SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 13
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Towards preaching what is practiced?
From practices to possibilities for living with flood in
         rural area of Bangladesh delta




                 Mahmuda Mutahara
                   PhD Candidate
           Wageningen University, Netherlands
               Date: 2 December 2012
Project Background
 Poverty and hunger
   Social insecurity
 Social and institutional
          conflict
 Ecological disruption
Focus Area

                  Region:
                  South-west
                  Districts:
                  Jessore,
                  Khulna,
                     South-
                     Western
                   Satkhira
                     Region

SATKHIRA
                  River System:
                  Upper Bhadra,
                  Hari, Kobadak,
                  Bhairab
Behind the Problem

 Frequent cyclone and storm
  surges
 Un available upstream flow
  from Ganges River
 Changing nature of tidal
  action
 Shifting pattern of seasonal
  rainfall
 Structural Interventions
(Coastal Embankment and polder)
Problem Statement
Objectives
Innovate a learning process and contribute for strengthening rural
community resilience


i)     Identify peoples’ perception to flood and changes in livelihoods

ii)    Show the relationship/gap between water management system
       and community practise
iii)   Compare community views to WMP in Bangladesh and Dutch
       delta

iv) Develop an indicator framework to assess community resilience

i)     Innovate a Multi Actor Learning Approach to enhance community
       resilience
Main Research Questions


                Research Sub - Questions
   How do people define the flood culture in SW area of Bangladesh delta?

   How do water management initiatives influence the livelihoods and
    community development in such flood vulnerable rural coastal area?

   What is the community view and how do they respond to practiced water
    management system in Bangladesh and Dutch delta in terms of future
    climate vulnerability?

   How does community resilience be assessed in a flood vulnerable rural
    area of Bangladesh delta?

   How does a knowledge approach contribute to enhance the community
    resilience in rural delta of Bangladesh in context of climate risk?
General Research Concept
                   Definition:
                    Issue and vulnerability


Integration:                              Interaction:
  Integrate social, economic,               Community, management
environmental factors                     options, Policy maker (different
                                          level of actor)


                 Identification:
                   Current capacity to cope with climate
                   change (level of resilience)


                 Innovation:
                 Knowledge to community level capacity
                 enhancement
Data Collection:
      Literature review/institutional survey
      Participatory Rural Appraisal
            Mobility map
            Social Map (Village map)
            Group Discussion or FSM
            Actors dialogue and feed back
       Questionnaire survey
       Case studies
       Interview with experts and agencies
Study Components


       Development of MASL framework

          Assess community resilience
             (Using DROP Model)

       Identification of resilience factor for
                       locality
         Comparative analysis between
        community view and response to
             WM in BD and NL
        Identification impact to livelihood
                      system

       Review and scenario generation of
          certain issue (flood & water
                     logging)
Work Plan
            Period                 Place                       Proposed activities

From March to August 2012       The           Attending courses and work on research proposal,
                                Netherlands   literature review
From September 2012 to          Bangladesh    First field visit: defining study area; Secondary
February 2013                                 information collection; Institutional survey and data
                                              collection
From March to May 2013          The           Reviewing information gathered and draft of first and
                                Netherlands   second articles
From June 2013 to February 2014 Bangladesh    Second field visit: Questioners survey, Stakeholder
                                              consultation
From March to May 2014          The           Review of collected data, data analysis and draft of 3rd
                                Netherlands   articles
From June 2014 to August 2015   Bangladesh    Final field visit: FGD and stakeholder workshop; data
                                              analysis and report writing
From September 2015 to          The           Reviewing previous articles and writing final thesis
February 2016                   Netherlands
Towards Preaching What is Practiced? Community Resilience in Bangladesh's Flood-Prone Deltas

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshop
piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshoppiloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshop
piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake WorkshopWater, Land and Ecosystems (WLE)
 
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE Initiative
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE InitiativeEnhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE Initiative
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE InitiativeGlobal Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...practicalanswerssl
 
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...weADAPT
 
Irrigation futures - Role of community participation and partnerships
Irrigation futures  - Role of community participation and partnershipsIrrigation futures  - Role of community participation and partnerships
Irrigation futures - Role of community participation and partnershipsChristina Parmionova
 
FinalReportFall2009_LB
FinalReportFall2009_LBFinalReportFall2009_LB
FinalReportFall2009_LBLydia Bi
 
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...Global Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...Global Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…weADAPT
 
Sustainable Uplands Results Presentation
Sustainable Uplands Results PresentationSustainable Uplands Results Presentation
Sustainable Uplands Results PresentationMark Reed
 
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9Brady Mattsson
 
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesResilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesThe Rockefeller Foundation
 
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influence
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of InfluenceWatersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influence
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influencetlclapp2
 
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...Rahul Mitra
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshop
piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshoppiloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshop
piloting and upscaling of mus - IWMI/WRC Research Uptake Workshop
 
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE Initiative
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE InitiativeEnhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE Initiative
Enhancing urban resilience to extreme waters: The WASH and RESCUE Initiative
 
IWRM Methodology and Guidelines for SIDS
IWRM Methodology and Guidelines for SIDSIWRM Methodology and Guidelines for SIDS
IWRM Methodology and Guidelines for SIDS
 
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...
Decision support system for Local Level Agencies and Communities Disaster Ris...
 
