SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 8
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
THE ROAD TO THE ASEAN ECONOMIC COMMUNITY 	   ANALYSIS | EXPERTISE | INSIGHT
                                                             VOLUME 2 US$5




CAMBODIA2012
The foreign business leaders survey
rates the kingdom’s business environment



Getting started
How to do business in cambodia

ALL ABOUT asean
Shaping the region’s economic future

facts & FIGURES
The region in numbers
CAMBODIAoverview




                                           propitious
                                            position
                                      The second installment of the
                                 Foreign Business Leaders Survey shows
                            there is much reason for optimism in the Kingdom


By Laurent Notin, Indochina Research




W                                                                   “
                    elcome to the 2012 edition of                                            has been introduced, and the skies have opened be-
                    the Cambodian Foreign Business                  With                     tween Siem Reap and Sihanoukville. With Cambodia
                    Leaders Survey. For the second year             cambodia                 chairing Asean in 2012, more growth is definitely to
                    in a row, we have spoken to a broad             chairing                 be expected.
                                                                    asean in
                    range of foreign business leaders               2012, more                I believe optimism is in the air. Eighty percent of the
working and living in Cambodia, asking them about                   groWth is                business men and women we have interviewed feel
their perceptions of doing business in the country. We              definitely to            confident the economic conditions of the country will
                                                                    be expected

                                                                    ”
have made some additions to our questionnaire, and                                           improve over the next three to five years, while 51% of
we have introduced a new section (page 14), which                                            them see mid-term opportunities in the primary sec-
should provide our readers with a                                                                               tor (agriculture, agribusiness, food
valuable picture of the Cambodian                                                                               processing, forestry and fishery).
labour market in terms of cost,                                                                                   Cambodia can count on its business
existing skills and training needs                                                                              friendly environment, as well as its
from an employer’s perspective.                                                                                 labour force, to drive growth. The
  Last year, we tried to demonstrate                                                                            ease of starting a company is cited as
that Cambodia was very much a                                                                                   a clear positive of doing business in
country under construction and                                                                                  the Kingdom, and cost and availabil-
would remain at work for quite                                                                                  ity of labour are key business advan-
a long time, for there were many                                                                                tages, according to our survey.
issues to tackle. But Cambodia is                                                                                 Of course, it is not all rosy. Cam-
becoming more than just a blip on                                                                               bodia still has many challenges to
the radar: every year the country                                                                               address, as mentioned by our re-
takes another step forward. I re-                                                                               spondents. The legal system, access
member when I first came to the                                                                                 to domestic loans, energy or public
country six years ago, I was struck                                                                             utilities, among others, will have
by the country’s energy; despite all                                                                            to improve. But this does not seem
the worldwide turbulence in that                                                                                to be a deterrent to future invest-
time, this has not changed.                                                                                     ments: 92% of the foreign business
  The Cambodian business land-                                                                                  leaders expect to invest the same
scape has experienced impor-                                                                                    amount or more money in 2012.
tant changes in the last year. For                                                                                On that note, let me conclude by
instance, the new European Union                                                                                sincerely thanking all survey par-
trade legislation offered increased                                                                             ticipants. We know their time is pre-
access to Europe, the agri-business                                                                             cious, and we are grateful for them
industry expanded significantly de-                                                                             having taken a moment to complete
spite regional flooding, increased                                                                              our questionnaire.
investment from Japan in particu-                                                                                 Cambodia is looking far into the
lar demonstrated a higher level of                                                                              future. So if you haven’t already,
sophistication in the manufactur-                                                                               why don’t you come and ‘feel’ the
ing sector, an anti-corruption law                                                                              country for yourself ? Z

                                                                Research by INDOCHINA RESEARCH, Cambodia
                   The Questionnaires for the survey on pages 12 - 23 were sent by email to a pre-selected list of foreign business managers/decision-makers/
                                       leaders working for private companies based in Cambodia. Research coordinated by Florence Pollet.
                                                     www.indochinaresearch.com        cambodia@indochinaresearch.com



10 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                            FocusAsean 2012 | 11
CAMBODIAINsIght




Courting Cambodia
                                                                                                                              By Simon Marks




                                                                                                                              T
                                                                                                                                          aking the Asean chair for the second time, Cambodia
                                                                                                                                          will be keen to use this year to prove itself a force to
Our signature Foreign Business Leaders Survey reveals what                                                                                be reckoned with. In its role as Asean chair, Cambo-
the country’s key players really think of the market                                                                                      dia has already said it wants to initiate six-party talks
                                                                                                                                          with North Korea and has expressed the need to fi-
                                                                                                                              nalise a first draft of the Asean Human Rights Declaration. This
                                                                                                                              year’s Asean summits will strive to showcase the country as a
                                                                                                                              viable investment destination.
                                                                                                                                 Indeed, Cambodia has come a long way in the last 10 years.
 P Ease of Doing Business in Cambodia                                                                                         Economic growth of over 6% has become the norm. A stock mar-
                                                                                                                              ket launched last year. Skyscrapers are gradually giving Phnom
 On a scale of one to 10, how would you evaluate the ease of doing business in                                                Penh a skyline, and the manufacturing sector is beginning to
 Cambodia at present?                                                                                                         move beyond garments.
 Poor                                                                    Excellent                                              But while optimism in the economy is high, Cambodia, like
                                                                                                                              most developing countries, still grapples with a host of matters
                                                                                                                              that restrict the speed at which the country is developing and
 1       2        3        4        5        6         7        8        9       10
                                                                                                                              reduce the ease of doing business.
 1%     5%        11%     6%       16%      20%      24%       9%       5%       1%
                                                                                                                                In order to perceive how foreign investors – particularly from
                                  Average: 5.72                                                                               Western countries – rate doing business in Cambodia, Indochina
                                                                                                                              Research, a regional market research company, asked 66 for-
                                                                                                                              eign business managers, decision makers and members of the
                                                                                                                              private sector to answer questions on what it is really like to do
                                                                                                                              business here.
                                                                                                                                The businesses questioned operated in a wide range of sectors
                                                                                                                              including consulting, trade, retail, banking, hospitality, manu-
                                                                                                                              facturing and information technology. Asked to evaluate the
                                                                                                                              ease of doing business in Cambodia by giving the country a score
                                                                                                                              of between one and 10, the average score was 5.72.
                                                                                                                                Still, the vast majority of businesses are confident that
                                                                                                                              Cambodia’s economic situation will improve in the near future.
                                                                                                                              According to the survey, 38% of businesses are “very confident”
                                                                                                                              that the economy will improve in the next three to five years,
                                                                                                                              while a further 42% of businesses are “somewhat confident”.
                                                                                                                              No businesses expressed zero confidence and only 5% were
                                                                                                                              “somewhat not confident”.
                                                                                                                                “People I talk to not just in Cambodia but outside the coun-
                                                                                                                              try are very optimistic about Cambodia,” said Faisal Ahmed,
                                                                                                                              resident representative for the International Monetary Fund in
                                                                                                                              Cambodia. “Obviously one big advantage of Cambodia is that it
                                                                                                                              is starting later. You learn from the mistakes of others and your
                                                                                                                              opportunity set is bigger.”
                                                                                                                                Ahmed added that more and more investors are viewing
                                                                                                                              Cambodia as a potential market. A major reason for this is
                                                                                                                              the competitive edge Cambodia now has when it comes to the
                                                                                                                              cost of labour.


