SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 41
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Evolution of
                      Low Cost Airlines
                      Mark Diamond, P i i l ICF SH&E
                      M k Di     d Principal,
                      MPP 1986


                      Prepared for:




                      21 September 2011


icfi.com/aviation |                                    0
Agenda


                1. ICF SH&E summary

                2. What defines a Low Cost Carrier (LCC)?

                3. Evolution of LCC’s

                4. Added bonus: the airline network planning process

                5. Q&A




icfi.com/aviation |                                                    1
SECTION 1

                      ICF SH&E summary




icfi.com/aviation |                      2
ICF SH&E is a consulting firm exclusively dedicated to the
g
global air transport industry
                p           y


                       Specialty consulting firm with over 70 staff
                       Founded in 1963
                       Performed over 8,000 individual engagements worldwide
                       Full-service offices in Boston, New York and London, with
                        specialists worldwide
                       Staff recruited from airlines airports academia finance
                                             airlines, airports, academia, finance,
                        government agencies, manufacturers and IT
                       Joined publicly-held ICF International in December 2007




icfi.com/aviation |                                                                   3
Our client base spans the aviation industry and its
participants

                       Passenger airlines
                       Air cargo express & integrated logistics operators
                            cargo,
                       Major & regional airports
                       National, regional & local governments
                       International development agencies
                       Maintenance, repair, & overhaul (MRO) providers
                       Airframe, engine & avionics suppliers
                       Leasing companies, IT, equipment & service providers
                       Investors & financial institutions
                       Booking, distribution & travel services
                       Corporate & business aviation




icfi.com/aviation |                                                            4
Selected airlines we’ve worked with
 Spain
   p      Ireland       France         UK             Luxembourg
                                                               g   Netherlands Germany Scandinavia Finland
                                                                                       y                       Poland        Hungary Romania
                                                                                                                                g y                      Russia     Bulgaria
                                                                                                                                                                       g       Czech.
 Iberia   Aer Lingus    Air France     BA             Luxair       KLM         Lufthansa SAS         Finnair   Central Wings Malev     Tarom             Aeroflot   Balkan     CSA
                        Air Littoral   Br. Midland                             Condor &                        LOT                                       S7
Canada
                                       EasyJet                                 Neckermann                                                                UTair          China
Air Canada                                                                                   Switz.    Italy   Greece Turkey       Cyprus
                                       Virgin Atlantic                                                                                                                  China Eastern
WestJet                                                                                      flybaboo Alitalia Olympic Pegasus     Aegean                               China Northern
                                                                                                                        THY        Cyprus                               China Southern
           United States
                                                                                                                                   Helios                               Formosa
 American             Maxjet
 Alaska/Horizon       Mesa Air                                                                                                                                          South
                                                                                                                                                                        So th Korea
 Aloha                Midwest                                                                                                                                           Asiana
 Am. West             Netjets                                                                                                                                           Korean Air
 Atlantic Coast       Northwest
                                                                                                                                                                        Japan
 Atlas Air            Pan Am
                                                                                                                                                                        ANA
 Bus. Express         Polar
                                                                                                                                                                        Japan Airlines
 Continental          SkyLink
 Commutair            Southwest                                                                                                                                         Hong Kong
 Delta                Spirit                                                                                                                                            Air Hong Kong
 DHL                  TWA                                                                                                                                               Cathay Pacific
 Emery                United                                                                                                                                            Dragon
 Falcon Air           UPS
                                                                                                                                                                        Taiwan
 FedEx                US Airways
                                                                                                                                                                        Formosa
 Great Plains         Western Pac.
 Harmony              Virgin America                                                                                                                                    Thailand
 Hawaiian                                                                                                                                                               Thai
                                                                                                                                                                        Airways
Mexico              Venezuela          Chile
Aeromar             Aeropostal         LanChile                                                                                                                         Philippines
Aeromexico          VIASA                                                                                                                                               Philippine
                                       Peru
ALMA
                    Ecuador            Aeroperu                                                                                                                         Indonesia
Mexicana
                    Ecuatoriana                                                                                                                                         Garuda
TAESA                                  Argentina
                    TAME
                                       Aerolineas                                                                                                                       Micronesia
Cayman Islands
                    Antilles           Argentinas                                                                                                                       Air Micronesia
Cayman Airways
                    ALM                Austral
                                                                                                                                                                        Malaysia
Central America
                    Colombia                                                                                                                                            AirAsia
Copa Airlines                                                                    Bahrain     Saudi Lebanon      Kuwait    U.A.E.      Oman   Sri Lanka
                    Avianca                                                                                                                                             MAS
Grupo TACA                                                                       Bex Air     Arabia MEA         Jazeera   Royal Jet   Oman   Air Lanka
                    Brazil                                                       Gulf Air    NAS                Kuwait    Etihad                                        New Zealand
Jamaica
                    BRA                                                                      Saudia                                                                     Air New Zealand
Air Jamaica
                    GOL                                                                      Netjets
West Indies                                                                                                                                                             Australia
                    Transbrasil
ALM                                                      Morocco Egypt        Ethiopia      Ivory Coast   Uganda S Africa
                                                                                                                   S.         Madagascar     Mauritius                  Qantas
                    TAM
BWIA                                                     Royal Air Egyptair   Ethiopian     Air Afrique   Uganda SAA          Air            Air Mauritius              Australian
                    VARIG
                                                         Maroc                                            Airlines SA Express Madagascar
                    VASP
                                                                                                                   Mango



  icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                                                                                                    5
Management consulting services

                       Strategic and business planning

                       Alliances

                       Privatization advisory

                       Process improvement

                       P bli policy / economic research
                        Public li            i         h

                       Litigation support

                       Business and industry analysis
                                            y     y

                       Financial services support (investment analysis,
                        due diligence & advisory)

                       Bankruptcy merger & financial restructuring
                        Bankruptcy,

                       Financial management audits




icfi.com/aviation |                                                        6
Financial and technical services

                            Asset management
                            Appraisals
                            Aircraft and engine repair oversight
                            Financial modeling
                            Interiors management
                            Reliability analysis
                            Inspection services
                            Litigation support
                                 g        pp
                            Future value forecasts
                            Maintenance reserve requirements
                            D dili
                             Due diligence
                            Aircraft procurements
                            Aircraft & other asset remarketing



icfi.com/aviation |                                                 7
Airport services

                       Demand forecasting                  Cargo marketing
                       Air service marketing and           Cargo facility & business
                        route development                    planning

                       Strategic & master planning         Safety & security
                                                             evaluations
                       Airport system planning –
                        commercial and GA                   Air traffic control
                                                             infrastructure planning
                       Capacity & delay analysis
                                                            Airport concession &
                       Environment / noise analyses         lease structure
                       Economic impact studies             Bilateral & regulatory
                                                             advisory
                       Airport privatization

                       Operational restructuring

                       Airport finance, rates & charges




icfi.com/aviation |                                                                      8
Aviation safety & security services



                           Aviation safety and security audits of commercial
                             i li      i    t     d i ti       th iti
                            airlines, airports, and aviation authorities

                           Program design
                           Professional training
                           Safety-related technical analysis
                           Security, quality and loss control
                           Legal and regulatory support
                           Aviation claims services




icfi.com/aviation |                                                             9
SECTION 2

                      What defines a
                      Low Cost Carrier (LCC)?




icfi.com/aviation |                             10
First of all – why is this important?

     Whether you’re in industry or government, it’s critically important to
      understand how the industry works

     LCC’s are a fundamental driver of airline industry evolution worldwide

         • There are 9 LCC’s in the U.S. and 100+ worldwide, accounting for about 21%
           of U.S. airline industry revenue and about 25% of scheduled seats globally

     Plus – it’s interesting




icfi.com/aviation |                                                                     11
What defines a Low Cost Carrier (LCC)?

