Suche senden
Hochladen
Fabric Arch Compet
•
2 gefällt mir
•
1,293 views
He Hariyadi
Folgen
Very Low latency Switch Fabric, its new era Data Center Cloud
Weniger lesen
Mehr lesen
Melden
Teilen
Melden
Teilen
1 von 55
Jetzt herunterladen
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Empfohlen
Pcdvpcu en ex9200-customer-presentation-1
Pcdvpcu en ex9200-customer-presentation-1
He Hariyadi
TechWiseTV Workshop - Q&A - Cisco Catalyst 9100 Access Points for Wi-Fi 6
TechWiseTV Workshop - Q&A - Cisco Catalyst 9100 Access Points for Wi-Fi 6
Robb Boyd
Cisco catalyst 3750 x series switches
Cisco catalyst 3750 x series switches
3Anetwork com
Cisco SFPOC48SR
Cisco SFPOC48SR
savomir
Pro Labs Hardware Com Optical Brochure
Pro Labs Hardware Com Optical Brochure
jwalkup_001
Deploying Carrier Ethernet features on ASR 9000
Deploying Carrier Ethernet features on ASR 9000
Vinod Kumar Balasubramanyam
ASR-9000 в качестве платформы внедрения SDN в сетях операторов связи
ASR-9000 в качестве платформы внедрения SDN в сетях операторов связи
Cisco Russia
SIS_LineCard_2016
SIS_LineCard_2016
Melanie Miller
Empfohlen
Pcdvpcu en ex9200-customer-presentation-1
Pcdvpcu en ex9200-customer-presentation-1
He Hariyadi
TechWiseTV Workshop - Q&A - Cisco Catalyst 9100 Access Points for Wi-Fi 6
TechWiseTV Workshop - Q&A - Cisco Catalyst 9100 Access Points for Wi-Fi 6
Robb Boyd
Cisco catalyst 3750 x series switches
Cisco catalyst 3750 x series switches
3Anetwork com
Cisco SFPOC48SR
Cisco SFPOC48SR
savomir
Pro Labs Hardware Com Optical Brochure
Pro Labs Hardware Com Optical Brochure
jwalkup_001
Deploying Carrier Ethernet features on ASR 9000
Deploying Carrier Ethernet features on ASR 9000
Vinod Kumar Balasubramanyam
ASR-9000 в качестве платформы внедрения SDN в сетях операторов связи
ASR-9000 в качестве платформы внедрения SDN в сетях операторов связи
Cisco Russia
SIS_LineCard_2016
SIS_LineCard_2016
Melanie Miller
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
Cisco Russia
1 asr9 k platform architecture
1 asr9 k platform architecture
Thanh Hung Quach
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
savomir
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
Jeff Green
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
seiland
Cisco switching technical
Cisco switching technical
ImranD1
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
ADVA
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
Cisco Canada
ISR vs ASR
ISR vs ASR
Mujahid Pasha
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Cisco Canada
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Arrow ECS UK
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
savomir
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
ADVA
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Cisco Canada
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Suministros Obras y Sistemas
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
candy tang
Fujitsu 100G Overview
Fujitsu 100G Overview
Ed Dodds
4.) switch performance (w features)
4.) switch performance (w features)
Jeff Green
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Router Analysis, Inc.
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
erjosito
Aws dc simple-workflow
Aws dc simple-workflow
beaknit
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
Bob Radcliffe
Weitere ähnliche Inhalte
Was ist angesagt?
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
Cisco Russia
1 asr9 k platform architecture
1 asr9 k platform architecture
Thanh Hung Quach
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
savomir
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
Jeff Green
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
seiland
Cisco switching technical
Cisco switching technical
ImranD1
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
ADVA
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
Cisco Canada
ISR vs ASR
ISR vs ASR
Mujahid Pasha
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Cisco Canada
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Arrow ECS UK
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
savomir
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
ADVA
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Cisco Canada
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Suministros Obras y Sistemas
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
candy tang
Fujitsu 100G Overview
Fujitsu 100G Overview
Ed Dodds
4.) switch performance (w features)
4.) switch performance (w features)
Jeff Green
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Router Analysis, Inc.
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
erjosito
Was ist angesagt?
