This presentation done for Interactive Media Strategies module, uses DEC Haiti earthquake appeal as a case study. The aim is to identify an interactive media trend/theme, present our findings in a 10 minute commentary ending with a discussion. Additional comments are to be added into a final report. Presentation research pilfered profusely from DEC's website, social media channels, Third Sector, Mashable, Wikipedia and other online sources.
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Are social media channels effective fundraising tools for emergency appeals?
1. Are social media channels effective
fundraising tools for emergency appeals?
- A DEC Haiti earthquake appeal case study
IMS State of the Industry presentation
10.02.2010
Rebekah Hah
2. Trends in interactive media
• Increasing number of people are
using social media
• Those who use social media are
also using more of it
3. What is social media?
Media designed to be disseminated
through social interaction
• Interactions: from broadcast media
monologues (one to many) into social
media dialogues (many to many)
• People: from content consumers into
content producers
5. Why charities use social media to raise funds
• Cost-effective
• Addition to other offline and
online fundraising methods
6. Why charities use social media to raise funds
• Cost-effective
• Addition to other offline and
online fundraising methods
• Broaden existing usage as a
marketing communications tool
7. Why charities use social media to raise funds
• Cost-effective
• Addition to other offline and
online fundraising methods
• Broaden existing usage as a
marketing communications tool
• Reach supporters who see new
media as a way of life
8. Why charities use social media to raise funds
• Cost-effective
• Addition to other offline and
online fundraising methods
• Broaden existing usage as a
marketing communications tool
• Reach supporters who see new
media as a way of life
• Already used as a platform to
promote good causes
9. Why charities use social media to raise funds
• Cost-effective
• Addition to other offline and
online fundraising methods
• Broaden existing usage as a
marketing communications tool
• Reach supporters who see new
media as a way of life
• Already used as a platform to
promote good causes
• Measurable and trackable results
10. Weaknesses of ‘social media fundraising’
• A tool more for raising
awareness and engagement in
vision rather than fundraising
11. Weaknesses of ‘social media fundraising’
• A tool more for raising awareness
and engagement in vision rather
than fundraising
• ‘Slacktivism’
Describes "feel-good" measures, in
support of an issue or social cause,
that have little or no practical
effect other than to make the
person doing it feel satisfaction
12. Weaknesses of ‘social media fundraising’
• A tool more for raising awareness
and engagement in vision rather
than fundraising
• ‘Slacktivism’
• Drop in the ocean compared to
other fundraising methods
13. Weaknesses of ‘social media fundraising’
• A tool more for raising awareness
and engagement in vision rather
than fundraising
• ‘Slacktivism’
• Drop in the ocean compared to
other fundraising methods
• Not sustainable
14. Weaknesses of ‘social media fundraising’
• A tool more for raising awareness
and engagement in vision rather
than fundraising
• ‘Slacktivism’
• Drop in the ocean compared to
other fundraising methods
• Not sustainable
• Direct donation platforms still in
its infancy
15. Case study: DEC Haiti earthquake appeal
(DEC) is made up of 13
member agencies who
provide humanitarian
aid in times of disaster.
For their Haiti earthquake appeal, the DEC has adopted
newer fundraising techniques using social media.
