SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Download to read offline
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 1 of 9



                       UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                          DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
_______________________________________
                                        )
IN RE: NEW ENGLAND                      )
COMPOUNDING PHARMACY, INC.              )   MDL No. 1:13-md-2419-FDS
PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION           )
                                        )
This Document Relates To:               )
                                        )
      All Actions                       )
                                        )
                                        )

                                         MDL Order No. 2
                                          April 9, 2013

                          ORDER APPOINTING LEAD COUNSEL,
                        FEDERAL-STATE LIAISON COUNSEL, AND
                          PLAINTIFFS’ STEERING COMMITTEE

       This order is intended to create a leadership structure for plaintiffs’ counsel in order to

organize, simplify, and streamline the handling of these matters on behalf of all plaintiffs,

consistent with the fair administration of justice.

1.     Lead Counsel

       The Court hereby appoints the following individual as Lead Counsel:

       Thomas M. Sobol
       (with Kristen Johnson Parker as his alternate)
       HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP
       55 Cambridge Parkway, Suite 301
       Cambridge, MA 02142
       Phone:(617)482-3700
       Fax:(617)482-3003
       tom@hbsslaw.com
       kristenjp@hbsslaw.com

       The responsibilities of Lead Counsel are set forth in section 7 of this order.

2.     Federal-State Liaison Counsel

       The Court hereby appoints the following individual as Federal-State Liaison Counsel:
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 2 of 9




      Mark P. Chalos
      (with Elizabeth J. Cabraser as his alternate)
      LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, LLP
      150 Fourth Avenue, North
      Suite 1650
      Nashville, TN 37219
      Phone:(615)313.9000
      Fax:(615)313.9965
      mchalos@lchb.com
      ecabraser@lchb.com

      The responsibilities of Lead Counsel are set forth in section 8 of this order.

3.    Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee

      The Court hereby appoints the following individuals to the Plaintiffs’ Steering

Committee (“PSC”):

      Thomas M. Sobol
      (with Kristen Johnson Parker as his alternate)

      Mark P. Chalos
      (with Elizabeth J. Cabraser as his alternate)

      Marc E. Lipton                                Kim Dougherty
      LIPTON LAW                                    JANET, JENNER & SUGGS, LLC
      18930 W. 10 Mile Road                         75 Arlington St.
      Southfield, MI 48075                          Suite 500
      Phone: (248) 557-1688                         Boston, MA 02116
      Fax: (248) 557-6344                           Phone: (617) 933-1265
      marc@liptonlawcenter.com                      kdougherty@myadvocates.com

      Patrick T. Fennell                            J. Gerard Stranch, IV
      CRANDALL & KATT                               BRANSTETTER, STRANCH &
      366 Elm Avenue, S.W.                          JENNINGS PLLC
      Roanoke, Virginia 24016                       227 Second Avenue North
      Phone: (540) 342-2000                         Nashville, TN 37201
      Fax: (540) 400-0616                           Phone: (615) 254-8801
      pfennell@crandalllaw.com                      Fax: (615) 255-5419
                                                    gerards@branstetterlaw.com



                                                2
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 3 of 9




       Mark Zamora
       ZAMORA FIRM
       6 Concourse Parkway, 22nd Floor
       Atlanta, GA 30328
       Phone: (404) 451-7781
       Fax: (404) 506-9223
       mark@markzamora.com

       The responsibilities of the PSC are set forth in section 9 of this order.

4.     Changes in Membership

       These appointments are personal in nature, and may not be changed without court order.

5.     Alternates

       The two alternate members may perform responsibilities under this order at the direction

of the appointed member.

6.     Designated Counsel

       The PSC may appoint other qualified plaintiffs’ counsel to perform legal services for the

common benefit of plaintiffs (“Designated Counsel”).

