SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 5
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Novel approaches to the management of disseminated
intravascular coagulation
Marcel Levi, MD; Evert de Jonge, MD; Tom van der Poll, MD; Hugo ten Cate, MD


   Objective: Disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) is a                  C–protein S system. Also, impaired fibrin degradation, because of
syndrome characterized by systemic intravascular activation of                   high circulating levels of plasminogen activator inhibitor, type 1,
coagulation, leading to widespread deposition of fibrin in the                    contributes to enhanced intravascular fibrin deposition.
circulation. We addressed the issue of whether there is evidence                     Conclusions: Although the cornerstone of DIC management is
that this fibrin deposition contributes to multiple organ failure. We             the specific and vigorous treatment of the underlying disorder,
also explored the current knowledge on the pathogenesis of DIC                   strategies aimed at inhibiting coagulation activation may theoret-
and reviewed current and future treatment for DIC.                               ically be justified. Such strategies have been found to be benefi-
   Data Sources: We searched and reviewed published articles on                  cial in experimental and initial clinical studies. These strategies,
experimental studies of DIC models in animals and clinical studies               which follow from our current understanding of the pathophysi-
in patients with DIC.                                                            ology of DIC, involve inhibition of tissue factor-mediated activa-
   Data Synthesis: There is ample experimental and clinical evi-                 tion of coagulation or restoration of physiologic anticoagulant
dence that DIC contributes to morbidity and mortality. Recent                    pathways by means of the administration of antithrombin con-
knowledge on important pathogenetic mechanisms that may lead                     centrate or (activated) protein C concentrate. Although no com-
to DIC has resulted in novel preventive and therapeutic ap-                      plete evidence from controlled clinical trials is available for most
proaches to patients with DIC. Although the trigger for the acti-                of the proposed therapeutic interventions, these novel strategies
vation of the coagulation system may vary depending on the                       are being studied. (Crit Care Med 2000; 28[Suppl.]:S20 –S24)
underlying condition, it is usually mediated by several cytokines.                   KEY WORDS: disseminated intravascular; sepsis; cytokines; co-
Thrombin generation proceeds via the (extrinsic) tissue factor/                  agulation; fibrinolysis; antithrombin III; protein C; tissue factor;
factor VIIa route and simultaneously occurring depression of                     tissue factor pathway inhibitor
inhibitory mechanisms, such as antithrombin III and the protein




D            isseminated intravascular co-                 which may lead to thrombotic occlusion       may be accompanied by secondary fibrino-
             agulation (DIC) is not a dis-                 of small and midsize vessels. This situa-    lysis or inhibited fibrinolysis.”
             ease or a symptom but a syn-                  tion may compromise blood supply to              Clinical Conditions Associated With
             drome that is always                          various organs and may, in conjunction       Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation.
secondary to an underlying disorder (1,                    with hemodynamic and metabolic de-           DIC may complicate a variety of clinical
2). DIC is characterized by widespread                     rangements, contribute to multiple or-       disorders. Bacterial infection, in particu-
activation of blood coagulation, resulting                 gan failure. Simultaneously, consump-        lar, severe sepsis, is the most common
in the intravascular formation of fibrin,                   tion and subsequent exhaustion of            entity associated with DIC (1, 3). In addi-
                                                           platelets and coagulation proteins be-       tion, systemic infections with any other
                                                           cause of the ongoing activation of coag-     microorganism, such as viruses and par-
                                                           ulation may induce severe bleeding com-      asites, may lead to DIC. A common patho-
     From the Department of Vascular Medicine (Drs.
Levi and ten Cate), Internal Medicine (Drs. Levi and van
                                                           plications. In fact, bleeding may be the     genetic feature of DIC that is the result of
der Poll), Intensive Care (Dr. de Jonge) and the Labo-     presenting symptom in a patient with         severe infection is the generalized inflam-
ratory of Experimental Medicine (Dr. van der Poll),        DIC. Hence, a patient with DIC can           matory response, characterized by the
Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam,          present with a simultaneously occurring      systemic release of cytokines (5).
the Netherlands; Department of Internal Medicine (Dr.
ten Cate), Slotervaart Hospital, Amsterdam, the Neth-
                                                           thrombotic and bleeding problem; this            Severe trauma is another clinical condi-
erlands.                                                   obviously complicates the choice of treat-   tion frequently associated with DIC (6, 7). A
     Presented, in part, at the Margaux Conference on      ment (3).                                    combination of mechanisms, including re-
Critical Illness, Margaux, France, November 11–13,            Although there is no general consensus    lease of tissue material in the circulation
1999.
     Adapted from the article “Disseminated intravas-
                                                           on the definition of DIC, the definition put   (fat, phospholipids), hemolysis, and endo-
cular coagulation: State-of-the-art” presented at the      forward by Muller-Berghaus et al. (4) in
                                                                          ¨                             thelial damage, may contribute to the sys-
XIVth Congress of the International Society of Throm-      1995 may be most appropriate: “Dissemi-      temic activation of coagulation (8). In par-
bosis and Hemostasis (ISTH), WA 1999 (Thromb               nated intravascular coagulation is an ac-    ticular, in head trauma patients, local
Haemostas 1999; 82:695–705) and “Disseminated
intravascular coagulation: Current concepts” (N Engl
                                                           quired syndrome characterized by the acti-   coagulation activation, and systemic coag-
J Med 1999; 341:586 –592).                                 vation of intravascular coagulation up to    ulation activation are detectable, which
     Copyright © 2000 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins     intravascular fibrin formation. The process   may be understandable in view of the rela-

S20                                                                                                          Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)
tively large amount of tissue factor in the    ders represent a distinct group of diseases      combination of consumption resulting
cerebral compartment.                          beyond the scope of this article.                from ongoing thrombin generation, deg-
    Both solid tumors and hematologic              Pathogenesis of Disseminated Intra-          radation by elastase released from acti-
malignancies may be complicated by DIC.        vascular Coagulation. In recent years,           vated neutrophils, and impaired synthe-
The mechanism of the derangement of            the mechanisms of the pathologic sys-            sis. Low antithrombin III levels in DIC
the coagulation system is poorly under-        temic fibrin deposition in DIC have be-           are associated with increased mortality
stood in this situation. However, most         come increasingly clear. Enhanced fibrin          (20). In addition to the decrease in anti-
studies implicate tissue factor, potentially   formation is caused by tissue factor-            thrombin III, a significant depression of
expressed on the surface of tumor cells,       mediated thrombin generation and si-             the protein C–protein S system may oc-
in this process (9). A distinct form of DIC    multaneously occurring dysfunction of            cur. In models of experimental endotox-
is frequently encountered in acute pro-        inhibitory mechanisms, such as the anti-         emia, down-regulation of thrombomodu-
myelocytic leukemia, which is character-       thrombin system and the protein C–pro-           lin has been demonstrated, resulting in
ized by a severe hyperfibrinolytic state on     tein S protein system. In addition to en-        diminished protein C activity, which may
top of an activated coagulation system         hanced fibrin formation, fibrin removal is         enhance the procoagulant state (21). Tis-
(10). Although clinical bleeding predom-       impaired because the fibrinolytic system          sue factor, the trigger of coagulation, is
inates in acute promyelocytic leukemia,        is depressed. This impairment of endog-          inhibited by tissue factor pathway inhib-
disseminated thrombosis is found in            enous thrombolysis is caused mainly by           itor (TFPI). Administration of recombi-
many patients at postmortem examina-           high circulating levels of plasminogen ac-       nant TFPI to healthy volunteers results in
tion.                                          tivator inhibitor, type 1. In a later stage of   complete inhibition of endotoxin-induced
    Acute DIC occurs in obstetrical calam-     DIC, fibrinolytic activity may be in-             thrombin generation (22). Moreover, in
ities such as placental abruption and am-      creased and contribute to bleeding. The          vivo experiments in lethal baboon models
niotic fluid emboli (11). Amniotic fluid         derangement of coagulation and fibrino-           indicate that TFPI is a potent inhibitor of
has been shown to activate coagulation in      lysis is mediated by several cytokines,          sepsis-related mortality. Whether this ef-
vitro, and the degree of placental separa-     particularly in DIC associated with infec-       fect results solely from impaired clotting
tion correlates with the extent of DIC,        tious disease but probably also in most          activity remains uncertain. In contrast to
suggesting that leakage of thromboplas-        other clinical conditions associated with        other coagulation inhibitors, acquired
tin-like material from the placental sys-      DIC.
                                                                                                deficiencies of TFPI have not been ob-
tem is responsible for DIC. The most               Activation of Blood Coagulation in
                                                                                                served, and DIC is generally associated
common obstetrical complication associ-        Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation.
                                                                                                with only modestly reduced levels, or
ated with activation of blood coagulation      In all experimental models, thrombin
                                                                                                even increased concentrations, of TFPI.
is eclampsia and the HELLP (hemolysis,         generation is detectable at 3–5 hrs after
                                                                                                    Experimental models indicate that at
elevated liver enzymes, and low platelets)     the infusion of microorganisms or endo-
                                                                                                the time of maximal activation of coagu-
syndrome (12). However, this complica-         toxin (14, 15). Several lines of evidence
                                                                                                lation, the fibrinolytic system is largely
tion is characterized by microangiopathic      point to the tissue factor/factor VIIa sys-
                                                                                                shut off. Experimental bacteremia and
hemolytic anemia with secondary                tem as pivotal in the initiation of throm-
changes in the coagulation system, a sit-      bin generation. First, experiments in hu-        endotoxemia result in a rapid increase in
uation that is related to, but clearly dis-    mans with endotoxemia or in humans               fibrinolytic activity, likely because of the
tinct from, DIC.                               infused with the proinflammatory cyto-            release of plasminogen activators from
    Vascular disorders, such as large aor-     kine tumor necrosis factor (TNF) did not         endothelial cells. This profibrinolytic re-
tic aneurysms or giant hemangiomas             show any change in markers for activa-           sponse is followed almost immediately by
(Kasabach-Merritt syndrome), may result        tion of the contact system (16). Similarly,      a suppression of fibrinolytic activity re-
in local activation of coagulation (13).       inhibition of the contact system did not         sulting from a sustained increase in
Activated coagulation factors can ulti-        prevent activation of coagulation in bac-        plasma levels of plasminogen activator
mately “overflow” to the systemic circu-        teremic baboons (17). Furthermore, ab-           inhibitor, type 1 (23).
lation and cause DIC, but the systemic         rogation of the tissue factor/factor VIIa            Cytokines. The derangement of coag-
depletion of coagulation factors and           pathway by monoclonal antibodies specif-         ulation and fibrinolysis is mediated by
platelets as a result of local consumption     ically directed against tissue factor or fac-    several proinflammatory cytokines, such
is more common. This may result in a           tor VIIa activity resulted in complete in-       as TNF- , interleukin (IL)-1, and IL-6.
clinical condition that is hardly distin-      hibition of thrombin generation in               The principal mediator of coagulation ac-
guishable from DIC.                            endotoxin-challenged chimpanzees and             tivation in DIC appears to be IL-6 (24).
    Microangiopathic hemolytic anemia          prevented DIC and mortality in baboons           TNF- indirectly influences the activa-
represents a group of disorders: throm-        that were infused with Escherichia coli          tion of coagulation because of its effects
bocytopenic thrombotic purpura, hemo-          (18, 19).                                        on IL-6, and TNF- is the pivotal media-
lytic uremic syndrome, chemotherapy-               Suppression of Physiologic Anticoag-         tor of the dysregulation of the physiologic
induced microangiopathic hemolytic             ulant Pathways and Impaired Fibrinoly-           anticoagulant pathways and the fibrino-
anemia, malignant hypertension, and the        sis. Impaired function of various natural        lytic defect (25). Anti-inflammatory cyto-
HELLP syndrome (12). Although some             regulating pathways of coagulation acti-         kines, such as IL-10, may modulate the
characteristics of microangiopathic he-        vation may contribute to fibrin forma-            activation of coagulation, as it was shown
molytic anemia and the resulting throm-        tion. Plasma levels of the most important        that administration of recombinant IL-10
botic occlusion of small and midsize ves-      inhibitor of thrombin, antithrombin III,         to humans completely abrogated the
sels leading to organ failure may mimic        are usually markedly reduced in septic           endotoxin-induced effects on coagulation
the clinical picture of DIC, these disor-      patients. This reduction is caused by a          (26).

Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)                                                                                             S21
Diagnosis of Disseminated Intravas-         sial. These controversies arise from the




                                                                                                I
cular Coagulation in Routine Clinical          lack of properly conducted clinical trials
Settings. There is no single test to accu-     on DIC treatment because of the com-                     t is well established
rately diagnose DIC in an individual pa-       plexity of DIC’s clinical presentation, its
                                                                                                        that the cornerstone
tient. However, a combination of a clini-      variable and unpredictable course, and its
cal condition that may be complicated by       either subtle or catastrophic clinical con-              of disseminated intra-
DIC with a number of laboratory results        sequences. Besides, the clinical picture of
will establish the presence of DIC with an     a patient with widespread thrombotic             vascular coagulation treat-
acceptable level of certainty. Some novel      deposition in small vessels of various or-
laboratory tests (such as assays for solu-     gans on the one hand and bleeding be-            ment is the specific and vig-
ble fibrin) will be available soon and may      cause of consumption and subsequent de-          orous treatment of the
help in the diagnosis; however, most of        pletion of platelets and coagulation
the newer tests are currently available in     factors on the other hand does not di-           underlying disorder. In some
specialized laboratories only. In these cir-   rectly guide the physician to specific
cumstances, a diagnosis of DIC may be          therapies. Despite these complicating cir-       cases, the disseminated in-
made by a combination of platelet count,       cumstances, it is well established that the
measurement of global clotting times           cornerstone of DIC treatment is the spe-
                                                                                                travascular coagulation will
(activated partial thromboplastin time         cific and vigorous treatment of the un-           completely resolve within
and prothrombin time), measurement of          derlying disorder. In some cases, the DIC
antithrombin III and/or one or two clot-       will completely resolve within hours after       hours after the resolution of
ting factors, and a test for fibrin degrada-    the resolution of the underlying condi-
tion products (2). It should be empha-         tion (for example, DIC induced by placen-        the underlying condition.
sized that serial coagulation tests are        tal abruption and amniotic fluid embo-
generally more helpful than single labo-       lism). In other cases (for example, DIC in
ratory results in establishing the diagno-     patients with sepsis and a systemic in-
sis of DIC. A reduction in the platelet        flammatory response syndrome), DIC             tients with DIC. However, a beneficial
count or a clear downward trend at sub-        may be present for a number of days,          effect of heparin on clinically important
sequent measurements is a sensitive (al-       even after proper treatment for the un-       outcome events in patients with DIC has
though not specific) sign of DIC. The           derlying condition has been initiated. In     never been demonstrated in controlled
prolongation of global clotting times may      these patients, supportive measures to        clinical trials (29, 30). Also, the safety of
reflect the consumption and depletion of        manage the DIC may be necessary.              heparin treatment is debatable in DIC
various coagulation factors, which may         Briefly, these interventions may consist       patients who are prone to bleeding. On
be further substantiated by the measure-       of plasma and platelet substitution ther-     the other hand, most patients with DIC
ment of one or two selected coagulation        apy, anticoagulant strategies, or adminis-    should receive adequate prophylaxis to
factors. However, the accuracy of one-         tration of physiologic coagulation inhib-     prevent venous thromboembolism (31);
stage clotting assays in patients with DIC     itors.                                        this may be achieved with low-dose hep-
has been contested.                                Plasma and Platelet Substitution          arin. In view of this, there is a case for
   Measurement of antithrombin III has         Therapy. Low levels of platelets and co-      administering subcutaneous heparin or
the additional advantage of specifically        agulation factors may increase the risk of    perhaps even intravenous low-dose hepa-
assessing the consumption of the most          bleeding. However, plasma or platelet         rin to patients with DIC. Higher doses of
important inhibitor of thrombin. Mea-          substitution therapy should not be insti-     heparin should be reserved for patients
surement of fibrinogen has often been           tuted on the basis of laboratory results      with clinically overt thromboembolism
advocated but, in fact, is usually not very    alone; such therapy is indicated only in      or extensive fibrin deposition, like pur-
helpful for diagnosing DIC. Fibrinogen         patients with active bleeding and in those    pura fulminans or acral ischemia (30).
acts as an acute-phase reactant, and de-       requiring an invasive procedure or other-         Theoretically, the most logical antico-
spite ongoing consumption, plasma lev-         wise at risk for bleeding complications       agulant to use in DIC is one directed
els can remain well within the normal          (27). The suggestion that administration      against tissue factor activity. Recently, a
range for a long period. In a consecutive      of blood components might add “fuel to        potent and specific inhibitor of the ter-
series of patients, the sensitivity of a low   the fire” has, in fact, never been proven in   nary complex between tissue factor/factor
fibrinogen level for the diagnosis of DIC       clinical or experimental studies (1). The     VIIa and factor Xa has been developed
was only 28% and hypofibrinogenemia             efficacy of treatment with plasma or           (33). This agent, rNAPc2, is derived from
was detected only in very severe cases of      platelets has not been proven in random-      the family of nematode anticoagulant
DIC. Tests for fibrin degradation products      ized controlled trials but appears to be a    proteins, which were originally isolated
(such as dimerized plasmin fragment D)         rational therapy in bleeding patients or in   from hematophagous hookworm nema-
may be helpful to differentiate DIC from       patients at risk for bleeding who have a      todes. At present, rNAPc2 is being inves-
other conditions that may be associated        significant depletion of these elements.       tigated in phase II/III clinical studies, in-
with a low platelet count and prolonged            Anticoagulants. Experimental studies      cluding a study in DIC patients.
clotting times.                                have shown that heparin can at least              Coagulation Inhibitor Concentrates.
   Current and Future Treatment of Dis-        partly inhibit the activation of coagula-     Because antithrombin III is one of the
seminated Intravascular Coagulation.           tion in sepsis and other causes of DIC        most important physiologic inhibitors of
Several issues in the proper management        (28). Success using heparin has been          coagulation and antithrombin III treat-
of patients with DIC remain controver-         claimed in uncontrolled case series of pa-    ment showed promising results in animal

