Assessment of community platforms by Stipso on behalf of ScotlandIS

1. ! ! !! !
!"#$%&'()*+,+-.#/)0,$,12$&/3))
"#$%&'()!%!*#+,-.&!"+//-('&0!'(!1.+&2%(,)
)
"4+(5$#2)6.'$22.,%+(7$,)
89:.'(7;.3!4+22+5'()!6#'/%#0!#$7$%#.8!9'(,'()7:!7&'67+!8%7!;$$(!&%7<$,!&+!
'(=$7&')%&$!+(2'($!.+//-('&0!7+2-&'+(7:!'(!+#,$#!&+!#$.+//$(,!&8$!/+7&!%6&!
62%&9+#/!9+#!&8$!1>1!6#+,-.&!/%(%)$#7!.+//-('&0?!@!=%#'$&0!+9!62%&9+#/!!"#$%!
8%=$!;$$(!',$(&'9'$,!%(,!'(=$7&')%&$,:!&8$!76$.'9'.!%&'(!)&*%!$A%/'($,!%#$!,#%5(!
9#+/!7-))$7&'+(7!/%,$!;0!1.+&2%(,!>1!%(,!7&'67+B7!+5(!'(=$7&')%&'+(7?!
)
<(#&'(&#.=)
C? "+//-('&0!4$%&-#$7!D'7&7!E!>,$(&'9'$,!;0!F$7$%#.8!4$$,;%.<!%(,!
7&'67+!
G? >(=$7&')%&$,!*2%&9+#/7!H06$7!
I? 7&'67+B7!F$.+//$(,%&'+(!!
J? >/62$/$(&%&'+(!F$K-'#$/$(&7!
!
>$22&,7(1)?.+(&#./)@7/(/)
H8$!6#$2'/'(%#0!#$7$%#.8!',$(&'9'$,!&8$!9+22+5'()!<$0!,$7'#%;2$!9$%&-#$73!
?.+(&#./)A%.,(757.%)91)6./.+#'B)
>+4.,%+#)
>&/($2)*.29.#/B7C)?$#2)D5$#)&/.#)E)'$2C+,1)C#$574./F)
?$#&2)G7(B)*&4(7C4.)HB#.+%/)DIJ0F)
K;.,()6<L")
09747(1)H$)MC4$+%)*+(.#7+4/)D"#./.,(+(7$,/N)<47%.)<B+#./N)L7%.$/FN)@7,O/)
P#$&C)Q.G/RS4$-)
*.29.#)"#$574./)
*.29.#/B7C)T+(+9+/.)
T.4.-+(7$,)$5)".#27//7$,/)D+%27,R&/.#)#$4./F)
T&./)"+12.,()+,%)T$,+(7$,/)*+,+-.2.,()
K;.,(/)"+12.,()*+,+-.2.,()
09747(1)H$)*+O.)P#$&C)>4$/.%)D"#7;+(.F)
>$,5.#.,'.)>+447,-RU.97,+#/)
!