(20)
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
Инновации в архитектуре маршрутизатора ASR9K. Технология сетевой витруализаци...
1 asr9 k platform architecture
1 asr9 k platform architecture
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
Cisco XFP-10GLR-OC192SR
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
20.) physical (optics copper and power)
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
9000 InfiniBand Datasheet
Cisco switching technical
Cisco switching technical
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
Performance Tradeoffs of 120 Gb/s DP-QPSK in ROADM Systems
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
Fiber Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) – Design, operations and management best p...
ISR vs ASR
ISR vs ASR
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Unified Access Update - 11AC and Switching Platform
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Product Guide
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
Cisco MEM-C6K-CPTFL256M
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
New Breed of Carrier Chooses ADVA Ensemble for Intel-Powered NFV Solutions
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Deploying Cisco ISR G2 and ASR 1000 in the Enterprise
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Cisco Catalyst Poster
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
Why we should choose the cisco 3850 and 3650 switches
Fujitsu 100G Overview
Fujitsu 100G Overview
4.) switch performance (w features)
4.) switch performance (w features)
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Cisco ASR 1000 Series Testing Results and Analysis
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
Dc tco in_a_nutshell
Andere mochten auch
Aws dc simple-workflow
Aws dc simple-workflow
beaknit
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
Bob Radcliffe
Shenzhen longreen products brochure
Shenzhen longreen products brochure
Anna Cao
OCP-SPIRIT-Final-v5
OCP-SPIRIT-Final-v5
Serge Amougou
Proactively Managing Your Data Center Infrastructure
Proactively Managing Your Data Center Infrastructure
kimotte
Leading the Way in Intelligent Data Center Infrastructure
Leading the Way in Intelligent Data Center Infrastructure
Huawei Enterprise Hong Kong
QFabric: Enabling The New Data Center
QFabric: Enabling The New Data Center
Juniper Networks
Architecting data center networks in the era of big data and cloud
Architecting data center networks in the era of big data and cloud
bradhedlund
Managing human resources at data centers 1.0
Managing human resources at data centers 1.0
aqel aqel
Huawei presentation at TADHack
Huawei presentation at TADHack
Alan Quayle
477AC32961
477AC32961
Kassien Smith
Information Storage Associate Version 3 (EMCISA) certificate
Information Storage Associate Version 3 (EMCISA) certificate
Praful P
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate
Lawrence Lam LPIC© CLA© ITIL©
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate (1)
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate (1)
Kar Leong chooi
VMware Certified Associate 6 - Data Center Virtualization certificate
VMware Certified Associate 6 - Data Center Virtualization certificate
Ankit Gupta
IBM_WebSphere_12_23_16_PM
IBM_WebSphere_12_23_16_PM
Lawrence Lam LPIC© CLA© ITIL©
Chooi Kar Leong -SCSE
Chooi Kar Leong -SCSE
Kar Leong chooi
Certificate_1
Certificate_1
Kar Leong chooi
cca_certificate-1
cca_certificate-1
Kar Leong chooi
ACSP
ACSP
Daniel Boydston
Andere mochten auch
(20)
Aws dc simple-workflow
Aws dc simple-workflow
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
LumaNext ppt.11.16.15
Shenzhen longreen products brochure
Shenzhen longreen products brochure
OCP-SPIRIT-Final-v5
OCP-SPIRIT-Final-v5
Proactively Managing Your Data Center Infrastructure
Proactively Managing Your Data Center Infrastructure
Leading the Way in Intelligent Data Center Infrastructure
Leading the Way in Intelligent Data Center Infrastructure
QFabric: Enabling The New Data Center
QFabric: Enabling The New Data Center
Architecting data center networks in the era of big data and cloud
Architecting data center networks in the era of big data and cloud
Managing human resources at data centers 1.0
Managing human resources at data centers 1.0
Huawei presentation at TADHack
