SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 73
Research Trends and
Regulation in Haematopetic
 Stem Cell Transplantation

    Jeremy Chapman
Clinical Problem:
Allogeneic Graft Availability
   Leukemia Patients Needing BMT


          8/10                   2/10
       No Compatible        Compatible Sibling
       Family Donor             Donor



  Only 15-20% minority
 patients receive BMT via
       adult registry
Impact of Disease Stage and HLA
  Matching on Unrelated HCT
           Outcomes
        Low Risk
       Intermediate Risk
       High Risk
Impact of Single HLA Mismatch
 in Unrelated HCT for Low-risk
             Disease
LFS after Cord Blood or Bone Marrow
Transplant from Unrelated Donors in
      Adult Leukemia Patients




              Rocha et al, N Engl J Med 2004;351:2276-85.
Unrelated
Haematpoetic Stem
  cell donations:

  Bone Marrow
      PBSC
   Cord Blood
Bone Marrow or Peripheral Blood Stem Cells?




                 Stem Cell Trialists' Collaborative Group, JCO 2005
Pioneers in Cord Blood Transplantation




Eliane Gluckman
      Paris




                  Pablo Rubenstein
                     New York        John Wagner
                                     Minneapolis
Survival after 0-3 Mismatched Unrelated UCB &
              6/6 HLA-matched BMT in children

     1.0                                                              1.0




                                               Proportion Surviving
     0.8                                                              0.8

                                                                      0.6
                                                                                         BMT-TCD
     0.6                      UCBT                                                              56%
Proportion




                                      53%
Surviving




     0.4                              41%                             0.4                  UCBT 52%
                        BMT-MTX
     0.2                                                              0.2
                                p = .40                                                      p > .80
     0.0                                                              0.0
        0        6       12      18       24                                0   6     12     18        24
                     Months                                                         Months

             Patient analyses with match for age, diagnosis, and disease stage.



                                 Barker et al, Blood. 2001 May 15;97(10):2957-61.
Probability of Neutrophil Recovery by UCB Graft Cell Dose

                                           1.0
                                                            cell dose < 1.87*107/kg (n=23)

                                                           cell dose (1.87, 2.41) (n=21)
      Probability of neutrophil recovery

                                           0.8


                                                           cell dose > 2.41*107/kg (n=24)
                                           0.6




                                                     p-value = 0.003
                                           0.4
                                           0.2
                                           0.0




                                                 0          10              20                 30             40   50          60

                                                                                 days after transplantation

 No. at Risk: 68                                            66              53                 26             6     1


                                                                                   Laughlin, MJ., et al., N Engl J Med 2001;344:1815-22
DFS for Acute Leukemia in CR
                                    Single vs. Double UCBT
                                          CY60/TBI1320

                        1.0
                                         I   I   I I
Cumulative Proportion




                        0.8                                                          double
                                                                                I              I
                                                               I
                        0.6                                         I   I   I
                                                                                               I
                                                                                      single
                        0.4
                                         Double: Adults +
                        0.2              Adolescents
                                         Single: Children
                        0.0
                              0      2                 4        6       8       10         12
                                                           Months
PROBABILITY OF SURVIVAL
              Impact of Cell dose and HLA mismatch

              1.0


              0.8
                                           CB matched
PROBABILITY




              0.6
                                           CB 1 agmm (>2.5)

              0.4                          CB 2 agmm (>2.5)



              0.2                          CB 1 agmm (<2.5)

                                           CB 2 agmm (<2.5)

              0.0
                    0    1         2             3
                               YEARS
Mary Horowitz
  CIBMTR                                                 University of Wisconsin




               ... ..
      ............... .
               ..
                                                           . .... .......... .
     .......... . . .
           . ..
                  . .... ..           . . ..                    . .........
                                                           ... ..........
                        . ..           . ..          .
                                                               . .
                                                                  .. .. .
                             .          .
                                 ..                                   ... ..
                                                                         .           ..
            .
              .
                                      .      ..
                                          .... .                           . .... ...
                                            .
                                                ..
135 staff including, 6 PhD statisticians, 14 MS statisticians, 11 MD-MS faculty;
Active program of statistical methodology research specifically focused on
transplant outcomes in addition to supporting clinical studies
Overall Survival
                                    Pediatric Study

                          100

                                               CB matched (n=36) 62%
Adjusted Probability, %




                                             BM matched (n=116) 45%
                           80            CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157) 45%



                           60


                           40


                           20             CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44) 36%
                                            CB 2-Ag MM (n=267) 33%


                           0
                                0   12      24            36           48   60

                                                 Months
                                                                             Mjz06_13.ppt
Neutrophil Recovery
                                    Pediatric Study

                 100
                           BM (n=492), 97%
                                                         CB matched (n=35), 86%


                  80                                     CB MM high dose (n=362), 79%
Probability, %




                                                          CB MM low dose (n=97), 64%
                  60


                  40


                  20


                  0
                       0            20       40           60           80           100

                                                  Days
                                                                                        CAL05_13.ppt
Acute Grade 2-4 GVHD
                              Pediatric Study

                 100


                  80
                                                        BM MM (n=123), 70%
Probability, %




                  60
                                                    BM matched (n=368), 50%


                  40
                                                        CB MM (n=454), 40%


                  20
                                                     CB matched (n=35), 20%


                  0
                       0     20    40          60            80           100

                                        Days
                                                                              CAL05_15.ppt
Chronic GVHD
                               Pediatric Study

                 100


                  80
Probability, %




                  60


                                                         BM MM (n=123), 35%
                  40

                                                   BM matched (n=369), 33%

                  20
                                                CB matched/MM (n=466), 17%

                  0
                       0   6      12     18         24         30         36

                                       Months
                                                                               CAL05_16.ppt
Treatment-related Mortality
                                 Pediatric Study

                 100


                  80
Probability, %




                                           CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44), 43%
                                                 BM MM (n=123), 40%
                  60
                                             CB 2-Ag MM (n=267), 47%


                  40
                                             CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157),
                                                                29%

                  20                         BM matched (n=369), 26%

                                               CB matched (n=35), 6%

                  0
                       0        12    24            36          48      60

                                           Months
                                                                             CAL05_27.ppt
Leukemia-free survival
                                Pediatric study

                 100


                  80
Probability, %




                                                                  CB matched (n=35), 60%
                  60

                                                         CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157), 41%
                  40


                         BM matched (n=369), 40%
                  20   CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44), 36%
                         CB 2-Ag MM (n=267), 33%
                              BM MM (n=123), 30%
                  0
                       0          12           24            36           48           60

                                                    Months
                                                                                            CAL05_17.ppt
Overall Survival
                            Pediatric Study

                 100


                  80
Probability, %




                                                           CB matched (n=36), 62%
                  60
                                                    CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157), 45%


                  40

                                  BM matched (n=369),    44%
                  20                    BM MM (n=123),   40%
                                CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44),   35%
                                   CB 2-Ag MM (n=267),   35%

                  0
                       0   12           24            36           48              60

                                             Months
                                                                                        CAL05_20.ppt
The IPA/NIMA effect - Jon Van Rood

  Mother         Father   NIMA = non inherited maternal antigens
IMA/NIMA       IPA/NIPA
                          NIPA = non inherited paternal antigens
                          IMA     = inherited maternal antigens
                          IPA     = inherited paternal antigens

                            The mother develops B and T cell
                            immunity against the IPA of the
                            fetus, which is controlled by T reg.
                            Likewise, the fetus develop immunity
                            and T reg against the NIMA.
                            Immunity can be lifelong in both mother
                            and child.
    Patient IMA/IPA
HSCT with a parental donor shows a differential effect of maternal
               versus paternal donors on survival.




