1. Regionalism, Ethnicity, And Trifurcation: All In The Name Of National Integrity 18/04/11 6:09 AM
Printer Friendly Version
Home
Regionalism, Ethnicity, And Trifurcation:
All In The Name Of National Integrity
By Dr. Nyla Ali Khan
15 April, 2011
Countercurrents.org
Why Subscribe ?
The question relevant to my purposes here is that is the “executive order,” not “bill”
Popularise CC
permitting the issuance of Dogra certificates to the Dogras, Hindu and Muslim, of
Join News Letter
Jammu province along the lines of Sir Owen Dixon’s proposition of the trifurcation of the
Editor's Picks
State along religious and communal lines? Why is this vestige of British colonialism still
Press Releases given legitimacy? The Dogra Certificate was initiated by the British colonial government
Action Alert to facilitate the recruitment of the Dogra royals into the armed forces? Who does it apply
Feed Burner to now that Indian royals have been incorporated into the citizenry? Why do the young
Read CC In Your people of Jammu require certificates proclaiming their allegiance to one particular
Own Language
province of J & K and one ethnicity in order to be eligible for recruitment into the
Bradley Manning Indian Central Reserve Forces? Now that the concerned Tehsildar has the power, vested
India Burning in him by the State, to issue such certificates to “to eligible desirous persons irrespective
Mumbai Terror of his/ her ethnicity, religion, cultural background and mother-tongue,” is the pluralistic
Financial Crisis
and diverse population of J & K going to go through systemic homogenization or
systemic divisions?
Iraq
AfPak War I quickly attempt to connect Sir Own Dixon’s proposition of the trifurcation of J & K
Peak Oil with the controversial Dogra certificates. In the interests of expediency, the UNCIP
Globalisation
appointed a single mediator, Sir Owen Dixon, the United Nations representative for
India and Pakistan, Australian jurist and wartime ambassador to the United States, to
Localism
efficiently resolve the Kashmir conflict. Dixon noted, in 1950, that the Kashmir issue was
Alternative Energy
so tumultuous because Kashmir was not a holistic geographic, economic, or demographic
Climate Change
entity, but, on the contrary, an aggregate of diverse territories brought under the rule of
US Imperialism one maharaja. In a further attempt to resolve the conflict, Sir Owen Dixon propounded
US Elections the trifurcation of the state along communal or regional lines, or facilitating the
Palestine secession of parts of the Jhelum Valley to Pakistan.
Latin America
Despite the bombastic statements and blustering of the governments of both India and
Communalism
Pakistan, however, the Indian government has all along perceived the inclusion of
Gender/Feminism Pakistani-administered J & K and the Northern Areas into India as unfeasible. Likewise,
Dalit the government of Pakistan has all along either implicitly or explicitly acknowledged the
Humanrights impracticality of including the predominantly Buddhist Ladakh and predominantly
Economy Hindu Jammu as part of Pakistan. The coveted area that continues to generate
irreconcilable differences between the two governments is the Valley of Kashmir. Dixon
India-pakistan
lamented:
Kashmir
Environment “None of these suggestions commended themselves to the Prime Minister of India. In the
http://countercurrents.org/alikhan150411.htm Page 1 of 4

