2. What is Style Premia Investing?
Style Premia Investing refers to allocating to
various risk factors, within and across asset
classes, that have been proven to generate
significant risk-adjusted returns over time.
Many names, same underlying premiseâŠ
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
2
3. What Characteristics do Style Premia have?
-
A style premium is a risk premium and thus should have some economic intuition or behavioural
explanation why an investment in it should carry an excess return (why am I getting paid?).
-
Style premia should be well-documented in academic research and persist over time (multiple
decades).
-
Style premia are pervasive, existing across regions and asset classes.
-
Style premia need to be liquid and be scalable to allow for institutional investment.
-
Style premia will be dynamic and not hold a static allocation to any asset class or market.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
3
4. Section 1:
Style Premia Case Studies
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
4
5. Neil Woodford: Style Premia in Practice
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Invesco Perpetual High Income Fund
FTSE All Share
Source: Invesco, Bloomberg
- Neil Woodford presents us with an intriguing practical look into style premia investing in the UK.
- His track record is impressive â he has beaten the FTSE All Share over the past 12 years by 3.4% p.a.
- But is this the correct benchmark to use to assess his performance?
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
5
6. Betting Against Beta â Frazzini and Pedersen (2013)
- Frazzini and Pedersen (2013) find that âbetting
against betaâ has been a very effective investing
strategy across many asset classes (US equities, 20
international equity markets, Treasury bonds,
corporate bonds and futures).
- By going long low beta assets while going short
high beta assets, this has historically produced a
significant premium.
- They posit that due to leverage aversion, many
investors seeking high returns will bid up high
volatility assets rather than choosing to lever low
volatility assets.
- This leads to a premium for those willing to invest
in low beta assets which can be termed a
âdefensive style premiumâ.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
6
7. Academic Research Has Highlighted Other Effects Over Long Periods of Time
Fama & French (1992)
Jegadeesh & Titman (1993)
- Buying rising stocks and selling falling stocks leads to excess
outperformance of about 1% per month (1965-1989). This is known
as the (price) momentum factor.
- Small cap stocks outperform large cap stocks over the long
term (1962-1989). (On a risk-adjusted basis, however, the
difference is negligible.)
- âCheapâ stocks (based on fundamental rations such as priceto-book or price-to-earnings) outperform âexpensiveâ stocks.
This holds up even on a risk-adjusted basis and is known as
the value factor.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
7
8. Applying Style Premia to Neil Woodford
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan-01 Jan-02 Jan-03 Jan-04 Jan-05 Jan-06 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13
Regressed
Invesco High Income Fund
FTSE All Share
Source: Deutsche Bank, Invesco,
Bloomberg; Calculations: Redington
Market
Portfolio Weights
Value
Momentum
Defensive
75%
13%
19%
52%
Woodfordâs performance can broadly be explained by: a lower than 100% weight to the market
(represented by the FTSE All Share) along with allocations to value, momentum and defensive factors.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
8
9. Buffettâs Alpha
-
Like Neil Woodford, Warren Buffett provides another fascinating example of style premia
investing in equities.
-
In a paper titled âBuffettâs Alphaâ, AQR Capital Management principals Frazzini, Kabiller and Pedersen
find that:
âą
âą
Berkshire has levered 1.6-to-1 on average, borrowing partly through its insurance companyâs
float at rates over 3% below the US T-bill rate giving it ultra-cheap financing (2.2% on average).
âą
When controlling for exposures to style premia and leverage, Buffettâs alpha over the S&P 500
becomes insignificant.
âą
-
Berkshire Hathaway has a Sharpe ratio of 0.76 from 1976 to 2012, double that of S&P 500
(0.37). This is a higher Sharpe ratio than any other US stock or mutual fund over that period.
Buffett has suffered large absolute and relative drawdowns. His success
stems from being able to stick with his strategy over the long run.
Neither Woodford nor Buffett ever likely thought about âharvestingâ premia.
They do, however, state similar characteristics for companies they like:
cheap, stable, profitable, growing and with high payout ratios.
Can their approach to investment be done systematically?
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
9
10. Section 2:
The Evolution of Alpha and Beta
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
10
11. Is Alpha Just Beta Waiting to be Discovered?
Time
Alpha
Alpha
Other
Market
Risk
Premia
Alpha
Equity
Risk
Premium
Prior to capweighted indices, all
returns were
effectively viewed as
alpha
Equity
Risk
Premium
With the
introduction of
CAPM, the equity
market effect was
separated from
returns
This was then
extrapolated to
include other asset
classes such as
bonds and
commodities
Alpha
Style Premia
Other Market
Risk Premia
Equity Risk
Premium
Now we can
separate out a
number of risk
premia with much
less being left as
pure alpha
Source: Figure 2, âIs Alpha Just Beta Waiting To Be Discovered?â, AQR Capital Management
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
11
12. A Continuum Between Beta and Alpha
Low
High
Alpha
C
A
P
A
C
I
T
Y
F
E
E
S
Style Premia
Market Risk Premia
High
Low
Source: Figure 11, âIs Alpha Just Beta Waiting To Be Discovered?â, AQR Capital Management
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
12
13. Style Premia vs. Smart Beta
-
Alternative indexation strategies, otherwise known as âsmart betaâ, are related to style premia. Many
smart beta equity strategies take exposure to the same factors identified as style premia here.
-
However, smart beta strategies are long-only and therefore have a high amount of market exposure.
Style premia strategies are long/short in implementation and should have little to no market exposure.
Exposures of a
typical smart
beta strategy
Alpha
Style Premia
Market Risk Premia
-
Our preferred structure for most pension schemes is to access liquid market risk premia through
futures/swaps (e.g. volatility-controlled equities or risk parity) and to access style premia directly. This
is usually lower cost than through a total return swap (TRS) on smart beta indices.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
13
14. Style Premia Decomposition of the RAFI Fundamental Index
250
200
150
100
50
0
Jan-01 Jan-02 Jan-03 Jan-04 Jan-05 Jan-06 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Regressed
RAFI Fundamental Index
Source: Deutsche Bank, Research Affiliates,
Bloomberg; Calculations: Redington
Market
Portfolio Weights
Value
Momentum
Defensive
100%
21%
8%
0%
Mostly market exposure gained along with some value and momentum style premia.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
14
16. Major Style Premia Families Cutting Across Liquid Markets
Value
Momentum
âąBuying assets that are âcheapâ relative to their
fundamental value and selling âexpensiveâ assets
âąFor example: go long lowest price-to-book stocks, go
short highest price-to-book stocks
âąInvolves buying assets that recently outperformed
peers and selling those that recently underperformed
âąFor example: go long stocks with highest 3 month
return, go short stocks with lowest 3 month return
Carry
âąImplies buying high-yielding assets and selling lowyielding assets
âąFor example: go long highest yielding currencies, go
short lowest yielding currencies
Defensive
âąConsists of buying low-risk, high-quality assets and
selling high-risk, low-quality assets
âąFor example: go long high return-on-equity stocks, go
short low return-on-equity stocks
Need to be able to go long, go short and to leverage across multiple asset classes.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
16
17. Style Premia Returns Have Been Strong
Performance of Style Strategies (log value, excess return over cash)
200%
Cumulative Return
150%
100%
50%
0%
-50%
Dec-89
Dec-92
AQR Value
Dec-95
Dec-98
AQR Momentum
Dec-01
AQR Carry
Dec-04
AQR Defensive
Dec-07
Dec-10
MSCI World
Source: AQR Capital Management
An individual style premium may not work for a number of years. This is why diversification matters.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
17
18. Performance Over Various Economic Regimes Has Held Up Better Than Asset Classes
Sharpe Ratio
All
0.71
-0.18
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
Sharpe Ratio
0.46
All
0.71
-0.09
Sharpe Ratio
0.32
All
0.06
0.43
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
1.21
0.52
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
All
1.34
1.14
0.93
0.81
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
Carry
0.88
All
0.72
0.9
0.88
1.1
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
Defensive
Source: Exhibit 2, âExploring Macroeconomic Sensitivitiesâ,
AQR Capital Management
Private & Confidential
1.02
-0.09
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
0.51
0.76
Momentum
0.1
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
0.73
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
All
1.22
Commodities
2.0
1.0
0.0
-1.0
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
0.71
0.29
Global Bonds
2.0
1.0
0.0
-1.0
Sharpe Ratio
0.31
1.03
Sharpe Ratio
Sharpe Ratio
Global Equities
2.0
1.0
0.0
-1.0
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
Sharpe Ratio
Value
For period 1972 to 2013
Style Premia Investing
0.85
All
1.07
0.88
0.53
0.89
Growth Up + Growth Up + Growth Down Growth Down
Inflation Up
Inflation + Inflation Up + Inflation
Down
Down
26 February 2014
18
19. Style Premia are Generally Uncorrelated to Each Other and to Equities
Style Premia Rolling 12 Month Correlation to
Equities
Average Pairwise Rolling 12 Month Correlation
for Style Premia Factors
0.3
0.8
0.6
0.2
0.4
0.1
0.2
0
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.4
-0.2
-0.6
-0.3
-0.4
1990
-0.8
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
2010
2012
-1
1990
1992
Style Premia Correlation (1990-2013)
Value
Momentum
Carry
Value
-0.60
-0.09
0.22
-0.04
0.12
-0.03
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
2010
2012
Value Momentum Carry Defensive Composite Equities
Defensive
1.00
Defensive
1998
Style Premia Performance (1990-2013)
1.00
Carry
1996
1.00
Momentum
1994
Excess Return 3.29%
7.61%
4.86%
12.55%
2.09%
Volatility
1.00
4.82%
12.0%
12.0%
12.0%
12.0%
12.4%
15.5%
0.27
0.40
0.63
0.40
1.01
0.14
Sharpe Ratio
Source: AQR Capital Management
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
19
20. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: How do I know these style premia havenât just been âdata-minedâ?
