Murdock, k. imt 662 898 fa10-cbi_peer_revcommentsheet
1. Peer Review Comment Sheet
Class, take a careful look at another classmate’s narrative and leave your
comments on this sheet. Be sure to give specific feedback in addition to circling a rating
in each section, and make sure your feedback is a good mix of constructive praise and
criticism (e.g., no “your paper is good” or “your paper is not good” in every category).
Writer’s Name & Paper Title: _______________________________________________
Reader’s Name (you): _____________________________________________________
Qualities Rating (please circle)
1. Development of Details/Ideas Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
2. Organization Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
3. Awareness of Audience Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
4. Word Choice Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
5. Sentence Variety Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
6. Conventions/Grammar/Spelling Needs Improvement | Good | Excellent
Comments:
