SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Views of Greeks on Migration
    An Ongoing Debate




                   T. Bakker, V.Tsiligiri & A. Gkiouleka
Current situation
• Fourth year of economic crisis.
• Golden Dawn in the parliament after the
  elections of 2012 (7%).
• Rise of racist attacks.
• Law 3838/10 judged as unconstitutional from
  the High Court.
• Xenios Zeus operation.
Expectations
• Racist feelings among Athenian population.
• More negative attitudes among Athenians
  living in areas with high immigrants’
  segregation.
• High level of perceived threat and difference
  between women and men.
Methodology
• Observation in various areas of Athens.
• Interviews: semi-structured, open questions,
  attention to threatening questions.
• Documentation of general discussions that
  came to attention during the winter course.
Map
Observations
Remarkably decreased number of migrants in
  the city center.
National identity is salient in the streets
  (flags, slogans, commercial labels).
Graffiti: A symbolic “battle” on the
               walls




FOREIGNERS OUTSIDE GREECE AI SIHTIR
NATIONAL FRONT
                      NATIONALISM




THE MORE THEY
STEAL OUR LIFE, THE
MORE THEY FEED US
WITH NATION AND
RACE
WE BECAME IMMIGRANTS IN OUR
                            NEIGHBOURHOOD




OUR GRANDPARENTS REFUGEES
OUR PARENTS IMMIGRANTS
WE RACISTS???
FOREIGNERS OUTSIDE




BEAT THE FASCISTS, DARLING
21 Interviews
                 Respondents’ characteristics
Gender: 14 women / 7 men
Age range:
• 18-30: 9 respondents
• 31-50: 7 respondents
• 51 and older: 5 respondents
Employment Status:
• 4 pensioners
• 7 university students
• 1 unemployed
• 9 employed (shop owners, private sector employees, street
  merchant)
General Findings
• Economic crisis and immigration strongly
  connected in the public discourse.
• Concern about the large number of
  immigrants.
• Criminality associated with economic crisis
  and strongly linked with immigrants.
• Immigrants mostly visible in the labor market.
Respondents with negative attitudes
• Most negative attitudes expressed in the areas with
  large numbers of immigrants.
• Certain ethnic groups are more stigmatized (Pakistani,
  Afghan, Bangladeshi, Iraqi)
• Perceived threat expressed mostly by women (physical
  violence associated mostly with men, less with
  immigrants).
• Imputation of disrespect for human life to migrants.
• Denial of being racist.
• Lack of inter-group relationships.
Respondents with positive attitudes
•   Racism is a diachronic phenomenon.
•   Personal threat from Golden Dawn.
•   Fear of being portrayed as racists.
•   Personal relationships with migrants.
•   Immigrants seen as the scapegoats of the
    economic and social crisis.
Impressions from the respondents’
              behaviour
• Differences in willingness to talk.
• Hot topic, taken very seriously.
• No hesitation of mentioning extreme negative
  thoughts.
• Distinction mentioned between the notion of
  “foreigner” and “immigrant”.
Conclusions & Suggestions
• Immigration is considered as a phenomenon to
  be handled seriously.
• The situation is perceived in contradicting ways
  among people.

• Further research for deeper understanding
  should take place on a larger scale (time &
  sample).
• Focus also should be given to the influence of
  dominant public discourse (mass & social media),
  political orientation and contacts with migrants.

More Related Content

What's hot

Migration, Globalization and Demographic Change
Migration, Globalization and Demographic ChangeMigration, Globalization and Demographic Change
Migration, Globalization and Demographic Changebrunogiegerich
 
Globalization and Filipino Migration
Globalization and Filipino MigrationGlobalization and Filipino Migration
Globalization and Filipino MigrationJanice Chin
 
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of Resentment
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of ResentmentRight-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of Resentment
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of ResentmentTuukka Ylä-Anttila
 
Migration A1 1
Migration A1 1Migration A1 1
Migration A1 1mrscox
 
Elements that make news
Elements that make newsElements that make news
Elements that make newsJasmin Cruz
 
