SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 16
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
INSIDE:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Asian
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Briefings

                                                                                                                                                                                            November 2011




  Receiverships and
   Commercial Real                                                                                                                                                    o   mp
                                                                                                                                                                             li   an
                                                                                                                                                                                       c e Of fi
                                                                                                                                                                                                  ce
                                                                                                                                                                                                       r •
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Ma
                                                                                                                                                                   &C
Estate Loan Defaults                                                                                                                    on
                                                                                                                                             • C
                                                                                                                                                 o   un
                                                                                                                                                          s   el                                             na
                                                                                                                                                                                                               gin
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  gS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       oci
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          al
                                                                                                                                   ti
                                                                                                                           e   gra                                                                                             Me
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    dia
                                                                                                                      nt
                                                                                                                   AI
                                                                                                              M&
                                                                                                          s •
                                                                                                      ion
                                                                                               lu t
                                                                                      g   So
                                                                          fe   i t in
                                                               n   te r
                                                            ou
                                                    ti- C
                                               An

                                          n•
                              ic   t io
                     P   re d
                on
    ig   at i
Lit
M&A Integration
——
Planning the
Integration of an
Acquired Company’s
Legal Department
BY FRANK FLETCHER AND KEITH E. GOTTFRIED

You are the general counsel of BiggerCo, a publicly-held
software and services company with annual revenues of
$600 million based in the heart of California’s Silicon
Valley. Almost three months ago, BiggerCo agreed to
acquire SmallerCo, another publicly-held software and
services company located in Raleigh, N.C., pursuant to
an all-cash, one-step merger transaction that merges
SmallerCo with, and into, BiggerCo. SmallerCo is
relatively comparable in size to BiggerCo, having about
the same revenues and an almost equal number of
employees. While the transaction has been structured
as a merger of equals, there is no doubt that BiggerCo is
acquiring SmallerCo and that BiggerCo’s management
team will be running the combined company. Among
the many attractions in buying SmallerCo were its very
significant international operations, as well as its large
government business. SmallerCo’s largest customer is
the US government. In contrast, BiggerCo has not, to
date, been successful in expanding overseas or in selling
to the US government.


                                      ACC Docket   57 November 2011
When the acquisition of SmallerCo                                                              more than their SmallerCo counterparts,
                                                                FRANK FLETCHER is the general
was first announced, many investors                               counsel of Nero AG, a developer   partly due to the increased cost of liv-
thought that BiggerCo had overpaid for                           of platform-neutral software      ing in Silicon Valley. While BiggerCo
                                                                 technology for editing and
SmallerCo. In response to that concern,                          managing video, music, photos     requires all of its outside counsel to
BiggerCo’s stock got walloped. To ad-            and other multimedia, which is headquartered      agree to its law firm retention agreement
                                                 in Karlsbad, Germany, with subsidiaries in
dress investor’s concerns, BiggerCo’s            Hangzhou, China; Yokohama, Japan; and             and related outside counsel policies,
                                                 Glendale, California. Fletcher is responsible for
CEO has been spending a lot of time on           all aspects of the company’s worldwide legal
                                                                                                   SmallerCo has no such process in place
the road touting the expected benefits of         function, including mergers and acquisitions,     and generally just executes whatever
                                                 software licensing, patents, trademarks,
the acquisition. Nevertheless, investors         antipiracy and litigation. Prior to joining Nero, engagement letter is sent to it by its law
remain skeptical and are particularly            he was a member of the products and               firm. Having just completed a lengthy
                                                 technologies law group at Sun Microsystems,
concerned with whether BiggerCo has              where he served as chief counsel for the CPU      “beauty contest” process to reduce the
the ability to successfully integrate the        manufacturing, testing and validation groups,     number of law firms it uses, BiggerCo
                                                 as well as the global business services group.
two companies.                                   He can be contacted at ffletcher@nero.com.         now uses only a handful of law firms
    With the closing of the acquisition of                                                         for most of its corporate, litigation and
                                                                KEITH E. GOTTFRIED is a partner
SmallerCo now visible on the horizon,                            in the Washington, DC office of    intellectual property work, and some of
                                                                 Blank Rome LLP. He concentrates
BiggerCo’s CEO has asked each of his                             his practice primarily on mergers
                                                                                                   these firms were required to agree to
senior executives, including you, to be                          and acquisitions, corporate       either alternative fee arrangements or
                                                 governance, shareholder activism, securities
ready at the next meeting of the execu-          regulation, NYSE and Nasdaq compliance, and       steep discounts off their standard billing
tive leadership team to present detailed         general corporate matters. Over the course of     rates, in exchange for being designated a
                                                 his career, Gottfried has worked on a number of
plans for integrating the applicable             high-profile mergers and acquisitions across a     “preferred firm.” In contrast, SmallerCo
operations of SmallerCo into their               broad range of industries and sectors. Prior to   uses over a dozen law firms and has
                                                 rejoining Blank Rome, he was the general
functional group, post-closing. Many             counsel of the US Department of Housing and       no discount or alternative fee arrange-
of the functional groups at BiggerCo,            Urban Development, a position to which he was     ments in place with any of them. All of
                                                 appointed by President George W. Bush and
including finance, accounting, market-            unanimously confirmed by the US Senate.            BiggerCo’s securities compliance and
                                                 Previous to that, Gottfried was the general
ing, product management, sales, IT and           counsel of Borland Software Corporation in
                                                                                                   corporate governance work is done by
human resources, have been working on            Cupertino, California. He can be contacted at     outside counsel, and you had not previ-
                                                 gottfried@blankrome.com.
their M&A integration plans for months.                                                            ously contemplated bringing that work
Given that these other functional groups                                                           in-house due to the absence of appropri-
have not been consumed for the past                                                                ate in-house resources. As such, you are
three months with executing the acquisition of SmallerCo,                     pleasantly surprised to learn that SmallerCo has been able
they have had ample time to review the applicable func-                       to bring all this work in-house and you are very impressed
tional group at SmallerCo, and contemplate and develop a                      with the in-house attorneys that service these areas. You
detailed integration plan.                                                    are equally surprised to learn that, notwithstanding how
    As your integration plan will be due shortly, you can’t                   much government contracts work is done by SmallerCo, it
put it off any longer. Where to start? You decide that to                     does not have any in-house government contract attorneys
develop your integration plan you must first assess the situ-                  and that all of the government contracts work is serviced
ation. The majority of SmallerCo’s attorneys are based in                     by outside counsel. With respect to technology, all of the
Raleigh, with several attorneys based overseas to support                     attorneys at BiggerCo have company-paid Blackberries® or
SmallerCo’s international operations. BiggerCo has all                        iPhones.® The attorneys at SmallerCo don’t have any such
of its attorneys based in Silicon Valley and has never had                    devices provided by the company. While BiggerCo uses a
attorneys based overseas. SmallerCo’s GC will move into                       state-of-the-art document management system that allows
the organizational framework at BiggerCo, but an exact                        all of the attorneys in the legal department to have access
role has not been identified, though it most likely will be                    to each other’s documents, no such system has ever been
some type of corporate development or corporate affairs                       deployed at SmallerCo.
role. While the BiggerCo legal department did not use such                         As you begin to tackle your legal department integration
titles as “assistant general counsel” or “associate general                   plan, you notice that, unlike many of the projects you take
counsel,” all of the attorneys at SmallerCo (other than the                   on, this one seems not to have any precedent or canned
GC) had the title “assistant general counsel” or “associ-                     checklists to look to. You check with your outside counsel
ate general counsel.” In addition, there is significant pay                    and none of them have any sample M&A integration plans
disparity between attorneys in BiggerCo’s legal depart-                       for a legal department. It seems impossible to believe that,
ment compared to those in SmallerCo’s legal department,                       with all the M&A transactions that get done in Silicon
with the BiggerCo attorneys being paid almost 20 percent                      Valley and beyond, nobody has ever sat down and prepared


                                                      ACC Docket     58 November 2011
DISCOVERY & DISPUTE SERVICES CENTER




Innovative. Efficient. Responsive.
McDermott stands behind the commitment to helping clients address the
demands of discovery in the electronic age, from retention through review.




                                                                                                                                                           www.mwe.com

Boston Brussels Chicago Düsseldorf Houston London Los Angeles Miami Milan Munich New York Orange County Paris Rome Silicon Valley Washington, D.C.
Strategic alliance with MWE China Law Offices (Shanghai)

McDermott Will & Emery conducts its practice through separate legal entities in each of the countries where it has offices. This communication may be considered attorney advertising.
Previous results are not a guarantee of future outcome.
The lack of attention                                              ACC Extras on…
                                                                     Integration of an Acquired
  to developing effective                                            Company’s Legal Department
  strategies for integrating
                                                                     ACC Docket
  an acquired company’s legal                                        • Due Diligence and Your M&A Success Story

  department is extremely                                              (Sept. 2011). www.acc.com/docket/success-story_sep11


  short-sighted and causes                                           InfoPAKSM
                                                                     • Organizational Effectiveness: The New Imperative
  many companies to miss the                                           for Developing a World-Class Legal Department
                                                                       (July 2011). www.acc.com/infopaks/wcld_jul11
  numerous opportunities
                                                                     Top Tens
  that may be presented by                                           • Top Ten Things to Do When Your
  the acquired company.                                                Company Is Acquired (Aug. 2011).
                                                                       www.acc.com/topten/comp-acquired_aug11
                                                                     • Top Ten Best Practices for Merger Transactions
                                                                       from a Litigator’s Perspective (Aug. 2011).
a detailed plan for how to combine the legal departments               www.acc.com/topten/merger-trans_aug11
of two public companies. The more you think about it, the
more issues come to mind, and there will be no shortage of           Presentation
issues to consider and address in planning the integration.          • Adding Value: Strategic Planning and
Clearly, having a detailed roadmap to guide you would                  Demonstrating Success (May 2011).
have been extremely helpful.                                           www.acc.com/strat-planning_may11
    This scenario may seem familiar to many of you. Like
the fictional in-house counsel depicted above, we also be-            Article
lieve that a detailed roadmap for planning and executing on          • Mergers and Acquisitions (Fraser Milner Casgrain
the integration of an acquired company’s legal department              LLP) (June 2010). www.acc.com/m&a-fraser_jun10
would be very useful. In our experience, the integration of
an acquired company’s legal department is rarely given the              ACC has more material on this subject on our website.
thought and attention it deserves. There are many reasons            Visit www.acc.com, where you can browse our resources
for this, including that a legal department is often viewed          by practice area or search by keyword.
as a cost center, and the development of a well-executed
integration plan could be expensive in the near-term. In ad-
dition, as noted above, a public company’s legal department       are currently not being actively used — that can be poten-
is generally not lacking for projects to keep it busy, if not     tially recycled for the acquired company’s products. There
consumed, and there is little “down time” or even incen-          may also be numerous “leaky faucets” in the acquired com-
tive to be strategic. How likely is a legal department to get     pany’s legal department that can be quickly turned off to
approval for additional headcount, or a budget to plan and        produce significant cost savings. Obvious areas here would
execute an M&A integration? We believe that the lack of           be franchise taxes for unused subsidiaries, trademark
attention to developing effective strategies for integrating      maintenance fees for marks that will never be used again,
an acquired company’s legal department is extremely short-        outside counsel who are being inefficiently managed and
sighted and causes many companies to miss the numerous            retained at much higher rates than what the acquirer typi-
opportunities that may be presented by the acquired com-          cally pays, license fees for software that is not being used,
pany. For instance, a thoughtful integration plan may, with       retainers for consultants who are not being used, and fees
regards to the review of the acquired company’s intellec-         for warehouse space to store files that is not being used.
tual property, uncover inventions that are still patentable.      In addition, a thoughtful integration plan could uncover
A thoughtful integration plan may also uncover unused             lawsuits and other claims where there is an opportunity —
trademarks that have been extremely well-protected — but          that theretofore had not been fully explored — to expedi-


                                                ACC Docket      60 November 2011
Macro
   view.
   Micro
   focus.
    One
 law firm.


