KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
0DDOLN
V0XZDWWD
$87+25
7DUMXPDQDDQG-RKQVRQ
,QWURGXFWLRQWR7UDQVODWLRQRI0DOLN
V0XZDWWD
7UDQVODWRUVC$...
LVDFROOHFWLRQRIWZRLWHPV
 WKHVDLQJVDQGGHHGVRI3URSKHW0XKDPPDGSEXK
DOVRNQRZQDVWKHVXQQDK
7KH
UHSRUWVRIWKH3URSKHW
VVDLQJVDQGGHHGVDUHFDOOHGDKDGLWK
 WKH OHJDO RSLQLRQV DQG GHFLVLRQV RI WKH 3URSKHW
V RPSDQLRQV WKHLU...
ZDVERUQLQ
$+DQGGLHGLQ$++HOLYHGPRVWRIKLVOLIHLQ0DGLQDKWKHFLWLQZKLFKWKH
3URSKHWSEXK
VHWWOHGLQ+HZDVDSUHHPLQHQWVFKRODURI,VODPDQGLVWKHRULJLQDWRURI
WKH 0DOLNL MXGLFLDO VFKRRO RI WKRXJKW +H LV UHSXWHG WR KDYH KD...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
8UZDVDLGWKDW$
LVKDWKHZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFH
XVHGWRSUDDVUZKLOHWKHVXQOLJKWZ...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP=DGLEQ$VODPWKDW$WDLEQDVDUVDLG$PDQ
FDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKL...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
WRSUDVXEKZKHQWKHVWDUVZHUHDOOYLVLEOHDQGOLNHDKD]HLQWKHVNDQGWRUHDGLQLWWZR
ORQJVXUDVIURPWKHPXIDVVDO
%R...
DQGWKDWKHVKRXOGSUD
LVKDGXULQJWKHILUVWWKLUGRIWKHQLJKWRULIKHGHODHGLWWKHQXSXQWLOWKHPLGGOHRIWKH
QLJKWDQGKHZDUQHGKLPQRWWREHIRUJ...
6HFWLRQ7KH7LPHRIWKH-XPXD3UDHU
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPKLVXQFOH$EX6XKDOLEQ0DOLNWKDWKLVIDWKHUVDLG
,XVHGWRVHHDF...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$PULEQDKDLEQDKDDO0D]LQLIURP,EQ$EL
6DOLWWKDW8WKPDQLEQ$IIDQSUDHGMXPXDLQ0D...
0DOLNFRPPHQWHG7KDWZDVESUDLQJMXPXDMXVWSDVWPLGGDDQG WKHQWUDYHOOLQJIDVW
6HFWLRQDWFKLQJD5DNDRIWKH3UDHU
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWR...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
%RRN1XPEHU
DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN WKDWDKD LEQ 6DLG XVHG WR VD (YHQ LI VRPHRQH
PDQDJHVWRSUDEH...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
LQWKHSUDHU1RWLFLQJWKHLUXQHDVLQHVVKHZHQWWRWKHPDQGVDLG
2SHRSOH$OODKVHL]HG
RXUVSLULWVDUZDK
DQGLI+HKDGZLVKHG+HZRXOGKDYHUHWXUQHGWKHPWRXVDWDWLPH
RWKHUWKDQWKLV6RLIRXVOHHSWKURXJKWKHWLPHIRUDSUDHURUIRUJHWLWDQGWKHQDUH
DQ[...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP $PU LEQ DKD DO0D]LQL WKDW KLV IDWKHU RQFH
DVNHG$EGXOODKLEQ=DGLEQ...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGDERXWZKDWDPDQVKRXOGGRLIKHKDGIRUJRWWHQWRULQVH
KLVPRXWKDQGQRVHXQWLOKHKDGSUDHGDQGKHVDLG+HG...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EX
]=LQDGIURPDO$UDMIURP$EX+XUDUDWKDW
WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$...
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP=DGLEQ$VODPWKDWWKHDDWRXZKREHOLHYH
:KHQRXULVHIRUSUDHUZDVKRXUIDFHVDQGRXUDUPVWRWKHHOERZVDQGZLSHRYH...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVDWKDWPHQ
DQGWKHLUZLYHVXVHGWRGRZXGXWRJHWKH...
, ZDON LQ GLUWSODFHV
8PP 6DODPD UHSOLHG 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP
SHDFHVDLG
:KDWIROORZVLHFOH...
SXULILHVLW

%RRN1XPEHU
DKD UHODWHG WRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWKHVDZ5DELDLEQ$EGDU5DKPDQYRPLWVHYHUDO
WLPHVZKHQKHZDVLQWKHPRVTXHDQGKHGLG...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP'DPUDLEQ6DLGDO0D]LQLIURP$EDQLEQ8WKPDQ
WKDW8WKPDQLEQ$IIDQDWHEUHDGDQGPHDW...
$EX7DOKDDQG8EDLEQ
.DEERWKJRWXSDQGSUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX
6HFWLRQ2Q:XGXLQ*HQHUDO
%RRN1XPEHU
DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP...
7KHDVNHGKLP 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK+RZZLOORXUHFRJQLVHWKRVHRIRXUFRPPXQLW
ZKRFRPHDIWHURX
+H VDLG 'RHVQ
W D PDQ ZKR KDV KRUVHV ZLWK ...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
ZLWKZKLWHPDUNVRQWKHLUIRUHKHDGVKDQGVDQGIHHWIURPZXGXDQG,ZLOOSUHFHGHWKHP
WR WKH +DZG 6RPH PHQ ZLOO EH...
ZKHQWKHPXD]K]KLQFDPHDQGWROGKLPWKDWLW
ZDVWLPHIRUWKHDVUSUDHU+HFDOOHGIRUZDWHUDQGGLGZXGX7KHQKHVDLG%$OODK,
VKDOOWHOORXVRPHWKLQJ...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP=DGLEQ$VODPIURP$WDLEQDVDUIURP$EGXOODK
DV6DQDELKLWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVK...