17. Within few days of the launch
• Flickr account attracted • YouTube video of the DEC
34,000 views of images broadcast appeal attracted
from the DEC’s member nearly 3,000 views
agencies
18. Two weeks after appeal launch
• Website traffic reached
over 250,000 per day, hits
jump by 25,000%
• Facebook fans increase
from 800 to over 15,000
• Twitter followers increase
from 400 to 2,500,
influence ranked in the top
0.10% of users
19. DEC Twitter/Text campaign
• Mobile text donation
method publicised
on Twitter
• Text campaign goes
viral – retweets
from public figures,
celebrities and
other supporters
20. DEC Twitter/Text campaign
• Keep followers
updated with
members’ work –
remind people why
they should support
the appeal
• Answers questions
about the aid
process – reduces
negative
perceptions
preventing people
from donating
21. DEC Twitter/Text campaign
• DEC appeal inspires supporters
to be creative with Twitter
fundraising initiatives
• Direct traffic to TV and other social media
channels to reinforce the appeal message
22. Facebook
• Important source of information – donation methods, press
releases, links to video updates
• Provides supporters a platform for their own fundraising initiatives
23. Results from Twitter/Text campaign
• After the announcement on
Twitter, the appeal raised
its first £8m. This was before
the televised appeal or
availability of text donation
• People texting ‘GIVE’ to
70077 has so far raised over
£161,000 despite being
promoted almost exclusively
on Twitter – no mention of
mobile donation method in
televised appeal
24. Lessons from DEC Haiti earthquake appeal
• Mobile donation integrated with social media promotion
gets round social media’s direct donation issues
• When online communities are empowered to make a real
difference, it is no longer a case of slacktivism
• Haiti appeal shows that social media can be a feasible
fundraising channel
• Funds raised through social media still a drop in the ocean,
but Haiti appeal indicates trend or at least potential for
impact to be much bigger in future emergency appeals
• Sustainable? Only time will tell
25. Other musings
• Immediacy of social media similar to the nature of
emergency appeals, making these channels
appropriate for emergency fundraising
• Social media channels are platforms for viral
communication, but not every tweet or status update is
passed along or acted on - message has to resonate
with people first
• While measurable, it is still difficult to predict results of
call-to-action requests on social media
• Results can surprise and amaze you
26. A few questions to ponder over
• Would the same lessons from DEC Haiti earthquake
appeal apply to non-emergency appeals?
• What other strengths and weaknesses are there in
using social media channels to raise funds for good
causes?
• Which benchmarks are best to gauge whether or not
social media channels make good fundraising tools?
Hinweis der Redaktion
Social networking – The EconomistSocialnomicsDonations – CAF Disaster Monitor Donations via online and text are steadily growing in popularityhttp://www.facebook.com/press/info.php?statistics
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_media
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/Personal thoughts: Updates in real time – channels conducive for immediate and current updates, just like the nature of the emergencyEasy for users to spread messages quickly – potential to go viral
Cost-effective (online methods) in comparison to traditional fundraising methods – SOS Children’s VillagesAddition to other offline and online fundraising methods - Scattergun approach by British Red Cross, Save the ChildrenSocial media makes it easier for charities to communicate directly with supporters – charities already using it to engage with supporters, why not use it to raise funds?http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Demographic –alternative way of reaching the intended audience, or audiences that see new media as a way of life, don’t necessarily use traditional broadcast media – Gen Y, Net-Gen)http://nonprofit.about.com/od/fundraising/a/wiredyoung.htmhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/919098/Charity-fundraisers-must-prepare-Generation-C/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH Already used as a platform to promote good causes (Facebook causes, Twibbons - #charitytuesday)http://mashable.com/2010/01/20/twibbon-one-million/(insert Twibbon tweets and #charitytuesday examples)Measurable and trackable results as evidence (Facebook causes, bespoke links created from URL shorteners - eg. Bit.ly)http://exchange.causes.com/2010/01/20-million-donated/
A tool more for connecting and communicating, raising awareness and engagement in vision rather than fundraising(Success judged in terms of engagement with supporters through marcomms more so than fundraising)http://afine2.wordpress.com/2009/04/27/social-media-glass-half-full-or-half-empty/http://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Slacktivism – Twibbons, Facebook causes (do good as long as you don’t have to get out of your chair)Call to action (easy to get a RT, more difficult to get the same people to open their wallets)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SlacktivismDrop in the ocean compared to other forms of fundraising – eg. Televised appeals (Action Aid expects to raise more money from DM campaign than online http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH)CAF Disaster Monitor – traditional comms methods most likely to motivate people to give, cash giving declining in popularity but still most frequently usedNot sustainable – donor fatigue? More one time gifts than regular