SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 49
Deutsche Bank
Markets Research

Asia                                Strategy                                                   Date
                                                                                               17 October 2012
                                    The Investigator
                                                                                               Strategy Update

                                                                                               Ajay Kapur, CFA

Policy Uncertainty – The Financial                                                             Strategist
                                                                                               (+852) 2203 6196

World's Dominator                                                                              ajay.kapur@db.com


                                                                                               Ritesh Samadhiya, CFA
Elevated Economic Policy Uncertainty – about to drop?
We might be at an important inflection point in the financial markets. The elevation of        Strategist
Economic Policy Uncertainty, since 2008, to twice the level of the previous 23 years has       (+852) 2203 6251
increased the equity risk premium, diminished the opportunity set for stock-picking, and       ritesh.samadhiya@db.com
favored defensive stocks over cyclicals. Finance professionals and investors may have
wrongly concluded that this state of affairs will be prolonged and enduring. We think this     Absolute Return Drivers
status quo view is wrong, and that we could be at a turning point, and that economic




                                                                                                                                                                                     Current Account Balance/GDP
policy uncertainty has probably peaked. Let the profitable boredom begin!
US Political Polarization at 130-year high




                                                                                                                                       Sentiment (Risk-Love)
Political polarization might just recede with this coming US election. Financial




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Total Score (current)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Real Exchange Rate
deregulation – a key driver of complexity, the consequent compensation premium in the




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Total Score (last)
financial sector, the rise in the ratio of bank fee income to total income, and income
inequality, all likely peaked together in 2008. Any potential reduction in political




                                                                                                                                                               Technicals
                                                                                                                           Valuation
polarization will likely involve compromise, less policy uncertainty, and a lower likelihood




                                                                                                               Liquidity




                                                                                                                                                                            Growth
of policies being overturned with every election.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Policy
Economic Policy Uncertainty highly correlated with poor stock-picking efficacy
Economic Policy Uncertainty is a function of media mentions of the issue, laws dropping        China                                                                                                                                                     8                    -2
off the books, and economic forecast dispersion. The correlation coefficient between           Hong Kong                                                                                                                                               -2                     -2
Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock-picking efficacy was only 0.09 between 1985 and          Indonesia                                                                                                                                                 1                      0
2007. Since then it has jumped to 0.74. As a stock-picker, you want Economic Policy            India                                                                                                                                                     4                      3
Uncertainty to fall. Adjusted for portfolio volatility, the stock-picking opportunity will     Korea                                                                                                                                                     6                    -3
become much wider if uncertainty drops.                                                        Malaysia                                                                                                                                                  2                      3
Economic Policy Uncertainty is highly correlated with equity risk premium and                  Philippines                                                                                                                                               5                      0
defensives over cyclicals                                                                      Singapore                                                                                                                                               -2                       4
From 1985 to 2007, there was NO relationship between the two, a correlation coefficient        Thailand                                                                                                                                                  4                      6
of -0.07. Since 2008, however, the correlation coefficient between policy uncertainty and
                                                                                               Taiwan                                                                                                                                                    1                      0
equity risk premium has shot up to 0.67! Presumably, stocks are “cheap” compared with
                                                                                               Asia ex-Japan                                                                                                                                             4                    -2
bonds, since policy is uncertain, the impact on cash flows is uncertain and, as the most
                                                                                               Japan                                                                                                                                                     2                    -4
junior entity in the capital structure, stocks need to be cheap to compensate for this
policy uncertainty.
Economic Policy Uncertainty probably peaking out globally: huge implications
                                                                                               Our model portfolio is available as a DB
In the US, a 130-year peak in political polarization and an important election on what to
do about this polarization should help resolve things one way or another. Whatever the         thematic basket (DBHKASTR).
outcome of the election, another four years of peak political polarization is not what the
electorate is voting for. In Europe, there is still a long way to go on reducing policy
uncertainty on the part of governments, north and southern Europe, and within provinces
in countries, but the ECB’s views are quite clear, agree or disagree with them. In China,
the important political transition that occurs once in a decade will soon be over.
Governance and policy – the work of government – can then get renewed attention. In
India, after a period of lethargy, the government has recently been invigorated and policy
has come unstuck. Of course, this is all speculation and could be wrong, but not having a
view on the direction of Policy Uncertainty is NOT an option for financial professionals,
given its salience.
We are adding Top Glove Corp Bhd, Korea Zinc Co Ltd., Ace Hardware and Shree
Cement Ltd to the model portfolio. The model portfolio is up 23.1% YTD vs. 13.3% for
MSCI AXJ.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
All prices are those current at the end of the previous trading session unless otherwise indicated. Prices are sourced
from local exchanges via Reuters, Bloomberg and other vendors. Data is sourced from Deutsche Bank and subject
companies. Deutsche Bank does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. Thus,
investors should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report.
Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. DISCLOSURES AND
ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS ARE LOCATED IN APPENDIX 1. MICA(P) 072/04/2012.
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Table Of Contents
Policy Uncertainty – The Financial World’s Dominator ..................................................... 3 
Asia Model Portfolio update ............................................................................................... 8 
Country selection .............................................................................................................. 15 
Country-sector selection .................................................................................................. 16 
Asia Model Portfolio ......................................................................................................... 20 
Global – valuation ............................................................................................................. 21 
Global metrics ................................................................................................................... 22 
Global metrics (continued) ............................................................................................... 23 
Global – market intelligence ............................................................................................. 24 
Global – market intelligence (continued) .......................................................................... 25 
Asia – valuation ................................................................................................................ 26 
Asia – investor sentiment ................................................................................................. 27 
Asia – technicals ............................................................................................................... 28 
Asia – growth and earnings.............................................................................................. 29 
Asia – liquidity .................................................................................................................. 30 
Asia – factor performance ................................................................................................ 31 
Asia – market intelligence ................................................................................................ 33 
Japan – valuations ............................................................................................................ 34 
Japan – investor sentiment .............................................................................................. 35 
Japan – technicals ............................................................................................................ 36 
Japan – growth and earnings ........................................................................................... 37 
Japan – liquidity ................................................................................................................ 38 
Japan – factor performance ............................................................................................. 39 
Japan – market intelligence.............................................................................................. 40 
Companies Mentioned ..................................................................................................... 41 

Appendix A ................................................................................... 42 




Page 2                                                                                                                                    Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Policy Uncertainty – The Financial World’s Dominator

The only thing that matters – policy uncertainty and polarization
We contend that the main driver of the level of equity markets, the relative performance
of risk assets versus “safe” assets, and the potential opportunity for stock-pricing –
pretty much what defines a finance professional’s life – are increasingly determined by
just one primary factor. The rest of it – all those company meetings, the travel,
spreadsheets, conferences and broker research reports – are less salient compared to
this one factor. This is a bold claim. So what is this salient, primary factor? And can we
prove our contention? It is, in our view, Policy Uncertainty.

A few academics have quantified this for the US and Europe, and we will try to prove
our point regarding its link with changes in the equity risk premium, the relative
performance of risky versus “safe assets” and the stock-picking opportunity set. We
will also speculate that Policy Uncertainty in the world is about to downshift remarkably
from current ungainly elevated levels. If we are right, this will have hugely positive
implications for equities, risk assets and the opportunities for stock-picking. So far,
since the financial crisis broke out, Policy Uncertainty has been at twice the level of the
previous 23 years, keeping the equity risk premium high, challenging risky assets versus
“safe assets”, and rendering stock-picking opportunities exceptionally tough. All that
might be about to change.

But first a quick point on political polarization in the USA, where we have the data. As
Figure 1 shows, political polarization in the USA, proxied by how often Republicans vote
similarly to one another, as do Democrats, is at a record high since 1880! It is like two
sullen adults sitting at opposite ends of a see-saw, looking away from each other. With
that degree of entrenched polarization, it is tough to get policies passed, and a
malodorous air of policy inaction and uncertainty hangs heavy in the land. Note in
Figure 1 how policy polarization correlates well with income inequality (or plutonomy).
(Interested readers in the concept of political polarization should go to
http://www.slate.com/articles/life/do_the_math/2001/12/growing_apart.single.html, The
Mathematical Evidence for Congress’ Growing Polarization by Jordan Ellenberg1.) Our
humble contention is that time-series that are at 130-year extremes are most likely to
mean revert, however fanciful that might seem at the time of the extreme. In other
words, political polarization might just recede with this coming US election. Financial
deregulation – a key driver of complexity, the consequent compensation premium in the
financial sector, the rise in the ratio of bank fee income to total income, and income
inequality, all likely peaked together in 2008. Any potential reduction in political
polarization will likely involve compromise, less policy uncertainty, and less of a
likelihood of policies being overturned with every election. As Figure 2 shows, more
policy certainty would diminish one key headache for business.

Economic Policy Uncertainty
Scott Baker, Nick Bloom and Steven Davis at Stanford have constructed Economic
Policy Uncertainty indices for the US, Europe and Canada. For the US, in their words:

To measure policy-related economic uncertainty, we construct an index from three types of underlying
components. One component quantifies newspaper coverage of policy-related economic uncertainty. A second
component reflects the number of federal tax code provisions set to expire in future years. The third component
uses disagreement among economic forecasters as a proxy for uncertainty.


The first component is an index of search results from 10 large newspapers. The newspapers included in our
index are USA Today, the Miami Herald, the Chicago Tribune, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times,



1
    Also see the original authors’ work at http://voteview.com/Polarized_America.htm#MPRBOOK

Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                                        Page 3
17 October 2012
The Investigator




the Boston Globe, the San Francisco Chronicle, the Dallas Morning News, the New York Times, and the Wall
Street Journal. From these papers, we construct a normalized index of the volume of news articles discussing
economic policy uncertainty of some type. The second component of our index draws on reports by the
Congressional Budget Office (CBO) that compile lists of temporary federal tax code provisions. We create
annual discounted numbers of tax code provisions scheduled to expire for each year, giving a measure of the
level of uncertainty regarding the path that the federal tax code will take in the future. The third component of
our policy-related uncertainty index draws on the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia's Survey of
Professional Forecasters. Here, we utilize the dispersion between individual forecasters' predictions about
future levels of the Consumer Price Index, Federal Expenditures, and State and Local Expenditures to
construct indices of uncertainty about policy-related macroeconomic variables. (From their website,
www.policyuncertainty.com)


Figure 1: US: record political polarization and income inequality – about to reverse?
 1.2                                                                                                                                        20
                                                                                                  Higher
 1.1                                                                                                                                        18
                                                                                                  Polarization
 1.0                                                                                                                                        16
 0.9
                                                                                                                                            14
 0.8
                                                                                                                                            12
 0.7
                                                                                                                                            10
 0.6
                                                                                                                                            8
 0.5
 0.4                                                                                                                                        6
                      House Polarization, LS
 0.3                  Senate Polarization, LS                                                                                               4
                      Income share of the top 1% (excluding capital gains), RS
 0.2                                                                                                                                        2
       1879                1899                1919                1939                1959                1979                1999
Source: Deutsche Bank. Polarization is measured as difference in party means - first dimension. http://voteview.com/Polarized_America.htm




Figure 2: US: Economic Uncertainty a huge problem




Source: NFIB

Figure 3 shows the US, European and Canadian Economic Policy uncertainty indices.
We will use the US version for our arguments here. Figure 4 shows the US Economic


Page 4                                                                                                                                           Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Policy Uncertainty Index alongside the average US stock performance correlations with
the MSCI USA benchmark (a proxy for the potential efficacy of stock picking. If stocks
all move in the same direction with the benchmark, it reduces the efficacy of stock-
picking, once we adjust for portfolio volatility). A few things stand out. As the inventors
of the index note, US Economic Policy Uncertainty since 2007 has been at twice the
level of the prior 23 years. As Figure 4 also shows, the relationship between Economic
Policy Uncertainty and the stock-picking opportunity set has increased markedly since
2008. The correlation coefficient between Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock-
picking efficacy was only 0.09 between 1985 and 2007. Since then, it has jumped to
0.74. If you are a stock-picker, you want Economic Policy Uncertainty to subside, big
time. Adjusted for portfolio volatility, the stock picking opportunity will become much
wider, and life presumably a bit less stressful. Having a view on Economic Policy
Uncertainty is critical.


Figure 3: Economic Policy Uncertainty has been elevated since 2008, about to drop?
300                                                                                                                                                       300
                         US Economic Policy Uncertainty Index

250                      European Economic Policy Uncertainty Index                                            High policy                                250
                                                                                                               uncertainty
                         Canadian Economic Policy Uncertainty Index
200                                                                                                                                                       200


150                                                                                                                                                       150


100                                                                                                                                                       100


  50                                                                                                                                                      50


    0                                                                                                                                                     0
        1/85         1/88          1/91           1/94          1/97           1/00            1/03         1/06           1/09           1/12
Source: Deutsche Bank, Scott Baker, Nick Bloom and Steven Davis (www.policyuncertainty.com)




Figure 4: Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock correlations with the benchmark move
together. Stock-picking to become more potent as Policy Uncertainty drops
  0.9                                Average US stock performance (60 trading days)                                   EU credit crisis                    300
                                     correlations with MSCI USA, LS                                       Lehman Failure
  0.8     87 crash                   US Economic Policy Uncertainty measure, RS
                                                                                                                                                          250
  0.7                                                              Worldcom Scandal
                                            High                                                          High policy
                                            economic                                                      uncertainty
  0.6                                                          LTCM                                                                                       200
                                            policy
                    US recession            uncertainty Asian
  0.5
                                                        Crisis
                                                                                                                                                          150
  0.4

  0.3                                                                                                                                                     100
                                                                                                                           Macro-driven market,
  0.2                                                                                                                        correlation 0.74
                                                                                                                                                          50
  0.1
                        Stock-pickers market, correlation 0.09
  0.0                                                                                                                                                     0
     1/86       1/88      1/90       1/92      1/94      1/96       1/98      1/00      1/02       1/04      1/06       1/08      1/10      1/12
Source: Deutsche Bank, Stock correlations with MSCI USA based on rolling 60-day daily returns on a broad universe of stocks covering the top 95% of total
market capitalization (i.e.1,053 to 2,684 stocks from 1985 to 2012). For more on the “Economic Policy Uncertainty Index”, go to the website
http://policyuncertainty.com. According to the authors, “To measure policy-related economic uncertainty, we construct an index from three types of underlying
components. One component quantifies newspaper coverage of policy-related economic uncertainty. A second component reflects the number of federal tax
code provisions set to expire in future years. The third component uses disagreement among economic forecasters as a proxy for uncertainty.”