GRHV ZXGX DQG DV KH ZDVKHV KLV IDFH HYHU ZURQJ
DFWLRQKHKDVVHHQZLWKKLVHHVOHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHURUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
$VKH
ZDVKHVKLVKDQGVHYHUZURQJDFWLRQKHKDVGRQHZLWKKLVKDQGVOHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHU
RUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
$QGDVKHZDVKHVKLVIHHWHYHUZURQJDFWLRQKLVIHHWKDYH
ZDONHGWROHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHURUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
VRWKDWKHFRPHVDZDSXULILHG
RIZURQJDFWLRQV
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,VKDTLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ$EL7DOKDWKDW$QDVLEQ
0DOLN...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
WROGWKHPDOOWRGRZXGXIURPLW$QDVDGGHG,VDZZDWHUFRPLQJRXWIURPKLVILQJHUV
7KHQDOORIWKHPWRWKHODVWPDQGLGZXG...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP$EEDGLEQ=LDGDGHVFHQGDQWRI
DO0XJKLUDLEQ6KXEDIURP...
ULWXDOOSXULILHGEZXGXFDQZLSHRYHUWKHP
6RPHRQH ZKR SXWV RQ OHDWKHU VRFNV ZKHQ KLV IHHW DUH QRW ULWXDOO SXULILHG E ZXGX
VKRXOG...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGDERXWDPDQZKRGLGZXGXZLWKKLVOHDWKHUVRFNVRQ
DQGIRUJRWWRZLSHRYHUWKHPXQWLOWKHZD...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
ZRNHQKLPXSIRUWKHVXEKSUDHUDQG8PDUKDGVDLG

HV:KRHYHUVWRSVGRLQJWKH
SUDHUZLOOJHWQRWKLQJIURP,VODPDQG KH...
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG7KDWLVZKDW,OLNHPRVWRXWRIZKDW,KDYHKHDUGDERXWWKH
PDWWHU
6HFWLRQ:XGXRQ$FFRXQWRI3URVWDWLF)OXLG
%RRN1XPEHU
...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
WRXFKRXUSHQLV
8UZDVDLG
,GLGQ
WNQRZWKDW
0DUZDQLEQDO+DNDPVDLGWKDW%XVUD
ELQW6DIZDQKDGWROGKLPWKDWVKHKH...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
%RRN 1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP8UZDLEQD]=XEDUIURP$
LVKD
XPPDOPXPLQLQWKDWWKH0H...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHG WRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVD:KHQ
WKHFLUFXPFLVHGSDUWSDVVHVWKHFLUFXPF...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EGXOODKLEQ'LQDUWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUUHODWHG
WKDW8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEPHQWLRQHGWRWKH0HVVHQJ...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
-XUXIDQGIRXQGVHPHQRQKLVFORWKHV+HVDLG6LQFHZHKDYHEHHQHDWLQJULFKPHDWRXU
YHLQVKDYHEHFRPHIXOVRPH+HGLGJK...
7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVV
KLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLGWRKHU0DRXUULJKWKDQGEHIXOORIGXVW)URPZKHUH
GRHVIDPLOUHVHPEODQFHFRPH
%...
%RRN1XPEHU
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVZHDWLQD
JDUPHQWZKLOHKHZDVMXQXEDQGWKHQSUDZ...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLGWKDWDPDQZKRGLGWDDPPXPEHFDXVHKHFRXOGQRWILQGDQ
ZDWHUDQGWKHQVWRRGDQGVDLGWKHWDNELU...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
SHUPLWWHGPHIURPPZLIHZKHQVKHLVPHQVWUXDWLQJ7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD
$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG/H...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG7KDWLVZKDWLVGRQHLQRXUFRPPXQLW
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG7KHSRVLWLRQZLWKXVLVWKDWZKHQDZRPDQZKREOHHGVDVLI
PHQVWUXDWLQJVWDUWVWRGRWKHSUDHUD...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP,EQDV6DEEDTWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHU
RI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLGL...
VRGRJKXVODQGLWZLOOQRWKDUPZKRHYHUKDVSHUIXPHWR
DSSOVRPHRILWDQGXVHDWRRWKVWLFN
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EX
]=LQD...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
, ZRXOG EH RYHUEXUGHQLQJ P FRPPXQLW , ZRXOG KDYH RUGHUHG WKHP WR XVH D WRRWK
VWLFN
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDU...
ZRXOG KDYH
RUGHUHGWKHPWRXVHDWRRWKVWLFNZLWKHDFKZXGX
%RRN3UDHU
6HFWLRQ7KHDOOWR3UDHU
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWDK...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
PDQRUDQWKLQJZLWKLQUDQJHKHDUVWKHYRLFHRIWKHPXD]K]KLQH[FHSWWKDWLWEHDUVZLWQHVV
IRUKLPRQWKHGDRIULVLQJ

...
FDSDFLWIRU
VRPHSHRSOHDUHKHDYDQGVRPHDUHOLJKWDQGWKHDUHQRWDEOHWREHDVRQHPDQ
0DOLN ZDV DVNHG DERXW D JDWKHULQJ RI SHRSOH ZKR ZL...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWKHKDGKHDUGWKDWWKHPXD]K]KLQFDPHWR8PDULEQ
DO.KDWWDEWRFDOOKLPWRWKHVXEKSUDH...
GRLQJH[FHSW
WKHFDOOWRSUDHU
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUKHDUGWKHLTDPDZKLOHKHZDVLQ
%DTLVRKHLQFUHDVH...
LQ5HODWLRQWRWKH$]KDQ
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EGXOODKLEQ'LQDUIURP$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUWKDW
WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$O...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
%RRN1XPEHU
DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP ,EQ 6KLKDE IURP 6DOLP LEQ $EGXOODK IURP
$EGXOODK LEQ ...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
0DOLNVDLGDERXWDQLPDPZKRIRUJRWWKHRSHQLQJWDNELUXQWLOKHKDGILQLVKHG KLVSUDHU
,WKLQNWKDWKHVKRXOGGRWKHSU...
LQWKHPDJKULESUDHU
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP8EDGXOODKLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ8WED
LEQ0DVXGIURP$EGXOODKLEQ$E...