      Simplicity, consistency, repeatability

      Maximize asset utilization – to spread fixed costs
          • M i
            Maximum aircraft operating h
                     i    ft      ti hours per d
                                               day, quick t
                                                      i k turns

      Minimize number of aircraft types
          • Enable economies of scale in crews, training, maintenance, p
                                                       g               procurement, spares
                                                                                     p
            inventory

      Outsource non-core functions
          • E g reservations & distribution handling maintenance etc
            E.g.,              distribution, handling, maintenance, etc.

      Drive costs out of the system & eliminate overhead wherever possible
          • Direct online booking vs. agency & Global Distribution System (“GDS”)
            commissions,
            commissions automated check in etc
                                      check-in, etc.

      Simplified pricing structure

      Low unit costs -> enable low fares -> stimulate market
                       >                   >


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                          12
How does the LCC model differ from the traditional
“legacy” airline model?
    Legacies have evolved, but were traditionally characterized by:
     Complexity
     Focus on revenue generation via hubbing
         • Susceptible to peaking of activity, poor resource utilization

     More services performed in-house
         • Reservations, passenger handling, aircraft handling, maintenance, etc.

     High overhead
     Distribution via intermediaries
         • Travel agencies & GDS’s

     Multiple aircraft types tailored to mission
     Complex pricing structures
     C ll ti b
      Collective bargaining agreements
                      i i           t


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                 13
Comparative domestic unit operating costs –
U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors
                        Domestic U.S. Cost per Available Seat Kilometer (CASK) – USD, CY 2010

                     $0.16                                                                 Legacy
                                                                                             g y
                     $0.14                                                                 LCC

                     $0.12
                                                                  United    Continental
         ASK - USD
                 D




                     $0.10                        US Airways      Delta

                                                       Frontier        American
                     $0.08                                      Alaska         USA 3000
                                            Southwest        Hawaiian
                                                                       JetBlue
        CA




                     $0.06
                     $0 06                       AirTran                              Virgin America
                                                                                      Vi i A     i
                                                 Allegiant      Spirit   Sun Country
                     $0.04

                     $
                     $0.02

                     $0.00
                             0      500    1,000   1,500   2,000    2,500         3,000   3,500
                                             Average Sector Length, Km

Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                    14
Cost & productivity metrics, U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors –
domestic market: aircraft utilization, unit labor cost
   Hours                          Average Daily Narrowbody Aircraft Utilization, CY 2010
     16       13.9                                                                                              LCC      Legacy
     14                13.0
                               11.6       11.2   11.2   10.6
     12                                                        10.4   10.3   10.2    9.9
                                                                                     99     9.8
                                                                                            98     9.3
                                                                                                   93     9.1
                                                                                                          91     8.8    8.6
     10
      8                                                                                                                        6.0
      6
      4
      2
      0




  Cents                                             Labor Costs Per ASK, CY 2010
                                                                    ASK
    7¢       6.0¢     5.9¢    5.8¢                                                                              LCC     Legacy
                                          5.7¢   5.7¢   5.5¢
    6¢                                                         5.1¢
    5¢                                                                4.5¢   4.3¢
                                                                                    3.8¢   3.7¢
    4¢                                                                                            3.3¢   3.0¢   3.0¢   2.8¢   2.6¢
                                                                                                                                 ¢
    3¢
    2¢
    1¢
    0¢




Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                                                  15
Revenue & traffic generation metrics, U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors
– domestic market: yield vs. load factor
                    y
                       Domestic Avg. Yield (Rev. per Passenger-Km, USD) vs. Load Factor, CY 2010


                            $0.16
                            $0 16
                                                                                                   Legacy
                            $0.14                                      Delta
                                                                         United                    LCC
                                                     US Airways
                            $0.12                                         Continental
                                                          Alaska
                                                                    American
              Yield - USD




                            $0.10      Southwest
                                                                   Frontier    Hawaiian
                                                   AirTran
                            $0.08                              JetBlue
                  d




                                          Virgin America
                                          Vi i A     i             Spirit
                                                                   S i it                   Allegiant
                            $0.06

                            $0.04

                            $0.02

                            $0.00
                                 75%                80%               85%                 90%            95%
                                                                   Load Factor
Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                            16
LCC’s offer the potential for tremendous fare-driven
 market stimulation
    When Southwest launched service at T.F. Green Airport (PVD) in
     Providence, R.I., in 1996, passenger traffic grew 85% in one year

         Total E l
         T t l Enplaned Passengers & Avg. Yield (Constant 2010 $) at PVD CY 1991 – CY 2007
                      dP             A    Yi ld (C   t t           t PVD,
Enplanements                                                                       Yield ($ / RPK)
 3,000,000                                                                                   16¢

                                                                                             14¢
                                                                                             14
 2,500,000
                                                                                             12¢
 2,000,000
                                                                                             10¢

 1,500,000                                                                                   8¢

                                                                                             6¢
 1,000,000
                                                                 Enplaned Passengers         4¢
                         Southwest starts
   500,000                                                       Yield (¢/RPK)
                         service Nov. 1996                                                   2¢

          0                                                                                  0¢



 Source: US DOT O&D Survey

 icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                 17
History of Low Cost Carriers
‘71 ‘72 ‘73 ‘74 ‘75 ‘76 ‘77 ‘78 ‘79 ‘80 ‘81 ‘82 ‘83 ‘84 ‘85 ‘86 ‘87 ‘88 ‘89 ‘90 ‘91 ‘92 ‘93 ‘94 ‘95 ‘96 ‘97 ‘98 ‘99 ‘00 ‘01 ‘02 ‘03 ‘04 ‘05 ‘06 ‘07 ‘08 ‘09 ‘10 ‘11


 Southwest (1971 – Present)
                                                Midway (1979-1991)
                                        People Express (1981 – 87)
                                                         Ryanair (1985 – Present)
                                                                                     Kiwi International (1992 1999)
                                                                                                        (1992-1999)
                                                                                     Valujet / AirTran (1992 – Present)
         1978
                                                                                         CAL Lite
    U.S. Airline
                                                                                         (‘93 – ‘95)
  Deregulation Act
                                                                                             Shuttle by United (‘94 – ‘01)
                                                                                                 Easyjet (1995 – Present)
                                                                                                    yj (                )
                                                                                                       WestJet (1996 – Present)

                              1983                                                                           Metrojet (US
                                                                                                             Airways) (‘98-’01)
                         U.S. Industry                                                                        Allegiant (1998 – Present)
                       Fully Deregulated                                                                           JetBlue (1999 – Present)
                                                                                                                           Gol (2001 – Present)
                                                                                                                                  Song (Delta)
                                                                                     1997                                         (2003 – 2006)