Figure 5 shows the relationship between the US Economic Policy Uncertainty index and
the equity risk premium (the higher it is, the “cheaper” stocks are versus bonds). From
1985 to 2007, there was NO relationship between the two, a correlation coefficient of -
0.07. Since 2008, however, the correlation coefficient between policy uncertainty and


Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                                                                                      Page 5
17 October 2012
The Investigator




the equity risk premium has shot up to 0.67! Presumably, stocks are “cheap” compared
with bonds, since policy is uncertain, the impact on cash flows is uncertain and, as the
most junior entity in the capital structure, stocks need to be cheap to compensate for
this policy uncertainty. Logically, if the correlation holds and there is a substantial
decline in policy uncertainty, the equity risk premium could decline in tandem – stocks
would beat bonds massively. Having a view on Economic Policy Uncertainty is critical.
How about defensive sectors versus cyclicals? Does US Economic Policy Uncertainty
have any role here? Yes. As Figure 6 shows, changes in US Economic Policy
Uncertainty relate well with changes in the relative performance of defensives versus
cyclicals. The correlation coefficient has doubled from 0.33 between 1985-2007 and
2008 now. As policy uncertainty rises, there is an unsurprising rush to defensives, and
vice versa. Again, this relationship has been a lot more salient since 2008. Having a
view on Economic Policy Uncertainty is critical.


Figure 5: Equity Risk Premium and Economic Policy Uncertainty have moved in lock-
step since 2008. Unlocking equity risk premium if Policy Uncertainty drops
250                                                                                                                                          8%
                                                                                                            High policy
230                  US Economic Policy Uncertainty Index,                                                  uncertainty
                     3mma, LS                                                                                                                6%
210
                     Equity Risk Premium (S&P500 earnings                                                                                    4%
190
                     yield less 10yr bond yield), RS
170
                                                                                                                                             2%
150
                                                                                                                                             0%
130
110                                                                                                                                          -2%
                                                                                                                       Correlation 0.67
  90
                         Correlation -0.07                                                                                                   -4%
  70
  50                                                                                                                                         -6%
       1/85    1/87      1/89      1/91     1/93      1/95      1/97     1/99      1/01      1/03     1/05      1/07    1/09   1/11   1/13
Source: Deutsche Bank


Figure 6: Defensives versus Cyclicals ( or risk-off versus risk-on) moves with changes in
Economic Policy Uncertainty
 80%                      Economic Policy Uncertainty, 6m change, LS                                                                         80%

 60%                      US defensive sectors / cyclical sectors, 6 month change, RS                                                        60%

 40%                                                                                                                                         40%

 20%                                                                                                                                         20%

   0%                                                                                                                                        0%
        1/85 1/87 1/89 1/91 1/93 1/95 1/97 1/99 1/01 1/03 1/05 1/07 1/09 1/11 1/13
-20%                                                                                                                                         -20%

-40%                                         Correlation 0.33                                                          Correlation 0.68      -40%

-60%          Defensive sectors are Consumer staples,                                                                                        -60%
              healthcare, utilities and telecom.
-80%                                                                                                                                         -80%
Source: Deutsche Bank. Defensive sector price index is from Datastream while MSCI CYC Index is used for cyclicals.


So what is our view on Policy Uncertainty globally? We can only speculate on this, but
it is important to do so. In the US, a 130-year peak in political polarization and an
important election on what to do about this polarization should help resolve things one
way or another. Whatever the outcome of the election, we think it’s safe to say that
another four years of peak political polarization is not what the electorate is hoping for.
The party that loses is unlikely to find recalcitrance and obstructionism a future vote-
gathering strategy, in our view. Of course, we could be wrong and the logjam, the


Page 6                                                                                                                                              Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




polarization, the policy uncertainty could go on for longer. In Europe, the ECB approved
its aggressive bond-buying plan with just one dissenter. While there is still a long way
to go on reducing policy uncertainty on the part of governments, north and southern
Europe, and within provinces in countries, the ECB’s views are quite clear, agree or
disagree with them. In China, the important political transition that occurs once in a
decade will soon be over. A renewed focus on governance and policy – the work of
government – can then begin. In India, after a period of lethargy, the government has
recently been invigorated and policy has come unstuck.

With the passage of time since the outbreak of the financial crisis, there is early
empirical evidence in the "austerity versus fiscal spending" debate. 2 As more time
elapses and more empirical results reveal themselves, we believe policy uncertainty will
likely diminish. Policymakers and voters will be better informed about the consequences
of opposing policy choices. Thus, the menu of successful policy options will likely shrink
– there should be less uncertainty about the "right" policy course.

Our simple read is that the substantial elevation of policy uncertainty around the world
is probably coming to an end. The confusion of policymakers in facing the rather unique
challenges of a once-in-seventy-years potential debt deflation was understandable. It is
by no means all blue skies from here, but policymakers and politicians are both learning
what is “working”, and what is not. Electorates are making choices about the direction
they want to go in, rather than the logjam of the past five years. Debtors and creditors
always fight about loss allocation in a debt crisis – time is the only healer that can bring
them together, however reluctantly. That time seems to be approaching. Again, this is
simple expectation on our part, and we could be plain wrong. But we stress that not
having a view on the direction of Policy Uncertainty is NOT an option for financial
professionals.

In sum, we might be at an important inflection point in financial markets. The elevation
of Economic Policy Uncertainty since 2008 has elevated the equity risk premium,
diminished the opportunity set for stock-picking, and favored defensive stocks over
cyclicals. The mindset of finance professionals and investors might have wrongly
concluded that this state of affairs is going to be prolonged and enduring – that bonds
are better than stocks, that stock-picking is ruinously counter-productive in this “macro-
driven” market, and that defensives are superior investments to cyclicals. This view
implies a continued elevated level of global Economic Policy Uncertainty. We think this
status quo view is wrong, and that we could be at a turning point, and that economic
policy uncertainty has probably peaked. Let the profitable boredom begin!




2
 See the latest IMF World Economic Outlook, Coping with High Debt and Sluggish Growth and Fiscal Policy in a
Depressed Economy by Lawrence H. Summers and J. Bradford DeLong.
(www.brookings.edu/~/.../2012_spring_BPEA_delongsummers.pdf)



Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                                     Page 7
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Asia Model Portfolio update
We are removing Hyundai Motor Co, Hyundai Mobis, Simplo Technology Co Ltd and
Starhub Ltd. Hyundai Motor and Hyundai Mobis have dropped to the fourth and third
quintile respectively in our multifactor stock ranking model. Hyundai Motor looks
weaker (relative to the region) on profitability, growth and earnings momentum.
Hyundai Mobis is now looking expensive and has lower earnings momentum. Simplo
Technology faded on price momentum, earnings momentum and consensus rating
metrics. We are cutting Singapore on poor earnings revisions and dropping Starhub
from the model portfolio.

We are adding Top Glove Corp Bhd, Korea Zinc Co Ltd, Ace Hardware and Shree
Cement Ltd. Top Glove ranks highly on valuation, earnings and price momentum. Korea
Zinc looks better on profitability, earnings, price momentum and earnings quality. Ace
hardware, though looking expensive, scores well on profitability, growth, earnings and
price momentum. Shree Cement looks good on profitability, earnings, price momentum
and consensus analyst rating. For factor description, see appendix A.

Top Glove Corp Bhd (TOPG MK)
Outlook remains positive; reiterating Buy. Disciplined capacity expansion plans,
expectations of leveling raw material prices as a result of higher rubber production in
ASEAN and slower consumption growth globally, as well as resilient demand for rubber
gloves for medical and hygiene purposes should drive multi-year growth for the sector
and allow Top Glove to generate two-year (FY13-15E) net profit CAGR of 14%, in our
view. We reiterate our Buy recommendation with a price target of RM6.05/share,
implying a total return of 21%. (Michelle Foong, 12 October 2012)

Korea Zinc Co Ltd (010130 KS)
Gold/silver price forecast upgrades affect Zijin/Zhaojin/Korea Zinc. Deutsche Bank’s
global commodity team has upgraded its gold/silver price forecasts by 2.4% for 2013
and 11.1% for 2014 in light of further central bank action to expand monetary
conditions. The most relevant stocks in Asia ex-Japan are Zijin, Zhaojin and Korea Zinc
(50% revenue exposure). We raise Zijin/Zhaojin/Korea Zinc’s 2013E earnings by
2.4%/5.1%/1.5%, respectively. Our DCF valuation method differentiates Zijin (Buy) from
Zhaojin (downgrade from Buy to Hold), with target price upgrades at 5.6% and 8.3%,
respectively. We believe the bullishness on the gold price has been factored into
Zhaojin’s share price, after a 36% rally in the past month. We roll over Korea Zinc’s
target price to 2013-based and raise it by 24%. Overall, Zijin and Korea Zinc stand out
after the upgrades, with their target prices now implying 20% and 27% upside potential.
(Chanwook Park, 4 October, 2012)

Ace Hardware (ACES IJ)
Consistently delivering strong growth and aggressive expansion. We believe that Ace
Hardware Indonesia will continue to deliver strong growth as it is one of the best
proxies for the expanding middle class, enjoying a forecast earnings CAGR of 22% over
the next three years. Management has a strong operational and financial track record,
delivering a sales CAGR of 32% on expansion of 21% over the past three years. We
believe the company is on track to have 100 stores in the next three years, which is a
43% increase. Maintaining Buy with new DCF-based target price of Rp8,000 (from
Rp5,000). (Reggy Susanto, 28 September, 2012)

Shree Cement (SRCM IN)
A high FCF yield of over 9% in FY13e, EBITDA CAGR of 27% over FY12-FY14e, driven
by improving realizations and attractive valuations of 6.6x FY13e EV/EBITA, and a ~30%
discount to large cap peers makes us confident of continued outperformance from the
stock despite a 37% rise in the stock price over the past three months. (Harshad Katkar,
16 October, 2012)


Page 8                                                                                     Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Summary

Global
High policy uncertainty, and the attendant flight from junior tranches of the capital
structure, along with a dismal prior decade of equity returns keeps them “cheap”.
Reduced policy uncertainty and losses from bond portfolios are likely to be required as
catalysts to unlock value in equities. Despite all the despair about global growth, our
own mother of all leading indicators (MOMLI) is looking up, as are asset-price-based
opinions on global growth. Meanwhile, analysts have lost confidence and are looking
for just 5% EPS growth globally in 2012, and 12% for 2013. Global Risk-Love
(sentiment) has now entered euphoria, a slight concern. The global Tape is very strong,
and the Marshallian K is rising.

Asia
Asian valuations are moderately below historical averages. The problem is margins – in
China they seem to be in a secular decline, while in India they seem to be at a cyclical
low. The region cannot rely on asset turns and leverage – both at global levels – to
boost relative ROEs compared with the world. It is probably going to have to be EBIT
margin expansion that gets the PB up. We don’t see any substantial decline in the cost
of equity to boost PB multiples. Risk-love in Asia is at neutral. Technicals are improving
– new highs are rising, and new lows have almost vanished. Asia’s leading economic
indicators are bottoming, and policy is no longer being tightened. Analysts have taken
the knife to this year’s EPS growth forecasts from around 13% at the start of the year to
5% now. We think that EPS revisions and economic surprises are about bottoming now.
New issuance and secondaries have been paltry – a good positive contrarian indicator.
Foreign fund flows have resumed in earnest as markets have rallied. Value strategies
and high profitability have done well this year, while high projected growth stocks have
been punished.

Japan
Japanese stocks continue to look undervalued versus history. A return to credible
inflation and higher nominal GDP growth globally is required to unlock value. Recent
tensions with China are unhelpful for risk assets in Japan. Sentiment is at neutral levels.
Technicals are mixed. Economic surprises are nasty and mean-reverting. They are
probably going to get less bad. EPS revisions continue to slide. Fund flows are weak
and the market continues to underperform the world as US 10-year bond yields remain
suppressed. Value remains the long-term winner.

China (neutral)
China’s valuations look “cheap” compared with history and are at fair value on our PB
ROE less COE model. However, on prospective ROEs of around 7% in three years’ time
and COE of around 10%, the current PB of 1.4 is substantially overvalued. Monetary
reflation could lift the current multiple, but the long-term deterioration in EBIT margins
is the key challenge to a re-rating. Sentiment is at neutral. Worryingly, turnover/market
cap is plumbing new depths. Once the political transition is done, and policy making,
reflation and market-supportive steps are likely taken, sentiment and pathetic turnover
might perk up. Technicals are weak. Policy is tightening via the currency, and weak
monetary growth. Real interest rates for corporates are rising with the corporate price
deflator contracting yoy. EPS revisions keep dropping as do EPS growth forecasts for
2012 and 2013. We are watching carefully for EPS revisions to hook up. The good news
is that the credit multiplier is rising yoy, and the market is responsive to this indicator.
The bad news is that the gap between M1 and M2 growth is still weak and correlates
with the PB multiple. We need to see a more credible reflation to see the market make




Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                     Page 9
17 October 2012
The Investigator




strong upward moves. Earnings revisions and momentum, together with analyst
opinions are being rewarded this year, while value investing has been patchy.

Hong Kong (neutral)
Hong Kong equities are at fair value compared with history, and about in the middle of
the pack compared with the other Asian markets. Sentiment has rebounded from the
panic levels earlier this year. Turnover to market capitalization is still anemic, but we are
encouraged by the rise in the gap between M1 and M2 growth. Technicals have
improved since the summer. Policy seems to be tightening (even as real interest rates
are quite negative), and EPS revisions are still quite weak. The EPS growth forecast for
2012 has collapsed – the sign changed from an expected +12% earlier this year to -12%
growth expected now! For next year, EPS growth is expected at 10%. Inflation is
making the real effective exchange rate less competitive, and the yield curve is flat. A
good dose of monetary reflation in China is required to turn liquidity up. Negative real
interest rates are here to stay in HK for longer than anyone recognizes. Value and low
risk styles have been exceptional performers this year.

India (overweight)
Despite the recent run-up, the market is still undervalued on EV/Sales, EV/EBITDA and
PB compared with history. On other metrics, like trailing PE and dividend yield, it is at
long-term averages. On our PB versus ROE less COE model it is at fair value, and needs
for ROEs to rise and/or COEs to fall – likely if the RBI cuts rates as the Rupee
strengthens. Risk-love has perked up from panic in May to neutral now. Meeting with
scores of clients around the world, however, we think there is still considerable
skepticism about the market. With the recent rally, technicals have improved. The
downgrade to GDP growth by the IMF is unfathomable to us simpletons. The leading
indicator from the OECD has been rising for months, and the EPS revisions trajectory
has also been improving for months. Our policy indicator has curled up with the
weakness in the Rupee. Looking ahead, we expect the monetary base to start growing
from its paltry 4% yoy rate, as net foreign asset growth resumes on the back of reforms
and confidence. EPS growth projections for next year, at 12-14%, are reasonable. The
monetary base growth at 4.4% is anemic. The lack of net foreign asset growth is being
compensated by a substantial increase in net RBI lending to government. This is a
vicious cycle that needs to be broken, and probably will be, if reform momentum is
maintained. The yield curve is no longer negative, but is still flat as a chapatti. Value and
EPS momentum have been rewarded well this year. Stick with them.