                                                                                                                                 “The minimum monthly wage for an IT
                                                                                                                                technician in Cambodia is $90 compared
                                                                                                                                         to $500 in Thailand”

                                                                                                                               In Vietnam, wages have doubled in the last four years and
                                                                                                                              the minimum salary in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi stands at
                                                                                              Photo: Chor Sokunthea/Reuters




                                                                                                                              two million dong (at the time of publication), or about $100,
                                                                                                                              per month. Wages in China are also on the rise. Earlier this
                                                                                                                              year a Chinese government report confirmed that the annual
                                                                                                                              average growth of minimum wages should be at least 13% in
                                                                                                                              the next three years. In February, minimum wages in China
Caught between tradition and modernity, Phnom Penh reflects Cambodia's economic development
                                                                                                                              had already risen to 1,500 yuan ($240) per month in regions
                                                                                                                              such as Shenzhen.                                             g


12 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                                                  FocusAsean 2012 | 13
cambodiaINsIght




IMF's Faisal Ahmed believes Cambodia's late start can be an advantage                                                                                         HR Inc's Sandra d'Amico pleads for a more balanced job market




  Although trade unions in Cambodia                  Road connections with neighbouring             The Right Course                                            Most of those attending higher education are doing so in
would like to see the minimum wage rise            countries are also improving. Money from                                                                   subject matters such as business, management and finance. But
to $96 per month – and the number of vio-          countries such as China, South Korea and         While 61% of businesses said the availability             the labour market is crying out for people with technical skills
lent protests by garment workers are on            Japan has either built or is in the process      of labour and 69% said the cost of labour                 in areas such as agriculture, information technology, human
the rise – the minimum wage in Cambodia            of building more than 1,000 kilometres of        was supportive to doing business, 53% of                  resources and marketing.
stands at just $66 per month (at the time          new roads in the country. National roads         those questioned said that the skills and                   According to the Cambodian Federation of Employers and
of publication), considerably lower than           four and five, which run between Phnom           education levels of the work force were not               Business Associations (Camfeba), more than 60% of Cambodian
other countries in the region. According           Penh and the Thai border were inaugurated        supportive to doing business.                             university students are graduating in either business or law. Only
to the Foreign Business Leaders Survey, the        in 2009. Work on a bridge over the Mekong                                                                  2% of students graduate in agriculture even though the govern-
minimum monthly wage for an IT techni-             in order to connect Phnom Penh with               P Workforce                                              ment is pushing for more exports in commodities such as rice,
cian in Cambodia is $90 compared to $500           Ho Chi Minh City is scheduled to finish by                                                                 cassava and rubber.
in Thailand.                                       2015. Roads in Mondulkiri and Ratanakiri          What are the strengths in terms of education/              “There needs to be a bigger focus on technical vocational
                                                   provinces that link with Vietnam have also        qualification of the local workforce?                    training,” said Sandra d’Amico, managing director for HR Inc
                                                   been improved in the past two years.                                                                       and vice president of Camfeba, adding that qualifying with voca-
    “There needs to be a                             These developments have all helped                             Ambition/Desire to learn                  tional skills tends to take less time and put people into jobs at a
  bigger focus on technical                        improve Cambodia’s ability to import and                                                                   much quicker rate than academic courses.
    vocational training”                           export goods. But what do investors in             Language skills                                           D’Amico said that too many parents and students look at university
                                                   Cambodia really feel about the ease of do-                                             Positive attitude   as a way to get people into white-collar jobs. What the job market
                                                   ing business in a country that only 20 years                              26%*                             really needs is engineers, factory supervisors and accountants.
  “The pull factors would be domes-                ago had no investment law?                                                                                   “Those people come into the market and actually earn more
                                                                                                          18%
tic ones like low wages and improving                According to the Survey and more than a                                                   15%**          money than university graduates,” she said.
infrastructure,” noted Ahmed.                      dozen interviews with economists, managers                                                                   Companies such as Japan’s Minebea, which makes small,
  “The government is making efforts to             and observers of Cambodia’s economy, doing                                                                 motorised parts for items such as mobile phones, have found
improve some of the bottlenecks on infra-          business here still has many challenges, from     * Willing to improve, continuous learning, eagerness     it difficult to find locals with the skills to operate its machin-
structure, and businesses are looking at the       high levels of corruption inside the country’s       to learn by graduates, once immersed in industry      ery. Banks also find it hard to hire locals with skills in risk man-
improvements made over the last five or 10         tax and custom authorities to unclear regula-     ** Diligent, committed, passionate, receptive to new     agement and marketing. To curb the problem, the government
                                                                                                        ideas/innovation, enthusiastic, full of energy,
years,” he added when asked to explain rising      tions and a work force in desperate need of                                                                has begun to at least talk about looking for investment in more
                                                                                                        serious
levels of confidence in Cambodia’s economy.        better training.                                                                                           vocational training schools.                                         g


14 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                                                                                   FocusAsean 2012 | 15
CambodiaINsIght




DFDL's Martin Desautels says more companies are now playing by the rule book                                                                         Transparency International's Preap Kol believes perception of corruption is also correlated to the country of origin of the investor




  Chevron Corp, which after years of              means there is an enthusiasm and ambition           For years, Cambodia has ranked as one of       its Cambodia operation due to the risk of               “It’s very unfair when there is such                  Martin Desautels, regional managing
exploration is one day expected to extract        to learn in Cambodia that is unparalleled         the most corrupt nations in the world on         corruption in the customs department.                 practices as nepotism and politicians run-            partner for DFDL Mekong, a pan-Asian law
oil from Cambodian waters, is opening a           elsewhere in the region. Nonetheless, the         Transparency International’s Corruption            “Everyone knows that custom officials               ning businesses,” said Kol. “It’s not a fair          firm, believes the standard of companies
centre to train workers to operate its pro-       Foreign Business Leaders Survey found that        Perceptions Index. For Western companies,        are among those who can become rich very              playing field, and serious businesses have            entering Cambodia’s marketplace is im-
duction platform once oil starts to flow. The     37% of companies expect their staff to be         corruption is high on the list of deterrents     quickly,” said Preap Kol, country representa-         to think about that before putting their              proving all the time. The main advantage
government also has plans to re-open the          more proactive and develop abilities such         to doing business. Committing corrupt            tive for Transparency International in Cam-           feet into the country.”                               firms in Asia might have over firms in the
University of Geology and Mines, though           as critical thinking, analytical and logical      acts when abroad is also more severely           bodia. “Every family wants their kid to be a            For Ahmed at the IMF, creating an equal             West is that their governments tend to
an exact date had not been announced at           thinking as well as creative thinking.            punished than in the past.                       custom official. It’s a very prestigious job.”        playing field allows countries to attract the         have closer connections, he noted.
time of publication.                                                                                  Both the United States and the United            Kol said that the onus for the government           most competitive companies and, there-                  “They operate a bit more often government
  But most of the initiatives to improve          Graft Grievances                                  Kingdom have implemented legislation,            to stamp out corruption had increased in              fore, the most favourable for consumers.              to government and operate often through
the workforce are still in the pipelines                                                            the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the        recent years, especially with Cambodia                  “Even-handed treatment is always a                  their embassies to get the initial contacts,”
and could take years to accomplish. There         An issue that is equally as troublesome when                                                       vying to become a non-permanent mem-                  positive factor for businesses to operate. I          he said, adding that the Ministry of Com-
is also still very little effort to inform peo-   doing business here, according to investors          “Everyone knows that                          ber of the United Nations Security Council.           don’t know if that is not being practiced,            merce is currently in the process of drafting
ple in the countryside, where most of the         and the Foreign Business Leaders Survey, is                                                        But because most of the large investments             but I think it is a general pre-condition to          a competition law to be in compliance with
population lives, about how to find jobs.         corruption. In all walks of life, businesses in
                                                                                                    customs officials are among                      still come from countries that also suffer            improving the business climate,” he said.             World Trade Organisation rules.
With more than 300,000 people entering            Cambodia are confronted with corruption,           those who can become rich                       from corruption, there is a lack of desire to           Although corruption and issues sur-                   “It’s true that in certain circumstances
the labour force every year, more simply          from the court system to the customs office.             very quickly”                             make reforms quickly.                                 rounding fair competition are high on                 the local company might have less strin-
needs to be done.                                 The survey found that 58% of businesses                                                              This scenario means that Western                    the minds of foreign investors, others say            gent obligations in practice to comply
  “In Cambodia where our biggest focus is         considered the legal system to be not sup-        Bribery Act respectively, that sets much         businesses looking to do business in                  that the business climate has seen major              with. But then again, if you talk to our tax
agriculture, there are hardly any agricul-        portive to doing business, while only 12%         tougher conditions and punishments for           Cambodia can find themselves at a com-                improvements over the last few years and              guys, that is changing. The government is
ture graduates. So this is the challenge,”        voiced an opinion to the contrary.                businesses found guilty of bribing a foreign     petitive disadvantage when compared to                that more and more companies are now                  trying to broaden its tax base. It’s less and
d’Amico said. “We are not doing the right           A quarter of companies found that firms         public official.                                 companies from countries such as China,               playing by the rule book.                             less true that it is possible to not pay tax,”
marketing. We are not telling people that         with connections to the government had              Such laws, including Cambodia’s own            Malaysia or Vietnam.                                                                                        he added.
if you study agriculture you will get a job.”     advantages in terms of paying taxes and           anti-corruption law, which forbids any pay-        Another issue brought up by businesses                                                                      To make the business environment more
  Despite the dearth of skills in the work        following regulations. And 55% of busi-           ment to public officials that does not receive   in the Foreign Business Leaders Survey is
                                                                                                                                                                                                            “The government is trying                            conducive to foreign investors, the gov-
force, most businesses said that the              nesses felt that the anti-corruption law,         a receipt, have already deterred companies       that local firms use their connections to              to broaden its tax base. It’s                        ernment is drafting more of the necessary
youthfulness of the country – 32% of the          which was implemented in 2010, bore no            from doing business here. Last year, the gi-     gain favourable business conditions in                  less and less true that it is                       legislation. For example, the new civil
population is still under the age of 15 –         influence in stamping out graft.                  ant US logistics company FedEx scaled back       areas such as tax.                                       possible to not pay tax”                           code, which came into force in December, g

