Whether the ongoing, acute Euro crisis results in a stabilized Euro, a contracted Euro or total disintegration, banking and financial services (BFS) companies must prepare their operational and IT systems to accommodate any resulting changes and limit revenue losses. We offer a remediation plan to prepare for these potentially disruptive changes that could affect systems and processes such as risk management, legal and compliance, cash and liquidity management, reporting, settlement and clearing, post-trade services, channel access, trade execution and management and many more.
The Work Ahead in Intelligent Automation: Coping with Complexity in a Post-Pa...
Euro Crisis: What Next?
1. • Cognizant 20-20 Insights
Euro Crisis: What Next?
The Euro crisis, regardless of its eventual outcome, poses complex
challenges for the banking and financial services industry. Given the
avalanche of change looming on the horizon, institutions should begin
assessing the potential impact on their business and preparing for
the most likely scenarios. A ‘wait and watch’ approach will almost
certainly guarantee having to play catch-up for the foreseeable future.
Executive Summary Scenario 1: Stabilized Existing Euro
The impact of the ongoing economic downturn • Existing and new governments regain popular
and the uncertainty surrounding the future of the support for existing or scaled-down austerity
Euro have been of grave concern to executives measures.
across the banking and financial services (BFS)
industry. Austerity programs, and the govern-
• Monetary intervention by the IMF and European
Central Bank (ECB) to inject liquidity reduces
ments that have enacted them, are coming under interest rates and provides stability to Euro
increasing pressure to scale back or are being economies. Repayment by banks under the
replaced, and there is increasing likelihood of one ECB’s Long-Term Refinancing Operation (LTRO)
or more countries exiting the Euro. in three years remains a risk to future stability.
In our opinion, the resolution of the Euro crisis • The purchase of sovereign debts by central
will pose major challenges for BFS CXOs. These banks and/or private bondholders taking a
will range from restoration of trust and limiting haircut on their holdings in low-rated sovereigns
financial losses to dealing with increased liquidity helps ailing economies repay their debt.
pressures, additional capital adequacy require- • Fiscal
rules are implemented to realign
ments, increased business risk, major systems economies to lower medium-term growth.
and process changes and lower profitability.
• Banks with exposure to the Eurozone continue
The Eurozone that emerges following the current to de-leverage via aggressive asset sales.
crisis is likely to be structurally different from the • Balance sheets improve, but profit and loss
Eurozone we know today. We anticipate one of the statements (P&Ls) are hit as prices soften in a
following scenarios: flooded market.
cognizant 20-20 insights | june 2012
2. • Europe remains over-banked and banks remain We believe that while every effort is being taken
undercapitalized; further consolidation and toward scenario 1, the most likely outcome is
government intervention along the lines of the scenario 2, a contracted Euro, with one or more
Bankia bailout in Spain. countries leaving the Euro. BFS institutions that
are actively assessing the potential impact, and
Scenario 2: Contracted Euro planning and preparing for it, will be better placed
• One or more countries are compelled to to weather this crisis. On the other hand, a failure
leave the Euro as a result of their electorates’ to prepare will render these institutions unable
rejection of austerity measures, further dete- to realign or dispose of their investments cost-
rioration in their economies, escalating interest effectively and/or make the necessary operational
rates and a lack of market confidence. changes in time, which could have a negative
impact on their financial stability.
• Agreed-upon orderly defaults and currency
revaluations lead to another liquidity crunch Euro Crisis: Current Situation
and significant market instability due to
The financial debt crisis in Europe exposed
increased counterparty risk.
numerous loopholes in the European Union’s
• BFS institutions exposed to exiting countries’ principles of integration, notably in the enforce-
debts face substantial financial losses. ment of fiscal discipline. This problem was
• All BFS institutions face a substantial impact compounded by the recent downturn in financial
on their business and business processes markets and the decrease in market willingness
and systems as they struggle to accom- to lend to sovereigns and the private sector in the
modate changes in existing legal contracts Eurozone.
and currencies and/or the reintroduction of
The Eurozone agreement to stabilize the
currencies in the exiting states.