Indonesia (neutral)
Valuations are at fair levels compared with history. We are a bit concerned about the
decline in Indonesia’s EBIT margins. Maintaining premium valuations to the region
requires maintaining premium ROEs to the region. Having almost doubled capex/GDP in
the past few years, and as it is exposed to any slowdown in nominal GDP growth in
China, keep an eye on declining margins in Indonesia. Indonesia has gone from the
poster child of solid macro policy last year to one that is perceived as having less than
optimal policies – interest rates cut “too soon”, etc. We didn’t understand either
position. Indeed, it seems that other EM central banks are now following BI in cutting
interest rates to combat slower growth. Maybe BI is a lot smarter than the gallery of
critics assumes. We think policy easing makes sense (unlike consensus) – real economy
data is coming in really weak, EPS revisions are negative (but recovering), and EPS
growth expectations have collapsed from 17% a few months ago to just 8% now for
calendar 2012. Inflation, a lagging indicator, is stable at the 4%-ish level. The currency is
more competitive in real effective terms, free liquidity is booming and the yield curve is
flat-ish. Value and EPS mo are king here. The rest are not really adding alpha this year.




Page 10                                                                                         Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Korea (underweight)
The market is at fair value compared with its history, but cheap compared with other
markets on a snapshot basis. This is a low ROE, low EBIT margin market, and is likely to
remain a low PB market unless ROEs rise sharply. Interestingly, unlike China, Taiwan
and Singapore, where margins have been in secular decline, and ROEs have been
goosed by rising asset turns and leverage (this has also been happening in Malaysia and
Indonesia recently), in Korea this is not happening. EBIT margins and ROEs move
together – albeit at low levels. We think this deserves a higher multiple than currently
obtained. We think investors in the other markets might be suffering from “ROE
illusion”, implying very strong nominal GDP growth and more leverage – both unlikely.
Sentiment is just shy of neutral. Technicals are a lot stronger than overall market
performance suggests. Close to a record percentage of stocks are making 52-week
highs. The leading economic indicator has been rising persistently for many months
now, but EPS revisions are still in the doldrums. Implication: margins are under
continued pressure. The terms of trade are improving and we expect this to feed
through to improving margins and EPS revisions soon. The yield curve is flat, and
flattening. Value has made a massive comeback in the past six months. Price and EPS
mo have been disasters this year. Stock-picking in Korea based on style is very tricky
because the factors go in and out of style with a head-spinning intensity.

Malaysia (neutral)
Malaysian equities are undervalued versus history but quite expensive versus the other
markets on a relative basis. As in Indonesia, we are concerned about the sharp drop in
EBIT margins, even as ROEs remain stable. Risk-Love is quite high, just shy of euphoria.
Technicals are neutral. The EPS revisions index has collapsed and EPS growth numbers
are being taken down for 2012. Price and EPS mo, along with ROE have been rewarded
this year. But value has been tepid.

Philippines (neutral)
The market is expensive compared with its history and versus other markets in the
region. We like that the EBITs and ROEs move together, so there is no leverage or asset
turnover-driven “ROE illusion”. Also, years of under-investment imply many years of
strong EBIT margins (unlike say in China, or maybe even Indonesia). Sentiment has
come off from the euphoria of the summer to neutral now. The leading economic
indicator is rising, and we expect EPS revisions to do the same. This is a requirement in
order to maintain its premium valuations. Value, a perennial king in Philippine alpha
generation, continues to do well, as do EPS revision strategies.

Singapore (neutral)
The market is cheap compared with history, but fairly valued compared with other
regional markets. EBIT margins are in secular decline, and maintaining ROEs will rely on
continued improvements in asset turnover and leverage. Sentiment is in mild euphoria.
Technicals are super-strong, with close to a record percentage of stocks making 52-
week highs. EPS growth projections for both 2012 and 2013 remain lackluster. Earnings
revisions also look weak. The good news is that the terms of trade are now picking up
nicely, so margins are likely to get a boost. Only stability and low risk factors are
generating alpha. Value strategies are mixed, but momentum strategies have destroyed
alpha this year.

Taiwan (underweight)
The market is a serial underperformer versus the region. EBIT margins are in secular
decline, and the high asset turnover is running into gravity now. Risk-love is in the tank.
EPS revisions are worsening, but there is hope. The terms of trade have gone vertical
and project rising EPS momentum. Given poor sentiment, and an impending
improvement in EPS growth projections, we need to keep an eye on the underweighted

Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                    Page 11
17 October 2012
The Investigator




market. This tech-heavy market is respecting price momentum and stocks supported by
analysts.

Thailand (overweight)
The market is fairly valued versus history and the region. The exception is PB – where
the market is at record premiums to the region. Could that be a reward for the solid
ROEs (driven not by EBIT margins but asset turns)? Sentiment is neutral. Technicals are
super-strong. About a quarter are making 52-week highs. Growth-leading indicators are
still strong, even as incoming data have been weak. Analysts have dropped projected
2012 EPS growth forecasts from 23% earlier his year to about 15% now. Also, we are
comforted with the rise in the terms of trade that should be supportive of margins and
EPS growth going forward. Value has been a disaster this year, while price and EPS
momentum strategies have been huge winners.




Page 12                                                                                   Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Figure 7: Model portfolio performance since inception (13 September 2010)
                  22 Model portfolio absolute returns (After T/C): 19.0% 1-week relative returns 0.1%                                                                                                     22
                  20 MSCI Asia ex Japan absolute returns: 4.8%           1-month relative returns 2.5%                                                                                                    20
                  18 Model portfolio relative returns (After T/C): 14.2% YTD relative returns 9.8%                                                                                                        18
                  16                                                      12-month relative returns 12.1%                                                                                                 16
                  14      After Transaction Cost                                                                                                                                                          14
                  12                                                                                                                                                                                      12
                  10                                                                                                                                                                                      10
                   8                                                                                                                                                                                      8
                   6                                                                                                                                                                                      6
                   4                                                                                                                                                                                      4
                   2                                                                                                                                                                                      2
                   0                                                                                                                                                                                      0
                  -2                                                                                                                                                                                      -2
                    9/10 11/10 1/11 3/11 5/11 7/11 9/11 11/11 1/12 3/12 5/12 7/12 9/12
Source: Deutsche Bank, MSCI, FactSet
Note: Performance is measured in local currency. Stock changes are effective as of close one day after they are officially published (i.e. Changes published on 4th May 2011 will be effective as of close 5th May 2011).
*New additions. Assume 50bps on both buying and selling as proxy for transaction cost. Note: Past performance does not guarantee future results



Figure 8: Model portfolio country and sector overweights/underweights
                                   -12% -9% -6% -3% 0%                      3%     6%      9% 12%                    Sector (MSCI Wgt)               -12% -9% -6% -3% 0%                      3%      6%      9% 12%
  Country (MSCI Wgt)
                                                                                                                                 Retailing (1.5%)
           THAILAND (3.0%)
                                                                                                                                Materials (7.0%)
                                                                                                                                   Energy (7.2%)
                  INDIA (9.5%)                                                                                                   Telecom (6.7%)
                                                                                                                                Cons Svc (1.7%)
                                                                                                                          Div Financials (2.4%)
          INDONESIA (3.7%)
                                                                                                                                 Cap Gds (7.6%)
                                                                                                                     Health Care Equip (0.3%)
        PHILIPPINES (1.2%)                                                                                                          Media (0.3%)
                                                                                                                              Real Estate (7.0%)

               CHINA (23.9%)                                                                                                  Comm Svc (0.0%)
                                                                                                                        Pharma/Biotech (0.7%)
                                       Underweight               Neutral       Overweight                                                                                                      Overweight
                                                                                                                                Software (3.2%)               Underweight
         SINGAPORE (7.3%)
                                                                                                                          Cons Dur/App (0.8%)
                                                                                                                   Food/Staples Retail (0.8%)
           MALAYSIA (4.9%)                                                                                             Food Beverages (3.6%)
                                                                                                                        Hhold Products (1.2%)
                                                                                                                                   Utilities (3.9%)
      HONG KONG (11.9%)
                                                                                                                                Insurance (4.3%)
                                                                                                                                Transport (1.9%)
             TAIWAN (14.4%)                                                       Current O/U wgt                       Tech Hardware (4.5%)                                                    Current O/U wgt
                                                                                  (17 October 2012)                                                                                             (17 October 2012)
                                                                                                                                     Autos (5.0%)
                                                                                  Previous O/U wgt                                                                                              Previous O/U wgt
                                                                                                                                   Semis (10.1%)
    SOUTH KOREA (20.1%)                                                           (07 August 2012)                                                                                              (07 August 2012)
                                                                                                                                   Banks (18.1%)

                                   -12% -9% -6% -3% 0%                      3%     6%      9% 12%                                                    -12% -9% -6% -3% 0%                      3%      6%      9% 12%

Source: Deutsche Bank, MSCI.
Note: Numbers in parenthesis are sector and country weights in MSCI AC Asia ex Japan index. The model portfolio is equal weighted; each stock has weighting of 2.5%.




Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                                                                                                                                       Page 13
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Figure 9: Asia Model Portfolio




                                                                                                                                                                                           Profitability
                                                                                                                                                                      FY 13




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Cons Rec
                                                                                                                                                                               Valuation


                                                                                                                                                                                                           Price Mo
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Earnings




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Earnings
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Stability


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Growth

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Quality
                                                                          DB      Date          Close    YTD Rtn      Hldg Per                 Mcap 20D ADT         PE (DB




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Risk
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Mo
                                                     BB Ticker     Mkt Rec       Added       16Oct12          (%)      Rtn (%)      Beta      (U$bn)      (U$ m)        est)
Energy - MSCI wgt: 7.2%, portfolio wgt: 12.5%
CNOOC Ltd.                                           883 HK        CN      H    11Dec10         15.94         20.5         -6.7        1.40     91.8       111.5         8.9 o                 + ++                   o     o ++ o                  o    o
Oil & Natural Gas Corp. Ltd.                         ONGC IN       IN      B    14Sep10       278.95          12.4        -14.7        0.65     45.2        20.3         8.7 ++ ++ +                                  o     o ++ o                  o    o
Oil India Ltd.                                       OINL IN       IN      B    30Sep11       485.85           5.9         -6.2        0.29       5.5         1.7        9.1 ++ +                           +         o     + ++ o                  o    o
PTT PCL                                              PTT TB        TH     NR    14Sep10       311.00           1.6                     1.27     29.0        38.7
SK Innovation Co. Ltd.                               096770 KS KR          B     7Aug12       154000           8.5         -6.9        1.47     13.5        55.8         6.6 ++ ++ +                                  o     - - ++ - -              o    o
Materials - MSCI wgt: 7.0%, portfolio wgt: 12.5%
Grasim Industries Ltd.                               GRASIM IN IN          B    27Jun12      3464.85          39.0         36.1        0.75       6.0         6.0      11.0 +                  + ++ ++ ++ o                               o         +    o
Shree Cement Ltd.                                    SRCM IN       IN      B    17Oct12      4048.80          87.7          NA         0.70       2.7         6.3      17.7 -               ++ ++ ++                        o       -     --        o   ++
Indocement Tunggal Prakarsa                          INTP IJ       ID      B    14Sep10        21450          27.5         19.6        1.34       8.2         5.5      15.9 -               ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ o                                        o    o
Korea Zinc Co. Ltd.                                  010130 KS KR          B    17Oct12       461000          51.6          NA         1.13       7.9       31.9         8.2 o ++ ++ ++                                     -      +      o         +    o
LG Chem Ltd.                                         051910 KS KR          B    14Sep10       316500          -0.3         -5.3        1.53     19.3        73.6       11.9 o ++ +                                    o     o ++ o                  o    --
Capital Goods - MSCI wgt: 7.6%, portfolio wgt: 10.0%
China Communications Construction Co. Ltd. 1800 HK                 CN      B    5May11           6.94         18.0          5.5        1.41     12.1        19.3         7.0 +                 +            o     ++        o      o      o         o   ++
Sino-Thai Engineering & Construction PCL             STEC TB       TH      B     7Aug12         20.70         72.8         36.2        0.82       0.8         3.9      19.3 o                  + ++ ++                      o ++ o                  o   ++
SembCorp Industries Ltd.                             SCI SP        SG      B    14Sep10          5.47         39.3         30.0        1.36       8.0         9.3      11.4 o ++ o                                ++        o      +      o         o    +
SembCorp Marine Ltd.                                 SMM SP        SG      B    11Dec10          4.92         35.3          8.0        1.66       8.4       14.5       13.2 o ++ o                                    +     o ++ - -                o    +
Commercial Services & Supplies - MSCI wgt: 0.0%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Transportation - MSCI wgt: 1.9%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Automobiles & Components - MSCI wgt: 5.0%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Consumer Durables & Apparel - MSCI wgt: 0.8%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Consumer Services - MSCI wgt: 1.7%, portfolio wgt: 5.0%
SJM Holdings Ltd.                                    880 HK        HK      B     9Mar12         16.30         34.5         10.1        1.34     11.7          9.7      12.7 + ++ ++ ++                                      o ++ ++                 o
Minor International PCL                              MINT TB       TH      B    27Jun12         17.80         76.2         26.2        1.06       2.1         6.5      20.4 o ++ ++ ++                                      o      - - ++           o
Media - MSCI wgt: 0.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
BEC World PCL                                        BEC TB        TH      H    11Nov11         57.25         31.7         59.1        0.73       3.7         3.4      20.8 -               ++ ++                     o     o ++ o                  o    --
Retailing - MSCI wgt: 1.5%, portfolio wgt: 7.5%
Belle International Holdings Ltd.                    1880 HK       CN      B    5May11          13.62          2.0         -6.9        0.93     14.8        25.5       15.7 -               ++ ++ ++                        o ++ ++                      o
Giordano International Ltd.                          709 HK        HK      H    14Sep10          6.40         20.4         61.0        0.88       1.3         2.5      12.3 + ++ +                                    +     o ++ ++                     ++
Ace Hardware Indonesia                               ACES IJ       ID      B    17Oct12      6650.00          62.8          NA         0.41       1.2         0.6      23.7 - -                + ++ ++                      o      + ++                  o
Food & Staples Retailing - MSCI wgt: 0.8%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Food Beverage & Tobacco - MSCI wgt: 3.6%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
Uni-President Enterprises Corp.                      1216 TT       TW      B     7Aug12         52.00         28.0          4.7        0.63       8.7       14.3       19.9 -                  + ++ ++                              -     +         o    o
Household & Personal Products - MSCI wgt: 1.2%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Health Care Equipment & Services - MSCI wgt: 0.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
Top Glove Corp. Bhd                                  TOPG MK MY            B    17Oct12          5.31          8.8          NA         0.99       1.1         2.2      14.1 ++ o                            +     ++        o ++ - -                o    o
Pharmaceuticals & Biotechnology - MSCI wgt: 0.7%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Banks - MSCI wgt: 18.1%, portfolio wgt: 7.5%
ICICI Bank Ltd.                                      ICICIBC IN IN         B     7Aug12      1042.05          54.6          7.0        1.44     22.7        78.4       12.7 - -                 o           o         o     o      --     o         o   ++
BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Ltd.                        2388 HK       HK      B    5May11          24.10         37.0          9.3        1.02     32.9        32.2       11.7 ++ o                            o         +     o      o      o         o    +
Industrial & Commercial Bank of China Ltd.           1398 HK       CN      B    5May11           4.88         11.2        -16.7        1.41    214.7       165.4         6.2 ++ ++ o                              --        o      o      o         o   ++
Diversified Financials - MSCI wgt: 2.4%, portfolio wgt: 5.0%
IDFC Ltd.                                            IDFC IN       IN      B    15May12       149.90          65.9         30.7        1.58       4.3       24.5       10.2 -               ++ o                      o    ++             o              o
Haitong Securities Co. Ltd-H share                   6837 HK       CN      B    27Jun12         10.70          NA          -0.2         NA      14.5          7.0      15.0 +                  +            +         +     o             o             ++
Insurance - MSCI wgt: 4.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
Dongbu Insurance Co. Ltd.                            005830 KS KR         NR     9Mar12        49550          -5.0          5.7        0.53       3.2         5.5        NA + ++                                      o     o             -              o
Real Estate - MSCI wgt: 7.0%, portfolio wgt: 7.5%
Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd.                         16 HK         HK      B    11Dec10       109.00          12.9        -12.7        1.08     36.8        82.2       13.1 +                   o ++                  o     o      o      o         o    --
Keppel Land Ltd.                                     KPLD SP       SG      B    15May12          3.47         65.3         18.0        1.69       4.4         5.3      13.3 + ++ ++                                   -     -       -    ++     --       o
Megaworld Corp.                                      MEG PM        PH      B     7Aug12          2.40         43.1          7.1        1.28       1.5         4.4        9.1 ++ o ++                                  o     +      o      o         o    o
Software & Services - MSCI wgt: 3.2%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
SouFun Holdings Ltd. ADS                             SFUN US       CN      B    30Aug11         17.71         28.0         10.5        1.64       1.4         3.8        8.0 ++ ++ ++ ++                                    -- --         +         o    o
Technology Hardware & Equipment - MSCI wgt: 4.5%, portfolio wgt: 0.0%
Semiconductors & Semiconductor Equipment - MSCI wgt: 10.1%, portfolio wgt: 5.0%
Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.                         005930 KS KR          B     7Aug12     1330000           25.8          2.8        1.14    178.8       337.8         8.6 + ++ o                                   o     +      +      o         o   ++
Novatek Microelectronics Corp.                       3034 TT       TW      B    28Jan11       104.50          43.7         18.9        1.23       2.2       18.6       12.6 o ++ o                                    o    ++ +           o         o   ++
Telecommunication Services - MSCI wgt: 6.7%, portfolio wgt: 10.0%
China Mobile Ltd.                                    941 HK        CN      H    14Sep10         83.70         14.7         15.9        0.46    217.0       196.8       10.8 ++ ++ +                               --        + ++ o                  o    o
China Communications Services Corp. Ltd.             552 HK        CN      B    30Sep11          4.39         32.6         28.9        0.63       3.9         2.7        9.2 ++ o ++ ++ ++ ++ o                                                 --      ++
Far EasTone Telecommunications Co. Ltd.              4904 TT       TW      B    30Sep11         72.40         32.5         65.7        0.12       8.1       13.9       17.4 -                  + ++ ++                      - - ++ o                o   ++
Telekom Malaysia Bhd                                 T MK          MY      H    15May12          6.23         35.6         23.6        0.76       7.3       16.6       26.3 o                   o ++ ++ ++ -                              --        o    o
Utilities - MSCI wgt: 3.9%, portfolio wgt: 2.5%
Guangdong Investment Ltd.                            270 HK        CN      B    30Sep11          6.20         35.5         32.4        0.38       5.0         4.5      12.6 o                   o           o         o     o      o                o
Db X-Trackers Csi300 Trn Index Et                    3049 HK       CN           15May12          5.62         -7.2        -11.1        1.00       0.3         3.7
Asia Model Portfolio (eq-wgt)**                                                                               23.1         19.0        1.03     26.6        36.7       13.1
MSCI Asia ex-Japan, LC                                                                                        13.3          4.8
Source: Deutsche Bank, FactSet, Bloomberg Finance LP. Note: Stocks are sorted by names in alphabetical order within each sector. Factor scores are given on a country and sector relative basis. Very Favorable (++),
Favorable (+), Neutral (0), Unfavorable (-), Very Unfavorable (--), Not Applicable (Blank). For a detailed explanation please see appendix A. Performance is measured in local currency. Stock changes are effective as of close
one day after they are officially published (i.e. Changes published on 4th May 2011 will be effective as of close 5th May 2011). *New additions. **Assume 50bps on both buying and selling as proxy for transaction cost.




Page 14                                                                                                                                                                        Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Country selection

Figure 10: Equity markets and their key drivers




                                                                                                                                     Current Account Balance/GDP
                                                                                       Sentiment (Risk-Love)




                                                                                                                                                                   Real Exchange Rate



                                                                                                                                                                                                 Total Score
                                                                                                               Technicals
                                                                         Valuation
                                                             Liquidity




                                                                                                                            Growth




                                                                                                                                                                                        Policy
                         China (Latest)                                                                                                                                                              8
                         China (Last)                                                                                                                                                                -2
                         Hong Kong (Latest)                                                                                                                                                          -2
                         Hong Kong (Last)                                                                                                                                                            -2
                         Indonesia (Latest)                                                                                                                                                          1
                         Indonesia (Last)                                                                                                                                                            0
                         India (Latest)                                                                                                                                                              4
                         India (Last)                                                                                                                                                                3
                         Korea (Latest)                                                                                                                                                              6
                         Korea (Last)                                                                                                                                                                -3
                         Malaysia (Latest)                                                                                                                                                           2
                         Malaysia (Last)                                                                                                                                                             3
                         Philippines (Latest)                                                                                                                                                        5
                         Philippines (Last)                                                                                                                                                          0
                         Singapore (Latest)                                                                                                                                                          -2
                         Singapore (Last)                                                                                                                                                            4
                         Thailand (Latest)                                                                                                                                                           4
                         Thailand (Last)                                                                                                                                                             6
                         Taiwan (Latest)                                                                                                                                                             1
                         Taiwan (Last)                                                                                                                                                               0
                         Asia ex-Japan (Latest                                                                                                                                                       4
                         Asia ex-Japan (Last)                                                                                                                                                        -2
                         Japan (Latest)                                                                                                                                                              2
                         Japan (Last)                                                                                                                                                                -4
Source: Deutsche Bank.
Blank cell represents factor not used in the model for that country.
     Most Favorable,       Favorable, O Neutral,     Less Favorable and              Least Favorable.


Liquidity is based on yoy change in M2/Market Cap ratio, valuation is based on composite valuation index (based on trailing P/E, 12m fwd P/E, P/cash earnings,
P/book, dividend yield, EV/EBIDTA and EV/Sales), sentiment is based on Risk-Love indicator, technicals are based on several price based indicators like percentage
of stocks above 200-d moving average, number of 52-Weeks new lows and new highs, indices above/below their 200-d moving average etc., growth is based on
leading economic indicators and earnings revision index, current account balance/GDP is based on deviation from 3-year moving average trend, real exchange rate
is based on deviation from 2-year moving average trend and policy is based on policy indicator.




Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong                                                                                                                                                                                     Page 15
17 October 2012
The Investigator




Country-sector selection

Figure 11: We prefer sectors with value, high earnings and price momentum, and better profitability

                                                                              0.90
                                                                   JP Banks
                                        HK Real Estate
                                              JP Telecom                      0.80
                                                                                 KO Autos
                                                   ID Hhold Products          0.70
                                                                                             TH Banks
                            ID Banks                                                                                                                                        Most preferred sectors
                                                                                                      CH Banks
                                                     TH Food Bev              0.60                   TH Telecom
                                                                                                JP Energy
                                                               IN Software
                                                                           0.50
         High earnings revisions &                          IN Hhold Products
                                                                                             JP HCare Equip/Svc
         price momentum, better                     MY Utilities      MY Telecom                                        CH Real Estate
                                                                           0.40              KO Insurance
         profitability                                                                                 KO Tech Hard/Equip

                                               IN Div Fin                                                                                                         SG Banks
                                                                                                      CH Utilities
                                                                              0.30                JP Autos                       TA Banks           PH Real Estate
                                                                                          TH Energy       SG Real Estate                     SG Retailing
                                                                                                    JP Transport              ID Utilities                 JP Div Fin
                                     ID Autos                   HK Telecom JP Food Bev                                                                                    KO Utilities                JP Fd/Staples Retail
                                                                         0.20                              ID Pharma/ Biotech         JP Comm Svc
                                               IN Energy                                                     HK Utilities
                                                                     PH Div Fin        PH Cap Gds
                                   MY Energy         JP Pharma/ Biotech                            HK Banks Software
                                                                                                            JP
                      HK Cons Svc                                                                                                                                     IN Banks
                                                        ID Food Bev 0.10                                          TH Media
                                                                    IN Pharma/ Biotech JP Materials                                                       MY Banks
                               MY Food Bev ID Telecom                                   HK Cap Gds
                                                            CH Telecom Materials
                                                                        ID
                                                                                      CH Software TA Real Estate
                                                 CH Transport SG Media Materials IN Autos                                                JP Real Estate
                                      TH Materials
                                                                       KO
                                                            TA Div Fin 0.00                     TA Telecom JP Cap Gds
                                                         CH Cap GdsJP Insurance           TA Cons Durables            SG Div Fin
                                               KO Retailing          KO Cap Gds Transport JP Tech Hard/Equip
                                                                              HK
                                                                                                                                                           KO Cons Svc
                                                                         KO Telecom      KO Energy JP Hhold Products                     KO Food Bev                                     JP Retailing          JP Media
                                  KO Hhold Products                                                              IN Materials
                                                         SG Food Bev -0.10                       MY Autos
                                                                                   CH Tech Hard/Equip
                                              CH HCare Equip/Svc                                     HK Semis
                                                                        KO Transport CH Energy
                                                        TA Materials -0.20                                                TA Semis                                                         PH Fd/Staples Retail
                                                                         HK Tech Hard/Equip JP Semis                                        SG Cap Gds
                                        TA Retailing                                           TA Cap Gds                  TA Insurance
                                                                                         HK Retailing     CH Autos
                                                  KO Fd/Staples Retail -0.30 IN Food Bev                              MY Materials
                                                                            HK Cons Durables
                                                                         SG Cons Svc SG Fd/Staples Retail
                                                                                                         CH Materials                        KO Cons Durables                       Cheaper
                                                                  JP Cons Svc                                    TA Tech Hard/Equip
                                                                        MY Cons Svc             ID Energy    MY Transport        MY Cap Gds        PH Telecom
                                                    CH Retailing        -0.40
                                                              CH Insurance                                            MY Div Fin SG Telecom
                                                TA Fd/Staples Retail                    CH Food Bev         IN Cap Gds      IN Utilities
                                                              IN Telecom IN Real Estate TA Transport
  Least preferred sectors                                                  IN Media HK Div Fin         KO Pharma/ Biotech KO Div Fin Cap Gds
                                                                                                                                          ID
                                                                        -0.50
                                                              TA Autos                                 KO Semis SG Transport

                                                CH Fd/Staples Retail                      KO Software
                                                                              -0.60                                        JP Utilities


                                                                              -0.70
 -0.40              -0.30              -0.20                -0.10                  0.00                 0.10           0.20               0.30             0.40               0.50               0.60                0.70
Source: Deutsche Bank, FactSet




Page 16                                                                                                                                                               Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017

More Related Content

What's hot

Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]
Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]
Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]mcarruthers
 
Advice for the wise september 2012
Advice for the wise september 2012Advice for the wise september 2012
Advice for the wise september 2012Karvy Private Wealth
 
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12Keynote Capitals Ltd.
 
The IBR India Newsletter
The IBR India NewsletterThe IBR India Newsletter
The IBR India NewsletterIBR_India
 
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-lesteFreeBalance
 
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conference
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services ConferenceMorgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conference
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conferenceinvestorrelation
 
September WMR Monthly Market Outlook
September WMR Monthly Market OutlookSeptember WMR Monthly Market Outlook
September WMR Monthly Market Outlookstenney
 
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?Susan Langdon
 
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008Jean-Marc Bloch-Lambert
 
Quest For Growth In Turbulent Times
Quest For Growth In Turbulent TimesQuest For Growth In Turbulent Times
Quest For Growth In Turbulent TimesSubrahmanyam KVJ
 
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call TranscriptSecond Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcriptfinance4
 
2011 Investor Sentiment Report
2011 Investor Sentiment Report2011 Investor Sentiment Report
2011 Investor Sentiment Reportjdpackwood
 
Choose More Reward Less Risk
Choose More Reward Less RiskChoose More Reward Less Risk
Choose More Reward Less Riskbrentshaw
 
Economy Update 1st September 2011
Economy Update 1st September 2011Economy Update 1st September 2011
Economy Update 1st September 2011ar330011
 
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton
 
CIT Presentation
CIT PresentationCIT Presentation
CIT Presentationfinance28
 
Fulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsFulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsDonald Marano
 

What's hot (19)

Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]
Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]
Insights Newsletter Autumn 2011.Final[1]
 
Advice for the wise september 2012
Advice for the wise september 2012Advice for the wise september 2012
Advice for the wise september 2012
 
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12
Keynote capitals india morning note september 4-'12
 
The IBR India Newsletter
The IBR India NewsletterThe IBR India Newsletter
The IBR India Newsletter
 
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste
2011 05-17 government financial transparency in timor-leste
 
Half Year Analyst Briefing as at 30 September 2011
Half Year Analyst Briefing as at 30 September 2011Half Year Analyst Briefing as at 30 September 2011
Half Year Analyst Briefing as at 30 September 2011
 
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conference
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services ConferenceMorgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conference
Morgan Stanley: Barclays Financial Services Conference
 
September WMR Monthly Market Outlook
September WMR Monthly Market OutlookSeptember WMR Monthly Market Outlook
September WMR Monthly Market Outlook
 
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?
Can Small Cap Stocks Weather the Storm?
 