  The attorneys at Saul Ewing
 examine legal issues through
  different lenses, combining
big-picture analysis with scrutiny
  of the finer details. Getting
   multiple perspectives from
  the same law firm gives our
  clients a singular advantage.




        www.saul.com
            DELAWARE
            MARYLAND
        MASSACHUSETTS
           NEW JERSEY
            NEW YORK
          PENNSYLVANIA
         WASHINGTON, DC

    Celebrating 90 Years

For more information please contact
 Managing Partner, David S. Antzis
 610.251.5055 / dantzis@saul.com
tiously resolve the matter, which could result in a signifi-
Five Ways to Doom                                                    cant reduction in legal fees being paid to outside counsel.
an M&A Transaction                                                   There may even be cases where the acquired company can
                                                                     reap a very attractive settlement payment from a defendant,
1.    Execute poorly on the M&A integration or
                                                                     but in the midst of the acquired company’s sales process,
      do not complete it on a timely basis.
                                                                     no one had been willing to engage with the defendant and
2.    Pay insufficient attention to customers (and employees)         its counsel to work out the mechanics of a settlement.
      as the kinks in the integration are worked out.                    Based on our M&A experiences, and particularly,
3.    Miss the landmines in due diligence.                           reflecting back on our past experiences in integrating an
4.    Overpay.                                                       acquired company’s legal department and being integrated
                                                                     into a acquirer’s legal department, we have prepared an
5.    Forget what it is you are buying (particularly in
                                                                     extensive list of issues that should be considered and ad-
      a services business when it is people).
                                                                     dressed sooner rather than later (hopefully, prior to the
                                                                     closing of the acquisition), as you begin to plan the integra-
                                                                     tion of an acquired company’s legal department with that
                                                                     of the acquirer, thus ensuring a smooth transition and a
Twenty-Five Key Areas of Focus                                       successful integration.
for Legal Department Integration
                                                                     Gathering background
1.    Legal personnel
                                                                        1. How do the legal needs of the acquired company
2.    Knowledge management
                                                                           compare to the legal needs of the acquirer?
3.    Budget and forecast
                                                                        2. How will the legal needs of the acquired
4.    Technology support
                                                                           company be satisfied moving forward?
5.    Invoice management
                                                                        3. Have you received feedback from your
6.    Records retention
                                                                           client groups regarding their anticipated
7.    Outside counsel management
                                                                           post-closing legal support needs?
8.    Litigation management
                                                                        4. What are the expectations of the acquirer’s
9.    SEC reporting
                                                                           CEO in terms of headcount and post-
10.   Corporate governance
                                                                           acquisition budget for the legal department?
11.   International operations
12.   Subsidiary clean-up
                                                                     Integrating the GC of the acquired company
13.   Patents, trademarks and other intellectual property
                                                                        5. Can the acquired company’s GC be expected to
14.   Labor and employment
                                                                           accept a role reporting to the acquirer’s GC, or
15.   Stock option and employee benefit plans
                                                                           would the acquired company’s GC prefer operating
16.   Forms and templates
                                                                           in a different department such as Corporate
17.   Contract management
                                                                           Development or HR? Does the former GC have
18.   Product licensing and sales
                                                                           knowledge and skills necessary for such a transition?
19.   Real estate (owned and leased)
                                                                        6. Do you know what role the GC of the target
20.   Regulatory environment
                                                                           envisions for himself at the merged company? Does
21.   Government sales and relations
                                                                           the former GC expect a dual-GC type of role?
22.   Public relations
                                                                        7. Does the former GC have job-title expectations
23.   Marketing
                                                                           (e.g., deputy GC, AGC or GC of subsidiary)?
24.   Insurance
25.   Corporate policies
                                                                     Other legal department personnel
                                                                        8. Will the legal department personnel of
                                                                            the acquired company be retained?
                                                                        9. Will there be a need to relocate legal department
                                                                            personnel from the acquired company’s
                                                                            offices to the acquirer’s headquarters?
                                                                        10. Is it necessary for the acquirer to have lawyers
                                                                            at multiple locations domestically? Overseas?



                                                      ACC Docket   62 November 2011
in louisiana, we see the complete picture.
 When you have legal challenges in the Bayou State, you need attorneys who see the risks you don’t.
 As the capital area’s largest law firm, we have the insight and resources to defend your interests
                          regardless of the size of the alligator you’re wrestling.

                                        we see things
                                            differently.



                                                  ‹  .HDQ 0LOOHU //3




                For the latest in Louisiana Legal Developments, please visit louisianalawblog.com
21. Is there an attorney at the acquirer with a necessary
Have you completed an                                              core competency who is expected to leave the
                                                                   acquirer in the near future and who may be replaced
assessment of the skill                                            with an attorney from the acquired company?
                                                               22. Have you obtained the bios for each
sets for attorneys at each legal                                   attorney from the acquired company,
                                                                   including title and salary history?
department to determine                                        23. Have you thought about an on-boarding
which skill sets are                                               process for the new attorneys? Will they all be
                                                                   brought to the parent HQ for this process? Or
in very short supply                                               is an off-site for all attorneys warranted?
                                                               24. Is the integration an opportunity to
and which are redundant?                                           upgrade the skills and competencies of
                                                                   your legal department with more qualified
                                                                   attorneys from the acquired company?
                                                               25. Are there any state bar issues? What is the state
11. What core competencies are required by the                     bar membership status of each new attorney
    acquirer’s legal department, and do any of the                 being added to the team? Can each new attorney
    acquired company’s legal department personnel                  produce a certificate of good standing in every
    fill a void in the acquirer’s legal department?                 jurisdiction in which they are admitted?
12. Is there a need to hire additional legal department        26. If you are going to be relocating attorneys
    personnel as a result of the acquisition?                      to California, can these attorneys obtain
13. Have job descriptions been prepared and                        in-house counsel registration?
    circulated to Human Resources for approval?                27. Have all legal department personnel from the
14. Is there any pay disparity between attorneys at the            acquired company been briefed on the policies
    two companies that will need to be addressed?                  and procedures of the acquirer’s legal department
15. Did there seem to be an inordinate                             (i.e., outside counsel retention, issuance of
    number of promotions or raises prior                           legal opinions, bar admission requirements,
    to the closing of the transaction?                             attorney conduct rules, CLE policies, etc.)?
16. Do you have a current organizational chart for             28. Do you have a standard email signature
    the acquired company’s legal department? Do                    that you require your attorneys to use?
    you have a current organizational chart for your               Has this been communicated to the
    own legal department? Have you developed an                    acquired company’s attorneys? ∑
    organizational chart for the merged company?
17. Have you completed an assessment of the skill           Please read the rest of this article, available exclusively in the
    sets for attorneys at each legal department             ACC Digital Docket at www.acc.com/docket.
    to determine which skill sets are in very
    short supply and which are redundant?                   Have a comment on this article? Visit ACC’s blog
18. Have you identified any “superstar” attorneys            at www.inhouseaccess.com/articles/acc-docket.
    on either side with skill sets you can’t
    afford to lose? Have you done anything to
    make sure you keep these individuals?
19. Are there any competencies in the target
    company’s legal department that are currently
    being underutilized (e.g., an ex-Big Law
    attorney currently doing licensing who could
    be supporting future MA projects)?
20. Is the acquirer missing any core competencies
    in its legal department (e.g., open source,
    export compliance, FCPA, patents, etc.)?




                                             ACC Docket   64 November 2011
MAKE YOUR MARK
ON THE CANADIAN LANDSCAPE.




Navigate your business interests north of the border with the help of Borden Ladner Gervais LLP (BLG). As Canada’s
largest law firm, we’ll help you realize your business goals and ensure there are no barriers to your Canadian success.

Not only has BLG been recognized as a Go-To Law Firm® of the World’s Leading Companies for five straight years,
but we also have the most lawyers selected by their peers in the 2011 edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada.®

Download a free copy of our booklet Doing Business in Canada at blg.com




Calgary | Montréal | Ottawa | Toronto | Vancouver | Waterloo Region
Lawyers | Patent  Trade-mark Agents | Borden Ladner Gervais LLP is an Ontario Limited Liability Partnership.
blg.com

