1. Backlist Ebooks &
the Library Market
One librarian’s perspective
Jason Price, PhD
Interim Library Director / Consultant
Claremont Colleges Library / SCELC
AAUP Boston June 21 2013
2. What do librarians think about
backlist ebooks?
“I don’t have a budget for those, heck I don’t
have a budget for new ones!”
“I’m happy to buy them on request or
demand, but don’t want to purchase until we
have a demonstrated need”
“I don’t like packages, can I pick & choose?”
“If they’re in collections, they’d better be
cheap!”
3. Backfile income from libraries…
Opportunity
1. Ebook aggregator
backfile subscriptions
2. Publisher-hosted
backfile packages
3. “Out of print” DDA
loans & purchases
Challenge
1. Little income? Competes
w/ DDA?
2. Requires deep discounts or
a new model
1. Long term availability for
DDA purchase
6. Subscription cost less than a penny on
the dollar per year!
Subscribable Ebrary Ebooks = 77,482
purchase price $5,670,776 (single-user price)
≤ $3.75/FTE… so for 5000 fte = $18750/year
% of list price per year = 0.33% (multi-user price)
Years to buy = 300+ years!
Ebsco subscription pricing is similar…
Q.E.D. Libraries investing in aggregator ebooks
should subscribe to both packages and avoid buying
individual books that are (or will be!) available by
subscription…
7. 2) Publisher-hosted backfile collections
Benefits of DRM-free content
outweighed by aversion to collections
Solution 1: Dime on the dollar
pricing (or less)!
Solution 2: Evidence-based custom collections
EBASS 25 Youtube Video
Outstanding 10 minute intro to all things PDA
http://bit.ly/ebassPDA
16. Questions for later discussion?
Q: Will libraries replace their print book
holdings with ebook versions?
A: Not for quite a while… (Journals 1st)
Q: Why do we need e-backlists since libraries
can scan print & post on courseware?
A: only covers 10% of a book - SIPX
Q: Won’t Hathi & Google provide this service /
swoop in?
A: Hathi – No. Google – maybe.
Hinweis der Redaktion
Publication dates of subscribed collections mirror the full collectionsEbsco has many more books from the 80s & 90sWhen we take a closer look at the most recent decade…
The data presented on this slide argue STRONGLY for subscribing to BOTH collections, given the differentiation presented in the previous slidesInstead of a 10 or 20 year period of subscription matching the purchase price, it would take 300(!) years of subscription costs to own the same contentFurthermore and perhaps equally important(!) books in the subscribed collections have unlimited simultaneous use, while purchased books from these two vendors are limited to a single simultaneous user (unless a premium is paid for each book)
Would they buy more if there was less DRM?
But of course they represent only a tiny portion of what is available in the overall marketplaceJSTOR offerings are just becoming available as we speak
Each color slice shows the proportion of collection by decade or century*from hathitrust.org website [http://www.hathitrust.org/visualizations_dates]
Caveat – this only reflects relative size -- its not book to book matching as in prior comparisons…that’s a next step
Not a fan of 3d graphs, except in this case where the EBAM is effectively carpet on the floor that wouldn’t be visible if you looked at it end on.Although some currently question the value of our owned print collections, potential future subscription models from Hathi or Google (should copyright and royalty issues prove to be solvable) would definitely call into question the value of ownership of aggregator hosted ebooks that are subsumed within them