                    1.0
                    0.8
                    0.6
                                          Mother donor N=47

     Event
                    0.4




      Free
    Survival
                    0.2




                                          Father donor N=71
                    0.0




                                              p<0.0001

    Years Follow-Up 0      1    2    3        4            5
       # at risk:    118   38   29   28      28            28
                                            M. Stern et al. Blood 2008
Identification of an acceptable mismatch
                    with the help of NIMA
                      van Rood et al. Pnas: 2009, 106, pp 19952




Patient              A1, A2 - B7, B44
cord blood           A1, A3 - B7, B44
mother of CB         A1, A2 - B7, B8                 NIMA=A2 and B8
    Combining the NIMA A2 and B8 with the CB phenotype can
      create for example the following Virtual CB phenotype:
                  A1, A2 / B7, B44
and 5 other Virtual Phenotypes (VP) if there is one substitution and
12 when there are two.
HLA typing of the mother created 16 different VPs!!
Transplant-Related Mortality
                                            (Patients ≥ 10 Years Old)



                           80
% with TRM (Cum. Incid.)




                                                 2 MM, No NIMA Match Reference 290/488
                           60                                              2 MM, 1NIMA Match
                                                        1 MM, No NIMA Match Reference

                           40                1 MM, 1NIMA Match 20/41 RR=0.6, P= 0.012



                           20
                                                       0 Mismatch 4/22 RR=0.3 P = 0.011

                            0

                                0       1                    2                     3
                                    Years Post-Transplant        PNAS 2009 106 (47) p10952
Time to Absolute Neutrophil Count ≥ 500
                 100

  (Cum. Incid)
                                                    0 Mismatch
                  80
                                               1-2 MM, 1 NIMA Match
                  60
% with ANC 500


                                              1-2 MM, No NIMA Match
                  40


                  20


                   0
                       0   7 14 21 28 35 42       56       70
                                days after transplant

        Patients                               N        RR    p value
        0 MM                                   15       3.8   <0.001
        1-2 MM,1 NIMA Match                    18       1.9    0.031
        1-2 MM, No NIMA Match                 219        reference
Relapse
                                                       (Patients with Myeloid Diseases)
                                    HLA MM/ NIMA                RR    P
                                    2 MM/No NIMA (n = 343)       0.7 0.075
                                    1 MN/No NIMA (n =193)        Reference
                               40
% with Relapse (Cum. Incid.)



                                    2 MM/NIMA Match (n = 31)      0.7 0.448
                                    1 MM/NIMA Match (n = 13)     0.2 0.074
                                    0 MM (n = 33)              0.7 0.306
                                                                                          1 MM, No NIMA Match
                               30                                                            0 Mismatch

                                                                                            2 MM, NIMA Match
                               20
                                                                                          2 MM, No NIMA Match


                               10                                                          1 MM, NIMA Match



                                0

                                      0                          1                    2                         3
                                                Years Post-Transplant              PNAS 2009, 106, pp 19952
Acknowledgements
         NYBC - NCBP              Europdonor Foundation
• Andromachi Scaradavou       • Henk van der Zanden
• Pablo Rubinstein            • Machteld Oudshoorn
• C. Carrier, C. Carpenter    • Jack Bakker,Angelo Melis
• NCBP Program Staff
                              • Frans Claas
• Transplant centers/
  physicians/data managers/
  patients

• Donating Mothers            • Eurotransplant Foundation
                              • Jacqueline Smits
• Cladd Stevens
Current Status

                                  Stem Cell Products provided for unrelated transplantation
                      18,000

                      16,000
                                                                          2008                       2009
Number of donations




                      14,000
                               Bone Marrow                                3,221                      3,445
                      12,000

                      10,000   PBSC                                      7,260                       8,162
                       8,000
                               Cord Blood Units 3,522                                                3,749
                       6,000

                       4,000

                       2,000

                          0
                               1988

                                      1989

                                             1990

                                                    1991

                                                           1992

                                                                  1993

                                                                         1994

                                                                                1995

                                                                                       1996

                                                                                              1997

                                                                                                     1998

                                                                                                            1999

                                                                                                                   2000

                                                                                                                           2001

                                                                                                                                  2002

                                                                                                                                         2003

                                                                                                                                                2004

                                                                                                                                                       2005

                                                                                                                                                              2006

                                                                                                                                                                     2007

                                                                                                                                                                            2008

                                                                                                                                                                                   2009
                                                                                                     Year
                                      BM donations                          PBSC donations                                Cord Blood Units Provided
% Patients Transplanted in Relation
                       to Searches Requested




Red: 0-10%
Yellow: 10-30%
Orange: 30-50%
Green: > 50%                     Analyzed from WMDA Annual Report 2009
The ABMDR is the best place to search for Australian Patients

                               These are the best registries to
                               search for Australian patients




      Chance of finding a donor for an AUSTRALIAN patient
Singapore Chinese Patients
In 2009
                                                                                        18 Products a Day
                                                                                         6,461 Products
                                                                                        crossed a Border

                                    Percentage of bone marrow/PBSC donations provided for
                                    national and international patients
                 75



                 65   69.7   69.4    69.1
                                             67.1   66.3    67.5
                                                                     65.6    64.7
                                                                                     61.1   61.2
Percentage (%)




                 55
                                                                                                    58.0
                                                                                                           56.2       55.1
                 45

                                                                                                           43.8       44.9
                 35
                                                                                             38.8 42.0
                                                                                     38.9
                                                                     34.4    35.3
                                             32.9   33.7   32.5
                      30.3   30.6    30.9
                 25
                      1997   1998     1999   2000   2001    2002     2003     2004   2005    2006   2007       2008   2009
                                                                     Year
                             Donations to international recipients          Donations to national recipients
In 2010, 149 cord blood banks
                                                                 participated worldwide


                                                    Number of CBUs provided for unrelated transplantation
                             4,500
                                                                           2010    2009
                             4,000
Number of cord blood units




                                     CBUs provided                         4,054 3,792
                             3,500

                             3,000

                             2,500

                             2,000

                             1,500

                             1,000

                              500

                                0
                                     1993

                                            1994

                                                      1995

                                                             1996

                                                                    1997

                                                                            1998

                                                                                   1999

                                                                                          2000

                                                                                                 2001

                                                                                                        2002

                                                                                                               2003

                                                                                                                      2004

                                                                                                                             2005

                                                                                                                                    2006

                                                                                                                                           2007

                                                                                                                                                  2008

                                                                                                                                                         2009

                                                                                                                                                                2010
                                                                                          Year
                                                   No information provided          Units provided for adults         Units provided for children
Degree of matching of the cord blood units provided for
                                     children (N=1,286 units)

                                                                                      0 mismatched
                                                       664
                                                                                      1 mismatched
                              600                                                     2 mismatched




Number of cord blood units
                                                                                      3 or more
                              500
                                                                                      not specified
                              400                              299
                                              245
                              300
                                                                                204
                              200

                              100                                       6

                                0




                                     Degree of matching of the cord blood units provided for
                                     adults (N=2,768 units)
                                                                                      0 mismatched
                                                               1,213                  1 mismatched
                             1,200                                                    2 mismatched
Number of cord blood units




                                                                                      3 or more
                             1,000                     830                            not specified
                                                                                771
                              800

                              600

                              400
                                              245
                              200                                       20

                                0
International exchange of cord
                                              blood products is increasing
                                       Number of cord blood units provided for national and international
                                       patients
                             3,000
                                                                                                                                2,726
                                                                                                                        2,537
                                                                                                               2,321
                             2,500
Number of Cord Blood Units




                                                                                                       2,207

                             2,000                                                             1,862
                                                                                      1,710

                                                                             1,368                                     1,255    1,328
                             1,500                                                                             1,235
                                                                   1,213
                                                                                                       1,098
                             1,000                                                             829
                                                             625                         652
                                                   510
                              500    346    372                               387
                                                                    284
                                            146    192       175
                                     129
                                0
                                     1999   2000   2001     2002     2003     2004      2005   2006    2007     2008     2009    2010
                                                                                     Year
                                                          Provided Internationally              Provided Nationally



In 2010: 3.63 cord blood products passing an international border a day
NATIONAL MARROW DONOR PROGRAM®                                                                                36
Entrusted to operate the C.W. Bill Young Cell Transplantation Program, including the Be The Match Registry®
AUSCORD


          29% OF RELEASES FROM
          3% OF INVENTORY
Over 70% of the CBUs shipped for
               adult patients have a TNC >150

        Cord blood shipments by TNC for adult patients
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
 0%
       2004      2005      2006     2007      2008      2009      2010