S22                                                                                              Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)
models of DIC, the use of antithrombin                     M, et al (Eds): DIC: Pathogenesis, Diagnosis     18. Levi M, ten Cate H, Bauer KA, et al: Inhibiton
III concentrates in patients with DIC has                  and Therapy of Disseminated Intravascular            of endotoxin-induced activation of coagula-
been studied relatively intensively. There                 Fibrin Formation. Amsterdam, Elsevier Sci-           tion and fibrinolysis by pentoxifylline or by a
are a number of controlled clinical trials                 ence Publishers BV, 1993                             monoclonal anti-tissue factor antibody in a
                                                      5.   Levi M, van der Poll T, ten Cate H, et al: The       chimpanzee model. J Clin Invest 1994; 93:
on the use of antithrombin concentrates
                                                           cytokine-mediated imbalance between coag-            114 –120
in DIC patients, mostly patients with sep-                 ulant and anticoagulant mechanisms in sep-       19. Biemond BJ, Levi M, ten Cate H, et al: Com-
sis and/or septic shock. All trials show                   sis and endotoxemia. Eur J Clin Invest 1997;         plete inhibition of endotoxin-induced coagu-
some improvement in DIC score, short-                      27:3–9                                               lation activation in chimpanzees with a
ening of DIC duration, or even improve-               6.   Bick RL: Disseminated intravascular coagu-           monoclonal antibody to factor VII/VIIa.
ment in organ function. The more recent                    lation: A common complication of trauma              Thromb Haemostas 1995; 73:223–228
clinical trials used very high doses of an-                and shock. In: The Traumatized Patient. Bor-     20. Fourrier F, Chopin C, Goudemand J, et al:
tithrombin concentrate to attain supra-                    ris LC, Lassen MR, Bergqvist D (Eds). New            Septic shock, multiple organ failure, and dis-
physiologic plasma levels, and the bene-                   York, Romer Grafik, 1992, pp 33–53                    seminated intravascular coagulation: Com-
ficial results in these trials seem to be              7.   Gando S, Kameue T, Nanzaki S, et al: Dis-            pared patterns of antithrombin III, protein C,
                                                           seminated intravascular coagulation is a fre-        and protein S deficiencies. Chest 1992; 101:
more distinct. Some trials showed a mod-
                                                           quent complication of systemic inflamma-              816 – 823
est reduction in mortality in antithrombin-                tory response syndrome. Thromb Haemostas         21. Conway EM, Rosenberg RD: Tumor necrosis
treated patients; this effect did not reach                1996; 75:224 –228                                    factor suppresses transcription of the throm-
statistical significance. However, if one              8.   Roumen JMH, Hendriks T, van der Ven J, et            bomodulin gene in endothelial cells. Mol Cell
performs a meta-analysis of the effect of                  al: Cytokine patterns in patients after major        Biol 1988; 8:5588 –5592
antithrombin III treatment on mortality                    vascular surgery, hemorrhagic shock, and se-     22. de Jonge E, Dekkers PEP, Creasey AA, et al:
in the trials, a statistically significant re-              vere blunt trauma. Ann Surg 1993;                    Tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) dose-
duction in mortality (from 47% to 32%)                     6:769 –776                                           dependently inhibits coagulation activation
is observed (odds ratio, 0.59; 95% confi-              9.   Contrino J, Hair G, Kreutzer D, et al: In situ       without influencing the fibrinolytic and cy-
dence interval, 0.39 – 0.87) (34 –37). It is               detection of expression of tissue factor in          tokine response during human endotoxemia.
                                                           vascular endothelial cells: Correlation with         Blood 2000; 95:1124 –1129
not clear from the literature which pa-
                                                           the malignant phenotype of human breast          23. Biemond BJ, Levi M, ten Cate H, et al: En-
tients will benefit most from antithrom-
                                                           tissue. Nat Med 1996; 2:209 –215                     dotoxin-induced activation and inhibition of
bin III treatment in terms of clinically             10.   Falanga A, Consonni R, Marchetti M, et al:           the fibrinolytic system: Effects of various in-
important outcomes (such as mortality                      Cancer procoagulant and tissue factor are            terventions in the cytokine and coagulation
or organ failure).                                         differently modulated by all-trans-retinoic          cascades in experimental endotoxemia in
    Depression of the protein C system                     acid in acute promyelocytic leukemia cells.          chimpanzees. Clin Sci 1995; 88:587–594
may contribute significantly to the patho-                  Blood 1998; 92:143–151                           24. van der Poll T, Levi M, Hack CE, et al: Elim-
physiology of DIC, and clinical observa-             11.   Martin JN, Stedman CM: Imitators of pre-             ination of interleukin 6 attenuates coagula-
tions suggest that this is associated with a               eclampsia and HELLP syndrome. Obstet                 tion activation in experimental endotoxemia
fatal outcome. Hence, supplementation                      Gynecol Clin North Am 1991; 18:181–198               in chimpanzees. J Exp Med 1994; 179:
of protein C may benefit patients with                12.   Ruggenenti P, Lutz J, Remuzzi G: Pathogen-           1253–1259
                                                           esis and treatment of thrombotic microangi-      25. van der Poll T, Levi M, van Deventer SJH, et
DIC. A favorable effect of administration
                                                           opathy. Kidney Int 1997; 58:S97–S101                 al: Differential effects of anti-tumor necrosis
of protein C concentrate in experimental             13.   Gibney EJ, Bouchier-Hayes D: Coagulopathy            factor monoclonal antibodies on systemic in-
animals with DIC lends support to this                     and abdominal aortic aneurysm. Eur J Vasc            flammatory responses in experimental endo-
notion. Some reports of successful treat-                  Surg 1990; 4:557–562                                 toxemia in chimpanzees. Blood 1994; 83:
ment with protein C concentrates in pa-              14.   van Deventer SJH, Buller HR, ten Cate JW, et
                                                                                ¨                               446 – 451
tients with DIC exist, but adequately con-                 al: Experimental endotoxemia in humans:          26. Pajkrt D, van der Poll T, Levi M, et al: Inter-
trolled clinical trials are not available.                 Analysis of cytokine release and coagulation,        leukin-10 inhibits activation of coagulation
Finally, in view of the pivotal role of tis-               fibrinolytic, and complement pathways.                and fibrinolysis during human endotoxemia.
sue factor in the initiation of thrombin                   Blood 1990; 76:2520 –2526                            Blood 1997; 89:2701–2705
generation in DIC, administration of (re-            15.   Taylor FB Jr: Role of tissue factor in the       27. Alving BM, Spivak JL, DeLoughery TG: Con-
                                                           coagulant and inflammatory response to                sultative hematology: Hemostasis and trans-
combinant) TFPI may prove to be of ben-
                                                           LD100 E. coli sepsis and in the early diagno-        fusion issues in surgery and critical care
efit (22).                                                  sis of DIC in the baboon. In: DIC: Pathogen-         medicine. In: Hematology. McArthur JR,
                                                           esis, diagnosis and therapy of disseminated          Schechter GP, Schrier SL (Eds). Washing-
REFERENCES                                                 intravascular fibrin formation. Muller-               ton, DC, American Society of Hematology
                                                           Berghaus GM, Madlener K, Blomback M, et              Education, 1998, pp 320 –341
 1. Marder VJ, Martin SE, Francis CW, et al:               al (Eds). Amsterdam, Excerpta Medica, 1993,      28. du Toit HJ, Coetzee AR, Chalton DO: Heparin
    Consumptive thrombohemorrhagic disor-                  pp 19 –32                                            treatment in thrombin-induced dissemi-
    ders. In: Hemostasis and Thrombosis: Basic       16.   van der Poll T, Buller HR, ten Cate H, et al:        nated intravascular coagulation in the ba-
    Principles and Clinical Practice. Colman RW,           Activation of coagulation after administra-          boon. Crit Care Med 1991; 19:1195–1200
    Hirsh J, Marder VJ, et al (Eds). Philadelphia,         tion of tumor necrosis factor to normal sub-     29. Corrigan JJ Jr: Heparin therapy in bacterial
    JB Lippincott, 1987, pp 975–1015                       jects. N Engl J Med 1990; 322:1622–1627              septicemia. J Pediatr 1977; 9:695–700
 2. Levi M, ten Cate H: Disseminated intravas-       17.   Pixley RA, de la Cadena R, Page J, et al: The    30. Feinstein DI: Diagnosis and management of
    cular coagulation: Current concepts. N Engl            contact system contributes to hypotension            disseminated intravascular coagulation: The
    J Med 1999; 341:586 –592                               but not disseminated intravascular coagula-          role of heparin therapy. Blood 1982; 60:
 3. Baglin T: Disseminated intravascular coagu-            tion in lethal bacteremia: In vivo use of a          284 –287
    lation: Diagnosis and treatment. BMJ 1996;             monclonal anti-factor XII antibody to block      31. Goldhaber SZ: Venous thromboembolism in
    312:683– 687                                           contact activation in baboons. J Clin Invest         the intensive care unit: The last frontier.
 4. Muller-Berghaus G, Madlener K, Blomback
       ¨                                      ¨            1993; 92:61– 68                                      Chest 1998; 113:5–7


Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)                                                                                                                S23
32. Deleted in proof.                                    seminated intravascular coagulation. Chest          randomized placebo-controlled, double-
33. Bergum P, Cruikshank A, Maki S, et al: The           1993; 104:882– 888                                  blind multicenter trial plus meta-analysis
    potent, factor X(a)-dependent inhibition by      35. Baudo F, Caimi TM, DeCataldo F, et al: An-          on all randomized, placebo-controlled, dou-
    rNAPc2 of factor VIIa/tissue factor involves         tithrombin III replacement therapy in pa-           ble-blind trials with antithrombin III in se-
    the binding of its cofactor to a exosite on          tients with sepsis and/or postsurgical com-         vere sepsis. Intensive Care Med 1998; 24:
    factor VII, followed by occupation of the ac-        plications: A controlled double-blind,              663– 672
    tive site. Abstr. Blood 1998; 92(Suppl):29           randomized, multicenter study. Intensive        37. Schuster HP, Matthias FR: Antithrombin III in
34. Fourrier F, Chopin C, Huart JJ, et al: Double-       Care Med 1998; 24:336 –342                          severe sepsis. Proceedings of the 15th Interna-
    blind, placebo-controlled trial of antithrom-    36. Eisele B, Lamy M, Thijs LG, et al: Antithrom-       tional Symposium on Intensive Care and
    bin III concentrates in septic shock with dis-       bin III in patients with severe sepsis. A           Emergency Medicine, Brussels, 1995, 21–24




S24                                                                                                          Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literature
Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of LiteratureAntiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literature
Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literaturemeducationdotnet
 
Lecture 30 hematopathology
Lecture 30 hematopathologyLecture 30 hematopathology
Lecture 30 hematopathologyGreen-book
 
Lecture 29 hematopathology
Lecture 29 hematopathologyLecture 29 hematopathology
Lecture 29 hematopathologyGreen-book
 
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesisIn vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesisVijay Avin BR
 
Magnani2006 myocarditis
Magnani2006 myocarditisMagnani2006 myocarditis
Magnani2006 myocarditistommy8998
 
Choque por disfuncion endotelial
Choque por disfuncion endotelialChoque por disfuncion endotelial
Choque por disfuncion endotelialElizabeth Pedrueza
 
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat Cancer
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat CancerAngiogenesis and its approach to treat Cancer
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat CancerDibyendu Dutta
 
Angiogenesis in health and disease
Angiogenesis in health and diseaseAngiogenesis in health and disease
Angiogenesis in health and diseaseRadhika Sasturkar
 
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytes
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytesLecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytes
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytesGreen-book
 
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound Healing
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound HealingAcute and Chronic inflammation & Wound Healing
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound HealingRozzan Khatiwada
 
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathydfsimedia
 
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limb
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limbThe role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limb
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limbKETAN VAGHOLKAR
 
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosa
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosaCutaneous polyarteritis nodosa
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosaMarwa Besar
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Angiogenesis
AngiogenesisAngiogenesis
Angiogenesis
 
Angiogenisis in tumer
Angiogenisis in tumerAngiogenisis in tumer
Angiogenisis in tumer
 
Angiogenesis
AngiogenesisAngiogenesis
Angiogenesis
 
Coagulation dirorder 2021
Coagulation dirorder 2021Coagulation dirorder 2021
Coagulation dirorder 2021
 
Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literature
Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of LiteratureAntiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literature
Antiangiogenesis Tumor Therapy: A Review of Literature
 
Lecture 30 hematopathology
Lecture 30 hematopathologyLecture 30 hematopathology
Lecture 30 hematopathology
 
Angiogenesis
AngiogenesisAngiogenesis
Angiogenesis
 
Lecture 29 hematopathology
Lecture 29 hematopathologyLecture 29 hematopathology
Lecture 29 hematopathology
 
Visualization of atherosclerotic vulnerable plaque
Visualization of atherosclerotic vulnerable plaqueVisualization of atherosclerotic vulnerable plaque
Visualization of atherosclerotic vulnerable plaque
 
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesisIn vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis
In vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis
 
Thrombosis of major veins.
Thrombosis of major veins.Thrombosis of major veins.
Thrombosis of major veins.
 