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008
InvestmentCommitteeResearch_AlchemyCapital_March2008
 
Quest For Growth In Turbulent Times
Quest For Growth In Turbulent TimesQuest For Growth In Turbulent Times
Quest For Growth In Turbulent Times
 
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call TranscriptSecond Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
Second Quarter 2003 Earnings Conference Call Transcript
 
2011 Investor Sentiment Report
2011 Investor Sentiment Report2011 Investor Sentiment Report
2011 Investor Sentiment Report
 
credit-suisse Presentation slides
credit-suisse Presentation slidescredit-suisse Presentation slides
credit-suisse Presentation slides
 
Choose More Reward Less Risk
Choose More Reward Less RiskChoose More Reward Less Risk
Choose More Reward Less Risk
 
Economy Update 1st September 2011
Economy Update 1st September 2011Economy Update 1st September 2011
Economy Update 1st September 2011
 
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
 
CIT Presentation
CIT PresentationCIT Presentation
CIT Presentation
 
Fulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsFulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial Advisors
 

Viewers also liked

21 vleesbereidingen
21 vleesbereidingen21 vleesbereidingen
21 vleesbereidingenPaul Laaper
 
New microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationNew microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationamitjade
 
新会绿地图第一期电子版
新会绿地图第一期电子版新会绿地图第一期电子版
新会绿地图第一期电子版xinhuifreenmap
 
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivy
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivyслайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivy
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivyGalinka091
 
Questionnaire jd
Questionnaire jdQuestionnaire jd
Questionnaire jdJaynieeLou
 
2012 the outlook for energy - a view to 2040
2012 the outlook for energy  - a view to 20402012 the outlook for energy  - a view to 2040
2012 the outlook for energy - a view to 2040Sergii Kurbatov
 
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupware
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - GroupwareSamarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupware
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupwarelajarv
 
09 verdikkingsmiddelen
09 verdikkingsmiddelen09 verdikkingsmiddelen
09 verdikkingsmiddelenPaul Laaper
 
Ecologíaydesarrollo1
Ecologíaydesarrollo1Ecologíaydesarrollo1
Ecologíaydesarrollo1ecologiaBH52
 
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diện
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diệnBài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diện
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diệnVũ Hồng Toàn
 
proekt1
proekt1proekt1
proekt1banahr
 
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songs
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songsUnit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songs
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songschusmix
 

Viewers also liked (20)

21 vleesbereidingen
21 vleesbereidingen21 vleesbereidingen
21 vleesbereidingen
 
Rhymes
RhymesRhymes
Rhymes
 
Pdftrabajos
PdftrabajosPdftrabajos
Pdftrabajos
 
New microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentationNew microsoft office power point presentation
New microsoft office power point presentation
 
新会绿地图第一期电子版
新会绿地图第一期电子版新会绿地图第一期电子版
新会绿地图第一期电子版
 
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivy
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivyслайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivy
слайд шоу будьте счастливы Budte shastlivy
 
проект
проектпроект
проект
 
Questionnaire jd
Questionnaire jdQuestionnaire jd
Questionnaire jd
 
Question 2
Question 2Question 2
Question 2
 
2012 the outlook for energy - a view to 2040
2012 the outlook for energy  - a view to 20402012 the outlook for energy  - a view to 2040
2012 the outlook for energy - a view to 2040
 
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupware
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - GroupwareSamarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupware
Samarbeidsteknologi - Gruppevare - Groupware
 
Sacraments.part2
Sacraments.part2Sacraments.part2
Sacraments.part2
 
09 verdikkingsmiddelen
09 verdikkingsmiddelen09 verdikkingsmiddelen
09 verdikkingsmiddelen
 
Ecologíaydesarrollo1
Ecologíaydesarrollo1Ecologíaydesarrollo1
Ecologíaydesarrollo1
 
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diện
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diệnBài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diện
Bài toán xác định tâm hình cầu ngoại tiếp khối đa diện
 
Trabajos 3º trimestre
Trabajos 3º trimestreTrabajos 3º trimestre
Trabajos 3º trimestre
 
proekt1
proekt1proekt1
proekt1
 
P12 leclerc
P12 leclercP12 leclerc
P12 leclerc
 
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songs
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songsUnit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songs
Unit1 story with pictures and unit 1 songs
 
8 0201 gaikwad
8 0201 gaikwad8 0201 gaikwad
8 0201 gaikwad
 

Similar to Db investigator strategy 121017

SunTrust at UBS Global Financial Services
SunTrust at UBS Global Financial ServicesSunTrust at UBS Global Financial Services
SunTrust at UBS Global Financial Servicesfinance20
 
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013kmyoung1
 
Religare budget special report
Religare  budget special reportReligare  budget special report
Religare budget special reportJasleen Batra
 
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation) Feb 12
Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)   Feb 12Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)   Feb 12
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation) Feb 12bandonfunds
 
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...QuanJianChingCFACAIA
 
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000mhakerem
 
BlackRock - 2023 Global Outlook
BlackRock - 2023 Global OutlookBlackRock - 2023 Global Outlook
BlackRock - 2023 Global OutlookInvestoida
 
IRJET - Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in India
IRJET -  	  Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in IndiaIRJET -  	  Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in India
IRJET - Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in IndiaIRJET Journal
 
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09guest4823993
 
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09Frank Zhang
 
HPS The Path Forward - Policy Options
HPS The Path Forward - Policy OptionsHPS The Path Forward - Policy Options
HPS The Path Forward - Policy OptionsHPSInsight
 
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Karvy Private Wealth
 
Room To Run, But Value Vanishes
Room To Run, But Value VanishesRoom To Run, But Value Vanishes
Room To Run, But Value VanishesBoyboy cute
 
economies-10-00011.pdf
economies-10-00011.pdfeconomies-10-00011.pdf
economies-10-00011.pdfAndriSatiawan
 

Similar to Db investigator strategy 121017 (20)

SunTrust at UBS Global Financial Services
SunTrust at UBS Global Financial ServicesSunTrust at UBS Global Financial Services
SunTrust at UBS Global Financial Services
 
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013
FMP Market Themes and Outlook January 2013
 
Religare budget special report
Religare  budget special reportReligare  budget special report
Religare budget special report
 
201809 FOMC
201809 FOMC201809 FOMC
201809 FOMC
 
201909 FOMC
201909 FOMC201909 FOMC
201909 FOMC
 
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation) Feb 12
Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)   Feb 12Bandon Isolated Alpha   Fixed Income (Presentation)   Feb 12
Bandon Isolated Alpha Fixed Income (Presentation) Feb 12
 
716188 (7)
716188 (7)716188 (7)
716188 (7)
 
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...
201906 FOMC - An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, unless when th...
 
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000
Midyear Market Update Q22010 Aug 000
 
BlackRock - 2023 Global Outlook
BlackRock - 2023 Global OutlookBlackRock - 2023 Global Outlook
BlackRock - 2023 Global Outlook
 
U.S. Real Rates
U.S. Real RatesU.S. Real Rates
U.S. Real Rates
 
IRJET - Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in India
IRJET -  	  Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in IndiaIRJET -  	  Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in India
IRJET - Reducing of Economic Uncertainty during Recession in India
 
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
 
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
Va G Mx B Pricing 5 16 09
 
Mid year outlook_2012
Mid year outlook_2012Mid year outlook_2012
Mid year outlook_2012
 
2012 Mid Year Outlook
2012 Mid Year Outlook2012 Mid Year Outlook
2012 Mid Year Outlook
 
HPS The Path Forward - Policy Options
HPS The Path Forward - Policy OptionsHPS The Path Forward - Policy Options
HPS The Path Forward - Policy Options
 
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
 
Room To Run, But Value Vanishes
Room To Run, But Value VanishesRoom To Run, But Value Vanishes
Room To Run, But Value Vanishes
 
economies-10-00011.pdf
economies-10-00011.pdfeconomies-10-00011.pdf
economies-10-00011.pdf
 

More from Sergii Kurbatov

Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 Report
Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 ReportBloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 Report
Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 ReportSergii Kurbatov
 
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)Sergii Kurbatov
 
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014Sergii Kurbatov
 
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014Sergii Kurbatov
 
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237Sergii Kurbatov
 
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждый
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждыйсобеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждый
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждыйSergii Kurbatov
 
Forecast 2013 alfa capital
Forecast 2013 alfa capitalForecast 2013 alfa capital
Forecast 2013 alfa capitalSergii Kurbatov
 
Monthly agricultural review october 2012
Monthly agricultural review october 2012Monthly agricultural review october 2012
Monthly agricultural review october 2012Sergii Kurbatov
 
grain market report 29 11-2012
grain market report 29 11-2012grain market report 29 11-2012
grain market report 29 11-2012Sergii Kurbatov
 
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012Sergii Kurbatov
 
Special report china_trade
Special report china_tradeSpecial report china_trade
Special report china_tradeSergii Kurbatov
 
The Financial Development Report 2012
The Financial Development Report 2012The Financial Development Report 2012
The Financial Development Report 2012Sergii Kurbatov
 
2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet
2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet
2012 2030 energy_outlook_bookletSergii Kurbatov
 
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017Sergii Kurbatov
 
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015Sergii Kurbatov
 
Nomura global economic outlook 121016
Nomura global economic outlook 121016Nomura global economic outlook 121016
Nomura global economic outlook 121016Sergii Kurbatov
 

More from Sergii Kurbatov (20)

Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 Report
Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 ReportBloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 Report
Bloomberg Commodity Index: January 2018 Report
 
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)
ProAgro Conference: Методы анализа рынков аграрной продукции (укр)
 
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014
Credit suisse-global-wealth-report-2014
 
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014
Ukraine IMF review_sept_2014
 
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237
Food and-agribusiness-survey-2014-118237
 
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждый
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждыйсобеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждый
собеседник+ №1. 100 книг, которые должен прочитать каждый
 
Evraz
EvrazEvraz
Evraz
 
Forecast 2013 alfa capital
Forecast 2013 alfa capitalForecast 2013 alfa capital
Forecast 2013 alfa capital
 
Monthly agricultural review october 2012
Monthly agricultural review october 2012Monthly agricultural review october 2012
Monthly agricultural review october 2012
 
grain market report 29 11-2012
grain market report 29 11-2012grain market report 29 11-2012
grain market report 29 11-2012
 
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012
IMF Ukraine country report 27-11-2012
 
Special report china_trade
Special report china_tradeSpecial report china_trade
Special report china_trade
 
Global outlook q1 2013
Global outlook q1 2013Global outlook q1 2013
Global outlook q1 2013
 
The Financial Development Report 2012
The Financial Development Report 2012The Financial Development Report 2012
The Financial Development Report 2012
 
2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet
2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet
2012 2030 energy_outlook_booklet
 
Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017Db investigator strategy 121017
Db investigator strategy 121017
 
Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018
 
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015
Jpm top country and sector ideas 121015
 
Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018
 
Nomura global economic outlook 121016
Nomura global economic outlook 121016Nomura global economic outlook 121016
Nomura global economic outlook 121016
 