7.     Responsibilities of Lead Counsel

       Lead Counsel shall have the following responsibilities:

              1.      to chair the PSC, which shall be generally responsible for coordinating the

                      activities of plaintiffs’ counsel during pretrial proceedings;

              2.      to present, after consultation with the PSC and other counsel as may be

                      appropriate, personally or by a designee, the position of the plaintiffs on

                      any matter arising during pretrial proceedings;

              3.      to delegate specific tasks to other counsel in a manner to ensure that

                      pretrial preparation for the plaintiffs is conducted effectively, efficiently,


                                                 3
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 4 of 9



          and economically, including the creation of subject matter-specific or

          other working groups;

    4.    to prepare and distribute to the parties periodic status reports, as

          appropriate;

    5.    to maintain adequate time and disbursement records covering services as

          Designated Counsel;

    6.    to coordinate and lead discussions with the Court, plaintiffs’ counsel and

          other stakeholders (for example, the NECP trustee and its counsel, the

          creditors’ committee and its counsel, other defense counsel, and

          non-parties) to ensure that court orders are followed, schedules are met,

          discovery is conducted and provided consistent with the requirements of

          Fed. R. Civ. P. 26, unnecessary expenditures of time and funds are

          avoided, and any negotiations are reasonably efficient and productive;

    7.    to coordinate, with the assistance of the Federal-State Liaison Counsel,

          with counsel in related state-court litigation, in order to avoid duplicative

          discovery, including minimizing the number of depositions taken of each

          witness, minimizing the number of lawyers who question witnesses at

          depositions, and reducing duplicative questioning;

    8.    to maintain an up-to-date comprehensive service list of plaintiffs’ counsel

          in MDL 2419 and promptly advise the Court of any changes;

    9.    to receive and distribute to plaintiffs’ counsel, as appropriate, orders,

          notices and correspondence from the Court;


                                     4
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 5 of 9



              10.     to maintain and make available to other plaintiffs’ counsel, on reasonable

                      notice and at reasonable times, a complete set of all pleadings and orders

                      filed and/or served in MDL 2419; and

              11.     to establish and maintain, in conjunction with the PSC and to the extent

                      deemed desirable by the PSC, a physical or virtual depository located

                      within the Court’s jurisdiction, or otherwise accessible to all plaintiffs’

                      counsel.

       Lead counsel shall be involved in any class or group settlement discussions, whether with

a single defendant or multiple defendants, whether taking place in the MDL or the bankruptcy.

8.     Responsibilities of Federal-State Liaison Counsel

       Federal-State Liaison Counsel shall have the following responsibilities:

              1.      where practicable, to communicate with attorneys prosecuting related

                      state-court actions in order to ascertain their status;

              2.      to provide information about related state-court proceedings to the Court

                      and counsel;

              3.      to help coordinate discovery and litigation efforts between state and

                      federal proceedings to avoid, where possible, duplicative or conflicting

                      efforts; and

              4.      to assist in providing access to participating state-court counsel to any

                      common-benefit document depository and common-benefit work-product,

                      in accordance with the terms of any common-benefit orders entered by the

                      Court.


                                                 5
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 6 of 9



       Should the need for a Federal-State Liaison become unnecessary, the person holding that

position shall retain his appointment to the plaintiffs’ steering committee.

9.     Responsibilities of PSC

       The PSC shall have the following responsibilities:

       A.      Discovery

               1.      to initiate, coordinate, and conduct all pretrial discovery on behalf of

                       plaintiffs in all actions subject to this order;

               2.      to develop and propose to the Court schedules for the commencement,

                       execution, and completion of all discovery on behalf of all plaintiffs;

               3.      to cause to be issued in the name of all plaintiffs the necessary discovery

                       requests, motions, and subpoenas concerning any witnesses and

                       documents needed to prepare for the trial of this litigation (similar

                       requests, motions, and subpoenas may be caused to be issued by the PSC

                       upon written request by an individual attorney in order to assist him or her

                       in the preparation of the pretrial stages of his or her client’s particular

                       claims); and

               4.      to conduct all discovery, by members or their designees approved by Lead

                       Counsel, in a coordinated and consolidated manner on behalf and for the

                       benefit of all plaintiffs.