Magnani2006 myocarditis
Magnani2006 myocarditisMagnani2006 myocarditis
Magnani2006 myocarditis
 
Choque por disfuncion endotelial
Choque por disfuncion endotelialChoque por disfuncion endotelial
Choque por disfuncion endotelial
 
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat Cancer
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat CancerAngiogenesis and its approach to treat Cancer
Angiogenesis and its approach to treat Cancer
 
Angiogenesis in health and disease
Angiogenesis in health and diseaseAngiogenesis in health and disease
Angiogenesis in health and disease
 
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytes
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytesLecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytes
Lecture 11 disturbances of body fluids and electrolytes
 
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound Healing
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound HealingAcute and Chronic inflammation & Wound Healing
Acute and Chronic inflammation & Wound Healing
 
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy
1362463849 derangement of wound healing in diabetic neuropathy
 
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limb
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limbThe role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limb
The role of inflammatory reaction in chronic venous disease of the lower limb
 
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosa
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosaCutaneous polyarteritis nodosa
Cutaneous polyarteritis nodosa
 

Andere mochten auch

Depliant Teatro Giovani
Depliant Teatro GiovaniDepliant Teatro Giovani
Depliant Teatro Giovanicpaolieri
 
Rainforest Lis
Rainforest LisRainforest Lis
Rainforest Lisalbullar
 
20100209 Moz Tw
20100209 Moz Tw20100209 Moz Tw
20100209 Moz TwASH
 
Adventures in Community Media
Adventures in Community MediaAdventures in Community Media
Adventures in Community MediaSteve Thompson
 
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bí
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bíTiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bí
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bíNguyen Cuong
 
April 1st PowerPoint
April 1st PowerPointApril 1st PowerPoint
April 1st PowerPointguest09dc03
 
The Octorama at the BBC
The Octorama at the BBCThe Octorama at the BBC
The Octorama at the BBCSteve Thompson
 
Newcastle Community News
Newcastle Community NewsNewcastle Community News
Newcastle Community NewsSteve Thompson
 

Andere mochten auch (9)

Depliant Teatro Giovani
Depliant Teatro GiovaniDepliant Teatro Giovani
Depliant Teatro Giovani
 
Rainforest Lis
Rainforest LisRainforest Lis
Rainforest Lis
 
Texas star chart
Texas star chartTexas star chart
Texas star chart
 
20100209 Moz Tw
20100209 Moz Tw20100209 Moz Tw
20100209 Moz Tw
 
Adventures in Community Media
Adventures in Community MediaAdventures in Community Media
Adventures in Community Media
 
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bí
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bíTiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bí
Tiêm chủng sự thực đằng sau sự huyền bí
 
April 1st PowerPoint
April 1st PowerPointApril 1st PowerPoint
April 1st PowerPoint
 
The Octorama at the BBC
The Octorama at the BBCThe Octorama at the BBC
The Octorama at the BBC
 
Newcastle Community News
Newcastle Community NewsNewcastle Community News
Newcastle Community News
 

Ähnlich wie Cid

Disseminated intravascular coagulation
Disseminated intravascular coagulationDisseminated intravascular coagulation
Disseminated intravascular coagulationGustavo Duarte Viana
 
Approach to DIC
Approach to DICApproach to DIC
Approach to DICikramdr01
 
Factors That V Leiden Thrombophilia
Factors That V Leiden ThrombophiliaFactors That V Leiden Thrombophilia
Factors That V Leiden ThrombophiliaBrenda Zerr
 
Coagulacion diseminada intravascular
Coagulacion diseminada intravascularCoagulacion diseminada intravascular
Coagulacion diseminada intravascularmrpienda
 
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdf
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdfALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdf
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdfzaragalicia
 
Choque y fluidos.pdf
Choque y fluidos.pdfChoque y fluidos.pdf
Choque y fluidos.pdfIMSS
 
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cid
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cidFisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cid
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cidJose Alberto Vejar
 
DIC Presentation
DIC PresentationDIC Presentation
DIC PresentationSalsabil A.
 
What Is Sepsis
What Is SepsisWhat Is Sepsis
What Is SepsisHusni Ajaj
 
Periodontal medicine.pptx
Periodontal medicine.pptxPeriodontal medicine.pptx
Periodontal medicine.pptxDentalYoutube
 
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptx
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptxDOC-20221116-WA0009..pptx
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptxMeghnaNigam1
 
periodontal medicine.pptx
periodontal medicine.pptxperiodontal medicine.pptx
periodontal medicine.pptxveena621629
 
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumar
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumarSepsis. dr.vinod kumar
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumarvinod joshi
 
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...arunperio
 
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome sirs
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome  sirsSystamic infalmatory response syndrome  sirs
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome sirsNahas N
 

Ähnlich wie Cid (20)

Disseminated intravascular coagulation
Disseminated intravascular coagulationDisseminated intravascular coagulation
Disseminated intravascular coagulation
 
Approach to DIC
Approach to DICApproach to DIC
Approach to DIC
 
Factors That V Leiden Thrombophilia
Factors That V Leiden ThrombophiliaFactors That V Leiden Thrombophilia
Factors That V Leiden Thrombophilia
 
Coagulacion diseminada intravascular
Coagulacion diseminada intravascularCoagulacion diseminada intravascular
Coagulacion diseminada intravascular
 
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdf
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdfALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdf
ALTERACIONES EN LA DISFUNCION MULTIORGANICA.pdf
 
Choque y fluidos.pdf
Choque y fluidos.pdfChoque y fluidos.pdf
Choque y fluidos.pdf
 
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cid
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cidFisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cid
Fisiopatologia y diagnóstico de cid
 
Dic seminar pdf
Dic seminar pdfDic seminar pdf
Dic seminar pdf
 
DIC Presentation
DIC PresentationDIC Presentation
DIC Presentation
 
Discitis.pdf
Discitis.pdfDiscitis.pdf
Discitis.pdf
 
What Is Sepsis
What Is SepsisWhat Is Sepsis
What Is Sepsis
 
Periodontal medicine.pptx
Periodontal medicine.pptxPeriodontal medicine.pptx
Periodontal medicine.pptx
 
Hematopathology.pptx
Hematopathology.pptxHematopathology.pptx
Hematopathology.pptx
 
Dic syndrome
Dic syndromeDic syndrome
Dic syndrome
 
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptx
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptxDOC-20221116-WA0009..pptx
DOC-20221116-WA0009..pptx
 
periodontal medicine.pptx
periodontal medicine.pptxperiodontal medicine.pptx
periodontal medicine.pptx
 
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumar
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumarSepsis. dr.vinod kumar
Sepsis. dr.vinod kumar
 
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...
gpqfwg3jq2ymkj8xy5hy-signature-2c5a151fab12e21d70b85ccdc99aeddabbd0b614a36e4d...
 
Periodontal medicine
Periodontal medicinePeriodontal medicine
Periodontal medicine
 
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome sirs
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome  sirsSystamic infalmatory response syndrome  sirs
Systamic infalmatory response syndrome sirs
 