         <90    90-119   120-149   150-199   200-249   250-300   >300
2010 Inventory and shipments
     TNC of BMDW inventory as of January 1,
                    2011
                           1%
                     2%         0.002%

                            6%
                     10%

               12%
                                    36%


                 33%                                TNC of the CBU products shipped in 2010
                                                                                          2%
                                                                               0.003

                                                                          6%
         <50     50-89          90-124    125-149                    8%           14%
         150-199 200-249 250-300 >300
                                                               20%
                                                                                        18%

76% of the shipments came
from 25% of the available                                                 32%

inventory
                                                         <50         50-89       90-124    125-149
                                                         150-199     200-249     250-300   >300
Shipping rate of the units listed
          in BMDW based on TNC
       (units shipped/units available)
TNC               Percentage(%)

< 50              0.03
50-89             0.09
90-124            0.3
125-149           1.0
150-199           2.3
200-249           6.3
250-300           10.5
>300              17.0
NATIONAL MARROW DONOR PROGRAM®                                                                                41
Entrusted to operate the C.W. Bill Young Cell Transplantation Program, including the Be The Match Registry®
2010
                               WHO Guiding Principles on
                     Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation
                            World Health Assembly - 22 May 2010

       1.
        1.   Consentfor deceased donor's donation
             Consent for deceased donor's donation
       2.
        2.   No conflictfor death determination
             No conflict for death determination
       3.
        3.   Deceasedbut also consenting live donors
             Deceased but also consenting live donors
       4.
        4.   Protectionof minors and incompetent persons
             Protection of minors and incompetent persons
       5.
        5.   No sale or purchase
              No sale or purchase
       6.
        6.   Promotionof donation nono advertisingbrokering
              Promotion of donation advertising nor nor brokering
       7.
        7.   Responsibility on origintransplant
              Responsibility on origin of of transplant
       8.
        8.   Justifiable professional fees
              Justifiable professional fees
       9. Allocationrules
        9. Allocation rules
       10. Quality safety efficacy of procedures and transplants
        10. Quality safety efficacy of procedures and transplants
       11. Transparency and confidentiality
        11. Transparency and confidentiality
2010                    WHO Guiding Principles on
                 Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation
             GP 5 Free donation and no purchase of human transplant as such,
                       but cost & expenditures recovery

                               GP 6                  GP 7                    GP 8
             GP 3           Promoting           Responsibility         Justifiable fees
         Maximizing DD     No advertising    for transplant origin
         Protecting LD

     GP 2             GP 4                                    GP 9
   Death Δγ      Protecting the                        Equitable allocation
   No conflict    incompetent
   GP 1
Consent DD


  Donor                                     Process                                  Recipient

     GP 10 Monitoring long term outcomes. Quality & safety of procedures & products

                 GP 11 Transparency, openness to scrutiny, anonymity
WHO Guiding Principles on
2010           Human Cell, Tissue Long term
                  Short and and Organ Transplantation
                  Donor Outcomes 2010
                  World Health Assembly - 22 May

                Recipient Outcomes
Guiding Principle 10




                    Quality systems
                      Traceability
                       Vigilance
                 Adverse event reporting
WHO Guiding Principles on
2010   Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation
             World Health Assembly - 22 May 2010




           Transparency
         Open to Scrutiny
       Maintaining privacy of
       Donors and Recipients
Clinical JASN 2011 on line
The blood safety paradigm doesn’t translate to Organs & Cells.
                    What is the problem?



Volume of activity                                  Scarcity of Donors
Blood donations are in the                          Blood donors can be
millions in many countries                          replaced

Organ donations are in the                          Organ donors are very
thousands in only a very                            scarce
few countries
                                                    Hemopoetic stem cell
Hemopoetic stem cell                                donors are usually unique
donations are even fewer                            for each recipient


          Mortality rates on organ transplant waiting lists are substantial
        Unavoidable mortality rates from transplantation are substantial
  Risks from transmission of disease are very small under standard procedures

        Regulation risk: causing more deaths than saved
The effect of putting the Barriers
               up
                        +++
                  500
                  400
In Country




                  300         National
                              Import
                  200
                              Export
                  100
                    0
Out of Country




                 -100
                 -200
                 -300
                 -400
                 -500   +
The effect of putting the Barriers
               up
                        +++
                  500
                  400
In Country




                  300         Import
                              National
                  200
                              Export
                  100
                    0
Out of Country




                 -100
                 -200
                 -300
                 -400
                 -500   +
Collateral
 damage by
 regulators


     IS


Unacceptable
What happened?
Analyze: where are CBUs
                                         used for transplantation?
                                    Number of Cord Blood Units shipped to each continent over time
                          1,600
Number of CBUs provided




                          1,400

                          1,200

                          1,000

                           800

                           600

                           400

                           200

                             0
                                  1999   2000   2001    2002   2003   2004      2005   2006    2007    2008   2009   2010
                                                                         Year
                                  Asia      Australia     Europe       North America          South America     Africa



                              35% of the CBUs shipped are shipped to North America
                              33% of the CBUs shipped are shipped to Asia
Guidance for Industry
        Minimally Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic
 Placental/Umbilical Cord Blood Intended for Hematopoietic
           Reconstitution for Specified Indications

             U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
                     Food and Drug Administration
             Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research
                             October 2009

  1 This guidance applies to HPC-Cs manufactured by U.S. cord blood establishments and non-
  U.S. cord blood establishments that distribute cord blood in the U.S. However, some non-U.S.
  cord blood establishments that participate in international registries may not apply for licensure
Importation and use of unlicensed placental/umbilical cord
  of their products. Importation and use of unlicensed placental/umbilical cord stem/progenitor
  cell products from non-U.S. cord blood establishments would be acceptable under an
stem/progenitor cell products from non-U.S. cord bloodan affiliated
  Investigational New Drug (IND) application held by the non-U.S. establishment,
establishments the U.S. transplant center, or a registry. Also, certain HPC-Cs
  U.S. establishment, would be acceptable under an Investigational New
  manufactured in the U.S. may not be licensed but could be listed in registries and made
Drug (IND) applicationan IND. Additional non-U.S. establishment, anof
  available for clinical use under held by the recommendations regarding submission
affiliated U.S. establishment, provided in the companion draft guidanceor a
  INDs for certain unlicensed HPC-Cs are the U.S. transplant center, entitled
  “Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff: Investigational New Drug Applications (INDs) for
registry. Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic Placental/Umbilical Cord Blood Intended for
  Minimally
  Hematopoietic Reconstitution for Specified Indications).”
Europe
 Reliant upon each national competent
 authority.....
EUROPEAN DIRECTIVE 2004/23/EC; article 9
Import/export of human tissues and cells
Member States and tissue establishments that receive such
imports from third countries shall ensure that they meet
standards of quality and safety.
Legislation to enact European Directive on HSC
                  August 2011

Not standardised
Legislated
Not Legislated
Global Quality
  Standards
Quality, efficacy and
           safety
     International Standards
     Accreditation and Audit
   Data collection and analysis
       Donor safety - SEAR
     Product safety - SPEAR
   Recipient safety – Outcome
            databases

This will not be enough – but it will
2009 – 9 events reported to the WMDA (to date)                     • 2009 – 7 events reported to the WMDA (to date). All except 1 prior to
 – 8 incidents from donations before 2009, 1 in 2009                 2009 (4 - 2008, 1 - 2006, 1 - 1996):
      (3 - 2008, 3 - 2006, 1 - 2003, 1-1997):                         – Donor blood group incorrect on label (all other identifiers
         • 5 cancers                                                       correct)
                 – Breast/ brain (benign)/NHL post BM                 – Incorrect product collected by courier (2 harvested on same day).
                 – Lung/ hepatoma post PBSC (hepatoma had 3 doses of       Identified and rectified before courier left airport
                      GCSF - not collected due to patient factors)    – Cord unit arrived partially thawed. 28% viability in segment. Not
         • 1 cauda equina syndrome post BM                                 infused
         • 1 severe groin bruising post groin line for DLI            – Clots in apheresis bag - engrafted
         • 1 faint following tubing rupture during PBSC (target dose  – Rupture of tubing on cell separator. Collection abandoned. Target
             collected on second day)                                      achieved on day 2
         • 1 fat embolism post GA and BM harvest - full recovery      – 2 donor derived malignancies
                                                                               • Patient with MDS (Tx 04/06) diagnosed with CML in 11/08.
                                                                                  Donor diagnosed with CML 05/08
                                                                               • Patient with CML (Tx 06/96) diagnosed with mantle cell
                                                                                  lymphoma in 05/08. Donor diagnosed with MCL 098/08
Clinical Working Group
     (S(P)EAR committee)