       B.      Hearings and Meetings

               1.      to call meetings of counsel for plaintiffs for any appropriate purpose,

                       including coordinating responses to questions of other parties or of the


                                                    6
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 7 of 9



             Court;

     2.      to initiate proposals, suggestions, schedules, or joint briefs, and any other

             appropriate matters concerning pretrial proceedings;

     3.      to examine witnesses and introduce evidence at hearings on behalf of

             plaintiffs; and

     4.      to speak for all plaintiffs at pretrial proceedings and in response to any

             inquiries by the Court, subject to the right of any plaintiff’s counsel to

             present non-repetitive individual or different positions.

C.   Trial

     1.      to coordinate the selection, management, and presentation of any common

             issue, “bellwether” and/or “test” case trials.

D.   Settlement and Miscellaneous

     1.      to negotiate and propose settlement of cases on behalf of plaintiffs or

             plaintiff groups, including exploring and, where appropriate, pursuing all

             settlement options concerning any claim or portion thereof of any case

             filed in this litigation;

     2.      to litigate any motions presented to the Court that involve matters within

             the sphere of the responsibilities of the PSC;

     3.      to negotiate and enter into stipulations with defendants concerning this

             litigation; provided, however, that all stipulations entered into by the PSC,

             except for strictly administrative details such as scheduling, must be

             submitted for Court approval and will not be binding until the Court has


                                         7
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 8 of 9



                       ratified the stipulation, and that any attorney not in agreement with a

                       non-administrative stipulation shall file with the Court a written objection

                       thereto within five days after he/she knows or should have reasonably

                       become aware of the stipulation, and that failure to object within the term

                       allowed shall be deemed a waiver and the stipulation will automatically be

                       binding on that party;

               4.      to maintain adequate files of all pretrial matters, including establishing

                       and maintaining a document or exhibit depository, in either real or virtual

                       format, and having those documents available, under reasonable terms and

                       conditions, for examination by all plaintiffs’ counsel;

               5.      to perform any task necessary and proper for the PSC to accomplish its

                       responsibilities as defined by the Court’s orders, including organizing

                       subcommittees or workgroups comprised of plaintiffs’ attorneys not on the

                       PSC and assigning them tasks consistent with the duties of the PSC; and

               6.      to perform such other functions as may be expressly authorized by further

                       orders of this Court.

10.    Privileged Communications.

       Because cooperation among counsel and the parties is essential for the orderly and

expeditious resolution of the litigation, the communication, transmission, or dissemination of

information among plaintiffs’ counsel shall be subject to the joint attorney-client privilege and

the protections afforded by the attorney work-product doctrine; provided, however, that the

conditions necessary to create such a privilege or protection have been satisfied and the privilege


                                                 8
Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 9 of 9



or protection has not been waived.

So Ordered.


                                           /s/ F. Dennis Saylor
                                           F. Dennis Saylor IV
                                           United States District Judge
Dated: April 9, 2013




                                       9

More Related Content

What's hot

Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community Association
Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community AssociationAnswering Brief by Newtown Estates Community Association
Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community AssociationAngela Kaaihue
 
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczek
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczekDoc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczek
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczekmalp2009
 
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...Cocoselul Inaripat
 
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-casehomeworkping7
 
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etc
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etcDoc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etc
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etcmalp2009
 
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- Kaaihue
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- KaaihueNewtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- Kaaihue
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- KaaihueAngela Kaaihue
 
Notice of intervention. Leandro
Notice of intervention. LeandroNotice of intervention. Leandro
Notice of intervention. LeandroEducationNC
 
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela Kaaihue
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela KaaihueRequest for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela Kaaihue
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela KaaihueAngela Kaaihue
 
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-casehomeworkping8
 
Sc order april 6 (2)
Sc order april 6 (2)Sc order april 6 (2)
Sc order april 6 (2)ZahidManiyar
 
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WV
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WVFederal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WV
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WVMarcellus Drilling News
 
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...Cocoselul Inaripat
 
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session Act
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session ActBankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session Act
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session ActHelixSEO
 

What's hot (15)

Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community Association
Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community AssociationAnswering Brief by Newtown Estates Community Association
Answering Brief by Newtown Estates Community Association
 
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczek
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczekDoc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczek
Doc1029 settlement $550_k_buckno lisicky buczek
 
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...
Defendants’ response brief in opposition to plaintiff’s motion for summary ju...
 