Euro through the implementation of austerity
• The implementation of tighter fiscal integration measures initially had a stabilizing effect in early
and monetary intervention in the contracted 2012, despite the unpopularity of the measures in
Eurozone builds confidence in the market, a number of countries. However, popular rejection
paving the way for future economic recovery. of these fiscal policies in recent weeks has
resulted in the failure of governments. Continued
Scenario 3: Total Disintegration
implementation of these austerity programs has
• Failure to find an effective solution, wholesale become politically untenable in certain countries.
rejection of austerity measures and/or the
bailouts of weaker countries by stronger The likely resolution of the Euro crisis is expected
countries leads to a decision to collapse the to have a major economic impact on BFS institu-
Euro. This is accompanied by a return to tions that are exposed to the ailing sovereigns.
members’ currencies at their appropriate value. To understand the global impact of the Eurozone
Such a scenario would have a significant impact crisis, it is important to consider the level of
on the world economy and could result in a exposure of the banks of various countries to
global depression, affecting all BFS institutions. Eurozone sovereigns (see Figure 1).
In scenarios 2 and 3, orderly defaults have been The tremors from a negative outcome of the
assumed. However, in the event of unpredict- Euro crisis will be felt by almost every country in
able “disorderly defaults,” a significant financial the world and could lead to a “perfect financial
meltdown could pose challenges in aligning storm.”
capital for risk-weighted assets.
What Could Happen to the Euro
This paper analyzes the aforementioned The Eurozone that emerges from the crisis will
scenarios in terms of the impact on operations most likely be structurally different from the
and IT amid increasing concern about the fate of current Eurozone. This, in turn, will have significant
the Euro and the ability/willingness of some of the implications for macroeconomic variables and
sovereigns and their counterparties to weather business models. The following section illustrates
this storm. Our analysis seeks to predict the mac- the various possible scenarios, their likelihood, the
roeconomic and high-level impact on business corresponding impact and suggested solutions
and IT processes in each of the scenarios followed (see Figure 2 for summary findings).
by a detailed analysis of the process impact of the
most likely scenario.
cognizant 20-20 insights 2
3. Banks’ Exposure to Eurozone Sovereigns
450 416.5
400 Greece Portugal Spain Italy Ireland
350
300
250
200 177.5
161.7 150.9 140.9
150 110.5 101.2 88.5
100 73.7 66.8
55.8 46.9 53.6
21.3 35.9 25.7 32.0 30.0 39.8
50 12.7 25.4 8.3 5.3 3.8 3.9 9.1 1.2
14.3
0.0 0.0
0
Germany France UK U.S. Italy Spain
In U.S. $ billions
Source: Bank for International Settlements as of end June 2011
Figure 1
The Emerging Scenario Banking and Capital Markets:
The Eurozone reforms agreed upon in December High-level Impact
2011 included embracing tighter fiscal rules and The contracted Euro or total disintegration
monetary expansion, and were a step in the scenarios will have different macroeconomic
right direction to resolve this crisis. However, the and business model impacts on BFS institutions.
austerity measures have not proved politically Increased sovereign risks will hamper BFS insti-
tenable in key countries. tutions due to falling mark-to-market values
resulting in financial losses and deteriorating
Given the current challenges faced in imple- liquidity positions as sovereign bonds are used
menting austerity measures, the downgrade of as liquidity buffers and collateral. On the liability
sovereign debt by ratings agencies and continued side, BFS institutions’ funding costs will rise due
market concerns, our view is that the most likely to limited access to funds and increased counter-
scenario is a contracted Euro. We predict that one party and default risks. The higher costs will be
or more sovereigns will exit the Euro, which will passed on to potential borrowers through tough
lead to a bleak outlook for their economies with credit standards or higher lending rates.
reduced access to international bond markets,
depreciating currencies, agreed-upon defaults BFS institutions will need to assess the situation
and economic contraction. so as to limit financial losses, evaluate strategies
for operating in these markets and evolve a risk
Consequently, financial markets are likely to framework based on the changing risk perception
experience spikes in counterparty risk, a new and appetite which will have a cascading impact
liquidity crunch and declining asset prices. BFS on operational and IT processes. Below we lay out
institutions will be under immense pressure our view of the high-level impact on the opera-
to meet the capital adequacy requirements tional and IT processes of BFS institutions. The
stipulated by regulators. degree of impact will vary for different BFS insti-
tutions depending on their business strategies,
There is also a possibility of “disorderly” defaults
lines of business and exposure to specific
which could result in a “Eurogeddon” impact on
Eurozone sovereigns.
the world financial markets. BFS institutions will
have very limited time in these circumstances to Banking Core Processes
manage their risk and limit financial losses.
Acquisition and Account Management: Banks
It is therefore essential that all major BFS institu- will need to focus on “know your customer”
tions with a significant exposure to the Eurozone (KYC) and assess country risk in the client on-
begin planning for the various possible outcomes boarding process. Resetting of client account and
of the crisis. portfolio currencies will be required, and any rein-
cognizant 20-20 insights 3
4. Potential Eurozone Outcomes
Stabilized
Contracted Euro Total Disintegration
Existing Euro
Likelihood Likely Highly Likely Unlikely but Plausible
• All the Euro member • Several sovereigns opt out with • Failure to reach an agreement on
states agree to tighter fis- agreed defaults. fiscal integration may lead to exit
Scenario
cal integration and none by major economies, trigger total
Details of the members opt out disintegration.
of the Euro.
• Sluggish growth in short • Contraction in GDP expected in • Loss of trust and excessive finan-
term in the Eurozone shrunken Eurozone and exiting cial losses will be marked by GDP
economy. sovereigns. contraction.
• Sovereigns on nega- • Sovereign’s monetary and fiscal • Sovereign’s monetary & fiscal poli-
tive watch list of rating policies need to be reviewed. cies need to be reviewed.
agencies with risk of • Sovereign ratings impact for a • Sovereign ratings impact for a
downgrade.
Macro- number of Euro member states. number of Euro member states.
Economic • High inflation due to • Phases of severe credit crunch • Rising unemployment.
monetary expansion.
Impact controlled by central banks. • Increasing inflation rates.
• Interest rates reduction in • Monetary intervention by central • Social unrest due to austerity mea-
short term.
banks would reduce interest rates sures implementation.
in short term for cheaper credit
• Contagion impact across the
access.
world’s financial markets.
• Social unrest due to austerity
measures implementation.
• Increased focus on risk • Impact on front to back office • Impact on front to back office
management and moni- trading activities such as pricing, trading activities such as pricing,
toring. trading strategies, settlement and trading and hedging strategies,
• Levy of additional taxes clearing in the markets settlement and clearing in the
to increase the sovereign exiting Euro. markets exiting Euro.
wallet. • Enhanced risk control focusing on • Major impacts on asset, counter-
credit, market and sovereign risk. party and sovereign ratings.
• Redenomination of accounts, • Significant focus on risk
existing positions, re-calibration management and monitoring.
of ATMs. • Redenomination of existing
• Changes to payment processing, positions from Euro to local
High-level clearing and settlement infra- currencies, recalibration of ATMs.
Business structure. • Payment processing, settle-
and IT • Reset of interest rates for ac- ment and clearing infrastructure
Impact counts, mortgages, loans and changes.
credit cards. • Reset of interest rates for accounts,
• Legal and compliance implica- mortgages, loans and credit cards.
tions on existing cross-border • Legal and compliance implications
contracts. on existing cross-border contracts.
• Valuation impact on existing • Valuation impact on existing
contracts. contracts.
• Monitoring capital adequacy • Monitoring capital adequacy
requirements. requirements.
• New regulatory reporting require- • Changes to regulatory framework.
ments.
• Crisis management team setup — define responsibilities, pre- and post-crisis tasks, management report-
ing, plans and resolution.
• Scenario planning - scenario discussions, impacts on line of businesses.
• Impact analysis on business strategies.
Remedia- • Operational and IT impact assessment across lines of business covering market integration strategy.
tions
• Contingency budgetary provisions.
• Creation of detailed run-book for Euro crisis impact.
• Detailed client communications planning.
• Road map planning and readiness assessment.
Figure 2
cognizant 20-20 insights 4
5. Banking Processes: nominated from the original national currency
into the Euro, might pose significant challenges.