16 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        FocusAsean 2012 | 17
CambodiaINsIght




                                                     The Foreign Business Leaders Survey                  to government data – but rice mill factories
                                                   found that 70% of businesses still believe             often have to grapple with high energy costs
                                                   that the supply of energy in Cambodia is               through the use diesel-powered generators.
                                                   unreliable and too expensive. A further
                                                   49% said that public transportation was not            Appraising Cambodia
                                                   supportive of business, with traffic jams
                                                   and heavy congestion becoming more                     During the financial crisis, which strongly
                                                   and more of a problem. There is still no               impacted Cambodia’s economy in 2009,
                                                   public bus service in any of Cambodia’s                the construction sector was badly affected
                                                   major cities. Though a slightly different              and has struggled to recover since. Hous-
                                                   view was given of communication services               ing prices, which had in some cases risen
                                                   with 65% of businesses stating that inter-             ten fold since 2005, have fallen by 50%. Pro-
                                                   net and phone services in the country were             jects such as Gold Tower 42, which is being
                                                   supportive of doing business.                          developed by South Korea’s Yon Woo Co,
                                                     In order to rectify the energy problem,              have ground to a halt. Plans to build three
                                                   the government has set out on a plan to                more towers in Phnom Penh’s Chamkar
                                                   build more than 20 hydropower dams on                  Mon district were also scrapped in 2010 by
                                                   rivers all over the country. The 338-mega-             South Korea's GS E&C company.
                                                   watt Kamchay dam in Kampot province                      Investors are now looking more toward
                                                   was the first of those to come on line last            real estate projects in the tourism sector.
Real estate developer Tom Sterling is betting on   year, and its energy is expected to provide            Cambodia expects to have seven million
tourism facilities                                 additional power to Thailand as well as                visitors per year by 2020, up from less than
                                                   Phnom Penh, Sihanoukville and Kampot.                  three million presently.
                                                   Although environmentalists warn the                        “What we’ve always specialised in is
regulates all corporate contracts. A com-          dams could seriously jeopardise the coun-              tourism-related resorts, hotels and luxury
mercial contract law, which will regulate          try’s fisheries, the government appears set            villas. That’s the sector that year-by-year
things such as franchises, is also being           to push forward with its policy of building            is growing, and parts of Thailand have be-
drafted. What is more, an arbitration cen-         more dams.                                             come oversaturated,” said Tom Sterling,
tre is due to be launched this year as a way         An argument in favour of the dams is that
for businesses to resolve disputes outside         they will provide rural areas with more                 “Cambodia expects to have
of the court system.                               electricity. The government has a target
  Those looking to invest in Cambodia will         to reach exports of one million tonnes of
                                                                                                          seven million visitors per year
welcome these initiatives. Still, 46% of busi-     milled rice by 2015 – exports of milled rice             by 2020, up from less than
nesses questioned by the Foreign Business          reached 200,000 tonnes in 2011, according                 three million presently“
Leaders Survey said that the intellectual
property law is not supportive of doing             P Business Environment                                director at Sterling Project Management,
business. Companies in Cambodia have a                                                                    a real estate company with operations in
tendency to copy already successful busi-                  Support                     Challenges         Thailand and Cambodia.
ness models, which creates “a climate of                                                                    High value office and residential property
suspiciousness”, they said.                                                                               in Phnom Penh is still limited. “There will
  “It’s difficult to enforce, there is no doubt                                                           be an oversupply coming on line this year,”
about it. This being said it is possible to                                                               Sterling said.
enforce. There is a department at the Min-                                                                  Still Japan’s Aeon Mall announced last
istry of Commerce who can help you en-                                                                    year it would start building a giant shop-
force your intellectual property,” Desautels                                                              ping complex this year. Hongkong Land,
said, adding that any company looking to            Cost of labour                                        a subsidiary of Jardine Matheson, is also
                                                                      69%     Access to             38%
protect their intellectual property rights                                    domestic loan               set to break ground soon on two projects
would need to take a “proactive approach”.                                                                (yet to be identified at time of publica-
                                                                                                          tion) on prime real estate in Phnom Penh.
                                                    Communication 65%         Education and         53%
Constructing a Community                            services                  skills of labour            Capital going into the manufacturing and
                                                                                                          agriculture sectors is also expected to rise.
Having experienced more than 10 years                                                                       Perhaps sensing that Cambodia in the
                                                    Political stability 65%   Anti-corruption       55%
of economic growth after decades of war             of government             law                         next few years will have developed its in-
and political instability, Cambodia still has                                                             frastructure and improved its overall busi-
a massive job to do before key infrastruc-                                                                ness climate, foreign direct investment is
                                                    Domestic         54%      Legal system/       58%
ture meets the expectation of investors.            demand                    conflict resolution         increasing. According to figures released
More advanced manufacturers from Japan                                                                    by the central bank in the first part of
have only just started entering the market                                                                the year, foreign direct investment in
                                                                                                                                                              Click to fly as smooth as silk
                                                    Rate of corporate 47%     Energy                70%
in the past couple of years since the gov-          income tax                                            Cambodia reached $632m in 2011, a 14%                           thaiairways.com
ernment opened special economic zones                                                                     increase compared to the previous year.
that provide businesses with a reliable en-                                                                 One of the major plus points for Cambodia’s
                                                    Commercial       32%
ergy source and the ability to trade goods          contracts law                                         economy over the past year has been in ex-      Tel. + 855 23 214359-61 Ext 102-106
through a so-called one-stop service.                                                                     ports. Despite economies in North America g
                                                                                                                                                                 or your preferred travel agent
18 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                       FocusAsean 2012 | 19
cambodiaINsIght




Canadia Bank's Michael Lor believes a process of natural selection will apply to Cambodia's crowded banking sector                                       CIMB's Bun Yin is keeping an eye on Cambodia's stock exchange with a view to future involvement




and Europe slowing, orders from those               Cambodia to take on the position of CEO                “Barriers to entry have been erected and      with a choice between Cambodia, Laos and             “They bring in the capital, they bring          of the recently launched stock market,
markets for Cambodian-made garments re-             for Canadia Bank in late 2011. “You have             the countries themselves have become a          Myanmar. Though showing many signs of              in the technology and they bring in the           investors hope that more businesses will
mained high. Exports to the US and Europe           countries that have moved ahead of the               little bit more selective,” he added.           reform in the right direction, political stabil-   expertise,” said Lor. “Over a period of time      adopt more stringent financial standards.
rose to more than $4 billion last year, dwarf-      pack – countries such as Thailand and                  When looking to make an investment in a       ity in Myanmar is still not assured, he said.      by a process of natural selection, you will         Other aspects that could help grow the
ing 2010’s total of just $2.88 billion. Much        Indonesia and to a certain extent Vietnam.           market with fewer competitors and cheap-        He added that as domestic demand is small-         notice that those players who find them-          banking sector further is a credit bureau
of that growth was spurred by a new trade           These countries today are overpriced.”               er prices, Lor said investors are now left      er in Laos than it is in Cambodia, it would        selves too small or not viable, will move         where borrowers’ credit history can be
agreement that dropped tariffs on all items                                                                                                              take longer for the landlocked country to          out on their own. But at this moment of           viewed as well as an interbank market,
except weapons exported to the EU.                    P Future Economic Situation                                                                        emerge as an investment hotspot.                   time there is no reason to restrict.”             which still does not exist in Cambodia. Both
  Another sector that experienced ample                                                                                                                    “For anybody who is looking for a market                                                           are currently being designed by the NBC.
activity over the past year was the bank-                                                                                                                to go in, and you realise that by way of de-                                                           “A significant amount of trade in Cambo-
                                                      60%                                                                                                                                                   “If you look at the emerging
ing sector. This year alone, Japan’s Bank                                                                                                                leting what is not possible, you are now left                                                        dia today is still done on a cash basis. But
of Tokyo-Mitsubishi opened a representa-
                                                                                                              53%
                                                                                                                                                         with only Cambodia,” Lor noted.
                                                                                                                                                                                                             markets in Southeast Asia                        you realise that as the business gets larger
tive office in Phnom Penh, and Vietnam’s
                                                      50%
                                                                                                                                                           Sharing his enthusiasm is Bun Yin, Head                today, this is the                          and the demands become more sophisti-
Saigon-Hanoi Commercial Joint Stock                                             39%
                                                                                                                                           42%           of Commercial Banking and Deputy Gen-                       place to be”                             cated, there is a need for an entity in be-
Bank and Military Bank have both opened               40%                                                                                          38%   eral Manager at CIMB Bank. “Since our                                                                tween the arbitrage,” Lor explained.
branches, bringing the total number of                                                                                                                   arrival in autumn 2010, results have ex-             Despite the high numbers of banks, the            Forty-two percent of businesses felt that
commercial banks to 32 in March 2012. A               30%                                                                                                ceeded all of our targets, both in terms of        Foreign Business Leaders Survey found that        Cambodia’s new bourse would have a
                                                                                        25%                          24%
host of other banks from countries such as                                                                                                               deposits and loans," he said. CIMB plans           38% of businesses thought access to credit        positive effect on business. Still, members
China and Malaysia also joined the pack               20%                                                                                                to open four new branches in Cambodia              was not supportive of doing business,             of the opposition and economists have
                                                                     16% 15%                                                         15%
last year.                                                                                              14%                                              this year.                                         compared to 21% who found it supportive.          warned that a culture of greed and corrup-
  The influx of banks over the past three             10%                                          9%                                                      It is views like this that are fast making       Bankers say part of the reason for this is be-    tion mean regulators need to be extremely
years is one of the most obvious signs that in-                 4%                                                              5%                       Cambodia’s banking market extremely                cause small and medium-sized enterprises          vigilant to fight against illegal activities.
vestors are eyeing up the potential in Cambo-                                                 0%                           0%                            competitive. Though some insiders be-              in Cambodia still have poor accounting and          The regulators “are very much aware of
                                                       0%
dia, a country where gross domestic product                                                                                                              lieve the market is overcrowded, oth-              financial reporting standards, a necessity        these risks… and that is why they are tak-
                                                               over the next 6-12 months       Over the next 2-3 years     Over the next 3-5 years
is still only equivalent to about $12 billion.                                                                                                           ers say the National Bank of Cambodia’s            for those looking to borrow money.                ing their time to prepare the ground. But
  “If you look at the emerging markets                                                                                                                   (NBC) policy of bringing in banks with a             Still, credit is growing at rate of about 25%   it’s always a learning process. There is no
                                                                 Not confident at all           Somewhat not confident            Neutral/Unsure
in Southeast Asia today, this is the place                                                                                                               proven track record will hold the country          per year, a level that the IMF has said is at     textbook that tells you for Cambodia you
                                                                 Somewhat confident             Very confident
to be,” said Michael Lor, who arrived in                                                                                                                 in good stead.                                     Cambodia’s upper limit. With the existence        need to do these 32 things. So there is a g

20 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                FocusAsean 2012 | 21
cambodiaINsIght




                                                                                                                                                       P Recommended Mid-Term Opportunities

                                                                                                                                                                                  #         Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
                                                                                                                                                                                  #         Food processing/agribusiness



                                                                                                                                                        51%                                                #         Export
                                                                                                                                                                                                           #         High-end consumer goods
                                                                                                                                                                                                           #         Automobiles
                                                                                                                                                                                                           #         Garment and footwear industry development


                                                                                                                                                                         33%
                                                                                                                                                                                               29%                                                                                        #      Global development of the e-economy


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      #      Solar
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       20%                          20%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        18%             18%                                           #      Oil
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      #      Gas
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    13%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     9%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     7%          7%           7%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2%              2%




                                                                                                                                                        Primary sector


                                                                                                                                                                         Secondary sector




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          development




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    development
                                                                                                                                                                                               Tourism/Hospitality


                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Transportation/Logistics

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Insurance/Banking
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   & Finance industry

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Communication


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Energy

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Construction/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Real estate
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Infrastruture


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Education


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Health

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Service industry


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Green economy


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Special economic zone
Taking a long-term approach to business has brought Dominique Catry of Comin Khmere success




trial and error process that all countries             the 1990s when relative peace was restored        “We have built over the years, sourcing        Today his company provides IT solu-                                                                                                               “Definitely the local firms have more
need to go through,” said IMF’s Ahmed.                 to the country, Catry has had to negotiate      and identifying the most competitive           tions for many businesses from banks to                                                                                                           advantages because they know how to get
                                                       many of the above hurdles.                      sources. That gives us an advantage,” he       telecommunication companies and em-                                                                                                               around with the system and processes,”
Long-term Investment                                     As chairman of Comin Khmere, an engi-         said. “When we got a fresh engineering         ploys more than 300 people, of which 10%                                                                                                          he said. “You need a niche to compete.
                                                       neering company with offices in Vietnam         graduate ten years ago, he didn’t know         are expatriates from India, Singapore and                                                                                                         Your business has to have advantages that
One man who has seen Cambodia evolve                   and Cambodia, he has overseen projects          anything. Today we can find people with        Malaysia. He said that after already expand-                                                                                                      others do not.”
over the years is Dominique Catry. Hav-                that have built transformers for the nation-    experience [in Cambodia] and experi-           ing into Laos, his firm was now looking at                                                                                                          Still, First Cambodia experiences many
ing lived in Phnom Penh as a businessman               al grid and provided hardware for Vattanac      ence oversees and that makes a lot of          other countries in Asean.                                                                                                                         of the same challenges that many foreign
prior to the Khmer Rouge regime in the                 Tower, a new 38-storey building on Phnom        difference,” he added.                           Foreign companies researching Cambodia                                                                                                          businesses face. Workers with the most
1970s and then returned to Cambodia in                 Penh’s Monivong Boulevard.                        It is a development other companies are      should realise that although local firms may                                                                                                      talent can sometimes leave to start their
                                                         Catry also helped found the French            keen to exploit. According to the Foreign      have the advantage in terms of knowing the                                                                                                        own businesses or get snapped up by
 P Future Investment                                   Cambodian Chamber of Commerce and is            Business Leaders Survey, almost half of        local market and systems, access to the mar-                                                                                                      larger companies.
                                                       a co-founder of the newly formed European       the businesses questioned said they were       ket in Cambodia is one of the most open in                                                                                                          “Retaining key staff is the biggest chal-
  What is your                          What is your   Chamber of Commerce in Cambodia. He said        planning to increase their investment in       the region, according to Eyra. He also noted                                                                                                      lenge,” he said. “A lot of multinational
  expectation                  expectation in terms    the Kingdom is currently nicely poised to see   Cambodia over the next year. Moreover,         that a foreigner can wholly own compa-                                                                                                            companies are taking our staff.”
  regarding further               of recruitment for   sustained economic growth in the future.        almost 60% of the businesses said they would   nies in Cambodia, which is not the case                                                                                                             Still, he believes that as the economy con-
  investments in your          the next 12 months?       Catry said while Vietnam is struggling        recruit more staff in the next 12 months.      in Vietnam, Myanmar, Thailand and Laos,                                                                                                           tinues to grow there will be more need for
  business for the                                     with high inflation and slower economic           A company that fits into that bracket is     where investors must find a local partner.                                                                                                        IT services.
  coming 12 months?
                                                       growth, Cambodia economy is better posi-        First Cambodia, a local information tech-        He also stressed that before investors set                                                                                                        “Before you could never sell them a dol-
                                                       tioned to attract investors at it capitalises   nology company that has also started doing     up shop in Cambodia they should conduct                                                                                                           lar’s worth. And now they start to invest
                                                       on strong growth above 6%.                      business in Laos.                              thorough market research and be aware it                                                                                                          a million.”
         0%    Reduce drastically        2%
                                                         Still, he said that building a successful       After working for MobiTel, Cambodia’s        remains a relatively small domestic market.                                                                                                         Last year he said his company received
         8%    Reduce somewhat           2%            business in Cambodia has taken time and         largest telecommunications company,                                                                                                                                                              a $2m-contract to provide technology so-
                                                       a lot of effort. In the early days employees    and then for British American Tobacco,                                                                                                                                                           lutions to a new brewery opened by Chip
        45%             Same             38%
                                                       in senior positions were almost exclusively     Houn Heng Erya realised there was a lack
                                                                                                                                                        “Before you could never                                                                                                                         Mong Group, a local firm with businesses
        39% Increase somewhat            50%
                                                       expatriates. Finding reliable sources for       of companies providing IT solutions for         sell them a dollar’s worth.                                                                                                                      in the construction sector.
         8% Increase drastically         9%            importing machinery and construction            Cambodia’s growing private sector. He             And now they start to                                                                                                                            “It’s just the beginning,” he said. “It’s got
                                                       materials was also a challenge.                 started First Cambodia in 2002.                       invest a million”                                                                                                                          to go up from here.” Z

