SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 67
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
April 3, 2009
                                            Action Notes                                            1 of 75
                                                                              Equity Research




RATING/TARGET/ESTIMATE CHANGES

Bombardier Inc. (BBD.B-T) US$2.71                                                                   ...... 3
BUY (Unchanged);Target: US$4.00 ↓ (Prior: US$5.00)
Q4/09 Review; Strong Quarter With Weakening Outlook

Cameco Corp. (CCO-T, CCJ-N) C$22.10                                                                 ...... 8
HOLD ↓ (Prior: BUY);Target: C$24.00 ↓ (Unchanged)
Downgrade to Hold - Uranium Price Forecast Lowered

Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT-T) C$13.68                                                             .... 11
BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$17.50 (Unchanged)
Equity Adds To Financial Flexibility

First Quantum Minerals Ltd. (FM-T) C$38.13                                                          .... 16
BUY ↑ (Prior: HOLD);Target: C$48.00 ↑ (Prior: C$40.00)
Upgrading to BUY on Higher Copper Price Forecast

Pacific Rubiales Energy Corp. (PRE-T) C$5.40                                                        .... 19
ACTION LIST BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$10.00 (Unchanged)
PRE Reports Q4/08 Results; Holds Conference Call

Quadra Mining Ltd. (QUA-T) C$6.00                                                                   .... 22
BUY ↑ (Prior: HOLD);Target: C$7.50 ↑ (Prior: C$5.00)
Target and Rating Increased on Higher Copper Prices

Research In Motion Ltd. (RIMM-Q, RIM-T) US$49.09                                                    .... 27
ACTION LIST BUY (Unchanged);Target: US$80.00 ↑ (Prior: US$70.00)
Strong Gross Margins Should Take the Stock Higher

Sino-Forest Corp. (TRE-T) C$10.15                                                                   .... 31
BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$13.50 ↑ (Prior: C$12.00)
Annual Poyry Valuation Report Released

INDUSTRY NOTES

Financial Services - Banks                                                                          .... 36
Large-Cap Canadian Banks: March Fund Flows

Financial Services - Banks                                                                          .... 40
Increased MTM Flexibility; Not a Game Changer

Financial Services - Diversified Financials                                                         .... 45
Its Official - Investors Went on Strike for 2009 RSP Season



                Please see the final pages of this document for important disclosure information.
April 3, 2009
                                           Action Notes                     2 of 75
                                                          Equity Research




Notes (cont’d)


Metals & Minerals                                                           .... 51
Q1/09 Marked-to-Market Metal Prices

INTRADAY NOTES (published April 2, 2009)

Dorel Industries Inc. (DII.B-T) C$19.75                                     .... 58
BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$26.00 (Unchanged)
Dorel Refocuses Recreational Segment into Five Centers

Energy Savings Income Fund (SIF.UN-T) C$10.68                               .... 61
HOLD (Unchanged);Target: C$11.50 (Unchanged)
Q4/F09 Guidance Up Primarily On Windfall Gas Margins

Labopharm Inc. (DDS-T, DDSS-Q) C$1.64                                       .... 63
HOLD (Unchanged);Target: C$2.50 (Unchanged)
Tramadol-Acetaminophen Falls Short
April 3, 2009
                                                                 Action Notes                                                                    3 of 75
                                                                                                               Equity Research


                                                                 Tim James, CFA                                Scott Farley, CA (Associate)
Transportation/Aerospace
Recommendation:                                   BUY
                                             Unchanged
Risk:                                                HIGH
                                                                Bombardier Inc.
12-Month Target Price:                        US$4.00↓
                                                                (BBD.B-T) US$2.71
Prior:                                         US$5.00
12-Month Total Return:                               50.6%
                                                                Q4/09 Review; Strong Quarter With Weakening Outlook
                   Market Data (US$)
Current Price                                           $2.71
                                                                Event
52-Wk Range                                       $1.72-$8.80
                                                                Bombardier reported Q4/09 results on April 2nd. Reported EPS increased to
Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm)                                  $4,752.8
EV ($mm)                                             $4,682.1
                                                                $0.17 from $0.12 a year earlier, exceeding our estimate and consensus of
Dividend per Share                                      $0.08
                                                                $0.14.
Dividend Yield                                          3.0%
Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths)                    12,044,540
                                                                Impact - Neutral
                 Financial Data (US$)
Fiscal Y-E                                            January   Based on Q4/09 results, our updated industry outlook and guidance provided,
Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm)                                 1,753.8
                                                                we are maintaining our FY10 EPS estimate at $0.50 and reducing our FY11
Float Shares (mm)                                     1,753.8
                                                                estimate to $0.40 (from $0.49).       We have reduced our target EPS and
Net Cash ($mm)                                         $295.0
                                                                EBITDA multiples to 8.0x (from 9.0x) and 4.5x (from 5.0x) to reflect current
Net Debt/Tot Cap                                          NA
BVPS (f.d.)                                             $1.45
                                                                market conditions which combined with lower FY11 earnings expectations
Cash ($mm)                                           $4,247.0
                                                                results in a decline in our price target to US$4.00. We are maintaining our
                 Estimates (US$)                                BUY recommendation.
Year                     2008A 2009A 2010E 2011E
EBITDA ($mm)            1,352.0 1,937.0 1,998.8 1,612.8
                                                                While we acknowledge that the outlook for the commercial aerospace
EBITDA (old)($mm)       1,352.0 1,937.0 1,850.4 1,627.1
                                                                industry continues to weaken, we continue to believe Bombardier is
EPS (f.d.)                 0.26    0.56    0.50    0.40
                                                                undervalued at current levels. We believe the company’s strong balance
EPS (f.d.)(old)            0.26    0.56    0.50    0.49
                                                                sheet, order backlog and Transportation segment potential will allow
       EPS (f.d.) Quarterly Estimates (US$)
                                                                Bombardier to weather the current economic downturn more successfully than
Year                     2008A     2009A    2010E      2011E
Q1                         0.04      0.12     0.12         --
                                                                current multiples imply.
Q2                         0.05      0.14     0.13         --
Q3                         0.05      0.14     0.12         --
                                                                We emphasize that negative Aerospace industry news flow is expected to
Q4                         0.12      0.17     0.13         --
                                                                continue for the next several quarters, and to the extent the market continues
                     Valuations
                                                                to key on this data, Bombardier’s share price may be challenged to move
Year                     2008A     2009A    2010E      2011E
                                                                materially higher. However, on a fundamental value basis, we consider
EV/EBITDA                  3.5x      2.4x     2.3x       2.9x
P/E (f.d.)                10.4x      4.8x     5.4x       6.8x   Bombardier shares to be attractive at current levels.

                                                                Aerospace:
All figures in US$, unless otherwise specified.
                                                                •   Revenues declined 4% compared to a year earlier on a 29% decrease in
                                                                    business jet deliveries. We had forecast a 6% decline.
                                                                •   EBITDA excluding Other income increased 13% to $364 million,
                                                                    representing 13.1% of revenue and a 190bp improvement year-over-
                                                                    year. The improvement was attributable to higher selling prices, a more
                                                                    favourable product mix and lower S&GA.


                                                                                                                             BBD.B-T: Price
                                                                Company Profile                                  10                                10
                                                                A global corporation headquartered in
                                                                Canada,        Bombardier      manufactures       8                                8

                                                                transportation solutions ranging from
                                                                regional aircraft and business jets to rail       6                                6

                                                                transportation equipment. Its revenues for
                                                                                                                  4                                4
                                                                the fiscal year ended January 31, 2009 were
 Please see the final pages of                                  US$19.7 billion and its shares are traded on
 this document for important                                                                                      2                                2
                                                                the Toronto Stock Exchange (BBD.B).                   2006     2007       2008

 disclosure information.
April 3, 2009
                                                                         Action Notes                                                4 of 75
                                                                                                                   Equity Research


                     •       Included in the EBITDA result is a write-down of used business jet inventory values which we estimate
                             represented approximately 70 bps of margin.
                     •       Bombardier received 6 net orders in the quarter including 19 net business jet cancellations and 25 net
                             Q400 orders, down from the 204 net orders received in Q4/08. These figures were revised downwards by
                             11 net orders from data disclosed on February 5th.

Exhibit 1: Bombardier Inc. – Q4/09 Financial Performance
                                                                                                          Q3/F09
                                                                                                          Growth
                     Millions of U.S. Dollars except per share amounts     Q4/F09     Q4/F08    Growth
                     Revenues
                     Aerospace                                              2,777     2,893       (4%)     (2%)
                     Transportation                                         2,652     2,377       12%      21%
                                                                            5,429     5,270         3%       8%

                     EBITDA (before Other expense (income))
                     Aerospace                                                364       256        42%      32%
                       Margin                                               13.1%      8.8%       4.3%      3.4%
                       EBITDA Excluding One-time items & EOAPC                364       323       13%       (6%)
                       Margin Excluding One-time Items & EOAPC              13.1%     11.2%       1.9%    (0.4%)
                     Transportation                                           215       135       59%       37%
                       Margin                                                8.1%      5.7%       2.4%      0.7%
                       Margin Excluding One-time Items                       8.1%      5.7%       2.4%      0.7%
                                                                              579       391       48%       34%
                         Total Margin                                       10.7%      7.4%       3.2%      1.8%
                         Margin Excluding One-time Items & EOAPC            10.7%      8.7%       2.0%    (0.3%)

                     EBIT (before Other expense (income))
                     Aerospace                                                255       157       62%      45%
                       Margin                                                9.2%      5.4%       3.8%     2.7%
                     Transportation                                           185       107       73%      53%
                       Margin                                                7.0%      4.5%       2.5%     1.0%
                                                                              440       264      66.7%    47.5%
                         Total Margin                                        8.1%      5.0%       3.1%     1.7%

                     Income (loss) for the period                             309       218       42%      169%
                       Margin                                                5.7%      4.1%       1.6%      3.2%

                     Earnings per Share - Basic & Diluted
                     From Continuing Operations                             $0.17     $0.12       42%      183%
                     Net Income (loss)                                      $0.17     $0.12       42%      183%

                     Net Debt to Total Capitalization                       -13.1%    -19.3%
                     Total Debt to Trailing EBITDA                             2.0x      3.2x
                     Average US$/C$ exchange rate                            0.816     1.007    (19.0%)   (6.7%)
                     Regional Jets
                       Deliveries                                              19        19         0%    (41%)
                       Net Orders                                               0        31     (100%)    300%
                     Regional Turbo-props
                       Deliveries                                              18        19       (5%)    (25%)
                       Net Orders                                              25        19       32%       20%
                     Business Jets
                       Deliveries                                               54       76      (29%)     (0%)
                       Net Orders                                              (19)     154     (112%)    (57%)

Source: Company reports, TD Newcrest estimates.
April 3, 2009
                                Action Notes                                                          5 of 75
                                                                        Equity Research


Transportation:
•   Transportation revenue increased 12% to $2.7 billion, slightly below our forecast of 17% growth, but still
    representing a strong result in our view. U.S. dollar appreciation was estimated to have reduced growth
    by approximately 12%.
•   EBITDA excluding Other income increased 59% to $215 million and margin by 240bps to 8.1%.
    Management attributed the improvement to better contract execution, increased overhead absorption and
    a declining impact from several low margin contracts.
•   Order intake remained strong at $2.6 billion, representing a 1.0x book-to-bill. This is slightly below the
    1.4x book to bill ratio reported over the previous eight quarters. Order backlog declined $6.2 billion from
    a year earlier, largely due to unfavourable currency movements and a contract cancellation.

Balance Sheet:
•   Bombardier reported negative FCF of $91 million compared to $924 million a year earlier. Aerospace
    FCF declined $825 million, significantly more than expected and accounting for 83% of the decrease.
    Transportation FCF declined in-line with estimates at $165 million. The decline in Aerospace was
    attributable to a build-up in aircraft inventories arising from higher cancellations and deferrals, and a
    decrease in customer advances.
•   The company reported cash of $3.5 billion at year-end with no debt maturities until May 2012. Required
    debt and capital lease repayments over the next three years total $29 million. The amount available under
    current facilities is $760 million.
•   Included in inventory at year-end were 19 new and 29 used aircraft valued at $448 million and compared
    to the $176 million in inventory at the end of Q3/09.
•   Bombardier estimated its calendar 2009 pension funding requirements at $400 million, compared to $332
    million in 2008. This is a relatively moderate increase as a result of the offsetting impacts of a lower
    discount rate on liabilities and weak return on plan assets in 2008.

Outlook
•   FY10 business jet deliveries are expected to be 25% below FY09, compared to the 10% reduction
    indicated on February 5th. Bombardier’s Learjet unit continues to face the deepest cuts, but Challenger
    and Global aircraft will also be affected.
•   The magnitude of additional reductions was not surprising, and remains relatively small in comparison to
    those announced by direct competitors. Gulfstream has guided to a 38% year-over-year decline and
    Cessna recently announced a second round of production cuts (unquantified) subsequent to its initial 20%
    reduction. We have assumed a year-over-year decline of 30% in our forecast (vs 18% previously).
•   Management guided to “single-digit”, constant-currency revenue growth within the Transportation
    segment. This compares to estimated Q4/09 and FY09 constant-currency growth of 24%. The EBIT
    margin target of 6% for the year was re-iterated.
•   FCF is expected to continue to be weak during the first half of the year, before improving during the
    second half. As comparables become easier and the inventory build-up is reduced, year-over-year
    declines in FCF are expected to moderate relative to Q4/09.
•   Maintenance capital spending will be reduced where possible, but there is no plan to reduce capital
    expenditures related to new aerospace development projects.