Chair: Bronwen Shaw
Vice-chair: Jeff Szer
S(P)EAR committee




• 175 S(P)EAR reported in 2011 thus far (26
  october)

  – 44 SPEAR (product related)

  – 131 SEAR (donor related)
SPEAR
• 10 BM
  – 4 bacterial contamination of product
  – 3 Quality
     • Clot/haemolysed/incorrect recipient name on product
  – 2 transfer of donor disease
     • Hepatitis B (possible)
     • B-CLL (definite)
  – 1 hypertension post infusion. PRES (probably not)
SPEAR
• 11 PBSC
   – 2 ‘suboptimal product’
      • 2 failed mobilisation – 1 patient received BM
   – 3 cryopreserved – poor viability on thaw (2 engrafted/1
     PGF – probable)
   – 1 transport delay/low viability – PGF (possible)
   – 1 different cell counts and volume at HC and TC
   – 2 TRALI (both possible)
   – 1 Donor XXY on chimerism
   – 1 fever post infusion (bacillus in patient, not in product)
• 1 DLI – unable to collect (whole blood collected)
SPEAR
• 22 CBU
   – 17 Quality
       • 6 Damage
       • 4 Thawed
       • 4 Other transport (e.g. Xrayed/temperature loggers/bacterial
         contamination)
       • 2 Data incorrect
       • 1 poor cell recovery (engrafted)
   – 2 Non-engraftment
       • 1 Low viability (probable)
       • 1 positive bacterial culture (possible)
   – 1 Donor derived MDS in engrafting cord (probable)
   – 1 ‘shocked heart’ (possible)
   – 1 infusion/washing issue – ARF (probable)
SEAR
• 22 BM
   – 6 malignancies (1 haem: CLL)
   – 2 osteomyelitis
   – 1 laryngospasm required retubing (definite)
   – 1 low sats in recovery – observation only (possible)
   – 2 thrombophlebitis (cannulae) (definite)
   – 1 sacral haematoma (surgery) (definite)
   – 3 prolonged back pain (definite)
   – 2 tendon/nerve injury (1 definite/1 probable)
   – 1 allogeneic blood for symptomatic anaemia
   – 1 cardiac arrythmia 6/52 post (possible)
   – 1 prolonged orthostatic dysregulation (definite)
   – 1 donor collapse 10 hours post harvest. Successful CPR. 2 allo units
      (definite)
• 2 DLI – anaphylaxis to apheresis set (definite)
   – Trigeminal neuralgia 21 days post (possible)
SEAR
• 107 PBSC
   – 1 donor death – CVC related (Definite)

    Mobilisation
    – 1 microscopic haematuria (probable)
    – 1 pain (hospitalised) (definite)
    – 1 severe headache-admission and CT (normal) (possible)
    – 1 intractable vomiting (hospitalised) (definite)
    – 1 elevated LFT (probable)
    – 1 erythema of legs D3 (hospitalised - steroids) (probable)
    – 1 collapse after 1st dose (went ahead) (probable)
    – 1 dysphagia ? Stress (probable)
    – 1 acute gout ankle on D3 – no pmh (definite)
    – 1 epidydimitis/urethritis needing antibiotics (probably not)
    – 1 severe breathlessness (?stress) G stopped. No collection (probable)
SEAR

• 107 PBSC

   Collection
   – 2 failed collections (citrate toxicity, BM instead; no peripheral access,
     donor refused CVC)
   – 1 limited collection (access problems – false aneurysm after femoral
     CVC, arterial puncture, 43% collected)
   – 1 chest tightness
   – 1 tetany
   – 1 abdo pain, normal ultrasound, admitted later ?cholecystitis
   – 1 allergic urticaria and hives, continued for 6 months requiring steroids
     (definite)
   – 1 herpes zoster (second apheresis)
SEAR
• 107 PBSC                             Within 1 month
   –   3 thrombophlebitis
   –   1 nerve damage to hand (definite)
   –   1 abnormal LFT ? Cause (probably not)
   –   1 MI (several risk factors) (probably not)
   –   1 anterior uveitis (3/7 post) (possible)
   –   1 intracranial haematoma 10/7 post, hospitalised, no intervention (possible)
   –   1 convulsions/palsy 1 mo post – brain bx, unknown cause (possible)
   –   1 hypertension and tiredness (possible)
   –   1 otitis media, pneumonia and renal insufficiency 2 /7(inpatient 16/7) (possible)
   –   1 pyogenic necrotising/haemorrhagic enteritis requiring surgery 3/7 (possible)
   –   1 atopic dermatitis of both hands 20/7 (possible)
   –   1 fever, abdo pain 2/7 post, 7/7 inpatient (possible)
   –   1 near syncope at home (probable)
   –   1 ITP 3/52 post - ?treatment (possible)
   –   1 paroxysmal AF 13/7, cardioversion (probably not)
   –   1 hyperthyroid (auto-immune) crisis with secondary cardiac failure at home
       14/7. Second donation (first also PBSC 17 months prior) (probable)
SEAR
• 107 PBSC
   – 1 pilonidal sinus 6/52 post (probably not)
   – 1 hypertonus 2/12, 8/12 thrombosis left eye with retinal detachment (probably
     not)
   – 1 retinal detachment 5/12 (probably not)
   – 1 basilar artery haemorrhage 3/12 (probably not)
   – 1 acute sarcoidosis 2/52 post. Resolved (possible)
   – 1 multiple liver haemangiomas and elevated LFT 6/12 (probably not)
   – 1 auto-immune hypothyroidism 2/12 (possible)
   – 1 fibromyalgia 6/12 (probably not)
   – 1 balanced chromosomal abnormality (18) – increased miscarriages
   – 1 severe disabling hip pain (>1 year) (possible)
   – 1 dilated cardiomyopathy 1yr (probably not)
   – 2 Crohns disease (18mo, 2yrs) (probably not)
   – 1 stroke 1yr (definitely not)
   – 1 neutropenia 1yr (N BM) (definitely not)
   – Joint swelling/raised LFT 1yr (probably not)
   – Transverse myelitis 3yr (probably not)
SEAR
• 107 PBSC
   – 3 ulcerative colitis (5 weeks, 2 mo, 4 mo) (possible)
   – 3 Rheumatoid arthritis (6mo-years) (prob not)
   – 4 Multiple sclerosis/optic neuritis (prob not)
   – 1 Atypical athropathia psoriatica (prob not)
   – 2 alopecia (3 mo/18 mo) (possible)
   – 1 ankylosing spondylitis (10 mo) (prob not)
   – 1 wegeners (3 mo) (prob not)
   – 1 ITP (3 yrs) ((prob not)
   – 1 Hashimotos (6 mo) (possible)
   – 1 de quervians (3 mo) (prob not)
   – 1 chronic keratitis (prob not)

    – 25 malignancies (non-haematological)
    – 8 haematological (T-ALL/ALL/2 HD/CML/AML/malt lymphoma/MGUS)
Challenges
1. Keeping open access for all recipients to all
HSC’s
2. Keeping the costs of HSC products down
3. Ensuring individual patient risk benefit
decisions
4. Maintaining small market share tests and
products
5. Maintaining rapid access search systems
6. Working with regulators and governments to
recognize the global nature of the issues but not
being afraid to call them to task
7. Establishing a coding and labelling system
Thank you

Jeremy_Chapman@wsahs.nsw.gov.au

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Jeremy Chapman - Australia - Tuesday 29 - Hematopoietic Stem Cells

28 doença metastática - presente & futuro
28   doença metastática - presente & futuro28   doença metastática - presente & futuro
28 doença metastática - presente & futuro
ONCOcare
 
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speakerJohanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
Fight Colorectal Cancer
 
Tact quality of life outcomes
Tact quality of life outcomesTact quality of life outcomes
Tact quality of life outcomes
Marilyn Mann
 