DQGVKHVDLGWRKLP0VRQRXKDYHUHPLQGHGPHEUHFLWLQJ
WKLVVXUDWKDWLWZDVZKDW,ODVWKHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQG
JUDQWKLP...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRUHFLWHLQDOO
IRXUUDNDVDVZKHQKHSUDHGDORQH LQHYHUUDNDWKHXP...
LQLW
6HFWLRQ%HKDYLRXULQWKH5HFLWDWLRQ
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLN IURP1DILIURP,EUDKLPLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ+XQDQIURP
KLVIDWK...
ZHDULQJJROGULQJVDQGUHFLWLQJ WKH4XU
DQLQUXNX
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPDKDLEQ6DLGIURP0XKDPPDGLEQ,EUDKLPLEQ
DO+D...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
WDONLQJFRQILGHQWLDOOWRRXU/RUG6RORRNWRZKDWRXFRQILGHWR+LPDQGGRQRWVD
WKH4XU
DQRXWORXGVRWKDWRWKHUVKHDU...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDWZKHQ$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUPLVVHGDQWKLQJ
RIWKHSUDHULQZKLFKWKHLPDPUHFLWHGRXWORXGKHZRX...
DQG VXUDW DO+DMM 6XUD
VORZO,+LVKDP
VIDWKHU
VDLG%
$OODK WKHQ LW PXVW KDYH EHHQ KLV KDELW WR JHW XS DW WKH FUDFN RI GDZQ +HVDLG2I
FRXUVH
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0...
IURPWKHUHFLWDWLRQRILWE8WKPDQLEQ$IIDQLQWKHVXEKSUDHU
EHFDXVHRIWKHJUHDWQXPEHURIWLPHVKHUHSHDWHGLWWRXV
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRP...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
JUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG,KRSHWKDWRXZLOOQRWOHDYHWKHPRVTXHXQWLORXNQRZDVXUD
ZKRVH OLNH $OODK KDV QRWVHQWGRZQ...
XQWLO,FDPHWRWKHHQGRILWDQGWKH0HVVHQJHURI
$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG
,WLVWKLVVXUDDQGLWLVWKHVHYHQ
RIWUHSHDWHGDQ...
KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
RIWKHLPDPLVHQRXJKIRURXDQGZKHQRXSUDRQRXURZQRXPXVWUHFLWH1DIL
DGGHG$EGXOODKLEQ
8PDUXVHGQRWWRUHFLWHEHK...
%RRN1XPEHU
DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP6XPDWKHPDZODRI$EX%DNUIURP$EX6DOLK
DV6DPPDQIURP$EX+XUDUDWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OOD...
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)
Nächste SlideShare
Wird geladen in …5
×

Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)

111 Aufrufe

Veröffentlicht am

Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik

Veröffentlicht in: Seele & Geist
0 Kommentare
0 Gefällt mir
Statistik
Notizen
  • Als Erste(r) kommentieren

  • Gehören Sie zu den Ersten, denen das gefällt!

Keine Downloads
Aufrufe
Aufrufe insgesamt
111
Auf SlideShare
0
Aus Einbettungen
0
Anzahl an Einbettungen
2
Aktionen
Geteilt
0
Downloads
0
Kommentare
0
Gefällt mir
0
Einbettungen 0
Keine Einbettungen

Keine Notizen für die Folie

Compilation of authentic hadith by imam malik (al muwatta)

  1. 1. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 0DDOLN V0XZDWWD $87+25 7DUMXPDQDDQG-RKQVRQ ,QWURGXFWLRQWR7UDQVODWLRQRI0DOLN V0XZDWWD 7UDQVODWRUVC$ LVKDC$EGDUDKPDQDW7DUMXPDQDDQGDCTXE-RKQVRQ 0DOLN V0XZDWWDWKHZHOOWURGGHQSDWK
  2. 2. LVDFROOHFWLRQRIWZRLWHPV WKHVDLQJVDQGGHHGVRI3URSKHW0XKDPPDGSEXK
  3. 3. DOVRNQRZQDVWKHVXQQDK
  4. 4. 7KH UHSRUWVRIWKH3URSKHW VVDLQJVDQGGHHGVDUHFDOOHGDKDGLWK WKH OHJDO RSLQLRQV DQG GHFLVLRQV RI WKH 3URSKHW V RPSDQLRQV WKHLU VXFFHVVRUV DQG VRPHODWHUDXWKRULWLHV 0DOLNIXOOQDPH 0DOLNELQ$QDVELQ0DOLNELQ$EX$PLU$O$VEDKL
  5. 5. ZDVERUQLQ $+DQGGLHGLQ$++HOLYHGPRVWRIKLVOLIHLQ0DGLQDKWKHFLWLQZKLFKWKH 3URSKHWSEXK
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
  7. 7. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 8UZDVDLGWKDW$ LVKDWKHZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFH XVHGWRSUDDVUZKLOHWKHVXQOLJKWZDVSRXULQJLQWRKHUURRPEHIRUHWKHVXQLWVHOIKDG EHFRPHYLVLEOHLHEHFDXVHLWZDVVWLOOKLJKLQWKHVN
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
  9. 9. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP WRSUDVXEKZKHQWKHVWDUVZHUHDOOYLVLEOHDQGOLNHDKD]HLQWKHVNDQGWRUHDGLQLWWZR ORQJVXUDVIURPWKHPXIDVVDO %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUWKDW8PDULEQDO .KDWWDEZURWHWR$EX0XVDDO$VKDULWKDWKHVKRXOGSUDDVUZKHQWKHVXQZDVVWLOOSXUH ZKLWHVRWKDWDPDQFRXOGULGHWKUHHIDUVDNKVEHIRUHPDJKULE
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