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...
A transdisciplinary approach to understanding complex social problems in coas...
 
Irrigation futures - Role of community participation and partnerships
Irrigation futures  - Role of community participation and partnershipsIrrigation futures  - Role of community participation and partnerships
Irrigation futures - Role of community participation and partnerships
 
FinalReportFall2009_LB
FinalReportFall2009_LBFinalReportFall2009_LB
FinalReportFall2009_LB
 
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...
Managed Retreat for Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction A C...
 
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...
Resilience of Urban Communities in a Changing Climate and Environment-Focus o...
 
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…
WD-NACE approaches to meaningful inclusion. By Ms. Nilufar Matin from SEI…
 
Wells Case Study
Wells Case StudyWells Case Study
Wells Case Study
 
Preserving Our Great Lakes: How Do we Adapt As they Change?
Preserving Our Great Lakes: How Do we Adapt As they Change?Preserving Our Great Lakes: How Do we Adapt As they Change?
Preserving Our Great Lakes: How Do we Adapt As they Change?
 
Community adaptation to flooding in a changing climate
Community adaptation to flooding in a changing climateCommunity adaptation to flooding in a changing climate
Community adaptation to flooding in a changing climate
 
Sustainable Uplands Results Presentation
Sustainable Uplands Results PresentationSustainable Uplands Results Presentation
Sustainable Uplands Results Presentation
 
Dutch Support to Bangladesh: Past and the Future
Dutch Support to Bangladesh: Past and the FutureDutch Support to Bangladesh: Past and the Future
Dutch Support to Bangladesh: Past and the Future
 
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9
Webinar 1 sdm_overview_final_2013_9_9
 
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal CitiesResilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
Resilience By Design: The Future of Coastal Cities
 
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influence
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of InfluenceWatersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influence
Watersheds Forum: Challenges and Points of Influence
 
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...
Institute for Social Change 2020 Keynote: Rethinking both "Public" and "Schol...
 
2 recovery guidelines
2 recovery guidelines2 recovery guidelines
2 recovery guidelines
 

Ähnlich wie Towards Preaching What is Practiced? Community Resilience in Bangladesh's Flood-Prone Deltas

Knowledge Mobilization and Social Innovation
Knowledge Mobilization and Social InnovationKnowledge Mobilization and Social Innovation
Knowledge Mobilization and Social InnovationKMb Unit, York University
 
Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.
 Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum. Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.
Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.energybiographies
 
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...Shahadat Hossain Shakil
 
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...Aberdeen CES
 
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open Space
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open SpaceParticipation in the Planning and Design of Public Open Space
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open SpaceJulie Meyer
 
Williams nccsc adaption workshop
Williams nccsc adaption workshopWilliams nccsc adaption workshop
Williams nccsc adaption workshopNC_CSC
 
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan PlanEvaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan PlanMatthew Cashmore
 
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen Science
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen ScienceThe Evolving Landscape of Citizen Science
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen ScienceAndrea Wiggins
 
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash SaciWATERs
 
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...CGIAR
 
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In Geography
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In GeographyApplying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In Geography
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In GeographyWendy Berg
 
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory research
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory researchDoing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory research
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory researchSustainabilityStudiesUHI
 
Workshop e-participation Bahia-Potenza
Workshop e-participation Bahia-PotenzaWorkshop e-participation Bahia-Potenza
Workshop e-participation Bahia-PotenzaGilberto Corso Pereira
 
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT project
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT projectPreliminary research work from the EcoADAPT project
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT projectweADAPT
 
Gender approaches in the COBAM project
Gender approaches in the COBAM projectGender approaches in the COBAM project
Gender approaches in the COBAM projectCIFOR-ICRAF
 
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...Södertörn University
 
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World Congress
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World CongressModel Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World Congress
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World CongressJosique Lorenzo Lemire
 
Stakeholders mapping in_community_based
Stakeholders mapping in_community_basedStakeholders mapping in_community_based
Stakeholders mapping in_community_basedZaid Perdana
 
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011Jayne Glass
 

Ähnlich wie Towards Preaching What is Practiced? Community Resilience in Bangladesh's Flood-Prone Deltas (20)

Knowledge Mobilization and Social Innovation
Knowledge Mobilization and Social InnovationKnowledge Mobilization and Social Innovation
Knowledge Mobilization and Social Innovation
 
Silka Plenary PPSR2012
Silka Plenary PPSR2012Silka Plenary PPSR2012
Silka Plenary PPSR2012
 
Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.
 Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum. Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.
Long-lived teams working across the primary-secondary analysis spectrum.
 
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...
Public Participation and Lay Knowledge in Environmental Governance: A Case St...
 