Go-To Law Firm® is a registered trademark of ALM Media, LLC. Used with permission. The Best Lawyers in Canada ® 2011 (Copyright 2010 by Woodward/White, Inc., of Aiken, S.C.)
Knowledge management                                               40. What will be the approval process for paying the
  29. How do you assess and preserve the knowledge of the              outstanding legal invoices of the acquired company?
      acquired company’s personnel, including those in the
      legal department, before they leave the company?           Records retention
                                                                   41. Will all of the acquired company’s files be kept in
Budget and forecast                                                    an existing location or moved to a new location?
  30. Has the legal department’s budget and forecast               42. Has the acquired company’s records retention
      been revised to reflect the consolidation with the                policy been recently updated and distributed
      legal department of the acquired company and the                 to the acquired company’s employees?
      resulting additional expenses, including, but not            43. Are processes in place to ensure that, with
      limited to, additional outside counsel fees, additional          respect to open litigation matters, relevant
      attorney and legal support personnel, additional                 records are being preserved? Is there any need
      costs for software licenses and technology support               to issue a document preservation memo(s) in
      (Blackberries®, cell phones, computers, etc.),                   connection with acquired company litigation?
      additional costs for malpractice insurance, additional       44. Is additional secure file storage capacity necessary?
      overhead allocation, additional travel and related           45. Have all the acquired company’s files and
      expenses, and additional bar and association dues?               records been scanned and backed up as part
                                                                       of the acquirer’s disaster recovery plans?
Technology support                                                 46. Do you know where all the acquired
  31. Does your IT department understand the                           company’s files are?
      needs of the merged legal department?                        47. Are there files in the possession of the acquired
      Are any additional servers required?                             company’s outside counsel that should be retrieved?
  32. Does either company’s legal department use                   48. What is the timetable for implementing the acquirer’s
      matter management, document management                           records retention policy at the acquired company?
      and/or calendaring software that will need to be
      rolled out to the other? Do you need to purchase           Combining best practices
      any additional software licenses or seats?                   49. Does the acquired company’s legal
  33. Does the acquired company have better software                   department use some best practices that
      license terms that can be leveraged by the acquirer?             can be adopted by the acquirer?
  34. Should all the computers in the acquired company’s
      legal department be scanned for documents                  Outside counsel management
      that can be imported into the acquirer’s legal               50. Have you received a list of outside counsel
      department document management system?                           employed by the acquired company, the tasks
  35. Does each of the acquired company’s attorneys have a             that they handle and the current billing rates?
      personal digital assistant or cell phone paid for by the     51. Have you received copies of all outside counsel
      company (e.g., Blackberry®, iPhone®, Android®, etc.)?            engagement letters for all active matters?
                                                                   52. Have all outside counsel to the acquired
Invoice management                                                     company, domestic and foreign, been
  36. How does the acquired company’s legal                            notified about the acquisition?
      department process and approve its invoices?                 53. Have all outside counsel to the acquired
  37. Have all outside counsel to the acquired                         company been provided with a copy of the
      company been advised that, going forward, all                    acquirer’s outside counsel guidelines?
      invoices for legal services should be sent to the            54. Has a decision been made as to which of
      attention of the acquirer’s legal department?                    the acquired company’s outside counsel
  38. Have all outside counsel to the acquired                         will continue to be retained?
      company been requested to notify the acquirer’s              55. Have all outside counsel to the acquired company
      legal department of all outstanding invoices                     that will continue to be retained been asked to
      as of a fixed date so that a proper accrual                       sign revised engagement letters with the acquirer
      can be made of legal expenses payable?                           that includes the acquirer’s standard engagement
  39. Are any of the outstanding invoices items                        letter addendum and outside counsel guidelines?
      that are reimbursable pursuant to any
      indemnification or insurance arrangements?
56. With respect to outside counsel that will not                68. Have you received litigation budgets and
      be retained going forward, has the acquirer                      forecasts for all ongoing matters involving the
      requested that all of the acquired company’s                     acquired company, including a calendar of court
      files be delivered to the acquirer?                               appearances, deposition schedules, etc.?
  57. Have all outside counsel been asked to provide               69. Are continuances or postponements necessary so
      a list of all matters that they are currently                    that you can get your arms around the matters
      working on for the acquired company?                             or make changes in assigned counsel?
  58. Are there matters being handled by outside counsel           70. Are all litigation matters appropriately described
      that can be handled more efficiently and effectively              in the disclosure schedule to the acquisition
      by in-house counsel? Are those matters capable of                agreement? Are there other claims or contingencies
      being transitioned from a practical perspective? If              that have “come out of the woodwork” since
      it would be more effective to transition the matter              closing that were not appropriately disclosed in the
      to in-house counsel, are additional resources                    disclosure schedule to the acquisition agreement?
      needed in-house prior to such transition?                    71. Have you requested of all court filings for
  59. In the acquisition, are you acquiring any                        ongoing litigation and other related materials
      new skill sets that would allow certain tasks                    for inclusion in the acquirer’s legal department
      previously performed for the acquirer by                         files and for distribution as required (insurance
      outside counsel to be brought in-house?                          companies, outside counsel, experts, etc.)?
  60. Have all outside counsel been asked to provide               72. Have you designated a point person
      budgets for open litigation matters that they                    for each litigation matter?
      are working on for the acquired company?                     73. Have the insurers been appropriately
  61. Is there an opportunity to consolidate some of                   notified of all pending litigation to the extent
      the matters being handled by outside counsel to a                required by the relevant policies?
      smaller number of firms? Does the acquirer need               74. Have you reviewed all current insurance
      multiple firms to process trademark filing requests?               policies for applicable coverage?
      Does the acquirer need multiple counsel in foreign           75. Have you requested a letter from the insurance
      jurisdictions? Does the acquirer need multiple                   carrier delineating coverage terms and limits?
      counsel to support the human resources group?
  62. Can the consolidation of outside counsel                  SEC reporting
      be leveraged to obtain cost savings?                         76. Does the description of the business in the
                                                                       Annual Report on Form 10-K need to be
Litigation management                                                  revised to reflect the acquired business?
  63. Has a list of all outstanding litigation matters             77. Do any changes need to be made to the risk factors or
      to which the acquired company is a party                         the forward-looking statement safe harbor factors?
      been prepared and compared with what                         78. Are there additional agreements that need
      was listed in the disclosure schedule?                           to be included as exhibits to the Form 10-K
  64. Have all outside counsel representing the acquired               (material contracts, employment agreements,
      company in litigation matters been notified of the                leases, credit agreements, the acquisition
      acquisition, and the new protocols for consultation              agreement, new employee benefit plans, etc.)?
      and approval of all actions in the litigation?               79. Will any of the officers or employees of
  65. Has the estimate for the costs to resolve the pending            the acquired company be deemed an
      matters changed since the transaction closed?                    executive officer of the acquirer for whom
  66. Are there litigation matters that can be easily                  Section 16 filings will be necessary?
      settled or otherwise disposed of? Should                     80. Are there any new directors of the acquirer
      settlement be considered? Are changes in                         as a result of the acquisition for whom
      litigation counsel necessary? Are changes                        Section 16 filings will be necessary?
      in litigation strategy necessary?                            81. Are there any Section 16 officers that will be
  67. Will any of the pending litigation matters need to be            departing from the acquirer or who will remain
      disclosed in either the acquirer’s Quarterly Report              with the acquirer but will no longer be deemed
      on Form 10-Q or Annual Report on Form 10-K?                      Section 16 officers? If yes, have “Section 16 exit
                                                                       memos” been prepared and distributed to them?



                                               ACC Docket     C7 November 2011
82. Do the processes that have been implemented                102. Have actions by unanimous consent been
      pursuant to Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act               prepared to change the officers and directors?
      need to be revised to address the acquired company?        103. Has a review been undertaken to determine which
  83. Will there be any changes to the list of named officers          subsidiaries to retain and which to eliminate?
      in the acquirer’s annual meeting proxy statement?          104. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries “significant
                                                                      subsidiaries” for SEC reporting purposes?
Corporate governance                                             105. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries subject to
  84. Will additional sub-certifications be needed to                  open federal, state, local or foreign tax audits?
      ensure compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act?             106. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries parties to any
  85. Are there any changes to any of                                 debt instruments, or are any of their assets pledged?
      the board committees?                                      107. Has the par value of the subsidiaries’ shares
  86. Are there any changes to the schedule                           been reviewed to determine whether excessive
      of board or committee meetings?                                 franchise taxes are being incurred?
                                                                 108. Are there domestic subsidiaries that need to
International operations                                              be merged out of existence or dissolved?
  87. Are additional legal personnel                             109. Are there subsidiaries that cannot be merged
      needed in overseas locations?                                   out of existence or dissolved because of open tax
  88. Do any of the acquired company’s trademarks                     audits, IP ownership or contractual reasons?
      need to be registered in overseas locations?               110. Have all the corporate minute books been
  89. Are any additional foreign qualifications needed?                retrieved and are they all up to date?
  90. Are there redundant foreign subsidiaries                   111. Are all the acquired subsidiaries in good standing
      or other legal entities as a result of the                      and are they qualified to do business in the
      acquisition that need to be merged out?                         jurisdictions where they need to be so qualified?
  91. Are any changes needed to either
      party’s transfer pricing policies?                       Patents
  92. Will there be any exchange control                         112. Does there need to be coordination between
      issues going forward?                                           the patent procedures at each company [e.g.,
  93. Are there any additional permits                                the invention disclosures, patent committees,
      or approvals to obtain?                                         patent payments to inventors (upon
  94. Should a compliance audit be performed                          submission of patentable idea, upon approval
      to assess any potential FCPA issues?                            of patentable idea by the patent committee,
  95. Are there opportunities to obtain any governmental              upon completion of the patent application,
      subsidies or incentives from the host government?               upon issuance of the patent, etc.)]?
                                                                 113. Do you have a current list of patents
Export controls compliance                                            for the acquired company?
  96. Has a review been undertaken to determine                  114. How will the patents of the acquired company
      whether any additional filings need to be done                   be docketed and maintained (i.e., by an existing
      with the US Department of Commerce to export                    patent service provider or moved to a new service
      the products of the acquired company?                           provider)? In examining the preceding, do you
  97. Are additional export licenses needed?                          recognize any tasks that can be brought in-house or
                                                                      consolidated for a third-party service provider, such
Subsidiary cleanup                                                    as management of maintenance fees for patents?
  98. Do you have a list of corporate entities                   115. Has a patent audit been conducted of the acquired
      owned by the acquired company?                                  company to determine whether there are additional
  99. Do you have an up-to-date list of                               inventions to patent that are not time-barred?
      your own corporate entities?                               116. Have your patent attorneys sat down with the key
  100. Have all of the acquired subsidiaries been entered             inventors at the acquired company and discussed
        into the acquirer’s subsidiary tracking database?             the patent philosophy of your company?
  101. Have you determined who will serve as the                 117. Is there any opportunity to license the
        directors of the foreign subsidiaries? Have you               acquired company’s patents and develop
        checked residency/nationality requirements?                   a revenue stream from such patents?
118. Is there any patented technology at the acquired          132. Have you applied for all potential “cyber-
       company that might cause you to change a                       squatting” domain names relating to
       current IP litigation strategy, or vice versa, is              the acquired company’s products?
       there any patented technology at the acquirer             133. Have you coordinated on how you would
       that can be leveraged in any IP litigation                     like splash screens to appear on the acquired
       that the acquired company is a party to?                       company’s websites? Is there a click-
  119. Does the transaction have any effect on                        through to the merged company’s site?
       any patent license agreements that the
       acquired company is a party to?                         Labor and employment
  120. Does the acquisition open the door to                     134. Should all of the acquired company’s employees
       examining a patent licensing strategy?                         be required to execute new offer letters?
  121. Does the acquired company have procedures                 135. Do the employees of the acquired company
       to examine patentable ideas prior to release                   need to sign new confidentiality and
       of new products? Would this be a good                          assignment of inventions agreements?
       opportunity to implement such procedures?                 136. Have all of the acquired company’s
                                                                      employees been advised of the acquirer’s
Trademarks and other intellectual property                            employee policies and procedures?
  122. Has the acquirer’s list of trademarks                     137. Have you coordinated with HR on any
       and service marks been updated?                                potential reductions in force (e.g., severance
  123. Has a decision been made as to which brand                     agreements, employment law compliance,
       names, trademarks and service marks of the                     collective bargaining issues)?
       acquired company will continue to be used?                138. Have WARN Act notices been given?
  124. Are additional registrations required,                    139. Have severance agreements been drafted?
       domestically and/or overseas?                             140. How can severance liabilities be minimized?
  125. Are there opportunities to restructure the                141. Have all employment agreements with
       ownership of the acquired company’s intellectual               severance provisions been reviewed?
       property to effect a more tax-efficient structure?         142. Should the legal department plan an
  126. Are revisions to the acquirer’s inter-                         employment law compliance training session
       company agreements required?                                   for the managers of the acquired company?
  127. Are there older trademarks at either company              143. Are there any collective bargaining organizing
       that can be re-used or expanded such that prior-               initiatives currently underway?
       use or registration rights can be leveraged?              144. Are the employees of the acquired company
                                                                      covered by any collective bargaining agreements?
Website                                                               When are such agreements next up for renewal?
  128. If the acquired company is going to continue with
       its stand-alone website for a transitional period,      Stock option and employee benefit plans
       have the copyright and trademark notices, privacy         145. Are any new stock option plans being
       policy and terms of use been revised to be in                  implemented to rollover the stock options of
       accordance with the acquirer’s approved template?              the employees of the acquired company?
  129. Have all the country-specific websites of the              146. Are there any new incentive compensation plans
       acquired company been reviewed to determine what               (ICP) or management by objectives (MBO) plans
       changes will need to be made to the copyright and              that are being implemented for the new employees?
       trademark notices, privacy policy and terms of use?       147. Have the appropriate Form S-8 and
  130. If the acquired company was a public company,                  other filings been made with the SEC
       have the investor relations and corporate                      and the applicable stock exchanges?
       governance links on the acquired company’s                148. Have the stock option plans been adapted, and
       website been re-linked to the acquirer’s investor              the requisite approvals obtained, so that stock
       relations and corporate governance pages?                      options can be issued to employees overseas?
  131. Are there web-linking agreements that
       need to be updated to reflect that the links             Use of forms and templates
       will now be to the acquirer’s website?                    149. Have you reviewed the acquired company’s
                                                                      template agreements and attendant rules of use?