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised finalWest xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
H. Jack West
 
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
odeckmyn
 
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
Institute For Medical Education and Research (IMER)
 
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodmanSbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
Dr. Vijay Anand P. Reddy
 
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
VEAB
 
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slidesTrial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
Marilyn Mann
 

Ähnlich wie Jeremy Chapman - Australia - Tuesday 29 - Hematopoietic Stem Cells (16)

28 doença metastática - presente & futuro
28   doença metastática - presente & futuro28   doença metastática - presente & futuro
28 doença metastática - presente & futuro
 
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speakerJohanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
Johanna Bendell Call-on Congress panel speaker
 
Dmt g pday_oct12
Dmt g pday_oct12Dmt g pday_oct12
Dmt g pday_oct12
 
Newest Modalities in Bone Marrow Transplantation
Newest Modalities in Bone Marrow TransplantationNewest Modalities in Bone Marrow Transplantation
Newest Modalities in Bone Marrow Transplantation
 
Tact quality of life outcomes
Tact quality of life outcomesTact quality of life outcomes
Tact quality of life outcomes
 
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised finalWest xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
West xcenda molec testing sf oct 2011 revised final
 
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
Benhamou Hcv Hiv Du 2010
 
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
The Future of Antiangiogenic Therapies in Ovarian Cancer: A Series of Communi...
 
Treatment of Large Cell Lymphoma
Treatment of Large Cell Lymphoma Treatment of Large Cell Lymphoma
Treatment of Large Cell Lymphoma
 
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodmanSbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
Sbrt liver tumors_kag(cancer ci 2013) karyn a. goodman
 
Medical Sample 23
Medical  Sample 23Medical  Sample 23
Medical Sample 23
 
Revascularización miocárdica sin bomba; iguales resultados al año que la ciru...
Revascularización miocárdica sin bomba; iguales resultados al año que la ciru...Revascularización miocárdica sin bomba; iguales resultados al año que la ciru...
Revascularización miocárdica sin bomba; iguales resultados al año que la ciru...
 
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
Masszi Tamás: Őssejt transzplantáció (Cml_sct_2012)
 
The Treatment of Hodgkin's Disease (part 2)
The Treatment of Hodgkin's Disease (part 2)The Treatment of Hodgkin's Disease (part 2)
The Treatment of Hodgkin's Disease (part 2)
 
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slidesTrial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
Trial to assess chelation therapy (tact) slides
 
Aversano
AversanoAversano
Aversano
 

Mehr von incucai_isodp

Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DKathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
incucai_isodp
 
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DHedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
incucai_isodp
 
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DChunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
incucai_isodp
 
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
incucai_isodp
 
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CJongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
incucai_isodp
 
German Farfalli - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
German Farfalli -  Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CGerman Farfalli -  Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
German Farfalli - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
incucai_isodp
 
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal  - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CCatarina Bolotinha - Portugal  - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
incucai_isodp
 
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
incucai_isodp
 
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. CAlaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
incucai_isodp
 
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. BKirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
incucai_isodp
 
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BGwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
incucai_isodp
 
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BDanielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
incucai_isodp
 
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BAzemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
incucai_isodp
 
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. AMerve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ASohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ALiliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ALeonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. AHani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. ADaniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
incucai_isodp
 
Gabriel Danovitch - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self Sufficiency
Gabriel Danovitch  - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self  SufficiencyGabriel Danovitch  - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self  Sufficiency
Gabriel Danovitch - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self Sufficiency
incucai_isodp
 

Mehr von incucai_isodp (20)

Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DKathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Kathy Yandle - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
 
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DHedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Hedi Aguiar - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
 
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. DChunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
Chunhee Bok - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. D
 
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
Bernadette Haase Kromwijk - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentatio...
 
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CJongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Jongwon Ha - Korea - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
 
German Farfalli - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
German Farfalli -  Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CGerman Farfalli -  Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
German Farfalli - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
 
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal  - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. CCatarina Bolotinha - Portugal  - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
Catarina Bolotinha - Portugal - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. C
 
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
Annemarie Luchtenburg - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations M...
 
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. CAlaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
Alaleh Gheissari - Iran - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. C
 
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. BKirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
Kirsten Howard - Australia - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. B
 
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BGwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Gwen O´Shaughnessy - USA - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
 
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BDanielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Danielle Nijkamp - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
 
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. BAzemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
Azemi Barama - Canada - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. B
 
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. AMerve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Merve Tarhan - Turkey - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ASohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Sohal Ismail - The Netherlands - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ALiliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Liliana Bisigniano - Argentina - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. ALeonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Leonardo De Castro - Singapore - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. AHani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
Hani Haider Kuwait - Wednesday 30 - Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. ADaniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
Daniela Norba - Germany - Wednesday 30 -Oral Presentations Misc. A
 
Gabriel Danovitch - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self Sufficiency
Gabriel Danovitch  - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self  SufficiencyGabriel Danovitch  - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self  Sufficiency
Gabriel Danovitch - USA - Wednesday 30 - Transplant Tourism Self Sufficiency
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
Sheetaleventcompany
 
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
rajnisinghkjn
 
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
Sheetaleventcompany
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉8630512678 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉8630512678 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉8630512678 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉8630512678 Top Class Call Girl Service Avai...
 
Call girls Service Phullen / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos a...
Call girls Service Phullen / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos a...Call girls Service Phullen / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos a...
Call girls Service Phullen / 9332606886 Genuine Call girls with real Photos a...
 
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
 
Low Cost Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP NISHA Call Girls in Bangalo...
Low Cost Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP NISHA Call Girls in Bangalo...Low Cost Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP NISHA Call Girls in Bangalo...
Low Cost Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP NISHA Call Girls in Bangalo...
 
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacytongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
 
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
 
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
Call Girl In Indore 📞9235973566📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Indore Call Girls Service ...
 
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book nowChennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
 
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
 
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
 
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their RegulationCardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
 
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
 
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
Gorgeous Call Girls Dehradun {8854095900} ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girls in Dehradun...
 
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉 8875999948 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉 8875999948 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉 8875999948 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls in Lucknow Just Call 👉👉 8875999948 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
 
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room DeliveryCall 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
 
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
 
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala 💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃 Top Class Call Girl Se...
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala  💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃  Top Class Call Girl Se...Kolkata Call Girls Naktala  💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃  Top Class Call Girl Se...
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala 💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃 Top Class Call Girl Se...
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
 