                                                                                Completion of                                      Wizz Air (2003 – Present)
                                                                               EU Liberalization                                   Jetstar (Qantas) (2003 – Present)
                                                                                                                                   Air Arabia (2003 – Present)
                                                                                                                                        Ted (United)
                                                                                                                                        (2004 – 2009)
                                                                                                                                            Spicejet (2005 – Present)
                                                                                                                                                    Virgin America
                                                                                                                                                    (2007 – Present)
                                                                                                                                                    Air Asia X
                                                                                                                                                    (2007 – Present)




     icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                                                                         18
LCC’s are operating today in every region of the globe
                                                                   Europe
                                                                                                                                A i
                                                                                                                                Asia
                                                 Ryanair                   Air One Smart Carrier
                                                 Bmibaby                   Blu-express                 Spring Airlines              Jeju Air
                                                 easyJet                   Meridiana                   Air India Express            Jin Air
                   North America                 eastJet Switzerland       Windjet                     Goair                        T’way Airlines
                                                 Belle Air                 airBaltic                   IndiGo                       Air Asia
                AirTran Airways
                                                 InterSkyy                 ArkeFly y                   JetLite                      AirAsia X
                Allegiant Air
                                                 Niki                      Norwegian Air Shuttle       Jet Konnect                  Firefly
                CanJet
                                                 Jetairfly                 Jet Air                     Kingfisher Red               Air Blue
                Frontier Airlines
                                                 Wizz Air                  Blue Air                    Spicejet                     Shaheen Air
                JetBlue Airways
                                                 Wizz Air Bulgaria         Avianova                    Batavia Air                  Airphil Express
                Southwest Airlines
                                                  Wizz Air Ukraine         Sky Express                 Citilink                     Cebu Pacific
                Spirit Airlines
                                                 Smart Wingsg                     g
                                                                             Vueling Airlines            Indonesia AirAsia            Spirit of Manila Airlines
                Sun Country Airlines
                                                 Climber Sterling          Anadolujet                  Lion Air                     Zest Airways
                USA3000 Airlines
                                                 Transavia                 Corendon Airlines           Air Next                     Mihin Lanka
                Virgin America
                                                 Transavia.com France      Onur Air                    Hokkaido Intl. Airlines      Jetstar Asia Airways
                WestJet
                                                 XL Airways France         Pegasus Airlines            JAL Express                  Tiger Airways
                                                 Germanwings               SunExpress                  Skymark Airlines             Valuair
                                                 TUIfly
                                                       y                    Flybe
                                                                               y                         Skynet Asia Airways          Nok Air
Latin America / C
                Carib.                           Iceland Express           Jet2                        StarFlyer                    Orient Thai Airlines
   REDjet                                                                                               Air Busan                    Thai AirAsia
   Azul Brazilian Airlines                                                  Middle East/ N. Africa      Eastar Jet                   Jetstar Pacific
   Gol Airlines
                                            Sub Saharan Africa                  Jazeera
   WebJet Linhas Aereas
                                           Fly540                              Nas Air
   EasyFly
                                           Aero Contractors                    Air Arabia
   Viva Colombia                                                                                                        Australia/Pacific
                                           Kulula.com                          Air Arabia Egypt
   Aires                                                                                                             Jetstar
                                           1Time                               Air Arabia Maroc
   Interjet                                                                                                          Tiger Airways Australia
                                           Mango                               Jet4You
   VivaAerobus
                                           Velvet Sky                          Flydubai
   Volaris
                                                                                RAK Airways
   LC Busre
                                                                                Felix Airways
   Peruvian Airlines
                                                                                Karthago Airlines
   Star Peru



    icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                                                                    19
Some key prerequisites for a successful Low Cost
Carrier operation:

               Deregulated market
                      • Little or no controls on fares, capacity, schedule
                                                      , p      y,

               Ability to turn aircraft quickly
                      • Premium on passenger & aircraft handling

               Ability to drive costs out of the system
                      • Work rules
                      • Outsourcing
                      • Strategic procurement

               Financing

               Understanding the market and the competition
                      • Legacies will not sit still and let their market disappear




icfi.com/aviation |                                                                  20
SECTION 3

                      Evolution of LCC’s




icfi.com/aviation |                        21
Over the years the original LCC model pioneered by
Southwest has evolved to include numerous variations
    Point-to-point flying             Connectivity & hubbing
    Short-haul                        Long-haul
                                           g
    Single aircraft type              Multiple aircraft types
    Domestic only                     International
    Operate in                        Operate in unserved or underserved
     contested markets                  markets
                                vs.
    “No frills”                       Quality product, in-flight entertainment
    Single class                      Economy + business
    Secondary airports                Primary airports
    Go-it-alone distribution          Code-sharing & alliances
    Direct booking                    Use of intermediaries for booking
    Standard, simple product          Unbundling of services + ancillary
                                        revenue sources


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                22
Many LCC’s now carry a considerable amount of flow traffic


                   U.S. LCC’s: Transfer Revenue (Multi-Coupon) as Percent of Total Revenue
                                                  CY 2009
        50%

                      43%
        40%


                                           31%
        30%


                                                      21%
        20%



        10%                                                       8%       7%
                                                                                          3%
         0%
                     Frontier              AirTran   Southwest   JetBlue   Spirit     Virgin America




Source: US DOT Origin-Destination Survey


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                    23
The lines between LCC’s and legacies have been blurring
   Legacies have adopted many cost efficiency practices, many of which
   L     i h      d t d          t ffi i          ti           f hi h
   were pioneered by LCC’s:
    Outsourcing non-core functions
    Direct on-line booking and automated check-in
    Unbundling of services and ancillary revenue offerings
    Focus on aircraft utilization “continuous hubbing”
                       utilization, continuous hubbing

   At the same time, LCC’s have moved closer to some legacy practices:
    Greater focus on connectivity, hub-and-spoke
    Code-sharing & alliances
    Multiple aircraft types
    L
     Long-haul
          h l
    Quality on-board amenities, multi-cabin product
    Primary airports
    Distribution via GDS’s

icfi.com/aviation |                                                      24
Recent developments

 JetBlue code-share with Lufthansa (2008)
 Southwest code-share with Volaris (2010)
 JetBlue & Westjet code-shares with American Airlines (2011)
 Southwest launches service at New York LaGuardia & Boston Logan (2009)
 Air Asia X – establishment of long-haul low cost service (2010)
 Growth of international LCC joint venture carriers
    • Air Asia               • Air Arabia
        – Japan                 – Morocco
        – Philippines           – Egypt

        – I d
          Indonesia
                 i              – Jordan

        – Thailand

        – Vietnam




icfi.com/aviation |                                                   25
Legacy “airline-within-an-airline” LCC’s have largely
disappeared in North America & Europe
    pp                                p

 In an effort to hold back the growth of independent LCC’s, a number of
  legacy carriers launched their own LCC’s:
    • CAL Lite (Continental): 1993-1995            • Bmibaby (British Midland): 2002-present

    • United Shuttle (United): 1994-2001           • Song (Delta): 2003-2006

    • Delta Express (Delta): 1996-2003             • Ted (United): 2004 2009
                                                                   2004-2009

    • Metrojet (US Airways): 1998-2001             • Jetstar (Qantas): 2004 - present

    • Go (British Airways): 1998-2003              • Mango (South African Airways): 2006-present

    • JAL Express (Japan Airlines): 1998-present   • FlyDubai (Emirates): 2009-present

    • Tango (Air Canada): 2001-2003

 Many have now disappeared
    • Difficult-to-resolve issues: Cannibalizing the parent airline’s business, and
      achieving enough independence from the parent carrier to achieve true low costs

    • Th need f LCC subsidiaries h d
      The    d for       b idi i has decreased as l
                                              d   legacy parent carriers h
                                                              t     i    have
      reduced costs and become more efficient

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                            26
Legacy airlines have reduced their costs in recent years,
but there is still an important cost gap relative to LCC’s
 The wide wave of Chapter 11 filings in 2002 – 2007 helped the Majors
  considerably in restructuring their costs
 F l costs remain a difficult-to-control cost driver for both legacies & LCC’
  Fuel   t      i    diffi lt t      t l     td i     f b th l      i     LCC’s

                         LCC and Legacy Carrier Average CASK (Constant 2010 $)
                                          CY 2005 - CY 2010
 2010 US$
  12¢

  10¢

    8¢

    6¢

    4¢
                                                                          LCC    Legacy
    2¢

    0¢
     ¢
                 2005         2006          2007          2008          2009       2010
Source: US DOT Form 41