  11. 11. 6HFWLRQ7KH7LPHRIWKH-XPXD3UDHU %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPKLVXQFOH$EX6XKDOLEQ0DOLNWKDWKLVIDWKHUVDLG ,XVHGWRVHHDFDUSHWEHORQJLQJWR$TLOLEQ$EL7DOLEVSUHDGRXWRQWKHGDRIMXPXDXS WRWKHZHVWZDOORIWKHPRVTXH:KHQWKHVKDGRZRIWKHZDOOFRYHUHGWKHZKROHFDUSHW 8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEZRXOGFRPHRXWDQGSUDWKHMXPXDSUDHU 0DOLN$EX6XKDO VIDWKHUDGGHG:HZRXOGWKHQUHWXUQDIWHUWKHMXPXDSUDHUDQGWDNH RXUPLGGDVOHHS %RRN1XPEHU
  12. 12. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$PULEQDKDLEQDKDDO0D]LQLIURP,EQ$EL 6DOLWWKDW8WKPDQLEQ$IIDQSUDHGMXPXDLQ0DGLQDDQGDVULQ0DODODSODFHVHYHQWHHQ PLOHVIURP0DGLQD
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
  15. 15. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP LQWKHSUDHU1RWLFLQJWKHLUXQHDVLQHVVKHZHQWWRWKHPDQGVDLG 2SHRSOH$OODKVHL]HG RXUVSLULWVDUZDK
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
  18. 18. %RRN1XPEHU DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGDERXWZKDWDPDQVKRXOGGRLIKHKDGIRUJRWWHQWRULQVH KLVPRXWKDQGQRVHXQWLOKHKDGSUDHGDQGKHVDLG+HGRHVQRWKDYHWRUHSHDWWKH SUDHUEXWVKRXOGULQVHKLVPRXWKDQGQRVHLIKHZLVKHVWRGRDQPRUHSUDHUVDIWHU WKDW 6HFWLRQ7KH:XGXRID0DQZKRKDVEHHQ$VOHHSZKHQKH*HWV8SWR3UD
  19. 19. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EX ]=LQDGIURPDO$UDMIURP$EX+XUDUDWKDW WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG:KHQRXZDNH XSIURPVOHHSWRSUDZDVKRXUKDQGVEHIRUHRXSXWWKHPLQWKHZXGXZDWHUIRURX GRQRWNQRZZKHUHRXUKDQGVKDYHVSHQWWKHQLJKW %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP=DGLEQ$VODPWKDW8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEVDLG,I RXIDOODVOHHS,LQJGRZQRXPXVWGRZXGXEHIRUHRXSUD
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
  21. 21. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVDWKDWPHQ DQGWKHLUZLYHVXVHGWRGRZXGXWRJHWKHULQWKHWLPHRIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 6HFWLRQ7KLQJVZKLFKGRQRWEUHDN:XGX %RRN1XPEHU DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP 0XKDPPDG LEQ 8PDUD IURP 0XKDPPDG LEQ ,EUDKLPWKDWWKHPRWKHURIWKHVRQRI,EUDKLPLEQ$EGDU5DKPDQLEQ$ZITXHVWLRQHG 8PP6DODPDWKHZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHDQG VDLG , DP D ZRPDQ ZKR ZHDUV D ORQJ VNLUW DQG VRPHWLPHV
  22. 22. , ZDON LQ GLUWSODFHV 8PP 6DODPD UHSOLHG 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFHVDLG :KDWIROORZVLHFOHDQSODFHV
  23. 23. SXULILHVLW %RRN1XPEHU DKD UHODWHG WRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWKHVDZ5DELDLEQ$EGDU5DKPDQYRPLWVHYHUDO WLPHVZKHQKHZDVLQWKHPRVTXHDQGKHGLGQRWOHDYHQRUGLGKHGRZXGXEHIRUHKH SUDHG DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGZKHWKHUDPDQZKRYRPLWHGIRRGKDGWRGRZXGXDQG KHVDLG+HGRHVQRWKDYHWRGRZXGXEXWKHVKRXOGULQVHWKHLQVLGHRIKLVPRXWKDQG ZDVKKLVPRXWKRXW %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUSUHSDUHGWKHERGRI RQHRI6DLGLEQ=DG VVRQVIRUEXULDODQGFDUULHGLWDQGWKHQHQWHUHGWKHPRVTXHDQG SUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX DKD VDLG WKDW 0DOLN ZDV DVNHG ZKHWKHU LW ZDV QHFHVVDU WR GR ZXGX EHFDXVH RI UHJXUJLWDWLQJ XQGLJHVWHG IRRG DQG KH VDLG 1R ZXGX LV QRW QHFHVVDU EXW WKH PRXWK VKRXOGEHULQVHG 6HFWLRQ'LVFRQWLQXLQJ'RLQJ:XGXRQ$FFRXQWRI(DWLQJRRNHG)RRG %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP=DG$VODPIURP$WDLEQDVDUIURP$EGXOODK $EEDV WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH DWH D VKRXOGHURIODPEDQGWKHQSUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPDKDLEQ6DLGIURP%XVKDULEQDVDUWKHPDZOD RIWKH%DQL+DULWKDWKDW6XZDGLEQDQ1XPDQWROGKLPWKDWKHZHQWZLWKWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVV KLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHRQWKHH[SHGLWLRQWR.KDEDU:KHQ WKHUHDFKHGDV6XKEDZKLFKZDVQHDU.KDEDUWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH VWRSSHG DQG SUDHG DVU +H DVNHG IRU SURYLVLRQV EXW RQO SDUFKHGEDUOHZDVEURXJKWVRKHDVNHGIRULWWREHPRLVWHQHG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK PD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHDWHDQGWKHSHRSOHDWHZLWKKLP7KHQKHJRW XSWRGRPDJKULEDQGULQVHGKLVPRXWKRXWDQGWKHULQVHGRXWWKHLUV7KHQKHSUDHG ZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWERWK0XKDPPDGLEQDO0XQNDGLUDQG6DIZDQLEQ 6XODP WUDQVPLWWHG WR KLP IURP 0XKDPPDG LEQ ,EUDKLP LEQ DO+DULWK DW7DPL IURP 5DELDLEQ$EGXOODKLEQDO+XGDUWKDWKHKDGHDWHQDQHYHQLQJPHDOZLWK8PDULEQDO .KDWWDEZKRWKHQSUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX %RRN1XPEHU