Jeremy Chapman - Australia - Tuesday 29 - Hematopoietic Stem Cells

  • 1. Research Trends and Regulation in Haematopetic Stem Cell Transplantation Jeremy Chapman
  • 2. Clinical Problem: Allogeneic Graft Availability Leukemia Patients Needing BMT 8/10 2/10 No Compatible Compatible Sibling Family Donor Donor Only 15-20% minority patients receive BMT via adult registry
  • 3. Impact of Disease Stage and HLA Matching on Unrelated HCT Outcomes Low Risk Intermediate Risk High Risk
  • 4. Impact of Single HLA Mismatch in Unrelated HCT for Low-risk Disease
  • 5. LFS after Cord Blood or Bone Marrow Transplant from Unrelated Donors in Adult Leukemia Patients Rocha et al, N Engl J Med 2004;351:2276-85.
  • 6. Unrelated Haematpoetic Stem cell donations: Bone Marrow PBSC Cord Blood
  • 7. Bone Marrow or Peripheral Blood Stem Cells? Stem Cell Trialists' Collaborative Group, JCO 2005
  • 8. Pioneers in Cord Blood Transplantation Eliane Gluckman Paris Pablo Rubenstein New York John Wagner Minneapolis
  • 9. Survival after 0-3 Mismatched Unrelated UCB & 6/6 HLA-matched BMT in children 1.0 1.0 Proportion Surviving 0.8 0.8 0.6 BMT-TCD 0.6 UCBT 56% Proportion 53% Surviving 0.4 41% 0.4 UCBT 52% BMT-MTX 0.2 0.2 p = .40 p > .80 0.0 0.0 0 6 12 18 24 0 6 12 18 24 Months Months Patient analyses with match for age, diagnosis, and disease stage. Barker et al, Blood. 2001 May 15;97(10):2957-61.
  • 10. Probability of Neutrophil Recovery by UCB Graft Cell Dose 1.0 cell dose < 1.87*107/kg (n=23) cell dose (1.87, 2.41) (n=21) Probability of neutrophil recovery 0.8 cell dose > 2.41*107/kg (n=24) 0.6 p-value = 0.003 0.4 0.2 0.0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 days after transplantation No. at Risk: 68 66 53 26 6 1 Laughlin, MJ., et al., N Engl J Med 2001;344:1815-22
  • 11. DFS for Acute Leukemia in CR Single vs. Double UCBT CY60/TBI1320 1.0 I I I I Cumulative Proportion 0.8 double I I I 0.6 I I I I single 0.4 Double: Adults + 0.2 Adolescents Single: Children 0.0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Months
  • 12. PROBABILITY OF SURVIVAL Impact of Cell dose and HLA mismatch 1.0 0.8 CB matched PROBABILITY 0.6 CB 1 agmm (>2.5) 0.4 CB 2 agmm (>2.5) 0.2 CB 1 agmm (<2.5) CB 2 agmm (<2.5) 0.0 0 1 2 3 YEARS
  • 13. Mary Horowitz CIBMTR University of Wisconsin ... .. ............... . .. . .... .......... . .......... . . . . .. . .... .. . . .. . ......... ... .......... . .. . .. . . . .. .. . . . .. ... .. . .. . . . .. .... . . .... ... . .. 135 staff including, 6 PhD statisticians, 14 MS statisticians, 11 MD-MS faculty; Active program of statistical methodology research specifically focused on transplant outcomes in addition to supporting clinical studies
  • 14. Overall Survival Pediatric Study 100 CB matched (n=36) 62% Adjusted Probability, % BM matched (n=116) 45% 80 CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157) 45% 60 40 20 CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44) 36% CB 2-Ag MM (n=267) 33% 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 Months Mjz06_13.ppt
  • 15. Neutrophil Recovery Pediatric Study 100 BM (n=492), 97% CB matched (n=35), 86% 80 CB MM high dose (n=362), 79% Probability, % CB MM low dose (n=97), 64% 60 40 20 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 Days CAL05_13.ppt
  • 16. Acute Grade 2-4 GVHD Pediatric Study 100 80 BM MM (n=123), 70% Probability, % 60 BM matched (n=368), 50% 40 CB MM (n=454), 40% 20 CB matched (n=35), 20% 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 Days CAL05_15.ppt
  • 17. Chronic GVHD Pediatric Study 100 80 Probability, % 60 BM MM (n=123), 35% 40 BM matched (n=369), 33% 20 CB matched/MM (n=466), 17% 0 0 6 12 18 24 30 36 Months CAL05_16.ppt
  • 18. Treatment-related Mortality Pediatric Study 100 80 Probability, % CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44), 43% BM MM (n=123), 40% 60 CB 2-Ag MM (n=267), 47% 40 CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157), 29% 20 BM matched (n=369), 26% CB matched (n=35), 6% 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 Months CAL05_27.ppt
  • 19. Leukemia-free survival Pediatric study 100 80 Probability, % CB matched (n=35), 60% 60 CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157), 41% 40 BM matched (n=369), 40% 20 CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44), 36% CB 2-Ag MM (n=267), 33% BM MM (n=123), 30% 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 Months CAL05_17.ppt
  • 20. Overall Survival Pediatric Study 100 80 Probability, % CB matched (n=36), 62% 60 CB 1-Ag MM high (n=157), 45% 40 BM matched (n=369), 44% 20 BM MM (n=123), 40% CB 1-Ag MM low (n=44), 35% CB 2-Ag MM (n=267), 35% 0 0 12 24 36 48 60 Months CAL05_20.ppt
  • 21. The IPA/NIMA effect - Jon Van Rood Mother Father NIMA = non inherited maternal antigens IMA/NIMA IPA/NIPA NIPA = non inherited paternal antigens IMA = inherited maternal antigens IPA = inherited paternal antigens The mother develops B and T cell immunity against the IPA of the fetus, which is controlled by T reg. Likewise, the fetus develop immunity and T reg against the NIMA. Immunity can be lifelong in both mother and child. Patient IMA/IPA
  • 22. HSCT with a parental donor shows a differential effect of maternal versus paternal donors on survival. 1.0 0.8 0.6 Mother donor N=47 Event 0.4 Free Survival 0.2 Father donor N=71 0.0 p<0.0001 Years Follow-Up 0 1 2 3 4 5 # at risk: 118 38 29 28 28 28 M. Stern et al. Blood 2008
  • 23. Identification of an acceptable mismatch with the help of NIMA van Rood et al. Pnas: 2009, 106, pp 19952 Patient A1, A2 - B7, B44 cord blood A1, A3 - B7, B44 mother of CB A1, A2 - B7, B8 NIMA=A2 and B8 Combining the NIMA A2 and B8 with the CB phenotype can create for example the following Virtual CB phenotype: A1, A2 / B7, B44 and 5 other Virtual Phenotypes (VP) if there is one substitution and 12 when there are two. HLA typing of the mother created 16 different VPs!!
  • 24. Transplant-Related Mortality (Patients ≥ 10 Years Old) 80 % with TRM (Cum. Incid.) 2 MM, No NIMA Match Reference 290/488 60 2 MM, 1NIMA Match 1 MM, No NIMA Match Reference 40 1 MM, 1NIMA Match 20/41 RR=0.6, P= 0.012 20 0 Mismatch 4/22 RR=0.3 P = 0.011 0 0 1 2 3 Years Post-Transplant PNAS 2009 106 (47) p10952
  • 25. Time to Absolute Neutrophil Count ≥ 500 100 (Cum. Incid) 0 Mismatch 80 1-2 MM, 1 NIMA Match 60 % with ANC 500 1-2 MM, No NIMA Match 40 20 0 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 56 70 days after transplant Patients N RR p value 0 MM 15 3.8 <0.001 1-2 MM,1 NIMA Match 18 1.9 0.031 1-2 MM, No NIMA Match 219 reference
  • 26. Relapse (Patients with Myeloid Diseases) HLA MM/ NIMA RR P 2 MM/No NIMA (n = 343) 0.7 0.075 1 MN/No NIMA (n =193) Reference 40 % with Relapse (Cum. Incid.) 2 MM/NIMA Match (n = 31) 0.7 0.448 1 MM/NIMA Match (n = 13) 0.2 0.074 0 MM (n = 33) 0.7 0.306 1 MM, No NIMA Match 30 0 Mismatch 2 MM, NIMA Match 20 2 MM, No NIMA Match 10 1 MM, NIMA Match 0 0 1 2 3 Years Post-Transplant PNAS 2009, 106, pp 19952
  • 27. Acknowledgements NYBC - NCBP Europdonor Foundation • Andromachi Scaradavou • Henk van der Zanden • Pablo Rubinstein • Machteld Oudshoorn • C. Carrier, C. Carpenter • Jack Bakker,Angelo Melis • NCBP Program Staff • Frans Claas • Transplant centers/ physicians/data managers/ patients • Donating Mothers • Eurotransplant Foundation • Jacqueline Smits • Cladd Stevens
  • 28. Current Status Stem Cell Products provided for unrelated transplantation 18,000 16,000 2008 2009 Number of donations 14,000 Bone Marrow 3,221 3,445 12,000 10,000 PBSC 7,260 8,162 8,000 Cord Blood Units 3,522 3,749 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Year BM donations PBSC donations Cord Blood Units Provided
  • 29. % Patients Transplanted in Relation to Searches Requested Red: 0-10% Yellow: 10-30% Orange: 30-50% Green: > 50% Analyzed from WMDA Annual Report 2009
  • 30. The ABMDR is the best place to search for Australian Patients These are the best registries to search for Australian patients Chance of finding a donor for an AUSTRALIAN patient
