SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1
What's the big deal
about self-plagiarism?
Publication Ethics - Editage Insights
What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1
Question
Dear Dr. Eddy, I recently submitted my manuscript for publication and it was rejected by the journal saying the
data is partially redundant since I have published it in the past. I agree that I used some of the data from a
previous paper because this is an extension of the same study. I would like to know why it is unacceptable to use
some of my own published data in my future publications.
Answer
I am sorry to learn about the journal’s decision on your manuscript.
A redundant publication is also referred to as self-plagiarism and is defined as a type of plagiarism in which
the writer republishes a work in its entirety or reuses portions of a previously written text while authoring a
new work. It is acceptable for authors to re-use their copyrighted works if the previously published work is
appropriately cited. However, it is considered unethical if the authors portray a previously published work as
new, when it is not.
A redundant publication could also lead to copyright infringement. Once a manuscript is accepted for
publication, the authors are often required to submit a signed copyright form to the publishers, wherein the
author guarantees that the work is original and that no part of it has been previously published. Though
authors can quote from their previous publications with the relevant citations, duplicate publication of
previously reported data is considered unethical.
According to guidelines issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE,) journal editors should
consider retracting a paper if it is found to be redundant. To prevent submission of redundant manuscripts,
individual journals follow specific guidelines. For example, the New England Journal of Medicine insists that
authors should submit to the editor copies of any published papers or other manuscripts in preparation or
submitted elsewhere that are related to the manuscript to be considered by the journal.
In the case of your manuscript, which is based on one of your earlier published studies, it is important that
you provide citations for all references to your previous work. Further, to avoid being considered guilty of
self-plagiarism, it would be advisable to add a note to the editor in the cover letter, informing him/her of
the previously published study that forms the basis of the current study.
TAGS: plagiarism self-plagiarism redundant publication
Content source: http://www.editage.com/insights/whats-the-big-deal-about-self-plagiarism
What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Weekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
Weekly Science Story Analysis AssignmentWeekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
Weekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
Jodie Nicotra
 
Veterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
Veterinary Nursing - Literature SearchingVeterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
Veterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
Jamie Halstead
 

Was ist angesagt? (18)

Computational Systems Biology (JCSB)
Computational Systems Biology (JCSB)Computational Systems Biology (JCSB)
Computational Systems Biology (JCSB)
 
Citing Your Sources
Citing Your SourcesCiting Your Sources
Citing Your Sources
 
Library101 citation 2
Library101 citation 2Library101 citation 2
Library101 citation 2
 
Project Management
Project Management Project Management
Project Management
 
Health Sport & Exercise Science
Health Sport & Exercise ScienceHealth Sport & Exercise Science
Health Sport & Exercise Science
 
Fenner2010
Fenner2010Fenner2010
Fenner2010
 
Sociology: Health & Medicine
Sociology: Health & MedicineSociology: Health & Medicine
Sociology: Health & Medicine
 
2 presentation-keivan-navi
2 presentation-keivan-navi2 presentation-keivan-navi
2 presentation-keivan-navi
 
Special Education: Early Childhood
Special Education: Early ChildhoodSpecial Education: Early Childhood
Special Education: Early Childhood
 
What do we know about the h index?
What do we know about the h index?What do we know about the h index?
What do we know about the h index?
 
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
 
Medline Resource Guide
Medline Resource GuideMedline Resource Guide
Medline Resource Guide
 
Altmetrics for research: impact measurement &#hcsm
Altmetrics for research: impact measurement &#hcsmAltmetrics for research: impact measurement &#hcsm
Altmetrics for research: impact measurement &#hcsm
 
Primary research presentation r leap 1st section of the manual
Primary research   presentation r leap 1st section of the manualPrimary research   presentation r leap 1st section of the manual
Primary research presentation r leap 1st section of the manual
 
Publications [www.writekraft.com]
Publications [www.writekraft.com]Publications [www.writekraft.com]
Publications [www.writekraft.com]
 
Citation indexing
Citation indexingCitation indexing
Citation indexing
 
Weekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
Weekly Science Story Analysis AssignmentWeekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
Weekly Science Story Analysis Assignment
 
Veterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
Veterinary Nursing - Literature SearchingVeterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
Veterinary Nursing - Literature Searching
 

Ähnlich wie Whats the big deal about self-plagiarism?

Ähnlich wie Whats the big deal about self-plagiarism? (20)

RPE05.pptx
RPE05.pptxRPE05.pptx
RPE05.pptx
 
2. Duplicate Publications.pptx
2. Duplicate Publications.pptx2. Duplicate Publications.pptx
2. Duplicate Publications.pptx
 
APA manual PPT Chapter - 1
APA  manual PPT Chapter - 1APA  manual PPT Chapter - 1
APA manual PPT Chapter - 1
 
Duplicate Publications and its Case Studies.pptx
Duplicate Publications and its Case Studies.pptxDuplicate Publications and its Case Studies.pptx
Duplicate Publications and its Case Studies.pptx
 
Error in publications: What authors need to know about errata, corrigenda and...
Error in publications: What authors need to know about errata, corrigenda and...Error in publications: What authors need to know about errata, corrigenda and...
Error in publications: What authors need to know about errata, corrigenda and...
 