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
110305779 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
 
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etc
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etcDoc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etc
Doc577 complaint action against officers directors legal audit etc
 
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- Kaaihue
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- KaaihueNewtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- Kaaihue
Newtown Loses By Default Judgment- NECA -vs- Kaaihue
 
Notice of intervention. Leandro
Notice of intervention. LeandroNotice of intervention. Leandro
Notice of intervention. Leandro
 
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela Kaaihue
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela KaaihueRequest for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela Kaaihue
Request for Entry of Default Judgment in favor for Angela Kaaihue
 
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
169850519 mayor-calixto-cataquiz-case
 
Sc order april 6 (2)
Sc order april 6 (2)Sc order april 6 (2)
Sc order april 6 (2)
 
Ca2 db243062 01
Ca2 db243062 01Ca2 db243062 01
Ca2 db243062 01
 
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WV
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WVFederal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WV
Federal Judge's Decision in EQT v. Fayette County, WV
 
Doc.88 1
Doc.88 1Doc.88 1
Doc.88 1
 
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...
Defendants dismas charties, inc., ana gispert, derek thomas and lashanda adam...
 
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session Act
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session ActBankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session Act
Bankruptcy Attorney Houston | 09/09/2005 Special Session Act
 

Viewers also liked

Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)
Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)
Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)mzamoralaw
 
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinion
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinionMensing Reglan/Generics opinion
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinionmzamoralaw
 
Memento Mori Vi Noite De Poesia Gustavo Dourado
Memento Mori   Vi Noite De Poesia   Gustavo DouradoMemento Mori   Vi Noite De Poesia   Gustavo Dourado
Memento Mori Vi Noite De Poesia Gustavo DouradoMemento Mori
 
Trail v. Lesko
Trail v. LeskoTrail v. Lesko
Trail v. Leskomzamoralaw
 
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEENCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEEmzamoralaw
 
Nucci Target Social Media Discovery
Nucci Target Social Media DiscoveryNucci Target Social Media Discovery
Nucci Target Social Media Discoverymzamoralaw
 
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginia
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria VirginiaLumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginia
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginiamzamoralaw
 
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS mzamoralaw
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Aps
ApsAps
Aps
 
Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)
Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)
Trail v. lesko (social media discovery)
 
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinion
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinionMensing Reglan/Generics opinion
Mensing Reglan/Generics opinion
 
Memento Mori Vi Noite De Poesia Gustavo Dourado
Memento Mori   Vi Noite De Poesia   Gustavo DouradoMemento Mori   Vi Noite De Poesia   Gustavo Dourado
Memento Mori Vi Noite De Poesia Gustavo Dourado
 
Trail v. Lesko
Trail v. LeskoTrail v. Lesko
Trail v. Lesko
 
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEENCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NCAA CONCUSSION MDL, ORDER AND PLAINTIFFS EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
 
Nucci Target Social Media Discovery
Nucci Target Social Media DiscoveryNucci Target Social Media Discovery
Nucci Target Social Media Discovery
 
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginia
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria VirginiaLumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginia
Lumber Liquidators MDL goes to Alexandria Virginia
 
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS
NEBRASKA TRIAL LAWYERS
 

Similar to Neccmdlorder

VW Clean Diesel PSC appointments
VW Clean Diesel PSC appointmentsVW Clean Diesel PSC appointments
VW Clean Diesel PSC appointmentsmzamoralaw
 
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-away
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-awayDoc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-away
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-awaymalp2009
 
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputes
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputesProposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputes
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputesHarve Abella
 
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial Arbitration
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial ArbitrationSaving Time and Costs in Commercial Arbitration
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial ArbitrationOluwaseyi Bamigboye
 
