SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
Download to read offline
Using Writing in Mathematics
to Deepen Student Learning
McREL
    Services & Products to Help All Students
    and Schools Succeed
    Since 1966, McREL has offered products and services aimed at improving
    student achievement to educators, administrators, and policymakers. We work
    with clients to understand their strengths and challenges in order to know
    how best to support their efforts, whether it’s providing a short workshop or
    comprehensive, long-term solutions.
    Visit our Web site at www.mcrel.org to find out what McREL’s experts do in
    these areas:
    •	Curriculum & Instruction
    •	Standards & Assessment
    •	Learning 24/7
    •	Leadership Development
    •	School & Systems Improvement
    •	Policy & Strategy

    Read more about our literacy-focused products and workshops on page 20.




    Acknowledgements
    The following McREL staff members contributed to this publication.
    Kathleen Dempsey, M.Ed.
    Matt Kuhn, M.A.
    Heather Martindill, M.S.



    © 2009 McREL
    20090609




www.mcrel.org
Using Writing in Mathematics
     to Deepen Student Learning
                               by
                        Vicki Urquhart




“Writing in mathematics gives me a window into my students’
thoughts that I don’t normally get when they just compute
problems. It shows me their roadblocks, and it also gives me,
as a teacher, a road map.”
                                              –Maggie Johnston
                                               9th-grade mathematics teacher,
                                               Denver, Colorado



                                                                info@mcrel.org
2	   www.mcrel.org
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
Writing is the ability to compose text effectively for different purposes and audiences.
When many of us reflect on our own school experiences, we recall writing in English
and history classes, but not in mathematics. Math classes previously relied on skill-
building and conceptual understanding activities. Today, teachers are realizing that
writing during a math lesson is more than just a way to document information;
it is a way to deepen student learning and a tool for helping students gain new
perspectives.

They recognize, too, that students whose strengths are language-based—and many
are—use writing as the key to understanding other disciplines, especially mathematics.
For example, Dr. David K. Pugalee (2004) conducted a study with 9th-grade algebra
students to determine if journal writing can be an effective instructional tool in
mathematics education and found that it may have a positive effect on problem
solving because the writer must organize and describe internal thoughts.

Like most things, learning to write well requires instruction and practice. In this
booklet, I aim to nudge secondary math teachers who are thinking about using
writing in their classrooms more extensively and to encourage those who want
to begin. Perhaps you will come to the same conclusion as mathematics educator
Marilyn Burns, who said, “I can no longer imagine teaching math without making
writing an integral aspect of students’ learning” (p. 30).  

Section One gives a brief background that answers the question you may be
wondering: Why write in mathematics? Section Two describes the existing role of
writing in the mathematics curriculum, and Section Three provides strategies and
ideas to put into practice right away.




                                                                          info@mcrel.org   3
Section One
     SECTION ONE:
     What we know from research about writing in the content areas
     Researchers agree that, like reading, improving student’s writing skills improves
     their capacity to learn (National Institute for Literacy, 2007). We also know that
     writing fosters community in a classroom and, because writing is a social act, it is a
     vehicle for students to learn more about themselves and others. Researcher Donna
     Alvermann (2002), an expert in adolescent literacy, studies students’ self-efficacy and
     engagement. She urges all teachers, despite their content area expertise, to encourage
     students to read and write in many different ways. She does so because she believes
     that writing raises the “cognitive bar,” challenging students to problem solve and
     think critically. What other single action requires students to be so grounded in a
     viewpoint that they can convince others, to know a process so thoroughly that they
     can explain it to someone else, or to grasp the nuances of an idea so deeply that they
     can convey it in a way that provokes thought and sparks discussion?

     I know that writing does this           Why are we writing in math class?
     for me each time I draft an             David Pugalee (2005), who researches
     article or prepare a workshop           the relationship between language and
     presentation. Until I read what         mathematics learning, asserts that writing
     I have written, I don’t see the         supports mathematical reasoning and problem
     holes in my logic, the missing          solving and helps students internalize the
     steps, or the rambling thoughts.        characteristics of effective communication. He
     Writing informs me that I only          suggests that teachers read student writing for
     have a cursory knowledge of             evidence of logical conclusions, justification of
                                             answers and processes, and the use of facts
     the content when I need a deep
                                             to explain their thinking.
     one. Simply put, it doesn’t let me
     cut corners. Whenever I have
     conducted workshops on using writing in mathematics, math teachers, quick to see
     the parallels with problem solving, have rallied to the idea. Happily, teachers who
     want to begin infusing writing in their instruction or who want to increase their
     use of it don’t have to start from scratch. They can begin with their own well-crafted
     lessons and add a writing activity that will enhance student engagement and heighten
     cognitive demands.




4	   www.mcrel.org
In Writing Next, researchers Graham and Perin (2007) identify the following 11
elements of current writing instruction that help young people learn to write well
and to use writing as a tool for learning.
1.	    Teach students strategies for planning, revising, and editing.
2.	    Explicitly and systematically teach students how to summarize texts.
3.	    Use instructional arrangements in which students work together on writing.
4.	    Assign students specific, reachable goals for their writing tasks.
5.	    Use computers and word processors as instructional supports for writing
       assignments.
6.	    Teach sentence combining as a way to construct more complex, sophisticated
       sentences.
7.	    Engage students in prewriting activities to generate ideas for composing.
8.	    Use inquiry activities where students analyze immediate, concrete data to
       develop ideas and content for a particular writing task.
9.	    Use the writing process to provide extended writing opportunities.
10.	   Provide opportunities to read, analyze, and emulate models of good writing.
11.	   Use writing as a tool for learning content material.

There are many formal and informal ways to make these elements actionable in
schools. For example, a school undertaking a writing initiative might adopt one
element a month for a year. Or, if teachers already meet regularly for book studies,
they could meet to share their ideas, concerns, and successes about implementing one
of these writing elements. I encourage you to try, share, and try again. You will get to
know your students in ways you never have before, and you will most certainly know
who is and isn’t learning mathematics content.




                                                                          info@mcrel.org   5
Section Two
     SECTION TWO:
     Writing as part of the mathematics curriculum
     Writing is not a separate entity from the mathematics curriculum; it is part of it.
     Among the learning goals that the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics
     (NCTM) has set for all students is
     to communicate their mathematical          Principles and Standards for School
     thinking.                                  Mathematics
     NCTM recommends that writing about         “Reflection and communication are
                                                intertwined processes in mathematics
     mathematics be nurtured across grades.
                                                learning…Writing in mathematics can also
     NCTM suggests that students write          help students consolidate their thinking
     explanations about how they solved a       because it requires them to reflect on
     problem, solutions to exercises as if they their work and clarify their thoughts about
     were writing a textbook, essays about      the ideas” NCTM (2000), p.61.
     what it means to prove something,
     or reports describing the significant
     contributions of well-known mathematicians (2000). Joan Countryman (1992), who
     explores the relationship between mathematics and writing, offers the following four
     benefits of writing in mathematics class:
     Students write to keep ongoing records about what they’re
     doing and learning.
     While they’re writing, students can restate new material in their own words, identify
     computations that are easy or difficult, or reflect on aspects that confuse them, as in
     this note from a student to his math teacher.

         Dear Mr. Kuhn:

         Today we talked a lot about equations. I understand what an equation is. I
         have used them many times. But I don’t really understand how an equation can
         be turned into a sentence. I know how to do the math but not how to explain
         it. Would you please spend some more time tomorrow teaching us how to make
         sentences out of equations?

         Thanks,
         Sammy




6	   www.mcrel.org
Students write in order to solve math problems.
Students can write the facts they need to answer a question beforehand and afterwards,
then check their computations against their written facts. This also helps them see
different ways to arrive at an answer. When doing a unit on slope, one of Maggie’s
students wrote down her thought process this way:

    In order to solve the problem, I need to find the rate of change in the sale of blue
    jeans by subtracting the amount sold in 1992 from 1996 and then add the costs on
    top of the cost in 1992 until it reaches this year.

    Another student wrote:

    I need to find the slope, which is the rate of change, and then next find B and
    finally solve the problem. The rate of change is the jeans.

Students write to explain mathematical ideas.
When students write explanations of their work and give examples, teachers can
better assess student understanding and progress throughout time. Writing is an ideal
vehicle for formative assessment, providing teachers with the information they need
to adjust their instruction.

Three kinds of writing prompts reflect three aspects of learning mathematics:
1) content, 2) process, and 3) affective. Content prompts deal with mathematical
concepts and relationships, process prompts focus on algorithms and problem
solving, and affective prompts center on students’ attitudes and feelings. Content
prompt examples include these:

•	 Define parallel in your own words.
•	 How would you describe a number line?
•	 Write a paragraph about the graph in the news.
•	 Write one sentence that describes an equation.
•	 How do you know that 1/4 is greater than 1/5? Explain your thinking.
•	 Write as many examples of a square that you can think of in five minutes.
•	 What properties do triangles have?
•	 Write everything you know about money.
•	 What were the key points in today’s lesson?




