Unleash Your Potential - Namagunga Girls Coding Club
linc-HOXA1 is a non-coding RNA that represses Hoxa1 in cis
1. linc-HOXA1 is a non-coding RNA that represses
Hoxa1 transcription in cis
Hédia Maamar1, Moran Cabili2, John Rinn2, Arjun Raj1
1University of Pennsylvania
2Harvard University and Broad Institute
Genes and Development, in press (2013)
Hédia Maamar
2. Xist is a non-coding RNA that regulates
transcription across an entire chromosome
Xist RNA
3. Hybridization of multiple oligonucleotides yields
fluorescent spots corresponding to single RNAs
Target mRNATarget mRNA
Multiple singly-labeled DNA
oligonucleotides, 20 bases each
Raj et al. Nature Methods, 2008
RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization
(RNA FISH)
Femino et al. Science 1998
4. The Hox clusters harbor several non-coding RNAs
phenomena, polycistronism and antisense transcription.
Polycistronic clusters
A polycistronic cluster designates two or more genes co-
transcribed from a single promoter, sharing a non-coding exon,
and whose products are generated by alternative splicing [18]. An
operon is a particular case where the mRNA retains the different
products after splicing. In Mammals, both operons and
polycistronic clusters are scarcely documented [18]. One clear
example nonetheless, is the case of the Hoxc4, Hoxc5 and Hoxc6
Widespread antisense transcription
Our analysis also revealed the existence of 15 TUs distinct from
the Hox and mir genes that are poly-adenylated and alternatively
spliced like genuine products of RNA Polymerase II. Most of these
TUs (14/15) are transcribed antisense (AS) to Hox genes (see fig 2),
and AS transcription can represent up to 38% of the spliced
transcripts (38.46% for HoxA, 33.11% for HoxB, 13.16% for
HoxC and 34.84% for HoxD). Cis-encoded antisenses and
bidirectional promoters are now known to be abundant in the
Figure 2. Synopsis of transcriptional activity in the Human Hox Clusters. Sense and antisense transcriptions are in red and green respectively. Dark
and light shaded boxes represent exon and intron. Mir genes are in blue. The three long transcripts presenting a murine homolog with a conserved
exon-exon boundary are headed by **. The 13 TUs (12 antisense and one sense) located at similar position in human and mouse are denoted by an
asterisk (*) while the 10 TUs showing conservation are depicted with
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0000356.g002
Rinn et al. Cell 2007
Mainguy et al. PLOS ONE 2007
5. linc-HOXA1 is a lincRNA expressed in mouse ES
cells located near Hoxa1
exon
3c
exon
3b
exon
3a
exon 1 exon 2
Chr6
11.5 kb90 kb 41 kb 3 kb
Isoform 1
Isoform 2
Isoform 3
Skap2 Hoxa1 Hoxa2 Hoxa3linc-HOXA1
6. There are three isoforms of linc-HOXA1 in mouse
embryonic stem cells
exon
3c
exon
3b
exon
3a
exon 1 exon 2
Isoform 1
Isoform 2
Isoform 3
Isoform 1
Isoform 2
Isoform 3
exon 3c exon 3b exon 3a
linc-HOXA1
7. Expression of the three isoforms of linc-HOXA1
was highly correlated in single cells
exon
3c
exon
3b
exon
3a
exon 1 exon 2
Isoform 1
Isoform 2
Isoform 3
Isoform 1
Isoform 2
Isoform 3
exon 3c exon 3b exon 3a
linc-HOXA1
120
120
90
90
60
60
E3a molecules per cell
E3bmoleculespercell
E3cmoleculespercell
E3cmoleculespercell30
30
0
0 1209060
E3a molecules per cell
300 1209060
E3b molecules per cell
300
y = ax + b
a = 1.296 [1.084, 1.507]
b = 4.893 [2.568, 7.219]
y = ax + b
a = 2.031 [1.750, 2.312]
b = 9.202 [6.112, 12.29]
y = ax + b
a = 1.253 [1.095, 1.411]
b = 6.652 [3.552, 9.753]
8. linc-HOXA1 and Hoxa1 transcripts both express in
mouse embryonic stem cells
MeannumberofRNApercell
A B
linc-HOXA1
linc-HOXA1
transcription siteHoxa1
9. linc-HOXA1 appears to correlate with Hoxa1 at the
population level
0
0 654321
20
linc-HOXA1
Hoxa1
40
Number of days of retinoic acid expos
0 days retinoic
acid exposure
1 day retinoic
acid exposure
2 da
acid
MeannumberofRNApercell
180 180
A
C
B
linc-HOXA1
linc-HOXA1
transcription siteHoxa1
Threshold
0
0 9654321
20
linc-HOXA1
Hoxa1
40
Number of days of retinoic acid exposure
0 days retinoic
acid exposure
1 day retinoic
acid exposure
2 days retinoic
acid exposure
MeannumberofRNApercell
40
60
120
180
120
180
Hoxa1mRNA
A
C
B
linc-HOXA1
linc-HOXA1
transcription siteHoxa1
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
125
26
127
35
n = 313, p = 0.33
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
26
107
1
101
n = 235, p = 10-5
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
254
56
43
1
n = 354, p = 0.007
Threshold
10. But linc-HOXA1 and Hoxa1 RNA anti-correlate at
the single cell level
0
0 40 80 120
linc-HOXA1 RNA
0 days retinoic
acid exposure
1 day retino
acid exposu
0 40
linc-HOXA1 R
Mean
0
20
40
60
0
60
120
180
Hoxa1mRNA
C
n
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
26
107
1
101
n = 235, p = 10-5
Threshold
Threshold
11. Treatment with retinoic acid eliminates this anti-
correlation
0
0 9654321
20
Hoxa1
Number of days of retinoic acid exposure
0 40 80 120
linc-HOXA1 RNA
0 days retinoic
acid exposure
1 day retinoic
acid exposure
2 days retinoic
acid exposure
0 40 80 120
linc-HOXA1 RNA
0 40 80 120
linc-HOXA1 RNA
MeannumberofRNAp0
20
40
60
0
60
120
180
0
60
120
180
Hoxa1mRNA
C
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
125
26
127
35
n = 313, p = 0.33
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
26
107
1
101
n = 235, p = 10-5
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
254
56
43
1
n = 354, p = 0.0077
Threshold
Threshold
12. We successfully knocked down linc-HOXA1 with
both Isis anti-sense oligonucleotides and siRNA
NumberofRNAmoleculespercell
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
12
16
Isis knockdown siRNA knockdown
linc-HOXA1
knockdown
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
8
4
0
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
13. But only the antisense oligonucleotides showed an
effect on Hoxa1... why?