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
  26. 26. 7KHDVNHGKLP 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK+RZZLOORXUHFRJQLVHWKRVHRIRXUFRPPXQLW ZKRFRPHDIWHURX +H VDLG 'RHVQ W D PDQ ZKR KDV KRUVHV ZLWK ZKLWH OHJV DQG ZKLWH EOD]HV RQ WKHLU IRUHKHDGVDPRQJWRWDOOEODFNKRUVHVUHFRJQLVHZKLFKRQHVDUHKLVRZQ7KHVDLG2I FRXUVH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK+HZHQWRQ(YHQVRZLOOWKHFRPHRQWKHGDRIULVLQJ
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
  30. 30. GRHV ZXGX DQG DV KH ZDVKHV KLV IDFH HYHU ZURQJ DFWLRQKHKDVVHHQZLWKKLVHHVOHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHURUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
  31. 31. $VKH ZDVKHVKLVKDQGVHYHUZURQJDFWLRQKHKDVGRQHZLWKKLVKDQGVOHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHU RUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
  32. 32. $QGDVKHZDVKHVKLVIHHWHYHUZURQJDFWLRQKLVIHHWKDYH ZDONHGWROHDYHVZLWKWKHZDWHURUWKHODVWGURSRIZDWHU
  33. 33. VRWKDWKHFRPHVDZDSXULILHG RIZURQJDFWLRQV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,VKDTLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ$EL7DOKDWKDW$QDVLEQ 0DOLNVDLG,VDZWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHRQ RQHRFFDVLRQZKHQWKHDVUSUDHUZDVDWKDQG(YHURQHZDVORRNLQJIRUZDWHUIRUZXGX EXWQRRQHFRXOGILQGDQ7KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQW KLPSHDFHEURXJKWVRPHZDWHULQDYHVVHO+HSXWKLVKDQGLQWRWKHYHVVHODQGWKHQKH
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
  36. 36. ULWXDOOSXULILHGEZXGXFDQZLSHRYHUWKHP 6RPHRQH ZKR SXWV RQ OHDWKHU VRFNV ZKHQ KLV IHHW DUH QRW ULWXDOO SXULILHG E ZXGX VKRXOGQRWZLSHRYHUWKHP
  37. 37. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGDERXWDPDQZKRGLGZXGXZLWKKLVOHDWKHUVRFNVRQ DQGIRUJRWWRZLSHRYHUWKHPXQWLOWKHZDWHUZDVGUDQGKHKDGSUDHGDQGKHVDLG+H VKRXOGZLSHRYHUKLVVRFNVDQGUHSHDWWKHSUDHUEXWQRWUHSHDWZXGX 0DOLNZDVDVNHGDERXWDPDQZKRZDVKHGKLVIHHWDQGSXWRQKLVOHDWKHUVRFNVDQGWKHQ VWDUWHGGRLQJZXGXDQGKHVDLG+HVKRXOGWDNHRIIKLVVRFNVDQGGRZXGXDQGZDVKKLV IHHW 6HFWLRQ+RZWR:LSHRYHU/HDWKHU6RFNV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDWKDWKHVDZKLVIDWKHUZLSLQJ RYHUKLVOHDWKHUVRFNV+HVDLG:KHQKHZLSHGRYHUKLVVRFNVKHZRXOGQHYHUGRPRUH WKDQZLSHWKHWRSVDQGKHZRXOGQRWZLSHWKHERWWRPV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHWKDW0DOLNKDGDVNHG,EQ6KLKDEKRZWRZLSHRYHUOHDWKHUVRFNV,EQ 6KLKDE KDG SXW RQH KDQG XQGHU WKH VRFN DQG KLV RWKHU KDQG DERYH WKH VRFN DQG WKHQ SDVVHGWKHPRYHULW DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG2XWRIDOOWKDW,KDYHKHDUGDERXWWKHPDWWHU,OLNHZKDW,EQ 6KLKDEVDLGWKHPRVW 6HFWLRQ1RVH%OHHGV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUZRXOGOHDYHDQGGR ZXGX LI KH KDG D QRVHEOHHG DQG WKHQ UHWXUQ DQG FRPSOHWH KLV SUDHU ZLWKRXW VDLQJ DQWKLQJ 6HFWLRQ+RZWR:LSHRYHU/HDWKHU6RFNV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ$EEDVXVHGWRKDYHQRVH EOHHGVDQGZRXOGOHDYHWRZDVKRIIWKHEORRG+HZRXOGWKHQUHWXUQDQGFRPSOHWHKLV SUDHU %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPD]LGLEQ$EGXOODK4XVDWDO/DWKLWKDWKHVDZ 6DLG LEQ DO0XVDDE KDYLQJ D QRVHEOHHG ZKLOH SUDLQJ +H ZHQW RII WR WKH URRP RI 8PP6DODPDWKHZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHDQG ZDWHUZDVEURXJKWWRKLPDQGKHGLGZXGX+HWKHQUHWXUQHGDQGFRPSOHWHGKLVSUDHU 6HFWLRQ:KDWWR'RLQWKH(YHQWRID1RVH%OHHG %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHWKDW$EGDU5DKPDQLEQ+DUPDODDO$VODPLVDLG,VDZ6DLGLEQDO 0XVDDEZLWKKLVQRVHEOHHGLQJDQGEORRGSRXUHGRXWRILWVRWKDWKLVILQJHUVZHUHDOO UHGIURPWKHEORRGFRPLQJRXWRIKLVQRVHDQGKHSUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EGDU5DKPDQLEQDO0XMDEEDUWKDWKHVDZ6DOLP LEQ$EGXOODKZLWKEORRGUXQQLQJIURPKLVQRVHVRWKDWKLVILQJHUVZHUHDOOFRORXUHGUHG 7KHQKHUXEEHGLWDQGSUDHGZLWKRXWGRLQJZXGX 6HFWLRQ:KDWWR'RLQWKH(YHQWRI%OHHGLQJIURPD:RXQGRUD1RVH%OHHG %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUWKDWDO0LVZDULEQ0DNKUDPD WROGKLPWKDWKHKDGYLVLWHG8PDULEQDO.KDWWDERQWKHQLJKWKHZDVVWDEEHGDQGKDG
