SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Guardian Letters 20 April 2012



So former prison service boss Martin Narey declines to apologise for the
abuse at Medomsley. It makes you wonder whether he was suitable to be
chief executive of Barnado's, or, for that matter, the current adoption
tsar.


Robin Wendt
 Chester



Guardian Letters 11 May 2012



Martin Narey has called for an inquiry into the "over-representation by
Asian men in child exploitation" (Grooming offences committed mostly
by Asian men, says ex-Barnardo's chief, 9 May). What does he know
about child exploitation? As former director general of the prison service
and assistant governor of Deerbolt prison, Narey failed to apologise for
the widespread rape and beating of children when it was brought into the
open on his watch (How did Neville Husband get away with the horrific
abuse of teenagers in his care?, Weekend, 14 April)…

Cristel AmissBlack Women's Rape Action Project, Kiki
AxelssonWomen Against Rape,Nina López Legal Action for Women



The Press Complaints Commission consideration:



[The Guardian] newspaper published two readers' letters which
claimed that [Martin Narey] had refused or declined to apologise
for child abuse that had taken place in the prison system at the
hands of Neville Husband. The newspaper had been aware that
the abuse had taken place long before the complainant had even
joined the prison service, and that the victims had sued the Home
Office when he no longer was in the service and was not therefore
in a position to publicly apologise on its behalf. It had known that
there was no question of him declining to apologise to the families,
yet published the letters anyway. The complainant had contacted
the newspaper in regard to each of these inaccuracies but it had
consistently failed to afford him a right of reply.



RESOLUTION:

The complaint was resolved when…the following letter from the
complainant [was published]:


On April 14, Eric Allison and Simon Hattenstone wrote an important
piece about the historic abuse of children in custody by a Prison Officer,
Neville Husband. I took little issue with Eric's moving account.
Subsequently however the Guardian published two letters. The first said
that I had declined to apologise for the abuse (and because of that had
been unsuitable to lead Barnardo's as I did for six years). The second
implied that, as Director General of the Prison Service I had tolerated the
widespread rape and beating of children.
Husband's offending began when I was thirteen years of age and the
offences for which he was subsequently convicted took place in 1977 when
I was still at University, five years before I joined the Prison Service and
twenty one years before I became Director General. Later, when
Husband's victims sued the Prison Service, I had resigned from the
Home Office and was in no position to make a response. The Guardian
knew from E mail exchanges however, that I stood ready to make public
my personal apology, and that I had, many years ago, expressed regret
about the abuse.
I do not deny the appalling nature of Husband's crimes. But it should not
have needed me to complain to the Press Complaints Commission before
this letter was published to make clear that the abuse did not occur when
I was in a position of authority, and that I did not tolerate the abuse or
fail to express my regret for it.

I may have had many failings as Director General of the Prison Service.
But failing to address the abuse of prisoners of any age was not one of
them.
Taken from:

http://www.pcc.org.uk/news/index.html?article=ODAwMg==

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie The guardian, neville husband and the pcc

A Story of Violence12
A Story of Violence12A Story of Violence12
A Story of Violence12TRENTESTA
 
Rand Kannenberg Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders Change
Rand Kannenberg   Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders ChangeRand Kannenberg   Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders Change
Rand Kannenberg Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders ChangeRand Kannenberg
 
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.Heidi Wilson
 
Newstory compressed
Newstory compressedNewstory compressed
Newstory compressedjackwendel2
 
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...CSSaunders
 
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuse
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuseMeeting the challenge of child sexual abuse
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuseUniversity of Salford
 
Feminist jurisprudence
Feminist jurisprudenceFeminist jurisprudence
Feminist jurisprudenceKaitlynHogan2
 
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017Nita Newsome
 
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.Alicia Brooks
 
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name Rae.docx
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name  Rae.docxInformative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name  Rae.docx
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name Rae.docxdirkrplav
 
Rand Kannenberg Professional Ethics In Corrections
Rand Kannenberg   Professional Ethics In CorrectionsRand Kannenberg   Professional Ethics In Corrections
Rand Kannenberg Professional Ethics In CorrectionsRand Kannenberg
 
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse Rydal Penrhos School Abuse
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse Alexander Curzon
 
Whether ithappenedornot
Whether ithappenedornotWhether ithappenedornot
Whether ithappenedornotshelbotts
 

Ähnlich wie The guardian, neville husband and the pcc (20)

ECP
ECPECP
ECP
 
A Story of Violence12
A Story of Violence12A Story of Violence12
A Story of Violence12
 
Hargitay100520
Hargitay100520Hargitay100520
Hargitay100520
 
Rand Kannenberg Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders Change
Rand Kannenberg   Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders ChangeRand Kannenberg   Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders Change
Rand Kannenberg Theories And Models Of Helping Offenders Change
 
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Early Pregnancy Persuasive Essay. Online assignment writing service.
 