Valuation
Bombardier is currently trading at 5.4x estimated FY10 EPS and estimated 6.8x FY11 EPS. On an EBITDA
basis, it is currently trading at 2.3x FY10 and 2.9x FY11 respectively. This compares to comparables which
are trading at 9.4x 2009 and 9.7x 2010 EPS, and 5.4x and 5.8x 2009 and 2010 EBITDA respectively.
April 3, 2009
                                                                                                                       Action Notes                                                                                                                                       6 of 75
                                                                                                                                                                                                             Equity Research


Exhibit 2: Bombardier Inc. – Comparables Table

                                                      Share Price                                                Earnings Per Share        EBITDA CAGR            P/E                                EV/EBITDA
                                                                       Shares O/S       Mkt Cap Five-year                                                                                                                      EV/Revenue    Net debt to     TTM EBITDA   Backlog to TTM
Company                                  Symbol           2-Apr-09                                              2008     2009E    2010E     10E vs. 08   2008    2009E 2010E      P/Book Trailing   2008     2009E    2010E
                                                                        (millions)     (millions) CAGR Revs                                                                                                                      Trailing   Capitalization     Margin        Revenue
Aerospace Companies
CAE Inc. ($CAD)                          CAE                 $7.96           255.0      $2,029.5   4.7%        $0.77     $0.68    $0.67       (2.7%)     10.4x    11.7x   11.9x      1.8x    6.0x     5.9x     6.2x     6.2x      1.4x         18.8%           23.9%           1.9x
The Boeing Company ($US)                 BA                 $37.20           726.1     $27,012.0   3.8%       $6.12     $5.01     $4.94       13.0%       6.1x     7.4x    7.5x       NA     5.7x     5.7x     4.4x     4.5x      0.5x          <0%             9.0%           5.3x
                                                                                                              € 1.95    € 1.20    € 1.30
European Aeronautic & Defense (€)        EAD                 € 9.45          814.8     € 7,698.8   7.5%                                      (11.1%)      4.8x     7.9x    7.2x      0.7x    0.3x      NA        NA      NA       0.0x          <0%            10.3%           9.3x
Embraer SA ($US)                         ERJ                $15.12           185.1      $2,799.0    NA         $2.24     $2.36    $2.66       (1.1%)      6.7x     6.4x    5.7x      1.3x    3.5x     3.5x     3.9x     3.6x      0.3x          <0%             9.6%           3.3x
Textron Inc. ($US)                       TXT                 $7.13           242.9      $1,732.2   7.8%        $3.17     $1.07    $1.51      (16.4%)      2.2x     6.7x    4.7x      0.7x    7.2x     7.3x    11.1x    10.4x      0.9x         81.8%           12.0%           1.6x
                                                                                                   6.0%                                       -3.7%       6.1x     8.0x    7.4x     1.1x     4.6x     5.6x     6.4x     6.2x      0.6x          50.3%          13.0%           4.3x
Diversified Companies
General Electric Corp. ($US)             GE                 $10.74       10,569.0    $113,511.1    6.2%       $1.72     $0.97     $0.91      (11.4%)      6.2x    11.1x   11.8x      1.1x   16.4x    16.5x       NA      NA       3.0x         80.6%           18.3%           0.9x
                                                                                                              € 1.90    € 4.88    € 4.79
Siemens Corp. (€)                        SIE                € 44.95          914.2    € 41,093.4   0.8%                                       21.1%      23.7x     9.2x    9.4x      1.5x    8.7x     9.3x     6.2x     6.3x      0.7x         34.9%            8.1%           NA
                                                                                                              € 1.39    € 1.39    € 1.52
Finmeccanica SpA (€)                     FNC                 € 9.78          578.2     € 5,651.4   14.9%                                      14.5%       7.0x     7.0x    6.4x      0.9x    5.0x     5.0x     4.1x     3.8x      0.6x         36.2%           12.0%           2.9x
United Technologies Corp. ($US)          UTX                $45.94           942.3     $43,289.0   13.6%       $4.90     $4.20    $4.45       (5.6%)      9.4x    10.9x   10.3x      2.7x    5.6x     5.6x     6.5x     6.3x      0.9x         31.0%           15.2%           1.0x
Average                                                                                            8.9%                                       4.6%       11.6x     9.6x    9.5x     1.6x     8.9x     9.1x     5.6x     5.5x      1.3x          45.7%          13.4%           1.6x
                                EX-GE                                                              9.8%                                       10.0%      13.4x     9.1x    8.7x     1.7x     6.4x     6.6x     5.6x     5.5x      0.7x          34.0%          11.8%           1.9x
Rail Transportation Companies
Alstom (€)                               ALO                € 42.17          287.0    € 12,103.4   (4.6%)     € 3.93     € 4.40   € 3.82      0.7%       10.7x     9.6x   11.0x      4.9x    6.0x     5.7x     5.0x     5.6x      0.6x          <0%            10.1%           2.6x
Vossloh AG (€)                           VOS                € 79.54           13.9     € 1,104.7   5.7%       € 6.30     € 6.26   € 6.77      3.2%       12.6x    12.7x   11.7x      2.3x    5.4x     5.4x     5.5x     5.1x      0.8x          <0%            13.8%           0.9x
Ansaldo STS (€)                          STS                € 11.92          100.0     € 1,192.0   6.8%       € 0.78     € 0.80   € 0.85      6.3%       15.4x    14.9x   14.1x       NA     7.7x     7.7x     7.2x     6.8x      0.9x          <0%            11.8%           2.8x
                                                                                                   2.6%                                       3.4%       12.9x   12.4x    12.3x     3.6x     6.4x     6.3x     5.9x     5.8x      0.8x          <0%            11.9%           2.1x


Bombardier Inc. ($US)                    BBD/B             C$ 3.35          1754.1      C$ 5,876   4.9%        $0.56     $0.50    $0.40       (8.8%)      4.8x     5.4x    6.8x     2.1x     3.6x     2.4x     2.3x     2.9x      0.2x          <0%             9.8%           2.4x
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Bombardier Aerospace      13.2%           2.4x
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Bombardier Transportation      6.4%           2.5x


Average All Bombardier Comparables (ex-outliers, greater than 1 standard dev. (minimum of 25%) from mean)                                     0.1%        8.2x     9.4x    9.7x     1.5x     6.1x     6.4x     5.4x     5.8x      0.8x          34.0%          11.5%           2.4x
Bombardier reports all financial results in U.S. Dollars. Share Price in Canadian Dollars.
Amounts for Embraer SA are based on U.S. listed ADR.
Data for comparables obtained from Bloomberg, except for BBD.B and CAE which are TD Newcrest estimates.

Source: Company reports, Bloomberg, TD Newcrest Estimates


                                          Justification of Target Price
                                          We are reducing our 12-month price target on Bombardier to US$4.00 and maintaining our BUY
                                          recommendation. Our price target is based on the average value arrived at through applying an 8.0x multiple to
                                          estimated FD EPS for the four quarters ending January 2011 and a 4.5x multiple to estimated EBITDA. We
                                          have revised our target multiples downwards slightly to reflect heightened aerospace cyclicality.

                                          Key Risks to Target Price
                                          Financial fragility of airline customers, aircraft financing availability, sustained long-term strength in oil
                                          prices, appreciation of the Canadian dollar, unusual effects on consumer confidence in travel, cost overruns on
                                          major projects, subordinate voting share structure (The Beaudoin family owns a majority of the multi-voting A
                                          shares, which have account for approximately 64% of total shareholder votes).

                                          Investment Conclusion
                                          We continue to recommend investors BUY shares in Bombardier. Historical precedents indicate that
                                          investments in capital equipment stocks such as Bombardier underperform at this point in the economic cycle.
                                          However, historically, Bombardier has traded at significantly higher valuations at this point in the cycle,
                                          arguably leaving limited downside risk based on current expectations. We maintain that following additional
                                          negative industry news flow over the next six months, investors will shift their focus to the valuation and
                                          downside protection provided by the Transportation segment earnings potential.
April 3, 2009
                                                                Action Notes                                                         7 of 75
                                                                                               Equity Research


Exhibit 3: Bombardier Inc. – Historical and Forecasted Operating and Financial Metrics

                     $US millions except per share amounts                  F2007      F2008      F2009     F2010E      F2011E
                     Revenues
                       Manufacturing                                       10,512     12,508     14,779      14,467      13,117
                       Services                                             2,738      3,016      3,117       3,415       3,778
                       Other                                                1,632      1,982      1,825       1,456       1,423
                     Total Revenues                                        14,882     17,506     19,721      19,339      18,318
                     Cost of Sales                                         12,667     14,607     16,049      15,577      14,965
                     Gross Profit                                           2,215      2,899      3,672       3,761       3,353
                     Selling, General & Administrative                        929      1,408      1,558       1,586       1,563
                     Research & Development                                   173        139        171         177         177
                     Amortization                                             518        512        555         570         577
                     Earnings before IT and Special Items                     595        840      1,388       1,429       1,036
                     Special Items                                            (42)     (100)         23         -           -
                     Operating Income From Continuing Operations (EBIT)       553        740      1,411       1,429       1,036

                     Net Income (loss)                                        268        317      1,008        904             736
                     Earnings (loss) per share:
                     Basic and diluted
                         From continuing operations                         $0.12      $0.16      $0.56      $0.50       $0.40
                         Net income (loss)                                  $0.14      $0.26      $0.56      $0.50       $0.40
                         Continuing Operations Excluding One-time Items     $0.12      $0.25      $0.56      $0.50       $0.40



                     Aerospace Statistics (units)
                     Aircraft Deliveries
                         Regional Jets                                       64         62         56         52         45
                         Growth                                           (42%)       (3%)      (10%)       (7%)      (13%)
                         Turboprops                                          48         66         54         62         55
                         Growth                                             71%       38%       (18%)       15%       (11%)
                         Total Regional Aircraft                            112        128        110        114        100
                         Growth                                           (19%)       14%       (14%)         4%      (12%)
                         Business Jets                                      212        232        235        164        133
                         Growth                                              8%         9%         1%      (30%)      (19%)
                         Other Aircraft                                        2         1          4          4          4

                     Transportation Statistics ($mlns.)
                     Orders
                         Manufacturing                                     7,800      7,700      6,300      5,985      7,302
                         Services                                          2,500      2,400      2,200      1,782      2,156
                         System & Signalling                               1,500      1,200      1,400      1,120      1,344
                                                                          11,800     11,300      9,900      8,887     10,802
                         Growth                                            61.8%     (4.2%)    (12.4%)    (10.2%)      21.5%
                     Revenues
                        Manufacturing                                      4,066      4,894     6,663      6,901       6,639
                        Growth                                              (7%)       20%       36%          4%        (4%)
                        Services                                           1,404      1,474     1,529      1,893       2,218
                         Growth                                               6%         5%        4%        24%        17%
                         System & Signalling                               1,116      1,425     1,564      1,242       1,209
                         Growth                                             17%        28%       10%       (21%)        (3%)
                                                                           6,586      7,793     9,756     10,037      10,066
                         Growth                                             (1%)       18%       25%          3%          0%

Source: Company reports, Bloomberg, TD Newcrest Estimates
April 3, 2009
                                                                  Action Notes                                                                        8 of 75
                                                                                                                  Equity Research


                                                                   Greg Barnes                                    Bonita To (Associate)
Metals & Minerals
Recommendation:                                     HOLD↓
Prior:                                                BUY
Risk:                                                 HIGH
                                                                 Cameco Corp.
12-Month Target Price:                        C$24.00↓
                                                                 (CCO-T, CCJ-N) C$22.10
                                             Unchanged
12-Month Total Return:                                 9.7%
                                                                 Downgrade to Hold - Uranium Price Forecast Lowered
                    Market Data (C$)
Current Price                                           $22.10
                                                                 Event
52-Wk Range                                      $14.33-$44.38
                                                                 We have lowered our uranium price forecast for 2009 and 2010 on lower spot
Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm)                                   $8,402.4
Dividend per Share                                       $0.24
                                                                 prices – the spot price hit a three-year low on March 30.
Dividend Yield                                           1.1%
Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths)                      1,935,728
                                                                 Impact
                   Financial Data (C$)
                                                                 Negative: Our lower uranium price forecast has negatively impacted our
Fiscal Y-E                                                Dec
Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm)                                    380.2   estimates for Cameco. We are maintaining our C$24.00 target price, however,
Float Shares (mm)                                        380.2
                                                                 due to share price appreciation since mid-February, we have downgraded our
Net Debt ($mm)                                         $943.8
                                                                 recommendation to HOLD from Buy.
Net Debt/Tot Cap                                         7.8%
NAVPS (current)(f.d.)                                  $17.27
Working Cap ($mm)                                     $1,208.0
                                                                 Details
                   Estimates (C$)
Year                     2007A 2008A         2009E 2010E         We have lowered our uranium price forecast for 2009 and 2010 on lower spot
EBITDA ($mm)              900.0 1,142.0       731.0 1,157.0
                                                                 prices – the spot price hit a three-year low on March 30. The downward trend
EBITDA (old)($mm)         900.0 1,142.0       798.0 1,215.0
                                                                 in the spot uranium price is continuing, although at a slower rate. Earlier this
EPS (f.d.)                 1.52    1.59        1.27    2.06
                                                                 week, Ux Consulting dropped its spot price to US$42.00/lb down US$0.50/lb
EPS (f.d.)(old)            1.52    1.59        1.43    2.19
                                                                 from the previous week. The spot price is now at it slowest level since May
CFPS (f.d.)                1.84    2.20        1.36    2.39
CFPS (f.d.)(old)           1.84    2.20        1.52    2.52      2006. Spot demand remains very weak although some “bargain hunting”
                                                                 buying has been evident over the past few weeks. What buying there is
       EPS (f.d.) Quarterly Estimates (C$)
Year                     2007A     2008A     2009E      2010E    remains highly discretionary. We have lowered our 2009 uranium price
Q1                         0.10      0.40      0.35         --
                                                                 forecast to US$50/lb (previously US$60/lb). Our lower forecast is based on a
Q2                         0.51      0.39      0.30         --
                                                                 weaker year-to-date price, which has averaged US$47/lb versus our forecast
Q3                         0.74      0.41      0.32         --
                                                                 of US$60/lb. With few near-term catalysts (utility buying remains highly
Q4                         0.17      0.47      0.30         --
                                                                 discretionary and speculative buying has disappeared), we do not expect a
                     Valuations
                                                                 significant move higher in uranium prices over the course of 2009, barring a
Year                     2007A     2008A     2009E      2010E
                                                                 major supply interruption. We continue to believe that the longer-term supply
EV/EBITDA                 10.5x      8.3x     12.9x       8.2x
P/E (f.d.)                14.5x     13.9x     17.4x      10.7x
                                                                 picture is very challenged with the majority of new supply dependant upon
P/CFPS (f.d.)             12.0x     10.0x     16.3x       9.2x
                                                                 two mega-projects (Cigar Lake and Olympic Dam expansion) for which no
                 Supplemental Data (US$)
                                                                 production clarity is evident – in our view, it could be the second half of the
Year                     2007E     2008A     2009E      2010E
                                                                 next decade before these two projects add meaningfully to supply.
Uranium ($/lb)            98.54     63.83     50.00      65.00
Prev. forecast            98.54     63.83     60.00      70.00



All figures in C$, unless otherwise specified.