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                       27
Public policy implications of LCC’s


   Stress on airport and airway infrastructure, potential for congestion
      • From fare driven market stimulation
             fare-driven
      • LCC’s now account for 29% of scheduled operations and 33% of scheduled seats at
        Boston Logan

   O
    Opportunity to develop air service – and local economies – at
         t it t d      l    i      i       dl    l       i      t
    underserved airports and markets

   Outside the U.S.:
      • Whether / how to protect a nation’s flag carrier from encroaching LCC competition?
      • Whether / how to ease the market into liberalization?




icfi.com/aviation |                                                                          28
SECTION 4

                      Added bonus: the airline
                      network planning process
                        t   k l    i




icfi.com/aviation |                              29
Network management is one of the core planning
activities of any airline
                y

   Route selection, capacity & frequency planning, scheduling, code-
    sharing & alliances fleet selection aircraft assignment, rotation plan
              alliances,      selection,         assignment

   Can have a huge impact on profitability and ROI

   But highly complex to manage

   Carriers must understand:

      • The implications of market & competitive developments

      • Where they’re making and losing money

      • How networks can be optimized to generate the most revenue with
        the most cost-effective use of resources




icfi.com/aviation |                                                          30
Network planning is all about managing trade-offs

                                 Yield    vs.   On-Board Load



       Local O&D (Origin-Destination)     vs.   Flow Traffic



            Locally Focused Schedule      vs.   Connectivity-Focused Schedule



      Schedule to Meet Market Needs       vs.   Schedule to Maximize Utilization


       Higher Frequency with Smaller            Lower Frequency With Larger
      Aircraft -- But Higher Unit Costs
                                          vs.   Aircraft – But Lower Unit Costs

  High Frequency / High Capacity to             Risk of Excess Capacity,
                                                               Capacity
 Generate “S-Curve” Market Benefits       vs.   Diluting Loads and Yields


             Planning Your Network to           Managing Constraints – Fleet,
                Meet Customer Needs
                                          vs.   Airport Capacity, Regulatory
                                                        Capacity



icfi.com/aviation |                                                                31
The “S-Curve” concept: adding frequency & “presence” in
a market will increase demand, yield and revenue
                             ,y
Risk: too much capacity can dilute onboard loads and / or yields

                                       S Curve
                                       S-Curve Illustration: Revenue Share vs. Capacity Share
                          100%

                          90%

                          80%
      Revenue Share (%)




                          70%

                          60%
              S




                          50%

                          40%

                          30%

                          20%

                          10%

                           0%
                                 0%   10%   20%    30%    40%    50%    60%     70%    80%      90%   100%

                                                  Frequency or Capacity Share (%)


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                                          32
Hubbing concept: each new spoke exponentially increases
the number of O&D city-pair markets an airline can access
                     yp

Risk: too much focus on connectivity may result in undesirable
schedules for important (and higher yield) local passengers

                                 Illustrative Hub-and-Spoke Network:
                             Number of Spokes vs. Number of O&D City-Pairs
                   350
                   300
        ty-Pairs




                   250
                   200
  O&D Cit




                   150
                   100
                   50
                    0
                         0       5             10             15             20   25
                                                    Spokes
                                                    S k


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                    33
The network planning process:
                                                            Profitability, Load Factor,
                                                            P fit bilit L d F t
               Evaluate Current Network Performance         Yield, RASK, CASK, Utilization, etc.

                                                            Traffic Growth, Regulatory Actions,
         Evaluate Industry Trends and Projected Demand      Price Elasticity by Segment, etc.

                                                            Aircraft Orders, Capacity &
               Evaluate Competitor Actions and Plans        Schedule Trends, etc.

                                                            Incremental Change vs.
       Develop Strategic Options for Network Optimization   New Business Models

                      Translate Strategic Options Into      Destinations, Routes, Frequencies,
                         Fleet & Network Scenarios          Aircraft Payload/Range, Fleet Size

                                                            Forecast Share, Traffic,
                  Model and Test Network Scenarios          Revenue, P fit bilit
                                                            R         Profitability


                       Select Optimum Network Plan          Iterative Testing

                                                            Incorporate Aircraft Rotations,
                       Refine Into Routed Schedule          Other Operating Constraints

                                  Operate                   Tactical Adjustments

                                                            Measure Results and
                              Review R
                              R i    Results
                                         lt                 Incorporate Lessons



icfi.com/aviation |                                                                               34
Modeling of network scenarios has become a
widespread practice
                                                             Profitability, Load Factor,
                Evaluate Current Network Performance         Yield, RASK, CASK, Utilization, etc.

                                                             Traffic Growth, Regulatory Actions,
          Evaluate Industry Trends and Projected Demand      Price Elasticity by Segment, etc.

                                                             Aircraft Orders, Capacity &
                Evaluate Competitor Actions and Plans        Schedule Trends, etc.

                                                             Incremental Change vs.
        Develop Strategic Options for Network Optimization   New Business Models

                      Translate Strategic Options Into       Destinations, Routes, Frequencies,
                         Fleet & Network Scenarios           Aircraft Payload/Range, Fleet Size

                                                             Forecast Share, Traffic,
                                                                      Share Traffic
                  Model and Test Network Scenarios           Revenue, Profitability


                       Select Optimum Network Plan           Iterative Testing

                                                             Incorporate Aircraft Rotations,
                                                             I        t Ai     ft R t ti
                       Refine Into Routed Schedule           Other Operating Constraints

                                  Operate                    Tactical Adjustments

                                                             Measure Results and
                              Review Results                 Incorporate Lessons


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                            35
A network model permits rapid testing of “what if” network
scenarios and hypotheses

          Proposed new routes and
           network & capacity plans
          New schedules & schedule
           modifications
          Optimal service timing &
           hubbing analyses
          Aircraft size vs. frequency trade-offs
          Code-shares & alliances
          Fleet planning – optimal aircraft types & fleet size
          Predict the impact of competitor actions

            Rationale: Model the impact of scenarios to understand
            likely results, before risking costly assets and resources

icfi.com/aviation |                                                      36
The fundamental principle: projected results are related to
the airlines’ service attributes relative to the competition
        In each O&D city-pair market across the carrier’s network

               Departure/arrival times
                  p
               Total elapsed trip time from origin to destination
               Capacity offered (seats)
               Service frequency
               Number of stops enroute
               N b of connections enroute
                Number f     ti         t
               On-line vs. code-share vs. interline

    The model calculates a “QSI” (“Quality of Service Index”) value for each service
       offered in every O&D market, based on a combination of these attributes

               The carrier’s projected share of that market is a function of its
                   carrier s
                            “QSI” value relative to its competitors


icfi.com/aviation |                                                                    37
Effective network optimization typically requires multiple
rounds of iterative testing and retesting
                          g             g
           Analyzing a proposed network and schedule scenario:

     Base                   Calibrate
                            C lib t                    Input
                                                       I    t                  Create New
                                                                               C t N
   Schedule                  Model                   Constraints               Network &
                       Market Sizes                Operational                Schedule
                                                                                Scenario
                       Time of Day Preference      Commercial
                       Airline Preference          Maintenance
                       Aircraft Preference
                       Non-stop or Connecting
                        Service


     Final                   Adjust                     Analyze                    Run
   Optimized               Network &                    Results                 Proposed
   Network &               Schedule                                            Network &
                                                  Share
   Schedule                 Scenario                                           Schedule in
                                                  Projected Traffic & Spill      Model
                                                  Projected Load Factor
                                                  Revenue
                                                  Profitability

icfi.com/aviation |                                                                          38
SECTION 5

                      Q&A




icfi.com/aviation |               39
icfi.com/aviation |   40

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Was ist angesagt? (20)

overview on airport operation
overview on airport operationoverview on airport operation
overview on airport operation
 