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATIONSAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATIONOluwaseyi Bamigboye
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizurerlhicksjr
 
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesDoc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesmalp2009
 
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesDoc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesmalp2009
 
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99malp2009
 
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...lee_fang
 
Lovenox trial scheduling
Lovenox trial schedulingLovenox trial scheduling
Lovenox trial schedulingJames Hilbert
 
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...Carlton Roark
 
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22Sharon Anderson
 

Similar to Neccmdlorder (20)

VW Clean Diesel PSC appointments
VW Clean Diesel PSC appointmentsVW Clean Diesel PSC appointments
VW Clean Diesel PSC appointments
 
10000001240
1000000124010000001240
10000001240
 
10000001237
1000000123710000001237
10000001237
 
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-away
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-awayDoc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-away
Doc962 freeman group motion compromise & settlement_ a walk-away
 
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputes
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputesProposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputes
Proposed rules on hearing & adjudicating disputes
 
10000001244
1000000124410000001244
10000001244
 
10000001241
1000000124110000001241
10000001241
 
10000001243
1000000124310000001243
10000001243
 
10000001246
1000000124610000001246
10000001246
 
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial Arbitration
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial ArbitrationSaving Time and Costs in Commercial Arbitration
Saving Time and Costs in Commercial Arbitration
 
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATIONSAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION
SAVING TIME AND COSTS IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
 
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesDoc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
 
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in feesDoc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
Doc1014 attorney volker going for $1 m in fees
 
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99
Doc1031 pay day for lynn tillotson pinker & cox $189,945.99
 
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...
1003 . 3_appendix_-_supp_brief_mtn_re_772_relief_from_rcvrship_order_bukrinsk...
 
Lovenox trial scheduling
Lovenox trial schedulingLovenox trial scheduling
Lovenox trial scheduling
 
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Disregards Criminal Conspiracy by Attorneys as Officers...
 
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22
SharonsDefaultJudgmentvsCitySt.Paul,MN 5 jul07ratasslegal 22
 
2365026_1
2365026_12365026_1
2365026_1
 

More from mzamoralaw

Wright v marshaw
Wright v marshawWright v marshaw
Wright v marshawmzamoralaw
 
Worley v. YMCA
Worley v. YMCAWorley v. YMCA
Worley v. YMCAmzamoralaw
 
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)mzamoralaw
 
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challenges
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challengesOpinion grossman FL preemptory challenges
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challengesmzamoralaw
 
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd party
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd partyJudge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd party
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd partymzamoralaw
 
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTS
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTSNEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTS
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTSmzamoralaw
 
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDER
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDERSchedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDER
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDERmzamoralaw
 
Morcellator Lawyer Georgia
Morcellator Lawyer GeorgiaMorcellator Lawyer Georgia
Morcellator Lawyer Georgiamzamoralaw
 
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damages
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive DamagesFirst LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damages
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damagesmzamoralaw
 
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprint
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprintTrial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprint
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprintmzamoralaw
 
GA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionment
GA Court of Appeals Double View ApportionmentGA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionment
GA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionmentmzamoralaw
 
Jpml2testosteron e d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actions
Jpml2testosteron e  d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actionsJpml2testosteron e  d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actions
Jpml2testosteron e d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actionsmzamoralaw
 
Jpml1testosterone low testerone litigaiton brief in support of transfer
Jpml1testosterone  low testerone litigaiton  brief in support of transferJpml1testosterone  low testerone litigaiton  brief in support of transfer
Jpml1testosterone low testerone litigaiton brief in support of transfermzamoralaw
 
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidation
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidationJpml motion for transfer and consolidation
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidationmzamoralaw
 
Decision and direction of election northwestern
Decision and direction of election northwesternDecision and direction of election northwestern
Decision and direction of election northwesternmzamoralaw
 
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?mzamoralaw
 

More from mzamoralaw (20)