                                                                           info@mcrel.org   7
Students write to describe learning processes.
     Writing about problem solving requires students to monitor and reflect on the
     strategies and processes they select. Maggie explains why she uses writing to enhance
     the metacognitive aspect of learning in mathematics: “If there’s no writing in math
     class, all they’re doing is the evaluation-execution portion of learning. Orientation
     and organization come before execution, and that’s what writing gets at. That’s the
     most valuable piece of writing in mathematics class,” she said.

     Maggie develops the reflective writing prompts she uses with a learning objective in
     mind. Frequently, it includes a metacognitive piece, which will require her students
     to organize a problem, do the problem, and rethink it. This is how it looks in her
     classroom:

         Maggie shows the class an example problem from her Algebra 2 class: 2 log4 x - 5
         log and asks, “Does anyone know how to do this problem?”

         She waits for a few minutes, sensing students’ hesitancy to respond. Maggie has
         anticipated this, so she removes the problem from the overhead, replacing it with a
         writing prompt she has prepared.

         “Here’s the writing prompt: When I see this problem, my first reaction is. . . Here
         are your options:

          1.	I realize why I hate math.
          2.	I’m a little afraid, but I know that condense means to make something smaller.
          3.	I’m not exactly sure how to do this problem, but we’ve been learning about logs.”

     Maggie has set the stage for learning by providing students a vehicle for describing
     their learning processes. The rest of the class period includes whole-class brainstorming
     about what students already know about solving similar problems, time to work
     alone and with a partner, and sharing learning processes and outcomes. To keep the
     workload down, Maggie uses only two or three writing prompts with each unit and
     tries to connect big ideas from each unit through writing. “Once they write about
     those big ideas, it really enhances their understanding, especially at the high school
     level,” said Maggie.




8	   www.mcrel.org
Section Three
SECTION THREE:
Strategies and ideas for writing in mathematics
Not only should teachers be aware of the instructional strategies that are most effective
in improving student writing (National Institute for Literacy, 2007; Graham & Perin,
2007); they also need ideas for implementation. In this section, I address that need by
returning to the work of Joan Countryman (1992), who observes that writing in the
mathematics classroom generally looks like one of six types: Free writes; biography
and autobiography; learning logs, blogs, and journals; summaries; word problems; and
formal writing. With an understanding of these forms, strategies for implementation,
and practical ideas for integrating technology tools, all teachers—regardless of their
own comfort levels with writing—can enhance their mathematics lessons.

1. Free writing
Free writing involves writing nonstop for a fixed amount of time, usually just a few
minutes. Free writes don’t allow time for students to agonize over grammar or spelling;
rather, they encourage students to think freely and raise questions about a topic or
idea. When you first ask students to free write, give them high-interest topics, so they
can begin to write immediately. For example, students usually have strong opinions
about whether or not they will ever use advanced mathematics in “real life,” why they
should use calculators during high-stakes assessments, or whether an additional year
of math should be required in the high school curriculum. Once they are used to
writing on broad topics, ask them to write on math-related topics, such as predicting
the effect of one rotating object on another or comparing methods of analyzing data
sets. Finally, develop prompts that relate specifically to the content you are covering
in class by asking students to summarize their learning or describing steps in solving
a problem.

Implementation Idea: The Journalists’ Questions1
Once students have become comfortable writing for short periods, introduce “The
Journalists’ Questions” (who? what? when? where? why? how?). Explain that this
traditional reporters’ style of writing is a way of identifying essential information.

When studying units of measure, for instance, ask students to write the general
topic “the metric system” on their papers and list the six questions, leaving room
for a response to each. Give them a few minutes at the beginning or end of class to
answer as many as they can. Collect and look over responses, and you will quickly
discern what information or misinformation students already have. Here’s how the
six questions might apply to the topic “the metric system.”

   1
     For more writing strategies, see Urquhart, V. & McIver, M. (2005). Teaching Writing in the Content Areas.
Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.




                                                                                              info@mcrel.org     9
The Metric System
      Who?          Only three countries have not adopted the metric system: the
                    United States, Liberia, and Myanmar. All the sciences use it,
                    however.

      What?         It is an international system of measurement with proportional
                    graduations that uses naturally occurring standards as base
                    units.
      When &        It was first adopted in 1791 in France and spread throughout
      Where?        Europe.
      Why?          France wanted a standardized system of measurement that
                    would help unify the country with a single currency and
                    countrywide market. It can be reproduced any time by any
                    country.
      How?          It is based on the number ten, so it is easy to go from one unit
                    to another. You just multiply or divide by 10.


    The next day, have a class discussion to clear up any misconceptions. Give students
    the option to write a paragraph describing the metric system or defending its use in
    science and mathematics.  If you have access to technology, a fun way to apply this
    strategy is to pair it with a Web site that you can check out ahead of time. Assign a
    topic, ask students to complete as many of the Journalists’ Questions as they can, and
    write a summary paragraph on the topic.

    2. Biography & autobiography
    This type of narrative non-fiction writing encourages students to write descriptively,
    and to identify significant events, personality traits, turning points, and impacts on a
    person’s life. The life stories of important mathematicians will intrigue some of your
    students, and there are many Web sites with biographies, such as Omnibiography.
    com; allmath.com/biography.php; or even Simpsonsmath.com, where students can
    read the math biographies of the show’s writers.

    To extend this writing opportunity, encourage students to write letters or e-mails
    to the mathematicians (or the Simpson creators) they learned about. Alternatively,
    ask students to illustrate in the form of a pie chart the percentage of the person’s life
    devoted to the activity that made him or her famous. You also can use a variation of
    autobiography called a “mathography” to learn more about your students’ attitudes,
    perceptions of their effort and abilities, and to know the kind of support they think
    they need.




10	 www.mcrel.org
Implementation Idea: Write Your Mathography
At the beginning of a year, ask students to write about their experiences learning
mathematics, describing the strategies their instructors used to help them learn. Or,
provide a choice of writing prompts, such as these:

•	 What early math accomplishments do you remember? (e.g., When and how did
   you learn to count? Who taught you? How did he or she teach you? Did you
   “show off” this new talent to others?)
•	 When you were in elementary school, what did you like (or not like) about
   math?
•	 What do you remember about learning to add and subtract? Which did you
   think was more fun? Why?
•	 Was math ever your favorite subject? If so, why? If not, why?	

3. Learning logs, blogs, & journals
Over time, the lines distinguishing learning logs and journals have blurred, but
students still can use these writing vehicles to respond to class discussions, make
connections between real-life and the content, and to reflect on themselves as
learners. Learning logs should focus on content, whereas journals might focus on
students’ ideas and questions about a broad range of general topics. Students use
each differently. While journaling, they might reflect on anything they consider
relevant, carry on conversations with their teachers, or both. Learning logs, on the
other hand, are less about “feeling” and more about understanding content. Similarly,
blogs allow students to share ideas and solutions in real time with each other, other
classes, and the teacher.

Although both kinds of insights are valuable,
teachers should assign learning logs, blogs,     Algebra I Learning Log
and journals with different intent. Students     •	 Date:
should write frequently in their logs and
                                                 •	 Name of topic, presenter,
blogs for several minutes at a time at least
                                                    chapter title, program/video:
once a week and should use an established
template for entering information. Journal       •	 Pages read, length of discussion/
writing can be less frequent, perhaps every         explanation or program/video:
two weeks. Here is one example of a learning     •	 Main points:
log template that you can adapt and provide
                                                 •	 Summary of main points:
students.




                                                                      info@mcrel.org    11
Implementation Idea: Climbing and Diving
    This is a good strategy to use when students are writing in their learning logs. As
    students move back and forth between climbing and diving (into a topic), they
    internalize the process and the content. For example, following a unit on the area
    of polygons, students spend 10 minutes writing everything they learned, including
    formulas and descriptions. They then read over their writing and select one idea to
    explore further, such as why the formula to determine the area of a triangle works for
    all triangles, regardless of type. The second 10-minute writing allows them to justify
    their thinking or reflect on their understanding. If you have access to technology, ask
    students to journal electronically or keep a class e-learning log or blog. (For more
    on Climbing and Diving, see Teaching Writing in the Content Areas by Urquhart &
    McIver.)

    Implementation Idea: Double-entry Journals
    A double-entry journal is a long-standing popular activity for any content area.
    Frequently, teachers pair it with a reading assignment where students summarize
    on the left, which represents literal information from the text, and respond to the
    summary on the right, which represents inferential and critical thinking. One way to
    use a double-entry journal focusing on problem solving is to have students write the
    problem in the left column and the details for solving it in the right column. To adapt
    the journal, ask students to create a third column and write a personal reflection that
    describes what was frustrating or easy, or to draw a horizontal line two-thirds of the
    way down the paper to provide a section for summarizing the process.

