SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
SHARE Study Outcomes: Domestic Violence Services Increase Safety,
         Improve the Lives of Women and Children, and
                   Reduce Long-Term Costs
There were dramatic positive changes in the lives of the women and children in the study
during the first 6-months of services, which persisted and/or improved over the full 18
months of the study.
Women and children were safer:
Prior to receiving services, 85% of women were in extreme or severe danger based on the Danger Assessment Scale. Following
domestic violence services, only 9.6% of women reported extreme or severe danger. The mean baseline Danger Assessment score
at the 18 month interview was 6.4, compared to 21.6 at the baseline interview.


                                                                                        80
Level of Danger                      Baseline                    18-months
                                                                                        70
Extreme Danger (18+)                                71.2%                 4.8%          60
                                                                                                                                                 Baseline
Severe Danger (14-17)                                14%                  4.8%          50
                                                                                        40                                                       18-months
Increased Danger (8-13)                             12.6%                23.5%
                                                                                        30
Variable Danger (0-7)                                2.2%                66.9%          20
                                                                                        10
                                                                                         0
                                                                                              extreme       severe   increased   variable
                                                                                               danger       danger     danger     danger


Their housing stability improved significantly:
Women and their children moved less frequently, stayed less often in emergency housing (motel vouchers, homeless or domestic
violence shelters), and had greater housing stability, as measured by the SHARE Housing Instability Index. Housing instability scores
dropped by 52%, the number of moves decreased by 80%, and the number of days in emergency housing decreased by 78%.


Housing Stability          SHARE Housing                     Mean Number          % who accessed emergency housing
                           Instability Index                 of Moves             Motel Voucher     Homeless shelter             DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
                                                                                                                                 shelter
Baseline                                            4.65                   3.94                     21.6%                 2.9%                        13.7%
18-month                                            2.41                   0.81                      1.9%                 2.7%                         3.5%



Women and children had better health and mental health, and were better able to succeed with day-to-day life:

                                   Change in Women's Outcomes

             Not having enough food to eat                                                                                  Fewer women met the criteria for
           Difficulty in meeting basic needs                                                                               clinical depression or had symptoms
                Income under $1500/month                                                                                 related to Post Traumatic Stress (PTSD)
                          Problem w /Drugs                                                                                or problematic use of alcohol or drugs
                                                                                                        Baseline
                        Problem w /Alcohol                                                                                at the 18-month interview compared
                                                                                                        18-months
   Lost/quit/fired from a job because of DV                                                                              to the baseline interview. They missed
             Taken time off because of DV                                                                                  fewer days of work, and had greater
                                      PTSD                                                                                job stability and economic resources.
                                Depression

                                               0%          20%     40%     60%    80%        100%
Their children missed fewer days of school and were more likely to be doing well or maintaining their school
  performance:
                           50

                           40                                                                                        Baseline
                           30                                                                                        18-months

                           20

                           10
                             0
                                 6+ school days missed 1+ school days missed due      school performance
                                                                 to DV                     declined


  However, the study participants continued to face long-term health, mental health, and
  economic constraints:
  Although the SHARE study found a reduction in negative outcomes for women and their children, and an increase in positive
  outcomes, in some cases the changes were small to moderate. This was particularly noticeable in indicators of health and mental
  health, and in areas which were highly impacted by inadequate resources.

  At 18-months:                                                                                                        “And I thought I would be
            73% of women still experienced symptoms consistent with PTSD                                            closer to normal by now but I,
            58% of women still met the criteria for clinical depression                                             I have flashbacks and when a
            74% of women received less than $1500 per month
                                                                                                                       door, somebody knocks at
            60% had difficulty meeting basic needs
                                                                                                                      the door, I freak out and . . .
            40% accessed food boxes.
                                                                                                                       this is part of the domestic
                                                                                                                                 violence”
  The SHARE study findings point to important funding, policy,
                                           and programmatic improvements:
                                                    Services need to flexibly address a wide range of needs of women and children
          “It’s all financial,
                                                    Services need to change over time as safety and housing stability increases to
      everything’s financial.
                                                     address the longer-term health/mental health and economic concerns
     If I had the money to do
                                                    Agencies need to address housing and DV/safety concerns simultaneously
       so, I would be gone.”
                                                    Funding, policy and practice should embrace housing instability as a critical
                                                                                      aspect of ending domestic violence.


Description of SHARE Study
The SHARE Study is a quasi-experimental, longitudinal, community-based participatory study designed to evaluate the effectiveness, including cost-effectiveness,
of an existing rapid re-housing program (Volunteers of America Home Free). The evaluation examines the role of housing stability in preventing revictimization
and reducing negative health outcomes of domestic violence survivors and their children.

Participants of the SHARE Study were 278 English or Spanish speaking women in the Portland, Oregon area who had experienced physical or sexual violence or
threats of violence by an intimate or ex intimate partner in the previous 6 months. Participants also had housing instability as a primary concern and had sought
services from a domestic violence or housing assistance agency. Over half were women of color; about ½ had a GED, high school diploma or less education; the
participants had high rates of unemployment and poverty; and most had young children. These survivors utilized a wide variety of resources to meet their and
their children’s situation and individual needs. The most frequently used services were: domestic violence, housing, public assistance, health care, police and
restraining orders. They also used these services: training and education, employment services, parenting classes, services for their children, child care, parenting
classes, counseling and alcohol and drug treatment.