High-level Impact
Capital Markets Core Processes
Acquisition & Account Management Client Acquisition and Setup: An increased focus
Reference Data Management on KYC will be required, with enhanced credit due
Channel Access diligence and country risk assessment during the
Legal & Compliance
Risk Management
client on-boarding process. Existing client data
Transaction Processing will need to be migrated to incorporate changes
related to reference currency such as settlement
Payments, Clearing & Settlement
instructions on markets exiting the Euro.
Customer
Books & Records Communication Trade Identification: Trade analytics and hedging
Reporting strategies will be impacted due to additional
currency and country exposure, which will mean
Low Impact Medium Impact High Impact
research and analyst teams will have to provide
additional supporting data.
Figure 3
Trade Execution and Capture: Margining and
collateral for exchange-traded products will be
troduction of a currency will require close client impacted, including re-profiling of collateral. Listed
management on their financial and transactional stock currency will need to be redenominated.
requirements.
Trade Management: Terms of confirmation and
Channel Access: Channels such as branch, counterparty netting agreements may undergo
direct, mobile, contact centers and ATMs will changes due to any currency exit scenario. Multi-
need to be recalibrated to account for currency listed stocks netting processes will have to be
changes. Withdrawal and reintroduction of new revisited and increased trading volumes in these
currency notes (e.g., the Drachma) and coinage highly volatile markets will compound the opera-
will be a particular challenge for banks within tional and IT challenges.
countries exiting the Euro, and advance contin-
gency planning will be required.
Capital Markets Processes:
Payments, Settlements and Clearing: Payments High-level Impact
infrastructure and systems will be heavily affected
by currency changes, and the need to reconstitute
agent/correspondent banking. There is likely to be Client Acquisition & Setup
a knock-on impact on European regulation such
as SEPA, despite the legally binding migration Trade Identification –
Research, Analytics, Strategies
deadline of February 1, 2014.
Reference Data Management
Trade Execution & Capture
Legal & Compliance
Risk Management
Transaction Processing: Changes in credit
policy, re-establishment of credit lines, implica- Trade Management
tions for trade financing and migration of existing
contracts will be major considerations. Clearing & Settlement
Customer Communication: Any changes in Other Post-Trade Services
terms and conditions related to accounts and
Product Control & Cash & Liquidity
transactions will need to be planned for and com- Books and Records Management
municated to clients.
Client and Regulatory Reporting
The impact on pension funds could be signifi- Low Impact Medium Impact High Impact
cant. For example, the potential redenomina-
tion of long-term assets (such as government or
company bonds), which had already been rede- Figure 4
cognizant 20-20 insights 5
6. Settlement and Clearing: Additional custody contracts from a legal and compliance perspec-
accounts in new currencies and interfacing with tive involving multiple parties from multiple geog-
new clearing infrastructures may be required in raphies. A major challenge will be to understand
the impacted markets. From the clearing house trade jurisdictions and entities ownership in order
perspective, there will be additional settlement to decide redenomination.
risk monitoring requirements for incorporating
increased country risk. Client and Regulatory Reporting: Interfaces with
new local regulatory regimes and additional client
Other Post-trade Services: Processes such as reporting will be required. Client communication
collateral management, margining and asset regarding these changes will need to be planned.
services on the stocks listed in these markets will
be impacted due to currency conversion. Remediation
Considering the scale of the impact on various
Common Core Processes processes, we recommend BFS institutions take
Reference Data Management: Banks will have the following actions:
to incorporate the price, exchange rate, ratings
impact and asset price listing changes. • Set up a Euro crisis management team
comprised of representatives from different
Product Control, Books and Records: Valuation lines of business. This team should drive the
will be a key consideration in the event of defaults impact assessment, budget planning, response
on existing contracts, with increased valuation planning and coordination with the lines of
and pricing complexities for structured products business and change management teams.
that have underlying exposure in the impacted
markets. Banks will need to increase focus on • Focus on scenario planning and assess the
potential impact on the lines of business and
P&L from these markets/products to ensure that
operating models.
risk models are prudently aligned and as per the
risk framework. Migration of existing positions • Identify the operational and IT processes that
including introduction of general ledger accounts will be impacted across the lines of business.
for new currencies, conversion of balances,
account entry processes and data warehouse(s)
• Estimate the size of the change for budget
alignment and resource planning.
will pose additional challenges.