Southwest Airlines: A Case Study
Southwest Airlines: A Case StudySouthwest Airlines: A Case Study
Southwest Airlines: A Case Study
 
AVIATION PPT (RAHUL GUPTA)
AVIATION PPT (RAHUL GUPTA) AVIATION PPT (RAHUL GUPTA)
AVIATION PPT (RAHUL GUPTA)
 
Strategy analysis airline industry
Strategy analysis  airline industryStrategy analysis  airline industry
Strategy analysis airline industry
 
Southwest Airlines
Southwest AirlinesSouthwest Airlines
Southwest Airlines
 
US Domestic Airline Industry
US Domestic Airline Industry US Domestic Airline Industry
US Domestic Airline Industry
 
Aviation
AviationAviation
Aviation
 
Airfare pricing process & strategies
Airfare pricing process & strategiesAirfare pricing process & strategies
Airfare pricing process & strategies
 
Airlines analysis
Airlines analysisAirlines analysis
Airlines analysis
 
Airport operation
Airport operationAirport operation
Airport operation
 
Analysis of Ryanair's Competitive Advantages
Analysis of Ryanair's  Competitive AdvantagesAnalysis of Ryanair's  Competitive Advantages
Analysis of Ryanair's Competitive Advantages
 
AVIATION SECURITY PRESENTATION
AVIATION SECURITY PRESENTATIONAVIATION SECURITY PRESENTATION
AVIATION SECURITY PRESENTATION
 
Airline Revenue Managemant
Airline Revenue ManagemantAirline Revenue Managemant
Airline Revenue Managemant
 
Emirates Airline
Emirates AirlineEmirates Airline
Emirates Airline
 
Emirates Airline
Emirates AirlineEmirates Airline
Emirates Airline
 
Southwest Airlines
Southwest AirlinesSouthwest Airlines
Southwest Airlines
 
Spicejet Complete
Spicejet CompleteSpicejet Complete
Spicejet Complete
 
Emirates - Business Model Case Study
Emirates - Business Model Case StudyEmirates - Business Model Case Study
Emirates - Business Model Case Study
 
Airline pricing strategies and revenue management
Airline pricing strategies and revenue managementAirline pricing strategies and revenue management
Airline pricing strategies and revenue management
 
Airline industry ppt
Airline industry pptAirline industry ppt
Airline industry ppt
 

Andere mochten auch

Airline iindustry scenario
Airline iindustry scenarioAirline iindustry scenario
Airline iindustry scenarioMarinet Ltd
 
low cost carrier
low cost carrierlow cost carrier
low cost carrierstudent
 
Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines
 Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines
Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlinesAmoon MH
 
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCI
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCIRehabilitation 國考題_SCI
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCIYi-Cheng Wu
 
Air arabia mini case.ppt
Air arabia mini case.pptAir arabia mini case.ppt
Air arabia mini case.pptBinayjeet Singh
 
case study a brand new sky
case study a brand new skycase study a brand new sky
case study a brand new skyMari Luz Garcia
 
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplace
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplaceAirline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplace
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplaceKevin May
 
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Media
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New MediaLow Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Media
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Mediaguest64e483d
 
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...Vishrut Shukla
 
Marketing mix of airlines industry
Marketing mix of airlines industryMarketing mix of airlines industry
Marketing mix of airlines industryCareer Risers
 
Aviation assignment frankfinn
Aviation assignment frankfinnAviation assignment frankfinn
Aviation assignment frankfinnprincessminu
 
Emirates ppt
Emirates pptEmirates ppt
Emirates pptMir Haris
 

Andere mochten auch (13)

Airline iindustry scenario
Airline iindustry scenarioAirline iindustry scenario
Airline iindustry scenario
 
low cost carrier
low cost carrierlow cost carrier
low cost carrier
 
Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines
 Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines
Marketing-plan-for-emirates-airlines
 
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCI
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCIRehabilitation 國考題_SCI
Rehabilitation 國考題_SCI
 
Air arabia mini case.ppt
Air arabia mini case.pptAir arabia mini case.ppt
Air arabia mini case.ppt
 
case study a brand new sky
case study a brand new skycase study a brand new sky
case study a brand new sky
 
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplace
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplaceAirline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplace
Airline ancillaries: What is working in today’s marketplace
 
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Media
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New MediaLow Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Media
Low Budget Airline Industry UAE-New Media
 
Airline Pax Marketing
Airline Pax MarketingAirline Pax Marketing
Airline Pax Marketing
 
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...
Development of Loyalty Program for Indigo - A Low Cost Indian Airline: Consum...
 
Marketing mix of airlines industry
Marketing mix of airlines industryMarketing mix of airlines industry
Marketing mix of airlines industry
 
Aviation assignment frankfinn
Aviation assignment frankfinnAviation assignment frankfinn
Aviation assignment frankfinn
 
Emirates ppt
Emirates pptEmirates ppt
Emirates ppt
 

Ähnlich wie Evolution of Low Cost Airlines

2012 General Presentation
2012 General Presentation2012 General Presentation
2012 General Presentationfitness400
 
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015Phu Nguyen
 
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...moz4
 
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference Embraer Present...
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference   Embraer Present...2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference   Embraer Present...
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference Embraer Present...Embraer RI
 
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERSBRIAN M. DUNLAP
 
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference2002* Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance ConferenceEmbraer RI
 
Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance ConferenceCsfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance ConferenceEmbraer RI
 

Ähnlich wie Evolution of Low Cost Airlines (8)

2012 General Presentation
2012 General Presentation2012 General Presentation
2012 General Presentation
 
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015
Post Event Report - Aviation Festival Asia 2015
 
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...
How many different airlines are there in the world? what are the names of the...
 
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference Embraer Present...
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference   Embraer Present...2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference   Embraer Present...
2005* Merrill Lynch 7th Annual Global Industries Conference Embraer Present...
 
Airline name
Airline nameAirline name
Airline name
 
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS
389 BOEING GLOBAL OPERATIONS AND MARKETING CUSTOMERS
 
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference2002* Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
2002* Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
 
Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
Csfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance ConferenceCsfb & Aviation Week   Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
Csfb & Aviation Week Aerospace & Defense Finance Conference
 