    4. Summaries
    Because students often find summary writing difficult, teachers should explicitly
    teach summary skills and provide plenty of opportunities for practice. Journals and
    learning logs are ideal places for students to practice summarizing. Students should
    understand they must identify main ideas, discriminating between information
    that is essential and information that is merely interesting. Here are some practical
    suggestions for using summary writing:

    •	 Teach students how to organize key ideas into logical patterns using webs,
       charts, or diagrams, such as a Venn Diagram, which visually represents common
       elements, or a concept map, which presents relationship among a set of
       connected ideas.
    •	 Use summary writing when students are learning large amounts of information
       and vocabulary terms.
    •	 Allow students to write collaboratively or summarize together as a whole class.




12	 www.mcrel.org
Venn Diagram

                          Types of Numbers

                      Prime                    Even

                           103                 4 18
                     17
                                    2
                     3      11                  6
                           23                600



Concept Map




                    9 - 4 = 5
   See how many                                          A bird found 9
  things you have                 Equation
                                                         beetles. He ate
   to begin with.                                        4. At the same
  Then take away                                         time, 5 beetles
                     How does                    Story
  some. Count how
                     it work?
                                 Subtraction               hid under a
  many things you                                         rock. Then the
   have left, and
                                   Drawing               bird flew away.
    that is your
      answer.




                                                             info@mcrel.org   13
Implementation Idea: Magnet Summaries
    A great way to explicitly teach summary writing is with the “Magnet Summary”
    strategy.

    Sample steps for using Magnet Summaries
    •	 When studying equations, provide students a written selection (e.g., a textbook
       section, Web site, or teacher-created document) that explains how to solve an
       equation.
    •	 Read the selection ahead of time and develop a list of key vocabulary words that
       appear, such as inverse, variable, logarithm, exponent, etc.
    •	 Provide students with the same number of index cards as total number of words
       on the list.
    •	 Write the magnet word list on the board, overhead transparency, or PowerPoint,
       and ask students to write each word on an index card.
    •	 Distribute the text selection, and ask students to read it. Working on their
       own, they should reread and look for the magnet words, identifying key words
       or phrases in the text that help explain or directly relate to the magnet word.
       Explain that these are the words or phrases that the magnet words “attract,” and
       students can highlight them with a marker, if it will help them remember the
       meaning of the words.
    •	 On the back of each index card, students then write a summary sentence
       in their own words that defines, describes, or expresses the main idea of the
       magnet word.
    •	 Students read their sentences and organize the cards in a logical order.
    •	 Students write a summary paragraph, adding transitional words and phrases.
    •	 Students read their summaries to others, and revise for clarity and cohesion,
       using peer feedback.
    5. Word problems
    Words are tools for thinking in mathematics, just as they are in other disciplines.
    Good word problems promote thinking and encourage students to use their own
    language, thus owning their ideas. Pugalee cites the research of  Winograd (1992),
    suggesting that students, when asked to write original word problems, will write
    more interesting and challenging ones than textbook problems.




14	 www.mcrel.org
Implementation Idea: Explicitly Teach Relevant Vocabulary
Whether writing their own word problems or preparing to write constructed responses,
students need to be comfortable with certain words, know their definitions, and be
able to use them in writing tasks. There are six concrete steps for learning a new word
(Paynter, Bodrova, & Doty, 2005):

1.	 Identify the new word and elicit students’ background knowledge (e.g., the term
    “probability model”).
2.	 Explain the meaning of the new word (e.g., tell students that a probability
    model is a technique for representing the chances of something occurring, and
    that they will use a model, or something they can manipulate, to determine the
    chances of two students each drawing a red chip from a bag of five blue and
    five red chips. Show them two colored charts, one representing each student’s
    chances, and a third chart representing the chances of both of the students
    drawing a red chip.
3.	 Monitor students as they work in small groups to generate their own
    explanations. If they have difficulty, you might need to provide a sentence stem
    or ask questions or provide tools, such as dictionaries or thesauruses.
4.	 Ask students to create a visual representation of the new word. If you have access
    to technology and the Internet, encourage students to find clip art, photos, or
    interactive models (see a selection of mathematics and science interactives at
    http://www.explorelearning.com).
5.	 Provide an experience to use the new word (e.g., discuss the probability that
    students will win the state lottery).
6.	 Engage students in activities (e.g., vocabulary baseball or vocabulary bingo) to
    help them remember the word and its meaning.




                                                                        info@mcrel.org    15
In addition to teaching mathematics-specific vocabulary, teach students terms they
    will see on state tests. Several of the most-used terms on constructed response items
    appear in the chart that follows. You can assign the writing task on the chart or adapt
    it to use with your students.

      Common Constructed Response Terms with Definitions and
      Mathematics Writing Tasks
          Term               Definition               Mathematics Writing Tasks

      Analyze         Break down a topic into     Examine a set of economic
                      its parts and examine       statistics and write an editorial on
                      how each part functions     the cause and effect relationship
                      in relation to the whole.   between high wages and inflation.
      Describe        Represent a person,        Write a detailed description of a
                      object, or idea in words.	 model so that someone else can
                                                 re-create it.
      Evaluate        General: Determine          Write an article for a student
                      the significance, worth,    newspaper about the benefits of
                      or quality of objects or    taking extra math courses in high
                      ideas.                      school.
                      Specific to                 Evaluate the expression for x =
                      mathematics: Evaluate       5, y = 3. Work it out, and write an
                      an expression for a         explanation for someone else to
                      given amount.               follow.
      Narrate         Write a sequence of         Relate the story of the evolution
                      actions occurring over      of the abacus through ancient,
                      time.                       middle, and modern times.
      Reflect/        Present to readers the Think about a different method of
      Question        same questions you ask solving the same problem that still
                      yourself.              results in an accurate answer, and
                                             explain it.
      Summarize       Briefly restate others’     Write a report compiling highlights
                      ideas in your own           of the research on a mathematical
                      words. 	                    question that intrigues you.
      Synthesize      Combine information         Write the final rubric criteria for a
                      and ideas from multiple     math writing assignment.
                      sources.




16	 www.mcrel.org
6. Formal writing
Formal writing should always be graded. When students write formally, they go
beyond the kinds of short writings they might have been doing in learning logs,
blogs, journals, or free writes to write research reports and essays. Formal writing can
still be done collaboratively, however.

Implementation Idea: Conduct a Research Project and Write a Report

Research topics can cover a wide range of students’ interests—Aristotle’s contributions
to the field of mathematics, the reason gas prices go up or down just before an election,
or differences in attitudes towards mathematics in other countries. Whatever students’
interests, when it is time to write the report, explain that formal mathematics research
papers include several sections, although not all papers contain all sections. A basic
format to adapt and share follows.

1.	 Title: Use it to catch the attention of the reader and reflect the content of the
    paper.
2.	 Abstract: This is a summary paragraph that explains the basic purpose of the
    paper, states the question(s) answered, and tells the reader what was proved.
3.	 Literature Review: When researchers consult existing literature and extend the
    ideas they find there, they include a literature review. To complete this section,
    ask questions such as, “What kind of relevant studies or techniques should I
    know about in order to do the project?” “How have others gone about trying to
    solve the problem, and how is my approach different?”
4.	 Statement of the Problem: This “sets the stage” for the paper. A brief
    introduction gives the reader some context. What inspired you to explore this
    problem? Is it a modification of some other question? Why is this problem
    important or interesting to you?
5.	 Body of the Report: This takes the reader on a trip through the research project.
    Using your learning log, write the body of the report as narrative non-fiction,
    including your initial ideas. Include nonlinguistic representations and examples
    as support.
6.	 Ideas for Further Research: State any questions that surfaced that are beyond the
    scope of the project.
7.	 References. You must credit the people whose work you use. The Internet is a
    great resource for this. Writing labs at colleges or universities, in particular, offer
    online user-friendly guidance.




                                                                            info@mcrel.org    17
Final
    FINAL THOUGHTS
    Standards have long been a kind of road map for teachers. For Maggie Johnston,
    the mathematics teacher quoted at the beginning of this booklet, writing also is a
    road map, and perhaps a richer, more detailed one. Teachers who include writing
    experiences in their classrooms set the stage for active problem solving, invention and
    discovery, increased reading, and improved content learning. Students get a chance
    to express new knowledge and skills in their own words, organize their thinking
    about the content, share their ideas, experience a creative side of mathematics, and
    learn to value the act of writing; teachers get a tool that can motivate and engage
    students, instant evaluations about students’ learning, and a way to participate in
    interdisciplinary collaboration. Whatever the purpose, writing should be as much at
    home in a mathematics class as in an English class.




18	 www.mcrel.org
References
 
REFERENCES

Alvermann, D. E. (2002). Effective literacy instruction for adolescents. Journal of Literacy
  Research, 34(2), 189–208. Retrieved April 1, 2009, from http://www.coe.uga.edu/
  reading/faculty/alvermann/effective2.pdf
Bergman, S. (1992). Exploratory programs in middle level schools: A responsive idea.
  In J. Irvin (Ed.), Transforming middle level education (pp. 179–192). Boston: Allyn
  and Bacon.
Burns, Marilyn. (2004, October). Writing in math. Educational Leadership, 30–33.
Countryman, J. (1992). Writing to learn mathematics. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Graham, S. & Perin, D. (2007). Writing next: Effective strategies to improve writing of
  adolescents in middle and high schools. New York: Alliance for Excellent Education.
Mizelle, N. B. (1995, April). Transition from middle school into high school: The student
 perspective. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational
 Research Association, San Francisco.
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM). (2000). Principles and
 standards for school mathematics. Reston, VA: Author.
National Institute for Literacy. (2007). What content-area teachers should know about
 adolescent literacy. Washington, DC: Author.
Paynter, D. E., Bodrova, E. & Doty, J. K. (2005). For the love of words: Vocabulary
  instruction that works. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Pugalee, D. K. (2004). A comparison of verbal and written descriptions of students’
  problem-solving processes. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 55, 27–47.
Pugalee, D. K. (2005). Writing to develop mathematical understanding. Norwood, MA:
  Christopher-Gordon.
Urquhart, V. & McIver, M. (2005). Teaching writing in the content areas. Alexandria,
  VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Winograd, K. (1992). What fifth graders learn when they write their own math
 problems. Educational Leadership, 64(4), 64–66.




                                                                            info@mcrel.org     19
Workshops
    Essential Skills for Academic and Lifelong Success
    Because mathematics and literacy skills are fundamental to student success, McREL
    provides educators with services and products that translate rigorous research into
    practical classroom applications. Learn more about McREL’s mathematics workshops
    and training at http://www.mcrel.org/topics/Mathematics.
    •	 Doing the Right Things Right in Mathematics
    •	 Increasing Mathematical Understanding Through Literacy
    •	 Making Afterschool Count: Mathematics Learning in Afterschool
    •	 Mathematics Leadership Institute (six 2-day sessions)
    •	 Meeting Learning Standards for Preschool and Kindergarten Children: Literacy
       and Mathematics
    •	 Technology in the Content Areas: Elementary Mathematics
    •	 Technology in the Content Areas: Secondary Mathematics
    •	 What Research Says about Improving Mathematics Achievement




Products
    E-mail us at info@mcrel.org to request a product catalog for ordering
    these popular manuals:
    •	
    •	
         For the Love of Words: Vocabulary Instruction that Works
         Remove Limits to Learning With Systematic Vocabulary Instruction•
    •	   Scaffolding Literacy Development in the Preschool Classroom
    •	   Scaffolding Literacy Development in the Kindergarten Classroom
    •	   Teaching Reading in the Content Areas: If Not Me, Then Who? 2nd ed.
    •	   Teaching Reading in Mathematics
    •	   Teaching Writing in the Content Areas
    •	   EDThoughts: What We Know About Mathematics Teaching and Learning, 2nd ed.




    Contact Us
    Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning
    4601 DTC Boulevard, Suite 500
    Denver, Colorado 80237
    Phone: 303.337.0990, Fax: 303.337.3005, E-mail: info@mcrel.org



20	 www.mcrel.org
Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning
        4601 DTC Blvd., Ste. 500, Denver, CO 80237-2596
                      P: 800-781-0156 • F: 303-337-3005
            E-mail info@mcrel.org • Web site www.mcrel.org

More Related Content

What's hot

Nature, scope and development of mathematics ppt
Nature, scope and development of mathematics pptNature, scope and development of mathematics ppt
Nature, scope and development of mathematics pptForum of Blended Learning
 
Man made resources & informal learning contexts
Man made resources & informal learning contextsMan made resources & informal learning contexts
Man made resources & informal learning contextsKrishna Priya. K.B.
 
Developing concepts in mathematics
Developing concepts in mathematicsDeveloping concepts in mathematics
Developing concepts in mathematicsCarlo Magno
 
Effective strategies for teaching mathematics
Effective strategies for teaching mathematicsEffective strategies for teaching mathematics
Effective strategies for teaching mathematicsBetty Tshaena Mochosa
 
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of Mathematics
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of MathematicsCultural & Aesthetic Values of Mathematics
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of MathematicsSreelekshmiV5
 
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptx
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptxNature and Development of Mathematics.pptx
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptxaleena568026
 
Innovative lesson plan
Innovative lesson planInnovative lesson plan
Innovative lesson plannimmyherrycal
 
Math Powerpoint For Presentation
Math Powerpoint For PresentationMath Powerpoint For Presentation
Math Powerpoint For PresentationDeirdre L. Thorpe
 
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacher
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacherProffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacher
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacherJovin John
 
8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths
8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths
8 Tips on How to Help Students with MathsLearnPick
 
Correlation of mathematics
Correlation of mathematicsCorrelation of mathematics
Correlation of mathematicsAthira RL
 
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics Laboratory
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics LaboratoryMaths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics Laboratory
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics LaboratoryForum of Blended Learning
 
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICS
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICSMETHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICS
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICSfarsana kabeer
 
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLAN
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLANDRILL WORK & DALTON PLAN
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLANSruthy S Nair
 
Maths club assignment pdf
Maths club assignment pdfMaths club assignment pdf
Maths club assignment pdfNISHAMATHS
 
Applications of maths in our daily life
Applications of maths in our daily lifeApplications of maths in our daily life
Applications of maths in our daily lifeAbhinav Somani
 
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,Library
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,LibraryMathematics Laboratory,Club,Library
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,Librarymathsvidhya2014
 
Recent Trends of Mathematics in Education
Recent Trends of Mathematics in EducationRecent Trends of Mathematics in Education
Recent Trends of Mathematics in Educationijtsrd
 

What's hot (20)

Nature, scope and development of mathematics ppt
Nature, scope and development of mathematics pptNature, scope and development of mathematics ppt
Nature, scope and development of mathematics ppt
 
Man made resources & informal learning contexts
Man made resources & informal learning contextsMan made resources & informal learning contexts
Man made resources & informal learning contexts
 
Developing concepts in mathematics
Developing concepts in mathematicsDeveloping concepts in mathematics
Developing concepts in mathematics
 
Effective strategies for teaching mathematics
Effective strategies for teaching mathematicsEffective strategies for teaching mathematics
Effective strategies for teaching mathematics
 
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of Mathematics
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of MathematicsCultural & Aesthetic Values of Mathematics
Cultural & Aesthetic Values of Mathematics
 
Mathematical Laboratory
Mathematical LaboratoryMathematical Laboratory
Mathematical Laboratory
 
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptx
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptxNature and Development of Mathematics.pptx
Nature and Development of Mathematics.pptx
 
Innovative lesson plan
Innovative lesson planInnovative lesson plan
Innovative lesson plan
 
Math Powerpoint For Presentation
Math Powerpoint For PresentationMath Powerpoint For Presentation
Math Powerpoint For Presentation
 
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacher
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacherProffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacher
Proffessional qualities and competencies of mathematics teacher
 
8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths
8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths
8 Tips on How to Help Students with Maths
 
Correlation of mathematics
Correlation of mathematicsCorrelation of mathematics
Correlation of mathematics
 
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics Laboratory
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics LaboratoryMaths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics Laboratory
Maths Co-curricular Activities : Mathematics Laboratory
 
Mathematics club
Mathematics clubMathematics club
Mathematics club
 
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICS
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICSMETHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICS
METHODS OF TEACHING MATHEMATICS
 
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLAN
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLANDRILL WORK & DALTON PLAN
DRILL WORK & DALTON PLAN
 
Maths club assignment pdf
Maths club assignment pdfMaths club assignment pdf
Maths club assignment pdf
 
Applications of maths in our daily life
Applications of maths in our daily lifeApplications of maths in our daily life
Applications of maths in our daily life
 
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,Library
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,LibraryMathematics Laboratory,Club,Library
Mathematics Laboratory,Club,Library
 
Recent Trends of Mathematics in Education
Recent Trends of Mathematics in EducationRecent Trends of Mathematics in Education
Recent Trends of Mathematics in Education
 

Similar to Writing in Mathematics

Nctm st.louis10272011
Nctm st.louis10272011Nctm st.louis10272011
Nctm st.louis10272011tkanold
 
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha Peterkin
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha PeterkinDecoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha Peterkin
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha PeterkinLaura Buscemi
 
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyPolya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyEFREN ARCHIDE
 
Reading and Writing for Understanding
Reading and Writing for UnderstandingReading and Writing for Understanding
Reading and Writing for Understandingharvardgraduateppe
 
EARCOS Reflections
EARCOS ReflectionsEARCOS Reflections
EARCOS ReflectionsTGascoigne
 
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًا
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًااستراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًا
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًاIEFE
 
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 Classroom
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 ClassroomPlanning Digital Learning for K-12 Classroom
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 ClassroomMagic Software
 
Writing Power Point
Writing Power PointWriting Power Point
Writing Power PointUniversity
 
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model  Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model MELANYVIVIANA
 
Get Students Talking
Get Students TalkingGet Students Talking
Get Students Talkingjwalts
 
How to Get Kids Talking about Math
How to Get Kids Talking about MathHow to Get Kids Talking about Math
How to Get Kids Talking about Mathjwalts
 
How to Get Students Talking
How to Get Students TalkingHow to Get Students Talking
How to Get Students Talkingjwalts
 
Learning Integration.pptx
Learning Integration.pptxLearning Integration.pptx
Learning Integration.pptxJoshHermoso
 

Similar to Writing in Mathematics (20)

AAMT Connect with Maths webinar: The importance of talk for mathematical lear...
AAMT Connect with Maths webinar: The importance of talk for mathematical lear...AAMT Connect with Maths webinar: The importance of talk for mathematical lear...
AAMT Connect with Maths webinar: The importance of talk for mathematical lear...
 