                                                                                                                                CCO-T: Price
                                                                 Company Profile                                    70                                  70
                                                                 Cameco is the world's largest uranium              60                                  60
                                                                 producer. While mainly known for its
                                                                                                                    50                                  50
                                                                 uranium and conversion businesses, the
                                                                 company also operates in two other business        40                                  40

                                                                 groups that include electricity generation and     30                                  30
                                                                 gold production.
 Please see the final pages of                                                                                      20                                  20

 this document for important                                                                                        10                                  10
                                                                                                                         2006    2007          2008

 disclosure information.
April 3, 2009
                                                                     Action Notes                                                                        9 of 75
                                                                                                                      Equity Research


Exhibit 1. Metal Price Forecasts

                                   2009E                    2010E                   2011E             2012E          2013E           2014E          LT
        US$/lb               Old      New             Old      New           Old       New            New            New             New          New

                                              ↓                      ↓                        ↓
        Aluminum            0.85                      0.90                   0.90
                                     0.62                     0.70                    0.80            0.90           0.90            0.90         0.90

                                              ↑                      ↑                        ↑
        Copper              1.40                      1.60                   2.00
                                     1.70                     1.90                    2.25            2.50           2.50            2.00         1.75

                                              ↓
        Lead                0.55                      0.60                   0.65
                                     0.54                     0.60                    0.65            0.60           0.50            0.45         0.45

                                              ↑
        Nickel              4.31                      5.00                   6.00
                                     4.56                     5.00                    6.00            7.00           6.00            6.00         6.00

                                              ↑
        Zinc                0.52                      0.60                   0.85
                                     0.56                     0.60                    0.85            1.00           0.80            0.75         0.75

        Coal*                125                      150                    150
                                     125                       150                    150             125            100             90           90

                                              ↓                      ↓
        Uranium              60                       70                     70
                                      50                       65                      70             70             60              50           50

        FX (US$/C$)         0.83                      0.85                   0.85
                                     0.83                     0.85                    0.85            0.85           0.85            0.85         0.85


        *US$/tonne, fob

Source: TD Newcrest.


                       We present changes to our estimates in the Exhibit 2 — our estimates have decreased due to our lower uranium
                       price forecast.

                       Exhibit 2. New Estimates

                                                                     EPS                             CFPS                     EBITDA (mm)
                                                              Old                             Old                            Old
                                                                           New                               New                            New
                                                             $1.52                           $1.84                          $900
                                              2007A                        $1.52                             $1.84                        $900
                                                             $1.59                           $2.20                          $1,142
                                              2008A                        $1.59                             $2.20                     $1,142
                                                             $1.43                           $1.52                          $798
                                              2009E                        $1.27                             $1.36                        $731
                                                             $2.19                           $2.52                          $1,215
                                              2010E                        $2.06                             $2.39                     $1,157

                       Source: TD Newcrest.


                       Valuation
                       Cameco currently trades at an EV/2009 EBITDA multiple of 12.9x and a P/NAV multiple of 1.3x, compared
                       to its large cap peer group average of 8.3x and 0.5x, respectively.

                       Justification of Target Price
                       Our target price is based upon an EV/blended 2009-2010 EBITDA multiple of 9.5x (60% weighting) and a
                       1.3x multiple to our 10% NAV (40% weighting, adjusted for the market valuation of Centerra).

                       Key Risks to Target Price
                       The main risks facing the company include forecast, financial, technical and political risks. Among other
                       things, these include risks related to uranium prices, input costs, and fuel prices, the governing fiscal and
                       legislative regimes, the timing of key developments, market conditions, capital and operating costs, foreign
                       exchange rates, resources and reserves, operating parameters, permitting, environmental, and staffing and key
                       personnel retention. Our forecast of Cameco’s realized price could be substantially different than that actually
                       realized by the company. Because Cameco is primarily a uranium mining and processing company, it faces
                       heightened environmental risks relative to other mining companies. Cameco is developing two new mines, the
                       Cigar Lake mine in Northern Saskatchewan and the Inkai operation in Kazakhstan that could face development
                       cost overruns or delayed schedules that are inherent in new mine construction. With its available cash and
April 3, 2009
                                Action Notes                                                         10 of 75
                                                                        Equity Research


credit facilities, we believe there exists heightened M&A risk, which could impact our estimates and valuation
for the company.

Investment Conclusion
We have lowered our recommendation to HOLD (from Buy) while our target price remains unchanged
at C$24.00. Our recommendation reflects the limited return to our target price, our benign forecast for the
uranium market over the next 12-18 months and our view that M&A risk has increased following
management’s statements that it is actively pursuing a C$1-2 billion acquisition. We estimate that following
the completion of a C$440 million equity issue in early March, Cameco has approximately C$1.1 billion in
available cash and credit facilities with which it could pursue an acquisition. We estimate the company’s net
debt/net debt-plus-equity ratio at approximately 13% post the equity issue. We believe that Cameco could
pursue acquisitions that would be additive to its production profile within the nearer term. Our model and
company guidance suggests that the company’s production profile is effectively flat through 2013 (excluding
Cigar Lake) at 20-22 million pounds U3O8 per annum. We also expect that if investors start to look forward to
2010 with a view that economic growth could start to stabilize, Cameco’s defensive attributes could become
less attractive.
April 3, 2009
                                                                  Action Notes                                                                      11 of 75
                                                                                                                Equity Research


                                                                  Greg Shaw, CFA                                Joel Douglas, CA (Associate)
Oil & Gas Producers
Recommendation:                                   BUY
                                             Unchanged
Risk:                                                 HIGH
                                                                 Celtic Exploration Ltd.
12-Month Target Price:                         C$17.50
                                                                 (CLT-T) C$13.68
                                             Unchanged
12-Month Total Return:                                27.9%
                                                                 Equity Adds To Financial Flexibility
                    Market Data (C$)
Current Price                                          $13.68
                                                                 Event
52-Wk Range                                      $9.19-$21.05
                                                                 Celtic bought deal financing
Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm)                                    $641.6
Dividend per Share                                          --
Dividend Yield                                              --
                                                                 Impact
Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths)                       158367
                                                                 Neutral
                   Financial Data (C$)
Fiscal Y-E                                       December 31
Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm)                                   46.9     Details
Shares O/S (basic)(mm)                                  43.7
                                                                 Celtic announced a bought deal to issue 2.75 million common shares,
Float Shares (mm)                                          --
                                                                 including the over allotment, at $13.25 per share that represented a 4%
Net Debt ($mm)                                        $146.1
                                                                 discount to the April 1 closing price. The issue provides gross proceeds of
Net Debt/Tot Cap                                           --
                                                                 $36.4 million that will be initially used to reduce bank debt. The issue is
                   Estimates (C$)
                                                                 expected to close on April 23, 2009.
Year                     2007A     2008A     2009E     2010E
EPS (f.d.)                 0.23      1.10      0.37      0.67
CFPS (f.d.)                2.30      3.24      3.05      4.14
                                                                 On a NAV basis, we believe the equity issue to be largely neutral, while our
CFPS (f.d.)(old)              --        --     3.18      4.36
                                                                 2009E CFPS declines to $3.05 from $3.18 and our 2010E CFPS declines to
Oil (b/d)                 3,110     3,400     3,340     3,050
                                                                 $4.14 from $4.36. With the issue, we believe that Celtic improves its financial
Gas (MMcf/d)               28.6      46.0      62.4      86.3
                                                                 flexibility. Post the issue we estimate Celtic will have ~$150 million of net
                   Supplemental Data                             debt drawn ($120 million proforma Q4/08 bank debt) under the bank facility
Year                     2007A     2008A     2009E     2010E
                                                                 of $200 million. Proceeds from the issue will ultimately be used to fund their
WTI (US$bbl)             $72.23    $99.92    $50.00    $70.00
                                                                 2009E capital program and for general corporate purposes.
NYMEX (US$)               $6.97     $8.89     $5.00     $7.00
AECO (C$)                 $6.45     $8.20     $5.15     $7.25
                                                                 The company continues to focus on its Kaybob Montney development
F/X (US$)                 $0.93     $0.94     $0.81     $0.83
                                                                 program which provides attractive economics that were further improved with
                                                                 the Alberta Government’s recently announced stimulus incentives for drilling.
All figures in C$, unless otherwise specified.
                                                                 We continue to believe the strong incentives for the Kaybob Montney will
                                                                 translate into an expanded program and anticipate Celtic will review its
                                                                 capital program as part of Q1/09 reporting. We have not increased our
                                                                 forecasts at this time. We provide a review of the Celtic Kaybob Montney
                                                                 opportunity on page 2 of this report.

                                                                 Our BUY rating and target of $17.50 remain unchanged. We believe
                                                                 Celtic is well positioned for growth in 2009, with a multi-year development
                                                                 program at Kaybob that provides attractive returns. In addition, Celtic’s active
                                                                 hedging program provides an estimated $41 million of gains in 2009 that
                                                                 supports development drilling. Celtic trades at a P/NAV based on current
                                                                 futures of 100%, compared to the coverage group average of 70%.
                                                                                                                              CLT-T: Price
                                                                 Company Profile                                  22                                  22
                                                                 Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT) is a Canadian      20                                  20
                                                                 oil and natural gas exploration, development     18                                  18
                                                                 and production company with properties in        16                                  16
                                                                 southern, east central, west central and         14                                  14
                                                                 northern Alberta. The company commenced          12                                  12
                                                                 operations in September 2002.
 Please see the final pages of                                                                                    10                                  10

 this document for important                                                                                       8                                  8
                                                                                                                       2006    2007          2008

 disclosure information.
April 3, 2009
                                      Action Notes                                                     12 of 75
                                                                             Equity Research


Kaybob Montney Main Focus For 2009
Celtic has identified up to 134 net future drilling locations (46 booked in the 2008 reserves) on 5 identified
Montney pools, including at Kaybob South and KayFox where Celtic received downspacing approval to 5
wells per section in 2009. Celtic estimates all-in costs of roughly $3.2 million per Hz Montney well with up to
11 multi-stage fracture stimulations per Hz well. Montney wells are generally expected to recover 2-3 bcf/well
and have average first year production of roughly 1.9 mmcf/d. Celtic currently plans a 2009 corporate drilling
program of 45-50 wells (80% Hz wells) that will largely be focused on the Montney opportunity. Celtic plans
to have 4 rigs on its Greater Kaybob properties over spring break-up, with 3 rigs dedicated to Montney
opportunities and the other rig dedicated to Bluesky opportunities. Throughout break-up we believe Celtic
could drill four to seven wells with these rigs (1 Bluesky well). Celtic management has indicated the service
providers have agreed only to charge for operated time during break-up.

The economics with Celtic’s Hz Montney wells have improved significantly as a result of the Alberta
Government’s March 2009 announcement that was geared to stimulate drilling activity by providing drilling
incentives and new production incentives. Exhibit 1 illustrates the government’s new production incentive
improves after tax rate of return by 30% based on a NYMEX price of US$5.00/mcf (15% increase based on a
NYMEX price of US$4.00/mcf).

Exhibit 1. Kaybob Montney Well Economics


                                           Celtic Kaybob Montney

             250.0%



             200.0%



             150.0%
    AT ROR




             100.0%



             50.0%



              0.0%
                      $3.00        $4.00        $5.00       $6.00    $7.00     $8.00
                                               Nymex Price ($/mcf)
                                Pre NWRR                                Post NWRR
Source: GeoScout, TD Newcrest


Under the drilling incentive program Celtic is eligible for drilling credits of $200 per meter for wells drilled
between April 1, 2009 and March 31, 2010, with the drilling credits to offset Celtic’s corporate crown royalties
payable between April 1, 2009 and March 31, 2011. With an average measured depth of 3,700 meters per
Kaybob Hz Montney well, Celtic is eligible for royalty credits of $740,000 per Hz well (on average). Based on
a $3.2 million cost per well, this represents roughly 23% of the cost of the well. Combined with the new well
royalty savings, Celtic is positioned to save up to 44% of the cost of each Hz Kaybob Montney well based on a
NYMEX price of US$5.00/mcf. Our calculation assumes full recovery of the drilling incentive credits. On our
forecasts and based on Celtic’s maximum royalty credit (50%) we estimate Celtic could potentially save $48
million in royalties between April 1, 2009 and December 31, 2010 under the drilling incentive program. This
implies Celtic would need to drill roughly 240,000 meters, which equates to roughly 65 Hz Montney wells
(average 3,700 meters/well) before March 31, 2010 (note the drilling incentive credit does not just apply to
April 3, 2009
                                                  Action Notes                                                                                                   13 of 75
                                                                                                                 Equity Research


Montney wells). Again we note Celtic’s current capital budget targets 45-50 wells in 2009, of which 80% will
be Hz wells.

Estimate revisions
The announced bought deal to issue 2.75 million common shares, including the over allotment, represents a
6% increase in the fully dilutes shares outstanding. With an issue price of $13.25/share, the equity issue
provides proceeds of $36.4 million that will likely be used initially to repay debt. The purpose of the issue is to
fund capital development activities and for general corporate purposes.