2. ! ! !! !
>(!%,,'&'+(!&+!&8$!9$%&-#$7!',$(&'9'$,!;0!&8$!<$0!#$7$%#.8:!7&'67+!%27+!
.%6&-#$,!%!2'7&!+9!62%&9+#/!9$%&-#$7!&8%&!/%0!6#+=$!-7$9-2?!H8$7$!9-#&8$#!
9$%&-#$7!%#$!.+22$.&$,!;0!;-LL!/'('()!.+//-('&0!62%&9+#/!#$2$=%(&!<$0!
5+#,7!9#+/!&8$!7+.'%2!5$;!%(,!1MN!&$#/7!9#+/!&8$!7$%#.8!5$;?!>(!
6%#&'.-2%#:!%(!$A&#%!$/68%7'7!5%7!62%.$,!-6+(!'(.+#6+#%&'()!+&,)'$!%(,!
-.$/!$.0%&1)/'!1&**$1!)2)!"!O6%#&'.-2%#20!4%.$;++<!%(,!H5'&&$#P!9$%&-#$7!
5'&8!&8$!62%&9+#/!Q!&8$!/+7&!%.&'=$!%#$%7!'(!&$#/7!+9!,$=$2+6/$(&!
$=+2-&'+(!9+#!.+//-('&0!62%&9+#/7?!
!
?&#(B.#)?.+(&#./)A%.,(757.%)91)/(7C/$)
?+'.9$$O)>$,,.'()<7-,)7,))
HG7((.#)A,(.-#+(7$,)
*.29.#)6$/(.#)
6<<)?..%/)
<.+#'B))
<&9)P#$&C/)
?$#&2)6.C47./);7+)K2+74)
"$44/))
<<@)
>B+()
>4+//757.%/)+,%)K2C4$12.,()855.#/))
@7;.)*$974.)<(#.+27,-)>$,,.'(7;7(1)
8C(727V.%)*$974.)0''.//)
!
A,;./(7-+(.%)"4+(5$#2/!
H8$!9+22+5'()!/%'(!.+//-('&0!62%&9+#/!&06$7:!.%6%;2$!+9!7$#='.'()!&8$!
<$0!,$7'#%;2$!9$%&-#$7:!8%=$!;$$(!',$(&'9'$,3!
!
%? R+7&$,!1+2-&'+(7!7-.8!%7!D'(<$,>(:!S++)2$!%(,!4%.$;++<!S#+-67!
;? N6$(!1+-#.$!1+2-&'+(7!%7!+99$#$,!;0!$?)?!T++/2%:!U#-6%2!%(,!
V-,,0*#$77!!
.? 4+#-/!1+2-&'+(7:!$?)?!W;-22$&'(:!/0;;:!$&.?!
,? X8'&$!D%;$2!%(,!"+#6+#%&$!"+//-('&0!1+2-&'+(7!7-.8!%7!Y'():!V')!
H$(&:!T'=$:!$&.?!
H8$!=%#'+-7!,'99$#$(&!&06$7!8%=$!;$$(!)#%,$,!;0!7&'67+!+(!&8$'#!
'/62$/$(&%&'+(!+9!&8$!<$0!9$%&-#$7!+(!%!7.%2$!+9!CEZ:!58$#$!C!/$%(7![=$#0!
6++#!'/62$/$(&%&'+(!+#![(+&!%=%'2%;2$!%(,!Z!/$%(7![=$#0!7&#+()!
'/62$/$(&%&'+(?!H8$!7.+#$7!9+#!%22!9$%&-#$7!8%=$!;$$(!%))#$)%&$,:!;#+<$(!
,+5(!;0!#$7$%#.8!;%7$,!9$%&-#$7:!7&'67+!9$%&-#$7:!%(,!+=$#%22!&+&%27?!

3. ! ! !! !
?.+(&#./) W$/(.%) 8C.,)<$&#'.) ?$#&2) UB7(.)
<$4&(7$,/) DX$$24+N)T#&C+4N) D;S&44.(7,F) @+9.4)
D@7,O.%A,N) S&%%1"#.//F)Y) DQ7,-N)
?+'.9$$ON) 9+/7');.#/7$,/) S7-)H.,(N)
P$$-4.)P#$&C/F) X7;.F)
>+4.,%+#) J! J! I! J!
>&/($2) G! J! I! J!
*.29.#/B7C)
?$#2)D5$#)&/.#)E)
'$2C+,1)
C#$574./F)
?$#&2)G7(B) I! I! Z! Z!
*&4(7C4.)HB#.+%/)
DIJ0F)
K;.,()6<L") Z! I! I! Z!
09747(1)H$)MC4$+%) J! I! I! J!
*+(.#7+4/)
D"#./.,(+(7$,/N)
<47%./B+#./N)
L7%.$/FN)@7,O/)
P#$&C)Q.G/RS4$-) I! J! J! J!
*.29.#)"#$574./) I! I! J! Z!
*.29.#/B7C) I! J! J! J!
T+(+9+/.)
T.4.-+(7$,)$5) I! Z! J! J!
".#27//7$,/)
D+%27,R&/.#)
#$4./F)
T&./)"+12.,() C! G! I! J!
+,%)T$,+(7$,/)
*+,+-.2.,()
K;.,(/)"+12.,() C! I! C! J!
*+,+-.2.,()
09747(1)H$)*+O.) J! Z! Z! Z!
P#$&C)>4$/.%)
D"#7;+(.F)

4. ! ! !! !
>$,5.#.,'.) I! G! C! J!
>+447,-)
?+'.9$$O) I! J! I! Z!
>$,,.'()<7-,)7,))
HG7((.#) C! J! I! Z!
A,(.-#+(7$,)
*.29.#)6$/(.#) J! J! Z! Z!
>&/($27V+94.) C! J! G! J!
@+1$&()T./7-,)
D<A<)S#+,%7,-F)
6<<)?..%/) I! Z! C! J!
<.+#'B)) I! Z! J! J!
<&9)P#$&C/) C! G! J! Z!
?$#&2)6.C47./) C! G! Z! J!
;7+)K2+74)
"$44/)) G! I! C! J!
K,'#1C(.%) Z! Z! Z! Z!
<.'&#7(1)
>B+() I! G! C! Z!
>4+//757.%/)+,%) C! I! C! J!
K2C4$12.,()
855.#/))
@7;.)*$974.) C! G! C! J!
<(#.+27,-)
>$,,.'(7;7(1)
8C(727V.%)*$974.) I! J! J! J!
0''.//)
6./.+#'B) Z[) ]) Z) ]^)
?.+(&#./))
/(7C/$)?.+(&#./)) Z_) [) `) ^_)
H$(+4)<'$#./) ab) ) [) cZ) bbc)