Newstory compressed
Newstory compressedNewstory compressed
Newstory compressed
 
Bcit bcgeu
Bcit bcgeuBcit bcgeu
Bcit bcgeu
 
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...
Professor Mike Nash: Vulnerability and public protection - have we got the ba...
 
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuse
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuseMeeting the challenge of child sexual abuse
Meeting the challenge of child sexual abuse
 
Feminist jurisprudence
Feminist jurisprudenceFeminist jurisprudence
Feminist jurisprudence
 
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017
Judge & Priestley Legal Update for Private Clients Winter 2017
 
Bcgeu scam
Bcgeu scamBcgeu scam
Bcgeu scam
 
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Printable Lined Paper. Online assignment writing service.
 
patrick lee browne
patrick lee brownepatrick lee browne
patrick lee browne
 
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name Rae.docx
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name  Rae.docxInformative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name  Rae.docx
Informative SpeechBy Raeo LoudermillStudent Name Rae.docx
 
Rand Kannenberg Professional Ethics In Corrections
Rand Kannenberg   Professional Ethics In CorrectionsRand Kannenberg   Professional Ethics In Corrections
Rand Kannenberg Professional Ethics In Corrections
 
Homophobia
HomophobiaHomophobia
Homophobia
 
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse Rydal Penrhos School Abuse
Rydal Penrhos School Abuse
 
Whether ithappenedornot
Whether ithappenedornotWhether ithappenedornot
Whether ithappenedornot
 
Rydal Penrhos Abuse
Rydal Penrhos AbuseRydal Penrhos Abuse
Rydal Penrhos Abuse
 

Mehr von Sir Martin Narey

Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decent
Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decentIcpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decent
Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decentSir Martin Narey
 
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.Sir Martin Narey
 
Joining the prison service brief reflections
Joining the prison service brief reflectionsJoining the prison service brief reflections
Joining the prison service brief reflectionsSir Martin Narey
 
2903652 rotherham response_acc2
2903652 rotherham response_acc22903652 rotherham response_acc2
2903652 rotherham response_acc2Sir Martin Narey
 
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?Sir Martin Narey
 
Adoption muddle is costing children their futures
Adoption muddle is costing children their futuresAdoption muddle is costing children their futures
Adoption muddle is costing children their futuresSir Martin Narey
 
Adoption luckock and broadhurst
Adoption luckock and broadhurstAdoption luckock and broadhurst
Adoption luckock and broadhurstSir Martin Narey
 
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014Sir Martin Narey
 
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014Sir Martin Narey
 
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)Sir Martin Narey
 
Alb impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)
Alb   impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)Alb   impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)
Alb impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)Sir Martin Narey
 
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 nov
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 novMythbuster op ed final mon 10 nov
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 novSir Martin Narey
 
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014Sir Martin Narey
 
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW Education
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW EducationPractice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW Education
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW EducationSir Martin Narey
 
The Times the Adoption Leadership Board
The Times  the Adoption Leadership BoardThe Times  the Adoption Leadership Board
The Times the Adoption Leadership BoardSir Martin Narey
 
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families act
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families actSection 9 of the 2014 children and families act
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families actSir Martin Narey
 
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)Sir Martin Narey
 
Fathers should not fear family courts
Fathers should not fear family courtsFathers should not fear family courts
Fathers should not fear family courtsSir Martin Narey
 

Mehr von Sir Martin Narey (20)

Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decent
Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decentIcpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decent
Icpa forget the bogus cures. just make prisons decent
 
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.
Forget about rehabilitation, concentrate on making prisons decent.
 
Joining the prison service brief reflections
Joining the prison service brief reflectionsJoining the prison service brief reflections
Joining the prison service brief reflections
 
Rcr jchr extract
Rcr jchr extractRcr jchr extract
Rcr jchr extract
 
Adcs speech july 2015
Adcs speech july 2015Adcs speech july 2015
Adcs speech july 2015
 
2903652 rotherham response_acc2
2903652 rotherham response_acc22903652 rotherham response_acc2
2903652 rotherham response_acc2
 
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?
Need we panic about the fall in placement orders?
 