2. Regionalism, Ethnicity, And Trifurcation: All In The Name Of National Integrity 18/04/11 6:09 AM
Book Review end, I became convinced that India’s agreement would never be obtained to
demilitarization in any such form, or to provisions governing the period of the plebiscite
Gujarat Pogrom
of any such character, as would in my opinion permit the plebiscite being conducted in
Kandhamal Violence
conditions sufficiently guarding against intimidation and other forms of influence and
WSF
abuse by which the freedom and fairness of the plebiscite might be imperiled.” (The
Arts/Culture Statesman, 15 September 1950)
India Elections
Sir Owen Dixon nonetheless remained determined to formulate a viable solution to the
Archives
Kashmir issue and suggested that a plebiscite be held only in the Kashmir Valley
Links
subsequent to its demilitarization, which would be conducted by an administrative body
Submission Policy
of UN officials. This proposal was rejected by Pakistan, which, however, reluctantly
About CC agreed to Sir Dixon’s further suggestion that the prime ministers of the two countries
Disclaimer meet with him to discuss the viability of various solutions to the Kashmir dispute. But
Fair Use Notice India decried this suggestion. A defeated man, Sir Dixon finally left the Indian
subcontinent on 23 August 1950. There seemed to be an inexplicable reluctance on both
Contact Us
sides, India and Pakistan, to solve the Kashmir dispute diplomatically and amicably. Sir
Search Our Archive
Dixon’s concluding recommendation was a bilateral resolution of the dispute with India
Subscribe To Our
News Letter and Pakistan as the responsible parties, without taking into account the ability of the
Kashmiri people to determine their own political future. Is this the anachronistic policy
Site Search being toed by the governments of India and Pakistan in 2011?
Our Site
Unlike the generation of Kashmiris that grew up in the 1940s and 1950s, the innocence
Web
of the generation that grew up in the 1990s and 2000s in J & K was cruelly ripped by the
forces of armed insurgency and counter insurgency; the romanticized image of Kashmir
Name:
fails to hold a lasting appeal for these children of an internecine war; the sense of peace
E-mail: and security historically provided by a democratically elected government has eluded
these denizens of a paranoid State; the machinations of electoral politics, including the
Subscribe
Unsubscribe
issuance of Dogra certificates, have vitiated the sociopolitical fabric; this post-lapsarian
generation has never known the allure of a political edifice built on a well-defined
Find us on ideology; it has been bereft of a nationalist and political discourse within which it could
Facebook
blossom; its scarred psyche is yet to be healed. In a democratic set-up, however flawed it
might be, the will and aspirations of the electorate are ignored by politicians at their own
peril. The youth in J & K clamors for democratic rights, efficient governance, a stable
Countercurrents.org
infrastructure, a much less fractious polity, which the coalition government is yet to
Like
provide.
4,906 people like
Countercurrents.org.
I would posit that for the masses of J & K, not the handful of missionary-school
educated, English speaking professionals, the coalition government lacks a
Mohammas Goldy representative character and richness of appeal. The electoral principal is discussion, not
autocratic decisions. Once the successors of popular leaders, who established their
credibility through ideology, conviction, perseverance, and working for the well-being of
Jl Jackie
their electorate, become complacent and rule with carte blanche, electoral politics
become defiled. The prominent cult of personality and deification of leaders in
mainstream political organizations in South Asia thwarts the rise of new leaders from the
Manish Preety
Facebook social plugin
ranks, thereby increasing the dependence of the party cadre on a “dynasty.” Much to the
chagrin of those of us who have idealistic notions of democracy, in addition to the
http://countercurrents.org/alikhan150411.htm Page 2 of 4

3. Regionalism, Ethnicity, And Trifurcation: All In The Name Of National Integrity 18/04/11 6:09 AM
killings of non-partisan civilians, the non-elite cadres of the National Conference, the
Congress, and the People’s Democratic Party are still unprotected and vulnerable, as the
recent killings of Farooq Ahmed Sheikh of Koil Pulwama and Ghulam Hassan Dar of
Hajin Bandipora, Ghulam Mohiuddin Bhat of Tral, and Moulvi Showkat Ahmed Shah,
Jamiat-e-Ahli Hadith clearly show.
The political bigwigs in J & K have not been able to create either conceptual frameworks
or political and sociocultural discourses in which the young people of today would be
energized and persuaded to actively participate. The current regime has been unable to
revive, let alone reinvigorate, civil society institutions that could initiate uncoerced
collective action around shared interests, values, and purposes. For those of us who have
learned to respect the strident potency of the voice of the people, the unequivocal and
pitiful assumption of mainstream politicians in J & K that power unilaterally flows from
New Delhi reeks of a reprehensibly unrepresentative character. I underscore that
Kashmir today is split into two nations, the plutocracy and the plebeians, with a
lackadaisical middleclass between the two, which lack ideological unifiers across class
and other social divides, and icons of national unity in the face of political and military
oppression.
Nyla Ali Khan is the author of The Fiction of Nationality in an Era of Transnationalism
(New York: Routlege, 2005) and Islam, Women, and Violence in Kashmir (New York:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2010). She is alsoa a Visiting Professor, Department of English ,
University of Oklahoma
0
Share
Comments are not moderated. Please be responsible and civil in your postings and stay
within the topic discussed in the article too. If you find inappropriate comments, just
Flag (Report) them and they will move into moderation que.
Comments
Logged in as Sandeep Mahajan Dashboard | Edit profile | Logout
There are no comments posted yet. Be the first one!
Post a new comment Check Spelling
Enter text right here!
Posting as Sandeep Mahajan (Logout)
http://countercurrents.org/alikhan150411.htm Page 3 of 4

4. Regionalism, Ethnicity, And Trifurcation: All In The Name Of National Integrity 18/04/11 6:09 AM
Subscribe to Replies Submit Comment
Comments by
ShareThis
http://countercurrents.org/alikhan150411.htm Page 4 of 4