  • 32. In 2009 18 Products a Day 6,461 Products crossed a Border Percentage of bone marrow/PBSC donations provided for national and international patients 75 65 69.7 69.4 69.1 67.1 66.3 67.5 65.6 64.7 61.1 61.2 Percentage (%) 55 58.0 56.2 55.1 45 43.8 44.9 35 38.8 42.0 38.9 34.4 35.3 32.9 33.7 32.5 30.3 30.6 30.9 25 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Year Donations to international recipients Donations to national recipients
  • 33. In 2010, 149 cord blood banks participated worldwide Number of CBUs provided for unrelated transplantation 4,500 2010 2009 4,000 Number of cord blood units CBUs provided 4,054 3,792 3,500 3,000 2,500 2,000 1,500 1,000 500 0 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Year No information provided Units provided for adults Units provided for children
  • 34. Degree of matching of the cord blood units provided for children (N=1,286 units) 0 mismatched 664 1 mismatched 600 2 mismatched Number of cord blood units 3 or more 500 not specified 400 299 245 300 204 200 100 6 0 Degree of matching of the cord blood units provided for adults (N=2,768 units) 0 mismatched 1,213 1 mismatched 1,200 2 mismatched Number of cord blood units 3 or more 1,000 830 not specified 771 800 600 400 245 200 20 0
  • 35. International exchange of cord blood products is increasing Number of cord blood units provided for national and international patients 3,000 2,726 2,537 2,321 2,500 Number of Cord Blood Units 2,207 2,000 1,862 1,710 1,368 1,255 1,328 1,500 1,235 1,213 1,098 1,000 829 625 652 510 500 346 372 387 284 146 192 175 129 0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Year Provided Internationally Provided Nationally In 2010: 3.63 cord blood products passing an international border a day
  • 36. NATIONAL MARROW DONOR PROGRAM® 36 Entrusted to operate the C.W. Bill Young Cell Transplantation Program, including the Be The Match Registry®
  • 37. AUSCORD 29% OF RELEASES FROM 3% OF INVENTORY
  • 38. Over 70% of the CBUs shipped for adult patients have a TNC >150 Cord blood shipments by TNC for adult patients 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 <90 90-119 120-149 150-199 200-249 250-300 >300
  • 39. 2010 Inventory and shipments TNC of BMDW inventory as of January 1, 2011 1% 2% 0.002% 6% 10% 12% 36% 33% TNC of the CBU products shipped in 2010 2% 0.003 6% <50 50-89 90-124 125-149 8% 14% 150-199 200-249 250-300 >300 20% 18% 76% of the shipments came from 25% of the available 32% inventory <50 50-89 90-124 125-149 150-199 200-249 250-300 >300
  • 40. Shipping rate of the units listed in BMDW based on TNC (units shipped/units available) TNC Percentage(%) < 50 0.03 50-89 0.09 90-124 0.3 125-149 1.0 150-199 2.3 200-249 6.3 250-300 10.5 >300 17.0
  • 41. NATIONAL MARROW DONOR PROGRAM® 41 Entrusted to operate the C.W. Bill Young Cell Transplantation Program, including the Be The Match Registry®
  • 42.
  • 43. 2010 WHO Guiding Principles on Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation World Health Assembly - 22 May 2010 1. 1. Consentfor deceased donor's donation Consent for deceased donor's donation 2. 2. No conflictfor death determination No conflict for death determination 3. 3. Deceasedbut also consenting live donors Deceased but also consenting live donors 4. 4. Protectionof minors and incompetent persons Protection of minors and incompetent persons 5. 5. No sale or purchase No sale or purchase 6. 6. Promotionof donation nono advertisingbrokering Promotion of donation advertising nor nor brokering 7. 7. Responsibility on origintransplant Responsibility on origin of of transplant 8. 8. Justifiable professional fees Justifiable professional fees 9. Allocationrules 9. Allocation rules 10. Quality safety efficacy of procedures and transplants 10. Quality safety efficacy of procedures and transplants 11. Transparency and confidentiality 11. Transparency and confidentiality
  • 44. 2010 WHO Guiding Principles on Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation GP 5 Free donation and no purchase of human transplant as such, but cost & expenditures recovery GP 6 GP 7 GP 8 GP 3 Promoting Responsibility Justifiable fees Maximizing DD No advertising for transplant origin Protecting LD GP 2 GP 4 GP 9 Death Δγ Protecting the Equitable allocation No conflict incompetent GP 1 Consent DD Donor Process Recipient GP 10 Monitoring long term outcomes. Quality & safety of procedures & products GP 11 Transparency, openness to scrutiny, anonymity
  • 45. WHO Guiding Principles on 2010 Human Cell, Tissue Long term Short and and Organ Transplantation Donor Outcomes 2010 World Health Assembly - 22 May Recipient Outcomes Guiding Principle 10 Quality systems Traceability Vigilance Adverse event reporting
  • 46. WHO Guiding Principles on 2010 Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation World Health Assembly - 22 May 2010 Transparency Open to Scrutiny Maintaining privacy of Donors and Recipients
  • 48. The blood safety paradigm doesn’t translate to Organs & Cells. What is the problem? Volume of activity Scarcity of Donors Blood donations are in the Blood donors can be millions in many countries replaced Organ donations are in the Organ donors are very thousands in only a very scarce few countries Hemopoetic stem cell Hemopoetic stem cell donors are usually unique donations are even fewer for each recipient Mortality rates on organ transplant waiting lists are substantial Unavoidable mortality rates from transplantation are substantial Risks from transmission of disease are very small under standard procedures Regulation risk: causing more deaths than saved
  • 49. The effect of putting the Barriers up +++ 500 400 In Country 300 National Import 200 Export 100 0 Out of Country -100 -200 -300 -400 -500 +
  • 50. The effect of putting the Barriers up +++ 500 400 In Country 300 Import National 200 Export 100 0 Out of Country -100 -200 -300 -400 -500 +
  • 51. Collateral damage by regulators IS Unacceptable
  • 53.
  • 54. Analyze: where are CBUs used for transplantation? Number of Cord Blood Units shipped to each continent over time 1,600 Number of CBUs provided 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Year Asia Australia Europe North America South America Africa 35% of the CBUs shipped are shipped to North America 33% of the CBUs shipped are shipped to Asia
  • 55. Guidance for Industry Minimally Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic Placental/Umbilical Cord Blood Intended for Hematopoietic Reconstitution for Specified Indications U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Food and Drug Administration Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research October 2009 1 This guidance applies to HPC-Cs manufactured by U.S. cord blood establishments and non- U.S. cord blood establishments that distribute cord blood in the U.S. However, some non-U.S. cord blood establishments that participate in international registries may not apply for licensure Importation and use of unlicensed placental/umbilical cord of their products. Importation and use of unlicensed placental/umbilical cord stem/progenitor cell products from non-U.S. cord blood establishments would be acceptable under an stem/progenitor cell products from non-U.S. cord bloodan affiliated Investigational New Drug (IND) application held by the non-U.S. establishment, establishments the U.S. transplant center, or a registry. Also, certain HPC-Cs U.S. establishment, would be acceptable under an Investigational New manufactured in the U.S. may not be licensed but could be listed in registries and made Drug (IND) applicationan IND. Additional non-U.S. establishment, anof available for clinical use under held by the recommendations regarding submission affiliated U.S. establishment, provided in the companion draft guidanceor a INDs for certain unlicensed HPC-Cs are the U.S. transplant center, entitled “Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff: Investigational New Drug Applications (INDs) for registry. Manipulated, Unrelated Allogeneic Placental/Umbilical Cord Blood Intended for Minimally Hematopoietic Reconstitution for Specified Indications).”
