SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 23
The Synergy between Percutaneous Coronary Intervention with TAXUS and Cardiac Surgery: The SYNTAX StudyThe 3-year Outcomes of the SYNTAX Trial in the Subset of Patients With Left Main Disease Patrick W. Serruys, MD PhD Erasmus Medical Center On behalf of the SYNTAX investigators 6:00-6:10PM, Sept 21, 2010 Featured Clinical Research I Conflicts of Interest: None
Disclosure Statement of Financial Interest I, Patrick W. Serruys, DO NOT have a financial interest/arrangement or affiliation with one or more organizations that could be perceived as a real or apparent conflict of interest in the context of the subject of this presentation.
SYNTAX Study Objectives The SYNTAX randomized trial is an attempt to provide an evidence base to determine the most appropriate treatment option for patients in a ‘real-world’ population seen by the surgeon and the interventional cardiologist in their daily practice In 2009, the ACC-AHA PCI Guidelines were updated and raised LM stenting from Class III to Class IIb (level B)1 In 2010, ESC-EACTS Guidelines revised and upgraded LM (isolated or in conjuction with 1 vessel disease) stenting from Class IIb (level C) to IIa (level B)2 1Kushner et al. Circulation 2009; 120:2271-2306 2Wijns et al. EHJ 2010
Amenable for both treatment options Amenable for only one treatment approach Randomized Arms N=1800 Two Registry ArmsN=1275 SYNTAX Trial Design + 23 US Sites 62 EU Sites Heart Team (surgeon & interventional cardiologist) Stratification: LM and Diabetes PCI n=198 CABG n=1077 TAXUS* n=903 CABG n=897 vs LM n=348(33.7%) 3VDn=549 (66.3%) 3VD n=546 (65.4%) LMn=357(34.6%) *TAXUS Express
Patients in SYNTAXLeft Main (LM) Subset RCT: Enrolled N=705 CABG n=348 PCI n=357 RCT: 1 Year Follow-up N=691 (98.0%) CABG n=336 PCI n=355 RCT: 2 Year Follow-up N=683 (96.9%) CABG n=331 PCI n=352 RCT: 3 Year Follow-up N=674 (95.6%) CABG n=325 PCI n=349
Heterogeneity in the Left Main Group Left Main Isolated n=91 (13%) Left Main + 1VD Left Main + 3VD n=258 (37%) n=138 (20%) n=218 (31%) Left Main + 2VD Site-reported data
Patient CharacteristicsLM Subset Core laboratory reported unless *Site-reported
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 All-Cause Death to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.64 Before 1 year* 4.5% vs 4.2% P=0.88 1-2 years* 1.9% vs 1.5% P=0.68 2-3 years* 2.3% vs 1.8% P=0.67 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 8.4% 7.3% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 CVA to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.02 Before 1 year* 2.7% vs 0.3% P=0.009 1-2 years* 0.9% vs 0.6% P=0.68 2-3 years* 0.3% vs 0.3% P=1.00 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 4.0% 1.2% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 Myocardial Infarction to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.14 Before 1 year* 4.2% vs 4.2% P=0.97 1-2 years* 0.0% vs 1.2% P=0.12 2-3 years* 0.0% vs 1.5% P=0.06 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 6.9% 4.1% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 All-Cause Death/CVA/MI to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.60 Before 1 year* 9.2% vs 7.0% P=0.29 1-2 years* 2.8% vs 3.2% P=0.76 2-3 years* 2.6% vs 3.0% P=0.76 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 14.3% 13.0% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 Repeat Revascularization to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.004 Before 1 year* 6.5% vs 11.8% P=0.02 1-2 years* 5.0% vs 8.2% P=0.10 2-3 years* 2.6% vs 3.9% P=0.36 20.0% Cumulative Event Rate (%) 11.7% Repeat CABG: 1.7%   vs 5.6%,   P=0.01 Repeat PCI:     10.0% vs 16.2%, P=0.01 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 MACCE to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.20 Before 1 year* 13.7% vs 15.8% P=0.44 1-2 years* 7.5% vs 10.3% P=0.22 2-3 years* 5.2% vs 5.7% P=0.78 26.8% Cumulative Event Rate (%) 22.3% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
CABG(n=348) TAXUS(n=357) Symptomatic Graft Occlusion & Stent Thrombosis to 3 Years LM Subset P=0.80 Patients (%) n=12 n=14 CABG TAXUS Post-procedure; ITT population
MACCE to 3 Years in LM Subgroups TAXUS CABG P=0.20 P=0.52 P=0.33 P=0.09 P=0.20 Patients, % n=  348 357 49 42 122 136 106 112 71 67 All LM LM + 1VD LM Isolated LM + 2VD LM + 3VD Cumulative KM Event Rate; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
Distal 7% 4% 11% 35% 27% Nondistal 29% 61% 66% 59% Both Vessel Distribution in LM Population According to Syntax Score Terciles 33+ 0-22 23-32
CTO 29.6% Non-CTO Vessel Distribution in LM Population According to Syntax Score Terciles 5.9% 16.5% 33+ 0-22 23-32
CABG(N=104) TAXUS(N=118) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile Low Scores (0-22) Left Main > > P=0.33 23.0% < Cumulative Event Rate (%) 18.0% > < Months Since Allocation Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
CABG(N=92) TAXUS(N=103) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile Intermediate Scores (23-32) Left Main > > P=0.90 23.4% < 23.4% > < Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
CABG(N=149) TAXUS(N=135) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile  Left Main SYNTAX Score 33 Left Main Left Main < P=0.003 37.3% > < 21.2% < < Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
SummaryLeft Main Subset  At 3 years, overall MACCE in the PCI group was comparable with CABG (22.3% CABG vs 26.8% PCI) Similar overall safety outcomes (Death/CVA/MI) between CABG and PCI at 3 years (14.3% CABG vs 13.0% PCI) There was a higher rate of revascularization in the PCI group (11.7% CABG vs 20.0% PCI), and a higher rate of CVA in the CABG group (4.0% CABG vs 1.2% PCI) PCI outcomes are excellent relative to CABG in LM isolated and LM+1VD
Conclusions For patients with left main disease Revascularization with PCI has comparable safety and efficacy outcomes to CABG  PCI is therefore a reasonable treatment alternative in this patient population, in particular, when the SYNTAX Score is low (≤22) or intermediate (23-32)
1800 syntax lm

