SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Download to read offline
6363 Woodway Dr
                                                                                                      Suite 870
                                                                                             Houston, TX 77057
                                                                                           Phone: 713-244-3030
                                                                                             Fax: 713-513-5669

                                                                                   Securities are offered through
                                                                                             RAYMOND JAMES
                                                                                   FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.
                                                                                          Member FINRA / SIPC




                                                                      Green Financial Group
                                                                                        An Independent Firm




Weekly Commentary by Dr. Scott Brown


What’s A Central Banker To Do?

August 22 – 26, 2011



Fed Camp. The Kansas City Fed’s annual monetary policy symposium in Jackson Hole, Wyoming is attended
by central bankers from around the world. For U.S. investors, the focus will be on Bernanke’s speech on
Friday (August 26). Many market participants are hoping for a repeat of last year, when the Fed Chairman
signaled the possibility of a second round of asset purchases (what most people call “QE2”). However, while
the August 9 Federal Open Market Committee indicated that its members were discussing a range of policy
tools to promote growth, the FOMC is unlikely to pull the trigger on another round of asset purchases
anytime soon. The main reason for that reluctance is the inflation backdrop.
The data reports over the last several weeks suggest a continued, but subpar, economic recovery – not a
recession. At best, growth is expected to be enough to absorb the growth in the working-age population, but
will fall short of what’s needed to make up much of the ground lost in the labor market during the downturn.
At worst, we enter a new recession. We continue to face a number of economic headwinds and the risks to the
growth outlook are tilted to the downside. Models of recession probabilities, as well as personal judgment,
suggest that the odds of entering a recession within the next 12 months may be 30% to 35% – not likely, but
too high for comfort.


Unlike a year ago, when the appearance of an economic soft patch was accompanied by falling inflation and
declining inflation expectations, the recent inflation experience has been different. The core CPI has risen at
a 2.5% annual rate in the first seven months of 2011 – above the Fed’s comfort range (1.5% to 2.0%), but not
“runaway” inflation. Commodity price pressures have moderated, but some firms are trying to pass along the
higher costs that were run up over the last several months. Wage pressures remain moderate. Inflation
expectations appear to be well-anchored. Breakeven inflation, the spread between yields on inflation-
adjusted and fixed-rate Treasuries, has dropped in the last few weeks, but that decline partly reflects a flight
to safety in fixed-rate Treasuries (there’s a time-varying liquidity premium built into the price of fixed-rate
Treasuries, which means that breakeven inflation rates are not necessarily the same as inflation
expectations). The Atlanta Fed has a model of deflation probabilities (the likelihood that the reference CPI
will be lower in April 2015 than it was in April 2010). The probability of deflation was relatively high last
year, but began to fall as the Fed indicated another round of asset purchases. Currently, the odds of deflation
remain low.
So why would the Fed want to undertake another round of asset purchases? In setting monetary policy, the
Fed has to be forward thinking. One could argue that the economy will continue to weaken and that the odds
of deflation will increase, but that seems like a bit of a stretch right now – a possibility, not the most likely
outcome. In addition, this isn’t Bernanke’s decision alone. He has to convince a majority on the FOMC.


In his monetary policy testimony in July, Bernanke highlighted a number of steps the Fed could take
if “economic weakness proves to be more persistent than expected and deflationary risks reemerge.” One is
to provide more explicit guidance about the period over which the federal funds rate will remain low (as was
done at the August 9 policy meeting). The Fed could also increase its asset purchases or lengthen the
maturity of securities held in its portfolio. It could also lower the interest rate that it pays on bank reserves.
However, the use of any of these tools is predicated on the Fed seeing a renewed risk of deflation.


Market participants expect something from Bernanke on Friday, but there’s a good chance that they’ll be
disappointed.

More Related Content

More from Jeff Green

The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding PatternThe Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
Jeff Green
 
S&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
S&P Downgrades U.S. DebtS&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
S&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
Jeff Green
 

More from Jeff Green (20)

What Does the Supreme Court Ruling on the Health-Care Reform Law Mean for You?
What Does the Supreme Court Ruling on the Health-Care Reform Law Mean for You?What Does the Supreme Court Ruling on the Health-Care Reform Law Mean for You?
What Does the Supreme Court Ruling on the Health-Care Reform Law Mean for You?
 
Europe and The Summer of Uncertainty
Europe and The Summer of UncertaintyEurope and The Summer of Uncertainty
Europe and The Summer of Uncertainty
 
Market Update: May 2012
Market Update: May 2012Market Update: May 2012
Market Update: May 2012
 
Market Update
Market UpdateMarket Update
Market Update
 
New 401(k) Plan Disclosure Rules
New 401(k) Plan Disclosure RulesNew 401(k) Plan Disclosure Rules
New 401(k) Plan Disclosure Rules
 
Fed Policy Outlook – Changes On The Way
Fed Policy Outlook – Changes On The WayFed Policy Outlook – Changes On The Way
Fed Policy Outlook – Changes On The Way
 
Debt Story
Debt StoryDebt Story
Debt Story
 
Market Update: November 14, 2011
Market Update: November 14, 2011Market Update: November 14, 2011
Market Update: November 14, 2011
 
Super Committee To The Rescue
Super Committee To The RescueSuper Committee To The Rescue
Super Committee To The Rescue
 
Feeling Better
Feeling BetterFeeling Better
Feeling Better
 
Fed Outlook – More Asset Purchases?
Fed Outlook – More Asset Purchases?Fed Outlook – More Asset Purchases?
Fed Outlook – More Asset Purchases?
 