22 | FocusAsean 2012                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     FocusAsean 2012 | 23

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie 2012 Cambodia Foreign Business Leaders survey

Workforce Survey H1low Res
Workforce Survey H1low ResWorkforce Survey H1low Res
Workforce Survey H1low Resbenquinton
 
Final 2012 ceo survey
Final 2012 ceo surveyFinal 2012 ceo survey
Final 2012 ceo surveyvyncke
 
15th Global PwC CEO Survey
15th Global PwC CEO Survey15th Global PwC CEO Survey
15th Global PwC CEO Surveyraysunita
 
Delivering Results Growth And Value In A Volatile World 15th Annual Globa...
Delivering Results   Growth And Value In A Volatile World   15th Annual Globa...Delivering Results   Growth And Value In A Volatile World   15th Annual Globa...
Delivering Results Growth And Value In A Volatile World 15th Annual Globa...Colin McKillop
 
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley
 
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley
 
manpower annual reports 2001
manpower annual reports 2001manpower annual reports 2001
manpower annual reports 2001finance12
 
Solar Energy Investment & Finance US
Solar Energy Investment & Finance USSolar Energy Investment & Finance US
Solar Energy Investment & Finance USCSP Today
 
el paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualel paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualfinance49
 
Piffa newsletter
Piffa newsletterPiffa newsletter
Piffa newsletternabeelak85
 
Fj australian - hr salary survey 2010-11
Fj   australian - hr salary survey 2010-11Fj   australian - hr salary survey 2010-11
Fj australian - hr salary survey 2010-11reneeclarke
 
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9 November 2009 Service Sector Growth In...
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9  November 2009   Service  Sector  Growth In...Business Times_Leading the way_ 9  November 2009   Service  Sector  Growth In...
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9 November 2009 Service Sector Growth In...PeopleWorldwide Singapore
 
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009Santanu Sengupta
 
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012ContinuitySA
 
el paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualel paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualfinance49
 

Ähnlich wie 2012 Cambodia Foreign Business Leaders survey (20)

Workforce Survey H1low Res
Workforce Survey H1low ResWorkforce Survey H1low Res
Workforce Survey H1low Res
 
Final 2012 ceo survey
Final 2012 ceo surveyFinal 2012 ceo survey
Final 2012 ceo survey
 
15th Global PwC CEO Survey
15th Global PwC CEO Survey15th Global PwC CEO Survey
15th Global PwC CEO Survey
 
Delivering Results Growth And Value In A Volatile World 15th Annual Globa...
Delivering Results   Growth And Value In A Volatile World   15th Annual Globa...Delivering Results   Growth And Value In A Volatile World   15th Annual Globa...
Delivering Results Growth And Value In A Volatile World 15th Annual Globa...
 
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
 
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
Morgan McKinley Singapore Salary Survey 2012
 
Wisdom Exchange 2009 – Winning Strategies in Turbulent Times
Wisdom Exchange 2009 – Winning Strategies in Turbulent TimesWisdom Exchange 2009 – Winning Strategies in Turbulent Times
Wisdom Exchange 2009 – Winning Strategies in Turbulent Times
 
manpower annual reports 2001
manpower annual reports 2001manpower annual reports 2001
manpower annual reports 2001
 
Solar Energy Investment & Finance US
Solar Energy Investment & Finance USSolar Energy Investment & Finance US
Solar Energy Investment & Finance US
 
HMC Newsletter 2010-2
HMC Newsletter 2010-2HMC Newsletter 2010-2
HMC Newsletter 2010-2
 
el paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualel paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnual
 
Piffa newsletter
Piffa newsletterPiffa newsletter
Piffa newsletter
 
Piffa
PiffaPiffa
Piffa
 
Recruitment Guide to South East Asia
Recruitment Guide to South East AsiaRecruitment Guide to South East Asia
Recruitment Guide to South East Asia
 
Fj australian - hr salary survey 2010-11
Fj   australian - hr salary survey 2010-11Fj   australian - hr salary survey 2010-11
Fj australian - hr salary survey 2010-11
 
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9 November 2009 Service Sector Growth In...
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9  November 2009   Service  Sector  Growth In...Business Times_Leading the way_ 9  November 2009   Service  Sector  Growth In...
Business Times_Leading the way_ 9 November 2009 Service Sector Growth In...
 
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009
Speeding Financial Inclusion through Bc Bf Model in India - 2009
 
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012
ContinuitySA Q1 Client Chronicles Newsletter 2012
 
el paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnualel paso 2004EPAnnual
el paso 2004EPAnnual
 
PEDCO 2012 Annual Meeting
PEDCO 2012 Annual MeetingPEDCO 2012 Annual Meeting
PEDCO 2012 Annual Meeting
 

