SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 2
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
‘How RTI Works’ Series © 2011 Jim Wright www.interventioncentral.org 1 
‘Say-Ask-Check’ Metacognitive Prompts Tied to a Word-Problem 
Cognitive Strategy (Montague, 1992) 
Cognitive 
Metacognitive ‘Say-Ask-Check’ Prompt 
Strategy Step 
Targets 
Sample Metacognitive ‘Say- 
Ask-Check’ Prompts 
1. Read the 
problem. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
reads and studies the problem carefully before 
proceeding. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Does the 
student fully understand the problem? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: Proceed only 
if the problem is understood. 
Say: “I will read the problem. 
I will reread the problem if I 
don’t understand it.” 
Ask: “Now that I have read 
the problem, do I fully 
understand it?” 
Check: “I understand the 
problem and will move 
forward.” 
2. Paraphrase 
the 
problem. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
restates the problem in order to demonstrate 
understanding. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Is the student 
able to paraphrase the problem? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: Ensure that 
any highlighted key words are relevant to the 
question. 
Say: “I will highlight key 
words and phrases that 
relate to the problem 
question.” 
“I will restate the problem in 
my own words.” 
Ask: “Did I highlight the most 
important words or phrases 
in the problem?” 
Check: “I found the key 
words or phrases that will 
help to solve the problem.” 
3. ‘Draw’ the 
problem. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
creates a drawing of the problem to 
consolidate understanding. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Is there a 
match between the drawing and the problem? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The drawing 
includes in visual form the key elements of the 
math problem. 
Say: “I will draw a diagram of 
the problem.” 
Ask: “Does my drawing 
represent the problem?” 
Check: “The drawing 
contains the essential parts 
of the problem.” 
4. Create a 
plan to 
solve the 
problem. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
generates a plan to solve the problem. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: What plan will 
help the student to solve this problem? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The plan is 
appropriate to solve the problem. 
Say: “I will make a plan to 
solve the problem.” 
Ask: “What is the first step of 
this plan? What is the next 
step of the plan?” 
Check: “My plan has the 
right steps to solve the 
problem.” 
5. Predict/ 
estimate the 
Answer. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
uses estimation or other strategies to predict or 
estimate the answer. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: What 
Say: “I will estimate what the 
answer will be.” 
Ask: “What numbers in the 
problem should be used in
‘How RTI Works’ Series © 2011 Jim Wright www.interventioncentral.org 2 
estimating technique will the student use to 
predict the answer? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The 
predicted/estimated answer used all of the 
essential problem information. 
my estimation?” 
Check: “I did not skip any 
important information in my 
estimation.” 
6. Compute 
the answer. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
follows the plan to compute the solution to the 
problem. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Does the 
answer agree with the estimate? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The steps in 
the plan were followed and the operations 
completed in the correct order. 
Say: “I will compute the 
answer to the problem.” 
Ask: “Does my answer 
sound right?” “Is my answer 
close to my estimate?” 
Check: “I carried out all of 
the operations in the correct 
order to solve this problem.” 
7. Check the 
answer. 
‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student 
reviews the computation steps to verify the 
answer. 
‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Did the student 
check all the steps in solving the problem and 
are all computations correct? 
‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The problem 
solution appears to have been done correctly. 
Say: “I will check the steps of 
my answer.” 
Ask: “Did I go through each 
step in my answer and check 
my work?” 
Check: “” 
Reference 
Montague, M. (1992). The effects of cognitive and metacognitive strategy instruction on the mathematical problem 
solving of middle school students with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 230-248.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt? (16)

Polya
PolyaPolya
Polya
 
Creating Math Arg 5_1_15 *pubilc
Creating Math Arg 5_1_15 *pubilcCreating Math Arg 5_1_15 *pubilc
Creating Math Arg 5_1_15 *pubilc
 
Cst test prep night 1
Cst test prep night 1Cst test prep night 1
Cst test prep night 1
 
Problem solving
Problem solvingProblem solving
Problem solving
 
Field testing chunk 1b
Field testing chunk 1bField testing chunk 1b
Field testing chunk 1b
 
Assignment4a
Assignment4aAssignment4a
Assignment4a
 
Assignment4a
Assignment4aAssignment4a
Assignment4a
 
Identifying a problem
Identifying a problemIdentifying a problem
Identifying a problem
 
Nyoba doang
Nyoba doangNyoba doang
Nyoba doang
 
Learning impact awards student version
Learning impact awards student versionLearning impact awards student version
Learning impact awards student version
 
Simplifying assessment 1
Simplifying assessment 1Simplifying assessment 1
Simplifying assessment 1
 
Solving math problems
Solving math problemsSolving math problems
Solving math problems
 
Study smart
Study smartStudy smart
Study smart
 
Top 10 Study Skills
Top 10 Study SkillsTop 10 Study Skills
Top 10 Study Skills
 
High impact instruction week 2
High impact instruction  week 2High impact instruction  week 2
High impact instruction week 2
 
2 interventions
2 interventions 2 interventions
2 interventions
 

Ähnlich wie Math meta cog_strategy_montague_say_ask_check

Polya problem solving cycle
Polya problem solving cyclePolya problem solving cycle
Polya problem solving cyclemrjdfield
 
Problem solving technique , strategies
Problem solving technique , strategiesProblem solving technique , strategies
Problem solving technique , strategiesHussein Kareem
 
LW SYP Spring Planning
LW SYP Spring PlanningLW SYP Spring Planning
LW SYP Spring PlanningJaimee Bohning
 
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]bbieniemy
 
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2Alan Robinson
 
7 step Problem solving cycle project report
7 step Problem solving cycle project report7 step Problem solving cycle project report
7 step Problem solving cycle project reportSandeep Kohli
 
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyPolya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyEFREN ARCHIDE
 
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in Mathematics
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in MathematicsCognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in Mathematics
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in MathematicsJohn Paul Hablado
 
Lesson Design And Planning
Lesson Design And PlanningLesson Design And Planning
Lesson Design And Planningjoanne chesley
 
March 03 decision making
March 03   decision makingMarch 03   decision making
March 03 decision makingEben Schaeffer
 
Acceleration Lesson Plan Checklist
Acceleration Lesson Plan ChecklistAcceleration Lesson Plan Checklist
Acceleration Lesson Plan Checklistjoniallison23
 
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bank
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test BankEducational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bank
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bankkynep
 
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docx
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docxJosh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docx
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docxpriestmanmable
 
Metacognitive and self regulation grid
Metacognitive and self regulation gridMetacognitive and self regulation grid
Metacognitive and self regulation gridGareth Jenkins
 
Problem solving methods ppt
Problem solving methods pptProblem solving methods ppt
Problem solving methods pptASWATHYASWATHY10
 

Ähnlich wie Math meta cog_strategy_montague_say_ask_check (20)

Polya problem solving cycle
Polya problem solving cyclePolya problem solving cycle
Polya problem solving cycle
 
Problem solving technique , strategies
Problem solving technique , strategiesProblem solving technique , strategies
Problem solving technique , strategies
 
LW SYP Spring Planning
LW SYP Spring PlanningLW SYP Spring Planning
LW SYP Spring Planning
 
Classroom assessment
Classroom assessmentClassroom assessment
Classroom assessment
 
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]
Teaching Through Problem Solving[1]
 
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2
Teach like a champion chapt.s 1 and 2
 
Problem solving4112
Problem solving4112Problem solving4112
Problem solving4112
 
7 step Problem solving cycle project report
7 step Problem solving cycle project report7 step Problem solving cycle project report
7 step Problem solving cycle project report
 
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving StrategyPolya's Problem-Solving Strategy
Polya's Problem-Solving Strategy
 
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in Mathematics
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in MathematicsCognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in Mathematics
Cognitive and meta cognitive strategies for problem solving in Mathematics
 
Tmelby
TmelbyTmelby
Tmelby
 
Lesson Two
Lesson TwoLesson Two
Lesson Two
 
Self assessment exercise
Self assessment exerciseSelf assessment exercise
Self assessment exercise
 
Lesson Design And Planning
Lesson Design And PlanningLesson Design And Planning
Lesson Design And Planning
 
March 03 decision making
March 03   decision makingMarch 03   decision making
March 03 decision making
 
Acceleration Lesson Plan Checklist
Acceleration Lesson Plan ChecklistAcceleration Lesson Plan Checklist
Acceleration Lesson Plan Checklist
 
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bank
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test BankEducational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bank
Educational Psychology Developing Learners 8th Edition Ormrod Test Bank
 
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docx
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docxJosh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docx
Josh AlessioProblem solving using the work backward” method..docx
 
Metacognitive and self regulation grid
Metacognitive and self regulation gridMetacognitive and self regulation grid
Metacognitive and self regulation grid
 
Problem solving methods ppt
Problem solving methods pptProblem solving methods ppt
Problem solving methods ppt
 

Mehr von carrawayj

Pep template (1)
Pep template (1)Pep template (1)
Pep template (1)carrawayj
 
Detective comprehension
Detective comprehensionDetective comprehension
Detective comprehensioncarrawayj
 
Tier 2 notification h v
Tier 2 notification h vTier 2 notification h v
Tier 2 notification h vcarrawayj
 
Tier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationTier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationcarrawayj
 
Tier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationTier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationcarrawayj
 
Parent notification, letter
Parent notification,  letterParent notification,  letter
Parent notification, lettercarrawayj
 
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]carrawayj
 
Click or clunk_check_sheet
Click or clunk_check_sheetClick or clunk_check_sheet
Click or clunk_check_sheetcarrawayj
 
Advanced story map_worksheet
Advanced story map_worksheetAdvanced story map_worksheet
Advanced story map_worksheetcarrawayj
 
Main idea map_graphic_organizer
Main idea map_graphic_organizerMain idea map_graphic_organizer
Main idea map_graphic_organizercarrawayj
 
Prior knowledge text_example
Prior knowledge text_examplePrior knowledge text_example
Prior knowledge text_examplecarrawayj
 
Recip teaching 2
Recip teaching 2Recip teaching 2
Recip teaching 2carrawayj
 
Recip teaching 1
Recip teaching 1Recip teaching 1
Recip teaching 1carrawayj
 
Clown with days
Clown with daysClown with days
Clown with dayscarrawayj
 
Treesmile filled in
Treesmile filled inTreesmile filled in
Treesmile filled incarrawayj
 
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_board
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_boardBuild number sense_thru_board_game_game_board
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_boardcarrawayj
 
Single blank green blue
Single blank green blueSingle blank green blue
Single blank green bluecarrawayj
 
Number line 1_10_and_1_20
Number line 1_10_and_1_20Number line 1_10_and_1_20
Number line 1_10_and_1_20carrawayj
 

Mehr von carrawayj (20)

Pep template (1)
Pep template (1)Pep template (1)
Pep template (1)
 
Detective comprehension
Detective comprehensionDetective comprehension
Detective comprehension
 
Tier 2 notification h v
Tier 2 notification h vTier 2 notification h v
Tier 2 notification h v
 
Tier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationTier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notification
 
Tier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notificationTier 3 mtg notification
Tier 3 mtg notification
 
Parent notification, letter
Parent notification,  letterParent notification,  letter
Parent notification, letter
 
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]
Parents guide rti_final_101111-2[1]
 
Click or clunk_check_sheet
Click or clunk_check_sheetClick or clunk_check_sheet
Click or clunk_check_sheet
 
Advanced story map_worksheet
Advanced story map_worksheetAdvanced story map_worksheet
Advanced story map_worksheet
 
Main idea map_graphic_organizer
Main idea map_graphic_organizerMain idea map_graphic_organizer
Main idea map_graphic_organizer
 
Prior knowledge text_example
Prior knowledge text_examplePrior knowledge text_example
Prior knowledge text_example
 
Recip teaching 2
Recip teaching 2Recip teaching 2
Recip teaching 2
 
Recip teaching 1
Recip teaching 1Recip teaching 1
Recip teaching 1
 
Smile b&w
Smile b&wSmile b&w
Smile b&w
 
2 smile b&w
2 smile b&w2 smile b&w
2 smile b&w
 
Clown with days
Clown with daysClown with days
Clown with days
 
Treesmile filled in
Treesmile filled inTreesmile filled in
Treesmile filled in
 
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_board
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_boardBuild number sense_thru_board_game_game_board
Build number sense_thru_board_game_game_board
 
Single blank green blue
Single blank green blueSingle blank green blue
Single blank green blue
 
Number line 1_10_and_1_20
Number line 1_10_and_1_20Number line 1_10_and_1_20
Number line 1_10_and_1_20
 

Math meta cog_strategy_montague_say_ask_check

  • 1. ‘How RTI Works’ Series © 2011 Jim Wright www.interventioncentral.org 1 ‘Say-Ask-Check’ Metacognitive Prompts Tied to a Word-Problem Cognitive Strategy (Montague, 1992) Cognitive Metacognitive ‘Say-Ask-Check’ Prompt Strategy Step Targets Sample Metacognitive ‘Say- Ask-Check’ Prompts 1. Read the problem. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student reads and studies the problem carefully before proceeding. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Does the student fully understand the problem? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: Proceed only if the problem is understood. Say: “I will read the problem. I will reread the problem if I don’t understand it.” Ask: “Now that I have read the problem, do I fully understand it?” Check: “I understand the problem and will move forward.” 2. Paraphrase the problem. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student restates the problem in order to demonstrate understanding. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Is the student able to paraphrase the problem? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: Ensure that any highlighted key words are relevant to the question. Say: “I will highlight key words and phrases that relate to the problem question.” “I will restate the problem in my own words.” Ask: “Did I highlight the most important words or phrases in the problem?” Check: “I found the key words or phrases that will help to solve the problem.” 3. ‘Draw’ the problem. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student creates a drawing of the problem to consolidate understanding. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Is there a match between the drawing and the problem? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The drawing includes in visual form the key elements of the math problem. Say: “I will draw a diagram of the problem.” Ask: “Does my drawing represent the problem?” Check: “The drawing contains the essential parts of the problem.” 4. Create a plan to solve the problem. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student generates a plan to solve the problem. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: What plan will help the student to solve this problem? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The plan is appropriate to solve the problem. Say: “I will make a plan to solve the problem.” Ask: “What is the first step of this plan? What is the next step of the plan?” Check: “My plan has the right steps to solve the problem.” 5. Predict/ estimate the Answer. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student uses estimation or other strategies to predict or estimate the answer. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: What Say: “I will estimate what the answer will be.” Ask: “What numbers in the problem should be used in
  • 2. ‘How RTI Works’ Series © 2011 Jim Wright www.interventioncentral.org 2 estimating technique will the student use to predict the answer? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The predicted/estimated answer used all of the essential problem information. my estimation?” Check: “I did not skip any important information in my estimation.” 6. Compute the answer. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student follows the plan to compute the solution to the problem. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Does the answer agree with the estimate? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The steps in the plan were followed and the operations completed in the correct order. Say: “I will compute the answer to the problem.” Ask: “Does my answer sound right?” “Is my answer close to my estimate?” Check: “I carried out all of the operations in the correct order to solve this problem.” 7. Check the answer. ‘Say’ (Self-Instruction) Target: The student reviews the computation steps to verify the answer. ‘Ask’ (Self-Question) Target: Did the student check all the steps in solving the problem and are all computations correct? ‘Check’ (Self-Monitor) Target: The problem solution appears to have been done correctly. Say: “I will check the steps of my answer.” Ask: “Did I go through each step in my answer and check my work?” Check: “” Reference Montague, M. (1992). The effects of cognitive and metacognitive strategy instruction on the mathematical problem solving of middle school students with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 230-248.