Built on the past, designed for the future- John Hewitt, Rethinking Housebuil...
Manual for Streets 1
1. Manual for Streets 1
The Contribution of Streets
to Successful Places to Live
Birmingham
18 April 2011
Phil Jones, PJA
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
2. What is a street anyway?
“A street is a highway that has important public realm functions beyond
the movement of traffic” (Manual for Streets)
Streets have a sense of place and are distinctive
Streets are lined with and provide direct access to buildings and public spaces
Most highways in built-up areas can be considered as streets.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
3. What are roads for?
‘The word ‘road’ derives
from the Old English word for a
journey on horseback: a road was
something that one rode along’
(Dictionary of Urbanism)
‘Roads are essentially highways
whose main function is
accommodating the movement of
motor traffic.’
(Manual for Streets)
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
4. Previous National Guidance on Residential Roads
Design Bulletin 32 Second Edition (1992)
“Residential roads and footpaths are an
integral part of housing layout where ... in the
patterns of movement around buildings the
needs of pedestrians and cyclists for safety
and convenience are given priority in design
over the use of motor vehicles.”
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
5. But highly standardised car-led geometric standards...
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
7. “Some housing, such as this, meets planning and highway standards,
but fails to create a sense of place or identity. We need to set our
sights higher”
The Communities Plan - 2003
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
8. Welcome to
The Midlands!!
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
20. Building for Life - 4 Groups, 20 Criteria
Environment and Community
Character
Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Design and Construction
Streets are fundamental to the assessment...
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
21. Q4. Does the development have easy access to public transport?
Group 1 -
Environment & Community
The Village, St Austell
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
22. Q9. Do the buildings and layout make it easy to find your way around?
The Village, St Austell
Group 2 - Character
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
23. Q 10. Are the streets defined by a well-structured
building layout?
The Russells, Broadway, Worcestershire
Group 2 - Character
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
24. Q11. Does the building layout take priority over the streets and car
parking, so that the highways do not dominate?
The Meadows, Shepton Mallet Broadclose, Bude
Group 3 - Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
25. Q12. Is the car parking well integrated and situated so it supports
the street scene?
Broadclose, Bude, Cornwall Lime Tree Square, Street, Somerset
Group 3 - Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
26. Q13. Are the streets pedestrian, cycle and vehicle friendly?
Victoria Gardens, Camelford, North Cornwall
Group 3 - Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
27. Q14. Does the scheme integrate with existing streets, paths and
surrounding development?
The Russells, Broadway, Worcestershire
Group 3 - Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
28. Q15. Are public spaces and pedestrian routes overlooked and do
they feel safe?
Gwean Pawl Urban Village, Redruth Clay Field, Elmswell, Suffolk
Group 3 - Streets, Parking & Pedestrianisation
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
29. Manual for Streets (2007)
Streets are the arteries of our
communities – a community’s
success can depend on how well
it is connected to local services
and the wider world.
However, streets are not just
there to get people from
A to B – they have many other
functions.
They form vital components of
residential areas and greatly
affect the overall quality of life for
local people.
(MfS Foreword)
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
30. Aims of Manual for Streets
Bring about a transformation in quality
A fundamental culture change to achieve streets that:
– help to build and strengthen the communities they
serve;
– meet the needs of all, by embodying the principles of
inclusive design
– provide part of a well-connected network;
– are attractive and have their own distinctive identity;
– are cost-effective to construct and maintain; and
– are safe.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
31. Manual for Streets -
Status and application
Manual for Streets replaced DB32
Applies throughout England and Wales
Focuses on lightly-trafficked residential streets; but
Many of its principles are applicable elsewhere, eg high streets and lanes
It is guidance, not a standard or policy document
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
32. Working in partnership
• Truly multidisciplinary teams: planners, highways
engineers, transport planners, researchers, urban
and landscape designers...
• Crossing sectors: local people, elected members,
consultants, local authority officers, campaign
groups, utilities, homebuilders…
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
33. Sustainability
MfS promotes walking, cycling, public transport due to...
– Climate change/emissions
– Congestion
– Accidents
– Health issues
Labyrinthine and badly connected places encourage car use
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
34. Mode hierarchy
Consider modes in order:
– Pedestrians
– Cyclists
– Public Transport
– Motor vehicles
Accommodate all users on streets
Tight corner radii level crossings
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
35. Developing a Movement Framework
Where are the key desire lines?
How can the development enhance the existing
movement framework rather than disrupt or sever it?
What points of connection and linkage
can be achieved?
Should these be for all modes?
Can concerns over ‘rat running’ be
addressed through slower speeds?
