SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 10
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
SAPERE: Self‐aware Pervasive 
    Service Ecosystems
            Franco Zambonelli
   Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia

           STREP – 3 years
         www.sapere‐project.eu
         www sapere‐project eu
           AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010   1
The Consortium
                     The Consortium

• Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia
   – Franco Zambonelli & Marco Mamei
     Franco Zambonelli & Marco Mamei
• Birkbeck College University of London
   – Giovanna Di Marzo Serugendo
     Giovanna Di Marzo
• Alma Mater Studiorum – Università di Bologna
   – Mirko Viroli & Andrea Omicini
• St. Andrews University
   – Simon Dobson
• Johannes Kepler Universitaet Linz
             p
   – Alois Ferscha
                      AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010   2
The Scenario
                        The Scenario
• Pervasive computing
   –   Sensor rich and always connected smart phones 
   –   Sensor networks and information tags
   –   Localization and activity recognition
   –   Internet of things and the real‐time Web
       Internet of things and the real time Web
• Innovative pervasive services arising
   – Situation‐aware adaptation
     Situation aware adaptation 
   – Interactive reality 
   – Pervasive collective intelligence and pervasive participation
• Open co‐production scenario, very dynamic, diverse 
  needs and diverse services, continuously evolving

                     AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010         3
The Overall Objective
                The Overall Objective
• Develop and demonstrate a highly‐innovative 
  theoretical and practical framework for pervasive 
  service ecosystems
  service ecosystems
   – Adaptivity and self‐management as inherent properties of 
     the ecosystem
              y
   – Systemic self‐awareness as an observable property of the 
     overall system
   – Long lasting (eternal) adaptivity
     Long‐lasting (eternal) adaptivity
   – Bio‐chemical inspiration
• Foundational re‐thinking of
  Foundational re thinking of
   – Service architectures and associated middleware
   – Self‐* algorithms and contextual knowledge management

                   AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010        4
The Architectural Approach
               The Architectural Approach
• Open production model
• Smooth data/services 
  distinction
    – LSA  live semantic 
      annotations
• Interactions
  Interactions  
    – Sorts of bio‐chemical reactions 
      among components
    – In a spatial substrate
      In a spatial substrate
• Eco‐laws 
    – Rule all interactions
    – Discovery + orchestration
                  + orchestration 
      seamlessly merged
• Built over a pervasive network 
  world
                          AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010   5
Specific Objectives
                  Specific Objectives
• Both of a scientific and technological nature
• Around which the various WPs are organized




                   AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010   6
Model, Structures, and Knowledge
           Model Structures and Knowledge
• M d l & M th d l
  Model & Methodology
   – Innovative chemical‐inspired semantic model for interactions among 
     components and their dynamic composition/aggregation
   – S
     Semantic (LSA) description and semantic pattern‐ mathing
           ti (LSA) d    i ti     d       ti   tt        thi
   – Uniform traitment of data and services
   – Methodological guidelines associated
• Structures & Space
   – Model distributed self‐* algorithms via the chemical LSA framework
   – Innovative flexible means for aggregation and composition
                                    gg g               p
   – Define decentralized means to control the behaviour of the ecosystem
• Knowledge & Time
   – Distributed knowledge management algorithms via the LSA framework
     Distributed knowledge management algorithms via the LSA framework
   – Define new means to perform distributed recognition of current situations
   – As well as to enable recognition of future situations


                         AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010                 7
Key Challenges
                                y        g
               for model, structure and knowledge
• C
  Can our chemically‐inspired computation model and the 
           h i ll i i d            t ti     d l d th
  eco‐laws?
   – Be flexible and general‐purpose enough?
                     g        p p          g
   – Effectively deal with the complexity and diversity of modern
     pervasive scenarios?
   – Be effectively implementable?
     Be effectively
• And, for structure and knowledge
   – Can it accommodate all needed distributed aggregation and 
     self‐composition algorthims
       lf        iti     l thi
   – Can it express all needed forms of knowledge management?
• Or should we rather go for application‐specific (or location‐
  Or should           go for application specific (or location
  specific) eco‐laws?