NumberofRNAmoleculespercell
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
12
16
Isis knockdown siRNA knockdown
linc-HOXA1
knockdown
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
8
4
0
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
14. We looked to changes to transcription sites after
linc-HOXA1 knockdown
linc-HOXA1
transcription site
15. Direct transcript visualization reveals that linc-
HOXA1 regulates Hoxa1 at the site of transcriptionSupplementary Figure 5
DAPI
Control (scramble knockdown) linc-HOXA1 knockdown
siRNAIsisanti-senseoligonucleotides
DAPIlinc-HOXA1 exon linc-HOXA1 exon
16. Direct transcript visualization reveals that linc-
HOXA1 regulates Hoxa1 at the site of transcriptionSupplementary Figure 5
DAPI
Control (scramble knockdown) linc-HOXA1 knockdown
siRNAIsisanti-senseoligonucleotides
DAPIlinc-HOXA1 exon linc-HOXA1 exon
17. Transcription site knockdown accounts for the
discrepancy between knockdown methods
NumberofRNAmoleculespercell
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
12
16
Isis knockdown siRNA knockdown
linc-HOXA1
knockdown
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
8
4
0
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
18. Transcription site knockdown accounts for the
discrepancy between knockdown methods
NumberofRNAmoleculespercell
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
n
12
16
Isis knockdown siRNA knockdown
linc-HOXA1
knockdown
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
8
4
0
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1
Number of active
transcription
sites per cell
Number of active
transcription
sites per cell
0.4
0.2
0
0.2
0
19. Over-expression of linc-HOXA1 did not affect
Hoxa1 expression levels
40
linc-HOXA1 isoforms Hoxa1 mRNA
Numberoflinc-HOXA1
RNAmolecules
60
20
0
NumberofHoxa1
mRNAmolecules
20
10
0
G
FP
(control)
Isoform
1
Isoform
2Isoform
3
G
FP
(control)
Isoform
1
Isoform
2Isoform
3
20. Over-expression of linc-HOXA1 did not affect
Hoxa1 expression levels
Hoxa1mRNAmolecules
Isoform 1
0 150 300
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
17
64
15
58
n = 154, p = 0.95
Isoform 2
0 150 300
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
8
40
19
77
n = 144, p = 0.65
linc-HOXA1 RNA molecules linc-HOXA1 RNA molecules linc-HOXA1 RNA molecules linc-HOXA1 RNA molecules
Isoform 3
0 150 300
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
7
24
21
92
n = 144, p = 0.62
40
80
0
GFP (control)
0 30 60
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
26
112
6
9
n = 153, p = 0.055
Threshold
21. We pulled down proteins associated with linc-
HOXA1 and analyzed by mass-spectrometry
Biotinylated RNA
PAGE Mass
spectrometry
Cell lysate
22. We pulled down proteins associated with linc-
HOXA1 and analyzed by mass-spectrometry
Biotinylated RNA
PAGE Mass
spectrometry
Cell lysate
exon3c
anti-sense
exon3c
sense
exon3a,b
anti-sense
exon3a,b
sense
exon3a
sense
30
40
50
80
PURB
(mass-spectrometry)
exon
3c
exon
3b
exon
3a
exon 1 exon 2
linc-HOXA1 GAA-rich region
23. We pulled down PURB (with a Myc tag) and looked
for linc-HOXA1 RNA by RT-PCR
anti-Myc
PURB-Myc
RT-PCR
500 bp
W
ater(negative
control)
TotallysateIgG
R
N
A
pulldow
n
M
YC
R
N
A
pulldow
n
200 bp
24. Knocking down PURB increased Hoxa1 levels and
got rid of the anti-correlationNumberofRNAmoleculespercell
Purb siRNA
knockdown
linc-HOXA1 Hoxa1Purb
15
25
20
10
5
0
controlknockdow
n
controlknockdow
ncontrolknockdow
n
Purb siRNA
knockdown
0 60
Threshold
120
linc-HOXA1 RNA
0
20
40
60
Hoxa1mRNA
Hoxa1
linc-HOXA1
12
3
23
6
n = 44, p = 0.96
25. What lessons does linc-HOXA1 hold for lincRNA
function?
linc-HOXA1
transcription site