                                               ACC Docket    C9 November 2011
150. Have you reviewed the acquired company’s                   163. Has a timeline been established for converting
       templates to determine if key provisions                        all of the acquired company’s product
       (warranties, limitation of liability,                           license agreements and sales agreements
       indemnification, rights in derivative IP, etc.)                  to the new forms and templates?
       comply with the policies of the acquirer?                  164. Have the forms been adapted for
  151. Have you provided the acquired company’s                        use in new foreign locations?
       attorneys with a copy of your standard                     165. Have the sales folks been briefed on the legal
       NDA(s) and the related rules of use?                            terms that they are not to negotiate without the
                                                                       approval of the acquirer’s legal department?
Contract management                                               166. Are new click-through agreements needed for
  152. Have the disclosure schedules been reviewed for                 the merged company’s software products?
       any contracts with change in control provisions            167. With the acquisition, is it realistic to form
       that will be triggered by the transaction and                   a group at the merged company to have
       require that a consent be obtained (or a                        paralegals or contract managers handle
       notice be provided) by the acquirer for the                     repetitive form agreements or processes, such
       contract’s assignment to be effective?                          as NDAs, evaluation agreements or open source
  153. Has a form notice to customers and                              reviews, or new product release approvals?
       request for consent been prepared by legal/
       contract management and approved by                      Real estate (owned and leased)
       sales/marketing for distribution?                          168. Are any leases being terminated?
  154. Are there contracts that require the acquirer              169. Do any of the leases to which the acquired
       to procure consents that still need to be                       company is a party to require notice or consent
       obtained for assignment of contracts from                       to assignment or change of control?
       the acquired company to the acquirer?                      170. Are any subleases being contemplated with respect
  155. Is someone charged with maintaining a                           to redundant office space of the acquired company?
       continuously updated list of contracts                     171. Are any leases being renegotiated?
       that require consents to be obtained?                      172. Are facilities being consolidated,
  156. How will the contract management                                domestically or overseas?
       process be merged?                                         173. Are there “change of address” notices, which
  157. Have the acquired company’s contract                            are required to be sent to any governmental
       management personnel been trained on                            authorities, domestically or overseas?
       the use of the acquirer’s forms?                           174. Are there opportunities to minimize
  158. How will the acquired company’s contract files be                real estate or transfer taxes?
       maintained and where will they be maintained?              175. In reviewing the consolidated property
  159. Are there customer contract forms used                          portfolio, are there opportunities to
       by the acquired company that should                             sell or sublease properties?
       replace forms used by the acquirer?
  160. Are there changes to the form customer contracts         Regulatory environment
       that need to be made due to the acquirer now doing         176. Does the acquired company place the
       business in additional states or foreign jurisdictions          acquirer in a new regulatory environment
       where local law requires such changes?                          where, for the first time, it is subject to
  161. Do you need to bring in a temp paralegal to                     compliance with a statute or regulation that
       handle notices and assignments required under the               heretofore it did not have to comply with?
       acquired company’s agreements? Or is it realistic          177. Are there notices to be filed in order to
       to assign these tasks to current staff members?                 comply with new regulatory requirements?
                                                                  178. Does the acquirer’s legal department have
Product licensing and sales                                            sufficient competency to ensure the acquirer’s
  162. Has a decision been made on which                               compliance with the new regulatory regime?
       company’s product licensing forms and                      179. Is the nature of the regulatory regime such that an
       templates will be used going forward?                           additional full-time in-house person is necessary,
                                                                       or is it such that outside counsel is sufficient?
180. Has an in-house legal person been appointed as the      194. Do the limits and retention amounts of the
       point person for this new regulatory regime? Or has          acquirer’s insurance need to be revised?
       outside counsel been identified to handle this area?     195. Is there transaction-specific litigation that
                                                                    needs to be brought to the attention of
Government sales and relations                                      the insurance broker and the insurer?
  181. Does the acquisition affect the acquirer’s              196. Has the acquirer’s legal malpractice
       government relations strategy?                               insurance coverage been updated to
  182. Are additional state and/or federal                          include the additional legal department
       lobbying resources needed?                                   personnel from the acquired company?
  183. Does the GSA schedule need to be                        197. Should any in-house counsel be covered
       amended to include the acquired company’s                    under the acquirer’s DO insurance policy
       products and price schedules?                                (e.g., GC, deputy GC, corporate secretary,
  184. Do security clearances need to be obtained by any            assistant corporate secretaries, etc.)?
       legal department personnel in connection with sales
       to governmental agencies and instrumentalities?       Corporate policies
  185. Are there government entities, domestic and             198. Have all of the acquired company employees
       overseas, where the relationship with the                    been made aware of the acquirer’s policies?
       acquired company could be improved?                          Have copies been distributed, either hard-copy
                                                                    or via email, of the acquirer’s policies to ensure
Public relations                                                    compliance (e.g., code of conduct, Sarbanes-
  186. Have the employees of the acquired                           Oxley Act, policy against harassment in the
       company been advised of the acquirer’s                       workplace, insider trading, antitrust/competition,
       communications policies and processes?                       revenue recognition, whistleblower, records
  187. Has the press release boilerplate been                       retention, foreign corrupt practices act, etc.)?
       updated to include, among other things,                 199. Is additional compliance training necessary for
       any additional forward-looking risk factors                  the employees of the acquired company?
       and trademark attribution language?                     200. Has a click-through acknowledgement been
                                                                    created for the website for the acquired
Marketing                                                           company employees to acknowledge that
  188. Have the marketing personnel of the                          they have read the acquirer’s policies?
       acquired company been briefed on the
       acquirer’s process for vetting and approving          Conclusion
       new brand names, trademarks and service                  The MA world is littered with deals that have gone bad
       marks, and approving all product packaging            because folks paid scant attention to the heavy lifting that
       and the legal notices placed thereon?                 integration requires following the closing of any transaction.
  189. Has the product packaging of the acquired             We hope the 200 items that we have listed above will pro-
       company’s products been reviewed to determine         vide in-house counsel with a useful roadmap for planning
       changes that will need to be made?                    the integration of two legal departments post-acquisition,
  190. Has the “style guide” been updated to                 and will contribute to not only a smooth transition, but also
       incorporate the acquired company’s products           an MA transaction that has a better chance of being suc-
       and brands, and has the legal department              cessful due to a thoughtful integration strategy.
       approved the revised “style guide”?

Insurance
  191. Has the acquirer’s insurance broker been
       brought up to date on the transaction, and
       provided with relevant information and required
       notices with respect to the transaction?
  192. Have the insurance policies of the acquired
       company been converted to tail policies?
  193. Is there additional insurance that needs to be
       procured as a result of the acquisition?


                                              ACC Docket C11 November 2011

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

A af plansbook2012
A af plansbook2012A af plansbook2012
A af plansbook2012tmburris
 
AAF Nissan Plans Book
AAF Nissan Plans BookAAF Nissan Plans Book
AAF Nissan Plans Bookashmlaw67
 
Acg 106 pav. tecnico_geral
Acg 106  pav. tecnico_geralAcg 106  pav. tecnico_geral
Acg 106 pav. tecnico_geralambiental
 
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter Announcement
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter AnnouncementOpenID Foundation Japan Chapter Announcement
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter AnnouncementDavid Recordon
 
Report: HSE in the Oilfield
Report: HSE in the OilfieldReport: HSE in the Oilfield
Report: HSE in the OilfieldDoug Sheridan
 
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0David Recordon
 
Festival DNA - workshop poster
Festival DNA - workshop posterFestival DNA - workshop poster
Festival DNA - workshop posterfestivalslab
 
Copenhagen en gt
Copenhagen en gtCopenhagen en gt
Copenhagen en gtmike_98026
 
Porfolio 2010
Porfolio 2010Porfolio 2010
Porfolio 2010sramzee
 
Brocade Migration Example
Brocade Migration ExampleBrocade Migration Example
Brocade Migration Examplenigelwakefield
 
Fringe eu procurement - sara piller
Fringe   eu procurement - sara pillerFringe   eu procurement - sara piller
Fringe eu procurement - sara pillerlgconf11
 
Open Source Success: jQuery
Open Source Success: jQueryOpen Source Success: jQuery
Open Source Success: jQueryjeresig
 
EdSocialMedia Keynote
EdSocialMedia KeynoteEdSocialMedia Keynote
EdSocialMedia KeynoteWhippleHill
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

A af plansbook2012
A af plansbook2012A af plansbook2012
A af plansbook2012
 
AAF Nissan Plans Book
AAF Nissan Plans BookAAF Nissan Plans Book
AAF Nissan Plans Book
 
Acg 106 pav. tecnico_geral
Acg 106  pav. tecnico_geralAcg 106  pav. tecnico_geral
Acg 106 pav. tecnico_geral
 