Evolution of Low Cost Airlines

  • 1. Evolution of Low Cost Airlines Mark Diamond, P i i l ICF SH&E M k Di d Principal, MPP 1986 Prepared for: 21 September 2011 icfi.com/aviation | 0
  • 2. Agenda 1. ICF SH&E summary 2. What defines a Low Cost Carrier (LCC)? 3. Evolution of LCC’s 4. Added bonus: the airline network planning process 5. Q&A icfi.com/aviation | 1
  • 3. SECTION 1 ICF SH&E summary icfi.com/aviation | 2
  • 4. ICF SH&E is a consulting firm exclusively dedicated to the g global air transport industry p y  Specialty consulting firm with over 70 staff  Founded in 1963  Performed over 8,000 individual engagements worldwide  Full-service offices in Boston, New York and London, with specialists worldwide  Staff recruited from airlines airports academia finance airlines, airports, academia, finance, government agencies, manufacturers and IT  Joined publicly-held ICF International in December 2007 icfi.com/aviation | 3
  • 5. Our client base spans the aviation industry and its participants  Passenger airlines  Air cargo express & integrated logistics operators cargo,  Major & regional airports  National, regional & local governments  International development agencies  Maintenance, repair, & overhaul (MRO) providers  Airframe, engine & avionics suppliers  Leasing companies, IT, equipment & service providers  Investors & financial institutions  Booking, distribution & travel services  Corporate & business aviation icfi.com/aviation | 4
  • 6. Selected airlines we’ve worked with Spain p Ireland France UK Luxembourg g Netherlands Germany Scandinavia Finland y Poland Hungary Romania g y Russia Bulgaria g Czech. Iberia Aer Lingus Air France BA Luxair KLM Lufthansa SAS Finnair Central Wings Malev Tarom Aeroflot Balkan CSA Air Littoral Br. Midland Condor & LOT S7 Canada EasyJet Neckermann UTair China Air Canada Switz. Italy Greece Turkey Cyprus Virgin Atlantic China Eastern WestJet flybaboo Alitalia Olympic Pegasus Aegean China Northern THY Cyprus China Southern United States Helios Formosa American Maxjet Alaska/Horizon Mesa Air South So th Korea Aloha Midwest Asiana Am. West Netjets Korean Air Atlantic Coast Northwest Japan Atlas Air Pan Am ANA Bus. Express Polar Japan Airlines Continental SkyLink Commutair Southwest Hong Kong Delta Spirit Air Hong Kong DHL TWA Cathay Pacific Emery United Dragon Falcon Air UPS Taiwan FedEx US Airways Formosa Great Plains Western Pac. Harmony Virgin America Thailand Hawaiian Thai Airways Mexico Venezuela Chile Aeromar Aeropostal LanChile Philippines Aeromexico VIASA Philippine Peru ALMA Ecuador Aeroperu Indonesia Mexicana Ecuatoriana Garuda TAESA Argentina TAME Aerolineas Micronesia Cayman Islands Antilles Argentinas Air Micronesia Cayman Airways ALM Austral Malaysia Central America Colombia AirAsia Copa Airlines Bahrain Saudi Lebanon Kuwait U.A.E. Oman Sri Lanka Avianca MAS Grupo TACA Bex Air Arabia MEA Jazeera Royal Jet Oman Air Lanka Brazil Gulf Air NAS Kuwait Etihad New Zealand Jamaica BRA Saudia Air New Zealand Air Jamaica GOL Netjets West Indies Australia Transbrasil ALM Morocco Egypt Ethiopia Ivory Coast Uganda S Africa S. Madagascar Mauritius Qantas TAM BWIA Royal Air Egyptair Ethiopian Air Afrique Uganda SAA Air Air Mauritius Australian VARIG Maroc Airlines SA Express Madagascar VASP Mango icfi.com/aviation | 5
  • 7. Management consulting services  Strategic and business planning  Alliances  Privatization advisory  Process improvement  P bli policy / economic research Public li i h  Litigation support  Business and industry analysis y y  Financial services support (investment analysis, due diligence & advisory)  Bankruptcy merger & financial restructuring Bankruptcy,  Financial management audits icfi.com/aviation | 6
  • 8. Financial and technical services  Asset management  Appraisals  Aircraft and engine repair oversight  Financial modeling  Interiors management  Reliability analysis  Inspection services  Litigation support g pp  Future value forecasts  Maintenance reserve requirements  D dili Due diligence  Aircraft procurements  Aircraft & other asset remarketing icfi.com/aviation | 7
  • 9. Airport services  Demand forecasting  Cargo marketing  Air service marketing and  Cargo facility & business route development planning  Strategic & master planning  Safety & security evaluations  Airport system planning – commercial and GA  Air traffic control infrastructure planning  Capacity & delay analysis  Airport concession &  Environment / noise analyses lease structure  Economic impact studies  Bilateral & regulatory advisory  Airport privatization  Operational restructuring  Airport finance, rates & charges icfi.com/aviation | 8
  • 10. Aviation safety & security services  Aviation safety and security audits of commercial i li i t d i ti th iti airlines, airports, and aviation authorities  Program design  Professional training  Safety-related technical analysis  Security, quality and loss control  Legal and regulatory support  Aviation claims services icfi.com/aviation | 9
  • 11. SECTION 2 What defines a Low Cost Carrier (LCC)? icfi.com/aviation | 10
  • 12. First of all – why is this important?  Whether you’re in industry or government, it’s critically important to understand how the industry works  LCC’s are a fundamental driver of airline industry evolution worldwide • There are 9 LCC’s in the U.S. and 100+ worldwide, accounting for about 21% of U.S. airline industry revenue and about 25% of scheduled seats globally  Plus – it’s interesting icfi.com/aviation | 11
  • 13. What defines a Low Cost Carrier (LCC)?  Simplicity, consistency, repeatability  Maximize asset utilization – to spread fixed costs • M i Maximum aircraft operating h i ft ti hours per d day, quick t i k turns  Minimize number of aircraft types • Enable economies of scale in crews, training, maintenance, p g procurement, spares p inventory  Outsource non-core functions • E g reservations & distribution handling maintenance etc E.g., distribution, handling, maintenance, etc.  Drive costs out of the system & eliminate overhead wherever possible • Direct online booking vs. agency & Global Distribution System (“GDS”) commissions, commissions automated check in etc check-in, etc.  Simplified pricing structure  Low unit costs -> enable low fares -> stimulate market > > icfi.com/aviation | 12
  • 14. How does the LCC model differ from the traditional “legacy” airline model? Legacies have evolved, but were traditionally characterized by:  Complexity  Focus on revenue generation via hubbing • Susceptible to peaking of activity, poor resource utilization  More services performed in-house • Reservations, passenger handling, aircraft handling, maintenance, etc.  High overhead  Distribution via intermediaries • Travel agencies & GDS’s  Multiple aircraft types tailored to mission  Complex pricing structures  C ll ti b Collective bargaining agreements i i t icfi.com/aviation | 13
  • 15. Comparative domestic unit operating costs – U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors Domestic U.S. Cost per Available Seat Kilometer (CASK) – USD, CY 2010 $0.16 Legacy g y $0.14 LCC $0.12 United Continental ASK - USD D $0.10 US Airways Delta Frontier American $0.08 Alaska USA 3000 Southwest Hawaiian JetBlue CA $0.06 $0 06 AirTran Virgin America Vi i A i Allegiant Spirit Sun Country $0.04 $ $0.02 $0.00 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 Average Sector Length, Km Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity icfi.com/aviation | 14
  • 16. Cost & productivity metrics, U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors – domestic market: aircraft utilization, unit labor cost Hours Average Daily Narrowbody Aircraft Utilization, CY 2010 16 13.9 LCC Legacy 14 13.0 11.6 11.2 11.2 10.6 12 10.4 10.3 10.2 9.9 99 9.8 98 9.3 93 9.1 91 8.8 8.6 10 8 6.0 6 4 2 0 Cents Labor Costs Per ASK, CY 2010 ASK 7¢ 6.0¢ 5.9¢ 5.8¢ LCC Legacy 5.7¢ 5.7¢ 5.5¢ 6¢ 5.1¢ 5¢ 4.5¢ 4.3¢ 3.8¢ 3.7¢ 4¢ 3.3¢ 3.0¢ 3.0¢ 2.8¢ 2.6¢ ¢ 3¢ 2¢ 1¢ 0¢ Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity icfi.com/aviation | 15
  • 17. Revenue & traffic generation metrics, U.S. LCC’s vs. Majors – domestic market: yield vs. load factor y Domestic Avg. Yield (Rev. per Passenger-Km, USD) vs. Load Factor, CY 2010 $0.16 $0 16 Legacy $0.14 Delta United LCC US Airways $0.12 Continental Alaska American Yield - USD $0.10 Southwest Frontier Hawaiian AirTran $0.08 JetBlue d Virgin America Vi i A i Spirit S i it Allegiant $0.06 $0.04 $0.02 $0.00 75% 80% 85% 90% 95% Load Factor Source: US DOT Form 41, domestic entity icfi.com/aviation | 16
  • 18. LCC’s offer the potential for tremendous fare-driven market stimulation  When Southwest launched service at T.F. Green Airport (PVD) in Providence, R.I., in 1996, passenger traffic grew 85% in one year Total E l T t l Enplaned Passengers & Avg. Yield (Constant 2010 $) at PVD CY 1991 – CY 2007 dP A Yi ld (C t t t PVD, Enplanements Yield ($ / RPK) 3,000,000 16¢ 14¢ 14 2,500,000 12¢ 2,000,000 10¢ 1,500,000 8¢ 6¢ 1,000,000 Enplaned Passengers 4¢ Southwest starts 500,000 Yield (¢/RPK) service Nov. 1996 2¢ 0 0¢ Source: US DOT O&D Survey icfi.com/aviation | 17
  • 19. History of Low Cost Carriers ‘71 ‘72 ‘73 ‘74 ‘75 ‘76 ‘77 ‘78 ‘79 ‘80 ‘81 ‘82 ‘83 ‘84 ‘85 ‘86 ‘87 ‘88 ‘89 ‘90 ‘91 ‘92 ‘93 ‘94 ‘95 ‘96 ‘97 ‘98 ‘99 ‘00 ‘01 ‘02 ‘03 ‘04 ‘05 ‘06 ‘07 ‘08 ‘09 ‘10 ‘11 Southwest (1971 – Present) Midway (1979-1991) People Express (1981 – 87) Ryanair (1985 – Present) Kiwi International (1992 1999) (1992-1999) Valujet / AirTran (1992 – Present) 1978 CAL Lite U.S. Airline (‘93 – ‘95) Deregulation Act Shuttle by United (‘94 – ‘01) Easyjet (1995 – Present) yj ( ) WestJet (1996 – Present) 1983 Metrojet (US Airways) (‘98-’01) U.S. Industry Allegiant (1998 – Present) Fully Deregulated JetBlue (1999 – Present) Gol (2001 – Present) Song (Delta) 1997 (2003 – 2006) Completion of Wizz Air (2003 – Present) EU Liberalization Jetstar (Qantas) (2003 – Present) Air Arabia (2003 – Present) Ted (United) (2004 – 2009) Spicejet (2005 – Present) Virgin America (2007 – Present) Air Asia X (2007 – Present) icfi.com/aviation | 18
  • 20. LCC’s are operating today in every region of the globe Europe A i Asia  Ryanair  Air One Smart Carrier  Bmibaby  Blu-express  Spring Airlines  Jeju Air  easyJet  Meridiana  Air India Express  Jin Air North America  eastJet Switzerland  Windjet  Goair  T’way Airlines  Belle Air  airBaltic  IndiGo  Air Asia  AirTran Airways  InterSkyy  ArkeFly y  JetLite  AirAsia X  Allegiant Air  Niki  Norwegian Air Shuttle  Jet Konnect  Firefly  CanJet  Jetairfly  Jet Air  Kingfisher Red  Air Blue  Frontier Airlines  Wizz Air  Blue Air  Spicejet  Shaheen Air  JetBlue Airways  Wizz Air Bulgaria  Avianova  Batavia Air  Airphil Express  Southwest Airlines  Wizz Air Ukraine  Sky Express  Citilink  Cebu Pacific  Spirit Airlines  Smart Wingsg  g Vueling Airlines  Indonesia AirAsia  Spirit of Manila Airlines  Sun Country Airlines  Climber Sterling  Anadolujet  Lion Air  Zest Airways  USA3000 Airlines  Transavia  Corendon Airlines  Air Next  Mihin Lanka  Virgin America  Transavia.com France  Onur Air  Hokkaido Intl. Airlines  Jetstar Asia Airways  WestJet  XL Airways France  Pegasus Airlines  JAL Express  Tiger Airways  Germanwings  SunExpress  Skymark Airlines  Valuair  TUIfly y  Flybe y  Skynet Asia Airways  Nok Air Latin America / C Carib.  Iceland Express  Jet2  StarFlyer  Orient Thai Airlines  REDjet  Air Busan  Thai AirAsia  Azul Brazilian Airlines Middle East/ N. Africa  Eastar Jet  Jetstar Pacific  Gol Airlines Sub Saharan Africa  Jazeera  WebJet Linhas Aereas  Fly540  Nas Air  EasyFly  Aero Contractors  Air Arabia  Viva Colombia Australia/Pacific  Kulula.com  Air Arabia Egypt  Aires  Jetstar  1Time  Air Arabia Maroc  Interjet  Tiger Airways Australia  Mango  Jet4You  VivaAerobus  Velvet Sky  Flydubai  Volaris  RAK Airways  LC Busre  Felix Airways  Peruvian Airlines  Karthago Airlines  Star Peru icfi.com/aviation | 19
  • 21. Some key prerequisites for a successful Low Cost Carrier operation:  Deregulated market • Little or no controls on fares, capacity, schedule , p y,  Ability to turn aircraft quickly • Premium on passenger & aircraft handling  Ability to drive costs out of the system • Work rules • Outsourcing • Strategic procurement  Financing  Understanding the market and the competition • Legacies will not sit still and let their market disappear icfi.com/aviation | 20
  • 22. SECTION 3 Evolution of LCC’s icfi.com/aviation | 21
  • 23. Over the years the original LCC model pioneered by Southwest has evolved to include numerous variations  Point-to-point flying  Connectivity & hubbing  Short-haul  Long-haul g  Single aircraft type  Multiple aircraft types  Domestic only  International  Operate in  Operate in unserved or underserved contested markets markets vs.  “No frills”  Quality product, in-flight entertainment  Single class  Economy + business  Secondary airports  Primary airports  Go-it-alone distribution  Code-sharing & alliances  Direct booking  Use of intermediaries for booking  Standard, simple product  Unbundling of services + ancillary revenue sources icfi.com/aviation | 22
  • 24. Many LCC’s now carry a considerable amount of flow traffic U.S. LCC’s: Transfer Revenue (Multi-Coupon) as Percent of Total Revenue CY 2009 50% 43% 40% 31% 30% 21% 20% 10% 8% 7% 3% 0% Frontier AirTran Southwest JetBlue Spirit Virgin America Source: US DOT Origin-Destination Survey icfi.com/aviation | 23
  • 25. The lines between LCC’s and legacies have been blurring Legacies have adopted many cost efficiency practices, many of which L i h d t d t ffi i ti f hi h were pioneered by LCC’s:  Outsourcing non-core functions  Direct on-line booking and automated check-in  Unbundling of services and ancillary revenue offerings  Focus on aircraft utilization “continuous hubbing” utilization, continuous hubbing At the same time, LCC’s have moved closer to some legacy practices:  Greater focus on connectivity, hub-and-spoke  Code-sharing & alliances  Multiple aircraft types  L Long-haul h l  Quality on-board amenities, multi-cabin product  Primary airports  Distribution via GDS’s icfi.com/aviation | 24
  • 26. Recent developments  JetBlue code-share with Lufthansa (2008)  Southwest code-share with Volaris (2010)  JetBlue & Westjet code-shares with American Airlines (2011)  Southwest launches service at New York LaGuardia & Boston Logan (2009)  Air Asia X – establishment of long-haul low cost service (2010)  Growth of international LCC joint venture carriers • Air Asia • Air Arabia – Japan – Morocco – Philippines – Egypt – I d Indonesia i – Jordan – Thailand – Vietnam icfi.com/aviation | 25
  • 27. Legacy “airline-within-an-airline” LCC’s have largely disappeared in North America & Europe pp p  In an effort to hold back the growth of independent LCC’s, a number of legacy carriers launched their own LCC’s: • CAL Lite (Continental): 1993-1995 • Bmibaby (British Midland): 2002-present • United Shuttle (United): 1994-2001 • Song (Delta): 2003-2006 • Delta Express (Delta): 1996-2003 • Ted (United): 2004 2009 2004-2009 • Metrojet (US Airways): 1998-2001 • Jetstar (Qantas): 2004 - present • Go (British Airways): 1998-2003 • Mango (South African Airways): 2006-present • JAL Express (Japan Airlines): 1998-present • FlyDubai (Emirates): 2009-present • Tango (Air Canada): 2001-2003  Many have now disappeared • Difficult-to-resolve issues: Cannibalizing the parent airline’s business, and achieving enough independence from the parent carrier to achieve true low costs • Th need f LCC subsidiaries h d The d for b idi i has decreased as l d legacy parent carriers h t i have reduced costs and become more efficient icfi.com/aviation | 26