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012Peace-House
 
David Brown - Shifing values and preferences
David Brown - Shifing values and preferencesDavid Brown - Shifing values and preferences
David Brown - Shifing values and preferencesOECDregions
 
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United States
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United StatesRight-Wing Populism in Europe and the United States
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United StatesJeffrey Hart
 
New approaches to humanitarianism
New approaches to humanitarianismNew approaches to humanitarianism
New approaches to humanitarianismHelen Hintjens
 
Cultural integration
Cultural integrationCultural integration
Cultural integrationManisha Hamal
 
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...AwqafSA
 

What's hot (20)

Global networks
Global networksGlobal networks
Global networks
 
Migration, Globalization and Demographic Change
Migration, Globalization and Demographic ChangeMigration, Globalization and Demographic Change
Migration, Globalization and Demographic Change
 
Globalization and Filipino Migration
Globalization and Filipino MigrationGlobalization and Filipino Migration
Globalization and Filipino Migration
 
MIGRATION-RAFI
MIGRATION-RAFIMIGRATION-RAFI
MIGRATION-RAFI
 
Refugees in Europe
Refugees in EuropeRefugees in Europe
Refugees in Europe
 
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of Resentment
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of ResentmentRight-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of Resentment
Right-Wing Populist Parties and the Politicization of Resentment
 
Political Economy of Populism
Political Economy of PopulismPolitical Economy of Populism
Political Economy of Populism
 
Soc 451, 9th class
Soc 451, 9th classSoc 451, 9th class
Soc 451, 9th class
 
Migration A1 1
Migration A1 1Migration A1 1
Migration A1 1
 
Immigrants
ImmigrantsImmigrants
Immigrants
 
Soc 451, 7th class
Soc 451, 7th classSoc 451, 7th class
Soc 451, 7th class
 
Elements that make news
Elements that make newsElements that make news
Elements that make news
 
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012
Peace House Accomplishments & Activities 2012
 
David Brown - Shifing values and preferences
David Brown - Shifing values and preferencesDavid Brown - Shifing values and preferences
David Brown - Shifing values and preferences
 
Ch03 AP Human
Ch03 AP HumanCh03 AP Human
Ch03 AP Human
 
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United States
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United StatesRight-Wing Populism in Europe and the United States
Right-Wing Populism in Europe and the United States
 
New approaches to humanitarianism
New approaches to humanitarianismNew approaches to humanitarianism
New approaches to humanitarianism
 
Seminar outcome
Seminar outcomeSeminar outcome
Seminar outcome
 
Cultural integration
Cultural integrationCultural integration
Cultural integration
 
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...
Rolling back Xenophobia through community dialogues presenation - Nurudean Ss...
 

Viewers also liked

Muslim migrants in athens religious
Muslim migrants in athens religiousMuslim migrants in athens religious
Muslim migrants in athens religiousdorethvanmanen
 
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greece
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, GreeceSeeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greece
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greecedorethvanmanen
 
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1dellissimo
 
Muslim Migrants in Athens: Religion in Times of Marginalisation
Muslim Migrants in Athens:  Religion in Times of MarginalisationMuslim Migrants in Athens:  Religion in Times of Marginalisation
Muslim Migrants in Athens: Religion in Times of Marginalisationdorethvanmanen
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Muslim migrants in athens religious
Muslim migrants in athens religiousMuslim migrants in athens religious
Muslim migrants in athens religious
 
Crisis overload
Crisis overloadCrisis overload
Crisis overload
 
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greece
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, GreeceSeeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greece
Seeing the city anew, Sudanese perspectives of Athens, Greece
 
Lives passing borders
Lives passing bordersLives passing borders
Lives passing borders
 
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1
Mar 8 single_map_analysis_1
 
Muslim Migrants in Athens: Religion in Times of Marginalisation
Muslim Migrants in Athens:  Religion in Times of MarginalisationMuslim Migrants in Athens:  Religion in Times of Marginalisation
Muslim Migrants in Athens: Religion in Times of Marginalisation
 