How to deal with a journal rejection seminar
How to deal with a journal rejection seminar How to deal with a journal rejection seminar
How to deal with a journal rejection seminar
 
Dealing with Academic Rejection 25 Feb 2017
Dealing with Academic Rejection 25 Feb 2017Dealing with Academic Rejection 25 Feb 2017
Dealing with Academic Rejection 25 Feb 2017
 
Paper Clinic.pptx
Paper Clinic.pptxPaper Clinic.pptx
Paper Clinic.pptx
 
Academic manuscript to Publication
Academic manuscript to PublicationAcademic manuscript to Publication
Academic manuscript to Publication
 
Review process 2
Review process 2Review process 2
Review process 2
 
publication.pptx
publication.pptxpublication.pptx
publication.pptx
 
How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
 
Instructions to Authors
Instructions to AuthorsInstructions to Authors
Instructions to Authors
 
APA Manual Chapter 8
APA Manual Chapter  8APA Manual Chapter  8
APA Manual Chapter 8
 
Prepare to Publish: Find the Best Journal Know Your Rights as an Author
Prepare to Publish: Find the Best Journal Know Your Rights as an AuthorPrepare to Publish: Find the Best Journal Know Your Rights as an Author
Prepare to Publish: Find the Best Journal Know Your Rights as an Author
 
Plagiarism
PlagiarismPlagiarism
Plagiarism
 
Daniel Feerst - What is Ethical Publishing and unethical Publishing
Daniel Feerst - What is Ethical Publishing and unethical PublishingDaniel Feerst - What is Ethical Publishing and unethical Publishing
Daniel Feerst - What is Ethical Publishing and unethical Publishing
 
Cmps research school retreat pres by sutton
Cmps research school retreat pres by suttonCmps research school retreat pres by sutton
Cmps research school retreat pres by sutton
 
Etiquette in research and scientific publishing
Etiquette in research and scientific publishingEtiquette in research and scientific publishing
Etiquette in research and scientific publishing
 
prezentare workshop-taylor-and-francis-publishing-in-academic-journals–tips-...
 prezentare workshop-taylor-and-francis-publishing-in-academic-journals–tips-... prezentare workshop-taylor-and-francis-publishing-in-academic-journals–tips-...
prezentare workshop-taylor-and-francis-publishing-in-academic-journals–tips-...
 

Mehr von Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)

Mehr von Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals) (20)

14 quick tips for responding to reviewer comments
14 quick tips for responding to reviewer comments14 quick tips for responding to reviewer comments
14 quick tips for responding to reviewer comments
 
Types of plagiarism in academic publishing
Types of plagiarism in academic publishingTypes of plagiarism in academic publishing
Types of plagiarism in academic publishing
 
Manuscript Submission Checklist: Everything you need to consider before submi...
Manuscript Submission Checklist: Everything you need to consider before submi...Manuscript Submission Checklist: Everything you need to consider before submi...
Manuscript Submission Checklist: Everything you need to consider before submi...
 
Authorship (Part 2): How to decided the order of authors in a research paper
Authorship (Part 2): How to decided the order of authors in a research paperAuthorship (Part 2): How to decided the order of authors in a research paper
Authorship (Part 2): How to decided the order of authors in a research paper
 
Authorship (Part 1): Who should be the author of a research paper
Authorship (Part 1): Who should be the author of a research paperAuthorship (Part 1): Who should be the author of a research paper
Authorship (Part 1): Who should be the author of a research paper
 
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
 
Nuggets of wisdom from industry thought leaders
Nuggets of wisdom from industry thought leadersNuggets of wisdom from industry thought leaders
Nuggets of wisdom from industry thought leaders
 
Tips for choosing a legitimate open access journal
Tips for choosing a legitimate open access journalTips for choosing a legitimate open access journal
Tips for choosing a legitimate open access journal
 
How to write a cover letter for journal submissions
How to write a cover letter for journal submissionsHow to write a cover letter for journal submissions
How to write a cover letter for journal submissions
 
9 tips for presenting at an academic conference
9 tips for presenting at an academic conference9 tips for presenting at an academic conference
9 tips for presenting at an academic conference
 
6 ethical principles to follow - when writing a paper on Traditional Medicine
6 ethical principles to follow - when writing a paper on Traditional Medicine6 ethical principles to follow - when writing a paper on Traditional Medicine
6 ethical principles to follow - when writing a paper on Traditional Medicine
 