Adoption muddle is costing children their futures
Adoption muddle is costing children their futuresAdoption muddle is costing children their futures
Adoption muddle is costing children their futures
 
Adoption luckock and broadhurst
Adoption luckock and broadhurstAdoption luckock and broadhurst
Adoption luckock and broadhurst
 
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014
The case for adoption in a nutshell from Sir James Munby, December 2014
 
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014
Munby judgement on adoption: December 2014
 
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)
Adoption cypn nov 2014 (1)
 
Alb impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)
Alb   impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)Alb   impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)
Alb impact of court judgments on adoption - november 2014 (1) (1)
 
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 nov
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 novMythbuster op ed final mon 10 nov
Mythbuster op ed final mon 10 nov
 
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014
Press release pupil premium + adop register july2014
 
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW Education
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW EducationPractice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW Education
Practice Educator's view of the Narey report on Children's SW Education
 
The Times the Adoption Leadership Board
The Times  the Adoption Leadership BoardThe Times  the Adoption Leadership Board
The Times the Adoption Leadership Board
 
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families act
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families actSection 9 of the 2014 children and families act
Section 9 of the 2014 children and families act
 
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)
ELEVEN THINGS THAT PEOPLE TOLD ME ABOUT MY REPORT (BEFORE THEY’D SEEN IT)
 
Fathers should not fear family courts
Fathers should not fear family courtsFathers should not fear family courts
Fathers should not fear family courts
 

The guardian, neville husband and the pcc

  • 1. Guardian Letters 20 April 2012 So former prison service boss Martin Narey declines to apologise for the abuse at Medomsley. It makes you wonder whether he was suitable to be chief executive of Barnado's, or, for that matter, the current adoption tsar.
 Robin Wendt
 Chester Guardian Letters 11 May 2012 Martin Narey has called for an inquiry into the "over-representation by Asian men in child exploitation" (Grooming offences committed mostly by Asian men, says ex-Barnardo's chief, 9 May). What does he know about child exploitation? As former director general of the prison service and assistant governor of Deerbolt prison, Narey failed to apologise for the widespread rape and beating of children when it was brought into the open on his watch (How did Neville Husband get away with the horrific abuse of teenagers in his care?, Weekend, 14 April)… Cristel AmissBlack Women's Rape Action Project, Kiki AxelssonWomen Against Rape,Nina López Legal Action for Women The Press Complaints Commission consideration: [The Guardian] newspaper published two readers' letters which claimed that [Martin Narey] had refused or declined to apologise for child abuse that had taken place in the prison system at the hands of Neville Husband. The newspaper had been aware that the abuse had taken place long before the complainant had even joined the prison service, and that the victims had sued the Home Office when he no longer was in the service and was not therefore in a position to publicly apologise on its behalf. It had known that
  • 2. there was no question of him declining to apologise to the families, yet published the letters anyway. The complainant had contacted the newspaper in regard to each of these inaccuracies but it had consistently failed to afford him a right of reply. RESOLUTION: The complaint was resolved when…the following letter from the complainant [was published]: On April 14, Eric Allison and Simon Hattenstone wrote an important piece about the historic abuse of children in custody by a Prison Officer, Neville Husband. I took little issue with Eric's moving account. Subsequently however the Guardian published two letters. The first said that I had declined to apologise for the abuse (and because of that had been unsuitable to lead Barnardo's as I did for six years). The second implied that, as Director General of the Prison Service I had tolerated the widespread rape and beating of children. Husband's offending began when I was thirteen years of age and the offences for which he was subsequently convicted took place in 1977 when I was still at University, five years before I joined the Prison Service and twenty one years before I became Director General. Later, when Husband's victims sued the Prison Service, I had resigned from the Home Office and was in no position to make a response. The Guardian knew from E mail exchanges however, that I stood ready to make public my personal apology, and that I had, many years ago, expressed regret about the abuse. I do not deny the appalling nature of Husband's crimes. But it should not have needed me to complain to the Press Complaints Commission before this letter was published to make clear that the abuse did not occur when I was in a position of authority, and that I did not tolerate the abuse or fail to express my regret for it. I may have had many failings as Director General of the Prison Service. But failing to address the abuse of prisoners of any age was not one of them.