Nctm st.louis10272011
Nctm st.louis10272011Nctm st.louis10272011
Nctm st.louis10272011
 
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha Peterkin
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha PeterkinDecoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha Peterkin
Decoder slides Mengyuan Suo & Tanisha Peterkin
 
Cognitive Apprenticeship
Cognitive ApprenticeshipCognitive Apprenticeship
Cognitive Apprenticeship
 
April 2013
April 2013April 2013
April 2013
 
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyPolya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
 
Reading and Writing for Understanding
Reading and Writing for UnderstandingReading and Writing for Understanding
Reading and Writing for Understanding
 
EARCOS Reflections
EARCOS ReflectionsEARCOS Reflections
EARCOS Reflections
 
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًا
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًااستراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًا
استراتيجيات التعلم الاحترافية لتخريج معلمين متمرسين مستقبلًا
 
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 Classroom
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 ClassroomPlanning Digital Learning for K-12 Classroom
Planning Digital Learning for K-12 Classroom
 
Writing Power Point
Writing Power PointWriting Power Point
Writing Power Point
 
Red slideshare
Red slideshareRed slideshare
Red slideshare
 
Red slideshare
Red slideshareRed slideshare
Red slideshare
 
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model  Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model
Oral presentation 1: getting an academic writing model
 
Get Students Talking
Get Students TalkingGet Students Talking
Get Students Talking
 
How to Get Kids Talking about Math
How to Get Kids Talking about MathHow to Get Kids Talking about Math
How to Get Kids Talking about Math
 
How to Get Students Talking
How to Get Students TalkingHow to Get Students Talking
How to Get Students Talking
 
December 2012 c
December 2012 cDecember 2012 c
December 2012 c
 
November 2012
November 2012November 2012
November 2012
 
Learning Integration.pptx
Learning Integration.pptxLearning Integration.pptx
Learning Integration.pptx
 

More from jwalts

2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13
2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.132013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13
2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13jwalts
 
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN SAMPLE ACTION PLAN
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN jwalts
 
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATE
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATESCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATE
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATEjwalts
 
LCSS Professional Learning Plan Template
LCSS Professional Learning Plan TemplateLCSS Professional Learning Plan Template
LCSS Professional Learning Plan Templatejwalts
 
Your pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipYour pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipjwalts
 
Your pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipYour pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipjwalts
 
EDU323: Week 02
EDU323: Week 02EDU323: Week 02
EDU323: Week 02jwalts
 
Week 02
Week 02Week 02
Week 02jwalts
 
EDU323 Week 1
EDU323 Week 1EDU323 Week 1
EDU323 Week 1jwalts
 
EDU 323: Week 4
EDU 323: Week 4EDU 323: Week 4
EDU 323: Week 4jwalts
 
Research on Graphic Organizers
Research on Graphic OrganizersResearch on Graphic Organizers
Research on Graphic Organizersjwalts
 
EDU 323: Week 3
EDU 323: Week 3EDU 323: Week 3
EDU 323: Week 3jwalts
 
EDU 323: Week 2
EDU 323: Week 2EDU 323: Week 2
EDU 323: Week 2jwalts
 
Considerations
ConsiderationsConsiderations
Considerationsjwalts
 
Grant Writing Basics
Grant Writing BasicsGrant Writing Basics
Grant Writing Basicsjwalts
 
Grant Writing Organizational Tool
Grant Writing Organizational ToolGrant Writing Organizational Tool
Grant Writing Organizational Tooljwalts
 
EDU 323: Week 1 PPT
EDU 323: Week 1 PPTEDU 323: Week 1 PPT
EDU 323: Week 1 PPTjwalts
 
EDU309 Week 3
EDU309 Week 3EDU309 Week 3
EDU309 Week 3jwalts
 
Edu320 week 3
Edu320 week 3Edu320 week 3
Edu320 week 3jwalts
 
Sample Presentation: Social Studies
Sample Presentation: Social StudiesSample Presentation: Social Studies
Sample Presentation: Social Studiesjwalts
 

More from jwalts (20)

2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13
2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.132013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13
2013 ccrpi indicators 10.11.13
 
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN SAMPLE ACTION PLAN
SAMPLE ACTION PLAN
 
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATE
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATESCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATE
SCHOOL DATA ANALYSIS TEMPLATE
 
LCSS Professional Learning Plan Template
LCSS Professional Learning Plan TemplateLCSS Professional Learning Plan Template
LCSS Professional Learning Plan Template
 
Your pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipYour pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csip
 
Your pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csipYour pl plan for csip
Your pl plan for csip
 
EDU323: Week 02
EDU323: Week 02EDU323: Week 02
EDU323: Week 02
 
Week 02
Week 02Week 02
Week 02
 
EDU323 Week 1
EDU323 Week 1EDU323 Week 1
EDU323 Week 1
 
EDU 323: Week 4
EDU 323: Week 4EDU 323: Week 4
EDU 323: Week 4
 
Research on Graphic Organizers
Research on Graphic OrganizersResearch on Graphic Organizers
Research on Graphic Organizers
 
EDU 323: Week 3
EDU 323: Week 3EDU 323: Week 3
EDU 323: Week 3
 
EDU 323: Week 2
EDU 323: Week 2EDU 323: Week 2
EDU 323: Week 2
 
Considerations
ConsiderationsConsiderations
Considerations
 
Grant Writing Basics
Grant Writing BasicsGrant Writing Basics
Grant Writing Basics
 
Grant Writing Organizational Tool
Grant Writing Organizational ToolGrant Writing Organizational Tool
Grant Writing Organizational Tool
 
EDU 323: Week 1 PPT
EDU 323: Week 1 PPTEDU 323: Week 1 PPT
EDU 323: Week 1 PPT
 
EDU309 Week 3
EDU309 Week 3EDU309 Week 3
EDU309 Week 3
 
Edu320 week 3
Edu320 week 3Edu320 week 3
Edu320 week 3
 
Sample Presentation: Social Studies
Sample Presentation: Social StudiesSample Presentation: Social Studies
Sample Presentation: Social Studies
 

Recently uploaded

Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxMusic 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxleah joy valeriano
 
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptIntegumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptshraddhaparab530
 
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfGrade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfJemuel Francisco
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSJoshuaGantuangco2
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...Postal Advocate Inc.
 
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture hons
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture honsFood processing presentation for bsc agriculture hons
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture honsManeerUddin
 
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translation
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translationActivity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translation
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translationRosabel UA
 
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONTHEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONHumphrey A Beña
 
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdf
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdfICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdf
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdfVanessa Camilleri
 
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...JhezDiaz1
 
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY - GERBNER.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY -  GERBNER.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY -  GERBNER.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY - GERBNER.pptxiammrhaywood
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatYousafMalik24
 
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptxmary850239
 
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)Mark Reed
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxVanesaIglesias10
 
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptx
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptxKarra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptx
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptxAshokKarra1
 
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4JOYLYNSAMANIEGO
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptxMusic 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
Music 9 - 4th quarter - Vocal Music of the Romantic Period.pptx
 
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.pptIntegumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
Integumentary System SMP B. Pharm Sem I.ppt
 
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdfGrade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
Grade 9 Quarter 4 Dll Grade 9 Quarter 4 DLL.pdf
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
 
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
 
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture hons
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture honsFood processing presentation for bsc agriculture hons
Food processing presentation for bsc agriculture hons
 
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translation
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translationActivity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translation
Activity 2-unit 2-update 2024. English translation
 
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONTHEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
 
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdf
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdfICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdf
ICS2208 Lecture6 Notes for SL spaces.pdf
 
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
 
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY - GERBNER.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY -  GERBNER.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY -  GERBNER.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY -CULTIVATION THEORY - GERBNER.pptx
 
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxFINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
FINALS_OF_LEFT_ON_C'N_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
 
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
4.18.24 Movement Legacies, Reflection, and Review.pptx
 
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)
Influencing policy (training slides from Fast Track Impact)
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
 
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptx
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptxKarra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptx
Karra SKD Conference Presentation Revised.pptx
 