Cid

  • 1. Novel approaches to the management of disseminated intravascular coagulation Marcel Levi, MD; Evert de Jonge, MD; Tom van der Poll, MD; Hugo ten Cate, MD Objective: Disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) is a C–protein S system. Also, impaired fibrin degradation, because of syndrome characterized by systemic intravascular activation of high circulating levels of plasminogen activator inhibitor, type 1, coagulation, leading to widespread deposition of fibrin in the contributes to enhanced intravascular fibrin deposition. circulation. We addressed the issue of whether there is evidence Conclusions: Although the cornerstone of DIC management is that this fibrin deposition contributes to multiple organ failure. We the specific and vigorous treatment of the underlying disorder, also explored the current knowledge on the pathogenesis of DIC strategies aimed at inhibiting coagulation activation may theoret- and reviewed current and future treatment for DIC. ically be justified. Such strategies have been found to be benefi- Data Sources: We searched and reviewed published articles on cial in experimental and initial clinical studies. These strategies, experimental studies of DIC models in animals and clinical studies which follow from our current understanding of the pathophysi- in patients with DIC. ology of DIC, involve inhibition of tissue factor-mediated activa- Data Synthesis: There is ample experimental and clinical evi- tion of coagulation or restoration of physiologic anticoagulant dence that DIC contributes to morbidity and mortality. Recent pathways by means of the administration of antithrombin con- knowledge on important pathogenetic mechanisms that may lead centrate or (activated) protein C concentrate. Although no com- to DIC has resulted in novel preventive and therapeutic ap- plete evidence from controlled clinical trials is available for most proaches to patients with DIC. Although the trigger for the acti- of the proposed therapeutic interventions, these novel strategies vation of the coagulation system may vary depending on the are being studied. (Crit Care Med 2000; 28[Suppl.]:S20 –S24) underlying condition, it is usually mediated by several cytokines. KEY WORDS: disseminated intravascular; sepsis; cytokines; co- Thrombin generation proceeds via the (extrinsic) tissue factor/ agulation; fibrinolysis; antithrombin III; protein C; tissue factor; factor VIIa route and simultaneously occurring depression of tissue factor pathway inhibitor inhibitory mechanisms, such as antithrombin III and the protein D isseminated intravascular co- which may lead to thrombotic occlusion may be accompanied by secondary fibrino- agulation (DIC) is not a dis- of small and midsize vessels. This situa- lysis or inhibited fibrinolysis.” ease or a symptom but a syn- tion may compromise blood supply to Clinical Conditions Associated With drome that is always various organs and may, in conjunction Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation. secondary to an underlying disorder (1, with hemodynamic and metabolic de- DIC may complicate a variety of clinical 2). DIC is characterized by widespread rangements, contribute to multiple or- disorders. Bacterial infection, in particu- activation of blood coagulation, resulting gan failure. Simultaneously, consump- lar, severe sepsis, is the most common in the intravascular formation of fibrin, tion and subsequent exhaustion of entity associated with DIC (1, 3). In addi- platelets and coagulation proteins be- tion, systemic infections with any other cause of the ongoing activation of coag- microorganism, such as viruses and par- ulation may induce severe bleeding com- asites, may lead to DIC. A common patho- From the Department of Vascular Medicine (Drs. Levi and ten Cate), Internal Medicine (Drs. Levi and van plications. In fact, bleeding may be the genetic feature of DIC that is the result of der Poll), Intensive Care (Dr. de Jonge) and the Labo- presenting symptom in a patient with severe infection is the generalized inflam- ratory of Experimental Medicine (Dr. van der Poll), DIC. Hence, a patient with DIC can matory response, characterized by the Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, present with a simultaneously occurring systemic release of cytokines (5). the Netherlands; Department of Internal Medicine (Dr. ten Cate), Slotervaart Hospital, Amsterdam, the Neth- thrombotic and bleeding problem; this Severe trauma is another clinical condi- erlands. obviously complicates the choice of treat- tion frequently associated with DIC (6, 7). A Presented, in part, at the Margaux Conference on ment (3). combination of mechanisms, including re- Critical Illness, Margaux, France, November 11–13, Although there is no general consensus lease of tissue material in the circulation 1999. Adapted from the article “Disseminated intravas- on the definition of DIC, the definition put (fat, phospholipids), hemolysis, and endo- cular coagulation: State-of-the-art” presented at the forward by Muller-Berghaus et al. (4) in ¨ thelial damage, may contribute to the sys- XIVth Congress of the International Society of Throm- 1995 may be most appropriate: “Dissemi- temic activation of coagulation (8). In par- bosis and Hemostasis (ISTH), WA 1999 (Thromb nated intravascular coagulation is an ac- ticular, in head trauma patients, local Haemostas 1999; 82:695–705) and “Disseminated intravascular coagulation: Current concepts” (N Engl quired syndrome characterized by the acti- coagulation activation, and systemic coag- J Med 1999; 341:586 –592). vation of intravascular coagulation up to ulation activation are detectable, which Copyright © 2000 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins intravascular fibrin formation. The process may be understandable in view of the rela- S20 Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)
  • 2. tively large amount of tissue factor in the ders represent a distinct group of diseases combination of consumption resulting cerebral compartment. beyond the scope of this article. from ongoing thrombin generation, deg- Both solid tumors and hematologic Pathogenesis of Disseminated Intra- radation by elastase released from acti- malignancies may be complicated by DIC. vascular Coagulation. In recent years, vated neutrophils, and impaired synthe- The mechanism of the derangement of the mechanisms of the pathologic sys- sis. Low antithrombin III levels in DIC the coagulation system is poorly under- temic fibrin deposition in DIC have be- are associated with increased mortality stood in this situation. However, most come increasingly clear. Enhanced fibrin (20). In addition to the decrease in anti- studies implicate tissue factor, potentially formation is caused by tissue factor- thrombin III, a significant depression of expressed on the surface of tumor cells, mediated thrombin generation and si- the protein C–protein S system may oc- in this process (9). A distinct form of DIC multaneously occurring dysfunction of cur. In models of experimental endotox- is frequently encountered in acute pro- inhibitory mechanisms, such as the anti- emia, down-regulation of thrombomodu- myelocytic leukemia, which is character- thrombin system and the protein C–pro- lin has been demonstrated, resulting in ized by a severe hyperfibrinolytic state on tein S protein system. In addition to en- diminished protein C activity, which may top of an activated coagulation system hanced fibrin formation, fibrin removal is enhance the procoagulant state (21). Tis- (10). Although clinical bleeding predom- impaired because the fibrinolytic system sue factor, the trigger of coagulation, is inates in acute promyelocytic leukemia, is depressed. This impairment of endog- inhibited by tissue factor pathway inhib- disseminated thrombosis is found in enous thrombolysis is caused mainly by itor (TFPI). Administration of recombi- many patients at postmortem examina- high circulating levels of plasminogen ac- nant TFPI to healthy volunteers results in tion. tivator inhibitor, type 1. In a later stage of complete inhibition of endotoxin-induced Acute DIC occurs in obstetrical calam- DIC, fibrinolytic activity may be in- thrombin generation (22). Moreover, in ities such as placental abruption and am- creased and contribute to bleeding. The vivo experiments in lethal baboon models niotic fluid emboli (11). Amniotic fluid derangement of coagulation and fibrino- indicate that TFPI is a potent inhibitor of has been shown to activate coagulation in lysis is mediated by several cytokines, sepsis-related mortality. Whether this ef- vitro, and the degree of placental separa- particularly in DIC associated with infec- fect results solely from impaired clotting tion correlates with the extent of DIC, tious disease but probably also in most activity remains uncertain. In contrast to suggesting that leakage of thromboplas- other clinical conditions associated with other coagulation inhibitors, acquired tin-like material from the placental sys- DIC. deficiencies of TFPI have not been ob- tem is responsible for DIC. The most Activation of Blood Coagulation in served, and DIC is generally associated common obstetrical complication associ- Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation. with only modestly reduced levels, or ated with activation of blood coagulation In all experimental models, thrombin even increased concentrations, of TFPI. is eclampsia and the HELLP (hemolysis, generation is detectable at 3–5 hrs after Experimental models indicate that at elevated liver enzymes, and low platelets) the infusion of microorganisms or endo- the time of maximal activation of coagu- syndrome (12). However, this