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter Announcement
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter AnnouncementOpenID Foundation Japan Chapter Announcement
OpenID Foundation Japan Chapter Announcement
 
Los Angeles
Los AngelesLos Angeles
Los Angeles
 
Spiral Of Knowledge - 1967
Spiral Of Knowledge - 1967Spiral Of Knowledge - 1967
Spiral Of Knowledge - 1967
 
Are you paying attention
Are you paying attentionAre you paying attention
Are you paying attention
 
Webster City Enterprise Zone Map
Webster City Enterprise Zone MapWebster City Enterprise Zone Map
Webster City Enterprise Zone Map
 
Report: HSE in the Oilfield
Report: HSE in the OilfieldReport: HSE in the Oilfield
Report: HSE in the Oilfield
 
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0
Web 2.0 Expo Berlin: OpenID Emerging from Web 2.0
 
Festival DNA - workshop poster
Festival DNA - workshop posterFestival DNA - workshop poster
Festival DNA - workshop poster
 
Copenhagen en gt
Copenhagen en gtCopenhagen en gt
Copenhagen en gt
 
Porfolio 2010
Porfolio 2010Porfolio 2010
Porfolio 2010
 
Brocade Migration Example
Brocade Migration ExampleBrocade Migration Example
Brocade Migration Example
 
Implementing OpenID
Implementing OpenIDImplementing OpenID
Implementing OpenID
 
Kiss the BRD Good-Bye
Kiss the BRD Good-ByeKiss the BRD Good-Bye
Kiss the BRD Good-Bye
 
Fringe eu procurement - sara piller
Fringe   eu procurement - sara pillerFringe   eu procurement - sara piller
Fringe eu procurement - sara piller
 
Open Source Success: jQuery
Open Source Success: jQueryOpen Source Success: jQuery
Open Source Success: jQuery
 
Informing community-based participatory action research on gender & adaptati...
Informing community-based participatory action research on gender  & adaptati...Informing community-based participatory action research on gender  & adaptati...
Informing community-based participatory action research on gender & adaptati...
 
EdSocialMedia Keynote
EdSocialMedia KeynoteEdSocialMedia Keynote
EdSocialMedia Keynote
 

Ähnlich wie M&A Integration Planning The Integration Of An Acquired Companys Legal Department

High stakes world of Mobile Payments
High stakes world of Mobile PaymentsHigh stakes world of Mobile Payments
High stakes world of Mobile PaymentstxtNation
 
UBD Media Kit 2012
UBD Media Kit 2012UBD Media Kit 2012
UBD Media Kit 2012UnBuenDoctor
 
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility Matrix
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility MatrixInternational Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility Matrix
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility MatrixGHY International
 
art of presentation Map of Jamies Yam
art of presentation Map of Jamies Yamart of presentation Map of Jamies Yam
art of presentation Map of Jamies YamJamies Yam
 
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media Kit
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media KitSeattle Magazine 2012 Media Kit
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media Kitjkueber
 
Expanded Game Experience
Expanded Game ExperienceExpanded Game Experience
Expanded Game Experienceaakoo
 
Issues for metabolomics and
Issues for metabolomics and Issues for metabolomics and
Issues for metabolomics and Duncan Hull
 
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And Growth
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And GrowthU.S. Renewable Energy Market And Growth
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And GrowthBrookeHeaton
 
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal November 2007
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal  November 2007Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal  November 2007
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal November 2007Xero
 
SIAT Space
SIAT SpaceSIAT Space
SIAT SpaceNate1066
 
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload Mobility
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload MobilityVMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload Mobility
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload MobilitySal Lopez
 

Ähnlich wie M&A Integration Planning The Integration Of An Acquired Companys Legal Department (20)

High stakes world of Mobile Payments
High stakes world of Mobile PaymentsHigh stakes world of Mobile Payments
High stakes world of Mobile Payments
 
UBD Media Kit 2012
UBD Media Kit 2012UBD Media Kit 2012
UBD Media Kit 2012
 
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility Matrix
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility MatrixInternational Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility Matrix
International Trade Compliance Strategy Responsibility Matrix
 
art of presentation Map of Jamies Yam
art of presentation Map of Jamies Yamart of presentation Map of Jamies Yam
art of presentation Map of Jamies Yam
 
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media Kit
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media KitSeattle Magazine 2012 Media Kit
Seattle Magazine 2012 Media Kit
 
Intimacy Web
Intimacy WebIntimacy Web
Intimacy Web
 
Expanded Game Experience
Expanded Game ExperienceExpanded Game Experience
Expanded Game Experience
 
Orlando _ Florida
Orlando _ FloridaOrlando _ Florida
Orlando _ Florida
 
Issues for metabolomics and
Issues for metabolomics and Issues for metabolomics and
Issues for metabolomics and
 
Social Media Branding by Dawn Jensen
Social Media Branding by Dawn JensenSocial Media Branding by Dawn Jensen
Social Media Branding by Dawn Jensen
 
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And Growth
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And GrowthU.S. Renewable Energy Market And Growth
U.S. Renewable Energy Market And Growth
 
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal November 2007
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal  November 2007Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal  November 2007
Xero Advertisment - NZ Accountants Journal November 2007
 
SIAT Space
SIAT SpaceSIAT Space
SIAT Space
 
Map A4ol
Map A4olMap A4ol
Map A4ol
 
Map A4ol
Map A4olMap A4ol
Map A4ol
 
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload Mobility
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload MobilityVMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload Mobility
VMware vCloud Director and Nexus 1000V / Workload Mobility
 
Maps
MapsMaps
Maps
 
Jun05 A01 Bct
Jun05 A01 BctJun05 A01 Bct
Jun05 A01 Bct
 
Heart Tarsia
Heart TarsiaHeart Tarsia
Heart Tarsia
 
Timeline 1
Timeline 1Timeline 1
Timeline 1
 

Mehr von Frank Fletcher

M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...
M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...
M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...Frank Fletcher
 
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...Frank Fletcher
 
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...Frank Fletcher
 
Sept 2012 Acc Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals Quickly
Sept 2012 Acc  Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals QuicklySept 2012 Acc  Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals Quickly
Sept 2012 Acc Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals QuicklyFrank Fletcher
 
September 2011 Acc Docket Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...
September 2011 Acc Docket  Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...September 2011 Acc Docket  Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...
September 2011 Acc Docket Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...Frank Fletcher
 
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...Frank Fletcher
 
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...Frank Fletcher
 
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHER
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHERApr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHER
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHERFrank Fletcher
 

Mehr von Frank Fletcher (8)

M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...
M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...
M&A Integration - Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company's Legal Dep...
 
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...
November 2011 acc_docket_planning_the_integration_of_an_acquired_company's_le...
 
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
 
Sept 2012 Acc Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals Quickly
Sept 2012 Acc  Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals QuicklySept 2012 Acc  Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals Quickly
Sept 2012 Acc Docket Fletcher How To Negotiate Important Deals Quickly
 
September 2011 Acc Docket Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...
September 2011 Acc Docket  Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...September 2011 Acc Docket  Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...
September 2011 Acc Docket Due Diligence & Your M&A Success Story Fle...
 
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...
June 2011 Acc Docket Developing Effective Relationships With Business Partner...
 
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...
May 2011 ACC Docket 100 Issues To Clarify With Your M&A Counsel Fletcher Gott...
 
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHER
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHERApr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHER
Apr 2011 ACC Docket A Worldwide Wiki FLETCHER
 

M&A Integration Planning The Integration Of An Acquired Companys Legal Department

