Honor Killings - The Crown prosecutor (the Canadian equivalent of a DA) argued these murders were honor killings. The three Shafia daughters had shamed the family by adopting Western lifestyles and the two elder daughters had boyfriends. Not surprisingly, most Muslim ...

1. SEARCH LATEST NEWS
Honor Killings Home Privacy Archive
HONOR KILLINGS
POSTED BY EIZ ON THURSDAY, 19 JANUARY, 2012, 7:14 AM
GO
Honor-Killings.png
The Crown prosecutor (the Canadian equivalent of a DA) argued these murders were honor
killings. The three Shafia daughters had shamed the family by adopting Western lifestyles and the
two elder daughters had boyfriends. Not surprisingly, most Muslim ...
Share |
HONOR KILLINGS
POSTED BY EIZ ON THURSDAY, 19 JANUARY, 2012, 7:14 AM
This story didn't receive much attention
here but it has dominated the headlines in
Canada since October when the Shafia
Family trial began in Kingston, Ontario.
Mohammad Shafia, his second wife
Tooba Yahya and his son Hamed Shafia
were accused of the June 2009 murders
of his teenaged daughters Zainab, Sahar
and Geeti (ages 19, 17 & 13) and his first
wife Rona Amir Mohammad. Their bodies
were found submerged inside a car in a
lock along the Rideau Canal outside of
Kingston.
The Shafias were originally from Afghanistan but fled to Dubai before moving to Australia and then
finally to Canada in 2007 settling in Montreal. On Sunday, the three defendants were found guilty of
four counts of first degree murder and each sentenced to life in prison with parole eligibility in 25
years. The Crown prosecutor (the Canadian equivalent of a D.A.) argued these murders were
honor killings. The three Shafia daughters had shamed the family by adopting Western lifestyles
and the two elder daughters had boyfriends.
Not surprisingly, most Muslim organizations have rejected that the Shafia murders were an honor
killing and argue that they are an act of domestic violence. Alaa Elsayed, Director of Religious
Affairs at the Islamic Centre of Canada in Toronto, claims, "It's a domestic violence issue, bottom
line. It has nothing to do with religion, specifically Islam." Meanwhile, Alia Hogben of the Canadian
Council of Muslim Women calls the killings "femicide."
But Tarek Fatah, founder of the Muslim Canadian Congress, sees things quite differently. Fatah
told The Toronto Star the system had failed the Shafia girls:
If a white student would go to the principal or the police and say they would be beaten up, no one
would go to their parents and say 'can you repeat what you said to us?' These girls went to the
school, the cops, child services and everyone wanted to protect multiculturalism - not the lives of
these young women.
It's also not surprising that some Canadian feminists aren't willing to call the Shafia murders
honor killings and that many liberal Canadians are unwilling to call these acts honor killings for
fear of being called racist. But here are a couple of articles that take these arguments apart - one