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...
Towards a systematic framework for analysis of tools and approaches to integr...
 
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open Space
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open SpaceParticipation in the Planning and Design of Public Open Space
Participation in the Planning and Design of Public Open Space
 
Williams nccsc adaption workshop
Williams nccsc adaption workshopWilliams nccsc adaption workshop
Williams nccsc adaption workshop
 
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan PlanEvaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
 
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen Science
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen ScienceThe Evolving Landscape of Citizen Science
The Evolving Landscape of Citizen Science
 
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash
Scoping Study_Dr. Anjal Prakash
 
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...
Designing options to narrow gender gaps in agricultural value chains using a ...
 
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In Geography
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In GeographyApplying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In Geography
Applying Pedagogies To Wicked Problems In Geography
 
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory research
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory researchDoing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory research
Doing things differently: Re-evaluating our role in participatory research
 
Workshop e-participation Bahia-Potenza
Workshop e-participation Bahia-PotenzaWorkshop e-participation Bahia-Potenza
Workshop e-participation Bahia-Potenza
 
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT project
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT projectPreliminary research work from the EcoADAPT project
Preliminary research work from the EcoADAPT project
 
Gender approaches in the COBAM project
Gender approaches in the COBAM projectGender approaches in the COBAM project
Gender approaches in the COBAM project
 
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...
Community-based social learning interventions: conceptual and methodological ...
 
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World Congress
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World CongressModel Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World Congress
Model Forests, Social and political impacts, by Josique, IUFRO World Congress
 
Stakeholders mapping in_community_based
Stakeholders mapping in_community_basedStakeholders mapping in_community_based
Stakeholders mapping in_community_based
 
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011
Jayne Glass Knowledge Coproduction Seminar July 2011
 

Towards Preaching What is Practiced? Community Resilience in Bangladesh's Flood-Prone Deltas

  • 1. Towards preaching what is practiced? From practices to possibilities for living with flood in rural area of Bangladesh delta Mahmuda Mutahara PhD Candidate Wageningen University, Netherlands Date: 2 December 2012
  • 3.  Poverty and hunger  Social insecurity  Social and institutional conflict  Ecological disruption
  • 4. Focus Area Region: South-west Districts: Jessore, Khulna, South- Western Satkhira Region SATKHIRA River System: Upper Bhadra, Hari, Kobadak, Bhairab
  • 5. Behind the Problem  Frequent cyclone and storm surges  Un available upstream flow from Ganges River  Changing nature of tidal action  Shifting pattern of seasonal rainfall  Structural Interventions (Coastal Embankment and polder)
  • 7. Objectives Innovate a learning process and contribute for strengthening rural community resilience i) Identify peoples’ perception to flood and changes in livelihoods ii) Show the relationship/gap between water management system and community practise iii) Compare community views to WMP in Bangladesh and Dutch delta iv) Develop an indicator framework to assess community resilience i) Innovate a Multi Actor Learning Approach to enhance community resilience
  • 8. Main Research Questions Research Sub - Questions  How do people define the flood culture in SW area of Bangladesh delta?  How do water management initiatives influence the livelihoods and community development in such flood vulnerable rural coastal area?  What is the community view and how do they respond to practiced water management system in Bangladesh and Dutch delta in terms of future climate vulnerability?  How does community resilience be assessed in a flood vulnerable rural area of Bangladesh delta?  How does a knowledge approach contribute to enhance the community resilience in rural delta of Bangladesh in context of climate risk?
  • 9. General Research Concept Definition: Issue and vulnerability Integration: Interaction: Integrate social, economic, Community, management environmental factors options, Policy maker (different level of actor) Identification: Current capacity to cope with climate change (level of resilience) Innovation: Knowledge to community level capacity enhancement
  • 10. Data Collection:  Literature review/institutional survey  Participatory Rural Appraisal  Mobility map  Social Map (Village map)  Group Discussion or FSM  Actors dialogue and feed back  Questionnaire survey  Case studies  Interview with experts and agencies
  • 11. Study Components Development of MASL framework Assess community resilience (Using DROP Model) Identification of resilience factor for locality Comparative analysis between community view and response to WM in BD and NL Identification impact to livelihood system Review and scenario generation of certain issue (flood & water logging)
  • 12. Work Plan Period Place Proposed activities From March to August 2012 The Attending courses and work on research proposal, Netherlands literature review From September 2012 to Bangladesh First field visit: defining study area; Secondary February 2013 information collection; Institutional survey and data collection From March to May 2013 The Reviewing information gathered and draft of first and Netherlands second articles From June 2013 to February 2014 Bangladesh Second field visit: Questioners survey, Stakeholder consultation From March to May 2014 The Review of collected data, data analysis and draft of 3rd Netherlands articles From June 2014 to August 2015 Bangladesh Final field visit: FGD and stakeholder workshop; data analysis and report writing From September 2015 to The Reviewing previous articles and writing final thesis February 2016 Netherlands