  • 1. INSIDE: Asian Briefings November 2011 Receiverships and Commercial Real o mp li an c e Of fi ce r • Ma &C Estate Loan Defaults on • C o un s el na gin gS oci al ti e gra Me dia nt AI M& s • ion lu t g So fe i t in n te r ou ti- C An n• ic t io P re d on ig at i Lit
  • 2. M&A Integration —— Planning the Integration of an Acquired Company’s Legal Department BY FRANK FLETCHER AND KEITH E. GOTTFRIED You are the general counsel of BiggerCo, a publicly-held software and services company with annual revenues of $600 million based in the heart of California’s Silicon Valley. Almost three months ago, BiggerCo agreed to acquire SmallerCo, another publicly-held software and services company located in Raleigh, N.C., pursuant to an all-cash, one-step merger transaction that merges SmallerCo with, and into, BiggerCo. SmallerCo is relatively comparable in size to BiggerCo, having about the same revenues and an almost equal number of employees. While the transaction has been structured as a merger of equals, there is no doubt that BiggerCo is acquiring SmallerCo and that BiggerCo’s management team will be running the combined company. Among the many attractions in buying SmallerCo were its very significant international operations, as well as its large government business. SmallerCo’s largest customer is the US government. In contrast, BiggerCo has not, to date, been successful in expanding overseas or in selling to the US government. ACC Docket 57 November 2011
  • 3. When the acquisition of SmallerCo more than their SmallerCo counterparts, FRANK FLETCHER is the general was first announced, many investors counsel of Nero AG, a developer partly due to the increased cost of liv- thought that BiggerCo had overpaid for of platform-neutral software ing in Silicon Valley. While BiggerCo technology for editing and SmallerCo. In response to that concern, managing video, music, photos requires all of its outside counsel to BiggerCo’s stock got walloped. To ad- and other multimedia, which is headquartered agree to its law firm retention agreement in Karlsbad, Germany, with subsidiaries in dress investor’s concerns, BiggerCo’s Hangzhou, China; Yokohama, Japan; and and related outside counsel policies, Glendale, California. Fletcher is responsible for CEO has been spending a lot of time on all aspects of the company’s worldwide legal SmallerCo has no such process in place the road touting the expected benefits of function, including mergers and acquisitions, and generally just executes whatever software licensing, patents, trademarks, the acquisition. Nevertheless, investors antipiracy and litigation. Prior to joining Nero, engagement letter is sent to it by its law remain skeptical and are particularly he was a member of the products and firm. Having just completed a lengthy technologies law group at Sun Microsystems, concerned with whether BiggerCo has where he served as chief counsel for the CPU “beauty contest” process to reduce the the ability to successfully integrate the manufacturing, testing and validation groups, number of law firms it uses, BiggerCo as well as the global business services group. two companies. He can be contacted at ffletcher@nero.com. now uses only a handful of law firms With the closing of the acquisition of for most of its corporate, litigation and KEITH E. GOTTFRIED is a partner SmallerCo now visible on the horizon, in the Washington, DC office of intellectual property work, and some of Blank Rome LLP. He concentrates BiggerCo’s CEO has asked each of his his practice primarily on mergers these firms were required to agree to senior executives, including you, to be and acquisitions, corporate either alternative fee arrangements or governance, shareholder activism, securities ready at the next meeting of the execu- regulation, NYSE and Nasdaq compliance, and steep discounts off their standard billing tive leadership team to present detailed general corporate matters. Over the course of rates, in exchange for being designated a his career, Gottfried has worked on a number of plans for integrating the applicable high-profile mergers and acquisitions across a “preferred firm.” In contrast, SmallerCo operations of SmallerCo into their broad range of industries and sectors. Prior to uses over a dozen law firms and has rejoining Blank Rome, he was the general functional group, post-closing. Many counsel of the US Department of Housing and no discount or alternative fee arrange- of the functional groups at BiggerCo, Urban Development, a position to which he was ments in place with any of them. All of appointed by President George W. Bush and including finance, accounting, market- unanimously confirmed by the US Senate. BiggerCo’s securities compliance and Previous to that, Gottfried was the general ing, product management, sales, IT and counsel of Borland Software Corporation in corporate governance work is done by human resources, have been working on Cupertino, California. He can be contacted at outside counsel, and you had not previ- gottfried@blankrome.com. their M&A integration plans for months. ously contemplated bringing that work Given that these other functional groups in-house due to the absence of appropri- have not been consumed for the past ate in-house resources. As such, you are three months with executing the acquisition of SmallerCo, pleasantly surprised to learn that SmallerCo has been able they have had ample time to review the applicable func- to bring all this work in-house and you are very impressed tional group at SmallerCo, and contemplate and develop a with the in-house attorneys that service these areas. You detailed integration plan. are equally surprised to learn that, notwithstanding how As your integration plan will be due shortly, you can’t much government contracts work is done by SmallerCo, it put it off any longer. Where to start? You decide that to does not have any in-house government contract attorneys develop your integration plan you must first assess the situ- and that all of the government contracts work is serviced ation. The majority of SmallerCo’s attorneys are based in by outside counsel. With respect to technology, all of the Raleigh, with several attorneys based overseas to support attorneys at BiggerCo have company-paid Blackberries® or SmallerCo’s international operations. BiggerCo has all iPhones.® The attorneys at SmallerCo don’t have any such of its attorneys based in Silicon Valley and has never had devices provided by the company. While BiggerCo uses a attorneys based overseas. SmallerCo’s GC will move into state-of-the-art document management system that allows the organizational framework at BiggerCo, but an exact all of the attorneys in the legal department to have access role has not been identified, though it most likely will be to each other’s documents, no such system has ever been some type of corporate development or corporate affairs deployed at SmallerCo. role. While the BiggerCo legal department did not use such As you begin to tackle your legal department integration titles as “assistant general counsel” or “associate general plan, you notice that, unlike many of the projects you take counsel,” all of the attorneys at SmallerCo (other than the on, this one seems not to have any precedent or canned GC) had the title “assistant general counsel” or “associ- checklists to look to. You check with your outside counsel ate general counsel.” In addition, there is significant pay and none of them have any sample M&A integration plans disparity between attorneys in BiggerCo’s legal depart- for a legal department. It seems impossible to believe that, ment compared to those in SmallerCo’s legal department, with all the M&A transactions that get done in Silicon with the BiggerCo attorneys being paid almost 20 percent Valley and beyond, nobody has ever sat down and prepared ACC Docket 58 November 2011
  • 4. DISCOVERY & DISPUTE SERVICES CENTER Innovative. Efficient. Responsive. McDermott stands behind the commitment to helping clients address the demands of discovery in the electronic age, from retention through review. www.mwe.com Boston Brussels Chicago Düsseldorf Houston London Los Angeles Miami Milan Munich New York Orange County Paris Rome Silicon Valley Washington, D.C. Strategic alliance with MWE China Law Offices (Shanghai) McDermott Will & Emery conducts its practice through separate legal entities in each of the countries where it has offices. This communication may be considered attorney advertising. Previous results are not a guarantee of future outcome.
  • 5. The lack of attention ACC Extras on… Integration of an Acquired to developing effective Company’s Legal Department strategies for integrating ACC Docket an acquired company’s legal • Due Diligence and Your M&A Success Story department is extremely (Sept. 2011). www.acc.com/docket/success-story_sep11 short-sighted and causes InfoPAKSM • Organizational Effectiveness: The New Imperative many companies to miss the for Developing a World-Class Legal Department (July 2011). www.acc.com/infopaks/wcld_jul11 numerous opportunities Top Tens that may be presented by • Top Ten Things to Do When Your the acquired company. Company Is Acquired (Aug. 2011). www.acc.com/topten/comp-acquired_aug11 • Top Ten Best Practices for Merger Transactions from a Litigator’s Perspective (Aug. 2011). a detailed plan for how to combine the legal departments www.acc.com/topten/merger-trans_aug11 of two public companies. The more you think about it, the more issues come to mind, and there will be no shortage of Presentation issues to consider and address in planning the integration. • Adding Value: Strategic Planning and Clearly, having a detailed roadmap to guide you would Demonstrating Success (May 2011). have been extremely helpful. www.acc.com/strat-planning_may11 This scenario may seem familiar to many of you. Like the fictional in-house counsel depicted above, we also be- Article lieve that a detailed roadmap for planning and executing on • Mergers and Acquisitions (Fraser Milner Casgrain the integration of an acquired company’s legal department LLP) (June 2010). www.acc.com/m&a-fraser_jun10 would be very useful. In our experience, the integration of an acquired company’s legal department is rarely given the ACC has more material on this subject on our website. thought and attention it deserves. There are many reasons Visit www.acc.com, where you can browse our resources for this, including that a legal department is often viewed by practice area or search by keyword. as a cost center, and the development of a well-executed integration plan could be expensive in the near-term. In ad- dition, as noted above, a public company’s legal department are currently not being actively used — that can be poten- is generally not lacking for projects to keep it busy, if not tially recycled for the acquired company’s products. There consumed, and there is little “down time” or even incen- may also be numerous “leaky faucets” in the acquired com- tive to be strategic. How likely is a legal department to get pany’s legal department that can be quickly turned off to approval for additional headcount, or a budget to plan and produce significant cost savings. Obvious areas here would execute an M&A integration? We believe that the lack of be franchise taxes for unused subsidiaries, trademark attention to developing effective strategies for integrating maintenance fees for marks that will never be used again, an acquired company’s legal department is extremely short- outside counsel who are being inefficiently managed and sighted and causes many companies to miss the numerous retained at much higher rates than what the acquirer typi- opportunities that may be presented by the acquired com- cally pays, license fees for software that is not being used, pany. For instance, a thoughtful integration plan may, with retainers for consultants who are not being used, and fees regards to the review of the acquired company’s intellec- for warehouse space to store files that is not being used. tual property, uncover inventions that are still patentable. In addition, a thoughtful integration plan could uncover A thoughtful integration plan may also uncover unused lawsuits and other claims where there is an opportunity — trademarks that have been extremely well-protected — but that theretofore had not been fully explored — to expedi- ACC Docket 60 November 2011
  • 6. Macro view. Micro focus. One law firm. The attorneys at Saul Ewing examine legal issues through different lenses, combining big-picture analysis with scrutiny of the finer details. Getting multiple perspectives from the same law firm gives our clients a singular advantage. www.saul.com DELAWARE MARYLAND MASSACHUSETTS NEW JERSEY NEW YORK PENNSYLVANIA WASHINGTON, DC Celebrating 90 Years For more information please contact Managing Partner, David S. Antzis 610.251.5055 / dantzis@saul.com
  • 7. tiously resolve the matter, which could result in a signifi- Five Ways to Doom cant reduction in legal fees being paid to outside counsel. an M&A Transaction There may even be cases where the acquired company can reap a very attractive settlement payment from a defendant, 1. Execute poorly on the M&A integration or but in the midst of the acquired company’s sales process, do not complete it on a timely basis. no one had been willing to engage with the defendant and 2. Pay insufficient attention to customers (and employees) its counsel to work out the mechanics of a settlement. as the kinks in the integration are worked out. Based on our M&A experiences, and particularly, 3. Miss the landmines in due diligence. reflecting back on our past experiences in integrating an 4. Overpay. acquired company’s legal department and being integrated into a acquirer’s legal department, we have prepared an 5. Forget what it is you are buying (particularly in extensive list of issues that should be considered and ad- a services business when it is people). dressed sooner rather than later (hopefully, prior to the closing of the acquisition), as you begin to plan the integra- tion of an acquired company’s legal department with that of the acquirer, thus ensuring a smooth transition and a Twenty-Five Key Areas of Focus successful integration. for Legal Department Integration Gathering background 1. Legal personnel 1. How do the legal needs of the acquired company 2. Knowledge management compare to the legal needs of the acquirer? 3. Budget and forecast 2. How will the legal needs of the acquired 4. Technology support company be satisfied moving forward? 5. Invoice management 3. Have you received feedback from your 6. Records retention client groups regarding their anticipated 7. Outside counsel management post-closing legal support needs? 8. Litigation management 4. What are the expectations of the acquirer’s 9. SEC reporting CEO in terms of headcount and post- 10. Corporate governance acquisition budget for the legal department? 11. International operations 12. Subsidiary clean-up Integrating the GC of the acquired company 13. Patents, trademarks and other intellectual property 5. Can the acquired company’s GC be expected to 14. Labor and employment accept a role reporting to the acquirer’s GC, or 15. Stock option and employee benefit plans would the acquired company’s GC prefer operating 16. Forms and templates in a different department such as Corporate 17. Contract management Development or HR? Does the former GC have 18. Product licensing and sales knowledge and skills necessary for such a transition? 19. Real estate (owned and leased) 6. Do you know what role the GC of the target 20. Regulatory environment envisions for himself at the merged company? Does 21. Government sales and relations the former GC expect a dual-GC type of role? 22. Public relations 7. Does the former GC have job-title expectations 23. Marketing (e.g., deputy GC, AGC or GC of subsidiary)? 24. Insurance 25. Corporate policies Other legal department personnel 8. Will the legal department personnel of the acquired company be retained? 9. Will there be a need to relocate legal department personnel from the acquired company’s offices to the acquirer’s headquarters? 10. Is it necessary for the acquirer to have lawyers at multiple locations domestically? Overseas? ACC Docket 62 November 2011