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie 1800 syntax lm

NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptx
NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptxNOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptx
NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptxIrving Torres Lopez
 
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market duality
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market dualityGetting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market duality
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market dualityGilbert Mbara
 
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOs
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOsLong-term outcome for patients with CTOs
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOsEuro CTO Club
 
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015Duff & Phelps
 
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit Webinar
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit WebinarA Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit Webinar
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit WebinarStratasan
 
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcoma
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue SarcomaPreoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcoma
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcomafondas vakalis
 
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?GRAPE
 
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung CancerYong Chan Ahn
 
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...trytonmedical
 
Rutger Ploeg - The Netherlands - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...
Rutger Ploeg  - The Netherlands  - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...Rutger Ploeg  - The Netherlands  - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...
Rutger Ploeg - The Netherlands - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...incucai_isodp
 
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...Peter J Stavroulakis
 
Published data on CTO complications
Published data on CTO complicationsPublished data on CTO complications
Published data on CTO complicationsEuro CTO Club
 
Macroeconomics and financial imbalances
Macroeconomics and financial imbalancesMacroeconomics and financial imbalances
Macroeconomics and financial imbalancesADEMU_Project
 
leaders_5y_presentation
leaders_5y_presentationleaders_5y_presentation
leaders_5y_presentationiveccc
 

Ähnlich wie 1800 syntax lm (20)

Saito S DRAGON trial
Saito S DRAGON trialSaito S DRAGON trial
Saito S DRAGON trial
 
NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptx
NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptxNOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptx
NOBLE LEFT MAIN BIFURCATION PCI.pptx
 
TCT 2010: COMPARE Trial
TCT 2010: COMPARE TrialTCT 2010: COMPARE Trial
TCT 2010: COMPARE Trial
 
Mann T 201110
Mann T 201110Mann T 201110
Mann T 201110
 
Macro Determinants of Mortality in Papua New Guinea
Macro Determinants of Mortality in Papua New GuineaMacro Determinants of Mortality in Papua New Guinea
Macro Determinants of Mortality in Papua New Guinea
 
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market duality
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market dualityGetting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market duality
Getting things right: optimal tax policy with labor market duality
 
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOs
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOsLong-term outcome for patients with CTOs
Long-term outcome for patients with CTOs
 
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015
Healthcare Sector Update - October 2015
 
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit Webinar
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit WebinarA Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit Webinar
A Comprehensive Approach to Service Line Growth: Product Line Toolkit Webinar
 
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcoma
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue SarcomaPreoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcoma
Preoperative Radiotherapy In Extremity Soft Tissue Sarcoma
 
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?
Does social security reform reduce gains from higher retirement age?
 
TNCS audit 2016
TNCS audit 2016TNCS audit 2016
TNCS audit 2016
 
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer
1411 APLCC AHNYC SBRT & IMRT in Lung Cancer
 
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...
P. Genereux, the tryton stent_dedicated bifurcation stent in coronary bifurca...
 
Rutger Ploeg - The Netherlands - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...
Rutger Ploeg  - The Netherlands  - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...Rutger Ploeg  - The Netherlands  - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...
Rutger Ploeg - The Netherlands - Tuesday 29 - Use of Perfusion Machines or ...
 
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...
The Impact of the Sovereign-Debt Crisis on the Financial Health of Greek List...
 
PCI & AimRadial 2018 | Experience with Left Main PCI by Radial Access - Zsolt...
PCI & AimRadial 2018 | Experience with Left Main PCI by Radial Access - Zsolt...PCI & AimRadial 2018 | Experience with Left Main PCI by Radial Access - Zsolt...
PCI & AimRadial 2018 | Experience with Left Main PCI by Radial Access - Zsolt...
 
Published data on CTO complications
Published data on CTO complicationsPublished data on CTO complications
Published data on CTO complications
 
Macroeconomics and financial imbalances
Macroeconomics and financial imbalancesMacroeconomics and financial imbalances
Macroeconomics and financial imbalances
 
leaders_5y_presentation
leaders_5y_presentationleaders_5y_presentation
leaders_5y_presentation
 

Mehr von TriMed Media Group

HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of Care
HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of CareHCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of Care
HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of CareTriMed Media Group
 
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018Forecast of Statin Market to 2018
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018TriMed Media Group
 
PCPs speak out on rad reporting
PCPs speak out on rad reportingPCPs speak out on rad reporting
PCPs speak out on rad reportingTriMed Media Group
 
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...TriMed Media Group
 
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...TriMed Media Group
 
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...TriMed Media Group
 
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam Kassing
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam KassingHow Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam Kassing
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam KassingTriMed Media Group
 
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun Krishnaraj
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun KrishnarajMeaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun Krishnaraj
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun KrishnarajTriMed Media Group
 
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid Coleman
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid ColemanCMIO Summit 2011 | Reid Coleman
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid ColemanTriMed Media Group
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin GrahamTriMed Media Group
 
2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran
2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran
2011 CMIO Summit | David CochranTriMed Media Group
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonoughTriMed Media Group
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha AgrawalTriMed Media Group
 

Mehr von TriMed Media Group (20)

2013 AMDIS Fall Symposium
2013 AMDIS Fall Symposium2013 AMDIS Fall Symposium
2013 AMDIS Fall Symposium
 
HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of Care
HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of CareHCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of Care
HCLF 2013: Evidence at the Center of Care
 
