SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 42
These aren’t the rights you’re looking for Controlling Creativity by other means
Law Contextual &  programmed social  rules Architecture
Architecture
TECHNOLOGY controls how (& what) we interact, think & CREATE
Affordancespot the ethical dilemma?
Exodus 20:14 THE WICKED BIBLE (1631)
Bargain: a LIMITED & EXCLUSIVE right to control how a work may be used…
Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that’s invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. Anything invented after you’re thirty-five is against the natural order of things.
The problem today?
DigitalizationConnectivityDevicesStorage
What does this mean?
The theoretically possible becomes the inevitable
Here comes everybody
My Space Digg Twitter iphone YouTube Wikileaks Linkedin Blogger 1999 2007 2009 2001 2003 2005 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 Farmville Ning Second Life Spotify Flickr Skype Facebook Wikipedia Google c:a 1998
2006 2007
business models die
Law as artificial barrier
Law & Norms
Tolerated The untouchables Homage Legal ilLegal Untolerated
The Battleship Potemkin 1925 - Odessa Steps scene – director Sergei M. Eisenstein
The Untouchables (1987) film directed by Brian De Palma
Tolerated The untouchables Homage Legal ilLegal Parody Downfall parodies Untolerated
Oliver HirschbiegelDerUntergang (2004)
Tolerated AMV The untouchables Remix Homage Legal ilLegal Parody Downfall parodies Untolerated
FMA AMV Gimme a Man After Midnight - Abba  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_xB-RFOZDs
Tolerated AMV The untouchables Remix Homage Legal ilLegal Piracy Parody Downfall parodies 60 Years Later  String of Puppies Untolerated
Uncertainty of regulation
Norm conflict
Contextual &  programmed social  rules
Norms from above
Anti-Piracy Advertisement http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5SmrHNWhak Anti-Piracy ad
god is dead?
The IT Crowd - Series 2 - Episode 3: Piracy warning parody http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUNfynI8bdA IT Crowd parody
YouTube Copyright School uploaded April 14, 2011
What to do?
“The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers”
Understanding the user
Thank you.
Information ,[object Object]

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Controlling Creativity by Other Means, Leuven April 2011

Law, Ethics & Information Systems
Law, Ethics  & Information SystemsLaw, Ethics  & Information Systems
Law, Ethics & Information SystemsMathias Klang
 
Kulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt
Kulturella Allmänningar & UpphovsrättKulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt
Kulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt Mathias Klang
 
Information politics
Information politicsInformation politics
Information politicsMathias Klang
 
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible? Mathias Klang
 
From copyright to copy right
From copyright to copy rightFrom copyright to copy right
From copyright to copy rightMathias Klang
 
Internet Creativity Vs Internet Regulation
Internet Creativity Vs  Internet RegulationInternet Creativity Vs  Internet Regulation
Internet Creativity Vs Internet RegulationMathias Klang
 
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsFailure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsMathias Klang
 
Social Media Stockholm
Social Media StockholmSocial Media Stockholm
Social Media StockholmMathias Klang
 
Privacy: why should we be concerned?
Privacy: why should we be concerned?Privacy: why should we be concerned?
Privacy: why should we be concerned?Mathias Klang
 
A Paranoid Peek at Social Media
A Paranoid Peek at Social MediaA Paranoid Peek at Social Media
A Paranoid Peek at Social MediaMathias Klang
 
Privacy in social media: so what?
Privacy in social media: so what?Privacy in social media: so what?
Privacy in social media: so what?Mathias Klang
 
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?Marc Torrens
 
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks Infotech
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks InfotechImportance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks Infotech
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks InfotechEBriks Infotech Pvt. Ltd.
 
Lag etik & Informationssystem
Lag etik  & InformationssystemLag etik  & Informationssystem
Lag etik & InformationssystemMathias Klang
 
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)Felipe Prado
 
Future of work u4 - 2017-09-20
Future of work   u4 - 2017-09-20Future of work   u4 - 2017-09-20
Future of work u4 - 2017-09-20Lykle de Vries
 
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows Mathias Klang
 
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.BA and Beyond
 
Xpm nov 17 morals and ethics in technology
Xpm nov 17   morals and ethics in technologyXpm nov 17   morals and ethics in technology
Xpm nov 17 morals and ethics in technologyAndy Longshaw
 
Information is correct, knowledge is relevant
Information is correct, knowledge is relevantInformation is correct, knowledge is relevant
Information is correct, knowledge is relevantMathias Klang
 

Ähnlich wie Controlling Creativity by Other Means, Leuven April 2011 (20)

Law, Ethics & Information Systems
Law, Ethics  & Information SystemsLaw, Ethics  & Information Systems
Law, Ethics & Information Systems
 
Kulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt
Kulturella Allmänningar & UpphovsrättKulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt
Kulturella Allmänningar & Upphovsrätt
 
Information politics
Information politicsInformation politics
Information politics
 
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?
Off the Grid: Is anonymity possible?
 
From copyright to copy right
From copyright to copy rightFrom copyright to copy right
From copyright to copy right
 
Internet Creativity Vs Internet Regulation
Internet Creativity Vs  Internet RegulationInternet Creativity Vs  Internet Regulation
Internet Creativity Vs Internet Regulation
 
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsFailure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
 
Social Media Stockholm
Social Media StockholmSocial Media Stockholm
Social Media Stockholm
 
Privacy: why should we be concerned?
Privacy: why should we be concerned?Privacy: why should we be concerned?
Privacy: why should we be concerned?
 