  • 8. in louisiana, we see the complete picture. When you have legal challenges in the Bayou State, you need attorneys who see the risks you don’t. As the capital area’s largest law firm, we have the insight and resources to defend your interests regardless of the size of the alligator you’re wrestling. we see things differently. ‹ .HDQ 0LOOHU //3 For the latest in Louisiana Legal Developments, please visit louisianalawblog.com
  • 9. 21. Is there an attorney at the acquirer with a necessary Have you completed an core competency who is expected to leave the acquirer in the near future and who may be replaced assessment of the skill with an attorney from the acquired company? 22. Have you obtained the bios for each sets for attorneys at each legal attorney from the acquired company, including title and salary history? department to determine 23. Have you thought about an on-boarding which skill sets are process for the new attorneys? Will they all be brought to the parent HQ for this process? Or in very short supply is an off-site for all attorneys warranted? 24. Is the integration an opportunity to and which are redundant? upgrade the skills and competencies of your legal department with more qualified attorneys from the acquired company? 25. Are there any state bar issues? What is the state 11. What core competencies are required by the bar membership status of each new attorney acquirer’s legal department, and do any of the being added to the team? Can each new attorney acquired company’s legal department personnel produce a certificate of good standing in every fill a void in the acquirer’s legal department? jurisdiction in which they are admitted? 12. Is there a need to hire additional legal department 26. If you are going to be relocating attorneys personnel as a result of the acquisition? to California, can these attorneys obtain 13. Have job descriptions been prepared and in-house counsel registration? circulated to Human Resources for approval? 27. Have all legal department personnel from the 14. Is there any pay disparity between attorneys at the acquired company been briefed on the policies two companies that will need to be addressed? and procedures of the acquirer’s legal department 15. Did there seem to be an inordinate (i.e., outside counsel retention, issuance of number of promotions or raises prior legal opinions, bar admission requirements, to the closing of the transaction? attorney conduct rules, CLE policies, etc.)? 16. Do you have a current organizational chart for 28. Do you have a standard email signature the acquired company’s legal department? Do that you require your attorneys to use? you have a current organizational chart for your Has this been communicated to the own legal department? Have you developed an acquired company’s attorneys? ∑ organizational chart for the merged company? 17. Have you completed an assessment of the skill Please read the rest of this article, available exclusively in the sets for attorneys at each legal department ACC Digital Docket at www.acc.com/docket. to determine which skill sets are in very short supply and which are redundant? Have a comment on this article? Visit ACC’s blog 18. Have you identified any “superstar” attorneys at www.inhouseaccess.com/articles/acc-docket. on either side with skill sets you can’t afford to lose? Have you done anything to make sure you keep these individuals? 19. Are there any competencies in the target company’s legal department that are currently being underutilized (e.g., an ex-Big Law attorney currently doing licensing who could be supporting future MA projects)? 20. Is the acquirer missing any core competencies in its legal department (e.g., open source, export compliance, FCPA, patents, etc.)? ACC Docket 64 November 2011
  • 10. MAKE YOUR MARK ON THE CANADIAN LANDSCAPE. Navigate your business interests north of the border with the help of Borden Ladner Gervais LLP (BLG). As Canada’s largest law firm, we’ll help you realize your business goals and ensure there are no barriers to your Canadian success. Not only has BLG been recognized as a Go-To Law Firm® of the World’s Leading Companies for five straight years, but we also have the most lawyers selected by their peers in the 2011 edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada.® Download a free copy of our booklet Doing Business in Canada at blg.com Calgary | Montréal | Ottawa | Toronto | Vancouver | Waterloo Region Lawyers | Patent Trade-mark Agents | Borden Ladner Gervais LLP is an Ontario Limited Liability Partnership. blg.com Go-To Law Firm® is a registered trademark of ALM Media, LLC. Used with permission. The Best Lawyers in Canada ® 2011 (Copyright 2010 by Woodward/White, Inc., of Aiken, S.C.)
  • 11. Knowledge management 40. What will be the approval process for paying the 29. How do you assess and preserve the knowledge of the outstanding legal invoices of the acquired company? acquired company’s personnel, including those in the legal department, before they leave the company? Records retention 41. Will all of the acquired company’s files be kept in Budget and forecast an existing location or moved to a new location? 30. Has the legal department’s budget and forecast 42. Has the acquired company’s records retention been revised to reflect the consolidation with the policy been recently updated and distributed legal department of the acquired company and the to the acquired company’s employees? resulting additional expenses, including, but not 43. Are processes in place to ensure that, with limited to, additional outside counsel fees, additional respect to open litigation matters, relevant attorney and legal support personnel, additional records are being preserved? Is there any need costs for software licenses and technology support to issue a document preservation memo(s) in (Blackberries®, cell phones, computers, etc.), connection with acquired company litigation? additional costs for malpractice insurance, additional 44. Is additional secure file storage capacity necessary? overhead allocation, additional travel and related 45. Have all the acquired company’s files and expenses, and additional bar and association dues? records been scanned and backed up as part of the acquirer’s disaster recovery plans? Technology support 46. Do you know where all the acquired 31. Does your IT department understand the company’s files are? needs of the merged legal department? 47. Are there files in the possession of the acquired Are any additional servers required? company’s outside counsel that should be retrieved? 32. Does either company’s legal department use 48. What is the timetable for implementing the acquirer’s matter management, document management records retention policy at the acquired company? and/or calendaring software that will need to be rolled out to the other? Do you need to purchase Combining best practices any additional software licenses or seats? 49. Does the acquired company’s legal 33. Does the acquired company have better software department use some best practices that license terms that can be leveraged by the acquirer? can be adopted by the acquirer? 34. Should all the computers in the acquired company’s legal department be scanned for documents Outside counsel management that can be imported into the acquirer’s legal 50. Have you received a list of outside counsel department document management system? employed by the acquired company, the tasks 35. Does each of the acquired company’s attorneys have a that they handle and the current billing rates? personal digital assistant or cell phone paid for by the 51. Have you received copies of all outside counsel company (e.g., Blackberry®, iPhone®, Android®, etc.)? engagement letters for all active matters? 52. Have all outside counsel to the acquired Invoice management company, domestic and foreign, been 36. How does the acquired company’s legal notified about the acquisition? department process and approve its invoices? 53. Have all outside counsel to the acquired 37. Have all outside counsel to the acquired company been provided with a copy of the company been advised that, going forward, all acquirer’s outside counsel guidelines? invoices for legal services should be sent to the 54. Has a decision been made as to which of attention of the acquirer’s legal department? the acquired company’s outside counsel 38. Have all outside counsel to the acquired will continue to be retained? company been requested to notify the acquirer’s 55. Have all outside counsel to the acquired company legal department of all outstanding invoices that will continue to be retained been asked to as of a fixed date so that a proper accrual sign revised engagement letters with the acquirer can be made of legal expenses payable? that includes the acquirer’s standard engagement 39. Are any of the outstanding invoices items letter addendum and outside counsel guidelines? that are reimbursable pursuant to any indemnification or insurance arrangements?
  • 12. 56. With respect to outside counsel that will not 68. Have you received litigation budgets and be retained going forward, has the acquirer forecasts for all ongoing matters involving the requested that all of the acquired company’s acquired company, including a calendar of court files be delivered to the acquirer? appearances, deposition schedules, etc.? 57. Have all outside counsel been asked to provide 69. Are continuances or postponements necessary so a list of all matters that they are currently that you can get your arms around the matters working on for the acquired company? or make changes in assigned counsel? 58. Are there matters being handled by outside counsel 70. Are all litigation matters appropriately described that can be handled more efficiently and effectively in the disclosure schedule to the acquisition by in-house counsel? Are those matters capable of agreement? Are there other claims or contingencies being transitioned from a practical perspective? If that have “come out of the woodwork” since it would be more effective to transition the matter closing that were not appropriately disclosed in the to in-house counsel, are additional resources disclosure schedule to the acquisition agreement? needed in-house prior to such transition? 71. Have you requested of all court filings for 59. In the acquisition, are you acquiring any ongoing litigation and other related materials new skill sets that would allow certain tasks for inclusion in the acquirer’s legal department previously performed for the acquirer by files and for distribution as required (insurance outside counsel to be brought in-house? companies, outside counsel, experts, etc.)? 60. Have all outside counsel been asked to provide 72. Have you designated a point person budgets for open litigation matters that they for each litigation matter? are working on for the acquired company? 73. Have the insurers been appropriately 61. Is there an opportunity to consolidate some of notified of all pending litigation to the extent the matters being handled by outside counsel to a required by the relevant policies? smaller number of firms? Does the acquirer need 74. Have you reviewed all current insurance multiple firms to process trademark filing requests? policies for applicable coverage? Does the acquirer need multiple counsel in foreign 75. Have you requested a letter from the insurance jurisdictions? Does the acquirer need multiple carrier delineating coverage terms and limits? counsel to support the human resources group? 62. Can the consolidation of outside counsel SEC reporting be leveraged to obtain cost savings? 76. Does the description of the business in the Annual Report on Form 10-K need to be Litigation management revised to reflect the acquired business? 63. Has a list of all outstanding litigation matters 77. Do any changes need to be made to the risk factors or to which the acquired company is a party the forward-looking statement safe harbor factors? been prepared and compared with what 78. Are there additional agreements that need was listed in the disclosure schedule? to be included as exhibits to the Form 10-K 64. Have all outside counsel representing the acquired (material contracts, employment agreements, company in litigation matters been notified of the leases, credit agreements, the acquisition acquisition, and the new protocols for consultation agreement, new employee benefit plans, etc.)? and approval of all actions in the litigation? 79. Will any of the officers or employees of 65. Has the estimate for the costs to resolve the pending the acquired company be deemed an matters changed since the transaction closed? executive officer of the acquirer for whom 66. Are there litigation matters that can be easily Section 16 filings will be necessary? settled or otherwise disposed of? Should 80. Are there any new directors of the acquirer settlement be considered? Are changes in as a result of the acquisition for whom litigation counsel necessary? Are changes Section 16 filings will be necessary? in litigation strategy necessary? 81. Are there any Section 16 officers that will be 67. Will any of the pending litigation matters need to be departing from the acquirer or who will remain disclosed in either the acquirer’s Quarterly Report with the acquirer but will no longer be deemed on Form 10-Q or Annual Report on Form 10-K? Section 16 officers? If yes, have “Section 16 exit memos” been prepared and distributed to them? ACC Docket C7 November 2011