Similar to Views of Greeks on Migration An Ongoing Debate

Population distribution. Human Geography
Population distribution. Human GeographyPopulation distribution. Human Geography
Population distribution. Human GeographyAssignmentOnUs
 
Migration Revision A level
Migration Revision A level Migration Revision A level
Migration Revision A level Brittany Farrant
 
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and Challenges
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and ChallengesMigration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and Challenges
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and ChallengesInstituto Diáspora Brasil (IDB)
 
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docx
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docxReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docx
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docxlorent8
 
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docx
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docxMulticulturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docx
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docxgilpinleeanna
 
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agents
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agentsGreek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agents
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agentsdorethvanmanen
 
Multiculturalism in the uk
Multiculturalism in the ukMulticulturalism in the uk
Multiculturalism in the ukTommy Lumby
 
Race, ethnicity, and migration
Race, ethnicity, and migrationRace, ethnicity, and migration
Race, ethnicity, and migrationfatima d
 
Cult anth lecture migration
Cult anth lecture migrationCult anth lecture migration
Cult anth lecture migrationkolsonanth
 
Informative Presentation By Gertrude Malesi
Informative Presentation By Gertrude MalesiInformative Presentation By Gertrude Malesi
Informative Presentation By Gertrude MalesiGertrude Osinde
 
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...Migrating out of Poverty
 
38132070 brain-drain
38132070 brain-drain38132070 brain-drain
38132070 brain-draingyanchandi
 
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docx
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docxRace and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docx
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docxaudeleypearl
 
POPULATION CHANGE.pptx
POPULATION CHANGE.pptxPOPULATION CHANGE.pptx
POPULATION CHANGE.pptxRhaine K2
 

Similar to Views of Greeks on Migration An Ongoing Debate (20)

Public Lecture Slides (10.3.2017) Is Japan susceptible to populism?
 Public Lecture Slides (10.3.2017) Is Japan susceptible to populism?  Public Lecture Slides (10.3.2017) Is Japan susceptible to populism?
Public Lecture Slides (10.3.2017) Is Japan susceptible to populism?
 
Population distribution. Human Geography
Population distribution. Human GeographyPopulation distribution. Human Geography
Population distribution. Human Geography
 
Migration Revision A level
Migration Revision A level Migration Revision A level
Migration Revision A level
 
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and Challenges
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and ChallengesMigration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and Challenges
Migration and Transnationalism: Opportunities and Challenges
 
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docx
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docxReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docx
ReferencesKorgen, K. O., & Atkinson, M. P. (2019). Sociology.docx
 
Wilfred Yang Wang: Remaking Guangzhou: Political Engagement and Place-making ...
Wilfred Yang Wang: Remaking Guangzhou: Political Engagement and Place-making ...Wilfred Yang Wang: Remaking Guangzhou: Political Engagement and Place-making ...
Wilfred Yang Wang: Remaking Guangzhou: Political Engagement and Place-making ...
 
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docx
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docxMulticulturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docx
Multiculturalism in the NewsBrian Taylor, Antoinette Dent, Tia.docx
 
Demography 2018
Demography 2018Demography 2018
Demography 2018
 
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agents
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agentsGreek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agents
Greek perspectives on migration: State institutions, the police and their agents
 
Multiculturalism in the uk
Multiculturalism in the ukMulticulturalism in the uk
Multiculturalism in the uk
 
Race, ethnicity, and migration
Race, ethnicity, and migrationRace, ethnicity, and migration
Race, ethnicity, and migration
 
Cult anth lecture migration
Cult anth lecture migrationCult anth lecture migration
Cult anth lecture migration
 
Informative Presentation By Gertrude Malesi
Informative Presentation By Gertrude MalesiInformative Presentation By Gertrude Malesi
Informative Presentation By Gertrude Malesi
 
RURAL URBAN DYNAMICS.pptx
RURAL URBAN DYNAMICS.pptxRURAL URBAN DYNAMICS.pptx
RURAL URBAN DYNAMICS.pptx
 
migration-basic.ppt
migration-basic.pptmigration-basic.ppt
migration-basic.ppt
 
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...
No choice or no chance? Decision-making and narratives of migration among Eri...
 
