Slides from our presentation on Ruby on Rails Penetration Testing

1. Ruby on Rails
Building and Breaking Rails App
http://www.3SLabs.com

2. • Released to the world as ‘extracted’ from BaseCamp
(37Signals) by @dhh during July 2004.
• Merged with Merb Project during December 2008 and Rails
3.0 was released.
• Two supported branch of development currently:
– Rails 3.x
– Rails 4.x

3. Acceptance of RoR
.. and LOT more

4. Building Web Applications using Ruby on Rails

5. RoR Application Structure
Image Source: http://blog.ifuturz.com/ruby-on-rails/ruby-on-rails-mvc-learn-with-fun.html

6. Building a RoR App
1. Ruby & Ruby Gem Installation
2. Generate RoR Project
3. Design ERD
4. Generate Scaffolds
5. Define Relationships
6. Create Database Schema
7. Start Application Server

7. RoR: Web Blog Example
Our Blog is a web application where one or more Users
can self-register and sign-in using their registered
credentials.
Upon sign-in each User should be able to publish Blog
Post that is visible to any user or visitor of the portal.
Any User or Visitor of the portal should optionally
Comment on any Blog Post.

8. RoR: Web Blog ERD

9. Step1: Generate Project

10. Step2: Generate Scaffolds

11. Step3: Setup Database Schema

12. Step4: Launch App Server

13. http://m.xkcd.org/844/
Now write some
code or customize
the views..

14. After some love of Bootstrap3

15. Learning Ruby on Rails
• Ruby on Rails Official Guide
– http://guides.rubyonrails.org/
• Agile Web Development with Rails
– http://pragprog.com/book/rails4/agile-web-development-with-rails
• Ruby on Rails Podcasts
– http://podcast.rubyonrails.org/
• Rails Code School
– https://www.codeschool.com/courses/rails-for-zombies-redux
• Rails Cast
– http://railscasts.com/

16. Breaking Ruby on Rails Applications
Image (Karate) by Nicholas Riggle from The Noun Project CC By 2.0

17. Penetration Testing Rails App
• Black/Gray Box Approach
– Conventional Testing
– Fingerprinting Rails Framework
– Rails specific Vulnerability Testing
– Rails specific Weakness Testing
• White Box Approach
– Automated Scan for known Vulnerabilities
• Brakeman
– Attack Surface enumeration through Routes
– Authentication & Authorization Testing
– Common Rails information disclosures (secret_token.rb)
– Model Attributes Security
– Custom/Unconventional SQL Queries Audit
– Responsive View Audit

18. Fingerprinting Rails Applications
• No generic and definitive technique!
– It’s a cat & mouse game really.
• Heuristics
– Session Identifier
– Asset Pipeline
– [ … ]

19. Fingerprinting Rails Application
Not so easy for an application served with a reverse
proxy which is almost always the case in production.

20. Fingerprinting Rails Application
Leveraging the assets pipeline which is enabled by default from Rails 3.1

21. Automated Testing: Brakeman
http://brakemanscanner.org/
Need source code access !

22. Automated Testing: grep(1)
eval
instance_eval class_eval
DRb.start_server
find_by_sql
system exec
popen
You will be surprised to see how effective this is !
/`(.*)`/

23. Attack Surface: Routes

24. Attack Surface: Routes
• Default Routing
– <Resource> is handled by app/controllers/<resources>_controller.rb
– CRUD on Resource

25. Session Security
• A whole set of attacks are possible on Session
Management functionality of any Web
Application.
– Session Hijack, Session Fixation, Session Id Prediction, Session
Data Tampering, Leveraging Session Data for RCE etc.
• Rails provide inbuilt Session Management
– The session object is available to application
developer as a Hash/Map to store arbitrary data.
– The session object is serialized and stored in
corresponding session storage as per configuration.
– Signed cookie is used for session storage by default.

26. Session Security
http://robertheaton.com/2013/07/22/how-to-hack-a-rails-app-using-its-secret-token/
Not a Good idea !

27. Session Security: Best Practices
Enforce SSL in order to avoid sniffing of session id
Re-generate session after authentication to avoid session fixation
Store session in database instead of Cookie which is default
Cookie based Session Store are susceptible to Replay Attacks

28. Authentication
• Multiple Popular Authentication Plugin
– Devise
– RESTful Authentication
– […]
• Devise
– Auto-generated Registration, Confirmation, Login,
Forgot Password etc.
– Controller filter for enforcing authentication.

29. Testing Authentication
• Generic Issues
– Weak Session Management
– Weak Authentication Enforcement
– Weak Password Encryption
• Plugin/Gem Specific
– Devise Vulnerabilities
– Lack of Authentication Enforcement
– Timing Attacks
– Information Gathering through default message
Are all controllers protected by Authentication System?

30. Authorization
• Not provided by default in the framework.
– Encourages RESTful design.
• Easy to implement RBAC on Resources
– Multiple Gem/Plugin available
Example usage of CanCan for Authorization
https://github.com/ryanb/cancan

31. Testing Authorization
• Authorization Plugin or Custom Coded?
• Every functionality is RESTful?
• Query scoping in Controller

32. Rails CSRF Protection
CSRF Token generation and checking is enforced by default.
• Application must use Rails Form Tag Helps to
generate forms rather than HTML directly.
• HTTP GET is not protected !

33. Killing Rails CSRF Protection
http://blog.codeclimate.com/blog/2013/03/27/rails-insecure-defaults/

34. Rails Model Security
• The Business Logic Layer
– Database Abstraction through ORM
– Entity Relationship Definition
– Business Logic
• Common Security Issues
– Attribute Mass Assignment
• Mitigated by default in newer version of Rails
– Custom (insecure) SQL Queries
– Business Logic Vulnerabilities

35. Rails Model: Attribute Mass Assignment
The Model
The Controller
The Malicious Input

36. Rails Model: SQL Queries
Model Scope
Chained Query Interface (ActiveRelation)
Parameterized Qury

37. Rails Model: Insecure SQL Queries
The application developer should ensure that the Query Interface
understand the difference between Query and Data.

38. Rails Model: SQL Injection Vectors
• ActiveRecord does not escape parameters for
certain options:
Source: http://rails-sqli.org/

39. View Rendering
• Dynamic parameters are encoded by default
unless explicitly marked as safe.
• There are scope for Reflected XSS
– Strings marked explicitly with html_safe method.
– Textile/Markdown Injection
– Insecure used of content_tag

40. Secure Headers
• Rails 3.x is vulnerable to Clickjacking & UI
Redressing Type of attacks in default
configuration.
– Easy Mitigation
• gem ‘secureheaders’ in Gemfile
– https://github.com/twitter/secureheaders

41. Rails: Framework Vulnerabilities
http://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-12043/product_id-22568/Rubyonrails-Ruby-On-Rails.html

42. References
• Ruby on Rails Security Guide
– http://guides.rubyonrails.org/security.html
• Brakeman Scanner
– http://brakemanscanner.org/
• Rails SQLi Examples
– http://rails-sqli.org/
• OWASP Cheatsheet for RoR
– https://www.owasp.org/index.php/Ruby_on_Rails_Cheatsheet
• Ruby Security Configuration
– http://blog.codeclimate.com/blog/2013/03/27/rails-insecure-defaults/
• Ruby Mechanize
– http://mechanize.rubyforge.org/
• Ruby Nokogiri
– http://nokogiri.org/
• The Noun Project
– http://thenounproject.com/