Ladue
LadueLadue
Ladue
 
MGM Complaint
MGM ComplaintMGM Complaint
MGM Complaint
 
Wright v marshaw
Wright v marshawWright v marshaw
Wright v marshaw
 
Worley v. YMCA
Worley v. YMCAWorley v. YMCA
Worley v. YMCA
 
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)
Mdl 2767-initial transfer-03-17 (1)
 
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challenges
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challengesOpinion grossman FL preemptory challenges
Opinion grossman FL preemptory challenges
 
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd party
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd partyJudge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd party
Judge's ruling on seeling bills to 3rd party
 
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTS
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTSNEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTS
NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL CEASE AND DESIST LETTER HERBAL PRODUCTS
 
USA v.Mira
USA v.Mira USA v.Mira
USA v.Mira
 
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDER
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDERSchedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDER
Schedule of action androgel MDL AND TRANSFER ORDER
 
Ftc national
Ftc nationalFtc national
Ftc national
 
Morcellator Lawyer Georgia
Morcellator Lawyer GeorgiaMorcellator Lawyer Georgia
Morcellator Lawyer Georgia
 
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damages
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive DamagesFirst LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damages
First LowT Complaint filed in Georgia Punitive Damages
 
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprint
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprintTrial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprint
Trial 2014 3_mar_dougherty, bruera_reprint
 
GA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionment
GA Court of Appeals Double View ApportionmentGA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionment
GA Court of Appeals Double View Apportionment
 
Jpml2testosteron e d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actions
Jpml2testosteron e  d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actionsJpml2testosteron e  d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actions
Jpml2testosteron e d's response to plainitffs motion to coordinate actions
 
Jpml1testosterone low testerone litigaiton brief in support of transfer
Jpml1testosterone  low testerone litigaiton  brief in support of transferJpml1testosterone  low testerone litigaiton  brief in support of transfer
Jpml1testosterone low testerone litigaiton brief in support of transfer
 
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidation
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidationJpml motion for transfer and consolidation
Jpml motion for transfer and consolidation
 
Decision and direction of election northwestern
Decision and direction of election northwesternDecision and direction of election northwestern
Decision and direction of election northwestern
 
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?
Low testosterone and claimed heart injuries?
 

