SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 13
After the Court & Election Decisions:
    What’s Next for Health Care?



               Tom Miller
       American Enterprise Institute
           November 8, 2012
Story Lines to Pursue


• Cross-pressures on exchanges
• Recalibrating Medicaid expansion
      Metabolic disorder or fiscal bulimia?
• State-level politics
• Setting the table for the 2014 “stress test”
• Transparency without real prices
Primary Political Scenarios:
  Ratification, Rejection, or Equivocation?


Post-November playing field scenarios
• Re-election w/o full congressional control
 From “rope a dope” to “survive & advance”
 Reality-based revision or fuller strength
  dosage?
 Pottery barn rules
Primary ACA Political Equations:
                 Blame Shifting



• States – branch offices, handle dirty work
• Keep full costs off-budget
The Ordeal of Change:
         Politics vs. Markets


• Strategic & tactical repositioning
• Getting beyond a common rhetoric
• National goals, local trial & error
• Scalability, replication, adaptation
Pilot Program Prototypes?


•
Pilot Program Prototypes?


•
Pilot Program Prototypes?


•
Don’t Just Look under the
      Street Light for Lost Keys

• Social determinants of health
• Broader portfolio of investments
• Scope of practice
• Competition policy
• Telemedicine
• Broader use of self-insurance
Choke Points & Leverage




• Exchanges (state v. fed)
• Medicaid expansion
• Renegotiate & rewrite vs. repeal & replace
The Secret Plan for
          Health Delivery Reform,
ACA Implementation, & Affordable Entitlements
Predictive Modeling:
Probabilities, Possibilies & Implausibilities

• Centripetal, not centrifugal, forces
• But changing permanent law alters frame of
  reference
• Accountability: to patients or politicians?
• Macroeconomic overrides
Bonus Rounds


• Six Picks for Post-Election Health Policy
http://www.realclearmarkets.com/articles/2012/11/07/six_picks_f
or_post-election_health_policy_99976.html
• When Obamacare Fails: The Playbook for Market-
Based Reform (AEI, November 2012)
• Beyond Repeal and Replace (AEI project)
•http://www.aei.org/issue/health/healthcare-reform/beyond-
repeal-and-replace-series

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Mehr von reportingonhealth

Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?reportingonhealth
 
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?reportingonhealth
 
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...reportingonhealth
 
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"reportingonhealth
 
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"reportingonhealth
 
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"reportingonhealth
 
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"reportingonhealth
 
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"reportingonhealth
 
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"reportingonhealth
 
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"reportingonhealth
 
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"reportingonhealth
 
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"reportingonhealth
 
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"reportingonhealth
 
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"reportingonhealth
 
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"reportingonhealth
 

Mehr von reportingonhealth (20)

Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
 
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
 
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
 
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
 
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
 
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
 
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
 
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
 
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
 
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
 
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
 
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
 
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
 
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Dr. Garen J. Wintemute: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
 

After The Court And Election Decisions: What's Next For Healthcare?

  • 1. After the Court & Election Decisions: What’s Next for Health Care? Tom Miller American Enterprise Institute November 8, 2012
  • 2. Story Lines to Pursue • Cross-pressures on exchanges • Recalibrating Medicaid expansion  Metabolic disorder or fiscal bulimia? • State-level politics • Setting the table for the 2014 “stress test” • Transparency without real prices
  • 3. Primary Political Scenarios: Ratification, Rejection, or Equivocation? Post-November playing field scenarios • Re-election w/o full congressional control  From “rope a dope” to “survive & advance”  Reality-based revision or fuller strength dosage?  Pottery barn rules
  • 4. Primary ACA Political Equations: Blame Shifting • States – branch offices, handle dirty work • Keep full costs off-budget
  • 5. The Ordeal of Change: Politics vs. Markets • Strategic & tactical repositioning • Getting beyond a common rhetoric • National goals, local trial & error • Scalability, replication, adaptation
  • 9. Don’t Just Look under the Street Light for Lost Keys • Social determinants of health • Broader portfolio of investments • Scope of practice • Competition policy • Telemedicine • Broader use of self-insurance
  • 10. Choke Points & Leverage • Exchanges (state v. fed) • Medicaid expansion • Renegotiate & rewrite vs. repeal & replace
  • 11. The Secret Plan for Health Delivery Reform, ACA Implementation, & Affordable Entitlements
  • 12. Predictive Modeling: Probabilities, Possibilies & Implausibilities • Centripetal, not centrifugal, forces • But changing permanent law alters frame of reference • Accountability: to patients or politicians? • Macroeconomic overrides
  • 13. Bonus Rounds • Six Picks for Post-Election Health Policy http://www.realclearmarkets.com/articles/2012/11/07/six_picks_f or_post-election_health_policy_99976.html • When Obamacare Fails: The Playbook for Market- Based Reform (AEI, November 2012) • Beyond Repeal and Replace (AEI project) •http://www.aei.org/issue/health/healthcare-reform/beyond- repeal-and-replace-series