No Recession, At Least For Now
No Recession, At Least For NowNo Recession, At Least For Now
No Recession, At Least For Now
 
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding PatternThe Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
 
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding PatternThe Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
The Economic Outlook – In A Holding Pattern
 
Policy Conundrums
Policy ConundrumsPolicy Conundrums
Policy Conundrums
 
S&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
S&P Downgrades U.S. DebtS&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
S&P Downgrades U.S. Debt
 
The Debt Ceiling and the Road Ahead
The Debt Ceiling and the Road AheadThe Debt Ceiling and the Road Ahead
The Debt Ceiling and the Road Ahead
 
A Fate Worse Than Debt?
A Fate Worse Than Debt?A Fate Worse Than Debt?
A Fate Worse Than Debt?
 
The Debt Ceiling Crisis
The Debt Ceiling CrisisThe Debt Ceiling Crisis
The Debt Ceiling Crisis
 
The Employment Outlook
The Employment OutlookThe Employment Outlook
The Employment Outlook
 

What’s A Central Banker To Do?

  • 1. 6363 Woodway Dr Suite 870 Houston, TX 77057 Phone: 713-244-3030 Fax: 713-513-5669 Securities are offered through RAYMOND JAMES FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC. Member FINRA / SIPC Green Financial Group An Independent Firm Weekly Commentary by Dr. Scott Brown What’s A Central Banker To Do? August 22 – 26, 2011 Fed Camp. The Kansas City Fed’s annual monetary policy symposium in Jackson Hole, Wyoming is attended by central bankers from around the world. For U.S. investors, the focus will be on Bernanke’s speech on Friday (August 26). Many market participants are hoping for a repeat of last year, when the Fed Chairman signaled the possibility of a second round of asset purchases (what most people call “QE2”). However, while the August 9 Federal Open Market Committee indicated that its members were discussing a range of policy tools to promote growth, the FOMC is unlikely to pull the trigger on another round of asset purchases anytime soon. The main reason for that reluctance is the inflation backdrop.
  • 2. The data reports over the last several weeks suggest a continued, but subpar, economic recovery – not a recession. At best, growth is expected to be enough to absorb the growth in the working-age population, but will fall short of what’s needed to make up much of the ground lost in the labor market during the downturn. At worst, we enter a new recession. We continue to face a number of economic headwinds and the risks to the growth outlook are tilted to the downside. Models of recession probabilities, as well as personal judgment, suggest that the odds of entering a recession within the next 12 months may be 30% to 35% – not likely, but too high for comfort. Unlike a year ago, when the appearance of an economic soft patch was accompanied by falling inflation and declining inflation expectations, the recent inflation experience has been different. The core CPI has risen at a 2.5% annual rate in the first seven months of 2011 – above the Fed’s comfort range (1.5% to 2.0%), but not “runaway” inflation. Commodity price pressures have moderated, but some firms are trying to pass along the higher costs that were run up over the last several months. Wage pressures remain moderate. Inflation expectations appear to be well-anchored. Breakeven inflation, the spread between yields on inflation- adjusted and fixed-rate Treasuries, has dropped in the last few weeks, but that decline partly reflects a flight to safety in fixed-rate Treasuries (there’s a time-varying liquidity premium built into the price of fixed-rate Treasuries, which means that breakeven inflation rates are not necessarily the same as inflation expectations). The Atlanta Fed has a model of deflation probabilities (the likelihood that the reference CPI will be lower in April 2015 than it was in April 2010). The probability of deflation was relatively high last year, but began to fall as the Fed indicated another round of asset purchases. Currently, the odds of deflation remain low.
  • 3. So why would the Fed want to undertake another round of asset purchases? In setting monetary policy, the Fed has to be forward thinking. One could argue that the economy will continue to weaken and that the odds of deflation will increase, but that seems like a bit of a stretch right now – a possibility, not the most likely outcome. In addition, this isn’t Bernanke’s decision alone. He has to convince a majority on the FOMC. In his monetary policy testimony in July, Bernanke highlighted a number of steps the Fed could take if “economic weakness proves to be more persistent than expected and deflationary risks reemerge.” One is to provide more explicit guidance about the period over which the federal funds rate will remain low (as was done at the August 9 policy meeting). The Fed could also increase its asset purchases or lengthen the maturity of securities held in its portfolio. It could also lower the interest rate that it pays on bank reserves. However, the use of any of these tools is predicated on the Fed seeing a renewed risk of deflation. Market participants expect something from Bernanke on Friday, but there’s a good chance that they’ll be disappointed.