5. ! ! !! !
!
6.'$22.,%+(7$,!
>(!%,,'&'+(!&+!)#%,'()!&8$!,'99$#$(&!62%&9+#/7!&06$7!5'&8!#$)%#,7!&+!
'/62$/$(&%&'+(!+9!9$%&-#$7:!7&'67+!8%7!%27+!$A%/'($,!62%&9+#/7!'(!#$2%&'+(!
&+!7$&E-6!%(,!/%'(&$(%(.$!.+7&7!%(,!&'/$:!$%7$!+9!&$.8('.%2!7$&E-6:!-7$#!
9#'$(,2'($77!%(,!.+//-('&0!76'#'&!Q!'?$?!58'.8!7+2-&'+(!;$7&!$()$(,$#7!%!
.+//-('&0!76'#'&!&+!$(7-#$!&8%&!-7$#7!5'22!9'(,!%(!$()%)'()!$(='#+(/$(&!
5'&8!2+5!;%##'$#7!&+!%.&'=$!.+(&#';-&'+(?))
)
R+7&$,!1+2-&'+(7!
H8$!8+7&$,!7+2-&'+(7!OS++)2$:!D'(<$,>(:!4%.$;++<!)#+-67P!%#$!$%70!%(,!
9#$$!&+!7$&E-6:!;-&!7'/62'7&'.!%(,!(+&!=$#0!92$A';2$!&+!-7$?!H8$#$!'7!(+!#$%2!
7$(7$!+9!.+//-('&0!+5($#78'6:!%(,!.#'&'.%2!9$%&-#$7!%#$!/'77'()!+#!=$#0!
76%#7$20!'/62$/$(&$,?!7&'67+!,+$7!(+&!#$.+//$(,!-7'()!&8'7!&06$!+9!
7+2-&'+(!9+#!&8$!*#+,-.&!"+//-('&0!*2%&9+#/?!!!
N6$(!1+-#.$!
H8$!6+&$(&'%2!9+#!+6$(!7+-#.$!7+2-&'+(7!'7!;%7'.%220!2'/'&2$77?!R+5$=$#:!&8$!
#$%2'7%&'+(!+9!&8'7!6+&$(&'%2!%(,!&8$!/%'(&$(%(.$!+9!&8$!.#$%&$,!62%&9+#/:!'7!
=$#0!.+7&!%(,!&'/$!'(&$(7'=$:!%(,!-7$#!9#'$(,2'($77!+9&$(!7-99$#7?!N6$(!
7+-#.$!7+2-&'+(7!,+!(+&!8%=$!&8$![+-&!+9!&8$!;+A!9-(.&'+(%2'&0!+9!58'&$!
2%;$2!7+2-&'+(7?!7&'67+!,+$7!(+&!#$.+//$(,!6-#7-'()!&8$!+6$(!7+-#.$!
+6&'+(?!
4+#-/7!
4+#-/7!2%.<!7$=$#%2!+9!&8$!,$7'#$,!<$0!9$%&-#$7?!>(,$$,:!9+#-/7!%#$!
6$#8%67!;$7&!7$$(!%7!%!9$%&-#$!+9!&8$!,$7'#$,!.+//-('&0!62%&9+#/:!%(,!(+&!
%6&!9+#!-7$!%7!&8$!;%7'.!62%&9+#/!'&7$29?!7&'67+!,+$7!(+&!#$.+//$(,!-7'()!
9+#-/!;+%#,7!%7!&8$!;%7'7!9+#!&8$!.+//-('&0!7'&$?!
X8'&$!2%;$2!7+2-&'+(7!
H8$!X8'&$!D%;$2!7+2-&'+(7!7.+#$!8')8$7&!5'&8!#$)%#,7!&+!;$7&!
'/62$/$(&'()!&8$!9$%&-#$7!2'7&7?!4+#!7$&!-6!.+7&7!%(,!&'/$:!&8$7$!7+2-&'+(7!
%#$!%27+!%&&#%.&'=$:!#$K-'#'()!/'('/%2!$99+#&!&+!%22+5!9+#!7+68'7&'.%&$,!
9-(.&'+(%2'&0:!%(,!-7$#!9#'$(,2'($77?!N9!%22!&8$!X8'&$!D%;$2!+99$#'()7:!7&'67+!
#$.+//$(,7!-7'()!Y'()?!!!!!
)