2012 Cambodia Foreign Business Leaders survey

  • 1. THE ROAD TO THE ASEAN ECONOMIC COMMUNITY ANALYSIS | EXPERTISE | INSIGHT VOLUME 2 US$5 CAMBODIA2012 The foreign business leaders survey rates the kingdom’s business environment Getting started How to do business in cambodia ALL ABOUT asean Shaping the region’s economic future facts & FIGURES The region in numbers
  • 2. CAMBODIAoverview propitious position The second installment of the Foreign Business Leaders Survey shows there is much reason for optimism in the Kingdom By Laurent Notin, Indochina Research W “ elcome to the 2012 edition of has been introduced, and the skies have opened be- the Cambodian Foreign Business With tween Siem Reap and Sihanoukville. With Cambodia Leaders Survey. For the second year cambodia chairing Asean in 2012, more growth is definitely to in a row, we have spoken to a broad chairing be expected. asean in range of foreign business leaders 2012, more I believe optimism is in the air. Eighty percent of the working and living in Cambodia, asking them about groWth is business men and women we have interviewed feel their perceptions of doing business in the country. We definitely to confident the economic conditions of the country will be expected ” have made some additions to our questionnaire, and improve over the next three to five years, while 51% of we have introduced a new section (page 14), which them see mid-term opportunities in the primary sec- should provide our readers with a tor (agriculture, agribusiness, food valuable picture of the Cambodian processing, forestry and fishery). labour market in terms of cost, Cambodia can count on its business existing skills and training needs friendly environment, as well as its from an employer’s perspective. labour force, to drive growth. The Last year, we tried to demonstrate ease of starting a company is cited as that Cambodia was very much a a clear positive of doing business in country under construction and the Kingdom, and cost and availabil- would remain at work for quite ity of labour are key business advan- a long time, for there were many tages, according to our survey. issues to tackle. But Cambodia is Of course, it is not all rosy. Cam- becoming more than just a blip on bodia still has many challenges to the radar: every year the country address, as mentioned by our re- takes another step forward. I re- spondents. The legal system, access member when I first came to the to domestic loans, energy or public country six years ago, I was struck utilities, among others, will have by the country’s energy; despite all to improve. But this does not seem the worldwide turbulence in that to be a deterrent to future invest- time, this has not changed. ments: 92% of the foreign business The Cambodian business land- leaders expect to invest the same scape has experienced impor- amount or more money in 2012. tant changes in the last year. For On that note, let me conclude by instance, the new European Union sincerely thanking all survey par- trade legislation offered increased ticipants. We know their time is pre- access to Europe, the agri-business cious, and we are grateful for them industry expanded significantly de- having taken a moment to complete spite regional flooding, increased our questionnaire. investment from Japan in particu- Cambodia is looking far into the lar demonstrated a higher level of future. So if you haven’t already, sophistication in the manufactur- why don’t you come and ‘feel’ the ing sector, an anti-corruption law country for yourself ? Z Research by INDOCHINA RESEARCH, Cambodia The Questionnaires for the survey on pages 12 - 23 were sent by email to a pre-selected list of foreign business managers/decision-makers/ leaders working for private companies based in Cambodia. Research coordinated by Florence Pollet. www.indochinaresearch.com cambodia@indochinaresearch.com 10 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 11
  • 3. CAMBODIAINsIght Courting Cambodia By Simon Marks T aking the Asean chair for the second time, Cambodia will be keen to use this year to prove itself a force to Our signature Foreign Business Leaders Survey reveals what be reckoned with. In its role as Asean chair, Cambo- the country’s key players really think of the market dia has already said it wants to initiate six-party talks with North Korea and has expressed the need to fi- nalise a first draft of the Asean Human Rights Declaration. This year’s Asean summits will strive to showcase the country as a viable investment destination. Indeed, Cambodia has come a long way in the last 10 years. P Ease of Doing Business in Cambodia Economic growth of over 6% has become the norm. A stock mar- ket launched last year. Skyscrapers are gradually giving Phnom On a scale of one to 10, how would you evaluate the ease of doing business in Penh a skyline, and the manufacturing sector is beginning to Cambodia at present? move beyond garments. Poor Excellent But while optimism in the economy is high, Cambodia, like most developing countries, still grapples with a host of matters that restrict the speed at which the country is developing and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 reduce the ease of doing business. 1% 5% 11% 6% 16% 20% 24% 9% 5% 1% In order to perceive how foreign investors – particularly from Average: 5.72 Western countries – rate doing business in Cambodia, Indochina Research, a regional market research company, asked 66 for- eign business managers, decision makers and members of the private sector to answer questions on what it is really like to do business here. The businesses questioned operated in a wide range of sectors including consulting, trade, retail, banking, hospitality, manu- facturing and information technology. Asked to evaluate the ease of doing business in Cambodia by giving the country a score of between one and 10, the average score was 5.72. Still, the vast majority of businesses are confident that Cambodia’s economic situation will improve in the near future. According to the survey, 38% of businesses are “very confident” that the economy will improve in the next three to five years, while a further 42% of businesses are “somewhat confident”. No businesses expressed zero confidence and only 5% were “somewhat not confident”. “People I talk to not just in Cambodia but outside the coun- try are very optimistic about Cambodia,” said Faisal Ahmed, resident representative for the International Monetary Fund in Cambodia. “Obviously one big advantage of Cambodia is that it is starting later. You learn from the mistakes of others and your opportunity set is bigger.” Ahmed added that more and more investors are viewing Cambodia as a potential market. A major reason for this is the competitive edge Cambodia now has when it comes to the cost of labour. “The minimum monthly wage for an IT technician in Cambodia is $90 compared to $500 in Thailand” In Vietnam, wages have doubled in the last four years and the minimum salary in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi stands at Photo: Chor Sokunthea/Reuters two million dong (at the time of publication), or about $100, per month. Wages in China are also on the rise. Earlier this year a Chinese government report confirmed that the annual average growth of minimum wages should be at least 13% in the next three years. In February, minimum wages in China Caught between tradition and modernity, Phnom Penh reflects Cambodia's economic development had already risen to 1,500 yuan ($240) per month in regions such as Shenzhen. g 12 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 13
  • 4. cambodiaINsIght IMF's Faisal Ahmed believes Cambodia's late start can be an advantage HR Inc's Sandra d'Amico pleads for a more balanced job market Although trade unions in Cambodia Road connections with neighbouring The Right Course Most of those attending higher education are doing so in would like to see the minimum wage rise countries are also improving. Money from subject matters such as business, management and finance. But to $96 per month – and the number of vio- countries such as China, South Korea and While 61% of businesses said the availability the labour market is crying out for people with technical skills lent protests by garment workers are on Japan has either built or is in the process of labour and 69% said the cost of labour in areas such as agriculture, information technology, human the rise – the minimum wage in Cambodia of building more than 1,000 kilometres of was supportive to doing business, 53% of resources and marketing. stands at just $66 per month (at the time new roads in the country. National roads those questioned said that the skills and According to the Cambodian Federation of Employers and of publication), considerably lower than four and five, which run between Phnom education levels of the work force were not Business Associations (Camfeba), more than 60% of Cambodian other countries in the region. According Penh and the Thai border were inaugurated supportive to doing business. university students are graduating in either business or law. Only to the Foreign Business Leaders Survey, the in 2009. Work on a bridge over the Mekong 2% of students graduate in agriculture even though the govern- minimum monthly wage for an IT techni- in order to connect Phnom Penh with P Workforce ment is pushing for more exports in commodities such as rice, cian in Cambodia is $90 compared to $500 Ho Chi Minh City is scheduled to finish by cassava and rubber. in Thailand. 2015. Roads in Mondulkiri and Ratanakiri What are the strengths in terms of education/ “There needs to be a bigger focus on technical vocational provinces that link with Vietnam have also qualification of the local workforce? training,” said Sandra d’Amico, managing director for HR Inc been improved in the past two years. and vice president of Camfeba, adding that qualifying with voca- “There needs to be a These developments have all helped Ambition/Desire to learn tional skills tends to take less time and put people into jobs at a bigger focus on technical improve Cambodia’s ability to import and much quicker rate than academic courses. vocational training” export goods. But what do investors in Language skills D’Amico said that too many parents and students look at university Cambodia really feel about the ease of do- Positive attitude as a way to get people into white-collar jobs. What the job market ing business in a country that only 20 years 26%* really needs is engineers, factory supervisors and accountants. “The pull factors would be domes- ago had no investment law? “Those people come into the market and actually earn more 18% tic ones like low wages and improving According to the Survey and more than a 15%** money than university graduates,” she said. infrastructure,” noted Ahmed. dozen interviews with economists, managers Companies such as Japan’s Minebea, which makes small, “The government is making efforts to and observers of Cambodia’s economy, doing motorised parts for items such as mobile phones, have found improve some of the bottlenecks on infra- business here still has many challenges, from * Willing to improve, continuous learning, eagerness it difficult to find locals with the skills to operate its machin- structure, and businesses are looking at the high levels of corruption inside the country’s to learn by graduates, once immersed in industry ery. Banks also find it hard to hire locals with skills in risk man- improvements made over the last five or 10 tax and custom authorities to unclear regula- ** Diligent, committed, passionate, receptive to new agement and marketing. To curb the problem, the government ideas/innovation, enthusiastic, full of energy, years,” he added when asked to explain rising tions and a work force in desperate need of has begun to at least talk about looking for investment in more serious levels of confidence in Cambodia’s economy. better training. vocational training schools. g 14 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 15