  • 28. Legacy airlines have reduced their costs in recent years, but there is still an important cost gap relative to LCC’s  The wide wave of Chapter 11 filings in 2002 – 2007 helped the Majors considerably in restructuring their costs  F l costs remain a difficult-to-control cost driver for both legacies & LCC’ Fuel t i diffi lt t t l td i f b th l i LCC’s LCC and Legacy Carrier Average CASK (Constant 2010 $) CY 2005 - CY 2010 2010 US$ 12¢ 10¢ 8¢ 6¢ 4¢ LCC Legacy 2¢ 0¢ ¢ 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Source: US DOT Form 41 icfi.com/aviation | 27
  • 29. Public policy implications of LCC’s  Stress on airport and airway infrastructure, potential for congestion • From fare driven market stimulation fare-driven • LCC’s now account for 29% of scheduled operations and 33% of scheduled seats at Boston Logan  O Opportunity to develop air service – and local economies – at t it t d l i i dl l i t underserved airports and markets  Outside the U.S.: • Whether / how to protect a nation’s flag carrier from encroaching LCC competition? • Whether / how to ease the market into liberalization? icfi.com/aviation | 28
  • 30. SECTION 4 Added bonus: the airline network planning process t k l i icfi.com/aviation | 29
  • 31. Network management is one of the core planning activities of any airline y  Route selection, capacity & frequency planning, scheduling, code- sharing & alliances fleet selection aircraft assignment, rotation plan alliances, selection, assignment  Can have a huge impact on profitability and ROI  But highly complex to manage  Carriers must understand: • The implications of market & competitive developments • Where they’re making and losing money • How networks can be optimized to generate the most revenue with the most cost-effective use of resources icfi.com/aviation | 30
  • 32. Network planning is all about managing trade-offs Yield vs. On-Board Load Local O&D (Origin-Destination) vs. Flow Traffic Locally Focused Schedule vs. Connectivity-Focused Schedule Schedule to Meet Market Needs vs. Schedule to Maximize Utilization Higher Frequency with Smaller Lower Frequency With Larger Aircraft -- But Higher Unit Costs vs. Aircraft – But Lower Unit Costs High Frequency / High Capacity to Risk of Excess Capacity, Capacity Generate “S-Curve” Market Benefits vs. Diluting Loads and Yields Planning Your Network to Managing Constraints – Fleet, Meet Customer Needs vs. Airport Capacity, Regulatory Capacity icfi.com/aviation | 31
  • 33. The “S-Curve” concept: adding frequency & “presence” in a market will increase demand, yield and revenue ,y Risk: too much capacity can dilute onboard loads and / or yields S Curve S-Curve Illustration: Revenue Share vs. Capacity Share 100% 90% 80% Revenue Share (%) 70% 60% S 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Frequency or Capacity Share (%) icfi.com/aviation | 32
  • 34. Hubbing concept: each new spoke exponentially increases the number of O&D city-pair markets an airline can access yp Risk: too much focus on connectivity may result in undesirable schedules for important (and higher yield) local passengers Illustrative Hub-and-Spoke Network: Number of Spokes vs. Number of O&D City-Pairs 350 300 ty-Pairs 250 200 O&D Cit 150 100 50 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 Spokes S k icfi.com/aviation | 33
  • 35. The network planning process: Profitability, Load Factor, P fit bilit L d F t Evaluate Current Network Performance Yield, RASK, CASK, Utilization, etc. Traffic Growth, Regulatory Actions, Evaluate Industry Trends and Projected Demand Price Elasticity by Segment, etc. Aircraft Orders, Capacity & Evaluate Competitor Actions and Plans Schedule Trends, etc. Incremental Change vs. Develop Strategic Options for Network Optimization New Business Models Translate Strategic Options Into Destinations, Routes, Frequencies, Fleet & Network Scenarios Aircraft Payload/Range, Fleet Size Forecast Share, Traffic, Model and Test Network Scenarios Revenue, P fit bilit R Profitability Select Optimum Network Plan Iterative Testing Incorporate Aircraft Rotations, Refine Into Routed Schedule Other Operating Constraints Operate Tactical Adjustments Measure Results and Review R R i Results lt Incorporate Lessons icfi.com/aviation | 34
  • 36. Modeling of network scenarios has become a widespread practice Profitability, Load Factor, Evaluate Current Network Performance Yield, RASK, CASK, Utilization, etc. Traffic Growth, Regulatory Actions, Evaluate Industry Trends and Projected Demand Price Elasticity by Segment, etc. Aircraft Orders, Capacity & Evaluate Competitor Actions and Plans Schedule Trends, etc. Incremental Change vs. Develop Strategic Options for Network Optimization New Business Models Translate Strategic Options Into Destinations, Routes, Frequencies, Fleet & Network Scenarios Aircraft Payload/Range, Fleet Size Forecast Share, Traffic, Share Traffic Model and Test Network Scenarios Revenue, Profitability Select Optimum Network Plan Iterative Testing Incorporate Aircraft Rotations, I t Ai ft R t ti Refine Into Routed Schedule Other Operating Constraints Operate Tactical Adjustments Measure Results and Review Results Incorporate Lessons icfi.com/aviation | 35
  • 37. A network model permits rapid testing of “what if” network scenarios and hypotheses  Proposed new routes and network & capacity plans  New schedules & schedule modifications  Optimal service timing & hubbing analyses  Aircraft size vs. frequency trade-offs  Code-shares & alliances  Fleet planning – optimal aircraft types & fleet size  Predict the impact of competitor actions Rationale: Model the impact of scenarios to understand likely results, before risking costly assets and resources icfi.com/aviation | 36
  • 38. The fundamental principle: projected results are related to the airlines’ service attributes relative to the competition In each O&D city-pair market across the carrier’s network  Departure/arrival times p  Total elapsed trip time from origin to destination  Capacity offered (seats)  Service frequency  Number of stops enroute  N b of connections enroute Number f ti t  On-line vs. code-share vs. interline The model calculates a “QSI” (“Quality of Service Index”) value for each service offered in every O&D market, based on a combination of these attributes The carrier’s projected share of that market is a function of its carrier s “QSI” value relative to its competitors icfi.com/aviation | 37
  • 39. Effective network optimization typically requires multiple rounds of iterative testing and retesting g g Analyzing a proposed network and schedule scenario: Base Calibrate C lib t Input I t Create New C t N Schedule Model Constraints Network &  Market Sizes  Operational Schedule Scenario  Time of Day Preference  Commercial  Airline Preference  Maintenance  Aircraft Preference  Non-stop or Connecting Service Final Adjust Analyze Run Optimized Network & Results Proposed Network & Schedule Network &  Share Schedule Scenario Schedule in  Projected Traffic & Spill Model  Projected Load Factor  Revenue  Profitability icfi.com/aviation | 38
  • 40. SECTION 5 Q&A icfi.com/aviation | 39