Huawei presentation at TADHack
477AC32961
477AC32961
Information Storage Associate Version 3 (EMCISA) certificate
Information Storage Associate Version 3 (EMCISA) certificate
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate (1)
CompTIA Storage+ Powered by SNIA certificate (1)
VMware Certified Associate 6 - Data Center Virtualization certificate
VMware Certified Associate 6 - Data Center Virtualization certificate
IBM_WebSphere_12_23_16_PM
IBM_WebSphere_12_23_16_PM
Chooi Kar Leong -SCSE
Chooi Kar Leong -SCSE
Certificate_1
Certificate_1
cca_certificate-1
cca_certificate-1
ACSP
ACSP
Ähnlich wie Fabric Arch Compet
Ceragon Networks: Enabling Mobile Broadband in Asia - Creative Approaches
Ceragon Networks: Enabling Mobile Broadband in Asia - Creative Approaches
Ceragon
OFC/NFOEC: Software Defined Optical Networks
OFC/NFOEC: Software Defined Optical Networks
ADVA
Qf deck
Qf deck
Liz Carlston
Intel's Nehalem Microarchitecture by Glenn Hinton
Intel's Nehalem Microarchitecture by Glenn Hinton
parallellabs
Cisco open network environment
Cisco open network environment
deepers
Alcatel lucent paolo_volpato_mpls_mw_uppersidex
Alcatel lucent paolo_volpato_mpls_mw_uppersidex
Paolo_Volpato
Introducing VNX Series
Introducing VNX Series
Arraya Solutions
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Newlink
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Newlink
Hp gavin pratt - open stack networking presentation
Hp gavin pratt - open stack networking presentation
laurabeckcahoon
Timing Excellence for Mobile Backhaul Networks at Broadband World Forum
Timing Excellence for Mobile Backhaul Networks at Broadband World Forum
ADVA
Cots moves to multicore: Wind River
Cots moves to multicore: Wind River
Konrad Witte
Big Data Smarter Networks
Big Data Smarter Networks
DataWorks Summit
Webcast: Reduce Costs, Improve Agility with Convergenomics
Webcast: Reduce Costs, Improve Agility with Convergenomics
Emulex Corporation
Programmable Networking is SFW (JavaOne presentation)
Programmable Networking is SFW (JavaOne presentation)
Juniper Networks
JavaOne Keynote: Programmable Networking is SFW
JavaOne Keynote: Programmable Networking is SFW
Juniper Developer Resources Cooney
Healthcare and emc vplex v.4 slideshare
Healthcare and emc vplex v.4 slideshare
charliechocho
Track A-Shmuel Panijel, Windriver
Track A-Shmuel Panijel, Windriver
chiportal
Presentación Data Center Cablevisión Day 2010
Presentación Data Center Cablevisión Day 2010
Logicalis Latam
Emulex OneConnect Universal CNA (Deep Dive)
Emulex OneConnect Universal CNA (Deep Dive)
Emulex Corporation
Ähnlich wie Fabric Arch Compet
(20)
Ceragon Networks: Enabling Mobile Broadband in Asia - Creative Approaches
Ceragon Networks: Enabling Mobile Broadband in Asia - Creative Approaches
OFC/NFOEC: Software Defined Optical Networks
OFC/NFOEC: Software Defined Optical Networks
Qf deck
Qf deck
Intel's Nehalem Microarchitecture by Glenn Hinton
Intel's Nehalem Microarchitecture by Glenn Hinton
Cisco open network environment
Cisco open network environment
Alcatel lucent paolo_volpato_mpls_mw_uppersidex
Alcatel lucent paolo_volpato_mpls_mw_uppersidex
Introducing VNX Series
Introducing VNX Series
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Vnx series-technical-review-110616214632-phpapp02
Hp gavin pratt - open stack networking presentation
Hp gavin pratt - open stack networking presentation
Timing Excellence for Mobile Backhaul Networks at Broadband World Forum
Timing Excellence for Mobile Backhaul Networks at Broadband World Forum
Cots moves to multicore: Wind River
Cots moves to multicore: Wind River
Big Data Smarter Networks
Big Data Smarter Networks
Webcast: Reduce Costs, Improve Agility with Convergenomics
Webcast: Reduce Costs, Improve Agility with Convergenomics
Programmable Networking is SFW (JavaOne presentation)
Programmable Networking is SFW (JavaOne presentation)
JavaOne Keynote: Programmable Networking is SFW
JavaOne Keynote: Programmable Networking is SFW
Healthcare and emc vplex v.4 slideshare
Healthcare and emc vplex v.4 slideshare
Track A-Shmuel Panijel, Windriver
Track A-Shmuel Panijel, Windriver
Presentación Data Center Cablevisión Day 2010
Presentación Data Center Cablevisión Day 2010
Emulex OneConnect Universal CNA (Deep Dive)
Emulex OneConnect Universal CNA (Deep Dive)
Fabric Arch Compet
1.