  • 5. CambodiaINsIght DFDL's Martin Desautels says more companies are now playing by the rule book Transparency International's Preap Kol believes perception of corruption is also correlated to the country of origin of the investor Chevron Corp, which after years of means there is an enthusiasm and ambition For years, Cambodia has ranked as one of its Cambodia operation due to the risk of “It’s very unfair when there is such Martin Desautels, regional managing exploration is one day expected to extract to learn in Cambodia that is unparalleled the most corrupt nations in the world on corruption in the customs department. practices as nepotism and politicians run- partner for DFDL Mekong, a pan-Asian law oil from Cambodian waters, is opening a elsewhere in the region. Nonetheless, the Transparency International’s Corruption “Everyone knows that custom officials ning businesses,” said Kol. “It’s not a fair firm, believes the standard of companies centre to train workers to operate its pro- Foreign Business Leaders Survey found that Perceptions Index. For Western companies, are among those who can become rich very playing field, and serious businesses have entering Cambodia’s marketplace is im- duction platform once oil starts to flow. The 37% of companies expect their staff to be corruption is high on the list of deterrents quickly,” said Preap Kol, country representa- to think about that before putting their proving all the time. The main advantage government also has plans to re-open the more proactive and develop abilities such to doing business. Committing corrupt tive for Transparency International in Cam- feet into the country.” firms in Asia might have over firms in the University of Geology and Mines, though as critical thinking, analytical and logical acts when abroad is also more severely bodia. “Every family wants their kid to be a For Ahmed at the IMF, creating an equal West is that their governments tend to an exact date had not been announced at thinking as well as creative thinking. punished than in the past. custom official. It’s a very prestigious job.” playing field allows countries to attract the have closer connections, he noted. time of publication. Both the United States and the United Kol said that the onus for the government most competitive companies and, there- “They operate a bit more often government But most of the initiatives to improve Graft Grievances Kingdom have implemented legislation, to stamp out corruption had increased in fore, the most favourable for consumers. to government and operate often through the workforce are still in the pipelines the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the recent years, especially with Cambodia “Even-handed treatment is always a their embassies to get the initial contacts,” and could take years to accomplish. There An issue that is equally as troublesome when vying to become a non-permanent mem- positive factor for businesses to operate. I he said, adding that the Ministry of Com- is also still very little effort to inform peo- doing business here, according to investors “Everyone knows that ber of the United Nations Security Council. don’t know if that is not being practiced, merce is currently in the process of drafting ple in the countryside, where most of the and the Foreign Business Leaders Survey, is But because most of the large investments but I think it is a general pre-condition to a competition law to be in compliance with population lives, about how to find jobs. corruption. In all walks of life, businesses in customs officials are among still come from countries that also suffer improving the business climate,” he said. World Trade Organisation rules. With more than 300,000 people entering Cambodia are confronted with corruption, those who can become rich from corruption, there is a lack of desire to Although corruption and issues sur- “It’s true that in certain circumstances the labour force every year, more simply from the court system to the customs office. very quickly” make reforms quickly. rounding fair competition are high on the local company might have less strin- needs to be done. The survey found that 58% of businesses This scenario means that Western the minds of foreign investors, others say gent obligations in practice to comply “In Cambodia where our biggest focus is considered the legal system to be not sup- Bribery Act respectively, that sets much businesses looking to do business in that the business climate has seen major with. But then again, if you talk to our tax agriculture, there are hardly any agricul- portive to doing business, while only 12% tougher conditions and punishments for Cambodia can find themselves at a com- improvements over the last few years and guys, that is changing. The government is ture graduates. So this is the challenge,” voiced an opinion to the contrary. businesses found guilty of bribing a foreign petitive disadvantage when compared to that more and more companies are now trying to broaden its tax base. It’s less and d’Amico said. “We are not doing the right A quarter of companies found that firms public official. companies from countries such as China, playing by the rule book. less true that it is possible to not pay tax,” marketing. We are not telling people that with connections to the government had Such laws, including Cambodia’s own Malaysia or Vietnam. he added. if you study agriculture you will get a job.” advantages in terms of paying taxes and anti-corruption law, which forbids any pay- Another issue brought up by businesses To make the business environment more Despite the dearth of skills in the work following regulations. And 55% of busi- ment to public officials that does not receive in the Foreign Business Leaders Survey is “The government is trying conducive to foreign investors, the gov- force, most businesses said that the nesses felt that the anti-corruption law, a receipt, have already deterred companies that local firms use their connections to to broaden its tax base. It’s ernment is drafting more of the necessary youthfulness of the country – 32% of the which was implemented in 2010, bore no from doing business here. Last year, the gi- gain favourable business conditions in less and less true that it is legislation. For example, the new civil population is still under the age of 15 – influence in stamping out graft. ant US logistics company FedEx scaled back areas such as tax. possible to not pay tax” code, which came into force in December, g 16 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 17
  • 6. CambodiaINsIght The Foreign Business Leaders Survey to government data – but rice mill factories found that 70% of businesses still believe often have to grapple with high energy costs that the supply of energy in Cambodia is through the use diesel-powered generators. unreliable and too expensive. A further 49% said that public transportation was not Appraising Cambodia supportive of business, with traffic jams and heavy congestion becoming more During the financial crisis, which strongly and more of a problem. There is still no impacted Cambodia’s economy in 2009, public bus service in any of Cambodia’s the construction sector was badly affected major cities. Though a slightly different and has struggled to recover since. Hous- view was given of communication services ing prices, which had in some cases risen with 65% of businesses stating that inter- ten fold since 2005, have fallen by 50%. Pro- net and phone services in the country were jects such as Gold Tower 42, which is being supportive of doing business. developed by South Korea’s Yon Woo Co, In order to rectify the energy problem, have ground to a halt. Plans to build three the government has set out on a plan to more towers in Phnom Penh’s Chamkar build more than 20 hydropower dams on Mon district were also scrapped in 2010 by rivers all over the country. The 338-mega- South Korea's GS E&C company. watt Kamchay dam in Kampot province Investors are now looking more toward was the first of those to come on line last real estate projects in the tourism sector. Real estate developer Tom Sterling is betting on year, and its energy is expected to provide Cambodia expects to have seven million tourism facilities additional power to Thailand as well as visitors per year by 2020, up from less than Phnom Penh, Sihanoukville and Kampot. three million presently. Although environmentalists warn the “What we’ve always specialised in is regulates all corporate contracts. A com- dams could seriously jeopardise the coun- tourism-related resorts, hotels and luxury mercial contract law, which will regulate try’s fisheries, the government appears set villas. That’s the sector that year-by-year things such as franchises, is also being to push forward with its policy of building is growing, and parts of Thailand have be- drafted. What is more, an arbitration cen- more dams. come oversaturated,” said Tom Sterling, tre is due to be launched this year as a way An argument in favour of the dams is that for businesses to resolve disputes outside they will provide rural areas with more “Cambodia expects to have of the court system. electricity. The government has a target Those looking to invest in Cambodia will to reach exports of one million tonnes of seven million visitors per year welcome these initiatives. Still, 46% of busi- milled rice by 2015 – exports of milled rice by 2020, up from less than nesses questioned by the Foreign Business reached 200,000 tonnes in 2011, according three million presently“ Leaders Survey said that the intellectual property law is not supportive of doing P Business Environment director at Sterling Project Management, business. Companies in Cambodia have a a real estate company with operations in tendency to copy already successful busi- Support Challenges Thailand and Cambodia. ness models, which creates “a climate of High value office and residential property suspiciousness”, they said. in Phnom Penh is still limited. “There will “It’s difficult to enforce, there is no doubt be an oversupply coming on line this year,” about it. This being said it is possible to Sterling said. enforce. There is a department at the Min- Still Japan’s Aeon Mall announced last istry of Commerce who can help you en- year it would start building a giant shop- force your intellectual property,” Desautels ping complex this year. Hongkong Land, said, adding that any company looking to Cost of labour a subsidiary of Jardine Matheson, is also 69% Access to 38% protect their intellectual property rights domestic loan set to break ground soon on two projects would need to take a “proactive approach”. (yet to be identified at time of publica- tion) on prime real estate in Phnom Penh. Communication 65% Education and 53% Constructing a Community services skills of labour Capital going into the manufacturing and agriculture sectors is also expected to rise. Having experienced more than 10 years Perhaps sensing that Cambodia in the Political stability 65% Anti-corruption 55% of economic growth after decades of war of government law next few years will have developed its in- and political instability, Cambodia still has frastructure and improved its overall busi- a massive job to do before key infrastruc- ness climate, foreign direct investment is Domestic 54% Legal system/ 58% ture meets the expectation of investors. demand conflict resolution increasing. According to figures released More advanced manufacturers from Japan by the central bank in the first part of have only just started entering the market the year, foreign direct investment in Click to fly as smooth as silk Rate of corporate 47% Energy 70% in the past couple of years since the gov- income tax Cambodia reached $632m in 2011, a 14% thaiairways.com ernment opened special economic zones increase compared to the previous year. that provide businesses with a reliable en- One of the major plus points for Cambodia’s Commercial 32% ergy source and the ability to trade goods contracts law economy over the past year has been in ex- Tel. + 855 23 214359-61 Ext 102-106 through a so-called one-stop service. ports. Despite economies in North America g or your preferred travel agent 18 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 19