6. ! ! !! !
UB1)Q7,-d)!)
<(#.,-(B/) >$,/.e&.,'./)
>(,-7&#0!D$%,$#7! H8$#$!%#$!/%(0!Y'()!-7$#7:!7+!]>!
.+/9+#&!2$=$27!8%=$!;$$(!8$%='20!
&$7&$,!%(,!$(8%(.$,?!H8$#$!'7!%27+!%!
8')8$#!6#+;%;'2'&0!+9!6#+,-.&!
.+//-('&0!-7$#7!58+!%2#$%,0!8%=$!
$A6$#'$(.$,!Y'()B7!]>?!!
S#+5'()!62-)'(!$.+707&$/! Y'()!8%7!&8$!5',$7&!%=%'2%;'2'&0!+9!
9$%&-#$!$(8%(.'()!62-)'(7:!58'.8!
%#$!=$#0!2'<$20!&+!)#+5!%6%.$!5'&8!
&8$!)#+-6B7!($$,7?!
M%7'20!;#%(,%;2$! Y'()!62%&9+#/7!%#$!$%7'20!;#%(,%;2$:!
.#$%&'()!)#+-6!',$(&'&0!%(,!2+0%2&0?!
^'('/%2!$99+#&!'7!#$K-'#$,!&+!.#$%&$!
;#%(,!7<'(?!
"+7&!$99'.'$(&! Y'()!+99$#7!%!9#$$!+($!/+(&8!&#'%2!
%(,!&8#$$!,'99$#$(&!.+7&!62%(7!E!
555?('()?.+/_.+/6%#$62%(7!
1-66+#&! V$.%-7$!&8$0!%#$!7+!;'):!&8$#$!'7!%!
=';#%(&!8$26!.+//-('&0:!5'&8!
0+-&-;$!7-66+#&!.2'67:!$&.?!
S#$%&$#!Y'()!.+//-('&'$7!70($#)0! 10($#)0!5'&8!7'&$7!2'<$!
I`/'(-&$7?.+?-<!Q!58+7$!-7$#7!.%(!
+=$#2%6!5'&8!&8$!*#+,-.&!
"+//-('&0!1'&$?!]7$#7!%2#$%,0!8%=$!
$A6$#'$(.$!5'&8!&8$!Y'()!]>?!
]7$#!9#'$(,2'($77! *%#&'.-2%#20!'(!.+(&#%7&!5'&8!T'=$:!
Y'()!'7!%!=$#0!-7$#!9#'$(,20!%(,!
+6$(!62%&9+#/?!H8'7!2+5$#7!&8$!
;%##'$#7!&+!6%#&'.'6%&'+(!%(,!
)#+5&8?!!!
!
!
!

7. ! ! !! !
A2C4.2.,(+(7$,)Y)6.e&7#.2.,(/)+,%)HB$&-B(/)
!
"8++7'()!Y'()!%7!&8$!.+//-('&0!62%&9+#/!5'22!$(&%'2!&8$!9+22+5'()!
#$K-'#$/$(&7?!!
%? S$($#%2!&$#/7!%(,!.+(,'&'+(7!&+!$(7-#$!)++,!($&'K-$&&$!
;? U$7')(!%(,!"11!5+#<!'(!+#,$#!&+!.#$%&$!%!.+//-('&0!;#%(,!%(,!
2++<!
.? ^+,$#%&'+(:!%,/'('7&#%&'+(!
,? 1+.'%2!X$;!>(&$)#%&'+(!%(,!1&#%&$)0!Q!'(!+#,$#!&+!6-78!&8$!7'&$!%(,!
)%'(!&#%.&'+(!'(!&8$!7+.'%2!5$;:!&8$#$!78+-2,!;$!%(!$99$.&'=$!7&#%&$)0!
'(!62%.$:!$?)?!'(.2-,'()![&5$$&!%(,![2'<$!;-&&+(7!+(!&8$!7'&$?!!!
$? "+(&$(&!1&#%&$)0!Q!,$76'&$!;$'()!%!7+.'%2!.+//-('&0:!#$2'%(&!+(!-7$#!
)$($#%&$,!.+(&$(&:!%![&+6!,+5(!.+(&$(&!7&#%&$)0!5'22!7&'22!;$!
($$,$,!(+&!+(20!'(!+#,$#!&+!)'=$!78%6$!%(,!7&#-.&-#$!&+!&8$!
.+//-('&0:!;-&!%27+!&+!#$='=$!,$%,!&+6'.7:!$(8%(.$!&+6'.%2!;-LL!%(,!
%27+!'(&$#%.&!5'&8!&8$!;-LL!9#+/!+&8$#!7+-#.$7!O$=$(!+&8$#!
62%&9+#/7P!9#+/!&8$!7%/$!7$.&+#?!!!
*2$%7$!7$$!&8$!9+22+5'()!2'(<!9+#!/+#$!,$&%'273!
8&&63__555?7+.'%2/$,'%$A%/'($#?.+/_8+5E&+E;-'2,E%E9#$$E7+.'%2E
/$,'%E/+('&+#'()E,%78;+%#,_!
!