A Paranoid Peek at Social Media
A Paranoid Peek at Social MediaA Paranoid Peek at Social Media
A Paranoid Peek at Social Media
 
Privacy in social media: so what?
Privacy in social media: so what?Privacy in social media: so what?
Privacy in social media: so what?
 
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?
Is DEMOCRACY in DANGER?
 
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks Infotech
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks InfotechImportance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks Infotech
Importance of relevant information for your Business - EBriks Infotech
 
Lag etik & Informationssystem
Lag etik  & InformationssystemLag etik  & Informationssystem
Lag etik & Informationssystem
 
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)
2600 v21 n3 (autumn 2004)
 
Future of work u4 - 2017-09-20
Future of work   u4 - 2017-09-20Future of work   u4 - 2017-09-20
Future of work u4 - 2017-09-20
 
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows
Empowered Citizens or Digital Dairy Cows
 
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.
BA and Beyond 20 - Liz Calder - We can, but should we? Modern ethics and the BA.
 
Xpm nov 17 morals and ethics in technology
Xpm nov 17   morals and ethics in technologyXpm nov 17   morals and ethics in technology
Xpm nov 17 morals and ethics in technology
 
Information is correct, knowledge is relevant
Information is correct, knowledge is relevantInformation is correct, knowledge is relevant
Information is correct, knowledge is relevant
 

Mehr von Mathias Klang

Surveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumSurveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumMathias Klang
 
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureWeb of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureMathias Klang
 
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Mathias Klang
 
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesSharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesMathias Klang
 
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Mathias Klang
 
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Mathias Klang
 
Civil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyCivil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyMathias Klang
 
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Mathias Klang
 
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherPublic/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherMathias Klang
 
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityDigital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityMathias Klang
 
Design and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityDesign and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityMathias Klang
 
Cities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignCities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignMathias Klang
 
Technologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireTechnologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireMathias Klang
 
Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Mathias Klang
 
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityPlatforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityMathias Klang
 
Is that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersIs that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersMathias Klang
 

Mehr von Mathias Klang (20)

Surveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumSurveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the Simulacrum
 
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureWeb of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
 
Klang PSU
Klang PSUKlang PSU
Klang PSU
 
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
 
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesSharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
 
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
 
FOSS & Society
FOSS & SocietyFOSS & Society
FOSS & Society
 
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
 
Civil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyCivil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & Technology
 
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
 
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherPublic/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
 
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityDigital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
 
Design and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityDesign and Access to the city
Design and Access to the city
 
Cities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignCities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & Design
 
Control by design
Control by designControl by design
Control by design
 
Technologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireTechnologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desire
 
Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371
 
Image by Wikipedia?
Image by Wikipedia?Image by Wikipedia?
Image by Wikipedia?
 
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityPlatforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
 
Is that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersIs that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriers
 

Controlling Creativity by Other Means, Leuven April 2011

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. Law and Prophets from Lawrence OP cc by ncnd
  2. image fromYumiko Hayakawa essay Public Benches Turn ‘Anti-Homeless’ (also recommend Design with Intent) Source http://architectures.danlockton.co.uk/2006/10/05/anti-homeless-benches-in-tokyo/
  3. A 1631 King James Bible, known as the "Wicked Bible,” contains an error in Exodus 20:14, where the Seventh Commandment reads, "Thou shalt commit adultery." The printers, Robert Barker and Martin Lucas, are said to have been fined 300 pounds for the offense, a huge sum at that time, and had their printers' license revoked. It is believed that only 11 of the original 1,000 have survived.
  4. November 21, 2010 from TheeErin cc by ncsa
  5. Home Computer (by unknown) from Stijn Vogels cc by nc sa
  6. Ready for Take Off from vyxle cc by nc
  7. I just couldn’t live with myself... from Eric "Claptøn" Nelsøn cc by ncsa
  8. Came hameháááá! from R'eyes cc by
  9. Freedom from _ambrown cc by nc
  10. Odeon Cinema Teatro from funadium cc by ncsa
  11. Berlin Wall by Mathias Klang cc by nc
  12. T-Rex from mistagrrr cc by
  13. The Battleship Potemkin 1925 - Odessa Steps scene – director Sergei M. Eisenstein
  14. The Untouchables (1987) film directed by Brian De Palma
  15. FMA AMV Gimme a Man After Midnight - Abba http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_xB-RFOZDs
  16. Generational Fights from Pensiero cc by ncnd
  17. DSC_0777 from C. G. P. Grey cc by
  18. Part of the The Sistine Chapel ceiling, painted by Michelangelo between 1508 and 1512http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sistine_Chapel_ceiling
  19. Anti-Piracy Advertisementhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5SmrHNWhak
  20. Part of the The Sistine Chapel ceiling, painted by Michelangelo between 1508 and 1512http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sistine_Chapel_ceiling
  21. 2nd Anoniversary from Anonymous9000 cc by
  22. The IT Crowd - Series 2 - Episode 3: Piracy warning parodyhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUNfynI8bdAhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuxO6CZptck
  23. PESSIMISM OF THE INTELLECT, OPTIMISM OF THE WILL by ruSSeLLhiGGs cc by ncsa
  24. Shakespeare's - Globe Theatre from Cyberslayer cc by ncsaHenry VI (Part 2) Act 4, scene 2 - William Shakespeare
  25. Copyright is for Losers by 917press cc by ncsa
  26. Eyes ! (Youth from Antikythera!) by agelakis cc by nc sa