3. Prohibited Activities
Hire, Fire, Retaliate, Term/Condition, Impact
Most Common
• Race, Sex, Age, Religion
Less Common
• Gender, Pregnancy, Family Responsibility
• National Origin, Color
• Military Status, Unemployment
• LGBT/Transgender, Associational
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
4. Examples of Protected Activity
• Obvious ones: sex and race
• Filing charge of discrimination with EEOC / OCRC
• Complaining to management about alleged
discrimination
• Serving as witness in discrimination investigation,
hearing, judicial proceeding
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
5. BFOQ Exception
• Only if characteristic is intrinsic to the job
• Must prove that no member of the group
discriminated against can perform the job
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
6. OCRC v EEOC
OCRC = Ohio Civil Rights Commission
EEOC = Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
Need to file charge with one of these agencies
before filing complaint in court (usually)
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
7. Legal Standard for Discrimination
Prima facie case:
McDonnell Douglas burden shifting analysis
1. Belongs to the protected class
2. Qualified for the job
3. Suffered an adverse employment action
4. Replaced by person outside class or treated less favorably than
similarly situated person
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
8. Legal Standard for Discrimination
Burden Shifts to Defendant
Prove legitimate non-discriminatory reason for the action
Burden Shifts to Plaintiff
Prove defendant’s reasons for the action were pretextual
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
9. Trends in Discrimination
Pregnancy
• Ohio recently passed 12 unpaid weeks
• Light duty if needed
• Eligible first day of work
Military
• Not hiring because of risk of being deployed
• Unemployed upon return from active duty
Religion
• All things Muslim
• Challenging religions upon first hearing about them
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
10. Attorney Tips
Representing Employers Representing Employees
• Have anti-discrimination • Is there an anti-discrimination
policies policy (handbook?)
• Apply employment policies • Seek out similarly situated
employees
consistently
• Determine how/when
• Provide regular training offender was last trained
• Don’t inflate ratings in • Compare reviews of non-
reviews protected employees
11. Social Media and
Employment Law
Employer Concerns
• Productivity
• Reputational Management
• Confidential / Trade Secrets
• Discrimination / Harassment Claims
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
12. Social Media in Litigation
Generally relevant info on social networking sites are
admissible evidence
Discovery has become tedious, expensive
Social media used to
• refute claims of emotional distress
• refute overtime hours
• prove violations of confidentiality / non-solicitation agreements
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
13. Social Media and ESI
Social media is considered electronically stored
information
Cost in retrieval may be shifted to the requesting or
requested party
Duty to preserve
Model Rule 1.3 may put affirmative duty on attorney to ask client for
social media up front
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
14. Social Media Policies
Hot topic right now
Social Media not generally covered in computer
use / IT policies
Tips on how to create and implement policy in
handout
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
15. NLRA Applies to Non-Union
Workplaces, Too
What is the NLRA
• Governs collective bargaining relationship of private
companies and unions
•Encourages employees to form, join, assist labor unions
• Protects employees who engage in “concerted activity”
for “mutual aid or protection”
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
16. Unlawful Under NLRA
To interfere with, restrain, coerce, discharge, or
otherwise discriminate against employees in the
exercise of their NLRA rights
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
17. NLRA Applies to Handbooks
Policies cannot prohibit employees’ ability to
engage in concerted activity
• Wages, discipline, working conditions
• No solicitation (leafletting, Girl Scout cookies)
• Employee committees
• Cannot refuse to hire based on union affiliation
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
18. NLRA Applies to
Union Organizing Drives
What employers cannot do:
Threaten
Interrogate
Promise
Surveillance
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
19. NLRA Applies to
Union Organizing Drives
What employers can do:
• Tell employees the company doesn’t want a union and why
• Provide factually accurate information (dues, rules, strike history)
• Explain changes that could result from becoming unionized
• Compare wages/benefits the union has with other companies
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
20. NLRA Applies to Social Media
Major movement
Posts involving working conditions and other
employees seem to be covered (usually)
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
21. NLRA Applies to Social Media
OK to do the following:
• Call boss “scumbag”
• Complain that BMW dealership offered hot dogs and chips at
event
• Post/Respond “A coworker feels that we don’t help our
clients enough at HUB. I about had it! My fellow coworkers
how do you feel?”
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
22. NLRA Applies to Social Media
Not ok to do the following:
• For reporter to tweet “Stay away Tucson” in response to city’s homicide rate
• For employee to post “Wuck Falmart! I swear if this tyranny doesn’t end in
this store they are about to get a wake up call because lots are about to quit”
• To have SM policy prohibiting employee conduct that disregarded any
person’s privacy and confidentiality or that may damage the reputation of the
employer, staff, or employees
• To have blogging policy that prohibited confidential and proprietary
information or inappropriate discussions about employer, management, or
coworkers
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
23. NLRA Disclaimer in Social Media
Policy
“Nothing in this Policy is intended to or will be
applied in a manner that limits employees’ rights to
engage in protected concerted activity as
prescribed by the National Labor Relations Act.”
May help
Matt Austin 614-734-0000 Matt.Austin@Austin-Legal.com
Hinweis der Redaktion
I included draft ROGS and RPFDs in the materials
Include all electronic devices, cover all forms of social media, get signed acknowledgement of policy, pre-approval for use of logos?