Chiquita Rollins, PhD     SHARE Co-Principal Investigator, DV Consultant             503-335-3078 cmrollins@q.com
Kris Billhardt, M.Ed,Ed.S Director, Volunteers of America Home Free                  503-802-0492 kbillhardt@voaor.org

Funding was provided by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (U49CE000520-01, 09/01/2005-
08/31/2010).

More Related Content

More from National Alliance to End Homelessness

California’s Approach for Implementing the Federal Fostering Connections to...
California’s Approach for  Implementing the Federal Fostering  Connections to...California’s Approach for  Implementing the Federal Fostering  Connections to...
California’s Approach for Implementing the Federal Fostering Connections to...National Alliance to End Homelessness
 
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your Program
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your ProgramRetooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your Program
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your ProgramNational Alliance to End Homelessness
 
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending Homelessness
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending HomelessnessHousing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending Homelessness
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending HomelessnessNational Alliance to End Homelessness
 
2.13 Matters of State: Advancing Policy Priorities in State Capitals
2.13 Matters of State:  Advancing Policy  Priorities in State Capitals2.13 Matters of State:  Advancing Policy  Priorities in State Capitals
2.13 Matters of State: Advancing Policy Priorities in State CapitalsNational Alliance to End Homelessness
 
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...National Alliance to End Homelessness
 
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran HomelessnessNational Alliance to End Homelessness
 
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric Rice
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric RiceA Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric Rice
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric RiceNational Alliance to End Homelessness
 
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)National Alliance to End Homelessness
 
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...National Alliance to End Homelessness
 

More from National Alliance to End Homelessness (20)

Frontline Practice within Housing First Programs
Frontline Practice within Housing First ProgramsFrontline Practice within Housing First Programs
Frontline Practice within Housing First Programs
 
Rapid Re-Housing with DV Survivors: Approaches that Work
Rapid Re-Housing with DV Survivors: Approaches that WorkRapid Re-Housing with DV Survivors: Approaches that Work
Rapid Re-Housing with DV Survivors: Approaches that Work
 
Non-chronic Adult Homelessness: Background and Opportunities
Non-chronic Adult Homelessness: Background and OpportunitiesNon-chronic Adult Homelessness: Background and Opportunities
Non-chronic Adult Homelessness: Background and Opportunities
 
California’s Approach for Implementing the Federal Fostering Connections to...
California’s Approach for  Implementing the Federal Fostering  Connections to...California’s Approach for  Implementing the Federal Fostering  Connections to...
California’s Approach for Implementing the Federal Fostering Connections to...
 
Health Care Reform: What’s in it for Homeless Families and Youth?
Health Care Reform: What’s in it for Homeless Families and Youth?Health Care Reform: What’s in it for Homeless Families and Youth?
Health Care Reform: What’s in it for Homeless Families and Youth?
 
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your Program
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your ProgramRetooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your Program
Retooling Transitional Housing: Steps for Implementing Changes to Your Program
 
The Fusion Project
The Fusion ProjectThe Fusion Project
The Fusion Project
 
Building Education and Employment Supports for Homeless LGBTQ Youth
Building Education and Employment Supports for Homeless LGBTQ YouthBuilding Education and Employment Supports for Homeless LGBTQ Youth
Building Education and Employment Supports for Homeless LGBTQ Youth
 
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending Homelessness
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending HomelessnessHousing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending Homelessness
Housing Choice Vouchers: Funding Outlook and Impact on Ending Homelessness
 
Family Reunification Pilot, Alameda County, CA
Family Reunification Pilot, Alameda County, CAFamily Reunification Pilot, Alameda County, CA
Family Reunification Pilot, Alameda County, CA
 
Avenues for Homeless Youth
Avenues for Homeless YouthAvenues for Homeless Youth
Avenues for Homeless Youth
 
Retooling Transitional Housing: Moving to New Models
Retooling Transitional Housing: Moving to New ModelsRetooling Transitional Housing: Moving to New Models
Retooling Transitional Housing: Moving to New Models
 
Improving Homeless Assistance Through Learning Collaboratives
Improving Homeless Assistance Through Learning CollaborativesImproving Homeless Assistance Through Learning Collaboratives
Improving Homeless Assistance Through Learning Collaboratives
 
2.13 Matters of State: Advancing Policy Priorities in State Capitals
2.13 Matters of State:  Advancing Policy  Priorities in State Capitals2.13 Matters of State:  Advancing Policy  Priorities in State Capitals
2.13 Matters of State: Advancing Policy Priorities in State Capitals
 
Shelter diversion
Shelter diversionShelter diversion
Shelter diversion
 
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...
Evaluating Philadelphia’s Rapid Re-Housing Impacts on Housing Stability and I...
 
