Distributed Collective Decision Making: From Ballot to Market
1. Distributed Collective Decision Making: From Ballot to Market Marko A. Rodriguez (1) Jennifer H. Watkins (2) (1) Digital Library Research & Prototyping Team (2) Socio-Political Dynamics Team Los Alamos National Laboratory (1) [email_address] (2) [email_address] http://cdms.lanl.gov Discovery Workshop: Applying Complexity Science to Organizational Design and Multistakeholder Systems
21. A Prediction Market. Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% $2.00 $2.00 $2.00 Bids Asks Y = $null N = $null $0.00 “ Will X happen? Y es or N o.”
22. A Prediction Market. Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N Y N $1.00 $1.00 $1.00 Bids Asks Y = $0.50 N = $0.50 $3.00
23. A Prediction Market. Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N Y N $1.00 $1.00 $1.00 Bids Asks Y = $0.50 N = $0.50 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.60” Human B: “Buying Y for $0.70”
24. A Prediction Market. Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N Y N $1.00 $1.00 $1.00 Bids Asks Y = $0.50 N = $0.50 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.60” Human B: “Buying Y for $0.70” Human C: “Selling Y for $0.70”
25. A Prediction Market. Y Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N N $1.00 $0.30 $1.70 Bids Asks Y = $0.70 N = $0.50 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.60”
26. A Prediction Market. Y Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N N $1.00 $0.30 $1.70 Bids Asks Y = $0.58 N = $0.42 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.60”
27. A Prediction Market. Y Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N N $1.00 $0.30 $1.70 Bids Asks Y = $0.58 N = $0.42 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.90” Human C: “Buying N for $0.45”
28. A Prediction Market. Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N $1.00 $0.30 $1.70 Bids Asks Y = $0.58 N = $0.42 $3.00 Human A: “Buying Y for $0.90” Human C: “Buying N for $0.45” Y Human B: “Selling Y for $0.90” N Human B: “Selling N for $0.45”
29. A Prediction Market. Y N Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N $0.10 $1.65 $1.25 Bids Asks Y = $0.90 N = $0.45 $3.00
30. A Prediction Market. Y N Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N $0.10 $1.65 $1.25 Bids Asks Y = $0.66 N = $0.33 $3.00
31. A Prediction Market. Y N Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% Y N Y N $0.10 $1.65 $1.25 Bids Asks Y = $0.66 N = $0.33 $3.00
32. A Prediction Market. N Human A Y = 100% N = 0% Human B Y = 70% N = 30% Human C Y = 45% N = 55% N N $2.10 $2.65 $1.25 Bids Asks Y = $0.66 N = $0.33 $0.00