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
36. Street Character Types
Consider
– Key dimensions (widths etc)
– Relationship to buildings and private realm
– Parking
– Materials
– Planting etc
Terminology important
– Eg avenue, mews, lane, boulevard
– Not Minor Access Road, Local Distributor Road
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
37. Assembling Streets...
Junctions as places
Street width considerations:
– Traffic composition
– Pedestrian flow
– Parking
– Width/height ratios
– Swept paths
– Trees
Designing in three
dimensions
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
38. Visibility
MfS recommends shorter ‘Y’/forward sight distances
than previous guidance
No safety case for ‘X’ distance of more than 2.4m
Can consider splays measured beyond the kerb
Design Miles per hour 37 30 25 20
Speed
DB32 - Y Distances (Metres) 90 70 45 33
Manual for Streets - Y Distances 59 43 33 25
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
39. Why are reduced visibility splays so critical?
Shorter sight lines helps to make urban development happen:
Sites that were previously undevelopable can now come forward
Maximising use of accessible, brownfield sites
Enabling higher densities
Less need for unsustainable greenfield sites
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
40. Y
X
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
41. Speed at Junctions and Links
Speed increases with road width and visibility for both links and junctions
30 45
40
25
Road Width = 5 m 35 Road Width = 5 m
Road Width = 6 m
Speed (mph)
20 Road Width = 6 m
Speed (mph)
30
Road Width = 7 m 25 Road Width = 7 m
15
Road Width = 8 m 20 Road Width = 8 m
10 Road Width = 9 m 15 Road Width = 9 m
Road Width = 10 m 10 Road Width = 10 m
5
5
0 0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Y Distance (m) Forward Visibility (m)
Junction data Link data
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
43. Frontage Access Research
Accident and Traffic Flow Data
examined for 20 sites
Traffic flows up to 23,000 per day
Very few recorded accidents
involving driveways
No safety justification for limiting
direct access to busier streets
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
45. Local Standards
Local standards are important to reflect local context
Local standards need to cover placemaking and urban design
Focus on improving local distinctiveness
– Vernacular details
– Material choices
Local authorities are strongly recommended to review
standards and guidance to embrace MfS principles.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
46. The Lincolnshire Design Guide for
Residential Areas (1996) advocates
the qualities of traditional settlements
over those of recent developments by
juxtaposing illustrations of both.
In the following pages it then proceeds
to propose a road layout which would
clearly make it impossible ever to
produce the type of traditional
settlement that is considered so
admirable.
Sue McGlynn and Ivor Samuels, 2000.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
47. Suffolk Residential Design Guide
“There have been many changes since
1993 in planning policy relating to
housing and a greater emphasis on
achieving higher quality design. The
SDG is now showing its age.”
It is anticipated that Manual for Streets
will be supplemented in Suffolk...
Work is progressing...
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
48. Worcestershire CC new standards...
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
50. Leicestershire/East Midlands guidance
Initial review in 2007 following MfS – but mainly junction visibility
More comprehensive review said to be pending...
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
55. Quality Audits
Quality Audits introduced in MfS1 - a ‘Balanced Audit’ reviewing key
aspects of a design against set objectives
Some authorities (eg Kent, Solihull) have taken the concept further
CIHT working towards a guidance note on Quality Audits.
Policy Review
Objective Setting
Design
Quality Auditing
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
56. Car Parking
Parking solutions should not dominate the scheme, and
should be carefully considered to reduce the impact of
parking spaces on the character and layout of the
development.
The Taylor Review.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
57. Car parking - key principles
No single best solution to providing car parking.
A combination of solutions will often be
appropriate
“Rediscover the street as a beautiful car park”
On-street parking is efficient, understandable and
can increase vitality and safety
Rear courtyards need to support on-street
parking, not replace it.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
61. Efficiency of types of parking
Level of efficiency/ Type of parking Comments
flexibility
On-street (communal) Most efficient as
High parking spaces are
shared and the street
provides the means of
accessing the spaces.
Off-street communal Requires additional
access and circulation
space.
Off-street allocated Although more
spaces but grouped inflexible, this
arrangement allows the
potential for future
changes in allocation.
Off-street allocated Inflexible, and largely
garages but grouped precludes shared use.
Also security concerns.
Off-street within Inflexible in perpetuity
individual dwelling and more space
curtilage consuming due to need
Low for driveways.
Garages within
individual dwelling
curtilage
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
62. Tricky Issues - Adoption
Highway Authority can refuse to adopt due to
concerns over geometry and maintenance issues –
visibility splays, radii, carriageway widths
materials, street trees and planting, sustainable
drainage...etc.
Solutions –
Development of protocols for collaborative
working with highways officers
Continuous learning from experience
Development of better standards
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
63. Tricky Issues – Level Surface Streets
Concerns of visually-impaired/vulnerable people
over ‘shared space’ designs has extended to very
lightly-trafficked streets.
Solutions – recognition of pros and cons of level
surfaces, close dialogue with relevant groups,
appropriate traffic speeds and volumes.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
72. “The quality of the public realm (streets, squares and open
space) generally does not reflect the quality of the
architectural heritage of Buxton town centre.”
Buxton Design Strategy
High Peak BC will work with Derbyshire CC to see that
highway works, including the design and construction of new
roads or highway improvements...reflect the Strategy as far
as possible. This will be key to raising the quality of the
public realm in the town centre.
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions
73. Discussion Points
- Geometry
- Materials
- Parking
- Level Surface Streets
- Trees and Planting
Phil Jones Associates sustainable transport solutions