Exhibit 2. Celtic Exploration: Estimate Revisions
                                                                         2009E                                         2010E
                                                               New        Old      Change                New            Old        Change

  Oil                                  Bbl/d                    3,340     3,340         0%                3,050         3,050              0%
  Gas                                 Mmcf/d                     62.4      62.4         0%                 86.3          86.3              0%
Production                                                     13,750    13,750         0%               17,440        17,440              0%
% Gas                                   %                        76%       76%                             83%           83%

Revenue*                               $mln                      $190      $190         0%                 $329          $329              0%
Revenue*                               $/boe                   $37.93    $37.93         0%               $51.72        $51.72              0%

Capital expenditures                   $mln                     $130       $130         0%                 $170            $170            0%

Cash Flow                              $mln                      $132      $131         1%                 $182             $180           1%
CFPS (f.d.)                           $/share                   $3.05     $3.18        -4%                $4.14            $4.36          -5%

Net Debt                               $mln                     $137       $168       -19%                 $126            $158          -21%
Net Debt/CF                             x                        1.0x       1.3x      -19%                  0.7x            0.9x         -22%

Commodity prices
  WTI                                 US$/bbl                  $50.00    $50.00                          $70.00        $70.00
  AECO                                 $/mcf                    $5.15     $5.15                           $7.25         $7.25
Source: TD Newcrest


Exhibit 3. Celtic Exploration: Cash Flow Sensitivities
CFPS - 2009E (FX fixed at $0.81)                                                    CFPS - 2010E (FX fixed at $0.83)
                                               WTI (US$/Bbl)                                                                            WTI (US$/Bbl)
                     $5.40   $40.00   $45.00      $50.00        $55.00   $60.00                             $6    $60.00      $65.00       $70.00       $75.00      $80.00
                     $4.65    $2.77    $2.79       $2.81         $2.84    $2.86                          $6.25     $3.29       $3.41        $3.52        $3.63       $3.74
     AECO (C$/Mcf)




                                                                                         AECO (C$/Mcf)




                     $4.90    $2.89    $2.92       $2.94         $2.96    $2.99                          $6.75     $3.60       $3.72        $3.83        $3.94       $4.05
                     $5.15    $3.02    $3.04       $3.05         $3.09    $3.11                          $7.25     $3.91       $4.03        $4.14        $4.25       $4.36
                     $5.40    $3.14    $3.17       $3.19         $3.21    $3.24                          $7.75     $4.22       $4.34        $4.45        $4.56       $4.67
                     $5.65    $3.27    $3.29       $3.32         $3.34    $3.36                          $8.25     $4.53       $4.65        $4.76        $4.87       $4.98

Net Debt to Cash Flow - 2009E                                                       Net Debt to Cash Flow - 2010E
                                               WTI (US$/Bbl)                                                                            WTI (US$/Bbl)
                     $0.15   $40.00   $45.00      $50.00        $55.00   $60.00                             $0    $60.00      $65.00       $70.00       $75.00      $80.00
                     $4.65    1.2x     1.2x        1.2x          1.2x     1.2x                           $6.25     1.1x        1.1x         1.0x         0.9x        0.9x
     AECO (C$/Mcf)




                                                                                         AECO (C$/Mcf)




                     $4.90    1.2x     1.1x        1.1x          1.1x     1.1x                           $6.75     0.9x        0.9x         0.8x         0.8x        0.7x
                     $5.15    1.1x     1.0x        1.0x          1.0x     1.0x                           $7.25     0.8x        0.7x         0.7x         0.6x        0.6x
                     $5.40    1.0x     1.0x        0.9x          0.9x     0.9x                           $7.75     0.7x        0.6x         0.6x         0.5x        0.5x
                     $5.65    0.9x     0.9x        0.9x          0.9x     0.8x                           $8.25     0.5x        0.5x         0.5x         0.4x        0.4x


Source: TD Newcrest


Valuation
                                                 Base NAV                                                        Multiples
Company                       Share Price        (Futures)               P/NAV    Operational                     NAV                  Subjective                Target
Celtic                            $13.68             $13.65                  100%       1.03x                          1.19x                 1.15x                 $17.50
Group Average                                                                 77%        1.05x                         1.09x                 1.15x
Source: TD Newcrest
April 3, 2009
                                  Action Notes                                                                  14 of 75
                                                                             Equity Research


Justification of Target Price
Our valuation methodology reflects a combination of an after-tax NAV assumption (adjusted for Celtic's
growth profile), which, in turn, is combined with an operational component to achieve a base target price
($15.48), and further adjusted for subjective factors, to arrive at our final target of $17.50/share. The subjective
adjustment reflects factors such as management performance and potential execution obstacles, which can
result in up to a 20% adjustment to the base target. Our NAV component generally represents roughly 60% of
the base target, with the operational component representing the balance of the base target.

Exhibit 4. Target Price Components

                                                                                        Subjective,
                                       Subjective                                         $2.30
                                         13%


                                                                 NAV,
           NAV                                Operational                                        Operational,
                                                                $10.00
           57%                                  30%                                                $5.20


Note: Target components may not add as the target is rounded to the nearest $0.25.
Source: TD Newcrest


Key Risks to Target Price
Key risks associated with this target price include those business risks of the company and industry, including
but not limited to: loss of key employees, drilling success, volatile commodity prices and operating costs,
product supply and demand, government regulations and taxes, exchange rates, interest rates, environmental
and weather concerns, and unfavorable tax legislation. Specific risks to Celtic include asset concentration of
the capital program in the Kaybob region.

Investment Conclusion
Our BUY rating and target of $17.50 remain unchanged. We believe Celtic is well positioned for growth in
2009, with a multi-year development program at Kaybob that provides attractive returns. In addition, Celtic’s
active hedging program provides an estimated $41 million of gains in 2009 that supports development drilling.
Celtic trades at a P/NAV based on current futures of 100%, compared to the coverage group average of 70%.
April 3, 2009
                                                              Action Notes                                                                                                                                                                  15 of 75
                                                                                                                                                          Equity Research


Exhibit 5. Corporate Profile
Celtic Exploration Ltd.                                                                                                                                                                                                TD Newcrest
Ticker               CLT-T                Rating           BUY                Target                                 $17.50                                     Shares Out. 43.7 mln                                                             April 2, 2009
Price                                     Risk                                Return
                     $13.68                                High                                                        28%                          Shares Out. (f.d.) 46.9 mln
Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT) is a Canadian oil and natural gas exploration, development and production company with properties in southern, east central,
west central and northern Alberta. The company commenced operations in September 2002.
Share Price                High              Low               Close          Commodity Assumptions                                             2006                       2007                        2008                    2009E                     2010E
             2008             $21.05             $9.19            $12.61 WTI (US$/Bbl)                                                         $66.07                    $72.23                      $99.92                   $50.00                  $70.00
             2007             $15.23           $10.60             $11.20 Nymex (US$/mmbtu)                                                      $6.73                     $6.97                       $8.89                     $5.00                    $7.00
Mgmt & Director Ownership                                               19% FX US$/C$                                                          $0.882                    $0.931                      $0.943                   $0.806                  $0.830
Cash Flow Sensitivity                                                         Production & Capex                                                2006                       2007                        2008                    2009E                     2010E
                                                                              Liquids                    Bbl/d                                  3,280                     3,110                       3,400                      3,340                   3,050
   2009E                                                                      Gas                        Mmcf/d                                  16.1                       28.6                        46.0                           62.4                               86.3
                                                                              Total                      BOE/d                                  5,960                     7,870                      11,070                   13,750                  17,440
   2010E
                                                                              % Gas                      %                                       45%                        60%                         69%                        76%                                   83%
         -$0.10   -$0.05   $0.00    $0.05   $0.10     $0.15    $0.20
                                                                              EV/boe/d                   $/boepd                       $100,013                      $75,055                        $66,069                  $56,682                 $44,015
                    Change Per FD Share on Increase in
                                                                              Dev Capex.                 $mm                                   $173.7                    $135.6                      $138.4                   $130.0                  $170.0
         WTI (US$1/bbl)    AECO (C$0.25/mcf)     FX (C$0.01/USD)
                                                                              % of CF                    %                                     223%                       165%                        106%                         98%                                  94%
Wells Drilled & Undeveloped Acres                                             Leverage                                                          2006                       2007                        2008                    2009E                     2010E
                                   2006          2007                  2008 Net Debt/CF                  x                                        1.4x                       1.7x                        1.3x                          1.0x                                  0.7x
Gross Wells                        83.0             65.0                54.0 Bank Credit Facilit $mm                                           $115.0                    $165.0                      $200.0                   $200.0                  $200.0
Net Wells                          62.8             56.0                41.1 Undrawn                     %                                          3%                      17%                         15%                        31%                                  37%
Net Acres                   235,300         248,900             246,600 Financial Results                                                       2006                       2007                        2008                    2009E                     2010E
Well Data                                   Celtic            Peer Avg. Revenue                          $/BOE                                 $61.27                    $55.38                      $60.11                   $46.08                  $51.72
Avg. Time onstream per well                                                   Royalties                  $/BOE                                 $10.90                    $11.16                      $14.43                      $7.20                $10.86
 in years.                                     6.4                4.5         Transportation             $/BOE                                  $0.66                     $0.87                       $0.57                     $0.65                    $0.68
Time on Production of (Mths):                                  Median         Op. Costs                  $/BOE                                 $10.90                    $11.12                      $10.21                      $9.81                $10.19
                                                                              Op. Netback                $/BOE                                 $38.81                    $32.23                      $34.90                   $28.41                  $29.99
                     Top Well                  1.0              14.8
                     Top 5 Wells               5.6              23.6          G&A*                       $/BOE                                  $1.42                     $1.56                       $1.43                      $1.28                    $1.12
                     Top 10 Wells            20.4               27.5          EBITDA                     $/BOE                                 $37.38                    $30.67                      $33.47                   $27.13                  $28.87
Production Concentration Risk in:                               Avg.          CFFO                       $/BOE                                 $35.79                    $28.65                      $32.22                   $26.37                  $28.55
                     Top Well                  7%                 9%          CFFO                       $mm                                    $77.9                     $82.3                      $130.6                   $132.3                  $181.8
                     Top 5 Wells            17%                 22%            Per Share                 $/Share                                $2.61                     $2.32                       $3.28                      $3.07                   $4.16
                     Top 10 Wells           27%                 30%            Per Share (f.d.) $/Share                                         $2.48                     $2.30                       $3.24                     $3.05                    $4.14
Net Wells Drilled as % of Total                                               Shares Avg (f.d.) mm                                               31.4                       35.8                        40.3                           43.3                               43.9
 Producing Wells in:                                                          Hedging                                                           2006                       2007                        2008                    2009E                     2010E
                     Last 12 mths              6%               13%           Gain/(Loss)                      $/boe                            $2.29                     $2.68                      -$4.88                      $8.14                   $0.00
                     Last 24 mths           16%                 25%           % Hedged                               %                              n/a                           n/a                   51%                        40%                                           0%
                                                                              Reserve
                     Last 36 mths           26%                 41%                                                  TP               TP RLI                    EV/TP boe                       P+P                  P+P RLI                       EV/boe
                                                                              Analysis
Percent of Production onstream in:                                                                           mmboe                     Years                       $/boe                    mmboe                       Years                       $/boe
                     Last 12 mths           42%                 30%           2008                           28,946                       6.6                    $25.27                     53,177                           12.0                  $13.75
                     Last 24 mths           60%                 48%           2007                           20,771                       6.2                    $28.44                     33,773                           10.0                  $17.49
                     Last 36 mths           69%                 64%           2006                           14,874                       6.5                    $40.08                     26,267                           11.4                  $22.69
                                                                              FD&A ($/boe)                   TP F&D                   TP FD&A                    Recycle                    P+P F&D                  P+P FD&A                      Recycle
Productivity/Well (BOE/d)                      24                 32          2008                           $14.89                   $19.46                        1.7x                       $7.28                   $12.24                        2.6x
Operated Production (%)                     86%                 89%           2007                           $22.29                   $21.45                        1.3x                     $23.53                    $19.27                        1.5x
Average Working Interest                    52%                 69%           2006                           $27.46                   $30.62                        1.2x                     $16.49                    $19.44                        1.8x
NAV                                              2007                  2008 Production per Debt Adjusted Share
NAV/Share            $/Share                     $9.42            $13.65
                                                                                         14000                                                                                                                                                    0.25
P/NAV                %                           145%              100%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         BOEPD/DA Share (f.d.)




                                                                                         12000
Tax Pool             $mm                         $305                  $358                                                                                                                                                                       0.20
                                                                                         10000
                                                                                 BOEPD




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.15
Acquisition Summary                                                                       8000
                                                                                          6000                                                                                                                                                    0.10
      Date           P+P mmBOE              Boe/d          Cost ($mm)
                                                                                          4000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.05
   04/29/2008              4.369            1,140               $45                       2000
                                                                                             0                                                                                                                                                    0.00
   04/05/2005              7.223             901                $40
                                                                                                 Q1/05

                                                                                                             Q2/05

                                                                                                                      Q3/05

                                                                                                                              Q4/05

                                                                                                                                       Q1/06

                                                                                                                                                Q2/06

                                                                                                                                                        Q3/06

                                                                                                                                                                 Q4/06

                                                                                                                                                                          Q1/07

                                                                                                                                                                                    Q2/07

                                                                                                                                                                                            Q3/07

                                                                                                                                                                                                     Q4/07

                                                                                                                                                                                                             Q1/08

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Q2/08

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Q3/08

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Q4/08




   10/21/2002               2.1              950                $23


                                                                                                                                                BOEPD                    BOEPD/DA Share (f.d.)


Greg Shaw, CFA 403-292-1204 greg.shaw@tdsecurities.com                                                                 Joel Douglas, CA (Associate) 403-299-3272 joel.douglas@tdsecurities.com
Source: Company Data, TD Newcrest
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q
Td Report First Q

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCall
dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCalldana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCall
dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCallfinance42
 
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlidesfinance23
 
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20final
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20finalAES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20final
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20finalfinance19
 
Baird September 2012 Facility Services Report
Baird September 2012 Facility Services ReportBaird September 2012 Facility Services Report
Baird September 2012 Facility Services ReportDavid Crace
 
ameriprise 3Q06_Release
ameriprise 3Q06_Releaseameriprise 3Q06_Release
ameriprise 3Q06_Releasefinance43
 
fmc technologies 2002ar
fmc technologies 2002arfmc technologies 2002ar
fmc technologies 2002arfinance50
 
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegG
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegGDuke Energy 02/01/06_RegG
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegGfinance21
 
Strength Of Ubs New
Strength Of Ubs NewStrength Of Ubs New
Strength Of Ubs Newubsbob
 
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release 2004 1st
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release  2004 1stallstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release  2004 1st
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release 2004 1stfinance7
 
Fall Newsletter 2010
Fall Newsletter 2010Fall Newsletter 2010
Fall Newsletter 2010mfissel
 
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, Leadership
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, LeadershipIan R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, Leadership
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, LeadershipIanRStuart
 
constellation energy 2004 Annual Report
constellation energy 2004 Annual Reportconstellation energy 2004 Annual Report
constellation energy 2004 Annual Reportfinance12
 

Was ist angesagt? (19)

dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCall
dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCalldana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCall
dana holdings 0CA5D6ED-FF04-4642-9D47-81A0CF09F4AB_4Q08_ConfCall
 
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides
3/2/07 DF Special Dividend ConferenceCallSlides
 
standardchartered Final Results 2004
standardchartered  	Final Results 2004standardchartered  	Final Results 2004
standardchartered Final Results 2004
 
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20final
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20finalAES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20final
AES1Q 2005 20Earnings20Slides20_20final
 
Baird September 2012 Facility Services Report
Baird September 2012 Facility Services ReportBaird September 2012 Facility Services Report
Baird September 2012 Facility Services Report
 
ameriprise 3Q06_Release
ameriprise 3Q06_Releaseameriprise 3Q06_Release
ameriprise 3Q06_Release
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of IPC Holdings, Ltd.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of IPC Holdings, Ltd. Q1 2009 Earning Report of IPC Holdings, Ltd.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of IPC Holdings, Ltd.
 