DATA CENTER FABRIC
ARCHITECTURE COMPETITIVE DIFFERENTIATORS SUTAPA BANSAL Product Marketing Manager, FSG Juniper Confidential
2.
In the struggle
for survival, the fittest win out because they succeed in adapting themselves best to their environment. Charles Darwin INCUMBENT Dunkleosteus Fish Marlin Ruled the World Fast, Agile SLOW, Armored Replaced FISH – Did Not Prehistoric Adapt NEW RULER! NOW EXTINCT! FAST MARLIN 2 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
3.
AGENDA
1 Challenges With Data Centers 2 Juniper’s Fabric Architecture 3 Competitive Cisco Fabric Path Fabric Path Architecture TRILL Protocol 4 Competitive Brocade VCS Architecture 5 Summary 3 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
4.
TRENDS IN THE
DATA CENTER Application Data Center Virtualization Architecture Consolidation Evolution 4 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
5.
CHANGING ROLES OF
THE NETWORK Traditional role – connecting users • North-South traffic Latency Tolerant New role – connecting devices • East-West traffic • Ideally one hop away Latency Sensitive Newest role – foundation of the cloud • Any-to-any connectivity Application running 5 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
6.
CHALLENGES IN DATA
CENTERS 1 Scale to support DC consolidation 2 High Performance Networking 3 Better user experience: Faster NW with low latency / lower oversubscription / large bandwidth 4 Virtualization support 5 High reliability 6 Manage complexity, and reduce cost of networking 6 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
7.
DEFINING THE IDEAL
NETWORK – A FABRIC Flat, any-to-any Single device connectivity N=1 Attributes Network Fabric Data Plane • Low latency and jitter Flat Any-to-any • Lossless • Non L2 and L3 support Control Plane Single device Shared state A Network Fabric has the…. Performance and Simplicity And Scalability and Resiliency of a single switch the of a network 7 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
8.
AGENDA
1 Challenges With Data Centers 2 Juniper’s Fabric Architecture 3 Competitive Cisco Fabric Path Fabric Path Architecture TRILL Protocol 4 Competitive Brocade VCS Architecture 5 Summary 8 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
9.
DATA PLANE IN
A SINGLE SWITCH Data Plane 1. All ports are directly connected to every other port 2. A single “full lookup” processes packets 9 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
10.
CONTROL PLANE IN
A SINGLE SWITCH Control Plane Single consciousness Centralized shared table(s) have information about all ports Management Plane All the ports are managed from a single point 10 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
11.
THE QFABRIC DATA
PLANE Data Plane So, we separate the fabric from the i/o ports And replace the copper traces with fiber links For redundancy add multiple devices 11 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
12.
THE QFABRIC DATA
PLANE Data Plane 1. All ports are directly connected to every other port 2. A single “full lookup” at the ingress edge Interconnect device Edge The distributed data plane is implemented on the interconnect and edge devices 12 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
13.
SCALING THE CONTROL
PLANE Control Plane Director The intelligence and state is federated, distributed across the fabric New Host Address A federated control plane provides both scalability and resiliency 13 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
14.
SCALING THE MANAGEMENT
PLANE Management Plane Director Single point of management Extensive use of automation Managed as a single switch - N=1 14 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
15.
QFABRIC HARDWARE
Interconnect Connects all the edge devices Cannot function as a standalone device Edge node Media independent I/O ToR device. Can be run in independent or fabric mode Director 2 RU high fixed configuration X86 based system architecture 15 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
16.
QFABRIC VALUE PROPOSITION
Low latency High – <1Us in rack Performance – <5Us across fabric – max cable length Flat Fabric Low jitter Large Seamless layer 2 and layer 3 with scale Scale Full Non-blocking and lossless Wirespeed Storage FCoE gateway and transit switch Convergence Green Lower power, HVAC, space Solution 16 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
17.
COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE 1H2011
Timeframe Estimate Cisco (N7K+N5K) Brocade QFabric FabricPath VDX 4 Chassis 24 Chassis 24 Chassis1 Configuration 125 ToRs 171 ToRs 136 ToRs Layer 3 Support Yes No No2 Networking Racks (#) 2 24 24 Power/Port 14W 37W 54W Device to Manage 1 191 160 Latency (Inter-rack) <5u >35u >93u Oversubscription 3:1 3:1 3:1 17 1Needs L3 core to scale for 6K ports Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net 2L3 supported only in spine/core devices Juniper Confidential
18.
AGENDA
1 Challenges With Data Centers 2 Juniper’s Fabric Architecture 3 Competitive Cisco Fabric Path Fabric Path Architecture TRILL Protocol 4 Competitive Brocade VCS Architecture 5 Summary 18 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
19.
JUNIPER QFABRIC VS.
CISCO FABRICPATH 3 COMPETITIVE AREAS Hardware Architecture Protocols Components 19 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
20.
CISCO FABRICPATH ARCHITECTURE
– FUTURE Cisco’s architecture is based on L2MP, Cisco called FabricPath, and the IETF standard is TRILL. Cisco FabricPath works at Layer 2, and need to extend the IS-IS protocol as its control protocol. DC Core Nexus 7000 WAN 10GbE Core IP+MPLS WAN Agg Router FabricPath DC Access Gigabit Ethernet 10 Gigabit Ethernet 10 Gigabit DCE 4Gb Fibre Channel 10 Gigabit FCoE/DCE Nexus 5548 and Nexus 2000 20 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
21.
CISCO FABRICPATH ARCHITECTURE REALITY
FOR 6000 PORT CONFIG FabricPath: 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 12 …. …. …. …. …. 1 19 20 38 39 57 58 76 77 95 96 112 Chassis: 4 vs 20 Access devs: 84 vs 112 Managed Devices: Links: 336 vs 4288 N = 1 vs 132 21 Note: Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net - OS* Over Subscription 3:1 - Ports: 4000 server ports Juniper Confidential
22.
QFABRIC RESILIENCY
CONTROL PLANE ISOLATED FROM DATA PLANE Control Plane Juniper Interconnect Director Redundant out-of-band connections MAC spoofing Unknown traffic X Server QFX 3500 Faster Re-convergence Dedicated control plane Out of band control plane – data plane flooded but control 22 plane is not blocked Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
23.
FABRICPATH CONTROL PLANE
PRONE TO ATTACKS: SHARED WITH DATA PATH Control Plane Same path used to propagate control plane changes as data plane; prone to attacks, less resilient Control Plane Propagation Over Same Data Plane Unknown Destination Traffic Flood X Nexus 5548 Control plane impacted due to data plane flood 23 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
24.
QFABRIC: HIGH PERFORMANCE,
LOW-LATENCY Data Plane <1Us <5Us <5Us Stock <1Us update <5Us 231.1.1.1 Server Storage Storage Back-End Server Server Server Server Application Servers QFABRIC: Predictable, consistent performance; every path < 5Us 24 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
25.
FABRICPATH: INCONSISTENT PERFORMANCE,
HIGH LATENCY Data Plane Different latency depending upon path; latency across Fabric <35Us Nexus 5548 14Us 35Us Stock update Storage Back-End Server Server Back-End 231.1.1.1 Server Application Servers Application Servers FabricPath: Unpredictable, inconsistent performance; QFabric is half the latency of a single Nexus7000 25 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
26.
QFABRIC: SCALED MANAGEMENT
PLANE Management Plane Admin Director Single point of management Extensive use of automation Managed as a single switch – N=1 26 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
27.
FABRICPATH COMPLEX AND
COSTLY MANAGEMENT: 1000 PORT VIEW M M Management Plane Each device managed Admin separately Multiple touch complex management M M M M OPEX: During image upgrade, provisioning, Maintenance 6*10G links M M M M M M M Nexus 5548 Each Device Managed as an Individual Switch 27 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
28.
JUNIPER QFABRIC VS.
CISCO FABRICPATH 3 COMPETITIVE AREAS Hardware Architecture Protocols Components 28 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
29.