                        AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010           8
Infrastructure and Applications
                Infrastructure and Applications
• I f t t
  Infrastructure
   – A very lightweight infrastructure
   – Ruling all interactions (from discovery to data exchange and 
     synchronization) by embedding the concept of eco‐laws
         h i ti ) b           b ddi th            t f     l
   – To most extent, acting as a recommendation and planning engine
   – Possibly inspired by tuple space coordination models
   – Yet made it more “fluid” and suitable for a pervasive computing 
     continuum substrate  not a network but a continuum of tuple spaces

• Applications
   –   The “Ecosystem of Display” as a general and impactful testbed
   –   To put at work and demonstrate the SAPERE findings
          p                                                 g
   –   Active and dynamic information sharing in urban scenarios
   –   Active participation of citizens to the working of the urban infrastructure


                            AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010                  9
Key Tangible Results
                         y    g
                                       (hopefully)
• A novel model and methodology to support the development 
  of complex service systems in open and dynamic pervasive 
  scenarios
• A uniform set of:
   – Self‐* algorithms for service/data composition and aggregation (in 
     the form of libraries)
     th f       f lib i )
   – Algorithms and tools for distributed management of contextual‐
     knowledge, to enforce present‐ and future‐awareness in the 
     ecosystem
• A novel middleware for pervasive computing scenarios (Open 
  Source)
        )
   – Integrating the stated algorithms in the form of libraries
• A set of released innovative application showcased on the 
  Ecosystem of Displays testbed 
  E      t     f Di l    t tb d
                        AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010           10

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch

Awareness keywords-dec-2010
Awareness keywords-dec-2010Awareness keywords-dec-2010
Awareness keywords-dec-2010awarenessproject
 
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010awarenessproject
 
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systems
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music SystemsSelf-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systems
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systemsawarenessproject
 
Marr spresentation97katyupdate
Marr spresentation97katyupdateMarr spresentation97katyupdate
Marr spresentation97katyupdateLarry Rostetter
 
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism Victoria
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism VictoriaDigital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism Victoria
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism VictoriaMike Hauser
 

Andere mochten auch (7)

B.arab
B.arab B.arab
B.arab
 
Grafica Catalogo Gioielli in oro e Argento
Grafica Catalogo Gioielli in oro e ArgentoGrafica Catalogo Gioielli in oro e Argento
Grafica Catalogo Gioielli in oro e Argento
 
Awareness keywords-dec-2010
Awareness keywords-dec-2010Awareness keywords-dec-2010
Awareness keywords-dec-2010
 
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010
Ascens project-introduction-dec-2010
 
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systems
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music SystemsSelf-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systems
Self-aware and Self-expressive Active Music Systems
 
Marr spresentation97katyupdate
Marr spresentation97katyupdateMarr spresentation97katyupdate
Marr spresentation97katyupdate
 
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism Victoria
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism VictoriaDigital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism Victoria
Digital Trends & Opportunities - Tourism Victoria
 

Ähnlich wie Sapere project-introduction-dec-2010

Australian Ecosystems Science Cloud
Australian Ecosystems Science CloudAustralian Ecosystems Science Cloud
Australian Ecosystems Science CloudTERN Australia
 
Australia's Environmental Predictive Capability
Australia's Environmental Predictive CapabilityAustralia's Environmental Predictive Capability
Australia's Environmental Predictive CapabilityTERN Australia
 
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...Platforma Otwartej Nauki
 
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDP
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDPIPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDP
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDPFabio Corubolo
 
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Enrico Motta
 
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...Platforma Otwartej Nauki
 
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approach
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approachCinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approach
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approachCBOD ANR project U-PSUD
 
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...tobold
 
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...Sebastian Dennerlein
 
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage networkEnno Meijers
 
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - Introduction
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - IntroductionPERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - Introduction
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - IntroductionPERICLES_FP7
 
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...eMadrid network
 
20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project
 20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project 20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project
20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA projectOpenAIRE
 
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the Campus
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the CampusRelationship Building and Advocacy Across the Campus
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the CampusUCD Library
 