  • 13. 82. Do the processes that have been implemented 102. Have actions by unanimous consent been pursuant to Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act prepared to change the officers and directors? need to be revised to address the acquired company? 103. Has a review been undertaken to determine which 83. Will there be any changes to the list of named officers subsidiaries to retain and which to eliminate? in the acquirer’s annual meeting proxy statement? 104. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries “significant subsidiaries” for SEC reporting purposes? Corporate governance 105. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries subject to 84. Will additional sub-certifications be needed to open federal, state, local or foreign tax audits? ensure compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act? 106. Are any of the acquired subsidiaries parties to any 85. Are there any changes to any of debt instruments, or are any of their assets pledged? the board committees? 107. Has the par value of the subsidiaries’ shares 86. Are there any changes to the schedule been reviewed to determine whether excessive of board or committee meetings? franchise taxes are being incurred? 108. Are there domestic subsidiaries that need to International operations be merged out of existence or dissolved? 87. Are additional legal personnel 109. Are there subsidiaries that cannot be merged needed in overseas locations? out of existence or dissolved because of open tax 88. Do any of the acquired company’s trademarks audits, IP ownership or contractual reasons? need to be registered in overseas locations? 110. Have all the corporate minute books been 89. Are any additional foreign qualifications needed? retrieved and are they all up to date? 90. Are there redundant foreign subsidiaries 111. Are all the acquired subsidiaries in good standing or other legal entities as a result of the and are they qualified to do business in the acquisition that need to be merged out? jurisdictions where they need to be so qualified? 91. Are any changes needed to either party’s transfer pricing policies? Patents 92. Will there be any exchange control 112. Does there need to be coordination between issues going forward? the patent procedures at each company [e.g., 93. Are there any additional permits the invention disclosures, patent committees, or approvals to obtain? patent payments to inventors (upon 94. Should a compliance audit be performed submission of patentable idea, upon approval to assess any potential FCPA issues? of patentable idea by the patent committee, 95. Are there opportunities to obtain any governmental upon completion of the patent application, subsidies or incentives from the host government? upon issuance of the patent, etc.)]? 113. Do you have a current list of patents Export controls compliance for the acquired company? 96. Has a review been undertaken to determine 114. How will the patents of the acquired company whether any additional filings need to be done be docketed and maintained (i.e., by an existing with the US Department of Commerce to export patent service provider or moved to a new service the products of the acquired company? provider)? In examining the preceding, do you 97. Are additional export licenses needed? recognize any tasks that can be brought in-house or consolidated for a third-party service provider, such Subsidiary cleanup as management of maintenance fees for patents? 98. Do you have a list of corporate entities 115. Has a patent audit been conducted of the acquired owned by the acquired company? company to determine whether there are additional 99. Do you have an up-to-date list of inventions to patent that are not time-barred? your own corporate entities? 116. Have your patent attorneys sat down with the key 100. Have all of the acquired subsidiaries been entered inventors at the acquired company and discussed into the acquirer’s subsidiary tracking database? the patent philosophy of your company? 101. Have you determined who will serve as the 117. Is there any opportunity to license the directors of the foreign subsidiaries? Have you acquired company’s patents and develop checked residency/nationality requirements? a revenue stream from such patents?
  • 14. 118. Is there any patented technology at the acquired 132. Have you applied for all potential “cyber- company that might cause you to change a squatting” domain names relating to current IP litigation strategy, or vice versa, is the acquired company’s products? there any patented technology at the acquirer 133. Have you coordinated on how you would that can be leveraged in any IP litigation like splash screens to appear on the acquired that the acquired company is a party to? company’s websites? Is there a click- 119. Does the transaction have any effect on through to the merged company’s site? any patent license agreements that the acquired company is a party to? Labor and employment 120. Does the acquisition open the door to 134. Should all of the acquired company’s employees examining a patent licensing strategy? be required to execute new offer letters? 121. Does the acquired company have procedures 135. Do the employees of the acquired company to examine patentable ideas prior to release need to sign new confidentiality and of new products? Would this be a good assignment of inventions agreements? opportunity to implement such procedures? 136. Have all of the acquired company’s employees been advised of the acquirer’s Trademarks and other intellectual property employee policies and procedures? 122. Has the acquirer’s list of trademarks 137. Have you coordinated with HR on any and service marks been updated? potential reductions in force (e.g., severance 123. Has a decision been made as to which brand agreements, employment law compliance, names, trademarks and service marks of the collective bargaining issues)? acquired company will continue to be used? 138. Have WARN Act notices been given? 124. Are additional registrations required, 139. Have severance agreements been drafted? domestically and/or overseas? 140. How can severance liabilities be minimized? 125. Are there opportunities to restructure the 141. Have all employment agreements with ownership of the acquired company’s intellectual severance provisions been reviewed? property to effect a more tax-efficient structure? 142. Should the legal department plan an 126. Are revisions to the acquirer’s inter- employment law compliance training session company agreements required? for the managers of the acquired company? 127. Are there older trademarks at either company 143. Are there any collective bargaining organizing that can be re-used or expanded such that prior- initiatives currently underway? use or registration rights can be leveraged? 144. Are the employees of the acquired company covered by any collective bargaining agreements? Website When are such agreements next up for renewal? 128. If the acquired company is going to continue with its stand-alone website for a transitional period, Stock option and employee benefit plans have the copyright and trademark notices, privacy 145. Are any new stock option plans being policy and terms of use been revised to be in implemented to rollover the stock options of accordance with the acquirer’s approved template? the employees of the acquired company? 129. Have all the country-specific websites of the 146. Are there any new incentive compensation plans acquired company been reviewed to determine what (ICP) or management by objectives (MBO) plans changes will need to be made to the copyright and that are being implemented for the new employees? trademark notices, privacy policy and terms of use? 147. Have the appropriate Form S-8 and 130. If the acquired company was a public company, other filings been made with the SEC have the investor relations and corporate and the applicable stock exchanges? governance links on the acquired company’s 148. Have the stock option plans been adapted, and website been re-linked to the acquirer’s investor the requisite approvals obtained, so that stock relations and corporate governance pages? options can be issued to employees overseas? 131. Are there web-linking agreements that need to be updated to reflect that the links Use of forms and templates will now be to the acquirer’s website? 149. Have you reviewed the acquired company’s template agreements and attendant rules of use? ACC Docket C9 November 2011
  • 15. 150. Have you reviewed the acquired company’s 163. Has a timeline been established for converting templates to determine if key provisions all of the acquired company’s product (warranties, limitation of liability, license agreements and sales agreements indemnification, rights in derivative IP, etc.) to the new forms and templates? comply with the policies of the acquirer? 164. Have the forms been adapted for 151. Have you provided the acquired company’s use in new foreign locations? attorneys with a copy of your standard 165. Have the sales folks been briefed on the legal NDA(s) and the related rules of use? terms that they are not to negotiate without the approval of the acquirer’s legal department? Contract management 166. Are new click-through agreements needed for 152. Have the disclosure schedules been reviewed for the merged company’s software products? any contracts with change in control provisions 167. With the acquisition, is it realistic to form that will be triggered by the transaction and a group at the merged company to have require that a consent be obtained (or a paralegals or contract managers handle notice be provided) by the acquirer for the repetitive form agreements or processes, such contract’s assignment to be effective? as NDAs, evaluation agreements or open source 153. Has a form notice to customers and reviews, or new product release approvals? request for consent been prepared by legal/ contract management and approved by Real estate (owned and leased) sales/marketing for distribution? 168. Are any leases being terminated? 154. Are there contracts that require the acquirer 169. Do any of the leases to which the acquired to procure consents that still need to be company is a party to require notice or consent obtained for assignment of contracts from to assignment or change of control? the acquired company to the acquirer? 170. Are any subleases being contemplated with respect 155. Is someone charged with maintaining a to redundant office space of the acquired company? continuously updated list of contracts 171. Are any leases being renegotiated? that require consents to be obtained? 172. Are facilities being consolidated, 156. How will the contract management domestically or overseas? process be merged? 173. Are there “change of address” notices, which 157. Have the acquired company’s contract are required to be sent to any governmental management personnel been trained on authorities, domestically or overseas? the use of the acquirer’s forms? 174. Are there opportunities to minimize 158. How will the acquired company’s contract files be real estate or transfer taxes? maintained and where will they be maintained? 175. In reviewing the consolidated property 159. Are there customer contract forms used portfolio, are there opportunities to by the acquired company that should sell or sublease properties? replace forms used by the acquirer? 160. Are there changes to the form customer contracts Regulatory environment that need to be made due to the acquirer now doing 176. Does the acquired company place the business in additional states or foreign jurisdictions acquirer in a new regulatory environment where local law requires such changes? where, for the first time, it is subject to 161. Do you need to bring in a temp paralegal to compliance with a statute or regulation that handle notices and assignments required under the heretofore it did not have to comply with? acquired company’s agreements? Or is it realistic 177. Are there notices to be filed in order to to assign these tasks to current staff members? comply with new regulatory requirements? 178. Does the acquirer’s legal department have Product licensing and sales sufficient competency to ensure the acquirer’s 162. Has a decision been made on which compliance with the new regulatory regime? company’s product licensing forms and 179. Is the nature of the regulatory regime such that an templates will be used going forward? additional full-time in-house person is necessary, or is it such that outside counsel is sufficient?
  • 16. 180. Has an in-house legal person been appointed as the 194. Do the limits and retention amounts of the point person for this new regulatory regime? Or has acquirer’s insurance need to be revised? outside counsel been identified to handle this area? 195. Is there transaction-specific litigation that needs to be brought to the attention of Government sales and relations the insurance broker and the insurer? 181. Does the acquisition affect the acquirer’s 196. Has the acquirer’s legal malpractice government relations strategy? insurance coverage been updated to 182. Are additional state and/or federal include the additional legal department lobbying resources needed? personnel from the acquired company? 183. Does the GSA schedule need to be 197. Should any in-house counsel be covered amended to include the acquired company’s under the acquirer’s DO insurance policy products and price schedules? (e.g., GC, deputy GC, corporate secretary, 184. Do security clearances need to be obtained by any assistant corporate secretaries, etc.)? legal department personnel in connection with sales to governmental agencies and instrumentalities? Corporate policies 185. Are there government entities, domestic and 198. Have all of the acquired company employees overseas, where the relationship with the been made aware of the acquirer’s policies? acquired company could be improved? Have copies been distributed, either hard-copy or via email, of the acquirer’s policies to ensure Public relations compliance (e.g., code of conduct, Sarbanes- 186. Have the employees of the acquired Oxley Act, policy against harassment in the company been advised of the acquirer’s workplace, insider trading, antitrust/competition, communications policies and processes? revenue recognition, whistleblower, records 187. Has the press release boilerplate been retention, foreign corrupt practices act, etc.)? updated to include, among other things, 199. Is additional compliance training necessary for any additional forward-looking risk factors the employees of the acquired company? and trademark attribution language? 200. Has a click-through acknowledgement been created for the website for the acquired Marketing company employees to acknowledge that 188. Have the marketing personnel of the they have read the acquirer’s policies? acquired company been briefed on the acquirer’s process for vetting and approving Conclusion new brand names, trademarks and service The MA world is littered with deals that have gone bad marks, and approving all product packaging because folks paid scant attention to the heavy lifting that and the legal notices placed thereon? integration requires following the closing of any transaction. 189. Has the product packaging of the acquired We hope the 200 items that we have listed above will pro- company’s products been reviewed to determine vide in-house counsel with a useful roadmap for planning changes that will need to be made? the integration of two legal departments post-acquisition, 190. Has the “style guide” been updated to and will contribute to not only a smooth transition, but also incorporate the acquired company’s products an MA transaction that has a better chance of being suc- and brands, and has the legal department cessful due to a thoughtful integration strategy. approved the revised “style guide”? Insurance 191. Has the acquirer’s insurance broker been brought up to date on the transaction, and provided with relevant information and required notices with respect to the transaction? 192. Have the insurance policies of the acquired company been converted to tail policies? 193. Is there additional insurance that needs to be procured as a result of the acquisition? ACC Docket C11 November 2011