Db investigator strategy 121017

  • 1. Deutsche Bank Markets Research Asia Strategy Date 17 October 2012 The Investigator Strategy Update Ajay Kapur, CFA Policy Uncertainty – The Financial Strategist (+852) 2203 6196 World's Dominator ajay.kapur@db.com Ritesh Samadhiya, CFA Elevated Economic Policy Uncertainty – about to drop? We might be at an important inflection point in the financial markets. The elevation of Strategist Economic Policy Uncertainty, since 2008, to twice the level of the previous 23 years has (+852) 2203 6251 increased the equity risk premium, diminished the opportunity set for stock-picking, and ritesh.samadhiya@db.com favored defensive stocks over cyclicals. Finance professionals and investors may have wrongly concluded that this state of affairs will be prolonged and enduring. We think this Absolute Return Drivers status quo view is wrong, and that we could be at a turning point, and that economic Current Account Balance/GDP policy uncertainty has probably peaked. Let the profitable boredom begin! US Political Polarization at 130-year high Sentiment (Risk-Love) Political polarization might just recede with this coming US election. Financial Total Score (current) Real Exchange Rate deregulation – a key driver of complexity, the consequent compensation premium in the Total Score (last) financial sector, the rise in the ratio of bank fee income to total income, and income inequality, all likely peaked together in 2008. Any potential reduction in political Technicals Valuation polarization will likely involve compromise, less policy uncertainty, and a lower likelihood Liquidity Growth of policies being overturned with every election. Policy Economic Policy Uncertainty highly correlated with poor stock-picking efficacy Economic Policy Uncertainty is a function of media mentions of the issue, laws dropping China 8 -2 off the books, and economic forecast dispersion. The correlation coefficient between Hong Kong -2 -2 Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock-picking efficacy was only 0.09 between 1985 and Indonesia 1 0 2007. Since then it has jumped to 0.74. As a stock-picker, you want Economic Policy India 4 3 Uncertainty to fall. Adjusted for portfolio volatility, the stock-picking opportunity will Korea 6 -3 become much wider if uncertainty drops. Malaysia 2 3 Economic Policy Uncertainty is highly correlated with equity risk premium and Philippines 5 0 defensives over cyclicals Singapore -2 4 From 1985 to 2007, there was NO relationship between the two, a correlation coefficient Thailand 4 6 of -0.07. Since 2008, however, the correlation coefficient between policy uncertainty and Taiwan 1 0 equity risk premium has shot up to 0.67! Presumably, stocks are “cheap” compared with Asia ex-Japan 4 -2 bonds, since policy is uncertain, the impact on cash flows is uncertain and, as the most Japan 2 -4 junior entity in the capital structure, stocks need to be cheap to compensate for this policy uncertainty. Economic Policy Uncertainty probably peaking out globally: huge implications Our model portfolio is available as a DB In the US, a 130-year peak in political polarization and an important election on what to do about this polarization should help resolve things one way or another. Whatever the thematic basket (DBHKASTR). outcome of the election, another four years of peak political polarization is not what the electorate is voting for. In Europe, there is still a long way to go on reducing policy uncertainty on the part of governments, north and southern Europe, and within provinces in countries, but the ECB’s views are quite clear, agree or disagree with them. In China, the important political transition that occurs once in a decade will soon be over. Governance and policy – the work of government – can then get renewed attention. In India, after a period of lethargy, the government has recently been invigorated and policy has come unstuck. Of course, this is all speculation and could be wrong, but not having a view on the direction of Policy Uncertainty is NOT an option for financial professionals, given its salience. We are adding Top Glove Corp Bhd, Korea Zinc Co Ltd., Ace Hardware and Shree Cement Ltd to the model portfolio. The model portfolio is up 23.1% YTD vs. 13.3% for MSCI AXJ. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong All prices are those current at the end of the previous trading session unless otherwise indicated. Prices are sourced from local exchanges via Reuters, Bloomberg and other vendors. Data is sourced from Deutsche Bank and subject companies. Deutsche Bank does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. Thus, investors should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. DISCLOSURES AND ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS ARE LOCATED IN APPENDIX 1. MICA(P) 072/04/2012.
  • 2. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Table Of Contents Policy Uncertainty – The Financial World’s Dominator ..................................................... 3  Asia Model Portfolio update ............................................................................................... 8  Country selection .............................................................................................................. 15  Country-sector selection .................................................................................................. 16  Asia Model Portfolio ......................................................................................................... 20  Global – valuation ............................................................................................................. 21  Global metrics ................................................................................................................... 22  Global metrics (continued) ............................................................................................... 23  Global – market intelligence ............................................................................................. 24  Global – market intelligence (continued) .......................................................................... 25  Asia – valuation ................................................................................................................ 26  Asia – investor sentiment ................................................................................................. 27  Asia – technicals ............................................................................................................... 28  Asia – growth and earnings.............................................................................................. 29  Asia – liquidity .................................................................................................................. 30  Asia – factor performance ................................................................................................ 31  Asia – market intelligence ................................................................................................ 33  Japan – valuations ............................................................................................................ 34  Japan – investor sentiment .............................................................................................. 35  Japan – technicals ............................................................................................................ 36  Japan – growth and earnings ........................................................................................... 37  Japan – liquidity ................................................................................................................ 38  Japan – factor performance ............................................................................................. 39  Japan – market intelligence.............................................................................................. 40  Companies Mentioned ..................................................................................................... 41  Appendix A ................................................................................... 42  Page 2 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 3. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Policy Uncertainty – The Financial World’s Dominator The only thing that matters – policy uncertainty and polarization We contend that the main driver of the level of equity markets, the relative performance of risk assets versus “safe” assets, and the potential opportunity for stock-pricing – pretty much what defines a finance professional’s life – are increasingly determined by just one primary factor. The rest of it – all those company meetings, the travel, spreadsheets, conferences and broker research reports – are less salient compared to this one factor. This is a bold claim. So what is this salient, primary factor? And can we prove our contention? It is, in our view, Policy Uncertainty. A few academics have quantified this for the US and Europe, and we will try to prove our point regarding its link with changes in the equity risk premium, the relative performance of risky versus “safe assets” and the stock-picking opportunity set. We will also speculate that Policy Uncertainty in the world is about to downshift remarkably from current ungainly elevated levels. If we are right, this will have hugely positive implications for equities, risk assets and the opportunities for stock-picking. So far, since the financial crisis broke out, Policy Uncertainty has been at twice the level of the previous 23 years, keeping the equity risk premium high, challenging risky assets versus “safe assets”, and rendering stock-picking opportunities exceptionally tough. All that might be about to change. But first a quick point on political polarization in the USA, where we have the data. As Figure 1 shows, political polarization in the USA, proxied by how often Republicans vote similarly to one another, as do Democrats, is at a record high since 1880! It is like two sullen adults sitting at opposite ends of a see-saw, looking away from each other. With that degree of entrenched polarization, it is tough to get policies passed, and a malodorous air of policy inaction and uncertainty hangs heavy in the land. Note in Figure 1 how policy polarization correlates well with income inequality (or plutonomy). (Interested readers in the concept of political polarization should go to http://www.slate.com/articles/life/do_the_math/2001/12/growing_apart.single.html, The Mathematical Evidence for Congress’ Growing Polarization by Jordan Ellenberg1.) Our humble contention is that time-series that are at 130-year extremes are most likely to mean revert, however fanciful that might seem at the time of the extreme. In other words, political polarization might just recede with this coming US election. Financial deregulation – a key driver of complexity, the consequent compensation premium in the financial sector, the rise in the ratio of bank fee income to total income, and income inequality, all likely peaked together in 2008. Any potential reduction in political polarization will likely involve compromise, less policy uncertainty, and less of a likelihood of policies being overturned with every election. As Figure 2 shows, more policy certainty would diminish one key headache for business. Economic Policy Uncertainty Scott Baker, Nick Bloom and Steven Davis at Stanford have constructed Economic Policy Uncertainty indices for the US, Europe and Canada. For the US, in their words: To measure policy-related economic uncertainty, we construct an index from three types of underlying components. One component quantifies newspaper coverage of policy-related economic uncertainty. A second component reflects the number of federal tax code provisions set to expire in future years. The third component uses disagreement among economic forecasters as a proxy for uncertainty. The first component is an index of search results from 10 large newspapers. The newspapers included in our index are USA Today, the Miami Herald, the Chicago Tribune, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, 1 Also see the original authors’ work at http://voteview.com/Polarized_America.htm#MPRBOOK Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 3
  • 4. 17 October 2012 The Investigator the Boston Globe, the San Francisco Chronicle, the Dallas Morning News, the New York Times, and the Wall Street Journal. From these papers, we construct a normalized index of the volume of news articles discussing economic policy uncertainty of some type. The second component of our index draws on reports by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) that compile lists of temporary federal tax code provisions. We create annual discounted numbers of tax code provisions scheduled to expire for each year, giving a measure of the level of uncertainty regarding the path that the federal tax code will take in the future. The third component of our policy-related uncertainty index draws on the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia's Survey of Professional Forecasters. Here, we utilize the dispersion between individual forecasters' predictions about future levels of the Consumer Price Index, Federal Expenditures, and State and Local Expenditures to construct indices of uncertainty about policy-related macroeconomic variables. (From their website, www.policyuncertainty.com) Figure 1: US: record political polarization and income inequality – about to reverse? 1.2 20 Higher 1.1 18 Polarization 1.0 16 0.9 14 0.8 12 0.7 10 0.6 8 0.5 0.4 6 House Polarization, LS 0.3 Senate Polarization, LS 4 Income share of the top 1% (excluding capital gains), RS 0.2 2 1879 1899 1919 1939 1959 1979 1999 Source: Deutsche Bank. Polarization is measured as difference in party means - first dimension. http://voteview.com/Polarized_America.htm Figure 2: US: Economic Uncertainty a huge problem Source: NFIB Figure 3 shows the US, European and Canadian Economic Policy uncertainty indices. We will use the US version for our arguments here. Figure 4 shows the US Economic Page 4 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 5. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Policy Uncertainty Index alongside the average US stock performance correlations with the MSCI USA benchmark (a proxy for the potential efficacy of stock picking. If stocks all move in the same direction with the benchmark, it reduces the efficacy of stock- picking, once we adjust for portfolio volatility). A few things stand out. As the inventors of the index note, US Economic Policy Uncertainty since 2007 has been at twice the level of the prior 23 years. As Figure 4 also shows, the relationship between Economic Policy Uncertainty and the stock-picking opportunity set has increased markedly since 2008. The correlation coefficient between Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock- picking efficacy was only 0.09 between 1985 and 2007. Since then, it has jumped to 0.74. If you are a stock-picker, you want Economic Policy Uncertainty to subside, big time. Adjusted for portfolio volatility, the stock picking opportunity will become much wider, and life presumably a bit less stressful. Having a view on Economic Policy Uncertainty is critical. Figure 3: Economic Policy Uncertainty has been elevated since 2008, about to drop? 300 300 US Economic Policy Uncertainty Index 250 European Economic Policy Uncertainty Index High policy 250 uncertainty Canadian Economic Policy Uncertainty Index 200 200 150 150 100 100 50 50 0 0 1/85 1/88 1/91 1/94 1/97 1/00 1/03 1/06 1/09 1/12 Source: Deutsche Bank, Scott Baker, Nick Bloom and Steven Davis (www.policyuncertainty.com) Figure 4: Economic Policy Uncertainty and stock correlations with the benchmark move together. Stock-picking to become more potent as Policy Uncertainty drops 0.9 Average US stock performance (60 trading days) EU credit crisis 300 correlations with MSCI USA, LS Lehman Failure 0.8 87 crash US Economic Policy Uncertainty measure, RS 250 0.7 Worldcom Scandal High High policy economic uncertainty 0.6 LTCM 200 policy US recession uncertainty Asian 0.5 Crisis 150 0.4 0.3 100 Macro-driven market, 0.2 correlation 0.74 50 0.1 Stock-pickers market, correlation 0.09 0.0 0 1/86 1/88 1/90 1/92 1/94 1/96 1/98 1/00 1/02 1/04 1/06 1/08 1/10 1/12 Source: Deutsche Bank, Stock correlations with MSCI USA based on rolling 60-day daily returns on a broad universe of stocks covering the top 95% of total market capitalization (i.e.1,053 to 2,684 stocks from 1985 to 2012). For more on the “Economic Policy Uncertainty Index”, go to the website http://policyuncertainty.com. According to the authors, “To measure policy-related economic uncertainty, we construct an index from three types of underlying components. One component quantifies newspaper coverage of policy-related economic uncertainty. A second component reflects the number of federal tax code provisions set to expire in future years. The third component uses disagreement among economic forecasters as a proxy for uncertainty.” Figure 5 shows the relationship between the US Economic Policy Uncertainty index and the equity risk premium (the higher it is, the “cheaper” stocks are versus bonds). From 1985 to 2007, there was NO relationship between the two, a correlation coefficient of - 0.07. Since 2008, however, the correlation coefficient between policy uncertainty and Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 5