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
 

Writing in Mathematics

  • 1. Using Writing in Mathematics to Deepen Student Learning
  • 2. McREL Services & Products to Help All Students and Schools Succeed Since 1966, McREL has offered products and services aimed at improving student achievement to educators, administrators, and policymakers. We work with clients to understand their strengths and challenges in order to know how best to support their efforts, whether it’s providing a short workshop or comprehensive, long-term solutions. Visit our Web site at www.mcrel.org to find out what McREL’s experts do in these areas: • Curriculum & Instruction • Standards & Assessment • Learning 24/7 • Leadership Development • School & Systems Improvement • Policy & Strategy Read more about our literacy-focused products and workshops on page 20. Acknowledgements The following McREL staff members contributed to this publication. Kathleen Dempsey, M.Ed. Matt Kuhn, M.A. Heather Martindill, M.S. © 2009 McREL 20090609 www.mcrel.org
  • 3. Using Writing in Mathematics to Deepen Student Learning by Vicki Urquhart “Writing in mathematics gives me a window into my students’ thoughts that I don’t normally get when they just compute problems. It shows me their roadblocks, and it also gives me, as a teacher, a road map.” –Maggie Johnston 9th-grade mathematics teacher, Denver, Colorado info@mcrel.org
  • 4. 2 www.mcrel.org
  • 5. Introduction INTRODUCTION Writing is the ability to compose text effectively for different purposes and audiences. When many of us reflect on our own school experiences, we recall writing in English and history classes, but not in mathematics. Math classes previously relied on skill- building and conceptual understanding activities. Today, teachers are realizing that writing during a math lesson is more than just a way to document information; it is a way to deepen student learning and a tool for helping students gain new perspectives. They recognize, too, that students whose strengths are language-based—and many are—use writing as the key to understanding other disciplines, especially mathematics. For example, Dr. David K. Pugalee (2004) conducted a study with 9th-grade algebra students to determine if journal writing can be an effective instructional tool in mathematics education and found that it may have a positive effect on problem solving because the writer must organize and describe internal thoughts. Like most things, learning to write well requires instruction and practice. In this booklet, I aim to nudge secondary math teachers who are thinking about using writing in their classrooms more extensively and to encourage those who want to begin. Perhaps you will come to the same conclusion as mathematics educator Marilyn Burns, who said, “I can no longer imagine teaching math without making writing an integral aspect of students’ learning” (p. 30). Section One gives a brief background that answers the question you may be wondering: Why write in mathematics? Section Two describes the existing role of writing in the mathematics curriculum, and Section Three provides strategies and ideas to put into practice right away. info@mcrel.org 3
  • 6. Section One SECTION ONE: What we know from research about writing in the content areas Researchers agree that, like reading, improving student’s writing skills improves their capacity to learn (National Institute for Literacy, 2007). We also know that writing fosters community in a classroom and, because writing is a social act, it is a vehicle for students to learn more about themselves and others. Researcher Donna Alvermann (2002), an expert in adolescent literacy, studies students’ self-efficacy and engagement. She urges all teachers, despite their content area expertise, to encourage students to read and write in many different ways. She does so because she believes that writing raises the “cognitive bar,” challenging students to problem solve and think critically. What other single action requires students to be so grounded in a viewpoint that they can convince others, to know a process so thoroughly that they can explain it to someone else, or to grasp the nuances of an idea so deeply that they can convey it in a way that provokes thought and sparks discussion? I know that writing does this Why are we writing in math class? for me each time I draft an David Pugalee (2005), who researches article or prepare a workshop the relationship between language and presentation. Until I read what mathematics learning, asserts that writing I have written, I don’t see the supports mathematical reasoning and problem holes in my logic, the missing solving and helps students internalize the steps, or the rambling thoughts. characteristics of effective communication. He Writing informs me that I only suggests that teachers read student writing for have a cursory knowledge of evidence of logical conclusions, justification of answers and processes, and the use of facts the content when I need a deep to explain their thinking. one. Simply put, it doesn’t let me cut corners. Whenever I have conducted workshops on using writing in mathematics, math teachers, quick to see the parallels with problem solving, have rallied to the idea. Happily, teachers who want to begin infusing writing in their instruction or who want to increase their use of it don’t have to start from scratch. They can begin with their own well-crafted lessons and add a writing activity that will enhance student engagement and heighten cognitive demands. 4 www.mcrel.org
  • 7. In Writing Next, researchers Graham and Perin (2007) identify the following 11 elements of current writing instruction that help young people learn to write well and to use writing as a tool for learning. 1. Teach students strategies for planning, revising, and editing. 2. Explicitly and systematically teach students how to summarize texts. 3. Use instructional arrangements in which students work together on writing. 4. Assign students specific, reachable goals for their writing tasks. 5. Use computers and word processors as instructional supports for writing assignments. 6. Teach sentence combining as a way to construct more complex, sophisticated sentences. 7. Engage students in prewriting activities to generate ideas for composing. 8. Use inquiry activities where students analyze immediate, concrete data to develop ideas and content for a particular writing task. 9. Use the writing process to provide extended writing opportunities. 10. Provide opportunities to read, analyze, and emulate models of good writing. 11. Use writing as a tool for learning content material. There are many formal and informal ways to make these elements actionable in schools. For example, a school undertaking a writing initiative might adopt one element a month for a year. Or, if teachers already meet regularly for book studies, they could meet to share their ideas, concerns, and successes about implementing one of these writing elements. I encourage you to try, share, and try again. You will get to know your students in ways you never have before, and you will most certainly know who is and isn’t learning mathematics content. info@mcrel.org 5
  • 8. Section Two SECTION TWO: Writing as part of the mathematics curriculum Writing is not a separate entity from the mathematics curriculum; it is part of it. Among the learning goals that the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) has set for all students is to communicate their mathematical Principles and Standards for School thinking. Mathematics NCTM recommends that writing about “Reflection and communication are intertwined processes in mathematics mathematics be nurtured across grades. learning…Writing in mathematics can also NCTM suggests that students write help students consolidate their thinking explanations about how they solved a because it requires them to reflect on problem, solutions to exercises as if they their work and clarify their thoughts about were writing a textbook, essays about the ideas” NCTM (2000), p.61. what it means to prove something, or reports describing the significant contributions of well-known mathematicians (2000). Joan Countryman (1992), who explores the relationship between mathematics and writing, offers the following four benefits of writing in mathematics class: Students write to keep ongoing records about what they’re doing and learning. While they’re writing, students can restate new material in their own words, identify computations that are easy or difficult, or reflect on aspects that confuse them, as in this note from a student to his math teacher. Dear Mr. Kuhn: Today we talked a lot about equations. I understand what an equation is. I have used them many times. But I don’t really understand how an equation can be turned into a sentence. I know how to do the math but not how to explain it. Would you please spend some more time tomorrow teaching us how to make sentences out of equations? Thanks, Sammy 6 www.mcrel.org
  • 9. Students write in order to solve math problems. Students can write the facts they need to answer a question beforehand and afterwards, then check their computations against their written facts. This also helps them see different ways to arrive at an answer. When doing a unit on slope, one of Maggie’s students wrote down her thought process this way: In order to solve the problem, I need to find the rate of change in the sale of blue jeans by subtracting the amount sold in 1992 from 1996 and then add the costs on top of the cost in 1992 until it reaches this year. Another student wrote: I need to find the slope, which is the rate of change, and then next find B and finally solve the problem. The rate of change is the jeans. Students write to explain mathematical ideas. When students write explanations of their work and give examples, teachers can better assess student understanding and progress throughout time. Writing is an ideal vehicle for formative assessment, providing teachers with the information they need to adjust their instruction. Three kinds of writing prompts reflect three aspects of learning mathematics: 1) content, 2) process, and 3) affective. Content prompts deal with mathematical concepts and relationships, process prompts focus on algorithms and problem solving, and affective prompts center on students’ attitudes and feelings. Content prompt examples include these: • Define parallel in your own words. • How would you describe a number line? • Write a paragraph about the graph in the news. • Write one sentence that describes an equation. • How do you know that 1/4 is greater than 1/5? Explain your thinking. • Write as many examples of a square that you can think of in five minutes. • What properties do triangles have? • Write everything you know about money. • What were the key points in today’s lesson? info@mcrel.org 7