Dear Reviewer: Notes of appreciation from authors to peer reviewers
Dear Reviewer: Notes of appreciation from authors to peer reviewersDear Reviewer: Notes of appreciation from authors to peer reviewers
Dear Reviewer: Notes of appreciation from authors to peer reviewers
 
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
 
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trialsA researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials
 
10 tips to help you reduce the length of your research paper
10 tips to help you reduce the length of your research paper10 tips to help you reduce the length of your research paper
10 tips to help you reduce the length of your research paper
 
How to write a literature review
How to write a literature reviewHow to write a literature review
How to write a literature review
 
Academic publishing advice from industry experts
Academic publishing advice from industry expertsAcademic publishing advice from industry experts
Academic publishing advice from industry experts
 
How to write an original research article
How to write an original research articleHow to write an original research article
How to write an original research article
 
What types of articles do journals publish?
What types of articles do journals publish?What types of articles do journals publish?
What types of articles do journals publish?
 
Learn more about replication studies and negative results
Learn more about replication studies and negative resultsLearn more about replication studies and negative results
Learn more about replication studies and negative results
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Morcall Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
vikas rana
 
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentationthe Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
brynpueblos04
 
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarkacall Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
vikas rana
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (14)

call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Morcall Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka Mor
 
LC_YouSaidYes_NewBelieverBookletDone.pdf
LC_YouSaidYes_NewBelieverBookletDone.pdfLC_YouSaidYes_NewBelieverBookletDone.pdf
LC_YouSaidYes_NewBelieverBookletDone.pdf
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Jasola (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Jasola (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Jasola (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Jasola (Delhi)
 
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escorts ...
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escorts ...(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escorts ...
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Navi Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Navi Mumbai Escorts ...
 
WOMEN EMPOWERMENT women empowerment.pptx
WOMEN EMPOWERMENT women empowerment.pptxWOMEN EMPOWERMENT women empowerment.pptx
WOMEN EMPOWERMENT women empowerment.pptx
 
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
KLINIK BATA Jual obat penggugur kandungan 087776558899 ABORSI JANIN KEHAMILAN...
 
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentationthe Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
the Husband rolesBrown Aesthetic Cute Group Project Presentation
 
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy TheoryPokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
Pokemon Go... Unraveling the Conspiracy Theory
 
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarkacall Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
call Now 9811711561 Cash Payment乂 Call Girls in Dwarka
 
(Aarini) Russian Call Girls Surat Call Now 8250077686 Surat Escorts 24x7
(Aarini) Russian Call Girls Surat Call Now 8250077686 Surat Escorts 24x7(Aarini) Russian Call Girls Surat Call Now 8250077686 Surat Escorts 24x7
(Aarini) Russian Call Girls Surat Call Now 8250077686 Surat Escorts 24x7
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Dashrath Puri (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Dashrath Puri (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Dashrath Puri (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Dashrath Puri (Delhi)
 
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
Call Girls In Mumbai Just Genuine Call ☎ 7738596112✅ Call Girl Andheri East G...
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar (Delhi)
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Palam (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Palam (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Palam (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Palam (Delhi)
 

Whats the big deal about self-plagiarism?

  • 1. What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1 What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? Publication Ethics - Editage Insights
  • 2. What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1 Question Dear Dr. Eddy, I recently submitted my manuscript for publication and it was rejected by the journal saying the data is partially redundant since I have published it in the past. I agree that I used some of the data from a previous paper because this is an extension of the same study. I would like to know why it is unacceptable to use some of my own published data in my future publications. Answer I am sorry to learn about the journal’s decision on your manuscript. A redundant publication is also referred to as self-plagiarism and is defined as a type of plagiarism in which the writer republishes a work in its entirety or reuses portions of a previously written text while authoring a new work. It is acceptable for authors to re-use their copyrighted works if the previously published work is appropriately cited. However, it is considered unethical if the authors portray a previously published work as new, when it is not. A redundant publication could also lead to copyright infringement. Once a manuscript is accepted for publication, the authors are often required to submit a signed copyright form to the publishers, wherein the author guarantees that the work is original and that no part of it has been previously published. Though authors can quote from their previous publications with the relevant citations, duplicate publication of previously reported data is considered unethical. According to guidelines issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE,) journal editors should consider retracting a paper if it is found to be redundant. To prevent submission of redundant manuscripts, individual journals follow specific guidelines. For example, the New England Journal of Medicine insists that authors should submit to the editor copies of any published papers or other manuscripts in preparation or submitted elsewhere that are related to the manuscript to be considered by the journal. In the case of your manuscript, which is based on one of your earlier published studies, it is important that you provide citations for all references to your previous work. Further, to avoid being considered guilty of self-plagiarism, it would be advisable to add a note to the editor in the cover letter, informing him/her of the previously published study that forms the basis of the current study. TAGS: plagiarism self-plagiarism redundant publication Content source: http://www.editage.com/insights/whats-the-big-deal-about-self-plagiarism
  • 3. What's the big deal about self-plagiarism? 1