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness
1.3 Beyond a 17 Percent Decrease: Next Steps for Ending Veteran Homelessness
 
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric Rice
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric RiceA Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric Rice
A Triage Tool for Homeless Youth: Proposed Items and Method by Eric Rice
 
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)
Family intervention building relationships and increasing stability for rhy (2)
 
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...
Reducing Family Homelessness in Virginia: Community and Organizational Change...
 

1.3 18-Month Fact Sheet

  • 1. SHARE Study Outcomes: Domestic Violence Services Increase Safety, Improve the Lives of Women and Children, and Reduce Long-Term Costs There were dramatic positive changes in the lives of the women and children in the study during the first 6-months of services, which persisted and/or improved over the full 18 months of the study. Women and children were safer: Prior to receiving services, 85% of women were in extreme or severe danger based on the Danger Assessment Scale. Following domestic violence services, only 9.6% of women reported extreme or severe danger. The mean baseline Danger Assessment score at the 18 month interview was 6.4, compared to 21.6 at the baseline interview. 80 Level of Danger Baseline 18-months 70 Extreme Danger (18+) 71.2% 4.8% 60 Baseline Severe Danger (14-17) 14% 4.8% 50 40 18-months Increased Danger (8-13) 12.6% 23.5% 30 Variable Danger (0-7) 2.2% 66.9% 20 10 0 extreme severe increased variable danger danger danger danger Their housing stability improved significantly: Women and their children moved less frequently, stayed less often in emergency housing (motel vouchers, homeless or domestic violence shelters), and had greater housing stability, as measured by the SHARE Housing Instability Index. Housing instability scores dropped by 52%, the number of moves decreased by 80%, and the number of days in emergency housing decreased by 78%. Housing Stability SHARE Housing Mean Number % who accessed emergency housing Instability Index of Moves Motel Voucher Homeless shelter DOMESTIC VIOLENCE shelter Baseline 4.65 3.94 21.6% 2.9% 13.7% 18-month 2.41 0.81 1.9% 2.7% 3.5% Women and children had better health and mental health, and were better able to succeed with day-to-day life: Change in Women's Outcomes Not having enough food to eat Fewer women met the criteria for Difficulty in meeting basic needs clinical depression or had symptoms Income under $1500/month related to Post Traumatic Stress (PTSD) Problem w /Drugs or problematic use of alcohol or drugs Baseline Problem w /Alcohol at the 18-month interview compared 18-months Lost/quit/fired from a job because of DV to the baseline interview. They missed Taken time off because of DV fewer days of work, and had greater PTSD job stability and economic resources. Depression 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
  • 2. Their children missed fewer days of school and were more likely to be doing well or maintaining their school performance: 50 40 Baseline 30 18-months 20 10 0 6+ school days missed 1+ school days missed due school performance to DV declined However, the study participants continued to face long-term health, mental health, and economic constraints: Although the SHARE study found a reduction in negative outcomes for women and their children, and an increase in positive outcomes, in some cases the changes were small to moderate. This was particularly noticeable in indicators of health and mental health, and in areas which were highly impacted by inadequate resources. At 18-months: “And I thought I would be  73% of women still experienced symptoms consistent with PTSD closer to normal by now but I,  58% of women still met the criteria for clinical depression I have flashbacks and when a  74% of women received less than $1500 per month door, somebody knocks at  60% had difficulty meeting basic needs the door, I freak out and . . .  40% accessed food boxes. this is part of the domestic violence” The SHARE study findings point to important funding, policy, and programmatic improvements:  Services need to flexibly address a wide range of needs of women and children “It’s all financial,  Services need to change over time as safety and housing stability increases to everything’s financial. address the longer-term health/mental health and economic concerns If I had the money to do  Agencies need to address housing and DV/safety concerns simultaneously so, I would be gone.”  Funding, policy and practice should embrace housing instability as a critical aspect of ending domestic violence. Description of SHARE Study The SHARE Study is a quasi-experimental, longitudinal, community-based participatory study designed to evaluate the effectiveness, including cost-effectiveness, of an existing rapid re-housing program (Volunteers of America Home Free). The evaluation examines the role of housing stability in preventing revictimization and reducing negative health outcomes of domestic violence survivors and their children. Participants of the SHARE Study were 278 English or Spanish speaking women in the Portland, Oregon area who had experienced physical or sexual violence or threats of violence by an intimate or ex intimate partner in the previous 6 months. Participants also had housing instability as a primary concern and had sought services from a domestic violence or housing assistance agency. Over half were women of color; about ½ had a GED, high school diploma or less education; the participants had high rates of unemployment and poverty; and most had young children. These survivors utilized a wide variety of resources to meet their and their children’s situation and individual needs. The most frequently used services were: domestic violence, housing, public assistance, health care, police and restraining orders. They also used these services: training and education, employment services, parenting classes, services for their children, child care, parenting classes, counseling and alcohol and drug treatment. Chiquita Rollins, PhD SHARE Co-Principal Investigator, DV Consultant 503-335-3078 cmrollins@q.com Kris Billhardt, M.Ed,Ed.S Director, Volunteers of America Home Free 503-802-0492 kbillhardt@voaor.org Funding was provided by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (U49CE000520-01, 09/01/2005- 08/31/2010).