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)Daniel S. Katz
 
Transforming knowledge management for climate action
Transforming knowledge management for climate action  Transforming knowledge management for climate action
Transforming knowledge management for climate action weADAPT
 

Ähnlich wie Sapere project-introduction-dec-2010 (20)

Academic Course: 13 Applications of and Challenges in Self-Awareness
Academic Course: 13 Applications of and Challenges in Self-AwarenessAcademic Course: 13 Applications of and Challenges in Self-Awareness
Academic Course: 13 Applications of and Challenges in Self-Awareness
 
Australian Ecosystems Science Cloud
Australian Ecosystems Science CloudAustralian Ecosystems Science Cloud
Australian Ecosystems Science Cloud
 
Australia's Environmental Predictive Capability
Australia's Environmental Predictive CapabilityAustralia's Environmental Predictive Capability
Australia's Environmental Predictive Capability
 
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...
Enabling Re-Use and Sustainability: The role of information infrastructure fu...
 
African Open Science Platform
African Open Science PlatformAfrican Open Science Platform
African Open Science Platform
 
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDP
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDPIPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDP
IPRES 2014 paper presentation: significant environment information for LTDP
 
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
Research in Intelligent Systems and Data Science at the Knowledge Media Insti...
 
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...
Linking Heterogeneous Scholarly Data Sources in an Interoperable Setting: the...
 
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approach
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approachCinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approach
Cinzia Battistella; Modeling a business ecosystem: a network analysis approach
 
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
 
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
 
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
 
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - Introduction
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - IntroductionPERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - Introduction
PERICLES workshop (London 15 October 2015) - Introduction
 
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...
2015 03 19 (EDUCON2015) eMadrid UPM Towards a Learning Analytics Approach for...
 
20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project
 20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project 20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project
20190527_Karen Hytteballe Ibanez _ The OPERA project
 
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the Campus
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the CampusRelationship Building and Advocacy Across the Campus
Relationship Building and Advocacy Across the Campus
 
FAIR play?
FAIR play? FAIR play?
FAIR play?
 
Data, Infrastructures and Public Policy
Data, Infrastructures and Public PolicyData, Infrastructures and Public Policy
Data, Infrastructures and Public Policy
 
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)
Open Source and Science at the National Science Foundation (NSF)
 
Transforming knowledge management for climate action
Transforming knowledge management for climate action  Transforming knowledge management for climate action
Transforming knowledge management for climate action
 

Mehr von awarenessproject

Immunity in Self-Aware Systems
Immunity in Self-Aware SystemsImmunity in Self-Aware Systems
Immunity in Self-Aware Systemsawarenessproject
 
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organization
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organizationReconciling self-adaptation and self-organization
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organizationawarenessproject
 
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010awarenessproject
 
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010awarenessproject
 
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010awarenessproject
 
Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010awarenessproject
 

Mehr von awarenessproject (7)

Immunity in Self-Aware Systems
Immunity in Self-Aware SystemsImmunity in Self-Aware Systems
Immunity in Self-Aware Systems
 
Mvs handout
Mvs handoutMvs handout
Mvs handout
 
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organization
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organizationReconciling self-adaptation and self-organization
Reconciling self-adaptation and self-organization
 
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
 
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
Awareness Inaugural Meeting Amsterdam 2010
 
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010
Inaugural awareness-meeting-dec-2010
 
Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010
 

Sapere project-introduction-dec-2010

  • 1. SAPERE: Self‐aware Pervasive  Service Ecosystems Franco Zambonelli Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia STREP – 3 years www.sapere‐project.eu www sapere‐project eu AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 1
  • 2. The Consortium The Consortium • Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia – Franco Zambonelli & Marco Mamei Franco Zambonelli & Marco Mamei • Birkbeck College University of London – Giovanna Di Marzo Serugendo Giovanna Di Marzo • Alma Mater Studiorum – Università di Bologna – Mirko Viroli & Andrea Omicini • St. Andrews University – Simon Dobson • Johannes Kepler Universitaet Linz p – Alois Ferscha AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 2
  • 3. The Scenario The Scenario • Pervasive computing – Sensor rich and always connected smart phones  – Sensor networks and information tags – Localization and activity recognition – Internet of things and the real‐time Web Internet of things and the real time Web • Innovative pervasive services arising – Situation‐aware adaptation Situation aware adaptation  – Interactive reality  – Pervasive collective intelligence and pervasive participation • Open co‐production scenario, very dynamic, diverse  needs and diverse services, continuously evolving AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 3
  • 4. The Overall Objective The Overall Objective • Develop and demonstrate a highly‐innovative  theoretical and practical framework for pervasive  service ecosystems service ecosystems – Adaptivity and self‐management as inherent properties of  the ecosystem y – Systemic self‐awareness as an observable property of the  overall system – Long lasting (eternal) adaptivity Long‐lasting (eternal) adaptivity – Bio‐chemical inspiration • Foundational re‐thinking of Foundational re thinking of – Service architectures and associated middleware – Self‐* algorithms and contextual knowledge management AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 4
  • 5. The Architectural Approach The Architectural Approach • Open production model • Smooth data/services  distinction – LSA  live semantic  annotations • Interactions Interactions   – Sorts of bio‐chemical reactions  among components – In a spatial substrate In a spatial substrate • Eco‐laws  – Rule all interactions – Discovery + orchestration + orchestration  seamlessly merged • Built over a pervasive network  world AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 5
  • 6. Specific Objectives Specific Objectives • Both of a scientific and technological nature • Around which the various WPs are organized AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 6
  • 7. Model, Structures, and Knowledge Model Structures and Knowledge • M d l & M th d l Model & Methodology – Innovative chemical‐inspired semantic model for interactions among  components and their dynamic composition/aggregation – S Semantic (LSA) description and semantic pattern‐ mathing ti (LSA) d i ti d ti tt thi – Uniform traitment of data and services – Methodological guidelines associated • Structures & Space – Model distributed self‐* algorithms via the chemical LSA framework – Innovative flexible means for aggregation and composition gg g p – Define decentralized means to control the behaviour of the ecosystem • Knowledge & Time – Distributed knowledge management algorithms via the LSA framework Distributed knowledge management algorithms via the LSA framework – Define new means to perform distributed recognition of current situations – As well as to enable recognition of future situations AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 7
  • 8. Key Challenges y g for model, structure and knowledge • C Can our chemically‐inspired computation model and the  h i ll i i d t ti d l d th eco‐laws? – Be flexible and general‐purpose enough? g p p g – Effectively deal with the complexity and diversity of modern pervasive scenarios? – Be effectively implementable? Be effectively • And, for structure and knowledge – Can it accommodate all needed distributed aggregation and  self‐composition algorthims lf iti l thi – Can it express all needed forms of knowledge management? • Or should we rather go for application‐specific (or location‐ Or should go for application specific (or location specific) eco‐laws? AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 8
  • 9. Infrastructure and Applications Infrastructure and Applications • I f t t Infrastructure – A very lightweight infrastructure – Ruling all interactions (from discovery to data exchange and  synchronization) by embedding the concept of eco‐laws h i ti ) b b ddi th t f l – To most extent, acting as a recommendation and planning engine – Possibly inspired by tuple space coordination models – Yet made it more “fluid” and suitable for a pervasive computing  continuum substrate  not a network but a continuum of tuple spaces • Applications – The “Ecosystem of Display” as a general and impactful testbed – To put at work and demonstrate the SAPERE findings p g – Active and dynamic information sharing in urban scenarios – Active participation of citizens to the working of the urban infrastructure AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 9
  • 10. Key Tangible Results y g (hopefully) • A novel model and methodology to support the development  of complex service systems in open and dynamic pervasive  scenarios • A uniform set of: – Self‐* algorithms for service/data composition and aggregation (in  the form of libraries) th f f lib i ) – Algorithms and tools for distributed management of contextual‐ knowledge, to enforce present‐ and future‐awareness in the  ecosystem • A novel middleware for pervasive computing scenarios (Open  Source) ) – Integrating the stated algorithms in the form of libraries • A set of released innovative application showcased on the  Ecosystem of Displays testbed  E t f Di l t tb d AWARE Meeting ‐ December 14, 2010 10