  • 56. Europe Reliant upon each national competent authority..... EUROPEAN DIRECTIVE 2004/23/EC; article 9 Import/export of human tissues and cells Member States and tissue establishments that receive such imports from third countries shall ensure that they meet standards of quality and safety.
  • 57. Legislation to enact European Directive on HSC August 2011 Not standardised Legislated Not Legislated
  • 58. Global Quality Standards
  • 59. Quality, efficacy and safety International Standards Accreditation and Audit Data collection and analysis Donor safety - SEAR Product safety - SPEAR Recipient safety – Outcome databases This will not be enough – but it will
  • 60. 2009 – 9 events reported to the WMDA (to date) • 2009 – 7 events reported to the WMDA (to date). All except 1 prior to – 8 incidents from donations before 2009, 1 in 2009 2009 (4 - 2008, 1 - 2006, 1 - 1996): (3 - 2008, 3 - 2006, 1 - 2003, 1-1997): – Donor blood group incorrect on label (all other identifiers • 5 cancers correct) – Breast/ brain (benign)/NHL post BM – Incorrect product collected by courier (2 harvested on same day). – Lung/ hepatoma post PBSC (hepatoma had 3 doses of Identified and rectified before courier left airport GCSF - not collected due to patient factors) – Cord unit arrived partially thawed. 28% viability in segment. Not • 1 cauda equina syndrome post BM infused • 1 severe groin bruising post groin line for DLI – Clots in apheresis bag - engrafted • 1 faint following tubing rupture during PBSC (target dose – Rupture of tubing on cell separator. Collection abandoned. Target collected on second day) achieved on day 2 • 1 fat embolism post GA and BM harvest - full recovery – 2 donor derived malignancies • Patient with MDS (Tx 04/06) diagnosed with CML in 11/08. Donor diagnosed with CML 05/08 • Patient with CML (Tx 06/96) diagnosed with mantle cell lymphoma in 05/08. Donor diagnosed with MCL 098/08
  • 61. Clinical Working Group (S(P)EAR committee) Chair: Bronwen Shaw Vice-chair: Jeff Szer
  • 62. S(P)EAR committee • 175 S(P)EAR reported in 2011 thus far (26 october) – 44 SPEAR (product related) – 131 SEAR (donor related)
  • 63. SPEAR • 10 BM – 4 bacterial contamination of product – 3 Quality • Clot/haemolysed/incorrect recipient name on product – 2 transfer of donor disease • Hepatitis B (possible) • B-CLL (definite) – 1 hypertension post infusion. PRES (probably not)
  • 64. SPEAR • 11 PBSC – 2 ‘suboptimal product’ • 2 failed mobilisation – 1 patient received BM – 3 cryopreserved – poor viability on thaw (2 engrafted/1 PGF – probable) – 1 transport delay/low viability – PGF (possible) – 1 different cell counts and volume at HC and TC – 2 TRALI (both possible) – 1 Donor XXY on chimerism – 1 fever post infusion (bacillus in patient, not in product) • 1 DLI – unable to collect (whole blood collected)
  • 65. SPEAR • 22 CBU – 17 Quality • 6 Damage • 4 Thawed • 4 Other transport (e.g. Xrayed/temperature loggers/bacterial contamination) • 2 Data incorrect • 1 poor cell recovery (engrafted) – 2 Non-engraftment • 1 Low viability (probable) • 1 positive bacterial culture (possible) – 1 Donor derived MDS in engrafting cord (probable) – 1 ‘shocked heart’ (possible) – 1 infusion/washing issue – ARF (probable)
  • 66. SEAR • 22 BM – 6 malignancies (1 haem: CLL) – 2 osteomyelitis – 1 laryngospasm required retubing (definite) – 1 low sats in recovery – observation only (possible) – 2 thrombophlebitis (cannulae) (definite) – 1 sacral haematoma (surgery) (definite) – 3 prolonged back pain (definite) – 2 tendon/nerve injury (1 definite/1 probable) – 1 allogeneic blood for symptomatic anaemia – 1 cardiac arrythmia 6/52 post (possible) – 1 prolonged orthostatic dysregulation (definite) – 1 donor collapse 10 hours post harvest. Successful CPR. 2 allo units (definite) • 2 DLI – anaphylaxis to apheresis set (definite) – Trigeminal neuralgia 21 days post (possible)
  • 67. SEAR • 107 PBSC – 1 donor death – CVC related (Definite) Mobilisation – 1 microscopic haematuria (probable) – 1 pain (hospitalised) (definite) – 1 severe headache-admission and CT (normal) (possible) – 1 intractable vomiting (hospitalised) (definite) – 1 elevated LFT (probable) – 1 erythema of legs D3 (hospitalised - steroids) (probable) – 1 collapse after 1st dose (went ahead) (probable) – 1 dysphagia ? Stress (probable) – 1 acute gout ankle on D3 – no pmh (definite) – 1 epidydimitis/urethritis needing antibiotics (probably not) – 1 severe breathlessness (?stress) G stopped. No collection (probable)
  • 68. SEAR • 107 PBSC Collection – 2 failed collections (citrate toxicity, BM instead; no peripheral access, donor refused CVC) – 1 limited collection (access problems – false aneurysm after femoral CVC, arterial puncture, 43% collected) – 1 chest tightness – 1 tetany – 1 abdo pain, normal ultrasound, admitted later ?cholecystitis – 1 allergic urticaria and hives, continued for 6 months requiring steroids (definite) – 1 herpes zoster (second apheresis)
  • 69. SEAR • 107 PBSC Within 1 month – 3 thrombophlebitis – 1 nerve damage to hand (definite) – 1 abnormal LFT ? Cause (probably not) – 1 MI (several risk factors) (probably not) – 1 anterior uveitis (3/7 post) (possible) – 1 intracranial haematoma 10/7 post, hospitalised, no intervention (possible) – 1 convulsions/palsy 1 mo post – brain bx, unknown cause (possible) – 1 hypertension and tiredness (possible) – 1 otitis media, pneumonia and renal insufficiency 2 /7(inpatient 16/7) (possible) – 1 pyogenic necrotising/haemorrhagic enteritis requiring surgery 3/7 (possible) – 1 atopic dermatitis of both hands 20/7 (possible) – 1 fever, abdo pain 2/7 post, 7/7 inpatient (possible) – 1 near syncope at home (probable) – 1 ITP 3/52 post - ?treatment (possible) – 1 paroxysmal AF 13/7, cardioversion (probably not) – 1 hyperthyroid (auto-immune) crisis with secondary cardiac failure at home 14/7. Second donation (first also PBSC 17 months prior) (probable)
  • 70. SEAR • 107 PBSC – 1 pilonidal sinus 6/52 post (probably not) – 1 hypertonus 2/12, 8/12 thrombosis left eye with retinal detachment (probably not) – 1 retinal detachment 5/12 (probably not) – 1 basilar artery haemorrhage 3/12 (probably not) – 1 acute sarcoidosis 2/52 post. Resolved (possible) – 1 multiple liver haemangiomas and elevated LFT 6/12 (probably not) – 1 auto-immune hypothyroidism 2/12 (possible) – 1 fibromyalgia 6/12 (probably not) – 1 balanced chromosomal abnormality (18) – increased miscarriages – 1 severe disabling hip pain (>1 year) (possible) – 1 dilated cardiomyopathy 1yr (probably not) – 2 Crohns disease (18mo, 2yrs) (probably not) – 1 stroke 1yr (definitely not) – 1 neutropenia 1yr (N BM) (definitely not) – Joint swelling/raised LFT 1yr (probably not) – Transverse myelitis 3yr (probably not)
  • 71. SEAR • 107 PBSC – 3 ulcerative colitis (5 weeks, 2 mo, 4 mo) (possible) – 3 Rheumatoid arthritis (6mo-years) (prob not) – 4 Multiple sclerosis/optic neuritis (prob not) – 1 Atypical athropathia psoriatica (prob not) – 2 alopecia (3 mo/18 mo) (possible) – 1 ankylosing spondylitis (10 mo) (prob not) – 1 wegeners (3 mo) (prob not) – 1 ITP (3 yrs) ((prob not) – 1 Hashimotos (6 mo) (possible) – 1 de quervians (3 mo) (prob not) – 1 chronic keratitis (prob not) – 25 malignancies (non-haematological) – 8 haematological (T-ALL/ALL/2 HD/CML/AML/malt lymphoma/MGUS)
  • 72. Challenges 1. Keeping open access for all recipients to all HSC’s 2. Keeping the costs of HSC products down 3. Ensuring individual patient risk benefit decisions 4. Maintaining small market share tests and products 5. Maintaining rapid access search systems 6. Working with regulators and governments to recognize the global nature of the issues but not being afraid to call them to task 7. Establishing a coding and labelling system

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. This slide shows graphically what happens. A single mismatch which is compensated by a single NIMA match, results in a TRM which is near identical to a zero mismatch. Two HLA mismatches compensated by a single NIMA match results in a TRM identical to a single mismatch.