An investigation of students' attitudes towards podcasts and blogs in a university course. Presented on the European Conference on Educational Research 2008 in Gothenburg. Authors: Maria Rasmusson, Susanne Sahlin and Marcus Sundgren.
1. Podcasting and blogging
– the way to learn?
A pilot study
Maria Rasmusson, Susanne Sahlin & Marcus Sundgren
Mid Sweden University
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
2. The purpose
• Investigate the students’ attitudes towards
podcasts and blogs in a university course
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
3. Research questions
• How did the students perceive the use of
iPods and podcasts in the course?
• How did they perceive the use of blogs in
the course?
• What benefits and disadvantages with these
technologies did the students perceive?
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
4. The course
• ICT and new media as support for
learning, 7.5 credits
• Half speed, mixed mode (2 campus
meetings)
• Summer course 2007 and 2008
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
5. Course objectives
• Be able to use ICT and media as a tool for
learning and for their future work as
teachers
• Be able to plan and create video for
educational purposes
• Be acquainted with research and technical
development in this field
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
6. Course
Communication
• Web page
• LMS (FirstClass)
• Blog
• Wiki
• Podcasts and iPod Video
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
7. Podcasts
• Enhanced podcasts: audio and slides
• Two of the podcasts were lectures by
assistant professors, not teaching in this
course
• Students were offered to borrow an
iPod Video during the course
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
8. Blog
• WordPress, on our own server
• Control of members and access
• Students were assigned to write a post and
also comment some of the peers’ posts
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
9. Conceptual framework
The socio-cultural perspective
Learning in relation to:
• Situatedness
• Activity
• Cultural tools
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
10. Method
• Interviews and questionnaires
• Participants: students in a summer course
at Mid Sweden University
• 2007: 17 students (7 drop-outs)
• 2008: 24 students (6 drop-outs)
• Two groups: proficient computer users,
average computer users
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
12. Interviews
• 2008: Three focus group interviews
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
13. Results - podcasts
Student perceptions of advantages:
• Recapitulation and detailed listening
(93 %)
• Portability (71 %)
• Timeshifting (64 %)
• A majority expressed that podcasts and
iPods supported their learning
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
14. Results - podcasts
Student perceptions of advantages:
• Listening is better than reading
• Useful in distance education
• Alternative or complement to campus
lectures
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
15. Results - podcasts
Student perceptions of disadvantages
• Technical obstacles (14 % significant
problems, 35 % minor problems)
• Other
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
16. Results - podcasts
Other comments regarding
disadvantages
• It is a limited experience compared to a
traditional lecture (body language etc.)
• One-way communication
• Asks for a forum for discussion with the
lecturers
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
17. Results - podcasts
• Location:
• At home, in the sofa (64 %)
• In the hammock, sun chair, outside (29 %)
• In the car (29 %)
• In a summer cottage, on vacation (36%)
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
18. Results - blog
Student perceptions of advantages:
• Support for learning (85,7%)
• Share thoughts with others
• Get response from others than the
teacher
• Writing for an audience
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
19. Results - blog
Other comments regarding advantages:
• Students experienced a new way of using
blogging as a tool for learning
• Got ideas about blogging in their own teaching
practice
• Blogging instead of literature seminars in
university courses
• Public forums makes you try harder
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
20. Results - blog
Student perceptions of disadvantages
• Only one student experienced technical
problems with the blog tool
• Communication is harder without F2F
interaction
• Public forums can lead to performance
anxiety
• Need for clear objectives for blog
assignments
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
21. Results - summary
• Students were very positive to podcasts
but experienced some technical difficulties
• The majority of the students expressed
that podcasts, iPod and blogs supported
their learning
• No technical obstacles in their blog use
• Quality of the podcast delivery is important
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
22. Findings in relation to
conceptual framework
Situatedness
• The students could choose the physical context
to a higher degree (iPod)
• Blogging could constitute a new context for
communication
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
23. Findings in relation to
conceptual framework
Situatedness
• The students acquired a new communication skill
which made them reflect on blogs as a tool for
learning
• The students reflected on their way of communicating
(blog)
• It seems like clear objectives is an important part of a
blogg assignment for learning purposes
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
24. Findings in relation to
conceptual framework
Activity
• Blogging for an audience made the student
more motivated
• Some students preferred listening (podcasts)
before reading, individuals prefer different
activities for learning
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
25. Findings in relation to
conceptual framework
Tools
• When technology develops, new artefacts
emerge and can be used for learning
• Podcasts and blogs are tools that the
students in this study valued for their
learning
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
26. Concluding remarks
• The participants in this study were rather
experienced computer users and this fact
could bias the results
• The results in our pilot study, regarding
podcasts, is supported by Tynan & Colbran
(2006)
• The small number of participants makes it
impossible to generalize the results
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
27. Thank you for listening!
maria.rasmusson@miun.se
susanne.sahlin@miun.se
marcus.sundgren@miun.se
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Editor's Notes
Participants in this course from both 2007 and 2008.
The assistant professors talked about their research in the field of digital competence.
Vygotsky described learning as being embedded within social events and occurring as an individual interacts with people, objects, and events in the environment.
Situatedness: Thinking, activity and communication always takes place in a social context. Learning is situated. The context can be cognitive, physical, communicative or historical. Learning depends on the ability to interpret and identify what is relevant in the particular situation.
Activity: Learning rests upon an activity within a context, and through mastering of mediated tools. Vygotsky ment that language and activity was closely connected. The language itself is an activity.
Tools: The tools are the resources used to understand the world and be active in it. The world is mediated through cultural tools. The most important tool is the language. The physical tools are called artefacts for instance information and communication technologies, a pen, a calculator, or vehicles. Our thinking is in contact with the world through the tools. The world is perceived differently in different cultures due to different cultural tools. Our acquisition of knowledge evolves on both an individual and collective level.
100% used computers every day or every week.
Recapitulation: “You can listen time and time again” “It was easy to rewind if you missed something”
Portability: “You don’t need to go to campus as with a F2F lecture”
Timeshifting: “You decide when and where”
Support for learning: A majority of students in courses both 07 and 08 expressed that both the podcasts and the iPods were a support for their learning: 07: 62,5 % podcast supported learning; 60% iPod supported learning. 08: 64,3% podcast; 81,8% iPod.
Other remarks: “It was nice with alternative course literature” “Flexible” “Simple”
14 % had problems that affected their use negatively and 35 % had some minor initial problems that were solved.
Technical obstacles: “Sometimes there was trouble but it always worked out” “Many steps (install software - transfer podcasts)” “Hard to find because of inexperience” “Tricky to use when you’ve never used an iPod before”
Others: “It creates a craving - I want an iPod of my own” “You can’t ask the lecturer if you don’t understand” “You can’t discuss with peers” “You could fall asleep when listening”
“ More relaxed than writing an assignment in a traditional way”
“Easy to share thoughts withs others”
“Easy to understand others’ opinions and what they want to communicate”
A majority of the students also had a positive experience of blogging, they enjoyed it.
The students required a clear structure for blog assignments, otherwise they fear that the blogging is becoming fuzzy.
Podcast: The students expressed the possibility to recapitulate and listen in more detail as the major advantages with podcasts for their learning. The lack of F2F-interaction with the lecturer was a disadvantage with podcasts.
* The students' perceieved the blogging in this course as a new context for communication in a learning situation. They reflected a lot on how blogging could be used in different learning situations.
* The students' perceieved the blogging in this course as a new context for communication in a learning situation. They reflected a lot on how blogging could be used in different learning situations.
* Having a reader (except for the teacher) in a blog makes you try harder.