  38. 38. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP ZRNHQKLPXSIRUWKHVXEKSUDHUDQG8PDUKDGVDLG HV:KRHYHUVWRSVGRLQJWKH SUDHUZLOOJHWQRWKLQJIURP,VODPDQG KHGLGWKHSUDHUZLWKEORRGSRXULQJIURPKLV ZRXQG %RRN1XPEHU DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP DKD LEQ 6DLG WKDW6DLGLEQDO0XVDDEZDV DVNHG:KDWGRRXVDDERXWVRPHRQHZKRLVDIIOLFWHGEDQRVHEOHHGZKLFKGRHVQRW VWRS0DOLNVDLGWKDWDKDLEQ6DLGVDLGWKDW6DLGLEQDO0XVDDEVDLG,VDWKDWKH VKRXOGVLJQDOZLWKKLVKHDGLHLQVWHDGRIGRLQJVDMGDRUUXNX
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
  42. 42. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDUHODWHG WRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVD:KHQ WKHFLUFXPFLVHGSDUWSDVVHVWKHFLUFXPFLVHGSDUWJKXVOLVREOLJDWRU 6HFWLRQ:XGXRID3HUVRQLQD6WDWHRI0DMRU5LWXDO,PSXULW-DQDED
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
  44. 44. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP -XUXIDQGIRXQGVHPHQRQKLVFORWKHV+HVDLG6LQFHZHKDYHEHHQHDWLQJULFKPHDWRXU YHLQVKDYHEHFRPHIXOVRPH+HGLGJKXVOZDVKHGWKHVHPHQIURPKLVFORWKLQJDQGGLG KLVSUDHUDJDLQ %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUIURPDKDLEQ $EGDU5DKPDQLEQ+D LEWKDWKHKDGVHWRIIIRU0XPUDZLWK8PDULEQDO.KDWWDELQD SDUWRIULGHUVDPRQJZKRPZDV$PULEQDO$V8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEGLVPRXQWHGIRUD UHVWODWHDWQLJKWRQDFHUWDLQURDGQHDUDFHUWDLQRDVLV8PDUKDGDZHWGUHDPZKHQLWZDV DOPRVWGDZQDQGWKHUHZDVQRZDWHUDPRQJWKHULGLQJSDUW+HURGHXQWLOKHFDPHWR VRPHZDWHUDQGWKHQKHEHJDQWRZDVKRIIZKDWKHVDZRIWKHVHPHQXQWLOLWKDGJRQH $PULEQDO$VVDLGWRKLP,WLVPRUQLQJDQGWKHUHDUHFORWKHVZLWKXVVRDOORZRXU JDUPHQWWREHZDVKHG 8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEVDLGWRKLP,DPVXUSULVHGDWRX$PULEQ DO$V(YHQLIRXFRXOGILQGFORWKHVZRXOGHYHUERGEHDEOHWRILQGWKHP%$OODKLI ,ZHUHWRGRLWLWZRXOGEHFRPHDVXQQD1R,ZDVKZKDW,VHHDQG,VSULQNOHZLWKZDWHU ZKDW,GRQRWVHH 0DOLNVSRNHDERXWDPDQZKRIRXQGWUDFHVRIDZHWGUHDPRQKLVFORWKHVDQGGLGQRW NQRZZKHQLWKDGRFFXUUHGDQGGLGQRWUHPHPEHUDQWKLQJKHKDGVHHQLQKLVVOHHS+H VDLG/HWWKHLQWHQWLRQRIKLVJKXVOEHIURPWKHWLPHZKHQKHODVWVOHSWDQGLIKHKDV SUDHGVLQFHWKDWODVWVOHHSKHVKRXOGUHSHDWLW7KLVLVEHFDXVHRIWHQDPDQKDVDZHW GUHDPDQGVHHVQRWKLQJDQGRIWHQKHVHHVVRPHWKLQJEXWGRHVQRWKDYHDQHPLVVLRQ%XW LIKHILQGVOLTXLGRQKLVJDUPHQWKHPXVWGRJKXVO7KLVLVEHFDXVH8PDUUHSHDWHGZKDWKH KDGSUDHGDIWHUWKHWLPHKHKDGODVWVOHSWDQGQRWZKDWZDVEHIRUHLW 6HFWLRQ*KXVORID:RPDQZKHQ6KH([SHULHQFHVWKH6DPHDVD0DQLQ+HU6OHHS %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP8UZDLEQD]=XEDUWKDW8PP 6XODPDQ VDLG WR WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH 6KRXOGDZRPDQGRJKXVOZKHQVKHH[SHULHQFHVWKHVDPHDVDPDQLQKHUVOHHS7KH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKVDLGWRKHUHVVKHVKRXOGGRJKXVO$ LVKDVDLGWRKHU6KDPH RQRX'RHVDZRPDQVHHWKDWLHDOLTXLG
  45. 45. 7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVV KLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLGWRKHU0DRXUULJKWKDQGEHIXOORIGXVW)URPZKHUH GRHVIDPLOUHVHPEODQFHFRPH %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUIURP=DQDEELQW $EL6DODPDWKDW8PP6DODPDWKHZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQW KLPSHDFHVDLG8PP6DODPDWKHZLIHRI$EX7DOKDDO$QVDULFDPHWRWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHDQGVDLG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK$OODK LV QRW DVKDPHG RI WKH WUXWKGRHV D ZRPDQ KDYH WR GR JKXVO LI VKH KDV KDG DQ HURWLF GUHDP +HVDLG HVLIVKHVHHVDQOLTXLG 6HFWLRQ*KXVOIRU0DMRU5LWXDO,PSXULW %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVD7KHUHLV QRKDUPLQGRLQJJKXVOZLWKZDWHUWKDWKDVEHHQXVHGERQH VZLIHDVORQJDVVKHLVQRW PHQVWUXDWLQJRULQDVWDWHRIPDMRUULWXDOLPSXULWMXQXE
  46. 46. %RRN1XPEHU
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