Dean r berry individual versus society unit
Dean r berry individual versus society unitDean r berry individual versus society unit
Dean r berry individual versus society unit
 
38132070 brain-drain
38132070 brain-drain38132070 brain-drain
38132070 brain-drain
 
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docx
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docxRace and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docx
Race and Ethnicity – Part II SOCY 3720-E01 Global Perspect.docx
 
POPULATION CHANGE.pptx
POPULATION CHANGE.pptxPOPULATION CHANGE.pptx
POPULATION CHANGE.pptx
 

Views of Greeks on Migration An Ongoing Debate

  • 1. Views of Greeks on Migration An Ongoing Debate T. Bakker, V.Tsiligiri & A. Gkiouleka
  • 2. Current situation • Fourth year of economic crisis. • Golden Dawn in the parliament after the elections of 2012 (7%). • Rise of racist attacks. • Law 3838/10 judged as unconstitutional from the High Court. • Xenios Zeus operation.
  • 3. Expectations • Racist feelings among Athenian population. • More negative attitudes among Athenians living in areas with high immigrants’ segregation. • High level of perceived threat and difference between women and men.
  • 4. Methodology • Observation in various areas of Athens. • Interviews: semi-structured, open questions, attention to threatening questions. • Documentation of general discussions that came to attention during the winter course.
  • 5. Map
  • 6. Observations Remarkably decreased number of migrants in the city center.
  • 7. National identity is salient in the streets (flags, slogans, commercial labels).
  • 8. Graffiti: A symbolic “battle” on the walls FOREIGNERS OUTSIDE GREECE AI SIHTIR
  • 9. NATIONAL FRONT NATIONALISM THE MORE THEY STEAL OUR LIFE, THE MORE THEY FEED US WITH NATION AND RACE
  • 10. WE BECAME IMMIGRANTS IN OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD OUR GRANDPARENTS REFUGEES OUR PARENTS IMMIGRANTS WE RACISTS???
  • 11. FOREIGNERS OUTSIDE BEAT THE FASCISTS, DARLING
  • 12.
  • 13. 21 Interviews Respondents’ characteristics Gender: 14 women / 7 men Age range: • 18-30: 9 respondents • 31-50: 7 respondents • 51 and older: 5 respondents Employment Status: • 4 pensioners • 7 university students • 1 unemployed • 9 employed (shop owners, private sector employees, street merchant)
  • 14. General Findings • Economic crisis and immigration strongly connected in the public discourse. • Concern about the large number of immigrants. • Criminality associated with economic crisis and strongly linked with immigrants. • Immigrants mostly visible in the labor market.
  • 15. Respondents with negative attitudes • Most negative attitudes expressed in the areas with large numbers of immigrants. • Certain ethnic groups are more stigmatized (Pakistani, Afghan, Bangladeshi, Iraqi) • Perceived threat expressed mostly by women (physical violence associated mostly with men, less with immigrants). • Imputation of disrespect for human life to migrants. • Denial of being racist. • Lack of inter-group relationships.
  • 16. Respondents with positive attitudes • Racism is a diachronic phenomenon. • Personal threat from Golden Dawn. • Fear of being portrayed as racists. • Personal relationships with migrants. • Immigrants seen as the scapegoats of the economic and social crisis.
  • 17. Impressions from the respondents’ behaviour • Differences in willingness to talk. • Hot topic, taken very seriously. • No hesitation of mentioning extreme negative thoughts. • Distinction mentioned between the notion of “foreigner” and “immigrant”.
  • 18. Conclusions & Suggestions • Immigration is considered as a phenomenon to be handled seriously. • The situation is perceived in contradicting ways among people. • Further research for deeper understanding should take place on a larger scale (time & sample). • Focus also should be given to the influence of dominant public discourse (mass & social media), political orientation and contacts with migrants.