  • 7. cambodiaINsIght Canadia Bank's Michael Lor believes a process of natural selection will apply to Cambodia's crowded banking sector CIMB's Bun Yin is keeping an eye on Cambodia's stock exchange with a view to future involvement and Europe slowing, orders from those Cambodia to take on the position of CEO “Barriers to entry have been erected and with a choice between Cambodia, Laos and “They bring in the capital, they bring of the recently launched stock market, markets for Cambodian-made garments re- for Canadia Bank in late 2011. “You have the countries themselves have become a Myanmar. Though showing many signs of in the technology and they bring in the investors hope that more businesses will mained high. Exports to the US and Europe countries that have moved ahead of the little bit more selective,” he added. reform in the right direction, political stabil- expertise,” said Lor. “Over a period of time adopt more stringent financial standards. rose to more than $4 billion last year, dwarf- pack – countries such as Thailand and When looking to make an investment in a ity in Myanmar is still not assured, he said. by a process of natural selection, you will Other aspects that could help grow the ing 2010’s total of just $2.88 billion. Much Indonesia and to a certain extent Vietnam. market with fewer competitors and cheap- He added that as domestic demand is small- notice that those players who find them- banking sector further is a credit bureau of that growth was spurred by a new trade These countries today are overpriced.” er prices, Lor said investors are now left er in Laos than it is in Cambodia, it would selves too small or not viable, will move where borrowers’ credit history can be agreement that dropped tariffs on all items take longer for the landlocked country to out on their own. But at this moment of viewed as well as an interbank market, except weapons exported to the EU. P Future Economic Situation emerge as an investment hotspot. time there is no reason to restrict.” which still does not exist in Cambodia. Both Another sector that experienced ample “For anybody who is looking for a market are currently being designed by the NBC. activity over the past year was the bank- to go in, and you realise that by way of de- “A significant amount of trade in Cambo- 60% “If you look at the emerging ing sector. This year alone, Japan’s Bank leting what is not possible, you are now left dia today is still done on a cash basis. But of Tokyo-Mitsubishi opened a representa- 53% with only Cambodia,” Lor noted. markets in Southeast Asia you realise that as the business gets larger tive office in Phnom Penh, and Vietnam’s 50% Sharing his enthusiasm is Bun Yin, Head today, this is the and the demands become more sophisti- Saigon-Hanoi Commercial Joint Stock 39% 42% of Commercial Banking and Deputy Gen- place to be” cated, there is a need for an entity in be- Bank and Military Bank have both opened 40% 38% eral Manager at CIMB Bank. “Since our tween the arbitrage,” Lor explained. branches, bringing the total number of arrival in autumn 2010, results have ex- Despite the high numbers of banks, the Forty-two percent of businesses felt that commercial banks to 32 in March 2012. A 30% ceeded all of our targets, both in terms of Foreign Business Leaders Survey found that Cambodia’s new bourse would have a 25% 24% host of other banks from countries such as deposits and loans," he said. CIMB plans 38% of businesses thought access to credit positive effect on business. Still, members China and Malaysia also joined the pack 20% to open four new branches in Cambodia was not supportive of doing business, of the opposition and economists have 16% 15% 15% last year. 14% this year. compared to 21% who found it supportive. warned that a culture of greed and corrup- The influx of banks over the past three 10% 9% It is views like this that are fast making Bankers say part of the reason for this is be- tion mean regulators need to be extremely years is one of the most obvious signs that in- 4% 5% Cambodia’s banking market extremely cause small and medium-sized enterprises vigilant to fight against illegal activities. vestors are eyeing up the potential in Cambo- 0% 0% competitive. Though some insiders be- in Cambodia still have poor accounting and The regulators “are very much aware of 0% dia, a country where gross domestic product lieve the market is overcrowded, oth- financial reporting standards, a necessity these risks… and that is why they are tak- over the next 6-12 months Over the next 2-3 years Over the next 3-5 years is still only equivalent to about $12 billion. ers say the National Bank of Cambodia’s for those looking to borrow money. ing their time to prepare the ground. But “If you look at the emerging markets (NBC) policy of bringing in banks with a Still, credit is growing at rate of about 25% it’s always a learning process. There is no Not confident at all Somewhat not confident Neutral/Unsure in Southeast Asia today, this is the place proven track record will hold the country per year, a level that the IMF has said is at textbook that tells you for Cambodia you Somewhat confident Very confident to be,” said Michael Lor, who arrived in in good stead. Cambodia’s upper limit. With the existence need to do these 32 things. So there is a g 20 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 21
  • 8. cambodiaINsIght P Recommended Mid-Term Opportunities # Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries # Food processing/agribusiness 51% # Export # High-end consumer goods # Automobiles # Garment and footwear industry development 33% 29% # Global development of the e-economy # Solar 20% 20% 18% 18% # Oil # Gas 13% 9% 7% 7% 7% 2% 2% Primary sector Secondary sector development development Tourism/Hospitality Transportation/Logistics Insurance/Banking & Finance industry Communication Energy Construction/ Real estate Infrastruture Education Health Service industry Green economy Special economic zone Taking a long-term approach to business has brought Dominique Catry of Comin Khmere success trial and error process that all countries the 1990s when relative peace was restored “We have built over the years, sourcing Today his company provides IT solu- “Definitely the local firms have more need to go through,” said IMF’s Ahmed. to the country, Catry has had to negotiate and identifying the most competitive tions for many businesses from banks to advantages because they know how to get many of the above hurdles. sources. That gives us an advantage,” he telecommunication companies and em- around with the system and processes,” Long-term Investment As chairman of Comin Khmere, an engi- said. “When we got a fresh engineering ploys more than 300 people, of which 10% he said. “You need a niche to compete. neering company with offices in Vietnam graduate ten years ago, he didn’t know are expatriates from India, Singapore and Your business has to have advantages that One man who has seen Cambodia evolve and Cambodia, he has overseen projects anything. Today we can find people with Malaysia. He said that after already expand- others do not.” over the years is Dominique Catry. Hav- that have built transformers for the nation- experience [in Cambodia] and experi- ing into Laos, his firm was now looking at Still, First Cambodia experiences many ing lived in Phnom Penh as a businessman al grid and provided hardware for Vattanac ence oversees and that makes a lot of other countries in Asean. of the same challenges that many foreign prior to the Khmer Rouge regime in the Tower, a new 38-storey building on Phnom difference,” he added. Foreign companies researching Cambodia businesses face. Workers with the most 1970s and then returned to Cambodia in Penh’s Monivong Boulevard. It is a development other companies are should realise that although local firms may talent can sometimes leave to start their Catry also helped found the French keen to exploit. According to the Foreign have the advantage in terms of knowing the own businesses or get snapped up by P Future Investment Cambodian Chamber of Commerce and is Business Leaders Survey, almost half of local market and systems, access to the mar- larger companies. a co-founder of the newly formed European the businesses questioned said they were ket in Cambodia is one of the most open in “Retaining key staff is the biggest chal- What is your What is your Chamber of Commerce in Cambodia. He said planning to increase their investment in the region, according to Eyra. He also noted lenge,” he said. “A lot of multinational expectation expectation in terms the Kingdom is currently nicely poised to see Cambodia over the next year. Moreover, that a foreigner can wholly own compa- companies are taking our staff.” regarding further of recruitment for sustained economic growth in the future. almost 60% of the businesses said they would nies in Cambodia, which is not the case Still, he believes that as the economy con- investments in your the next 12 months? Catry said while Vietnam is struggling recruit more staff in the next 12 months. in Vietnam, Myanmar, Thailand and Laos, tinues to grow there will be more need for business for the with high inflation and slower economic A company that fits into that bracket is where investors must find a local partner. IT services. coming 12 months? growth, Cambodia economy is better posi- First Cambodia, a local information tech- He also stressed that before investors set “Before you could never sell them a dol- tioned to attract investors at it capitalises nology company that has also started doing up shop in Cambodia they should conduct lar’s worth. And now they start to invest on strong growth above 6%. business in Laos. thorough market research and be aware it a million.” 0% Reduce drastically 2% Still, he said that building a successful After working for MobiTel, Cambodia’s remains a relatively small domestic market. Last year he said his company received 8% Reduce somewhat 2% business in Cambodia has taken time and largest telecommunications company, a $2m-contract to provide technology so- a lot of effort. In the early days employees and then for British American Tobacco, lutions to a new brewery opened by Chip 45% Same 38% in senior positions were almost exclusively Houn Heng Erya realised there was a lack “Before you could never Mong Group, a local firm with businesses 39% Increase somewhat 50% expatriates. Finding reliable sources for of companies providing IT solutions for sell them a dollar’s worth. in the construction sector. 8% Increase drastically 9% importing machinery and construction Cambodia’s growing private sector. He And now they start to “It’s just the beginning,” he said. “It’s got materials was also a challenge. started First Cambodia in 2002. invest a million” to go up from here.” Z 22 | FocusAsean 2012 FocusAsean 2012 | 23