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. Thank you’sTwo years of waiting for courtObamaCare and health policy problems didn’t stopVoters in Nov 2010 sent a message, but it has not gotten throughUnusual law in many ways ---- contorted process, but also a very slow-developing implementationIt takes a while to takeover the private health care system,while trying to hide all the costs, impacts, and long-term goals with false promises, budgeting accounting fictions, political scapegoating, and “whatever it takes” rulemaking --- and get all the rewiring done so it doesn’t compeltely collapseThis issue matters a lot It’s a big one, not just for the near term but how it will shape our future --- our politics, the role of govt, our economy and, oh yes, our health.
  2. Consumer demand within a budget constraintPublic vs. private money
  3. This morning, I’m going to cover the ground quickly, and hit the highlightsWhere are we? BulletsUrgency to stop before institutionallizatoin and capitulationSlower health spending ----- what a great solution ---- slow eco growth
  4. This morning, I’m going to cover the ground quickly, and hit the highlightsWhere are we? BulletsUrgency to stop before institutionallizatoin and capitulationSlower health spending ----- what a great solution ---- slow eco growth
  5. Pay or play No LEGAL COMPULSION to actually buy the insurance Before 2014, and after link to state-run exchange?Trying to go below March 2010 level, or at least below 138% FPL laterStates may try tto make BETTER deals Leverage ---- for participation and market share Watch Maine case (just lost yesterday?)CBO – only modest adjustments in enrollment and budget costs forecast guessing at Medicare state takeupFed tax credits for fed exchanges Possible litigatoinMain delivery vehiicle, w/ Medicaid partly stalledMid-Nov implementation ready deadine? Fed-facilitated overrideRuling impact depends on what feds attempt next, to stretch out compuulsion somewhere else Politics was stalled and frozen while waiting for Court Industry -- it’s just business
  6. Pay or play No LEGAL COMPULSION to actually buy the insurance Before 2014, and after link to state-run exchange?Trying to go below March 2010 level, or at least below 138% FPL laterStates may try tto make BETTER deals Leverage ---- for participation and market share Watch Maine case (just lost yesterday?)CBO – only modest adjustments in enrollment and budget costs forecast guessing at Medicare state takeupFed tax credits for fed exchanges Possible litigatoinMain delivery vehiicle, w/ Medicaid partly stalledMid-Nov implementation ready deadine? Fed-facilitated overrideRuling impact depends on what feds attempt next, to stretch out compuulsion somewhere else Politics was stalled and frozen while waiting for Court Industry -- it’s just business
  7. Pay or play No LEGAL COMPULSION to actually buy the insurance Before 2014, and after link to state-run exchange?Trying to go below March 2010 level, or at least below 138% FPL laterStates may try tto make BETTER deals Leverage ---- for participation and market share Watch Maine case (just lost yesterday?)CBO – only modest adjustments in enrollment and budget costs forecast guessing at Medicare state takeupFed tax credits for fed exchanges Possible litigatoinMain delivery vehiicle, w/ Medicaid partly stalledMid-Nov implementation ready deadine? Fed-facilitated overrideRuling impact depends on what feds attempt next, to stretch out compuulsion somewhere else Politics was stalled and frozen while waiting for Court Industry -- it’s just business
  8. Pay or play No LEGAL COMPULSION to actually buy the insurance Before 2014, and after link to state-run exchange?Trying to go below March 2010 level, or at least below 138% FPL laterStates may try tto make BETTER deals Leverage ---- for participation and market share Watch Maine case (just lost yesterday?)CBO – only modest adjustments in enrollment and budget costs forecast guessing at Medicare state takeupFed tax credits for fed exchanges Possible litigatoinMain delivery vehiicle, w/ Medicaid partly stalledMid-Nov implementation ready deadine? Fed-facilitated overrideRuling impact depends on what feds attempt next, to stretch out compuulsion somewhere else Politics was stalled and frozen while waiting for Court Industry -- it’s just business
  9. Pay or play No LEGAL COMPULSION to actually buy the insurance Before 2014, and after link to state-run exchange?Trying to go below March 2010 level, or at least below 138% FPL laterStates may try tto make BETTER deals Leverage ---- for participation and market share Watch Maine case (just lost yesterday?)CBO – only modest adjustments in enrollment and budget costs forecast guessing at Medicare state takeupFed tax credits for fed exchanges Possible litigatoinMain delivery vehiicle, w/ Medicaid partly stalledMid-Nov implementation ready deadine? Fed-facilitated overrideRuling impact depends on what feds attempt next, to stretch out compuulsion somewhere else Politics was stalled and frozen while waiting for Court Industry -- it’s just business
  10. g fieldOther legal challenges (fed exchange, MOE,Statutory vs reg conflict Employer mandate, state sovereingty Negotiate for big structural M waiversCritical mass?Reconciliation ---- debone and filet mostFirst day vs. first yearNew rulemaking, limited waivers What’s short-term popular Irreversible changes in markets?Avoiding biggest disasters Tactical vs. strategic Customization/standardization continuum
  11. It could crash, if not delayed and rewritten for reality
  12. Fiscal cliffRebid for more, better careInstalled base, population health
  13. Fiscal cliffRebid for more, better careInstalled base, population health