FABRICPATH TRILL: A
BRIEF OVERVIEW TRILL is a new IETF protocol to No Multipathing With STP perform Layer2 bridging based on Layer3 IS-IS link state routing technology B1 B3 B2 X Eliminates STP and increase Link B4 Blocked bandwidth utilization (active-N links) and Fabric efficiency by allowing equal bisectional traffic Trill Allows Multipath Minimal configuration burden on user RB1 Layer2 only technology and RB3 RB2 does not address Layer3 RB4 TRILL supposed to help inter- op but questionable 29 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
30.
ARE TRILL IMPLEMENTATIONS
INTER-OPERABLE? Next Hop Destination Address (NHDA) Outer Destination Address (ODA) NHDA NHSA ODA OSA Next Hop Source Address (NHSA) Outer Source Address (OSA) Different frame Ethertype = CTAG Next_Hop.VLAN Ethertype = DTAG FTAG (10b) TTL (6b) formats, = TRILL Ethertype V,R,M,OpL,Hop_Count Inner Destination Address (IDA) proprietary Egress Nickname Ingress Nickname IDA ISA extensions Inner Destination Address (IDA) – No Inner Source Address (ISA) interoperability IDA ISA Inner Source Address (ISA) Rest of Original Frame Rest of Original Frame FCS FCS Fabric Path TRILL TRILL implementation based on FSPF TRILL implementation based on IS-IS 30 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
31.
DATA CENTER DESIGN
L3 OR L2? Address Space Domain Size L3 Fault L3 Hierarchical Containment vs. vs. L2 Flat L2 Flexibility L3 Needed for: Need Both Capacity planning, L3 & L2 traffic engineering, VLANs anywhere Learning Complexity and G/W routing L3 Control Plane vs. L3 Convergence vs. L2 Data Plane L2 Plug and Play TRILL is L2 only Needs external (or internal) router to connect L2 domains 31 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
32.
QFABRIC VS FABRICPATH
QFabric is Layer 2 and Layer 3 1 4 QFabric 1 ... ... ... 84 FabricPath is only Layer 2 FabricPath: 1 2 3 4 5 6 12 1 1 …. 19 20 38 …. 39 …. 57 58 …. 76 77 …. 95 96 112 32 Note: Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net - OS* Over Subscription 3:1 - Ports: 4000 server ports Juniper Confidential
33.
ECONOMICS OF TRILL
BASED DATACENTERS Cisco Strategy Initial Pitch Real Deployment • L2-only Traffic • L3 or Multicast or FCoE or QCN • Position Fcard • Mcard Required • 32x10GE • 8x10GE • $35K ($1K/10GE) • $70K ($9K/10GE) Cost Cost Simple Rich Core Core Up-Sell (FP & L3 Cards) Lock-in Scale Simple Edge Simple Edge Scale 33 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
34.
QFABRIC EFFICIENT MULTI-PATHING BY
LOAD BALANCING Efficient Director Bandwidth utilization with spraying across unequal links 28% 25% 28% 25% 28% 25% 28% 25% 14% X Multi-Pathing Dynamic 34 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
35.
FABRICPATH TRILL: NOT
EFFICIENT LOAD BALANCING FOR MULTI-PATHING In-proffeciant bandwidth utilization NX7K 33%X 0% 25% 25% 33% 25% 25% 33% 33% 4 8 12 16 28 Nexus 5548 FP uses TRILL based on ECMP: Only equal cost paths are chosen 35 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
36.
KEY ISSUES WITH
FABRICPATH IMPLEMENTATION Poor Performance (high latency, high jitter) Complex Network Management Low Reliability and Control over Network Limited or No L3 (Layer 3 as a Service Limits FabricPath Scale Costly Solution) Limited Virtualization Support: Small 16K MAC Table, Small Port Density at Full L2/L3 Low on Uplink Bandwidth: Oversubscription 36 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
37.
JUNIPER QFABRIC VS.
CISCO FABRICPATH 3 COMPETITIVE AREAS Hardware Architecture Protocols Components 37 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
38.
Cisco Nexus Fabric
building blocks.. F: L2, FSS M: L3, no FSS Nexus 5548 at Access (ToR) Nexus 7K in Core Line cards in this architecture are either capable of L2 (with FSS) or L3 (without FSS) processing + Eliminates STP, allows multi-pathing + Scales to many core chassis at L2 - No layer 3 : Does matter whether traffic is within or across VLANs 38 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
39.