A: Firstly, there needs to be some intuitive reason as to why a premium exists. The premium should have been
tested out-of-sample, either in a different time period or in a different region. Style premia should pervade across
time and across markets/regions.
Q2: Wonât these style premia disappear over time as more people invest in them?
A: Yes, thatâs a possibility. However, behavioural characteristics which cause some of these premia to exist are
ingrained in human behaviour. It would take a significant change in the way people invest as a whole to affect style
premia returns. Note that this would have the same impact on fundamental active management, in which case the
Warren Buffett way of investing may also cease to work.
Q3: Will correlations between the premia increase as people invest on this basis (i.e. a package of style premia)?
A: Yes, this may begin to happen. This would lower the appeal of style premia, however, if they remain uncorrelated to
major asset classes they should remain of use to most investors. Additionally, investors should consider risk-controlled
structures such that increased correlations lead to lower exposures.
Q4: How can I invest in style premia?
A: You may already have exposure to style premia through investments in active managers. However, this is typically
not in a pure, risk-controlled format. The next section will highlight direct pathways for investment.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
20
22. Ways to Access Style Premia
Via TRS on various bank
style premia indices
Asset Managers trading
bank swaps on style premia
Asset Managers trading
underlying instruments
Private & Confidential
- Banks have live track records for style
premia indices going back a number of
years.
- This route is complex from a governance
perspective. The investor has to choose
how to allocate and de-allocate to styles.
- These could potentially be transacted by
a schemeâs LDI manager.
- Banks have a number of indices in each
area, some of which may not have
performed so well (adverse selection).
- This places a fiduciary in between the
bank and the pension scheme.
- Is the asset manager truly
independent of the bank?
- Has the potential to tap into a lot of
quantitative talent within banks.
- Has the asset manager thoroughly
due diligenced the intricacies of the
swap documentation?
- For pension schemes, this is the
most familiar pathway to invest in
style premia.
- The managers may be able to trade
more cheaply than the costs
embedded in a bank swap.
Style Premia Investing
- Few managers have a long track record in
a style premia product, especially in a
multi-asset context (hedge funds have
been employing similar strategies within
their funds previously though).
26 February 2014
22
23. Mapping Style Premia to Asset Classes
Manager A
Value
Momentum
Carry
Equities
ïŒ
ïŒ
Bonds
ïŒ
ïŒ
ïŒ
Rates
ïŒ
ïŒ
ïŒ
FX
ïŒ
ïŒ
ïŒ
Commodities
ïŒ
ïŒ
Defensive
ïŒ
ïŒ
ïŒ
Exposures to style premia within different asset classes will vary from manager to manager.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
23
24. Conclusions
-
A large part of the returns of some very successful investors can be explained by exposures to style
premia.
-
Much of what had previously been thought of as alpha is now being classed alternative beta. This
includes style premia which are systematic, liquid market strategies shown to produce significant
risk-adjusted returns.
-
Style premia performance has been strong with a low level of dependence on the economic
environment.
-
Style premia are especially attractive because they are generally uncorrelated to each other and to
major asset classes.
-
By accessing them through systematic, liquid and risk-controlled structures, investors can diversify
their risk while lowering manager fees.
-
Given lower credit spreads, pension schemes looking for other diversifiers to equities may need to
look at strategies such as style premia in order to achieve their objectives.
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
24
25. References
Crowell, B., R. Israel, D. Kabiller and A. Berger (2012), âIs Alpha Just Beta Waiting To Be Discovered?â, AQR
Capital Management
Fama, E.F. and French, K.R. (1992), âThe cross-section of expected stock returnsâ, Journal of Finance, 47, 2,
pp. 427-465
Frazzini, A. and L.H. Pedersen (2013), âBetting Against Betaâ, working paper, AQR Capital Management and
New York University
Frazzini, A., D. Kabiller and L.H. Pedersen (2013), âBuffettâs Alphaâ, working paper, AQR Capital
Management and New York University
Ilmanen, A., T. Maloney and A. Ross (2013), âExploring Macroeconomic Sensitivitiesâ, AQR Capital
Management
Jegadeesh, N. and S. Titman (1993), âThe returns to buying winners and selling losersâ, Journal of Finance,
48, 1, 65-91
Private & Confidential
Style Premia Investing
26 February 2014
25