Laser levelers are a solution to problems in cultivation like soil erosion, water wastage, and crop loss. They have become a popular small business in Punjab and Haryana, with over 4,000 in operation. There are challenges to their adoption in Eastern Uttar Pradesh, like small land holdings and lack of credit. Pilot projects are promoting laser leveler service providers in EUP. The business model analysis estimates attractive returns on investment of 6-23% even with medium performance over a 3 month season.
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Business Model - Laser Levellers
1. LASER LEVELLERS BUSINESS MODEL
By
Aanand Kumar
Business Model Specialist
Cereal Systems Initiative for South Asia
www.csisaportal.com
_________________________________________________________________________
Laser Levellers are a solution to several emergent problems faced in cultivation such as soil
erosion, water wastage, crop loss, pest problem and nutrient loss
Business model for Laser Leveller
Laser Leveller has been taken up as a small business by service providers on a wide scale in
Punjab and Haryana. More than 4000 laser levellers are in operation in Punjab. They are also
widely used in Haryana and western UP.
1
2. Laser Levellers are currently making an entry in EUP where there are several challenges that
they face.
Challenges in E-UP include:
Small and fragmented size of land holdings
Under developed credit flow and institutional finance
Inadequate participation of the private sector in commercialisation of the agri sector
Recurrent floods
Pilots are being done to promote Laser Levellers through Service Providers in EUP.
Cost of a tractor: Rs.6 lakh
Cost of a laser leveller Rs.3.5 lakh
Season March - May approx 90 days (~1000 hours)
$1 = 45 INR
In USD In Rs.
Investment
Tractor 50 HP $13,333 Rs. 600,000
Laser Leveller $7,778 Rs. 350,000
Total $21,111 Rs. 950,000
Revenue/ hour $10 Rs. 450
Costs/ hour
(assuming 15 hours per day of operation)
Salaries (for 3 drivers) $0.44 Rs. 20
Food (for 3 drivers) $0.22 Rs. 10
O&M $0.33 Rs. 15
Diesel $4.44 Rs. 200
Total $5.44 Rs. 245
Profits/ Hour $4.56 Rs. 205
2
3. Return on investment calculated as below is attractive even if performance is medium.
Estimates in Rs.
Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario
3
Minimum Optimal Maximum
Days in season 50 60 70
Average hours/ day 6 10 15
Hours in season 300 600 1050
Acres (~3 acres/ hour) 100 200 350
Revenue/ hour 450 450 450
Costs/ hour 245 245 245
Profits/ hour 205 205 205
Profits/ season 61500 123000 215250
Investment made
Tractor (50 hp) 650000 600000 600000
Laser Leveller 350000 350000 350000
Total investment made 1000000 950000 950000
ROI 6% 13% 23%
Assumptions made:
The season for laser leveller is for 90-100 days (March 1 till May 31)
Laser leveller will find work for approximately 1000 hours – approximately 15 hours
everyday
Approximately 15 hours of work can be done in a day at the maximum
Three drivers will be available round the clock
Money will be paid on time by all the farmers
Approximate times taken for laser levelling in hours per acre:
o 6 and above hours/ acre for undulating land with difference in elevation > 60 cm.
o 5-6 hours/ acre for rough scrub land which has never been farmed
o 2-3 hours for land which has been farmed and tilled but never been laser levelled
o 1 -1.5 hour/ acre for land laser levelled anytime during the past 2-3 years
Repeated usage in same farm:
o Under ideal conditions of zero till - never again. Might be done once in 10 years
o In minimum to normal till, laser levelling is required after every 2-3 years
Maintenance:
o Laser Leveler machines are low maintenance.
o A Laser Leveler unit can run for approximately 8 years if maintained properly.
Reach of a laser leveller
o Taking the maximum possible scenario, a Laser Leveller can work for 12 hours
daily for a period of 90 days, this works out to be 1080 hours
o If it takes 3 hours to cover one acre, the maximum possible is about 360 acres
o If the laser leveller is repeated in the same farm after every 4 years, we are
looking at an impact of 1080 acres per laser leveller
3
4. o Assuming that 50% of households agree to get their lands levelled, a laser
leveller can have a maximum impact zone of 2160 acres in its entire lifespan
o An average sized village has land approximately of 250-500 acres, a laser
leveller can ideally work maximum in 4-5 or maximum 10 villages in its entire
life.
o As per the census, Uttar Pradesh has 70 districts and 100,000 villages, while
Bihar has 37 districts and 39,000 villages. The approximate number of Laser
Levellers can thus be calculated.
Constraint analysis of the lone Service Provider in E-UP
- Clients are spread over 100 km range. When he has to travel to clients in the season,
travel time has a high opportunity cost. This leads to loss of income in season;
- Recovery of money is difficult. Of the Rs. 2,00,000 plus earned last year working on 128
acres, nearly 25% was received after nearly a week and more than a request. Rs.15,000
is still held by the farmers and inspite of several requests and a few conflicts, the farmers
do not want to give. One reason is that as the Service Provider is closely identified with
the hub from where some items are distributed free in pilots, and the farmers wrongly
expect that commercial Laser Leveler services to be free too for them. This attitude is
expected to change as the Service Provider becomes more and more independent;
- The Service Provider initially had the support of the hub staff and transport in meeting
new clients and explaining them the need of the Laser Leveler. Once he was put off
salary and asked to go it alone, his area of influence has got largely limited to his few
clients in a few villages and their word of recommendation. He has been trying to
leverage them to get more clients. He also finds it a bit intimidating to independently hold
meetings in new villages to publicise his work although he clearly understands that
publicity will help him in accessing more farmers;
- The Service Provider flatly mentions his interest in servicing the requirements of a few
very large farmers where he can work on large areas and be paid in bulk. He reasons
(correctly, according to him) that he can go to work on their fields day and night, stay
there, get food, water and shelter and has fewer hassles in getting money from them as
his transaction costs are low. However one of these very large farmer has not paid him
money inspite of several reminders and the Service Provider has been following it up
with him for a few months now;
- Through the limited but commendable work done, the Service Provider has already got a
demand of 171 acres for this year. 95% of the demand is from very large farmers who
are primarily into cash crops. Farmers are willing to call him and not Hariyali as they find
him more accommodating and sincere in his work;
- The Service Provider finds the demand aggregation, money collection and handling a
weak area in his business model and is not comfortable with the present process, where
he has to run after each client to get money and offer explanations. He is willing to even
share a small margin if there is any person/ agency willing to support him in doing this.
4