oneshttp://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Direct donation platforms still at its infancyFacebook (credit card payment, but only available for US/Canada registered charities) http://apps.facebook.com/causes/aboutTwitter apps raises awareness, but need tedious extra step for funds to reach charities.Also only available for US charities – no GiftAid. Twonate – can use different platforms to tweet your donation or even add a Twonate button on your website/blog, but you must sign in to use Paypal to pay for your donations after tweeting about it. Twollars – generic Twitter currency, each starts with 50 Twollars but can only be converted to real funds for charities when someone buys the Twollars from the charities that were given Twollars by other users http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/blog/2009/may/27/twollars-twitter-currency-charity
A tool more for connecting and communicating, raising awareness and engagement in vision rather than fundraising(Success judged in terms of engagement with supporters through marcomms more so than fundraising)http://afine2.wordpress.com/2009/04/27/social-media-glass-half-full-or-half-empty/http://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Slacktivism – Twibbons, Facebook causes (do good as long as you don’t have to get out of your chair)Call to action (easy to get a RT, more difficult to get the same people to open their wallets)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SlacktivismDrop in the ocean compared to other forms of fundraising – eg. Televised appeals (Action Aid expects to raise more money from DM campaign than online http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH)CAF Disaster Monitor – traditional comms methods most likely to motivate people to give, cash giving declining in popularity but still most frequently usedNot sustainable – donor fatigue? More one time gifts than regular oneshttp://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Direct donation platforms still at its infancyFacebook (credit card payment, but only available for US/Canada registered charities) http://apps.facebook.com/causes/aboutTwitter apps raises awareness, but need tedious extra step for funds to reach charities.Also only available for US charities – no GiftAid. Twonate – can use different platforms to tweet your donation or even add a Twonate button on your website/blog, but you must sign in to use Paypal to pay for your donations after tweeting about it. Twollars – generic Twitter currency, each starts with 50 Twollars but can only be converted to real funds for charities when someone buys the Twollars from the charities that were given Twollars by other users http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/blog/2009/may/27/twollars-twitter-currency-charity
A tool more for connecting and communicating, raising awareness and engagement in vision rather than fundraising(Success judged in terms of engagement with supporters through marcomms more so than fundraising)http://afine2.wordpress.com/2009/04/27/social-media-glass-half-full-or-half-empty/http://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Slacktivism – Twibbons, Facebook causes (do good as long as you don’t have to get out of your chair)Call to action (easy to get a RT, more difficult to get the same people to open their wallets)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SlacktivismDrop in the ocean compared to other forms of fundraising – eg. Televised appeals (Action Aid expects to raise more money from DM campaign than online http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH)CAF Disaster Monitor – traditional comms methods most likely to motivate people to give, cash giving declining in popularity but still most frequently usedNot sustainable – donor fatigue? More one time gifts than regular oneshttp://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Direct donation platforms still at its infancyFacebook (credit card payment, but only available for US/Canada registered charities) http://apps.facebook.com/causes/aboutTwitter apps raises awareness, but need tedious extra step for funds to reach charities.Also only available for US charities – no GiftAid. Twonate – can use different platforms to tweet your donation or even add a Twonate button on your website/blog, but you must sign in to use Paypal to pay for your donations after tweeting about it. Twollars – generic Twitter currency, each starts with 50 Twollars but can only be converted to real funds for charities when someone buys the Twollars from the charities that were given Twollars by other users http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/blog/2009/may/27/twollars-twitter-currency-charity
A tool more for connecting and communicating, raising awareness and engagement in vision rather than fundraising(Success judged in terms of engagement with supporters through marcomms more so than fundraising)http://afine2.wordpress.com/2009/04/27/social-media-glass-half-full-or-half-empty/http://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Slacktivism – Twibbons, Facebook causes (do good as long as you don’t have to get out of your chair)Call to action (easy to get a RT, more difficult to get the same people to open their wallets)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SlacktivismDrop in the ocean compared to other forms of fundraising – eg. Televised appeals (Action Aid expects to raise more money from DM campaign than online http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH)CAF Disaster Monitor – traditional comms methods most likely to motivate people to give, cash giving declining in popularity but still most frequently usedNot sustainable – donor fatigue? More one time gifts than regular oneshttp://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Direct donation platforms still at its infancyFacebook (credit card payment, but only available for US/Canada registered charities) http://apps.facebook.com/causes/aboutTwitter apps raises awareness, but need tedious extra step for funds to reach charities.Also only available for US charities – no GiftAid. Twonate – can use different platforms to tweet your donation or even add a Twonate button on your website/blog, but you must sign in to use Paypal to pay for your donations after tweeting about it. Twollars – generic Twitter currency, each starts with 50 Twollars but can only be converted to real funds for charities when someone buys the Twollars from the charities that were given Twollars by other users http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/blog/2009/may/27/twollars-twitter-currency-charity
A tool more for connecting and communicating, raising awareness and engagement in vision rather than fundraising(Success judged in terms of engagement with supporters through marcomms more so than fundraising)http://afine2.wordpress.com/2009/04/27/social-media-glass-half-full-or-half-empty/http://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Slacktivism – Twibbons, Facebook causes (do good as long as you don’t have to get out of your chair)Call to action (easy to get a RT, more difficult to get the same people to open their wallets)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SlacktivismDrop in the ocean compared to other forms of fundraising – eg. Televised appeals (Action Aid expects to raise more money from DM campaign than online http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH)CAF Disaster Monitor – traditional comms methods most likely to motivate people to give, cash giving declining in popularity but still most frequently usedNot sustainable – donor fatigue? More one time gifts than regular oneshttp://hildygottlieb.com/2009/02/08/social-media-fundraising-unsustainable-scarcity-based-begging/ Direct donation platforms still at its infancyFacebook (credit card payment, but only available for US/Canada registered charities) http://apps.facebook.com/causes/aboutTwitter apps raises awareness, but need tedious extra step for funds to reach charities.Also only available for US charities – no GiftAid. Twonate – can use different platforms to tweet your donation or even add a Twonate button on your website/blog, but you must sign in to use Paypal to pay for your donations after tweeting about it. Twollars – generic Twitter currency, each starts with 50 Twollars but can only be converted to real funds for charities when someone buys the Twollars from the charities that were given Twollars by other users http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/blog/2009/may/27/twollars-twitter-currency-charity
http://www.dec.org.uk/who_we_are/dec_members.htmlhttp://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/979232/Charities-adopt-new-methods-emergency-fundraising/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCHThe DEC itself appears to be shifting towards newer fundraising techniques. Kath Hindley, its deputy chief executive, says online donations made up £14m of the £25m it raised in the first five days. She says £8m was raised online after an announcement on Twitter before the TV appeal began.
http://www.thirdsector.co.uk/news/archive/978348/DEC-Haiti-earthquake-appeal-brings-25m/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCHThe appeal raised its first £8m after the committee announced the start of the appeal on Twitter. At 7.41pm on Wednesday (13 January), the DEC sent a message to its followers on the social networking site saying: "You're the first to know - DEC #Haiti Earthquake Appeal now live, UK broadcast appeals to follow."The opening of the appeal was followed at midnight on Thursday by the 'period of joint action', during which DEC member charities are obliged to offer donors the chance to donate to the DEC instead of directly to the charities.http://twitter.com/decappeal/status/7719398952
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Disasters-Emergency-Committee-DEC/33268280976?v=wall#!/note.php?note_id=277029712621Within a few day of their fundraising appeal:Flickr account attracted 34,000 views of images from the DEC’s member agenciesYouTube video of the DEC broadcast appeal attracted nearly 3,000 viewshttp://www.flickr.com/photos/disastersemergencycommittee/
http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=258530142621In two weeks since their fundraising appeal was made public:Website traffic reached over 250,000 per day hits jump by 25,000% (traffic change between 28 December 2009 and 27 January 2010)Facebook fans increase from 800 to over 15,000Twitter followers increase from 400 to 2,500 influence to be ranked in the top 0.10% of users (retweetrank.com)
Viral – celebrities and other supporters RT GIVE 70077 tweet, answers questions raised by followers – reassure help is reaching Haiti
Viral – celebrities and other supporters RT GIVE 70077 tweet, answers questions raised by followers – reassure help is reaching Haiti
After the announcement on Twitter, the appeal raised its first £8m. http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=258530142621Social media presence has long been regarded by many fundraisers as difficult for charities to directly monetise but people texting ‘GIVE’ to 70077 has so far raised over £161,000 despite being promoted almost exclusively on twitter. With a staggering £60m raised for the DEC Haiti Earthquake Appeal to date and almost half the people in the UK having donated.