This document outlines the key concepts and practices of critical literacy in K-8 classrooms. It discusses how critical literacy encourages students to question power relationships and analyze popular culture from multiple perspectives. The document presents an instructional model for critical literacy consisting of using students' personal experiences and interests, engaging in critical social practices like disrupting assumptions and considering diverse views, adopting a critical stance of inquiry and reflection, and creating curriculum with a critical edge. Teachers are encouraged to adopt this framework to promote social justice through literacy.
2. WHAT IS CRITICAL LITERACY?
CRITICAL LITERACY PRACTICES
ENCOURAGE STUDENTS TO :
use language to question the everyday
world
interrogate the relationship between
language and power
analyze popular culture and media
understand how power relationships are
socially constructed
consider actions that can be taken to
promote social justice
3. A CRITICAL CURRICULUM
Simply reading [a big idea] book does not
guarantee that the teacher is enacting a
critical curriculum. ..unless the teacher and
students are
involved in critical social practices and
working from a critical stance,
there is no assurance that there will
be anything critical about
[the big idea] read aloud. p.5
4. AN INSTRUCTIONAL MODEL OF CRITICAL LITERACY
A CRITICAL CURRICULUM
Personal and Cultural
Resources
Critical
Social
Practices
Critical Stance
Critical Literacy
Curriculum
Lewison,lelandandHarste2008,p.6
5. PERSONAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES
what students and teachers draw on to
create the content of the curriculum
start with students’ personal
knowledge, interests, and issues
6. PERSONAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES
Examples:
personal experiences
social issues
books
popular culture
media
home literacies
textbooks
oral texts
student desires and interests
community, national and international issues
competence in a language other than English
7. CRITICAL SOCIAL PRACTICE
1. Disrupt the commonplace
challenge beliefs and
assumptions, routines, habits, beliefs and theories about
how the world works
see everyday issues through a new lens
visualize how things might be different
question classroom and environmental texts
ask questions about authors’ intentions and what they
want readers to believe
create a problem-posing curriculum rather than a
problem-solving curriculum
issues are directly related to classroom community
rather than a prescribed curriculum
real-life issues and popular culture become topics of
study
students have a role in planning, gathering resources
and assessing learning
goal for teachers is to become partners with students in
meaningful inquiry
8. CRITICAL SOCIAL PRACTICE (CON’T)
2. Consider Multiple Viewpoints
look for books that present the voice of those who have
been silenced or marginalized
juxtapose multiple accounts of events
3. Focus on the Sociopolitical
investigate oppression and power relationships
how is language used to maintain domination?
9. CRITICAL SOCIAL PRACTICE (CON’T)
4. Take Action to Promote Social Justice
get things done
become actors and not spectators
create “products” to promote social changes
use the arts to express critical understandings
10. CRITICAL STANCE
A WAY OF THINKING AND TEACHING
1. Conscious Engagement
we do not just respond to events in our lives, but we
thoughtfully decide how to respond
without it, we simple respond to events using our
unconscious, commonsense frames, which make it
challenging to assume a critical stance
2. Engaging alternate ways of being
come to an understanding that parts of what we
believe about teaching, learning and curriculum
may not be working
11. CRITICAL STANCE (CON’T)
3. Taking Responsibility to Inquire
ask lots of questions
ask questions that make a difference
understand that all knowledge is constructed from
particular perspectives
consider multiple and contradictory viewpoints to enrich
our perceptions of the world
interrogate the everyday
understand that knowledge is not something static to be
learned
“knowledge is beliefs at rest”
“Too often we develop…memorize what others have
already found out” (p.17)
12. CRITICAL STANCE (CON’T)
4. Being Reflexive
always questioning
being aware of our own
role in maintaining status
quo or systems of injustice
13. LET’S BE CRITICALLY LITERATE
In table groups, read, deconstruct and analyze the
McDonald’s advertisement placed at your table.
Consider the questions recorded on the coloured
sheet.
Be prepared to briefly share your thoughts with the
whole group.
14. ANALYZING ADVERTISEMENTS
Personal and Cultural Resources
What personal experiences, social issues, popular
media, oral texts , community concerns and personal
desires are addressed in this poster?
Multiple Viewpoints
Which voices are heard ? Which voices are absent? What
might an alternative point of view be?
Critical Stance
What is the critical stance of the poster? How does the author
position the viewer and or consumer?
Action to Promote Social Justice
What are some ways that students can respond to
this advertisement?
15. WHATISTHEAUTHOR’SMESSAGE?
What personal
experiences, social
issues, popular
media, oral texts
, community
concerns and
personal desires
are addressed in
this poster?
Which voices are
heard ? Which
voices are absent?
What might an
alternative point of
view be?
What is the critical
stance of the
poster? How does
the author position
the viewer and or
consumer?
What are some
ways that students
can respond to this
advertisement?
16. WHATISTHEAUTHOR’SMESSAGE?
What personal
experiences, social
issues, popular
media, oral texts
, community
concerns and
personal desires be
addressed in this
poster?
Which voices are
heard ? Which
voices are absent?
What might an
alternative point of
view be?
What is the critical
stance of the
poster? How does
the author position
the viewer and or
consumer?
What are some
ways that students
can respond to this
advertisement?
17. WHATISTHEAUTHOR’SMESSAGE?
What personal
experiences, social
issues, popular
media, oral texts
, community
concerns and
personal desires be
addressed in this
poster?
Which voices are
heard ? Which
voices are absent?
What might an
alternative point of
view be?
What is the critical
stance of the
poster? How does
the author position
the viewer and or
consumer?
What are some
ways that students
can respond to this
advertisement?
18. WHATISTHEAUTHOR’SMESSAGE?
What personal
experiences, social
issues, popular
media, oral texts
, community
concerns and
personal desires be
addressed in this
poster?
Which voices are
heard ? Which
voices are absent?
What might an
alternative point of
view be?
What is the critical
stance of the
poster? How does
the author position
the viewer and or
consumer?
What are some
ways that students
can respond to this
advertisement?
-this is a key quote from the first chapter-it is something that we need to consider when we are planning lessons with texts that address big ideas-this chapter addresses these terms in more detail and we will investigate this briefly in this session
-refer to page 6 in the textThis is a graphic of the Instructional Model of Critical Literacy. (critical literacy curriculum)When teaching critical literacy it is not enough to introduce provocative texts alone. Students must be encouraged to develop a critical stance and to engage in social and personal practices within their own personal and cultural resources. The model captures the movement and interactivity of the 3 major components of the model: Personal and Cultural ResourcesCritical Social PracticesCritical Stance. The model demonstrates that critical literacy curriculum is active and cannot be taught via passive pedagogy. The spiral captures how each component spins in and out, up and down and back and forth. Reference to the model is found on pages 5 and 6 in our texts and book talk participants may wish to tab these pages..
-refer to page 6-the outer circle
Photocopy and distribute to 3 or 4 tables for group discussions. During whole group debrief display the appropriate add so all participants can see the advertisement in question.
Photocopy and distribute to 3 or 4 tables for group discussions. During whole group debrief display the appropriate add so all participants can see the advertisement in question.
Photocopy and distribute to 3 or 4 tables for group discussions. During whole group debrief display the appropriate add so all participants can see the advertisement in question.
Photocopy and distribute to 3 or 4 tables for group discussions. During whole group debrief display the appropriate add so all participants can see the advertisement in question.