  • 10. Students write to describe learning processes. Writing about problem solving requires students to monitor and reflect on the strategies and processes they select. Maggie explains why she uses writing to enhance the metacognitive aspect of learning in mathematics: “If there’s no writing in math class, all they’re doing is the evaluation-execution portion of learning. Orientation and organization come before execution, and that’s what writing gets at. That’s the most valuable piece of writing in mathematics class,” she said. Maggie develops the reflective writing prompts she uses with a learning objective in mind. Frequently, it includes a metacognitive piece, which will require her students to organize a problem, do the problem, and rethink it. This is how it looks in her classroom: Maggie shows the class an example problem from her Algebra 2 class: 2 log4 x - 5 log and asks, “Does anyone know how to do this problem?” She waits for a few minutes, sensing students’ hesitancy to respond. Maggie has anticipated this, so she removes the problem from the overhead, replacing it with a writing prompt she has prepared. “Here’s the writing prompt: When I see this problem, my first reaction is. . . Here are your options: 1. I realize why I hate math. 2. I’m a little afraid, but I know that condense means to make something smaller. 3. I’m not exactly sure how to do this problem, but we’ve been learning about logs.” Maggie has set the stage for learning by providing students a vehicle for describing their learning processes. The rest of the class period includes whole-class brainstorming about what students already know about solving similar problems, time to work alone and with a partner, and sharing learning processes and outcomes. To keep the workload down, Maggie uses only two or three writing prompts with each unit and tries to connect big ideas from each unit through writing. “Once they write about those big ideas, it really enhances their understanding, especially at the high school level,” said Maggie. 8 www.mcrel.org
  • 11. Section Three SECTION THREE: Strategies and ideas for writing in mathematics Not only should teachers be aware of the instructional strategies that are most effective in improving student writing (National Institute for Literacy, 2007; Graham & Perin, 2007); they also need ideas for implementation. In this section, I address that need by returning to the work of Joan Countryman (1992), who observes that writing in the mathematics classroom generally looks like one of six types: Free writes; biography and autobiography; learning logs, blogs, and journals; summaries; word problems; and formal writing. With an understanding of these forms, strategies for implementation, and practical ideas for integrating technology tools, all teachers—regardless of their own comfort levels with writing—can enhance their mathematics lessons. 1. Free writing Free writing involves writing nonstop for a fixed amount of time, usually just a few minutes. Free writes don’t allow time for students to agonize over grammar or spelling; rather, they encourage students to think freely and raise questions about a topic or idea. When you first ask students to free write, give them high-interest topics, so they can begin to write immediately. For example, students usually have strong opinions about whether or not they will ever use advanced mathematics in “real life,” why they should use calculators during high-stakes assessments, or whether an additional year of math should be required in the high school curriculum. Once they are used to writing on broad topics, ask them to write on math-related topics, such as predicting the effect of one rotating object on another or comparing methods of analyzing data sets. Finally, develop prompts that relate specifically to the content you are covering in class by asking students to summarize their learning or describing steps in solving a problem. Implementation Idea: The Journalists’ Questions1 Once students have become comfortable writing for short periods, introduce “The Journalists’ Questions” (who? what? when? where? why? how?). Explain that this traditional reporters’ style of writing is a way of identifying essential information. When studying units of measure, for instance, ask students to write the general topic “the metric system” on their papers and list the six questions, leaving room for a response to each. Give them a few minutes at the beginning or end of class to answer as many as they can. Collect and look over responses, and you will quickly discern what information or misinformation students already have. Here’s how the six questions might apply to the topic “the metric system.” 1 For more writing strategies, see Urquhart, V. & McIver, M. (2005). Teaching Writing in the Content Areas. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. info@mcrel.org 9
  • 12. The Metric System Who? Only three countries have not adopted the metric system: the United States, Liberia, and Myanmar. All the sciences use it, however. What? It is an international system of measurement with proportional graduations that uses naturally occurring standards as base units. When & It was first adopted in 1791 in France and spread throughout Where? Europe. Why? France wanted a standardized system of measurement that would help unify the country with a single currency and countrywide market. It can be reproduced any time by any country. How? It is based on the number ten, so it is easy to go from one unit to another. You just multiply or divide by 10. The next day, have a class discussion to clear up any misconceptions. Give students the option to write a paragraph describing the metric system or defending its use in science and mathematics. If you have access to technology, a fun way to apply this strategy is to pair it with a Web site that you can check out ahead of time. Assign a topic, ask students to complete as many of the Journalists’ Questions as they can, and write a summary paragraph on the topic. 2. Biography & autobiography This type of narrative non-fiction writing encourages students to write descriptively, and to identify significant events, personality traits, turning points, and impacts on a person’s life. The life stories of important mathematicians will intrigue some of your students, and there are many Web sites with biographies, such as Omnibiography. com; allmath.com/biography.php; or even Simpsonsmath.com, where students can read the math biographies of the show’s writers. To extend this writing opportunity, encourage students to write letters or e-mails to the mathematicians (or the Simpson creators) they learned about. Alternatively, ask students to illustrate in the form of a pie chart the percentage of the person’s life devoted to the activity that made him or her famous. You also can use a variation of autobiography called a “mathography” to learn more about your students’ attitudes, perceptions of their effort and abilities, and to know the kind of support they think they need. 10 www.mcrel.org
  • 13. Implementation Idea: Write Your Mathography At the beginning of a year, ask students to write about their experiences learning mathematics, describing the strategies their instructors used to help them learn. Or, provide a choice of writing prompts, such as these: • What early math accomplishments do you remember? (e.g., When and how did you learn to count? Who taught you? How did he or she teach you? Did you “show off” this new talent to others?) • When you were in elementary school, what did you like (or not like) about math? • What do you remember about learning to add and subtract? Which did you think was more fun? Why? • Was math ever your favorite subject? If so, why? If not, why? 3. Learning logs, blogs, & journals Over time, the lines distinguishing learning logs and journals have blurred, but students still can use these writing vehicles to respond to class discussions, make connections between real-life and the content, and to reflect on themselves as learners. Learning logs should focus on content, whereas journals might focus on students’ ideas and questions about a broad range of general topics. Students use each differently. While journaling, they might reflect on anything they consider relevant, carry on conversations with their teachers, or both. Learning logs, on the other hand, are less about “feeling” and more about understanding content. Similarly, blogs allow students to share ideas and solutions in real time with each other, other classes, and the teacher. Although both kinds of insights are valuable, teachers should assign learning logs, blogs, Algebra I Learning Log and journals with different intent. Students • Date: should write frequently in their logs and • Name of topic, presenter, blogs for several minutes at a time at least chapter title, program/video: once a week and should use an established template for entering information. Journal • Pages read, length of discussion/ writing can be less frequent, perhaps every explanation or program/video: two weeks. Here is one example of a learning • Main points: log template that you can adapt and provide • Summary of main points: students. info@mcrel.org 11
  • 14. Implementation Idea: Climbing and Diving This is a good strategy to use when students are writing in their learning logs. As students move back and forth between climbing and diving (into a topic), they internalize the process and the content. For example, following a unit on the area of polygons, students spend 10 minutes writing everything they learned, including formulas and descriptions. They then read over their writing and select one idea to explore further, such as why the formula to determine the area of a triangle works for all triangles, regardless of type. The second 10-minute writing allows them to justify their thinking or reflect on their understanding. If you have access to technology, ask students to journal electronically or keep a class e-learning log or blog. (For more on Climbing and Diving, see Teaching Writing in the Content Areas by Urquhart & McIver.) Implementation Idea: Double-entry Journals A double-entry journal is a long-standing popular activity for any content area. Frequently, teachers pair it with a reading assignment where students summarize on the left, which represents literal information from the text, and respond to the summary on the right, which represents inferential and critical thinking. One way to use a double-entry journal focusing on problem solving is to have students write the problem in the left column and the details for solving it in the right column. To adapt the journal, ask students to create a third column and write a personal reflection that describes what was frustrating or easy, or to draw a horizontal line two-thirds of the way down the paper to provide a section for summarizing the process. 4. Summaries Because students often find summary writing difficult, teachers should explicitly teach summary skills and provide plenty of opportunities for practice. Journals and learning logs are ideal places for students to practice summarizing. Students should understand they must identify main ideas, discriminating between information that is essential and information that is merely interesting. Here are some practical suggestions for using summary writing: • Teach students how to organize key ideas into logical patterns using webs, charts, or diagrams, such as a Venn Diagram, which visually represents common elements, or a concept map, which presents relationship among a set of connected ideas. • Use summary writing when students are learning large amounts of information and vocabulary terms. • Allow students to write collaboratively or summarize together as a whole class. 12 www.mcrel.org
  • 15. Venn Diagram Types of Numbers Prime Even 103 4 18 17 2 3 11 6 23 600 Concept Map 9 - 4 = 5 See how many A bird found 9 things you have Equation beetles. He ate to begin with. 4. At the same Then take away time, 5 beetles How does Story some. Count how it work? Subtraction hid under a many things you rock. Then the have left, and Drawing bird flew away. that is your answer. info@mcrel.org 13