Neccmdlorder

  • 1. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 1 of 9 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS _______________________________________ ) IN RE: NEW ENGLAND ) COMPOUNDING PHARMACY, INC. ) MDL No. 1:13-md-2419-FDS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION ) ) This Document Relates To: ) ) All Actions ) ) ) MDL Order No. 2 April 9, 2013 ORDER APPOINTING LEAD COUNSEL, FEDERAL-STATE LIAISON COUNSEL, AND PLAINTIFFS’ STEERING COMMITTEE This order is intended to create a leadership structure for plaintiffs’ counsel in order to organize, simplify, and streamline the handling of these matters on behalf of all plaintiffs, consistent with the fair administration of justice. 1. Lead Counsel The Court hereby appoints the following individual as Lead Counsel: Thomas M. Sobol (with Kristen Johnson Parker as his alternate) HAGENS BERMAN SOBOL SHAPIRO LLP 55 Cambridge Parkway, Suite 301 Cambridge, MA 02142 Phone:(617)482-3700 Fax:(617)482-3003 tom@hbsslaw.com kristenjp@hbsslaw.com The responsibilities of Lead Counsel are set forth in section 7 of this order. 2. Federal-State Liaison Counsel The Court hereby appoints the following individual as Federal-State Liaison Counsel:
  • 2. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 2 of 9 Mark P. Chalos (with Elizabeth J. Cabraser as his alternate) LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, LLP 150 Fourth Avenue, North Suite 1650 Nashville, TN 37219 Phone:(615)313.9000 Fax:(615)313.9965 mchalos@lchb.com ecabraser@lchb.com The responsibilities of Lead Counsel are set forth in section 8 of this order. 3. Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee The Court hereby appoints the following individuals to the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee (“PSC”): Thomas M. Sobol (with Kristen Johnson Parker as his alternate) Mark P. Chalos (with Elizabeth J. Cabraser as his alternate) Marc E. Lipton Kim Dougherty LIPTON LAW JANET, JENNER & SUGGS, LLC 18930 W. 10 Mile Road 75 Arlington St. Southfield, MI 48075 Suite 500 Phone: (248) 557-1688 Boston, MA 02116 Fax: (248) 557-6344 Phone: (617) 933-1265 marc@liptonlawcenter.com kdougherty@myadvocates.com Patrick T. Fennell J. Gerard Stranch, IV CRANDALL & KATT BRANSTETTER, STRANCH & 366 Elm Avenue, S.W. JENNINGS PLLC Roanoke, Virginia 24016 227 Second Avenue North Phone: (540) 342-2000 Nashville, TN 37201 Fax: (540) 400-0616 Phone: (615) 254-8801 pfennell@crandalllaw.com Fax: (615) 255-5419 gerards@branstetterlaw.com 2
  • 3. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 3 of 9 Mark Zamora ZAMORA FIRM 6 Concourse Parkway, 22nd Floor Atlanta, GA 30328 Phone: (404) 451-7781 Fax: (404) 506-9223 mark@markzamora.com The responsibilities of the PSC are set forth in section 9 of this order. 4. Changes in Membership These appointments are personal in nature, and may not be changed without court order. 5. Alternates The two alternate members may perform responsibilities under this order at the direction of the appointed member. 6. Designated Counsel The PSC may appoint other qualified plaintiffs’ counsel to perform legal services for the common benefit of plaintiffs (“Designated Counsel”). 7. Responsibilities of Lead Counsel Lead Counsel shall have the following responsibilities: 1. to chair the PSC, which shall be generally responsible for coordinating the activities of plaintiffs’ counsel during pretrial proceedings; 2. to present, after consultation with the PSC and other counsel as may be appropriate, personally or by a designee, the position of the plaintiffs on any matter arising during pretrial proceedings; 3. to delegate specific tasks to other counsel in a manner to ensure that pretrial preparation for the plaintiffs is conducted effectively, efficiently, 3
  • 4. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 4 of 9 and economically, including the creation of subject matter-specific or other working groups; 4. to prepare and distribute to the parties periodic status reports, as appropriate; 5. to maintain adequate time and disbursement records covering services as Designated Counsel; 6. to coordinate and lead discussions with the Court, plaintiffs’ counsel and other stakeholders (for example, the NECP trustee and its counsel, the creditors’ committee and its counsel, other defense counsel, and non-parties) to ensure that court orders are followed, schedules are met, discovery is conducted and provided consistent with the requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P. 26, unnecessary expenditures of time and funds are avoided, and any negotiations are reasonably efficient and productive; 7. to coordinate, with the assistance of the Federal-State Liaison Counsel, with counsel in related state-court litigation, in order to avoid duplicative discovery, including minimizing the number of depositions taken of each witness, minimizing the number of lawyers who question witnesses at depositions, and reducing duplicative questioning; 8. to maintain an up-to-date comprehensive service list of plaintiffs’ counsel in MDL 2419 and promptly advise the Court of any changes; 9. to receive and distribute to plaintiffs’ counsel, as appropriate, orders, notices and correspondence from the Court; 4
