SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 28
Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases Experts, Discovery, and Learned Treatises
Introduction  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Focus  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
Overview  ,[object Object],Experts Treatises SOAH Facts Witness
Presentation Map ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost/Benefit Analysis of Designating an Expert ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Who is an expert? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Do you really need an expert? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
One more case… ,[object Object],[object Object]
Dealing with the Opposing Expert ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Expert Testimony Offered by Non-Experts ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
Opposing Party as Fact Witness v. Expert ,[object Object],[object Object]
Require Opposing Experts to be Properly Designated ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
An Expert’s Effect on Discovery ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Preparing Experts for Discovery ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
More Preparation Tips ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Consequences of Discovery Errors
Aggressive Discovery ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Failure by a  witness  to keep documents that may be discoverable can result in sanctions.  Trevino, M.D. v. Ortega,  969 S.W.2d 950 (Tex. 1998).
Evidence spoliation is not a new concept. For years courts have struggled with the problem and devised possible solutions.  Probably the earliest and most enduring solution was the spoliation inference or  omnia praesumuntur contra spoliatorem :……
… All things are presumed against a wrongdoer . ,[object Object]
Use of Learned Treatises TRE 803 Hearsay Exception ,[object Object]
Exxon Corp. v. Makofski, 116 S.W.3d 176, 188 (Tex. App.--Houston [14th Dist.] 2003, pet. denied) ,[object Object]
State Office of Risk Mgmt. v. Larkins ,  258 S.W.3d 686 , Tex.App. Waco  2008 ,[object Object]
Tips for Dealing with Learned Treatises ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Summary ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...
SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...
SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...SterneKessler
 
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11Eric Rudich, Ph.D.
 
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Case
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The CaseThe Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Case
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Caseeratinoff
 
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?Karl Larson
 
Using terms of approximation
Using terms of approximationUsing terms of approximation
Using terms of approximationLev Rosenblum
 
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...Knobbe Martens - Intellectual Property Law
 
HT_Writing Sample
HT_Writing SampleHT_Writing Sample
HT_Writing SampleHenry Tran
 
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...Knobbe Martens - Intellectual Property Law
 
Federal Rules of Evidence Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"
Federal Rules of Evidence  Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"Federal Rules of Evidence  Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"
Federal Rules of Evidence Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"Litig8or
 
The Expert Witnesses
The Expert WitnessesThe Expert Witnesses
The Expert Witnessesalisonegypt
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizurerlhicksjr
 
Become Patent-smart Entrepreneur
Become Patent-smart EntrepreneurBecome Patent-smart Entrepreneur
Become Patent-smart Entrepreneurhemantchaskar
 
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the world
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the worldTerra lex guide to tracing assets around the world
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the worldMarlen Estévez Sanz
 

Was ist angesagt? (15)

Remedies in the Federal Court
Remedies in the Federal CourtRemedies in the Federal Court
Remedies in the Federal Court
 
SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...
SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...
SKGF_Advisory_Preparing and Prosecuting a Patent that Holds up in Litigation_...
 
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11
Rudich Landslide Article Jan '11
 
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Case
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The CaseThe Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Case
The Expert's Role In Developing And Proving The Case
 
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?
Patents on Software and Business Methods: Have the Rules Changed?
 
Using terms of approximation
Using terms of approximationUsing terms of approximation
Using terms of approximation
 
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...
Current State of the U.S. Patent Law: Risk Mitigation Based on Legal Opinions...
 
HT_Writing Sample
HT_Writing SampleHT_Writing Sample
HT_Writing Sample
 
Post-KSR Obviousness
Post-KSR ObviousnessPost-KSR Obviousness
Post-KSR Obviousness
 
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...
Overview of Patent Litigation in the United States – Knobbe Practice Webinar ...
 
Federal Rules of Evidence Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"
Federal Rules of Evidence  Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"Federal Rules of Evidence  Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"
Federal Rules of Evidence Restyled, December 1, 2011 "PowerPoint"
 
The Expert Witnesses
The Expert WitnessesThe Expert Witnesses
The Expert Witnesses
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
 
Become Patent-smart Entrepreneur
Become Patent-smart EntrepreneurBecome Patent-smart Entrepreneur
Become Patent-smart Entrepreneur
 
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the world
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the worldTerra lex guide to tracing assets around the world
Terra lex guide to tracing assets around the world
 

Andere mochten auch

Andere mochten auch (6)

Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases
Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law CasesLitigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases
Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases
 
The Power Of Pr 11 08
The Power Of Pr  11 08The Power Of Pr  11 08
The Power Of Pr 11 08
 