  • 16. Implementation Idea: Magnet Summaries A great way to explicitly teach summary writing is with the “Magnet Summary” strategy. Sample steps for using Magnet Summaries • When studying equations, provide students a written selection (e.g., a textbook section, Web site, or teacher-created document) that explains how to solve an equation. • Read the selection ahead of time and develop a list of key vocabulary words that appear, such as inverse, variable, logarithm, exponent, etc. • Provide students with the same number of index cards as total number of words on the list. • Write the magnet word list on the board, overhead transparency, or PowerPoint, and ask students to write each word on an index card. • Distribute the text selection, and ask students to read it. Working on their own, they should reread and look for the magnet words, identifying key words or phrases in the text that help explain or directly relate to the magnet word. Explain that these are the words or phrases that the magnet words “attract,” and students can highlight them with a marker, if it will help them remember the meaning of the words. • On the back of each index card, students then write a summary sentence in their own words that defines, describes, or expresses the main idea of the magnet word. • Students read their sentences and organize the cards in a logical order. • Students write a summary paragraph, adding transitional words and phrases. • Students read their summaries to others, and revise for clarity and cohesion, using peer feedback. 5. Word problems Words are tools for thinking in mathematics, just as they are in other disciplines. Good word problems promote thinking and encourage students to use their own language, thus owning their ideas. Pugalee cites the research of Winograd (1992), suggesting that students, when asked to write original word problems, will write more interesting and challenging ones than textbook problems. 14 www.mcrel.org
  • 17. Implementation Idea: Explicitly Teach Relevant Vocabulary Whether writing their own word problems or preparing to write constructed responses, students need to be comfortable with certain words, know their definitions, and be able to use them in writing tasks. There are six concrete steps for learning a new word (Paynter, Bodrova, & Doty, 2005): 1. Identify the new word and elicit students’ background knowledge (e.g., the term “probability model”). 2. Explain the meaning of the new word (e.g., tell students that a probability model is a technique for representing the chances of something occurring, and that they will use a model, or something they can manipulate, to determine the chances of two students each drawing a red chip from a bag of five blue and five red chips. Show them two colored charts, one representing each student’s chances, and a third chart representing the chances of both of the students drawing a red chip. 3. Monitor students as they work in small groups to generate their own explanations. If they have difficulty, you might need to provide a sentence stem or ask questions or provide tools, such as dictionaries or thesauruses. 4. Ask students to create a visual representation of the new word. If you have access to technology and the Internet, encourage students to find clip art, photos, or interactive models (see a selection of mathematics and science interactives at http://www.explorelearning.com). 5. Provide an experience to use the new word (e.g., discuss the probability that students will win the state lottery). 6. Engage students in activities (e.g., vocabulary baseball or vocabulary bingo) to help them remember the word and its meaning. info@mcrel.org 15
  • 18. In addition to teaching mathematics-specific vocabulary, teach students terms they will see on state tests. Several of the most-used terms on constructed response items appear in the chart that follows. You can assign the writing task on the chart or adapt it to use with your students. Common Constructed Response Terms with Definitions and Mathematics Writing Tasks Term Definition Mathematics Writing Tasks Analyze Break down a topic into Examine a set of economic its parts and examine statistics and write an editorial on how each part functions the cause and effect relationship in relation to the whole. between high wages and inflation. Describe Represent a person, Write a detailed description of a object, or idea in words. model so that someone else can re-create it. Evaluate General: Determine Write an article for a student the significance, worth, newspaper about the benefits of or quality of objects or taking extra math courses in high ideas. school. Specific to Evaluate the expression for x = mathematics: Evaluate 5, y = 3. Work it out, and write an an expression for a explanation for someone else to given amount. follow. Narrate Write a sequence of Relate the story of the evolution actions occurring over of the abacus through ancient, time. middle, and modern times. Reflect/ Present to readers the Think about a different method of Question same questions you ask solving the same problem that still yourself. results in an accurate answer, and explain it. Summarize Briefly restate others’ Write a report compiling highlights ideas in your own of the research on a mathematical words. question that intrigues you. Synthesize Combine information Write the final rubric criteria for a and ideas from multiple math writing assignment. sources. 16 www.mcrel.org
  • 19. 6. Formal writing Formal writing should always be graded. When students write formally, they go beyond the kinds of short writings they might have been doing in learning logs, blogs, journals, or free writes to write research reports and essays. Formal writing can still be done collaboratively, however. Implementation Idea: Conduct a Research Project and Write a Report Research topics can cover a wide range of students’ interests—Aristotle’s contributions to the field of mathematics, the reason gas prices go up or down just before an election, or differences in attitudes towards mathematics in other countries. Whatever students’ interests, when it is time to write the report, explain that formal mathematics research papers include several sections, although not all papers contain all sections. A basic format to adapt and share follows. 1. Title: Use it to catch the attention of the reader and reflect the content of the paper. 2. Abstract: This is a summary paragraph that explains the basic purpose of the paper, states the question(s) answered, and tells the reader what was proved. 3. Literature Review: When researchers consult existing literature and extend the ideas they find there, they include a literature review. To complete this section, ask questions such as, “What kind of relevant studies or techniques should I know about in order to do the project?” “How have others gone about trying to solve the problem, and how is my approach different?” 4. Statement of the Problem: This “sets the stage” for the paper. A brief introduction gives the reader some context. What inspired you to explore this problem? Is it a modification of some other question? Why is this problem important or interesting to you? 5. Body of the Report: This takes the reader on a trip through the research project. Using your learning log, write the body of the report as narrative non-fiction, including your initial ideas. Include nonlinguistic representations and examples as support. 6. Ideas for Further Research: State any questions that surfaced that are beyond the scope of the project. 7. References. You must credit the people whose work you use. The Internet is a great resource for this. Writing labs at colleges or universities, in particular, offer online user-friendly guidance. info@mcrel.org 17
  • 20. Final FINAL THOUGHTS Standards have long been a kind of road map for teachers. For Maggie Johnston, the mathematics teacher quoted at the beginning of this booklet, writing also is a road map, and perhaps a richer, more detailed one. Teachers who include writing experiences in their classrooms set the stage for active problem solving, invention and discovery, increased reading, and improved content learning. Students get a chance to express new knowledge and skills in their own words, organize their thinking about the content, share their ideas, experience a creative side of mathematics, and learn to value the act of writing; teachers get a tool that can motivate and engage students, instant evaluations about students’ learning, and a way to participate in interdisciplinary collaboration. Whatever the purpose, writing should be as much at home in a mathematics class as in an English class. 18 www.mcrel.org
  • 21. References   REFERENCES Alvermann, D. E. (2002). Effective literacy instruction for adolescents. Journal of Literacy Research, 34(2), 189–208. Retrieved April 1, 2009, from http://www.coe.uga.edu/ reading/faculty/alvermann/effective2.pdf Bergman, S. (1992). Exploratory programs in middle level schools: A responsive idea. In J. Irvin (Ed.), Transforming middle level education (pp. 179–192). Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Burns, Marilyn. (2004, October). Writing in math. Educational Leadership, 30–33. Countryman, J. (1992). Writing to learn mathematics. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. Graham, S. & Perin, D. (2007). Writing next: Effective strategies to improve writing of adolescents in middle and high schools. New York: Alliance for Excellent Education. Mizelle, N. B. (1995, April). Transition from middle school into high school: The student perspective. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM). (2000). Principles and standards for school mathematics. Reston, VA: Author. National Institute for Literacy. (2007). What content-area teachers should know about adolescent literacy. Washington, DC: Author. Paynter, D. E., Bodrova, E. & Doty, J. K. (2005). For the love of words: Vocabulary instruction that works. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Pugalee, D. K. (2004). A comparison of verbal and written descriptions of students’ problem-solving processes. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 55, 27–47. Pugalee, D. K. (2005). Writing to develop mathematical understanding. Norwood, MA: Christopher-Gordon. Urquhart, V. & McIver, M. (2005). Teaching writing in the content areas. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Winograd, K. (1992). What fifth graders learn when they write their own math problems. Educational Leadership, 64(4), 64–66. info@mcrel.org 19
  • 22. Workshops Essential Skills for Academic and Lifelong Success Because mathematics and literacy skills are fundamental to student success, McREL provides educators with services and products that translate rigorous research into practical classroom applications. Learn more about McREL’s mathematics workshops and training at http://www.mcrel.org/topics/Mathematics. • Doing the Right Things Right in Mathematics • Increasing Mathematical Understanding Through Literacy • Making Afterschool Count: Mathematics Learning in Afterschool • Mathematics Leadership Institute (six 2-day sessions) • Meeting Learning Standards for Preschool and Kindergarten Children: Literacy and Mathematics • Technology in the Content Areas: Elementary Mathematics • Technology in the Content Areas: Secondary Mathematics • What Research Says about Improving Mathematics Achievement Products E-mail us at info@mcrel.org to request a product catalog for ordering these popular manuals: • • For the Love of Words: Vocabulary Instruction that Works Remove Limits to Learning With Systematic Vocabulary Instruction• • Scaffolding Literacy Development in the Preschool Classroom • Scaffolding Literacy Development in the Kindergarten Classroom • Teaching Reading in the Content Areas: If Not Me, Then Who? 2nd ed. • Teaching Reading in Mathematics • Teaching Writing in the Content Areas • EDThoughts: What We Know About Mathematics Teaching and Learning, 2nd ed. Contact Us Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning 4601 DTC Boulevard, Suite 500 Denver, Colorado 80237 Phone: 303.337.0990, Fax: 303.337.3005, E-mail: info@mcrel.org 20 www.mcrel.org
  • 23.
  • 24. Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning 4601 DTC Blvd., Ste. 500, Denver, CO 80237-2596 P: 800-781-0156 • F: 303-337-3005 E-mail info@mcrel.org • Web site www.mcrel.org