• Plan the roadmap for delivery with critical
Cash and Liquidity Management: Cash and paths identified.
liquidity management functions will have to be
managed for nostro accounts in new currencies.
• Develop the market integration strategy.
Defaults and a credit crunch will lead to greater • Plan the delivery and implementation.
focus on effective cash and liquidity management • Assess readiness.
functions.
Such extensive changes will pose significant
Risk Management: BFS institutions will need to delivery and testing challenges and require sig-
review their risk framework for the identification, nificant coordination with external third parties
measurement and management of risk. Credit, for seamless transition. This might prove chal-
market and operational risk will be key focus lenging as third parties will also be in the midst
areas. There will be significant changes in the risk of managing the impact of the Euro crisis on their
models, with the need to reevaluate/re-hypothe- businesses.
cate models (with no historic data to reference),
BFS Institution Readiness
limits and monitoring, collateral and margining,
mark-to-market (MTM) calculations and realized BFS institutions have been closely monitoring the
P&L losses, credit lines and loan drawdown Euro crisis situation but we anticipate a variable
facilities and capital flight from peripheral level of mobilization across the industry. Failure
economies. More frequent stress testing is also to conduct the required “as-is” analysis and to
likely. determine the impact of the evolving scenarios
on its finances, business models, processes and
Legal and Compliance: There will be a substan- systems will leave a BFS institution unable to
tial impact on cross-border loans/derivatives respond effectively to the scenario that arises.
cognizant 20-20 insights 6
7. Impact of No/Late Action? and mitigating the risk, the choice of partner
BFS institutions that do not prepare sufficiently will be a crucial decision. Institutions must look
for the Euro crisis will face significant risk and for partners with experience
compliance issues and possible financial losses. in the Eurozone and a track
A resolution of the
Among the potential issues: record of helping institu-
tions with regulatory change Euro crisis needs
• An incomplete view of their positions in management. Deep domain renewed political
sovereign debt, contracts with underlying and analytical expertise
will and concerted
sovereign debt and their exposure to European across banking and capital
counterparties will undermine their ability to markets, scalability, agility, effort to implement
assess assets in their portfolios across their responsiveness and crisis politically acceptable
lines of business. management expertise are
fiscal rules together
some of the other attributes
• Failure to identify impacted contracts with
that the ideal third-party with other measures
complex legal entity structures may lead to
legal issues and significant financial losses. services provider will possess. aimed at boosting
• Setting aside additional capital requirements Conclusion growth to reduce the
corresponding to risky assets, managing this A resolution of the Euro deficit and debt.
exposure and potential defaults will pose sig- crisis needs renewed political
nificant financial challenges. will and concerted effort to implement politi-
• Inabilityto operate effectively and be cally acceptable fiscal rules together with other
compliant with the new regulatory regimes in measures aimed at boosting growth to reduce the
the landscape that follows the Euro crisis. deficit and debt.
• Increasedoperational risk due to increased The crisis has caused uncertainty for BFS insti-
manual intervention. tutions operating in the Eurozone. With unknown
timescales and high risks, these institutions need
Moving Forward
to be prepared to protect themselves against
The Euro crisis is likely to force significant
the risk of government and bank defaults and
disruptive changes upon BFS institutions, with
counterparty bankruptcy, and limit the impact of
both short- and long-term implications depending
process and systems change.
upon the scenario that plays out. A contracted
Euro (or worse, total disintegration) will have an BFS institutions must focus on the imminent
extensive impact on each institution’s processes changes and direct sufficient resources to assess
and systems, requiring additional resources the likely scenarios. The outcome is uncertain,
and experience to plan and deliver the changes but it is imperative that they plan ahead to be
in a cost-effective manner to meet the likely able to meet any eventuality. Those that do so will
timescales. not only be prepared for any disruption caused by
the crisis, but will also be in a strong position to
To meet these challenges, some institutions will
benefit from the changing environment.
seek to partner with services providers. While
this will ensure benefits in terms of identifying For BFS institutions, now is the time to act.
cognizant 20-20 insights 7