2009-01-16 Bank am Bellevue Conference
2009-01-16 Bank am Bellevue Conference 2009-01-16 Bank am Bellevue Conference
2009-01-16 Bank am Bellevue Conference
 
fmc technologies 2002ar
fmc technologies 2002arfmc technologies 2002ar
fmc technologies 2002ar
 
Hero Honda
Hero Honda Hero Honda
Hero Honda
 
3Q05FINAL
3Q05FINAL3Q05FINAL
3Q05FINAL
 
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegG
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegGDuke Energy 02/01/06_RegG
Duke Energy 02/01/06_RegG
 
Strength Of Ubs New
Strength Of Ubs NewStrength Of Ubs New
Strength Of Ubs New
 
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release 2004 1st
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release  2004 1stallstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release  2004 1st
allstate Quarterly Investor Information Earnings Press Release 2004 1st
 
Fall Newsletter 2010
Fall Newsletter 2010Fall Newsletter 2010
Fall Newsletter 2010
 
2003 Annual Report Letter to Stockholders
2003 Annual Report Letter to Stockholders 2003 Annual Report Letter to Stockholders
2003 Annual Report Letter to Stockholders
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Prologis
Q1 2009 Earning Report of PrologisQ1 2009 Earning Report of Prologis
Q1 2009 Earning Report of Prologis
 
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, Leadership
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, LeadershipIan R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, Leadership
Ian R. Stuart - Career History, Accomplishments, Leadership
 
constellation energy 2004 Annual Report
constellation energy 2004 Annual Reportconstellation energy 2004 Annual Report
constellation energy 2004 Annual Report
 

Ähnlich wie Td Report First Q

public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06
public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06
public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06finance20
 
Baird's 2008 Industrial Conference
Baird's 2008 Industrial ConferenceBaird's 2008 Industrial Conference
Baird's 2008 Industrial Conferencefinance46
 
Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results
	Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results	Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Resultsfinance12
 
Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results
	Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results	Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Resultsfinance12
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Company
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper CompanyQ1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Company
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Companyearningreport earningreport
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.earningreport earningreport
 
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentation
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentationStar Bulk Q3 2012 results presentation
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentationTradeWindsnews
 
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and media
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and mediacredit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and media
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and mediaQuarterlyEarningsReports2
 
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter ResultsRaytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Resultsfinance12
 
Mackie Research: Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)
Mackie Research:  Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)Mackie Research:  Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)
Mackie Research: Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)Graphite Graphite
 
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009investorrelation
 
dana holdings 3Q08Earnings
dana holdings 3Q08Earningsdana holdings 3Q08Earnings
dana holdings 3Q08Earningsfinance42
 
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)Graphite Graphite
 
xcel energy Q308_Presentation
xcel energy Q308_Presentationxcel energy Q308_Presentation
xcel energy Q308_Presentationfinance26
 
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy  Q3 08_Presentationxcel energy  Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentationfinance26
 
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy  Q3 08_Presentationxcel energy  Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentationfinance26
 
United Airlines - JPMC Briefing
United Airlines - JPMC BriefingUnited Airlines - JPMC Briefing
United Airlines - JPMC BriefingJohn Wildes
 
Boeing News Release
Boeing  News Release Boeing  News Release
Boeing News Release finance3
 

Ähnlich wie Td Report First Q (20)

public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06
public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06
public serviceenterprise group LEHMAN9-6-06
 
Tcw
TcwTcw
Tcw
 
Baird's 2008 Industrial Conference
Baird's 2008 Industrial ConferenceBaird's 2008 Industrial Conference
Baird's 2008 Industrial Conference
 
Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results
	Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results	Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2004 Second Quarter Results
 
Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results
	Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results	Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2004 First Quarter Results
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Company
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper CompanyQ1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Company
Q1 2009 Earning Report of International Paper Company
 
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.
Q1 2009 Earning Report of WESCO International, Inc.
 
Bp
BpBp
Bp
 
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentation
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentationStar Bulk Q3 2012 results presentation
Star Bulk Q3 2012 results presentation
 
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and media
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and mediacredit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and media
credit-suisse Slides - Presentation to analysts and media
 
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter ResultsRaytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Results
Raytheon Reports 2005 First Quarter Results
 
Mackie Research: Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)
Mackie Research:  Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)Mackie Research:  Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)
Mackie Research: Northern Graphite & Refactory Market Dynamics (Feb 21, 2012)
 
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009
Earning Presentation of General Motors: Q1 2009
 
dana holdings 3Q08Earnings
dana holdings 3Q08Earningsdana holdings 3Q08Earnings
dana holdings 3Q08Earnings
 
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)
Union Securities Research: Northern Graphite Corp. (TSXv: NGC)
 
xcel energy Q308_Presentation
xcel energy Q308_Presentationxcel energy Q308_Presentation
xcel energy Q308_Presentation
 
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy  Q3 08_Presentationxcel energy  Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
 
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy  Q3 08_Presentationxcel energy  Q3 08_Presentation
xcel energy Q3 08_Presentation
 
United Airlines - JPMC Briefing
United Airlines - JPMC BriefingUnited Airlines - JPMC Briefing
United Airlines - JPMC Briefing
 
Boeing News Release
Boeing  News Release Boeing  News Release
Boeing News Release
 

Mehr von Christopher R Anderson

Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securities
Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securitiesGraphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securities
Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securitiesChristopher R Anderson
 
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal Property
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal PropertyGreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal Property
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal PropertyChristopher R Anderson
 
British Geological Survey risk list2011
British Geological Survey risk list2011British Geological Survey risk list2011
British Geological Survey risk list2011Christopher R Anderson
 

Mehr von Christopher R Anderson (20)

Internet trends-2013
Internet trends-2013Internet trends-2013
Internet trends-2013
 
Keymet mine shaft and ore body
Keymet mine shaft and ore bodyKeymet mine shaft and ore body
Keymet mine shaft and ore body
 
Canada's rareearths may-2012
Canada's rareearths may-2012Canada's rareearths may-2012
Canada's rareearths may-2012
 
Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securities
Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securitiesGraphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securities
Graphite-is-black-gold-of-the-21st-century-industrial-alliance-securities
 
Hmmm december 18 2011
Hmmm december 18 2011Hmmm december 18 2011
Hmmm december 18 2011
 
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal Property
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal PropertyGreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal Property
GreenLight Completes 43-101 on Heavy REE, Base Metal Property
 
Gr nr-oct-19-2011
Gr nr-oct-19-2011Gr nr-oct-19-2011
Gr nr-oct-19-2011
 
British Geological Survey risk list2011
British Geological Survey risk list2011British Geological Survey risk list2011
British Geological Survey risk list2011
 
Graphite NB-Golden Gove Report
Graphite NB-Golden Gove ReportGraphite NB-Golden Gove Report
Graphite NB-Golden Gove Report
 
Graphite sept-1-2011
Graphite sept-1-2011Graphite sept-1-2011
Graphite sept-1-2011
 
Pan Am March Boca 2011 power point
Pan Am March Boca 2011 power pointPan Am March Boca 2011 power point
Pan Am March Boca 2011 power point
 
Rare earth elements summary
Rare earth elements summaryRare earth elements summary
Rare earth elements summary
 
Rare earth elements summary
Rare earth elements summaryRare earth elements summary
Rare earth elements summary
 
Arizona Real Estate
Arizona Real EstateArizona Real Estate
Arizona Real Estate
 
Keith Richards-review on his book
Keith Richards-review on his bookKeith Richards-review on his book
Keith Richards-review on his book
 
Aliance Mining nov final 2010 pp (9)
Aliance Mining nov final 2010 pp  (9)Aliance Mining nov final 2010 pp  (9)
Aliance Mining nov final 2010 pp (9)
 
November 19 2010
November 19 2010November 19 2010
November 19 2010
 
Kempt and Cowan Gold Mines
Kempt and Cowan Gold MinesKempt and Cowan Gold Mines
Kempt and Cowan Gold Mines
 
7waystousesocialmediatobuildbrands
7waystousesocialmediatobuildbrands7waystousesocialmediatobuildbrands
7waystousesocialmediatobuildbrands
 
RCR Quarterly Report- Oct-10-Copper
RCR Quarterly Report- Oct-10-CopperRCR Quarterly Report- Oct-10-Copper
RCR Quarterly Report- Oct-10-Copper
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...ssifa0344
 
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdf
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdfIndore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdf
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdfSaviRakhecha1
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...priyasharma62062
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfGale Pooley
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...dipikadinghjn ( Why You Choose Us? ) Escorts
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdf
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdfShrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdf
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdfvikashdidwania1
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdfGale Pooley
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri  6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Wadgaon Sheri 6297143586 Call Hot Ind...
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
 
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...
Solution Manual for Principles of Corporate Finance 14th Edition by Richard B...
 
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdf
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdfIndore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdf
Indore Real Estate Market Trends Report.pdf
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Andheri 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai Escorts...
 
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
VIP Call Girl in Mira Road 💧 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Get A New Crush Everyday ...
 
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
Mira Road Awesome 100% Independent Call Girls NUmber-9833754194-Dahisar Inter...
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Dighi ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex Servi...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
 
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...
VIP Independent Call Girls in Mira Bhayandar 🌹 9920725232 ( Call Me ) Mumbai ...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
Call Girls in New Ashok Nagar, (delhi) call me [9953056974] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in New Ashok Nagar, (delhi) call me [9953056974] escort service 24X7Call Girls in New Ashok Nagar, (delhi) call me [9953056974] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in New Ashok Nagar, (delhi) call me [9953056974] escort service 24X7
 
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdf
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdfShrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdf
Shrambal_Distributors_Newsletter_Apr-2024 (1).pdf
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Viman Nagar ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
 
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
From Luxury Escort Service Kamathipura : 9352852248 Make on-demand Arrangemen...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 26.pdf
 
(INDIRA) Call Girl Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
 
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...Top Rated  Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
Top Rated Pune Call Girls Sinhagad Road ⟟ 6297143586 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine S...
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
 