complica- toxin (14, 15). Several lines of evidence lation, the fibrinolytic system is largely tion is characterized by microangiopathic point to the tissue factor/factor VIIa sys- shut off. Experimental bacteremia and hemolytic anemia with secondary tem as pivotal in the initiation of throm- changes in the coagulation system, a sit- bin generation. First, experiments in hu- endotoxemia result in a rapid increase in uation that is related to, but clearly dis- mans with endotoxemia or in humans fibrinolytic activity, likely because of the tinct from, DIC. infused with the proinflammatory cyto- release of plasminogen activators from Vascular disorders, such as large aor- kine tumor necrosis factor (TNF) did not endothelial cells. This profibrinolytic re- tic aneurysms or giant hemangiomas show any change in markers for activa- sponse is followed almost immediately by (Kasabach-Merritt syndrome), may result tion of the contact system (16). Similarly, a suppression of fibrinolytic activity re- in local activation of coagulation (13). inhibition of the contact system did not sulting from a sustained increase in Activated coagulation factors can ulti- prevent activation of coagulation in bac- plasma levels of plasminogen activator mately “overflow” to the systemic circu- teremic baboons (17). Furthermore, ab- inhibitor, type 1 (23). lation and cause DIC, but the systemic rogation of the tissue factor/factor VIIa Cytokines. The derangement of coag- depletion of coagulation factors and pathway by monoclonal antibodies specif- ulation and fibrinolysis is mediated by platelets as a result of local consumption ically directed against tissue factor or fac- several proinflammatory cytokines, such is more common. This may result in a tor VIIa activity resulted in complete in- as TNF- , interleukin (IL)-1, and IL-6. clinical condition that is hardly distin- hibition of thrombin generation in The principal mediator of coagulation ac- guishable from DIC. endotoxin-challenged chimpanzees and tivation in DIC appears to be IL-6 (24). Microangiopathic hemolytic anemia prevented DIC and mortality in baboons TNF- indirectly influences the activa- represents a group of disorders: throm- that were infused with Escherichia coli tion of coagulation because of its effects bocytopenic thrombotic purpura, hemo- (18, 19). on IL-6, and TNF- is the pivotal media- lytic uremic syndrome, chemotherapy- Suppression of Physiologic Anticoag- tor of the dysregulation of the physiologic induced microangiopathic hemolytic ulant Pathways and Impaired Fibrinoly- anticoagulant pathways and the fibrino- anemia, malignant hypertension, and the sis. Impaired function of various natural lytic defect (25). Anti-inflammatory cyto- HELLP syndrome (12). Although some regulating pathways of coagulation acti- kines, such as IL-10, may modulate the characteristics of microangiopathic he- vation may contribute to fibrin forma- activation of coagulation, as it was shown molytic anemia and the resulting throm- tion. Plasma levels of the most important that administration of recombinant IL-10 botic occlusion of small and midsize ves- inhibitor of thrombin, antithrombin III, to humans completely abrogated the sels leading to organ failure may mimic are usually markedly reduced in septic endotoxin-induced effects on coagulation the clinical picture of DIC, these disor- patients. This reduction is caused by a (26). Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.) S21
  • 3. Diagnosis of Disseminated Intravas- sial. These controversies arise from the I cular Coagulation in Routine Clinical lack of properly conducted clinical trials Settings. There is no single test to accu- on DIC treatment because of the com- t is well established rately diagnose DIC in an individual pa- plexity of DIC’s clinical presentation, its that the cornerstone tient. However, a combination of a clini- variable and unpredictable course, and its cal condition that may be complicated by either subtle or catastrophic clinical con- of disseminated intra- DIC with a number of laboratory results sequences. Besides, the clinical picture of will establish the presence of DIC with an a patient with widespread thrombotic vascular coagulation treat- acceptable level of certainty. Some novel deposition in small vessels of various or- laboratory tests (such as assays for solu- gans on the one hand and bleeding be- ment is the specific and vig- ble fibrin) will be available soon and may cause of consumption and subsequent de- orous treatment of the help in the diagnosis; however, most of pletion of platelets and coagulation the newer tests are currently available in factors on the other hand does not di- underlying disorder. In some specialized laboratories only. In these cir- rectly guide the physician to specific cumstances, a diagnosis of DIC may be therapies. Despite these complicating cir- cases, the disseminated in- made by a combination of platelet count, cumstances, it is well established that the measurement of global clotting times cornerstone of DIC treatment is the spe- travascular coagulation will (activated partial thromboplastin time cific and vigorous treatment of the un- completely resolve within and prothrombin time), measurement of derlying disorder. In some cases, the DIC antithrombin III and/or one or two clot- will completely resolve within hours after hours after the resolution of ting factors, and a test for fibrin degrada- the resolution of the underlying condi- tion products (2). It should be empha- tion (for example, DIC induced by placen- the underlying condition. sized that serial coagulation tests are tal abruption and amniotic fluid embo- generally more helpful than single labo- lism). In other cases (for example, DIC in ratory results in establishing the diagno- patients with sepsis and a systemic in- sis of DIC. A reduction in the platelet flammatory response syndrome), DIC tients with DIC. However, a beneficial count or a clear downward trend at sub- may be present for a number of days, effect of heparin on clinically important sequent measurements is a sensitive (al- even after proper treatment for the un- outcome events in patients with DIC has though not specific) sign of DIC. The derlying condition has been initiated. In never been demonstrated in controlled prolongation of global clotting times may these patients, supportive measures to clinical trials (29, 30). Also, the safety of reflect the consumption and depletion of manage the DIC may be necessary. heparin treatment is debatable in DIC various coagulation factors, which may Briefly, these interventions may consist patients who are prone to bleeding. On be further substantiated by the measure- of plasma and platelet substitution ther- the other hand, most patients with DIC ment of one or two selected coagulation apy, anticoagulant strategies, or adminis- should receive adequate prophylaxis to factors. However, the accuracy of one- tration of physiologic coagulation inhib- prevent venous thromboembolism (31); stage clotting assays in patients with DIC itors. this may be achieved with low-dose hep- has been contested. Plasma and Platelet Substitution arin. In view of this, there is a case for Measurement of antithrombin III has Therapy. Low levels of platelets and co- administering subcutaneous heparin or the additional advantage of specifically agulation factors may increase the risk of perhaps even intravenous low-dose hepa- assessing the consumption of the most bleeding. However, plasma or platelet rin to patients with DIC. Higher doses of important inhibitor of thrombin. Mea- substitution therapy should not be insti- heparin should be reserved for patients surement of fibrinogen has often been tuted on the basis of laboratory results with clinically overt thromboembolism advocated but, in fact, is usually not very alone; such therapy is indicated only in or extensive fibrin deposition, like pur- helpful for diagnosing DIC. Fibrinogen patients with active bleeding and in those pura fulminans or acral ischemia (30). acts as an acute-phase reactant, and de- requiring an invasive procedure or other- Theoretically, the most logical antico- spite ongoing consumption, plasma lev- wise at risk for bleeding complications agulant to use in DIC is one directed els can remain well within the normal (27). The suggestion that administration against tissue factor activity. Recently, a range for a long period. In a consecutive of blood components might add “fuel to potent and specific inhibitor of the ter- series of patients, the sensitivity of a low the fire” has, in fact, never been proven in nary complex between tissue factor/factor fibrinogen level for the diagnosis of DIC clinical or experimental studies (1). The VIIa and factor Xa has been developed was only 28% and hypofibrinogenemia efficacy of treatment with plasma or (33). This agent, rNAPc2, is derived from was detected only in very severe cases of platelets has not been proven in random- the family of nematode anticoagulant DIC. Tests for fibrin degradation products ized controlled trials but appears to be a proteins, which were originally isolated (such as dimerized plasmin fragment D) rational therapy in bleeding patients or in from hematophagous hookworm nema- may be helpful to differentiate DIC from patients at risk for bleeding who have a todes. At present, rNAPc2 is being inves- other conditions that may be associated significant depletion of these elements. tigated in phase II/III clinical studies, in- with a low platelet count and prolonged Anticoagulants. Experimental studies cluding a study in DIC patients. clotting times. have shown that heparin can at least Coagulation Inhibitor Concentrates. Current and Future Treatment of Dis- partly inhibit the activation of coagula- Because antithrombin III is one of the seminated Intravascular Coagulation. tion in sepsis and other causes of DIC most important physiologic inhibitors of Several issues in the proper management (28). Success using heparin has been coagulation and antithrombin III treat- of patients with DIC remain controver- claimed in uncontrolled case series of pa- ment showed promising results in animal S22 Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)