Closer look at
Nexus7k with F & M cards For Parity: Lossless, 3:1, Oversubscription and Line-rate L3 From N5k • Backplane bandwidth of F (230GE) F card is 230G – Only 23*10 GE ports are line rate per F card • L3 traffic needs to go via M card which is limited to 80Gbps per card M (80GE) Every F Card will need 3xMcards to support line rate L3 traffic F(230G) So, a N7K 16 slot chassis will have: To N5k • 4 * F cards • 12 * M cards • i.e., 23 * 4 = 92 line-rate ToR facing ports 39 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
40.
QFABRIC VS. FABRICPATH
– 6000 PORTS QFabric QFabric 1/3 fewer Non-Blocking 1 4 devices L2 & L3 2/3 less power 1 125 $300k/year TRILL like - “Big Pile” Architecture 90% less floor space L3 7-10x faster 90% fewer links L2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Mgd. Devices 1 16 1 vs 193 1 vs 25 admins 1 21 .. .. 42 .. 63 84 .. .. 105 .. 126 .. 147 167 40 Note: Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net • OS* Over Subscription 3:1 • Ports: 6000 server ports Juniper Confidential
41.
QFABRIC VS. FABRICPATH
NUM DEVICES REQUIRED: CAPEX AND COMPLEXITY 250 Juniper QFabric $$ 200 150 100 Servers 50 Cisco FabricPath $$ 0 500p 1000p 3000p 6000p # of Devices JNPR # of Devices CSCO Servers 41 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
42.
QFABRIC VS. CISCO
NEXUS ENVIRONMENTAL FRIENDLINESS QFabric Environmental Labels Cisco Nexus Environmental Labels 5/6 China RoHS SR-3580 NEBS Level 3 6/6 • Verizon NEBS compliance Recycled Material 42 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
43.
QFABRIC VS. CISCO
NEXUS, ENERGY UTILIZATION 800000 700000 600000 500000 400000 300000 200000 100000 0 Max Power Nominal Power Qfabric Cisco 5548, NX7018 L2 Cisco 5548, NX7018 L3 Source for Cisco Power comparison http://www.cisco.com/en/US/prod/collateral/switches/ps9441/ps9670/data_sheet_c78-618603.html http://www.cisco.com/en/US/docs/switches/datacenter/hw/nexus7000/installation/guide/n7k_sys_specs.html 43 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
44.
QFABRIC VS CISCO
NEXUS TAKE AWAYS Performance 7x lower Latency (Juniper Qfabric <5Us vs. Nexus 35Usec ) Highest scale (6000 ports )with complete Layer 2 and layer 3 Invisible IT Management Complexity: Minimal. QFabric has operational simplicity of single switch High resiliency: no single point of failure Operational savings : 1/20th operators/administrators vs Fabricpath Most eco-friendly fabric 1/3 power/port at 1/10 footprint of FabricPath 44 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
45.
AGENDA
1 Challenges With Data Centers 2 Juniper’s Fabric Architecture 3 Competitive Cisco Fabric Path Fabric Path Architecture TRILL Protocol 4 Competitive Brocade VCS Architecture 5 Summary 45 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
46.
BROCADE VIRTUAL CLUSTER
SWITCH SOLUTION VDX 6720-24 VDX 6720 -60 No Scale : VCS fabric has only upto 10 switches Low port utilization: VDX 6720-60 has 60 ports but Ethernet Fabric connections take 12 ports (out of 50) on each switch. Minimal Virtualization support : 32k total MAC table insufficient for large scale Data center solution. Lack of basic layer3,QOS features Multicast group supporting is very limited, only 256. Manageability complexity VCS solution relies on each individual switches managed independently 46 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
47.
BROCADE VCS SOLUTION
: BRCD REFERENCE ARCHITECTURE Core layer: MLX with MCT BROCADE CLAIM: 6 links per trunk (24 total) VCS fabric has up 6:1 subscription 10-switch VCS fabric; to 10 switches ratio in VCS fabric 312 usable ports Scale: 600 ports vLAG Latency: 600ns * Up to 36 servers per rack 4 racks per VCS Servers With 1/10G and 10G DCB FCoE/iSCSI DCB Connectivity Storage 47 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
48.