Td Report First Q

  • 1. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 1 of 75 Equity Research RATING/TARGET/ESTIMATE CHANGES Bombardier Inc. (BBD.B-T) US$2.71 ...... 3 BUY (Unchanged);Target: US$4.00 ↓ (Prior: US$5.00) Q4/09 Review; Strong Quarter With Weakening Outlook Cameco Corp. (CCO-T, CCJ-N) C$22.10 ...... 8 HOLD ↓ (Prior: BUY);Target: C$24.00 ↓ (Unchanged) Downgrade to Hold - Uranium Price Forecast Lowered Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT-T) C$13.68 .... 11 BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$17.50 (Unchanged) Equity Adds To Financial Flexibility First Quantum Minerals Ltd. (FM-T) C$38.13 .... 16 BUY ↑ (Prior: HOLD);Target: C$48.00 ↑ (Prior: C$40.00) Upgrading to BUY on Higher Copper Price Forecast Pacific Rubiales Energy Corp. (PRE-T) C$5.40 .... 19 ACTION LIST BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$10.00 (Unchanged) PRE Reports Q4/08 Results; Holds Conference Call Quadra Mining Ltd. (QUA-T) C$6.00 .... 22 BUY ↑ (Prior: HOLD);Target: C$7.50 ↑ (Prior: C$5.00) Target and Rating Increased on Higher Copper Prices Research In Motion Ltd. (RIMM-Q, RIM-T) US$49.09 .... 27 ACTION LIST BUY (Unchanged);Target: US$80.00 ↑ (Prior: US$70.00) Strong Gross Margins Should Take the Stock Higher Sino-Forest Corp. (TRE-T) C$10.15 .... 31 BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$13.50 ↑ (Prior: C$12.00) Annual Poyry Valuation Report Released INDUSTRY NOTES Financial Services - Banks .... 36 Large-Cap Canadian Banks: March Fund Flows Financial Services - Banks .... 40 Increased MTM Flexibility; Not a Game Changer Financial Services - Diversified Financials .... 45 Its Official - Investors Went on Strike for 2009 RSP Season Please see the final pages of this document for important disclosure information.
  • 2. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 2 of 75 Equity Research Notes (cont’d) Metals & Minerals .... 51 Q1/09 Marked-to-Market Metal Prices INTRADAY NOTES (published April 2, 2009) Dorel Industries Inc. (DII.B-T) C$19.75 .... 58 BUY (Unchanged);Target: C$26.00 (Unchanged) Dorel Refocuses Recreational Segment into Five Centers Energy Savings Income Fund (SIF.UN-T) C$10.68 .... 61 HOLD (Unchanged);Target: C$11.50 (Unchanged) Q4/F09 Guidance Up Primarily On Windfall Gas Margins Labopharm Inc. (DDS-T, DDSS-Q) C$1.64 .... 63 HOLD (Unchanged);Target: C$2.50 (Unchanged) Tramadol-Acetaminophen Falls Short
  • 3. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 3 of 75 Equity Research Tim James, CFA Scott Farley, CA (Associate) Transportation/Aerospace Recommendation: BUY Unchanged Risk: HIGH Bombardier Inc. 12-Month Target Price: US$4.00↓ (BBD.B-T) US$2.71 Prior: US$5.00 12-Month Total Return: 50.6% Q4/09 Review; Strong Quarter With Weakening Outlook Market Data (US$) Current Price $2.71 Event 52-Wk Range $1.72-$8.80 Bombardier reported Q4/09 results on April 2nd. Reported EPS increased to Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm) $4,752.8 EV ($mm) $4,682.1 $0.17 from $0.12 a year earlier, exceeding our estimate and consensus of Dividend per Share $0.08 $0.14. Dividend Yield 3.0% Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths) 12,044,540 Impact - Neutral Financial Data (US$) Fiscal Y-E January Based on Q4/09 results, our updated industry outlook and guidance provided, Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm) 1,753.8 we are maintaining our FY10 EPS estimate at $0.50 and reducing our FY11 Float Shares (mm) 1,753.8 estimate to $0.40 (from $0.49). We have reduced our target EPS and Net Cash ($mm) $295.0 EBITDA multiples to 8.0x (from 9.0x) and 4.5x (from 5.0x) to reflect current Net Debt/Tot Cap NA BVPS (f.d.) $1.45 market conditions which combined with lower FY11 earnings expectations Cash ($mm) $4,247.0 results in a decline in our price target to US$4.00. We are maintaining our Estimates (US$) BUY recommendation. Year 2008A 2009A 2010E 2011E EBITDA ($mm) 1,352.0 1,937.0 1,998.8 1,612.8 While we acknowledge that the outlook for the commercial aerospace EBITDA (old)($mm) 1,352.0 1,937.0 1,850.4 1,627.1 industry continues to weaken, we continue to believe Bombardier is EPS (f.d.) 0.26 0.56 0.50 0.40 undervalued at current levels. We believe the company’s strong balance EPS (f.d.)(old) 0.26 0.56 0.50 0.49 sheet, order backlog and Transportation segment potential will allow EPS (f.d.) Quarterly Estimates (US$) Bombardier to weather the current economic downturn more successfully than Year 2008A 2009A 2010E 2011E Q1 0.04 0.12 0.12 -- current multiples imply. Q2 0.05 0.14 0.13 -- Q3 0.05 0.14 0.12 -- We emphasize that negative Aerospace industry news flow is expected to Q4 0.12 0.17 0.13 -- continue for the next several quarters, and to the extent the market continues Valuations to key on this data, Bombardier’s share price may be challenged to move Year 2008A 2009A 2010E 2011E materially higher. However, on a fundamental value basis, we consider EV/EBITDA 3.5x 2.4x 2.3x 2.9x P/E (f.d.) 10.4x 4.8x 5.4x 6.8x Bombardier shares to be attractive at current levels. Aerospace: All figures in US$, unless otherwise specified. • Revenues declined 4% compared to a year earlier on a 29% decrease in business jet deliveries. We had forecast a 6% decline. • EBITDA excluding Other income increased 13% to $364 million, representing 13.1% of revenue and a 190bp improvement year-over- year. The improvement was attributable to higher selling prices, a more favourable product mix and lower S&GA. BBD.B-T: Price Company Profile 10 10 A global corporation headquartered in Canada, Bombardier manufactures 8 8 transportation solutions ranging from regional aircraft and business jets to rail 6 6 transportation equipment. Its revenues for 4 4 the fiscal year ended January 31, 2009 were Please see the final pages of US$19.7 billion and its shares are traded on this document for important 2 2 the Toronto Stock Exchange (BBD.B). 2006 2007 2008 disclosure information.
  • 4. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 4 of 75 Equity Research • Included in the EBITDA result is a write-down of used business jet inventory values which we estimate represented approximately 70 bps of margin. • Bombardier received 6 net orders in the quarter including 19 net business jet cancellations and 25 net Q400 orders, down from the 204 net orders received in Q4/08. These figures were revised downwards by 11 net orders from data disclosed on February 5th. Exhibit 1: Bombardier Inc. – Q4/09 Financial Performance Q3/F09 Growth Millions of U.S. Dollars except per share amounts Q4/F09 Q4/F08 Growth Revenues Aerospace 2,777 2,893 (4%) (2%) Transportation 2,652 2,377 12% 21% 5,429 5,270 3% 8% EBITDA (before Other expense (income)) Aerospace 364 256 42% 32% Margin 13.1% 8.8% 4.3% 3.4% EBITDA Excluding One-time items & EOAPC 364 323 13% (6%) Margin Excluding One-time Items & EOAPC 13.1% 11.2% 1.9% (0.4%) Transportation 215 135 59% 37% Margin 8.1% 5.7% 2.4% 0.7% Margin Excluding One-time Items 8.1% 5.7% 2.4% 0.7% 579 391 48% 34% Total Margin 10.7% 7.4% 3.2% 1.8% Margin Excluding One-time Items & EOAPC 10.7% 8.7% 2.0% (0.3%) EBIT (before Other expense (income)) Aerospace 255 157 62% 45% Margin 9.2% 5.4% 3.8% 2.7% Transportation 185 107 73% 53% Margin 7.0% 4.5% 2.5% 1.0% 440 264 66.7% 47.5% Total Margin 8.1% 5.0% 3.1% 1.7% Income (loss) for the period 309 218 42% 169% Margin 5.7% 4.1% 1.6% 3.2% Earnings per Share - Basic & Diluted From Continuing Operations $0.17 $0.12 42% 183% Net Income (loss) $0.17 $0.12 42% 183% Net Debt to Total Capitalization -13.1% -19.3% Total Debt to Trailing EBITDA 2.0x 3.2x Average US$/C$ exchange rate 0.816 1.007 (19.0%) (6.7%) Regional Jets Deliveries 19 19 0% (41%) Net Orders 0 31 (100%) 300% Regional Turbo-props Deliveries 18 19 (5%) (25%) Net Orders 25 19 32% 20% Business Jets Deliveries 54 76 (29%) (0%) Net Orders (19) 154 (112%) (57%) Source: Company reports, TD Newcrest estimates.
  • 5. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 5 of 75 Equity Research Transportation: • Transportation revenue increased 12% to $2.7 billion, slightly below our forecast of 17% growth, but still representing a strong result in our view. U.S. dollar appreciation was estimated to have reduced growth by approximately 12%. • EBITDA excluding Other income increased 59% to $215 million and margin by 240bps to 8.1%. Management attributed the improvement to better contract execution, increased overhead absorption and a declining impact from several low margin contracts. • Order intake remained strong at $2.6 billion, representing a 1.0x book-to-bill. This is slightly below the 1.4x book to bill ratio reported over the previous eight quarters. Order backlog declined $6.2 billion from a year earlier, largely due to unfavourable currency movements and a contract cancellation. Balance Sheet: • Bombardier reported negative FCF of $91 million compared to $924 million a year earlier. Aerospace FCF declined $825 million, significantly more than expected and accounting for 83% of the decrease. Transportation FCF declined in-line with estimates at $165 million. The decline in Aerospace was attributable to a build-up in aircraft inventories arising from higher cancellations and deferrals, and a decrease in customer advances. • The company reported cash of $3.5 billion at year-end with no debt maturities until May 2012. Required debt and capital lease repayments over the next three years total $29 million. The amount available under current facilities is $760 million. • Included in inventory at year-end were 19 new and 29 used aircraft valued at $448 million and compared to the $176 million in inventory at the end of Q3/09. • Bombardier estimated its calendar 2009 pension funding requirements at $400 million, compared to $332 million in 2008. This is a relatively moderate increase as a result of the offsetting impacts of a lower discount rate on liabilities and weak return on plan assets in 2008. Outlook • FY10 business jet deliveries are expected to be 25% below FY09, compared to the 10% reduction indicated on February 5th. Bombardier’s Learjet unit continues to face the deepest cuts, but Challenger and Global aircraft will also be affected. • The magnitude of additional reductions was not surprising, and remains relatively small in comparison to those announced by direct competitors. Gulfstream has guided to a 38% year-over-year decline and Cessna recently announced a second round of production cuts (unquantified) subsequent to its initial 20% reduction. We have assumed a year-over-year decline of 30% in our forecast (vs 18% previously). • Management guided to “single-digit”, constant-currency revenue growth within the Transportation segment. This compares to estimated Q4/09 and FY09 constant-currency growth of 24%. The EBIT margin target of 6% for the year was re-iterated. • FCF is expected to continue to be weak during the first half of the year, before improving during the second half. As comparables become easier and the inventory build-up is reduced, year-over-year declines in FCF are expected to moderate relative to Q4/09. • Maintenance capital spending will be reduced where possible, but there is no plan to reduce capital expenditures related to new aerospace development projects. Valuation Bombardier is currently trading at 5.4x estimated FY10 EPS and estimated 6.8x FY11 EPS. On an EBITDA basis, it is currently trading at 2.3x FY10 and 2.9x FY11 respectively. This compares to comparables which are trading at 9.4x 2009 and 9.7x 2010 EPS, and 5.4x and 5.8x 2009 and 2010 EBITDA respectively.
  • 6. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 6 of 75 Equity Research Exhibit 2: Bombardier Inc. – Comparables Table Share Price Earnings Per Share EBITDA CAGR P/E EV/EBITDA Shares O/S Mkt Cap Five-year EV/Revenue Net debt to TTM EBITDA Backlog to TTM Company Symbol 2-Apr-09 2008 2009E 2010E 10E vs. 08 2008 2009E 2010E P/Book Trailing 2008 2009E 2010E (millions) (millions) CAGR Revs Trailing Capitalization Margin Revenue Aerospace Companies CAE Inc. ($CAD) CAE $7.96 255.0 $2,029.5 4.7% $0.77 $0.68 $0.67 (2.7%) 10.4x 11.7x 11.9x 1.8x 6.0x 5.9x 6.2x 6.2x 1.4x 18.8% 23.9% 1.9x The Boeing Company ($US) BA $37.20 726.1 $27,012.0 3.8% $6.12 $5.01 $4.94 13.0% 6.1x 7.4x 7.5x NA 5.7x 5.7x 4.4x 4.5x 0.5x <0% 9.0% 5.3x € 1.95 € 1.20 € 1.30 European Aeronautic & Defense (€) EAD € 9.45 814.8 € 7,698.8 7.5% (11.1%) 4.8x 7.9x 7.2x 0.7x 0.3x NA NA NA 0.0x <0% 10.3% 9.3x Embraer SA ($US) ERJ $15.12 185.1 $2,799.0 NA $2.24 $2.36 $2.66 (1.1%) 6.7x 6.4x 5.7x 1.3x 3.5x 3.5x 3.9x 3.6x 0.3x <0% 9.6% 3.3x Textron Inc. ($US) TXT $7.13 242.9 $1,732.2 7.8% $3.17 $1.07 $1.51 (16.4%) 2.2x 6.7x 4.7x 0.7x 7.2x 7.3x 11.1x 10.4x 0.9x 81.8% 12.0% 1.6x 6.0% -3.7% 6.1x 8.0x 7.4x 1.1x 4.6x 5.6x 6.4x 6.2x 0.6x 50.3% 13.0% 4.3x Diversified Companies General Electric Corp. ($US) GE $10.74 10,569.0 $113,511.1 6.2% $1.72 $0.97 $0.91 (11.4%) 6.2x 11.1x 11.8x 1.1x 16.4x 16.5x NA NA 3.0x 80.6% 18.3% 0.9x € 1.90 € 4.88 € 4.79 Siemens Corp. (€) SIE € 44.95 914.2 € 41,093.4 0.8% 21.1% 23.7x 9.2x 9.4x 1.5x 8.7x 9.3x 6.2x 6.3x 0.7x 34.9% 8.1% NA € 1.39 € 1.39 € 1.52 Finmeccanica SpA (€) FNC € 9.78 578.2 € 5,651.4 14.9% 14.5% 7.0x 7.0x 6.4x 0.9x 5.0x 5.0x 4.1x 3.8x 0.6x 36.2% 12.0% 2.9x United Technologies Corp. ($US) UTX $45.94 942.3 $43,289.0 13.6% $4.90 $4.20 $4.45 (5.6%) 9.4x 10.9x 10.3x 2.7x 5.6x 5.6x 6.5x 6.3x 0.9x 31.0% 15.2% 1.0x Average 8.9% 4.6% 11.6x 9.6x 9.5x 1.6x 8.9x 9.1x 5.6x 5.5x 1.3x 45.7% 13.4% 1.6x EX-GE 9.8% 10.0% 13.4x 9.1x 8.7x 1.7x 6.4x 6.6x 5.6x 5.5x 0.7x 34.0% 11.8% 1.9x Rail Transportation Companies Alstom (€) ALO € 42.17 287.0 € 12,103.4 (4.6%) € 3.93 € 4.40 € 3.82 0.7% 10.7x 