  51. 51. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG7KHSRVLWLRQZLWKXVLVWKDWZKHQDZRPDQZKREOHHGVDVLI PHQVWUXDWLQJVWDUWVWRGRWKHSUDHUDJDLQKHUKXVEDQGFDQKDYHVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVHZLWK KHU6LPLODUOLIDZRPDQZKRKDVJLYHQELUWKVHHVEORRGDIWHUVKHKDVUHDFKHGWKHIXOOHVW H[WHQWWKDWEOHHGLQJQRUPDOOUHVWUDLQVZRPHQKHUKXVEDQGFDQKDYH VH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH ZLWKKHUDQGVKHLVLQWKHVDPHSRVLWLRQDVDZRPDQZKREOHHGVDVLIPHQVWUXDWLQJ DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNVDLG7KHSRVLWLRQZLWKXVFRQFHUQLQJDZRPDQZKREOHHGVDVLI PHQVWUXDWLQJLVIRXQGHGRQWKHKDGLWKRI+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLV IDWKHUDQGLWLVZKDW ,SUHIHUWKHPRVWRIZKDW,KDYHKHDUGDERXWWKHPDWWHU 6HFWLRQ7KH8ULQHRIDQ,QIDQW%R %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUWKDW$ LVKDWKH ZLIHRIWKH3URSKHWPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG$QLQIDQWERZDV EURXJKW WR WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH DQG LW XULQDWHG RQ KLP 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH FDOOHGIRUVRPHZDWHUDQG UXEEHGRYHUWKHXULQHZLWKLW %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP8EDGXOODKLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ8WED LEQ0DVXGIURP8PP4DVLEQ0LKVDQWKDWVKHEURXJKWDEDEERRIKHUVZKRZDVQRW HWHDWLQJIRRGWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHDQG KHVDWLWLQKLVDUPVDQGLWXULQDWHGRQKLVJDUPHQWVRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODK EOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHFDOOHGIRUVRPHZDWHUDQGVSULQNOHGRYHULWEXWGLGQRW ZDVKLW 6HFWLRQ 8ULQDWLQJ6WDQGLQJDQG2WKHUZLVH %RRN1XPEHU DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN WKDW DKD LEQ 6DLG VDLG $ %HGRXLQ FDPH LQWR WKH PRVTXH DQG XQFRYHUHG KLV SULYDWH SDUWV WR XULQDWH 7KH SHRSOH FDOOHG RXW WR KLP DQG EHJDQWRUDLVHWKHLUYRLFHVEXWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQW KLPSHDFHVDLG OHWKLPEH 6RWKHOHWKLPEHDQGKHXULQDWHG7KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH RUGHUHG D EXFNHWIXO RI ZDWHU WR EH EURXJKWDQGLWZDVSRXUHGRQWKHSODFH %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ'LQDUVDLG,VDZ$EGXOODKLEQ8PDU XULQDWLQJZKLOHVWDQGLQJ DKDVDLGWKDW0DOLNZDVDVNHGLIDQKDGLWKKDGFRPHGRZQDERXWZDVKLQJWKHSULYDWH SDUWVRIXULQHDQGIDHFHVDQGKHVDLG,KDYHKHDUGWKDWVRPHRIWKRVHZKRKDYHSDVVHG DZDXVHGWRZDVKWKHPVHOYHVRIIDHFHV,OLNHWRZDVKPSULYDWHSDUWVRIXULQH 6HFWLRQ7KH7RRWKVWLFN6LZDN
  52. 52. %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP,EQDV6DEEDTWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLGLQDMXPXD0XVOLPV$OODKKDV PDGHWKLVGDDIHVWLYDOGDLG
  53. 53. VRGRJKXVODQGLWZLOOQRWKDUPZKRHYHUKDVSHUIXPHWR DSSOVRPHRILWDQGXVHDWRRWKVWLFN %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP$EX ]=LQDGIURPDO$UDMIURP$EX+XUDUDWKDW WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG:HUHLWQRWWKDW
  54. 54. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP , ZRXOG EH RYHUEXUGHQLQJ P FRPPXQLW , ZRXOG KDYH RUGHUHG WKHP WR XVH D WRRWK VWLFN %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP+XPDGLEQ$EGDU5DKPDQLEQ $ZIWKDW$EX+XUDUDVDLG:HUHLWQRWWKDWKHZRXOGEHRYHUEXUGHQLQJKLVFRPPXQLW KH WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK PD $OODK EOHVV KLP DQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH
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
  58. 58. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWKHKDGKHDUGWKDWWKHPXD]K]KLQFDPHWR8PDULEQ DO.KDWWDEWRFDOOKLPWRWKHVXEKSUDHUDQGIRXQGKLPVOHHSLQJVRKHVDLG3UDHULV EHWWHUWKDQVOHHSDQG8PDURUGHUHGKLPWRSXWWKDWLQWKHD]KDQIRUVXEK %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPKLVSDWHUQDOXQFOH$EX6XKDOLEQ0DOLNWKDWKLV XQFOH V IDWKHU VDLG , UHFRJQLVH QRWKLQJ QRZDGDV RI ZKDW , VDZ WKH SHRSOH LH WKH FRPSDQLRQVRIWKH0HVVHQJHUPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFH
  59. 59. GRLQJH[FHSW WKHFDOOWRSUDHU %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUKHDUGWKHLTDPDZKLOHKHZDVLQ %DTLVRKHLQFUHDVHGKLVSDFHRIZDONLQJWRWKHPRVTXH 6HFWLRQ7KH$]KDQ'XULQJD-RXUQHDQG:LWKRXW:XGX %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUFDOOHGWKHD]KDQRQD FROGDQGZLQGQLJKWDQGLQFOXGHGWKHSKUDVH'RWKHSUDHULQVKHOWHU7KHQKHVDLG 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHXVHGWRRUGHUWKH PXD]K]KLQWRVD 'RWKHSUDHULQVKHOWHU ZKHQLWZDVDFROGUDLQQLJKW %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDWRQDMRXUQH$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUGLGQR PRUH WKDQ WKH LTDPD H[FHSW IRU VXEK ZKHQ KH FDOOHG ERWK WKH D]KDQ DQG WKH LTDPD $EGXOODKLEQ8PDUXVHGWRVD7KHD]KDQLVIRUDQLPDPZKRPSHRSOHMRLQ %RRN1XPEHU DKD UHODWHG WR PH IURP 0DOLN IURP +LVKDP LEQ 8UZD WKDW KLV IDWKHU VDLG WR KLP :KHQRXDUHRQDMRXUQHRXFDQLIRXZLVKFDOOWKHD]KDQDQGWKHLTDPDRULIRX ZLVKWKHLTDPDDQGQRWWKHD]KDQ DKDVDLGWKDWKHKHDUG0DOLNVD7KHUHLVQRKDUPLQDPDQFDOOLQJWKHD]KDQZKLOH ULGLQJ %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPDKDLEQ6DLGWKDW6DLGLEQDO0XVDDEXVHGWR VD:KRHYHUSUDVRQZDWHUOHVVGHVRODWHODQG DQDQJHOSUDVRQKLVULJKWDQGDQDQJHO SUDVRQKLVOHIW:KHQKHFDOOVERWKWKHD]KDQDQGWKHLTDPDIRUWKHSUDHURUFDOOVRXW WKHLTDPDDQJHOVOLNHPRXQWDLQVSUDEHKLQGKLP 6HFWLRQ7KH'XUDWLRQRIWKH0HDOEHIRUH'DZQ6DKXU
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
  62. 62. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 0DOLNVDLGDERXWDQLPDPZKRIRUJRWWKHRSHQLQJWDNELUXQWLOKHKDGILQLVKHG KLVSUDHU ,WKLQNWKDWKHVKRXOGGRWKHSUDHUDJDLQDQGWKRVHEHKLQGKLPHYHQLIWKHKDYHVDLG WKHWDNELU 6HFWLRQ7KH5HFLWDWLRQRI4XU DQLQWKH0DJKULEDQGOVKD3UDHUV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP0XKDPPDGLEQ-XEDULEQ0XWLP WKDWKLVIDWKHUVDLG,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLP SHDFHUHFLWHDW7XU6XUD
  63. 63. LQWKHPDJKULESUDHU %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP,EQ6KLKDEIURP8EDGXOODKLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ8WED LEQ0DVXGIURP$EGXOODKLEQ$EEDVWKDW8PPDO)DGOELQWDO+DULWKKHDUGKLPUHFLWLQJ DO0XUVDODWVXUD
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
  66. 66. LQLW 6HFWLRQ%HKDYLRXULQWKH5HFLWDWLRQ %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLN IURP1DILIURP,EUDKLPLEQ$EGXOODKLEQ+XQDQIURP KLVIDWKHUIURP$OLLEQ$EL7DOLEWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQG JUDQW KLP SHDFH IRUEDGH ZHDULQJ WKH TDVVL DQ (JSWLDQ JDUPHQW VWULSHG ZLWK VLON
  67. 67. ZHDULQJJROGULQJVDQGUHFLWLQJ WKH4XU DQLQUXNX %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPDKDLEQ6DLGIURP0XKDPPDGLEQ,EUDKLPLEQ DO+DULWKDW7DPLIURP$EX+D]LPDW7DPPDUIURPDO%DDGLWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI $OODKPD$OODKEOHVVKLPDQGJUDQWKLPSHDFHFDPHRXWWRWKHSHRSOHZKLOHWKHZHUH SUDLQJDQGWKHLUYRLFHVZHUHUDLVHGLQWKHUHFLWDWLRQ+HVDLG:KHQRXSUDRXDUH
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
  69. 69. %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP1DILWKDWZKHQ$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUPLVVHGDQWKLQJ RIWKHSUDHULQZKLFKWKHLPDPUHFLWHGRXWORXGKHZRXOGVWDQGXSZKHQWKHLPDPKDG VDLGWKHWDVOLPDQGUHFLWHZKDWKHRZHGRXWORXGWRKLPVHOI %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNWKDWD]LGLEQ5XPDQVDLG,XVHGWRSUDQH[WWR1DIL LEQ-XEDULEQ0XWLPDQGKHZRXOGQXGJHPHWRSURPSWKLPZKLOHZHZHUHSUDLQJ 6HFWLRQ7KH 5HFLWDWLRQLQWKH6XEK3UDHU %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDIURPKLVIDWKHUWKDW$EX%DNUDV 6LGGLTSUDHGVXEKDQGUHFLWHGVXUDWDO%DTDUDLQWKHWZRUDN DV %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURP+LVKDPLEQ8UZDWKDWKLVIDWKHUKHDUG$EGXOODK LEQ $PLU LEQ 5DELD VD :H SUDHGVXEKEHKLQG8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEDQGKHUHFLWHG VXUDXVXI 6XUD
  70. 70. DQG VXUDW DO+DMM 6XUD
  71. 71. VORZO,+LVKDP VIDWKHU
  72. 72. VDLG% $OODK WKHQ LW PXVW KDYH EHHQ KLV KDELW WR JHW XS DW WKH FUDFN RI GDZQ +HVDLG2I FRXUVH %RRN1XPEHU DKDUHODWHGWRPHIURP0DOLNIURPDKDLEQ6DLGDQG5DELDLEQ$EL$EGDU5DKPDQ IURPDO4DVLPLEQ0XKDPPDGWKDWDO)XUDILVDLEQ8PDUDO+DQDILVDLG,RQOOHDUQW 6XUDXVXI6XUD
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
  74. 74. KWWSZZZLVODPPHVVDJHFRP JUDQWKLPSHDFHVDLG,KRSHWKDWRXZLOOQRWOHDYHWKHPRVTXHXQWLORXNQRZDVXUD ZKRVH OLNH $OODK KDV QRWVHQWGRZQ LQ WKH 7DZUDK QRU LQ WKH ,QMLO QRU LQ WKH 4XU DQ 8EDVDLG,EHJDQWRVORZGRZQPSDFHLQWKHKRSHRIWKDW7KHQ,VDLG 0HVVHQJHURI $OODK WKH VXUD RX SURPLVHG PH +H VDLG :KDW GR RX UHFLWH ZKHQ RX EHJLQ WKH SUDHU ,UHFLWHGWKH)DWLKD6XUD
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

×