  • 6. 17 October 2012 The Investigator the equity risk premium has shot up to 0.67! Presumably, stocks are “cheap” compared with bonds, since policy is uncertain, the impact on cash flows is uncertain and, as the most junior entity in the capital structure, stocks need to be cheap to compensate for this policy uncertainty. Logically, if the correlation holds and there is a substantial decline in policy uncertainty, the equity risk premium could decline in tandem – stocks would beat bonds massively. Having a view on Economic Policy Uncertainty is critical. How about defensive sectors versus cyclicals? Does US Economic Policy Uncertainty have any role here? Yes. As Figure 6 shows, changes in US Economic Policy Uncertainty relate well with changes in the relative performance of defensives versus cyclicals. The correlation coefficient has doubled from 0.33 between 1985-2007 and 2008 now. As policy uncertainty rises, there is an unsurprising rush to defensives, and vice versa. Again, this relationship has been a lot more salient since 2008. Having a view on Economic Policy Uncertainty is critical. Figure 5: Equity Risk Premium and Economic Policy Uncertainty have moved in lock- step since 2008. Unlocking equity risk premium if Policy Uncertainty drops 250 8% High policy 230 US Economic Policy Uncertainty Index, uncertainty 3mma, LS 6% 210 Equity Risk Premium (S&P500 earnings 4% 190 yield less 10yr bond yield), RS 170 2% 150 0% 130 110 -2% Correlation 0.67 90 Correlation -0.07 -4% 70 50 -6% 1/85 1/87 1/89 1/91 1/93 1/95 1/97 1/99 1/01 1/03 1/05 1/07 1/09 1/11 1/13 Source: Deutsche Bank Figure 6: Defensives versus Cyclicals ( or risk-off versus risk-on) moves with changes in Economic Policy Uncertainty 80% Economic Policy Uncertainty, 6m change, LS 80% 60% US defensive sectors / cyclical sectors, 6 month change, RS 60% 40% 40% 20% 20% 0% 0% 1/85 1/87 1/89 1/91 1/93 1/95 1/97 1/99 1/01 1/03 1/05 1/07 1/09 1/11 1/13 -20% -20% -40% Correlation 0.33 Correlation 0.68 -40% -60% Defensive sectors are Consumer staples, -60% healthcare, utilities and telecom. -80% -80% Source: Deutsche Bank. Defensive sector price index is from Datastream while MSCI CYC Index is used for cyclicals. So what is our view on Policy Uncertainty globally? We can only speculate on this, but it is important to do so. In the US, a 130-year peak in political polarization and an important election on what to do about this polarization should help resolve things one way or another. Whatever the outcome of the election, we think it’s safe to say that another four years of peak political polarization is not what the electorate is hoping for. The party that loses is unlikely to find recalcitrance and obstructionism a future vote- gathering strategy, in our view. Of course, we could be wrong and the logjam, the Page 6 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 7. 17 October 2012 The Investigator polarization, the policy uncertainty could go on for longer. In Europe, the ECB approved its aggressive bond-buying plan with just one dissenter. While there is still a long way to go on reducing policy uncertainty on the part of governments, north and southern Europe, and within provinces in countries, the ECB’s views are quite clear, agree or disagree with them. In China, the important political transition that occurs once in a decade will soon be over. A renewed focus on governance and policy – the work of government – can then begin. In India, after a period of lethargy, the government has recently been invigorated and policy has come unstuck. With the passage of time since the outbreak of the financial crisis, there is early empirical evidence in the "austerity versus fiscal spending" debate. 2 As more time elapses and more empirical results reveal themselves, we believe policy uncertainty will likely diminish. Policymakers and voters will be better informed about the consequences of opposing policy choices. Thus, the menu of successful policy options will likely shrink – there should be less uncertainty about the "right" policy course. Our simple read is that the substantial elevation of policy uncertainty around the world is probably coming to an end. The confusion of policymakers in facing the rather unique challenges of a once-in-seventy-years potential debt deflation was understandable. It is by no means all blue skies from here, but policymakers and politicians are both learning what is “working”, and what is not. Electorates are making choices about the direction they want to go in, rather than the logjam of the past five years. Debtors and creditors always fight about loss allocation in a debt crisis – time is the only healer that can bring them together, however reluctantly. That time seems to be approaching. Again, this is simple expectation on our part, and we could be plain wrong. But we stress that not having a view on the direction of Policy Uncertainty is NOT an option for financial professionals. In sum, we might be at an important inflection point in financial markets. The elevation of Economic Policy Uncertainty since 2008 has elevated the equity risk premium, diminished the opportunity set for stock-picking, and favored defensive stocks over cyclicals. The mindset of finance professionals and investors might have wrongly concluded that this state of affairs is going to be prolonged and enduring – that bonds are better than stocks, that stock-picking is ruinously counter-productive in this “macro- driven” market, and that defensives are superior investments to cyclicals. This view implies a continued elevated level of global Economic Policy Uncertainty. We think this status quo view is wrong, and that we could be at a turning point, and that economic policy uncertainty has probably peaked. Let the profitable boredom begin! 2 See the latest IMF World Economic Outlook, Coping with High Debt and Sluggish Growth and Fiscal Policy in a Depressed Economy by Lawrence H. Summers and J. Bradford DeLong. (www.brookings.edu/~/.../2012_spring_BPEA_delongsummers.pdf) Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 7
  • 8. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Asia Model Portfolio update We are removing Hyundai Motor Co, Hyundai Mobis, Simplo Technology Co Ltd and Starhub Ltd. Hyundai Motor and Hyundai Mobis have dropped to the fourth and third quintile respectively in our multifactor stock ranking model. Hyundai Motor looks weaker (relative to the region) on profitability, growth and earnings momentum. Hyundai Mobis is now looking expensive and has lower earnings momentum. Simplo Technology faded on price momentum, earnings momentum and consensus rating metrics. We are cutting Singapore on poor earnings revisions and dropping Starhub from the model portfolio. We are adding Top Glove Corp Bhd, Korea Zinc Co Ltd, Ace Hardware and Shree Cement Ltd. Top Glove ranks highly on valuation, earnings and price momentum. Korea Zinc looks better on profitability, earnings, price momentum and earnings quality. Ace hardware, though looking expensive, scores well on profitability, growth, earnings and price momentum. Shree Cement looks good on profitability, earnings, price momentum and consensus analyst rating. For factor description, see appendix A. Top Glove Corp Bhd (TOPG MK) Outlook remains positive; reiterating Buy. Disciplined capacity expansion plans, expectations of leveling raw material prices as a result of higher rubber production in ASEAN and slower consumption growth globally, as well as resilient demand for rubber gloves for medical and hygiene purposes should drive multi-year growth for the sector and allow Top Glove to generate two-year (FY13-15E) net profit CAGR of 14%, in our view. We reiterate our Buy recommendation with a price target of RM6.05/share, implying a total return of 21%. (Michelle Foong, 12 October 2012) Korea Zinc Co Ltd (010130 KS) Gold/silver price forecast upgrades affect Zijin/Zhaojin/Korea Zinc. Deutsche Bank’s global commodity team has upgraded its gold/silver price forecasts by 2.4% for 2013 and 11.1% for 2014 in light of further central bank action to expand monetary conditions. The most relevant stocks in Asia ex-Japan are Zijin, Zhaojin and Korea Zinc (50% revenue exposure). We raise Zijin/Zhaojin/Korea Zinc’s 2013E earnings by 2.4%/5.1%/1.5%, respectively. Our DCF valuation method differentiates Zijin (Buy) from Zhaojin (downgrade from Buy to Hold), with target price upgrades at 5.6% and 8.3%, respectively. We believe the bullishness on the gold price has been factored into Zhaojin’s share price, after a 36% rally in the past month. We roll over Korea Zinc’s target price to 2013-based and raise it by 24%. Overall, Zijin and Korea Zinc stand out after the upgrades, with their target prices now implying 20% and 27% upside potential. (Chanwook Park, 4 October, 2012) Ace Hardware (ACES IJ) Consistently delivering strong growth and aggressive expansion. We believe that Ace Hardware Indonesia will continue to deliver strong growth as it is one of the best proxies for the expanding middle class, enjoying a forecast earnings CAGR of 22% over the next three years. Management has a strong operational and financial track record, delivering a sales CAGR of 32% on expansion of 21% over the past three years. We believe the company is on track to have 100 stores in the next three years, which is a 43% increase. Maintaining Buy with new DCF-based target price of Rp8,000 (from Rp5,000). (Reggy Susanto, 28 September, 2012) Shree Cement (SRCM IN) A high FCF yield of over 9% in FY13e, EBITDA CAGR of 27% over FY12-FY14e, driven by improving realizations and attractive valuations of 6.6x FY13e EV/EBITA, and a ~30% discount to large cap peers makes us confident of continued outperformance from the stock despite a 37% rise in the stock price over the past three months. (Harshad Katkar, 16 October, 2012) Page 8 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 9. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Summary Global High policy uncertainty, and the attendant flight from junior tranches of the capital structure, along with a dismal prior decade of equity returns keeps them “cheap”. Reduced policy uncertainty and losses from bond portfolios are likely to be required as catalysts to unlock value in equities. Despite all the despair about global growth, our own mother of all leading indicators (MOMLI) is looking up, as are asset-price-based opinions on global growth. Meanwhile, analysts have lost confidence and are looking for just 5% EPS growth globally in 2012, and 12% for 2013. Global Risk-Love (sentiment) has now entered euphoria, a slight concern. The global Tape is very strong, and the Marshallian K is rising. Asia Asian valuations are moderately below historical averages. The problem is margins – in China they seem to be in a secular decline, while in India they seem to be at a cyclical low. The region cannot rely on asset turns and leverage – both at global levels – to boost relative ROEs compared with the world. It is probably going to have to be EBIT margin expansion that gets the PB up. We don’t see any substantial decline in the cost of equity to boost PB multiples. Risk-love in Asia is at neutral. Technicals are improving – new highs are rising, and new lows have almost vanished. Asia’s leading economic indicators are bottoming, and policy is no longer being tightened. Analysts have taken the knife to this year’s EPS growth forecasts from around 13% at the start of the year to 5% now. We think that EPS revisions and economic surprises are about bottoming now. New issuance and secondaries have been paltry – a good positive contrarian indicator. Foreign fund flows have resumed in earnest as markets have rallied. Value strategies and high profitability have done well this year, while high projected growth stocks have been punished. Japan Japanese stocks continue to look undervalued versus history. A return to credible inflation and higher nominal GDP growth globally is required to unlock value. Recent tensions with China are unhelpful for risk assets in Japan. Sentiment is at neutral levels. Technicals are mixed. Economic surprises are nasty and mean-reverting. They are probably going to get less bad. EPS revisions continue to slide. Fund flows are weak and the market continues to underperform the world as US 10-year bond yields remain suppressed. Value remains the long-term winner. China (neutral) China’s valuations look “cheap” compared with history and are at fair value on our PB ROE less COE model. However, on prospective ROEs of around 7% in three years’ time and COE of around 10%, the current PB of 1.4 is substantially overvalued. Monetary reflation could lift the current multiple, but the long-term deterioration in EBIT margins is the key challenge to a re-rating. Sentiment is at neutral. Worryingly, turnover/market cap is plumbing new depths. Once the political transition is done, and policy making, reflation and market-supportive steps are likely taken, sentiment and pathetic turnover might perk up. Technicals are weak. Policy is tightening via the currency, and weak monetary growth. Real interest rates for corporates are rising with the corporate price deflator contracting yoy. EPS revisions keep dropping as do EPS growth forecasts for 2012 and 2013. We are watching carefully for EPS revisions to hook up. The good news is that the credit multiplier is rising yoy, and the market is responsive to this indicator. The bad news is that the gap between M1 and M2 growth is still weak and correlates with the PB multiple. We need to see a more credible reflation to see the market make Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 9
  • 10. 17 October 2012 The Investigator strong upward moves. Earnings revisions and momentum, together with analyst opinions are being rewarded this year, while value investing has been patchy. Hong Kong (neutral) Hong Kong equities are at fair value compared with history, and about in the middle of the pack compared with the other Asian markets. Sentiment has rebounded from the panic levels earlier this year. Turnover to market capitalization is still anemic, but we are encouraged by the rise in the gap between M1 and M2 growth. Technicals have improved since the summer. Policy seems to be tightening (even as real interest rates are quite negative), and EPS revisions are still quite weak. The EPS growth forecast for 2012 has collapsed – the sign changed from an expected +12% earlier this year to -12% growth expected now! For next year, EPS growth is expected at 10%. Inflation is making the real effective exchange rate less competitive, and the yield curve is flat. A good dose of monetary reflation in China is required to turn liquidity up. Negative real interest rates are here to stay in HK for longer than anyone recognizes. Value and low risk styles have been exceptional performers this year. India (overweight) Despite the recent run-up, the market is still undervalued on EV/Sales, EV/EBITDA and PB compared with history. On other metrics, like trailing PE and dividend yield, it is at long-term averages. On our PB versus ROE less COE model it is at fair value, and needs for ROEs to rise and/or COEs to fall – likely if the RBI cuts rates as the Rupee strengthens. Risk-love has perked up from panic in May to neutral now. Meeting with scores of clients around the world, however, we think there is still considerable skepticism about the market. With the recent rally, technicals have improved. The downgrade to GDP growth by the IMF is unfathomable to us simpletons. The leading indicator from the OECD has been rising for months, and the EPS revisions trajectory has also been improving for months. Our policy indicator has curled up with the weakness in the Rupee. Looking ahead, we expect the monetary base to start growing from its paltry 4% yoy rate, as net foreign asset growth resumes on the back of reforms and confidence. EPS growth projections for next year, at 12-14%, are reasonable. The monetary base growth at 4.4% is anemic. The lack of net foreign asset growth is being compensated by a substantial increase in net RBI lending to government. This is a vicious cycle that needs to be broken, and probably will be, if reform momentum is maintained. The yield curve is no longer negative, but is still flat as a chapatti. Value and EPS momentum have been rewarded well this year. Stick with them. Indonesia (neutral) Valuations are at fair levels compared with history. We are a bit concerned about the decline in Indonesia’s EBIT margins. Maintaining premium valuations to the region requires maintaining premium ROEs to the region. Having almost doubled capex/GDP in the past few years, and as it is exposed to any slowdown in nominal GDP growth in China, keep an eye on declining margins in Indonesia. Indonesia has gone from the poster child of solid macro policy last year to one that is perceived as having less than optimal policies – interest rates cut “too soon”, etc. We didn’t understand either position. Indeed, it seems that other EM central banks are now following BI in cutting interest rates to combat slower growth. Maybe BI is a lot smarter than the gallery of critics assumes. We think policy easing makes sense (unlike consensus) – real economy data is coming in really weak, EPS revisions are negative (but recovering), and EPS growth expectations have collapsed from 17% a few months ago to just 8% now for calendar 2012. Inflation, a lagging indicator, is stable at the 4%-ish level. The currency is more competitive in real effective terms, free liquidity is booming and the yield curve is flat-ish. Value and EPS mo are king here. The rest are not really adding alpha this year. Page 10 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 11. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Korea (underweight) The market is at fair value compared with its history, but cheap compared with other markets on a snapshot basis. This is a low ROE, low EBIT margin market, and is likely to remain a low PB market unless ROEs rise sharply. Interestingly, unlike China, Taiwan and Singapore, where margins have been in secular decline, and ROEs have been goosed by rising asset turns and leverage (this has also been happening in Malaysia and Indonesia recently), in Korea this is not happening. EBIT margins and ROEs move together – albeit at low levels. We think this deserves a higher multiple than currently obtained. We think investors in the other markets might be suffering from “ROE illusion”, implying very strong nominal GDP growth and more leverage – both unlikely. Sentiment is just shy of neutral. Technicals are a lot stronger than overall market performance suggests. Close to a record percentage of stocks are making 52-week highs. The leading economic indicator has been rising persistently for many months now, but EPS revisions are still in the doldrums. Implication: margins are under continued pressure. The terms of trade are improving and we expect this to feed through to improving margins and EPS revisions soon. The yield curve is flat, and flattening. Value has made a massive comeback in the past six months. Price and EPS mo have been disasters this year. Stock-picking in Korea based on style is very tricky because the factors go in and out of style with a head-spinning intensity. Malaysia (neutral) Malaysian equities are undervalued versus history but quite expensive versus the other markets on a relative basis. As in Indonesia, we are concerned about the sharp drop in EBIT margins, even as ROEs remain stable. Risk-Love is quite high, just shy of euphoria. Technicals are neutral. The EPS revisions index has collapsed and EPS growth numbers are being taken down for 2012. Price and EPS mo, along with ROE have been rewarded this year. But value has been tepid. Philippines (neutral) The market is expensive compared with its history and versus other markets in the region. We like that the EBITs and ROEs move together, so there is no leverage or asset turnover-driven “ROE illusion”. Also, years of under-investment imply many years of strong EBIT margins (unlike say in China, or maybe even Indonesia). Sentiment has come off from the euphoria of the summer to neutral now. The leading economic indicator is rising, and we expect EPS revisions to do the same. This is a requirement in order to maintain its premium valuations. Value, a perennial king in Philippine alpha generation, continues to do well, as do EPS revision strategies. Singapore (neutral) The market is cheap compared with history, but fairly valued compared with other regional markets. EBIT margins are in secular decline, and maintaining ROEs will rely on continued improvements in asset turnover and leverage. Sentiment is in mild euphoria. Technicals are super-strong, with close to a record percentage of stocks making 52- week highs. EPS growth projections for both 2012 and 2013 remain lackluster. Earnings revisions also look weak. The good news is that the terms of trade are now picking up nicely, so margins are likely to get a boost. Only stability and low risk factors are generating alpha. Value strategies are mixed, but momentum strategies have destroyed alpha this year. Taiwan (underweight) The market is a serial underperformer versus the region. EBIT margins are in secular decline, and the high asset turnover is running into gravity now. Risk-love is in the tank. EPS revisions are worsening, but there is hope. The terms of trade have gone vertical and project rising EPS momentum. Given poor sentiment, and an impending improvement in EPS growth projections, we need to keep an eye on the underweighted Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 11
  • 12. 17 October 2012 The Investigator market. This tech-heavy market is respecting price momentum and stocks supported by analysts. Thailand (overweight) The market is fairly valued versus history and the region. The exception is PB – where the market is at record premiums to the region. Could that be a reward for the solid ROEs (driven not by EBIT margins but asset turns)? Sentiment is neutral. Technicals are super-strong. About a quarter are making 52-week highs. Growth-leading indicators are still strong, even as incoming data have been weak. Analysts have dropped projected 2012 EPS growth forecasts from 23% earlier his year to about 15% now. Also, we are comforted with the rise in the terms of trade that should be supportive of margins and EPS growth going forward. Value has been a disaster this year, while price and EPS momentum strategies have been huge winners. Page 12 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 13. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Figure 7: Model portfolio performance since inception (13 September 2010) 22 Model portfolio absolute returns (After T/C): 19.0% 1-week relative returns 0.1% 22 20 MSCI Asia ex Japan absolute returns: 4.8% 1-month relative returns 2.5% 20 18 Model portfolio relative returns (After T/C): 14.2% YTD relative returns 9.8% 18 16 12-month relative returns 12.1% 16 14 After Transaction Cost 14 12 12 10 10 8 8 6 6 4 4 2 2 0 0 -2 -2 9/10 11/10 1/11 3/11 5/11 7/11 9/11 11/11 1/12 3/12 5/12 7/12 9/12 Source: Deutsche Bank, MSCI, FactSet Note: Performance is measured in local currency. Stock changes are effective as of close one day after they are officially published (i.e. Changes published on 4th May 2011 will be effective as of close 5th May 2011). *New additions. Assume 50bps on both buying and selling as proxy for transaction cost. Note: Past performance does not guarantee future results Figure 8: Model portfolio country and sector overweights/underweights -12% -9% -6% -3% 0% 3% 6% 9% 12% Sector (MSCI Wgt) -12% -9% -6% -3% 0% 3% 6% 9% 12% Country (MSCI Wgt) Retailing (1.5%) THAILAND (3.0%) Materials (7.0%) Energy (7.2%) INDIA (9.5%) Telecom (6.7%) Cons Svc (1.7%) Div Financials (2.4%) INDONESIA (3.7%) Cap Gds (7.6%) Health Care Equip (0.3%) PHILIPPINES (1.2%) Media (0.3%) Real Estate (7.0%) CHINA (23.9%) Comm Svc (0.0%) Pharma/Biotech (0.7%) Underweight Neutral Overweight Overweight Software (3.2%) Underweight SINGAPORE (7.3%) Cons Dur/App (0.8%) Food/Staples Retail (0.8%) MALAYSIA (4.9%) Food Beverages (3.6%) Hhold Products (1.2%) Utilities (3.9%) HONG KONG (11.9%) Insurance (4.3%) Transport (1.9%) TAIWAN (14.4%) Current O/U wgt Tech Hardware (4.5%) Current O/U wgt (17 October 2012) (17 October 2012) Autos (5.0%) Previous O/U wgt Previous O/U wgt Semis (10.1%) SOUTH KOREA (20.1%) (07 August 2012) (07 August 2012) Banks (18.1%) -12% -9% -6% -3% 0% 3% 6% 9% 12% -12% -9% -6% -3% 0% 3% 6% 9% 12% Source: Deutsche Bank, MSCI. Note: Numbers in parenthesis are sector and country weights in MSCI AC Asia ex Japan index. The model portfolio is equal weighted; each stock has weighting of 2.5%. Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 13
  • 14. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Figure 9: Asia Model Portfolio Profitability FY 13 Cons Rec Valuation Price Mo Earnings Earnings Stability Growth Quality DB Date Close YTD Rtn Hldg Per Mcap 20D ADT PE (DB Risk Mo BB Ticker Mkt Rec Added 16Oct12 (%) Rtn (%) Beta (U$bn) (U$ m) est) Energy - MSCI wgt: 7.2%, portfolio wgt: 12.5% CNOOC Ltd. 883 HK CN H 11Dec10 15.94 20.5 -6.7 1.40 91.8 111.5 8.9 o + ++ o o ++ o o o Oil & Natural Gas Corp. Ltd. ONGC IN IN B 14Sep10 278.95 12.4 -14.7 0.65 45.2 20.3 8.7 ++ ++ + o o ++ o o o Oil India Ltd. OINL IN IN B 30Sep11 485.85 5.9 -6.2 0.29 5.5 1.7 9.1 ++ + + o + ++ o o o PTT PCL PTT TB TH NR 14Sep10 311.00 1.6 1.27 29.0 38.7 SK Innovation Co. Ltd. 096770 KS KR B 7Aug12 154000 8.5 -6.9 1.47 13.5 55.8 6.6 ++ ++ + o - - ++ - - o o Materials - MSCI wgt: 7.0%, portfolio wgt: 12.5% Grasim Industries Ltd. GRASIM IN IN B 27Jun12 3464.85 39.0 36.1 0.75 6.0 6.0 11.0 + + ++ ++ ++ o o + o Shree Cement Ltd. SRCM IN IN B 17Oct12 4048.80 87.7 NA 0.70 2.7 6.3 17.7 - ++ ++ ++ o - -- o ++ Indocement Tunggal Prakarsa INTP IJ ID B 14Sep10 21450 27.5 19.6 1.34 8.2 5.5 15.9 - ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ o o o Korea Zinc Co. Ltd. 010130 KS KR B 17Oct12 461000 51.6 NA 1.13 7.9 31.9 8.2 o ++ ++ ++ - + o + o LG Chem Ltd. 051910 KS KR B 14Sep10 316500 -0.3 -5.3 1.53 19.3 73.6 11.9 o ++ + o o ++ o o -- Capital Goods - MSCI wgt: 7.6%, portfolio wgt: 10.0% China Communications Construction Co. Ltd. 1800 HK CN B 5May11 6.94 18.0 5.5 1.41 12.1 19.3 7.0 + + o ++ o o o o ++ Sino-Thai Engineering & Construction PCL STEC TB TH B 7Aug12 20.70 72.8 36.2 0.82 0.8 3.9 19.3 o + ++ ++ o ++ o o ++ SembCorp Industries Ltd. SCI SP SG B 14Sep10 5.47 39.3 30.0 1.36 8.0 9.3 11.4 o ++ o ++ o + o o + SembCorp Marine Ltd. SMM SP SG B 11Dec10 4.92 35.3 8.0 1.66 8.4 14.5 13.2 o ++ o + o ++ - - o + Commercial Services & Supplies - MSCI wgt: 0.0%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Transportation - MSCI wgt: 1.9%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Automobiles & Components - MSCI wgt: 5.0%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Consumer Durables & Apparel - MSCI wgt: 0.8%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Consumer Services - MSCI wgt: 1.7%, portfolio wgt: 5.0% SJM Holdings Ltd. 880 HK HK B 9Mar12 16.30 34.5 10.1 1.34 11.7 9.7 12.7 + ++ ++ ++ o ++ ++ o Minor International PCL MINT TB TH B 27Jun12 17.80 76.2 26.2 1.06 2.1 6.5 20.4 o ++ ++ ++ o - - ++ o Media - MSCI wgt: 0.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% BEC World PCL BEC TB TH H 11Nov11 57.25 31.7 59.1 0.73 3.7 3.4 20.8 - ++ ++ o o ++ o o -- Retailing - MSCI wgt: 1.5%, portfolio wgt: 7.5% Belle International Holdings Ltd. 1880 HK CN B 5May11 13.62 2.0 -6.9 0.93 14.8 25.5 15.7 - ++ ++ ++ o ++ ++ o Giordano International Ltd. 709 HK HK H 14Sep10 6.40 20.4 61.0 0.88 1.3 2.5 12.3 + ++ + + o ++ ++ ++ Ace Hardware Indonesia ACES IJ ID B 17Oct12 6650.00 62.8 NA 0.41 1.2 0.6 23.7 - - + ++ ++ o + ++ o Food & Staples Retailing - MSCI wgt: 0.8%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Food Beverage & Tobacco - MSCI wgt: 3.6%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% Uni-President Enterprises Corp. 1216 TT TW B 7Aug12 52.00 28.0 4.7 0.63 8.7 14.3 19.9 - + ++ ++ - + o o Household & Personal Products - MSCI wgt: 1.2%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Health Care Equipment & Services - MSCI wgt: 0.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% Top Glove Corp. Bhd TOPG MK MY B 17Oct12 5.31 8.8 NA 0.99 1.1 2.2 14.1 ++ o + ++ o ++ - - o o Pharmaceuticals & Biotechnology - MSCI wgt: 0.7%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Banks - MSCI wgt: 18.1%, portfolio wgt: 7.5% ICICI Bank Ltd. ICICIBC IN IN B 7Aug12 1042.05 54.6 7.0 1.44 22.7 78.4 12.7 - - o o o o -- o o ++ BOC Hong Kong (Holdings) Ltd. 2388 HK HK B 5May11 24.10 37.0 9.3 1.02 32.9 32.2 11.7 ++ o o + o o o o + Industrial & Commercial Bank of China Ltd. 1398 HK CN B 5May11 4.88 11.2 -16.7 1.41 214.7 165.4 6.2 ++ ++ o -- o o o o ++ Diversified Financials - MSCI wgt: 2.4%, portfolio wgt: 5.0% IDFC Ltd. IDFC IN IN B 15May12 149.90 65.9 30.7 1.58 4.3 24.5 10.2 - ++ o o ++ o o Haitong Securities Co. Ltd-H share 6837 HK CN B 27Jun12 10.70 NA -0.2 NA 14.5 7.0 15.0 + + + + o o ++ Insurance - MSCI wgt: 4.3%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% Dongbu Insurance Co. Ltd. 005830 KS KR NR 9Mar12 49550 -5.0 5.7 0.53 3.2 5.5 NA + ++ o o - o Real Estate - MSCI wgt: 7.0%, portfolio wgt: 7.5% Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd. 16 HK HK B 11Dec10 109.00 12.9 -12.7 1.08 36.8 82.2 13.1 + o ++ o o o o o -- Keppel Land Ltd. KPLD SP SG B 15May12 3.47 65.3 18.0 1.69 4.4 5.3 13.3 + ++ ++ - - - ++ -- o Megaworld Corp. MEG PM PH B 7Aug12 2.40 43.1 7.1 1.28 1.5 4.4 9.1 ++ o ++ o + o o o o Software & Services - MSCI wgt: 3.2%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% SouFun Holdings Ltd. ADS SFUN US CN B 30Aug11 17.71 28.0 10.5 1.64 1.4 3.8 8.0 ++ ++ ++ ++ -- -- + o o Technology Hardware & Equipment - MSCI wgt: 4.5%, portfolio wgt: 0.0% Semiconductors & Semiconductor Equipment - MSCI wgt: 10.1%, portfolio wgt: 5.0% Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. 005930 KS KR B 7Aug12 1330000 25.8 2.8 1.14 178.8 337.8 8.6 + ++ o o + + o o ++ Novatek Microelectronics Corp. 3034 TT TW B 28Jan11 104.50 43.7 18.9 1.23 2.2 18.6 12.6 o ++ o o ++ + o o ++ Telecommunication Services - MSCI wgt: 6.7%, portfolio wgt: 10.0% China Mobile Ltd. 941 HK CN H 14Sep10 83.70 14.7 15.9 0.46 217.0 196.8 10.8 ++ ++ + -- + ++ o o o China Communications Services Corp. Ltd. 552 HK CN B 30Sep11 4.39 32.6 28.9 0.63 3.9 2.7 9.2 ++ o ++ ++ ++ ++ o -- ++ Far EasTone Telecommunications Co. Ltd. 4904 TT TW B 30Sep11 72.40 32.5 65.7 0.12 8.1 13.9 17.4 - + ++ ++ - - ++ o o ++ Telekom Malaysia Bhd T MK MY H 15May12 6.23 35.6 23.6 0.76 7.3 16.6 26.3 o o ++ ++ ++ - -- o o Utilities - MSCI wgt: 3.9%, portfolio wgt: 2.5% Guangdong Investment Ltd. 270 HK CN B 30Sep11 6.20 35.5 32.4 0.38 5.0 4.5 12.6 o o o o o o o Db X-Trackers Csi300 Trn Index Et 3049 HK CN 15May12 5.62 -7.2 -11.1 1.00 0.3 3.7 Asia Model Portfolio (eq-wgt)** 23.1 19.0 1.03 26.6 36.7 13.1 MSCI Asia ex-Japan, LC 13.3 4.8 Source: Deutsche Bank, FactSet, Bloomberg Finance LP. Note: Stocks are sorted by names in alphabetical order within each sector. Factor scores are given on a country and sector relative basis. Very Favorable (++), Favorable (+), Neutral (0), Unfavorable (-), Very Unfavorable (--), Not Applicable (Blank). For a detailed explanation please see appendix A. Performance is measured in local currency. Stock changes are effective as of close one day after they are officially published (i.e. Changes published on 4th May 2011 will be effective as of close 5th May 2011). *New additions. **Assume 50bps on both buying and selling as proxy for transaction cost. Page 14 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong
  • 15. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Country selection Figure 10: Equity markets and their key drivers Current Account Balance/GDP Sentiment (Risk-Love) Real Exchange Rate Total Score Technicals Valuation Liquidity Growth Policy China (Latest) 8 China (Last) -2 Hong Kong (Latest) -2 Hong Kong (Last) -2 Indonesia (Latest) 1 Indonesia (Last) 0 India (Latest) 4 India (Last) 3 Korea (Latest) 6 Korea (Last) -3 Malaysia (Latest) 2 Malaysia (Last) 3 Philippines (Latest) 5 Philippines (Last) 0 Singapore (Latest) -2 Singapore (Last) 4 Thailand (Latest) 4 Thailand (Last) 6 Taiwan (Latest) 1 Taiwan (Last) 0 Asia ex-Japan (Latest 4 Asia ex-Japan (Last) -2 Japan (Latest) 2 Japan (Last) -4 Source: Deutsche Bank. Blank cell represents factor not used in the model for that country. Most Favorable, Favorable, O Neutral, Less Favorable and Least Favorable. Liquidity is based on yoy change in M2/Market Cap ratio, valuation is based on composite valuation index (based on trailing P/E, 12m fwd P/E, P/cash earnings, P/book, dividend yield, EV/EBIDTA and EV/Sales), sentiment is based on Risk-Love indicator, technicals are based on several price based indicators like percentage of stocks above 200-d moving average, number of 52-Weeks new lows and new highs, indices above/below their 200-d moving average etc., growth is based on leading economic indicators and earnings revision index, current account balance/GDP is based on deviation from 3-year moving average trend, real exchange rate is based on deviation from 2-year moving average trend and policy is based on policy indicator. Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong Page 15
  • 16. 17 October 2012 The Investigator Country-sector selection Figure 11: We prefer sectors with value, high earnings and price momentum, and better profitability 0.90 JP Banks HK Real Estate JP Telecom 0.80 KO Autos ID Hhold Products 0.70 TH Banks ID Banks Most preferred sectors CH Banks TH Food Bev 0.60 TH Telecom JP Energy IN Software 0.50 High earnings revisions & IN Hhold Products JP HCare Equip/Svc price momentum, better MY Utilities MY Telecom CH Real Estate 0.40 KO Insurance profitability KO Tech Hard/Equip IN Div Fin SG Banks CH Utilities 0.30 JP Autos TA Banks PH Real Estate TH Energy SG Real Estate SG Retailing JP Transport ID Utilities JP Div Fin ID Autos HK Telecom JP Food Bev KO Utilities JP Fd/Staples Retail 0.20 ID Pharma/ Biotech JP Comm Svc IN Energy HK Utilities PH Div Fin PH Cap Gds MY Energy JP Pharma/ Biotech HK Banks Software JP HK Cons Svc IN Banks ID Food Bev 0.10 TH Media IN Pharma/ Biotech JP Materials MY Banks MY Food Bev ID Telecom HK Cap Gds CH Telecom Materials ID CH Software TA Real Estate CH Transport SG Media Materials IN Autos JP Real Estate TH Materials KO TA Div Fin 0.00 TA Telecom JP Cap Gds CH Cap GdsJP Insurance TA Cons Durables SG Div Fin KO Retailing KO Cap Gds Transport JP Tech Hard/Equip HK KO Cons Svc KO Telecom KO Energy JP Hhold Products KO Food Bev JP Retailing JP Media KO Hhold Products IN Materials SG Food Bev -0.10 MY Autos CH Tech Hard/Equip CH HCare Equip/Svc HK Semis KO Transport CH Energy TA Materials -0.20 TA Semis PH Fd/Staples Retail HK Tech Hard/Equip JP Semis SG Cap Gds TA Retailing TA Cap Gds TA Insurance HK Retailing CH Autos KO Fd/Staples Retail -0.30 IN Food Bev MY Materials HK Cons Durables SG Cons Svc SG Fd/Staples Retail CH Materials KO Cons Durables Cheaper JP Cons Svc TA Tech Hard/Equip MY Cons Svc ID Energy MY Transport MY Cap Gds PH Telecom CH Retailing -0.40 CH Insurance MY Div Fin SG Telecom TA Fd/Staples Retail CH Food Bev IN Cap Gds IN Utilities IN Telecom IN Real Estate TA Transport Least preferred sectors IN Media HK Div Fin KO Pharma/ Biotech KO Div Fin Cap Gds ID -0.50 TA Autos KO Semis SG Transport CH Fd/Staples Retail KO Software -0.60 JP Utilities -0.70 -0.40 -0.30 -0.20 -0.10 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 Source: Deutsche Bank, FactSet Page 16 Deutsche Bank AG/Hong Kong