9.6x 11.0x 4.9x 6.0x 5.7x 5.0x 5.6x 0.6x <0% 10.1% 2.6x Vossloh AG (€) VOS € 79.54 13.9 € 1,104.7 5.7% € 6.30 € 6.26 € 6.77 3.2% 12.6x 12.7x 11.7x 2.3x 5.4x 5.4x 5.5x 5.1x 0.8x <0% 13.8% 0.9x Ansaldo STS (€) STS € 11.92 100.0 € 1,192.0 6.8% € 0.78 € 0.80 € 0.85 6.3% 15.4x 14.9x 14.1x NA 7.7x 7.7x 7.2x 6.8x 0.9x <0% 11.8% 2.8x 2.6% 3.4% 12.9x 12.4x 12.3x 3.6x 6.4x 6.3x 5.9x 5.8x 0.8x <0% 11.9% 2.1x Bombardier Inc. ($US) BBD/B C$ 3.35 1754.1 C$ 5,876 4.9% $0.56 $0.50 $0.40 (8.8%) 4.8x 5.4x 6.8x 2.1x 3.6x 2.4x 2.3x 2.9x 0.2x <0% 9.8% 2.4x Bombardier Aerospace 13.2% 2.4x Bombardier Transportation 6.4% 2.5x Average All Bombardier Comparables (ex-outliers, greater than 1 standard dev. (minimum of 25%) from mean) 0.1% 8.2x 9.4x 9.7x 1.5x 6.1x 6.4x 5.4x 5.8x 0.8x 34.0% 11.5% 2.4x Bombardier reports all financial results in U.S. Dollars. Share Price in Canadian Dollars. Amounts for Embraer SA are based on U.S. listed ADR. Data for comparables obtained from Bloomberg, except for BBD.B and CAE which are TD Newcrest estimates. Source: Company reports, Bloomberg, TD Newcrest Estimates Justification of Target Price We are reducing our 12-month price target on Bombardier to US$4.00 and maintaining our BUY recommendation. Our price target is based on the average value arrived at through applying an 8.0x multiple to estimated FD EPS for the four quarters ending January 2011 and a 4.5x multiple to estimated EBITDA. We have revised our target multiples downwards slightly to reflect heightened aerospace cyclicality. Key Risks to Target Price Financial fragility of airline customers, aircraft financing availability, sustained long-term strength in oil prices, appreciation of the Canadian dollar, unusual effects on consumer confidence in travel, cost overruns on major projects, subordinate voting share structure (The Beaudoin family owns a majority of the multi-voting A shares, which have account for approximately 64% of total shareholder votes). Investment Conclusion We continue to recommend investors BUY shares in Bombardier. Historical precedents indicate that investments in capital equipment stocks such as Bombardier underperform at this point in the economic cycle. However, historically, Bombardier has traded at significantly higher valuations at this point in the cycle, arguably leaving limited downside risk based on current expectations. We maintain that following additional negative industry news flow over the next six months, investors will shift their focus to the valuation and downside protection provided by the Transportation segment earnings potential.
  • 7. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 7 of 75 Equity Research Exhibit 3: Bombardier Inc. – Historical and Forecasted Operating and Financial Metrics $US millions except per share amounts F2007 F2008 F2009 F2010E F2011E Revenues Manufacturing 10,512 12,508 14,779 14,467 13,117 Services 2,738 3,016 3,117 3,415 3,778 Other 1,632 1,982 1,825 1,456 1,423 Total Revenues 14,882 17,506 19,721 19,339 18,318 Cost of Sales 12,667 14,607 16,049 15,577 14,965 Gross Profit 2,215 2,899 3,672 3,761 3,353 Selling, General & Administrative 929 1,408 1,558 1,586 1,563 Research & Development 173 139 171 177 177 Amortization 518 512 555 570 577 Earnings before IT and Special Items 595 840 1,388 1,429 1,036 Special Items (42) (100) 23 - - Operating Income From Continuing Operations (EBIT) 553 740 1,411 1,429 1,036 Net Income (loss) 268 317 1,008 904 736 Earnings (loss) per share: Basic and diluted From continuing operations $0.12 $0.16 $0.56 $0.50 $0.40 Net income (loss) $0.14 $0.26 $0.56 $0.50 $0.40 Continuing Operations Excluding One-time Items $0.12 $0.25 $0.56 $0.50 $0.40 Aerospace Statistics (units) Aircraft Deliveries Regional Jets 64 62 56 52 45 Growth (42%) (3%) (10%) (7%) (13%) Turboprops 48 66 54 62 55 Growth 71% 38% (18%) 15% (11%) Total Regional Aircraft 112 128 110 114 100 Growth (19%) 14% (14%) 4% (12%) Business Jets 212 232 235 164 133 Growth 8% 9% 1% (30%) (19%) Other Aircraft 2 1 4 4 4 Transportation Statistics ($mlns.) Orders Manufacturing 7,800 7,700 6,300 5,985 7,302 Services 2,500 2,400 2,200 1,782 2,156 System & Signalling 1,500 1,200 1,400 1,120 1,344 11,800 11,300 9,900 8,887 10,802 Growth 61.8% (4.2%) (12.4%) (10.2%) 21.5% Revenues Manufacturing 4,066 4,894 6,663 6,901 6,639 Growth (7%) 20% 36% 4% (4%) Services 1,404 1,474 1,529 1,893 2,218 Growth 6% 5% 4% 24% 17% System & Signalling 1,116 1,425 1,564 1,242 1,209 Growth 17% 28% 10% (21%) (3%) 6,586 7,793 9,756 10,037 10,066 Growth (1%) 18% 25% 3% 0% Source: Company reports, Bloomberg, TD Newcrest Estimates
  • 8. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 8 of 75 Equity Research Greg Barnes Bonita To (Associate) Metals & Minerals Recommendation: HOLD↓ Prior: BUY Risk: HIGH Cameco Corp. 12-Month Target Price: C$24.00↓ (CCO-T, CCJ-N) C$22.10 Unchanged 12-Month Total Return: 9.7% Downgrade to Hold - Uranium Price Forecast Lowered Market Data (C$) Current Price $22.10 Event 52-Wk Range $14.33-$44.38 We have lowered our uranium price forecast for 2009 and 2010 on lower spot Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm) $8,402.4 Dividend per Share $0.24 prices – the spot price hit a three-year low on March 30. Dividend Yield 1.1% Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths) 1,935,728 Impact Financial Data (C$) Negative: Our lower uranium price forecast has negatively impacted our Fiscal Y-E Dec Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm) 380.2 estimates for Cameco. We are maintaining our C$24.00 target price, however, Float Shares (mm) 380.2 due to share price appreciation since mid-February, we have downgraded our Net Debt ($mm) $943.8 recommendation to HOLD from Buy. Net Debt/Tot Cap 7.8% NAVPS (current)(f.d.) $17.27 Working Cap ($mm) $1,208.0 Details Estimates (C$) Year 2007A 2008A 2009E 2010E We have lowered our uranium price forecast for 2009 and 2010 on lower spot EBITDA ($mm) 900.0 1,142.0 731.0 1,157.0 prices – the spot price hit a three-year low on March 30. The downward trend EBITDA (old)($mm) 900.0 1,142.0 798.0 1,215.0 in the spot uranium price is continuing, although at a slower rate. Earlier this EPS (f.d.) 1.52 1.59 1.27 2.06 week, Ux Consulting dropped its spot price to US$42.00/lb down US$0.50/lb EPS (f.d.)(old) 1.52 1.59 1.43 2.19 from the previous week. The spot price is now at it slowest level since May CFPS (f.d.) 1.84 2.20 1.36 2.39 CFPS (f.d.)(old) 1.84 2.20 1.52 2.52 2006. Spot demand remains very weak although some “bargain hunting” buying has been evident over the past few weeks. What buying there is EPS (f.d.) Quarterly Estimates (C$) Year 2007A 2008A 2009E 2010E remains highly discretionary. We have lowered our 2009 uranium price Q1 0.10 0.40 0.35 -- forecast to US$50/lb (previously US$60/lb). Our lower forecast is based on a Q2 0.51 0.39 0.30 -- weaker year-to-date price, which has averaged US$47/lb versus our forecast Q3 0.74 0.41 0.32 -- of US$60/lb. With few near-term catalysts (utility buying remains highly Q4 0.17 0.47 0.30 -- discretionary and speculative buying has disappeared), we do not expect a Valuations significant move higher in uranium prices over the course of 2009, barring a Year 2007A 2008A 2009E 2010E major supply interruption. We continue to believe that the longer-term supply EV/EBITDA 10.5x 8.3x 12.9x 8.2x P/E (f.d.) 14.5x 13.9x 17.4x 10.7x picture is very challenged with the majority of new supply dependant upon P/CFPS (f.d.) 12.0x 10.0x 16.3x 9.2x two mega-projects (Cigar Lake and Olympic Dam expansion) for which no Supplemental Data (US$) production clarity is evident – in our view, it could be the second half of the Year 2007E 2008A 2009E 2010E next decade before these two projects add meaningfully to supply. Uranium ($/lb) 98.54 63.83 50.00 65.00 Prev. forecast 98.54 63.83 60.00 70.00 All figures in C$, unless otherwise specified. CCO-T: Price Company Profile 70 70 Cameco is the world's largest uranium 60 60 producer. While mainly known for its 50 50 uranium and conversion businesses, the company also operates in two other business 40 40 groups that include electricity generation and 30 30 gold production. Please see the final pages of 20 20 this document for important 10 10 2006 2007 2008 disclosure information.
  • 9. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 9 of 75 Equity Research Exhibit 1. Metal Price Forecasts 2009E 2010E 2011E 2012E 2013E 2014E LT US$/lb Old New Old New Old New New New New New ↓ ↓ ↓ Aluminum 0.85 0.90 0.90 0.62 0.70 0.80 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 ↑ ↑ ↑ Copper 1.40 1.60 2.00 1.70 1.90 2.25 2.50 2.50 2.00 1.75 ↓ Lead 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.54 0.60 0.65 0.60 0.50 0.45 0.45 ↑ Nickel 4.31 5.00 6.00 4.56 5.00 6.00 7.00 6.00 6.00 6.00 ↑ Zinc 0.52 0.60 0.85 0.56 0.60 0.85 1.00 0.80 0.75 0.75 Coal* 125 150 150 125 150 150 125 100 90 90 ↓ ↓ Uranium 60 70 70 50 65 70 70 60 50 50 FX (US$/C$) 0.83 0.85 0.85 0.83 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 *US$/tonne, fob Source: TD Newcrest. We present changes to our estimates in the Exhibit 2 — our estimates have decreased due to our lower uranium price forecast. Exhibit 2. New Estimates EPS CFPS EBITDA (mm) Old Old Old New New New $1.52 $1.84 $900 2007A $1.52 $1.84 $900 $1.59 $2.20 $1,142 2008A $1.59 $2.20 $1,142 $1.43 $1.52 $798 2009E $1.27 $1.36 $731 $2.19 $2.52 $1,215 2010E $2.06 $2.39 $1,157 Source: TD Newcrest. Valuation Cameco currently trades at an EV/2009 EBITDA multiple of 12.9x and a P/NAV multiple of 1.3x, compared to its large cap peer group average of 8.3x and 0.5x, respectively. Justification of Target Price Our target price is based upon an EV/blended 2009-2010 EBITDA multiple of 9.5x (60% weighting) and a 1.3x multiple to our 10% NAV (40% weighting, adjusted for the market valuation of Centerra). Key Risks to Target Price The main risks facing the company include forecast, financial, technical and political risks. Among other things, these include risks related to uranium prices, input costs, and fuel prices, the governing fiscal and legislative regimes, the timing of key developments, market conditions, capital and operating costs, foreign exchange rates, resources and reserves, operating parameters, permitting, environmental, and staffing and key personnel retention. Our forecast of Cameco’s realized price could be substantially different than that actually realized by the company. Because Cameco is primarily a uranium mining and processing company, it faces heightened environmental risks relative to other mining companies. Cameco is developing two new mines, the Cigar Lake mine in Northern Saskatchewan and the Inkai operation in Kazakhstan that could face development cost overruns or delayed schedules that are inherent in new mine construction. With its available cash and
  • 10. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 10 of 75 Equity Research credit facilities, we believe there exists heightened M&A risk, which could impact our estimates and valuation for the company. Investment Conclusion We have lowered our recommendation to HOLD (from Buy) while our target price remains unchanged at C$24.00. Our recommendation reflects the limited return to our target price, our benign forecast for the uranium market over the next 12-18 months and our view that M&A risk has increased following management’s statements that it is actively pursuing a C$1-2 billion acquisition. We estimate that following the completion of a C$440 million equity issue in early March, Cameco has approximately C$1.1 billion in available cash and credit facilities with which it could pursue an acquisition. We estimate the company’s net debt/net debt-plus-equity ratio at approximately 13% post the equity issue. We believe that Cameco could pursue acquisitions that would be additive to its production profile within the nearer term. Our model and company guidance suggests that the company’s production profile is effectively flat through 2013 (excluding Cigar Lake) at 20-22 million pounds U3O8 per annum. We also expect that if investors start to look forward to 2010 with a view that economic growth could start to stabilize, Cameco’s defensive attributes could become less attractive.