  • 4. models of DIC, the use of antithrombin M, et al (Eds): DIC: Pathogenesis, Diagnosis 18. Levi M, ten Cate H, Bauer KA, et al: Inhibiton III concentrates in patients with DIC has and Therapy of Disseminated Intravascular of endotoxin-induced activation of coagula- been studied relatively intensively. There Fibrin Formation. Amsterdam, Elsevier Sci- tion and fibrinolysis by pentoxifylline or by a are a number of controlled clinical trials ence Publishers BV, 1993 monoclonal anti-tissue factor antibody in a 5. Levi M, van der Poll T, ten Cate H, et al: The chimpanzee model. J Clin Invest 1994; 93: on the use of antithrombin concentrates cytokine-mediated imbalance between coag- 114 –120 in DIC patients, mostly patients with sep- ulant and anticoagulant mechanisms in sep- 19. Biemond BJ, Levi M, ten Cate H, et al: Com- sis and/or septic shock. All trials show sis and endotoxemia. Eur J Clin Invest 1997; plete inhibition of endotoxin-induced coagu- some improvement in DIC score, short- 27:3–9 lation activation in chimpanzees with a ening of DIC duration, or even improve- 6. Bick RL: Disseminated intravascular coagu- monoclonal antibody to factor VII/VIIa. ment in organ function. The more recent lation: A common complication of trauma Thromb Haemostas 1995; 73:223–228 clinical trials used very high doses of an- and shock. In: The Traumatized Patient. Bor- 20. Fourrier F, Chopin C, Goudemand J, et al: tithrombin concentrate to attain supra- ris LC, Lassen MR, Bergqvist D (Eds). New Septic shock, multiple organ failure, and dis- physiologic plasma levels, and the bene- York, Romer Grafik, 1992, pp 33–53 seminated intravascular coagulation: Com- ficial results in these trials seem to be 7. Gando S, Kameue T, Nanzaki S, et al: Dis- pared patterns of antithrombin III, protein C, seminated intravascular coagulation is a fre- and protein S deficiencies. Chest 1992; 101: more distinct. Some trials showed a mod- quent complication of systemic inflamma- 816 – 823 est reduction in mortality in antithrombin- tory response syndrome. Thromb Haemostas 21. Conway EM, Rosenberg RD: Tumor necrosis treated patients; this effect did not reach 1996; 75:224 –228 factor suppresses transcription of the throm- statistical significance. However, if one 8. Roumen JMH, Hendriks T, van der Ven J, et bomodulin gene in endothelial cells. Mol Cell performs a meta-analysis of the effect of al: Cytokine patterns in patients after major Biol 1988; 8:5588 –5592 antithrombin III treatment on mortality vascular surgery, hemorrhagic shock, and se- 22. de Jonge E, Dekkers PEP, Creasey AA, et al: in the trials, a statistically significant re- vere blunt trauma. Ann Surg 1993; Tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) dose- duction in mortality (from 47% to 32%) 6:769 –776 dependently inhibits coagulation activation is observed (odds ratio, 0.59; 95% confi- 9. Contrino J, Hair G, Kreutzer D, et al: In situ without influencing the fibrinolytic and cy- dence interval, 0.39 – 0.87) (34 –37). It is detection of expression of tissue factor in tokine response during human endotoxemia. vascular endothelial cells: Correlation with Blood 2000; 95:1124 –1129 not clear from the literature which pa- the malignant phenotype of human breast 23. Biemond BJ, Levi M, ten Cate H, et al: En- tients will benefit most from antithrom- tissue. Nat Med 1996; 2:209 –215 dotoxin-induced activation and inhibition of bin III treatment in terms of clinically 10. Falanga A, Consonni R, Marchetti M, et al: the fibrinolytic system: Effects of various in- important outcomes (such as mortality Cancer procoagulant and tissue factor are terventions in the cytokine and coagulation or organ failure). differently modulated by all-trans-retinoic cascades in experimental endotoxemia in Depression of the protein C system acid in acute promyelocytic leukemia cells. chimpanzees. Clin Sci 1995; 88:587–594 may contribute significantly to the patho- Blood 1998; 92:143–151 24. van der Poll T, Levi M, Hack CE, et al: Elim- physiology of DIC, and clinical observa- 11. Martin JN, Stedman CM: Imitators of pre- ination of interleukin 6 attenuates coagula- tions suggest that this is associated with a eclampsia and HELLP syndrome. Obstet tion activation in experimental endotoxemia fatal outcome. Hence, supplementation Gynecol Clin North Am 1991; 18:181–198 in chimpanzees. J Exp Med 1994; 179: of protein C may benefit patients with 12. Ruggenenti P, Lutz J, Remuzzi G: Pathogen- 1253–1259 esis and treatment of thrombotic microangi- 25. van der Poll T, Levi M, van Deventer SJH, et DIC. A favorable effect of administration opathy. Kidney Int 1997; 58:S97–S101 al: Differential effects of anti-tumor necrosis of protein C concentrate in experimental 13. Gibney EJ, Bouchier-Hayes D: Coagulopathy factor monoclonal antibodies on systemic in- animals with DIC lends support to this and abdominal aortic aneurysm. Eur J Vasc flammatory responses in experimental endo- notion. Some reports of successful treat- Surg 1990; 4:557–562 toxemia in chimpanzees. Blood 1994; 83: ment with protein C concentrates in pa- 14. van Deventer SJH, Buller HR, ten Cate JW, et ¨ 446 – 451 tients with DIC exist, but adequately con- al: Experimental endotoxemia in humans: 26. Pajkrt D, van der Poll T, Levi M, et al: Inter- trolled clinical trials are not available. Analysis of cytokine release and coagulation, leukin-10 inhibits activation of coagulation Finally, in view of the pivotal role of tis- fibrinolytic, and complement pathways. and fibrinolysis during human endotoxemia. sue factor in the initiation of thrombin Blood 1990; 76:2520 –2526 Blood 1997; 89:2701–2705 generation in DIC, administration of (re- 15. Taylor FB Jr: Role of tissue factor in the 27. Alving BM, Spivak JL, DeLoughery TG: Con- coagulant and inflammatory response to sultative hematology: Hemostasis and trans- combinant) TFPI may prove to be of ben- LD100 E. coli sepsis and in the early diagno- fusion issues in surgery and critical care efit (22). sis of DIC in the baboon. In: DIC: Pathogen- medicine. In: Hematology. McArthur JR, esis, diagnosis and therapy of disseminated Schechter GP, Schrier SL (Eds). Washing- REFERENCES intravascular fibrin formation. Muller- ton, DC, American Society of Hematology Berghaus GM, Madlener K, Blomback M, et Education, 1998, pp 320 –341 1. Marder VJ, Martin SE, Francis CW, et al: al (Eds). Amsterdam, Excerpta Medica, 1993, 28. du Toit HJ, Coetzee AR, Chalton DO: Heparin Consumptive thrombohemorrhagic disor- pp 19 –32 treatment in thrombin-induced dissemi- ders. In: Hemostasis and Thrombosis: Basic 16. van der Poll T, Buller HR, ten Cate H, et al: nated intravascular coagulation in the ba- Principles and Clinical Practice. Colman RW, Activation of coagulation after administra- boon. Crit Care Med 1991; 19:1195–1200 Hirsh J, Marder VJ, et al (Eds). Philadelphia, tion of tumor necrosis factor to normal sub- 29. Corrigan JJ Jr: Heparin therapy in bacterial JB Lippincott, 1987, pp 975–1015 jects. N Engl J Med 1990; 322:1622–1627 septicemia. J Pediatr 1977; 9:695–700 2. Levi M, ten Cate H: Disseminated intravas- 17. Pixley RA, de la Cadena R, Page J, et al: The 30. Feinstein DI: Diagnosis and management of cular coagulation: Current concepts. N Engl contact system contributes to hypotension disseminated intravascular coagulation: The J Med 1999; 341:586 –592 but not disseminated intravascular coagula- role of heparin therapy. Blood 1982; 60: 3. Baglin T: Disseminated intravascular coagu- tion in lethal bacteremia: In vivo use of a 284 –287 lation: Diagnosis and treatment. BMJ 1996; monclonal anti-factor XII antibody to block 31. Goldhaber SZ: Venous thromboembolism in 312:683– 687 contact activation in baboons. J Clin Invest the intensive care unit: The last frontier. 4. Muller-Berghaus G, Madlener K, Blomback ¨ ¨ 1993; 92:61– 68 Chest 1998; 113:5–7 Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.) S23
  • 5. 32. Deleted in proof. seminated intravascular coagulation. Chest randomized placebo-controlled, double- 33. Bergum P, Cruikshank A, Maki S, et al: The 1993; 104:882– 888 blind multicenter trial plus meta-analysis potent, factor X(a)-dependent inhibition by 35. Baudo F, Caimi TM, DeCataldo F, et al: An- on all randomized, placebo-controlled, dou- rNAPc2 of factor VIIa/tissue factor involves tithrombin III replacement therapy in pa- ble-blind trials with antithrombin III in se- the binding of its cofactor to a exosite on tients with sepsis and/or postsurgical com- vere sepsis. Intensive Care Med 1998; 24: factor VII, followed by occupation of the ac- plications: A controlled double-blind, 663– 672 tive site. Abstr. Blood 1998; 92(Suppl):29 randomized, multicenter study. Intensive 37. Schuster HP, Matthias FR: Antithrombin III in 34. Fourrier F, Chopin C, Huart JJ, et al: Double- Care Med 1998; 24:336 –342 severe sepsis. Proceedings of the 15th Interna- blind, placebo-controlled trial of antithrom- 36. Eisele B, Lamy M, Thijs LG, et al: Antithrom- tional Symposium on Intensive Care and bin III concentrates in septic shock with dis- bin III in patients with severe sepsis. A Emergency Medicine, Brussels, 1995, 21–24 S24 Crit Care Med 2000 Vol. 28, No. 9 (Suppl.)