia and Algeria have significantly surpassed gender parity, to the extent that they now have more women than men enrolled in universities and colleges.
As was the case in last year’s report, Rwanda proved to be the best performer on this indicator in 2009, with 56.3 percent of its parliamentary seats held by women, followed by South Africa (45.0 percent), Angola (37.3 percent), Mozambique (34.8percent), and Uganda (30.7 percent). The remaining 26 countries that show improvements within this time period have less than 30 percent of seats held by women in national parliaments. Seventeen countries registered female participation below 10 percent in 2009. While overall trends for Africa on this indicator are positive.
In the formal economy, women are predominantly employed in the agricultural sector in Africa – especially in West Africa, Central Africa and Eastern and Southern Africa where it is estimated that they account for 60-80 per cent of the agricultural labour force – and are responsible for 70-80 per cent of the food production. Women make up 20% of the labour force in non-agricultural employment in North Africa, and 37% in sub-Saharan Africa. (UN:2007) In both North and SSA, women are underrepresented in many occupations, especially in the scientific and technological fields. Employment in the industrial sector remains generally less than 5 per cent for the majority of countries, with the percentage of women in the services sector falling between industry and agriculture. In all sectors, women are severely underrepresented in management and decision- making positions. They tend to advance more slowly than their male counterparts in their careers both in terms of assigned responsibilities and in terms of wage increases and are therefore at greater risk than men from poverty and disempowerment. [ECA:2001b; UNDP:2005; UN:2007]
Many African countries fail to report on gender parity at the tertiary level, with only nine countries providing data for both 1991 and 2007 (Burkina Faso, Burundi, Ethiopia, Ghana, Madagascar, Malawi, Morocco, Tanzania, and Tunisia). Data for these nine countries (see figure above) show that all of them have reduced gender disparity, with Tunisia (0.85) the best performer, followed by Morocco (0.31) and Tanzania (0.29). In 2007, Cape Verde, Algeria, and Tunisia surpassed parity and recorded indices of 1.21, 1.4, and 1.51 respectively. This means that in those countries, women are much more likely than men to access tertiary level education. With the majority of African countries recording a gender parity index below 0.90 in 2007, and many still struggling to reach a gender parity index of 0.50, it is highly unlikely that African countries will reach this tertiary level target by 2015 if current trends continue.
Information empowerment Information Literacy - information literacy, which is the ability to find and use information, is crucial because it involves increased confidence at a personal level. This enhanced confidence can lead to actions by women to influence larger political and legal systems. ICTs also facilitate the establishment of alternative media organizations and NGOs covering issues that are not given adequate attention by the mainstream media and to reach out to large sections of the population that were previously not served by the mainstream media. The Internet has brought women’s news and views into the public domain, with countless websites targeted specifically, if not exclusively, at women. Economic empowerment ICT can provide new opportunities for women’s economic empowerment by creating business and employment opportunities for women as owners and managers of ICT-accessed projects, as well as employees of new business ventures. Networking ICTs can contribute to increasing women’s networking for social and political advocacy, strengthening women’s participation in the political process, supporting the work of elected women officials, and increasing women’s access to government and its services. ICTs can thus effectively empower women through building new channels for social awareness, mobilizing resources for women, and networking women around matters that concern their lives
A survey of women’s access to ICTs in western Africa found that in some cases, men were threatened by their wives’ use of internet and cell phones – monitoring and in some cases prohibiting their use (Regentic:2005). In several regions, however, trends of mobile phone usage and ownership in particular appear to indicate a positive move towards gender parity and in some countries, imbalance in favour of females (see table above). Source: ECA’s Handbook on Gender, ICT Policy and e-Government in Africa.
A survey of women’s access to ICTs in western Africa found that in some cases, men were threatened by their wives’ use of internet and cell phones – monitoring and in some cases prohibiting their use (Regentic:2005). In several regions, however, trends of mobile phone usage and ownership in particular appear to indicate a positive move towards gender parity and in some countries, imbalance in favour of females (see table above). Source: ECA’s Handbook on Gender, ICT Policy and e-Government in Africa.
National e-government and ICT policies which understand the gendered conditions of both access and use of ICTs will have the potential to fully mobilise the contributions that women can make to national development when empowered by useful and appropriate information and esupport strategies.
ECA has also supported Togo and Chad in mainstreaming gender in their ICTs policy which is still in progress.
There are three main areas in which e-government can have real effects improving women's lives and incomes: Promoting government-citizen interaction and participation Information services in critical sectors Support to women's livelihoods.
To creatively involve farmers in research on Climate Change Adaptations measures, Ugunja Community Resource Centre (UCRC) (one of the ECA’s KN knowledge hubs) uses ICT to tap the farmers’ indigenous knowledge on climate change. They have identified a group of farmers that have been trained on use of digital cameras, video camera, sound recorders and writing skills. This group of farmers therefore uses the same equipments borrowed from UCRC to document their own innovations in their own language. UCRC staff assists the farmers in editing and cleaning the information received. The documented information is shared by the farmers in their meeting forums and UCRC is exploring on how to make this information available to other farmers through various media outlet. The project has been running for six months and an inventory of innovations has been developed through the aid of farmers. The technologies documented are quite promising and more focus needs to be given to such innovations as they trusted and are continuously practiced by farmers.
Founded in Ghana as a TradeNet in 2005 focused on agricultural marketing providing current market data via SMS and the web e-Soko is now active in 15 countries through different partnership agreements – both public sector agricultural projects and E-Soko country franchises – Ghana, Nigeria, Mozambique, Burundi, Zambia, Mali, Ivory Coast, Madagascar, Rwanda, Kenya, Burkina Faso, Sudan, Malawi, Tanzania and Uganda
Comfort Quarshie, Yam wholesaler and GAPTO member, Ghana, says: “ TradeNet liberates us from dictates of the ‘queen mothers’—spokespersons for women in West African markets,” “Queen mothers regulate the availability of commodities, and decide which trader groups go to the hinterlands each week to buy what, to sell where, and at what price. The queen mothers often hold the information and power. But now we use our mobile phones to get the information we need on prices and products—and make our own decisions.”