  • 11. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 11 of 75 Equity Research Greg Shaw, CFA Joel Douglas, CA (Associate) Oil & Gas Producers Recommendation: BUY Unchanged Risk: HIGH Celtic Exploration Ltd. 12-Month Target Price: C$17.50 (CLT-T) C$13.68 Unchanged 12-Month Total Return: 27.9% Equity Adds To Financial Flexibility Market Data (C$) Current Price $13.68 Event 52-Wk Range $9.19-$21.05 Celtic bought deal financing Mkt Cap (f.d.)($mm) $641.6 Dividend per Share -- Dividend Yield -- Impact Avg. Daily Trading Vol. (3mths) 158367 Neutral Financial Data (C$) Fiscal Y-E December 31 Shares O/S (f.d.)(mm) 46.9 Details Shares O/S (basic)(mm) 43.7 Celtic announced a bought deal to issue 2.75 million common shares, Float Shares (mm) -- including the over allotment, at $13.25 per share that represented a 4% Net Debt ($mm) $146.1 discount to the April 1 closing price. The issue provides gross proceeds of Net Debt/Tot Cap -- $36.4 million that will be initially used to reduce bank debt. The issue is Estimates (C$) expected to close on April 23, 2009. Year 2007A 2008A 2009E 2010E EPS (f.d.) 0.23 1.10 0.37 0.67 CFPS (f.d.) 2.30 3.24 3.05 4.14 On a NAV basis, we believe the equity issue to be largely neutral, while our CFPS (f.d.)(old) -- -- 3.18 4.36 2009E CFPS declines to $3.05 from $3.18 and our 2010E CFPS declines to Oil (b/d) 3,110 3,400 3,340 3,050 $4.14 from $4.36. With the issue, we believe that Celtic improves its financial Gas (MMcf/d) 28.6 46.0 62.4 86.3 flexibility. Post the issue we estimate Celtic will have ~$150 million of net Supplemental Data debt drawn ($120 million proforma Q4/08 bank debt) under the bank facility Year 2007A 2008A 2009E 2010E of $200 million. Proceeds from the issue will ultimately be used to fund their WTI (US$bbl) $72.23 $99.92 $50.00 $70.00 2009E capital program and for general corporate purposes. NYMEX (US$) $6.97 $8.89 $5.00 $7.00 AECO (C$) $6.45 $8.20 $5.15 $7.25 The company continues to focus on its Kaybob Montney development F/X (US$) $0.93 $0.94 $0.81 $0.83 program which provides attractive economics that were further improved with the Alberta Government’s recently announced stimulus incentives for drilling. All figures in C$, unless otherwise specified. We continue to believe the strong incentives for the Kaybob Montney will translate into an expanded program and anticipate Celtic will review its capital program as part of Q1/09 reporting. We have not increased our forecasts at this time. We provide a review of the Celtic Kaybob Montney opportunity on page 2 of this report. Our BUY rating and target of $17.50 remain unchanged. We believe Celtic is well positioned for growth in 2009, with a multi-year development program at Kaybob that provides attractive returns. In addition, Celtic’s active hedging program provides an estimated $41 million of gains in 2009 that supports development drilling. Celtic trades at a P/NAV based on current futures of 100%, compared to the coverage group average of 70%. CLT-T: Price Company Profile 22 22 Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT) is a Canadian 20 20 oil and natural gas exploration, development 18 18 and production company with properties in 16 16 southern, east central, west central and 14 14 northern Alberta. The company commenced 12 12 operations in September 2002. Please see the final pages of 10 10 this document for important 8 8 2006 2007 2008 disclosure information.
  • 12. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 12 of 75 Equity Research Kaybob Montney Main Focus For 2009 Celtic has identified up to 134 net future drilling locations (46 booked in the 2008 reserves) on 5 identified Montney pools, including at Kaybob South and KayFox where Celtic received downspacing approval to 5 wells per section in 2009. Celtic estimates all-in costs of roughly $3.2 million per Hz Montney well with up to 11 multi-stage fracture stimulations per Hz well. Montney wells are generally expected to recover 2-3 bcf/well and have average first year production of roughly 1.9 mmcf/d. Celtic currently plans a 2009 corporate drilling program of 45-50 wells (80% Hz wells) that will largely be focused on the Montney opportunity. Celtic plans to have 4 rigs on its Greater Kaybob properties over spring break-up, with 3 rigs dedicated to Montney opportunities and the other rig dedicated to Bluesky opportunities. Throughout break-up we believe Celtic could drill four to seven wells with these rigs (1 Bluesky well). Celtic management has indicated the service providers have agreed only to charge for operated time during break-up. The economics with Celtic’s Hz Montney wells have improved significantly as a result of the Alberta Government’s March 2009 announcement that was geared to stimulate drilling activity by providing drilling incentives and new production incentives. Exhibit 1 illustrates the government’s new production incentive improves after tax rate of return by 30% based on a NYMEX price of US$5.00/mcf (15% increase based on a NYMEX price of US$4.00/mcf). Exhibit 1. Kaybob Montney Well Economics Celtic Kaybob Montney 250.0% 200.0% 150.0% AT ROR 100.0% 50.0% 0.0% $3.00 $4.00 $5.00 $6.00 $7.00 $8.00 Nymex Price ($/mcf) Pre NWRR Post NWRR Source: GeoScout, TD Newcrest Under the drilling incentive program Celtic is eligible for drilling credits of $200 per meter for wells drilled between April 1, 2009 and March 31, 2010, with the drilling credits to offset Celtic’s corporate crown royalties payable between April 1, 2009 and March 31, 2011. With an average measured depth of 3,700 meters per Kaybob Hz Montney well, Celtic is eligible for royalty credits of $740,000 per Hz well (on average). Based on a $3.2 million cost per well, this represents roughly 23% of the cost of the well. Combined with the new well royalty savings, Celtic is positioned to save up to 44% of the cost of each Hz Kaybob Montney well based on a NYMEX price of US$5.00/mcf. Our calculation assumes full recovery of the drilling incentive credits. On our forecasts and based on Celtic’s maximum royalty credit (50%) we estimate Celtic could potentially save $48 million in royalties between April 1, 2009 and December 31, 2010 under the drilling incentive program. This implies Celtic would need to drill roughly 240,000 meters, which equates to roughly 65 Hz Montney wells (average 3,700 meters/well) before March 31, 2010 (note the drilling incentive credit does not just apply to
  • 13. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 13 of 75 Equity Research Montney wells). Again we note Celtic’s current capital budget targets 45-50 wells in 2009, of which 80% will be Hz wells. Estimate revisions The announced bought deal to issue 2.75 million common shares, including the over allotment, represents a 6% increase in the fully dilutes shares outstanding. With an issue price of $13.25/share, the equity issue provides proceeds of $36.4 million that will likely be used initially to repay debt. The purpose of the issue is to fund capital development activities and for general corporate purposes. Exhibit 2. Celtic Exploration: Estimate Revisions 2009E 2010E New Old Change New Old Change Oil Bbl/d 3,340 3,340 0% 3,050 3,050 0% Gas Mmcf/d 62.4 62.4 0% 86.3 86.3 0% Production 13,750 13,750 0% 17,440 17,440 0% % Gas % 76% 76% 83% 83% Revenue* $mln $190 $190 0% $329 $329 0% Revenue* $/boe $37.93 $37.93 0% $51.72 $51.72 0% Capital expenditures $mln $130 $130 0% $170 $170 0% Cash Flow $mln $132 $131 1% $182 $180 1% CFPS (f.d.) $/share $3.05 $3.18 -4% $4.14 $4.36 -5% Net Debt $mln $137 $168 -19% $126 $158 -21% Net Debt/CF x 1.0x 1.3x -19% 0.7x 0.9x -22% Commodity prices WTI US$/bbl $50.00 $50.00 $70.00 $70.00 AECO $/mcf $5.15 $5.15 $7.25 $7.25 Source: TD Newcrest Exhibit 3. Celtic Exploration: Cash Flow Sensitivities CFPS - 2009E (FX fixed at $0.81) CFPS - 2010E (FX fixed at $0.83) WTI (US$/Bbl) WTI (US$/Bbl) $5.40 $40.00 $45.00 $50.00 $55.00 $60.00 $6 $60.00 $65.00 $70.00 $75.00 $80.00 $4.65 $2.77 $2.79 $2.81 $2.84 $2.86 $6.25 $3.29 $3.41 $3.52 $3.63 $3.74 AECO (C$/Mcf) AECO (C$/Mcf) $4.90 $2.89 $2.92 $2.94 $2.96 $2.99 $6.75 $3.60 $3.72 $3.83 $3.94 $4.05 $5.15 $3.02 $3.04 $3.05 $3.09 $3.11 $7.25 $3.91 $4.03 $4.14 $4.25 $4.36 $5.40 $3.14 $3.17 $3.19 $3.21 $3.24 $7.75 $4.22 $4.34 $4.45 $4.56 $4.67 $5.65 $3.27 $3.29 $3.32 $3.34 $3.36 $8.25 $4.53 $4.65 $4.76 $4.87 $4.98 Net Debt to Cash Flow - 2009E Net Debt to Cash Flow - 2010E WTI (US$/Bbl) WTI (US$/Bbl) $0.15 $40.00 $45.00 $50.00 $55.00 $60.00 $0 $60.00 $65.00 $70.00 $75.00 $80.00 $4.65 1.2x 1.2x 1.2x 1.2x 1.2x $6.25 1.1x 1.1x 1.0x 0.9x 0.9x AECO (C$/Mcf) AECO (C$/Mcf) $4.90 1.2x 1.1x 1.1x 1.1x 1.1x $6.75 0.9x 0.9x 0.8x 0.8x 0.7x $5.15 1.1x 1.0x 1.0x 1.0x 1.0x $7.25 0.8x 0.7x 0.7x 0.6x 0.6x $5.40 1.0x 1.0x 0.9x 0.9x 0.9x $7.75 0.7x 0.6x 0.6x 0.5x 0.5x $5.65 0.9x 0.9x 0.9x 0.9x 0.8x $8.25 0.5x 0.5x 0.5x 0.4x 0.4x Source: TD Newcrest Valuation Base NAV Multiples Company Share Price (Futures) P/NAV Operational NAV Subjective Target Celtic $13.68 $13.65 100% 1.03x 1.19x 1.15x $17.50 Group Average 77% 1.05x 1.09x 1.15x Source: TD Newcrest
  • 14. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 14 of 75 Equity Research Justification of Target Price Our valuation methodology reflects a combination of an after-tax NAV assumption (adjusted for Celtic's growth profile), which, in turn, is combined with an operational component to achieve a base target price ($15.48), and further adjusted for subjective factors, to arrive at our final target of $17.50/share. The subjective adjustment reflects factors such as management performance and potential execution obstacles, which can result in up to a 20% adjustment to the base target. Our NAV component generally represents roughly 60% of the base target, with the operational component representing the balance of the base target. Exhibit 4. Target Price Components Subjective, Subjective $2.30 13% NAV, NAV Operational Operational, $10.00 57% 30% $5.20 Note: Target components may not add as the target is rounded to the nearest $0.25. Source: TD Newcrest Key Risks to Target Price Key risks associated with this target price include those business risks of the company and industry, including but not limited to: loss of key employees, drilling success, volatile commodity prices and operating costs, product supply and demand, government regulations and taxes, exchange rates, interest rates, environmental and weather concerns, and unfavorable tax legislation. Specific risks to Celtic include asset concentration of the capital program in the Kaybob region. Investment Conclusion Our BUY rating and target of $17.50 remain unchanged. We believe Celtic is well positioned for growth in 2009, with a multi-year development program at Kaybob that provides attractive returns. In addition, Celtic’s active hedging program provides an estimated $41 million of gains in 2009 that supports development drilling. Celtic trades at a P/NAV based on current futures of 100%, compared to the coverage group average of 70%.
  • 15. April 3, 2009 Action Notes 15 of 75 Equity Research Exhibit 5. Corporate Profile Celtic Exploration Ltd. TD Newcrest Ticker CLT-T Rating BUY Target $17.50 Shares Out. 43.7 mln April 2, 2009 Price Risk Return $13.68 High 28% Shares Out. (f.d.) 46.9 mln Celtic Exploration Ltd. (CLT) is a Canadian oil and natural gas exploration, development and production company with properties in southern, east central, west central and northern Alberta. The company commenced operations in September 2002. Share Price High Low Close Commodity Assumptions 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2008 $21.05 $9.19 $12.61 WTI (US$/Bbl) $66.07 $72.23 $99.92 $50.00 $70.00 2007 $15.23 $10.60 $11.20 Nymex (US$/mmbtu) $6.73 $6.97 $8.89 $5.00 $7.00 Mgmt & Director Ownership 19% FX US$/C$ $0.882 $0.931 $0.943 $0.806 $0.830 Cash Flow Sensitivity Production & Capex 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E Liquids Bbl/d 3,280 3,110 3,400 3,340 3,050 2009E Gas Mmcf/d 16.1 28.6 46.0 62.4 86.3 Total BOE/d 5,960 7,870 11,070 13,750 17,440 2010E % Gas % 45% 60% 69% 76% 83% -$0.10 -$0.05 $0.00 $0.05 $0.10 $0.15 $0.20 EV/boe/d $/boepd $100,013 $75,055 $66,069 $56,682 $44,015 Change Per FD Share on Increase in Dev Capex. $mm $173.7 $135.6 $138.4 $130.0 $170.0 WTI (US$1/bbl) AECO (C$0.25/mcf) FX (C$0.01/USD) % of CF % 223% 165% 106% 98% 94% Wells Drilled & Undeveloped Acres Leverage 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2006 2007 2008 Net Debt/CF x 1.4x 1.7x 1.3x 1.0x 0.7x Gross Wells 83.0 65.0 54.0 Bank Credit Facilit $mm $115.0 $165.0 $200.0 $200.0 $200.0 Net Wells 62.8 56.0 41.1 Undrawn % 3% 17% 15% 31% 37% Net Acres 235,300 248,900 246,600 Financial Results 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E Well Data Celtic Peer Avg. Revenue $/BOE $61.27 $55.38 $60.11 $46.08 $51.72 Avg. Time onstream per well Royalties $/BOE $10.90 $11.16 $14.43 $7.20 $10.86 in years. 6.4 4.5 Transportation $/BOE $0.66 $0.87 $0.57 $0.65 $0.68 Time on Production of (Mths): Median Op. Costs $/BOE $10.90 $11.12 $10.21 $9.81 $10.19 Op. Netback $/BOE $38.81 $32.23 $34.90 $28.41 $29.99 Top Well 1.0 14.8 Top 5 Wells 5.6 23.6 G&A* $/BOE $1.42 $1.56 $1.43 $1.28 $1.12 Top 10 Wells 20.4 27.5 EBITDA $/BOE $37.38 $30.67 $33.47 $27.13 $28.87 Production Concentration Risk in: Avg. CFFO $/BOE $35.79 $28.65 $32.22 $26.37 $28.55 Top Well 7% 9% CFFO $mm $77.9 $82.3 $130.6 $132.3 $181.8 Top 5 Wells 17% 22% Per Share $/Share $2.61 $2.32 $3.28 $3.07 $4.16 Top 10 Wells 27% 30% Per Share (f.d.) $/Share $2.48 $2.30 $3.24 $3.05 $4.14 Net Wells Drilled as % of Total Shares Avg (f.d.) mm 31.4 35.8 40.3 43.3 43.9 Producing Wells in: Hedging 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E Last 12 mths 6% 13% Gain/(Loss) $/boe $2.29 $2.68 -$4.88 $8.14 $0.00 Last 24 mths 16% 25% % Hedged % n/a n/a 51% 40% 0% Reserve Last 36 mths 26% 41% TP TP RLI EV/TP boe P+P P+P RLI EV/boe Analysis Percent of Production onstream in: mmboe Years $/boe mmboe Years $/boe Last 12 mths 42% 30% 2008 28,946 6.6 $25.27 53,177 12.0 $13.75 Last 24 mths 60% 48% 2007 20,771 6.2 $28.44 33,773 10.0 $17.49 Last 36 mths 69% 64% 2006 14,874 6.5 $40.08 26,267 11.4 $22.69 FD&A ($/boe) TP F&D TP FD&A Recycle P+P F&D P+P FD&A Recycle Productivity/Well (BOE/d) 24 32 2008 $14.89 $19.46 1.7x $7.28 $12.24 2.6x Operated Production (%) 86% 89% 2007 $22.29 $21.45 1.3x $23.53 $19.27 1.5x Average Working Interest 52% 69% 2006 $27.46 $30.62 1.2x $16.49 $19.44 1.8x NAV 2007 2008 Production per Debt Adjusted Share NAV/Share $/Share $9.42 $13.65 14000 0.25 P/NAV % 145% 100% BOEPD/DA Share (f.d.) 12000 Tax Pool $mm $305 $358 0.20 10000 BOEPD 0.15 Acquisition Summary 8000 6000 0.10 Date P+P mmBOE Boe/d Cost ($mm) 4000 0.05 04/29/2008 4.369 1,140 $45 2000 0 0.00 04/05/2005 7.223 901 $40 Q1/05 Q2/05 Q3/05 Q4/05 Q1/06 Q2/06 Q3/06 Q4/06 Q1/07 Q2/07 Q3/07 Q4/07 Q1/08 Q2/08 Q3/08 Q4/08 10/21/2002 2.1 950 $23 BOEPD BOEPD/DA Share (f.d.) Greg Shaw, CFA 403-292-1204 greg.shaw@tdsecurities.com Joel Douglas, CA (Associate) 403-299-3272 joel.douglas@tdsecurities.com Source: Company Data, TD Newcrest