  • 5. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 5 of 9 10. to maintain and make available to other plaintiffs’ counsel, on reasonable notice and at reasonable times, a complete set of all pleadings and orders filed and/or served in MDL 2419; and 11. to establish and maintain, in conjunction with the PSC and to the extent deemed desirable by the PSC, a physical or virtual depository located within the Court’s jurisdiction, or otherwise accessible to all plaintiffs’ counsel. Lead counsel shall be involved in any class or group settlement discussions, whether with a single defendant or multiple defendants, whether taking place in the MDL or the bankruptcy. 8. Responsibilities of Federal-State Liaison Counsel Federal-State Liaison Counsel shall have the following responsibilities: 1. where practicable, to communicate with attorneys prosecuting related state-court actions in order to ascertain their status; 2. to provide information about related state-court proceedings to the Court and counsel; 3. to help coordinate discovery and litigation efforts between state and federal proceedings to avoid, where possible, duplicative or conflicting efforts; and 4. to assist in providing access to participating state-court counsel to any common-benefit document depository and common-benefit work-product, in accordance with the terms of any common-benefit orders entered by the Court. 5
  • 6. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 6 of 9 Should the need for a Federal-State Liaison become unnecessary, the person holding that position shall retain his appointment to the plaintiffs’ steering committee. 9. Responsibilities of PSC The PSC shall have the following responsibilities: A. Discovery 1. to initiate, coordinate, and conduct all pretrial discovery on behalf of plaintiffs in all actions subject to this order; 2. to develop and propose to the Court schedules for the commencement, execution, and completion of all discovery on behalf of all plaintiffs; 3. to cause to be issued in the name of all plaintiffs the necessary discovery requests, motions, and subpoenas concerning any witnesses and documents needed to prepare for the trial of this litigation (similar requests, motions, and subpoenas may be caused to be issued by the PSC upon written request by an individual attorney in order to assist him or her in the preparation of the pretrial stages of his or her client’s particular claims); and 4. to conduct all discovery, by members or their designees approved by Lead Counsel, in a coordinated and consolidated manner on behalf and for the benefit of all plaintiffs. B. Hearings and Meetings 1. to call meetings of counsel for plaintiffs for any appropriate purpose, including coordinating responses to questions of other parties or of the 6
  • 7. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 7 of 9 Court; 2. to initiate proposals, suggestions, schedules, or joint briefs, and any other appropriate matters concerning pretrial proceedings; 3. to examine witnesses and introduce evidence at hearings on behalf of plaintiffs; and 4. to speak for all plaintiffs at pretrial proceedings and in response to any inquiries by the Court, subject to the right of any plaintiff’s counsel to present non-repetitive individual or different positions. C. Trial 1. to coordinate the selection, management, and presentation of any common issue, “bellwether” and/or “test” case trials. D. Settlement and Miscellaneous 1. to negotiate and propose settlement of cases on behalf of plaintiffs or plaintiff groups, including exploring and, where appropriate, pursuing all settlement options concerning any claim or portion thereof of any case filed in this litigation; 2. to litigate any motions presented to the Court that involve matters within the sphere of the responsibilities of the PSC; 3. to negotiate and enter into stipulations with defendants concerning this litigation; provided, however, that all stipulations entered into by the PSC, except for strictly administrative details such as scheduling, must be submitted for Court approval and will not be binding until the Court has 7
  • 8. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 8 of 9 ratified the stipulation, and that any attorney not in agreement with a non-administrative stipulation shall file with the Court a written objection thereto within five days after he/she knows or should have reasonably become aware of the stipulation, and that failure to object within the term allowed shall be deemed a waiver and the stipulation will automatically be binding on that party; 4. to maintain adequate files of all pretrial matters, including establishing and maintaining a document or exhibit depository, in either real or virtual format, and having those documents available, under reasonable terms and conditions, for examination by all plaintiffs’ counsel; 5. to perform any task necessary and proper for the PSC to accomplish its responsibilities as defined by the Court’s orders, including organizing subcommittees or workgroups comprised of plaintiffs’ attorneys not on the PSC and assigning them tasks consistent with the duties of the PSC; and 6. to perform such other functions as may be expressly authorized by further orders of this Court. 10. Privileged Communications. Because cooperation among counsel and the parties is essential for the orderly and expeditious resolution of the litigation, the communication, transmission, or dissemination of information among plaintiffs’ counsel shall be subject to the joint attorney-client privilege and the protections afforded by the attorney work-product doctrine; provided, however, that the conditions necessary to create such a privilege or protection have been satisfied and the privilege 8
  • 9. Case 1:13-md-02419-FDS Document 82 Filed 04/09/13 Page 9 of 9 or protection has not been waived. So Ordered. /s/ F. Dennis Saylor F. Dennis Saylor IV United States District Judge Dated: April 9, 2013 9