QFABRIC VS. BROCADE
VDX VCS SCALE BASED ON: BROCADE VDX IN ACCESS, AGGREATION (VCS ) WITH 450 PORTS BROCADE REALITY: BigIron BigIron 1. Max 450 ports or only Rx-16 Rx-16 315 ports server ports 2. Latency >1200ns within switch Based on: Max # TOR: 7, Aggregation devices: 3, Max MCT MLX: 2 VDX 6720-60 VDX 6720-60 7 MAX VCS SCALE: 450 Server Ports Only` 48 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
49.
QFABRIC VS BROCADE
VCS SCALE, SIMPLICITY AND MANAGEABILITY Max scale 350 7000 Manageabilty at 450 ports 300 290 6000 250 5000 200 4000 150 3000 100 2000 50 40 1000 2 1 - 0 # of Admins # of JNPR BRCD Links,Interactions BRCD JNPR 49 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
50.
QFABRIC VS BROCADE
VCS PERFORAMNCE 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 - Latency (usec) BRCD JNPR Based 50 on : BROCADE vdx IN ACCESS,AGGGREATION( vcs ) WITH 450 PORTS Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
51.
Brocade VCS implementation
KNOCKOFSS 1 Brocade solution does not scale – limited to 600 ports 2 No Storage Convergence : No FCoE-FC Gateway No Layer 3 – VCS does not achieve a single-layer DC 3 POOR PERFORMANCE: HIGH LATENCY ACROSS FABRIC 15Us* 4 Brocade implementation is based on FSPF:non-standard TRILL; it cannot interoperate with other vendors TRILL- 5 based implementation Brocade VCS is a NOT a single flat “Fabric” technology; similar to Juniper’s Virtual Chassis technology, only 3 6 years later *Assuming BigIron as Core switch because of lack of VCS core switch 51 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
52.
QFABRIC VS BROCADE
VCS TAKE AWAYS Performance Highest scale (6000 ports vs 450 ports )with complete Layer 2 and layer 3 3x lower Latency (Juniper Qfabric <5Us vs. BROCADE VCS ) Invisible IT Management Complexity: Minimal. QFabric has operational simplicity of single switch resiliency: no single point of failure Operational savings vs Brocade: ½ administrators ,1/7th cables neede using QFabric vs VCS 52 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
53.
AGENDA
1 Challenges With Data Centers 2 Juniper’s Fabric Architecture 3 Competitive Cisco Fabric Path Fabric Path Architecture TRILL Protocol 4 Competitive Brocade VCS Architecture 5 Summary 53 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net Juniper Confidential
54.
55.
JNPR VS CSCO
DETAIL COMPARISON …FOR MULTIPLE PORT COUNTS Category #Ports >> 500p 1000p 3000p 6000p Performance Latency (usec) CSCO 34 34 34 34 JNPR 5 5 5 5 Simplicity # of Devices CSCO 18 32 98 195 JNPR 15 25 67 129 # of Admins CSCO 2 2 5 9 JNPR 1 1 1 1 # of Cables CSCO 240 482 1,812 3,612 JNPR 44 84 252 500 Operational Expenses Power & Cooling Cost ($/yr) CSCO $ 61,834 $ 73,409 $ 245,355 $ 489,884 JNPR $ 33,717 $ 39,971 $ 66,237 $ 105,010 Adminstrative Costs ($/yr) CSCO $ 340,000 $ 460,000 $ 1,000,000 $ 1,800,000 JNPR $ 200,000 $ 200,000 $ 200,000 $ 200,000 Maintenance Cost ($/yr) CSCO $ 41,798 $ 73,396 $ 225,288 $ 448,319 JNPR Need PLM Input Capital Expenditure Equipment Costs CSCO $ 2,888,792 $ 3,953,584 $ 12,992,752 $ 25,950,876 JNPR Need PLM Input Green CO2 Emissions (lbs) CSCO 359,760 427,105 1,427,522 2,850,233 JNPR 196,174 232,559 385,378 610,969 55 Copyright © 2011 Juniper Networks, Inc. www.juniper.net
Jetzt herunterladen