Disqualifying Judge
Disqualifying JudgeDisqualifying Judge
Disqualifying Judge
 
Electronic Evidence Power Point V6 Final
Electronic Evidence Power Point V6 FinalElectronic Evidence Power Point V6 Final
Electronic Evidence Power Point V6 Final
 
File000116
File000116File000116
File000116
 
Las tics y Minsa
Las tics y MinsaLas tics y Minsa
Las tics y Minsa
 

Ähnlich wie Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases: Experts, Discovery, and Learned Treatises

Deposing The Opposing Expert Witness
Deposing The Opposing Expert WitnessDeposing The Opposing Expert Witness
Deposing The Opposing Expert WitnessGerry Schulze
 
The Changing Role Of The Experts
The Changing Role Of The ExpertsThe Changing Role Of The Experts
The Changing Role Of The Expertsalisonegypt
 
The changing role of the experts
The changing role of the expertsThe changing role of the experts
The changing role of the expertsAlison Stevens
 
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert Witness
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert WitnessEthics And The Trial Consultant And Expert Witness
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert WitnessCTIN
 
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...Prof Niamh M. Brennan
 
Daubert and it’s implications
Daubert and it’s implicationsDaubert and it’s implications
Daubert and it’s implicationsMahipreet Kaur
 
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...Howie, Sacks & Henry
 
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In Arizona
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In ArizonaThe Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In Arizona
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In ArizonaWeinberger Law Firm
 
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First CenturyWoodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Centuryjohn Kelly
 
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decision
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decisionDoes an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decision
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decisionGerald R. (Jerry) Genge
 
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docx
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docxChapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docx
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docxwalterl4
 
Evidence
EvidenceEvidence
EvidenceAraksya
 
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)   The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020) Financial Poise
 
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsResponding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsNexsen Pruet
 
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbingGraham Hain
 
Lecture 5_ Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdf
Lecture 5_  Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdfLecture 5_  Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdf
Lecture 5_ Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdfAlhattalizo
 
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)Financial Poise
 

Ähnlich wie Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases: Experts, Discovery, and Learned Treatises (20)

Deposing The Opposing Expert Witness
Deposing The Opposing Expert WitnessDeposing The Opposing Expert Witness
Deposing The Opposing Expert Witness
 
The Changing Role Of The Experts
The Changing Role Of The ExpertsThe Changing Role Of The Experts
The Changing Role Of The Experts
 
The changing role of the experts
The changing role of the expertsThe changing role of the experts
The changing role of the experts
 
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert Witness
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert WitnessEthics And The Trial Consultant And Expert Witness
Ethics And The Trial Consultant And Expert Witness
 
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...
Brennan, Niamh [2005] Accounting Expertise in Litigation and Dispute Resoluti...
 
Expert Testimony - Gangs
Expert Testimony - GangsExpert Testimony - Gangs
Expert Testimony - Gangs
 
Daubert and it’s implications
Daubert and it’s implicationsDaubert and it’s implications
Daubert and it’s implications
 
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...
Expert Witnesses: The Who, What, When And How Of Retaining Experts And Making...
 
Who is an expert
Who is an expertWho is an expert
Who is an expert
 
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In Arizona
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In ArizonaThe Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In Arizona
The Anatomy Of A Civil Lawsuit In Arizona
 
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First CenturyWoodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
 
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decision
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decisionDoes an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decision
Does an arbitrator with subject matter expertise get a better decision
 
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docx
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docxChapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docx
Chapter 21 - The Investigator and the Legal System1.docx
 
Evidence
EvidenceEvidence
Evidence
 
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)   The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)
The Basics: Working With an Expert (Series: Valuation 2020)
 
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsResponding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
 
Chapter8
Chapter8Chapter8
Chapter8
 
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing
2010 02 - New Law Journal - Hot-tubbing
 
Lecture 5_ Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdf
Lecture 5_  Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdfLecture 5_  Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdf
Lecture 5_ Experts _ the Justice System – Prt 2.pdf
 
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)
Selecting the Right Valuation Expert (Series: Valuation)
 

Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases: Experts, Discovery, and Learned Treatises

  • 1. Litigation Tips for Complex Administrative Law Cases Experts, Discovery, and Learned Treatises
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.  
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.  
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 20.
  • 21. Failure by a witness to keep documents that may be discoverable can result in sanctions. Trevino, M.D. v. Ortega, 969 S.W.2d 950 (Tex. 1998).
  • 22. Evidence spoliation is not a new concept. For years courts have struggled with the problem and devised possible solutions. Probably the earliest and most enduring solution was the spoliation inference or omnia praesumuntur contra spoliatorem :……
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.