2012 CMIO Leadership Forum
2012 CMIO Leadership Forum2012 CMIO Leadership Forum
2012 CMIO Leadership Forum
 
UPenn Oregon Telestroke
UPenn Oregon Telestroke UPenn Oregon Telestroke
UPenn Oregon Telestroke
 
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018Forecast of Statin Market to 2018
Forecast of Statin Market to 2018
 
PCPs speak out on rad reporting
PCPs speak out on rad reportingPCPs speak out on rad reporting
PCPs speak out on rad reporting
 
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...
Step up to bat and practice dictating complex cases a residents guide to effe...
 
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...
Radiology Workflow: Recognizing Clinical & Financial Benefits of Implementing...
 
RSNA 2012 - Photolog
RSNA 2012 - PhotologRSNA 2012 - Photolog
RSNA 2012 - Photolog
 
201209 cit-w&inicu
201209 cit-w&inicu201209 cit-w&inicu
201209 cit-w&inicu
 
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...
Inside a Private HIE: Clinical, Economic and Operational Successes at The Was...
 
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam Kassing
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam KassingHow Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam Kassing
How Healthcare Reform Is Affecting Radiology, Pam Kassing
 
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun Krishnaraj
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun KrishnarajMeaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun Krishnaraj
Meaningful Use: Impact on Radiology, Arun Krishnaraj
 
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid Coleman
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid ColemanCMIO Summit 2011 | Reid Coleman
CMIO Summit 2011 | Reid Coleman
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham
2011 CMIO Summit | Justin Graham
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Don Levick
2011 CMIO Summit | Don Levick2011 CMIO Summit | Don Levick
2011 CMIO Summit | Don Levick
 
2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran
2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran
2011 CMIO Summit | David Cochran
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough
2011 CMIO Summit | Brian McDonough
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Ben Stein
2011 CMIO Summit | Ben Stein2011 CMIO Summit | Ben Stein
2011 CMIO Summit | Ben Stein
 
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal
2011 CMIO Summit | Abha Agrawal
 

1800 syntax lm

  • 1. The Synergy between Percutaneous Coronary Intervention with TAXUS and Cardiac Surgery: The SYNTAX StudyThe 3-year Outcomes of the SYNTAX Trial in the Subset of Patients With Left Main Disease Patrick W. Serruys, MD PhD Erasmus Medical Center On behalf of the SYNTAX investigators 6:00-6:10PM, Sept 21, 2010 Featured Clinical Research I Conflicts of Interest: None
  • 2. Disclosure Statement of Financial Interest I, Patrick W. Serruys, DO NOT have a financial interest/arrangement or affiliation with one or more organizations that could be perceived as a real or apparent conflict of interest in the context of the subject of this presentation.
  • 3. SYNTAX Study Objectives The SYNTAX randomized trial is an attempt to provide an evidence base to determine the most appropriate treatment option for patients in a ‘real-world’ population seen by the surgeon and the interventional cardiologist in their daily practice In 2009, the ACC-AHA PCI Guidelines were updated and raised LM stenting from Class III to Class IIb (level B)1 In 2010, ESC-EACTS Guidelines revised and upgraded LM (isolated or in conjuction with 1 vessel disease) stenting from Class IIb (level C) to IIa (level B)2 1Kushner et al. Circulation 2009; 120:2271-2306 2Wijns et al. EHJ 2010
  • 4. Amenable for both treatment options Amenable for only one treatment approach Randomized Arms N=1800 Two Registry ArmsN=1275 SYNTAX Trial Design + 23 US Sites 62 EU Sites Heart Team (surgeon & interventional cardiologist) Stratification: LM and Diabetes PCI n=198 CABG n=1077 TAXUS* n=903 CABG n=897 vs LM n=348(33.7%) 3VDn=549 (66.3%) 3VD n=546 (65.4%) LMn=357(34.6%) *TAXUS Express
  • 5. Patients in SYNTAXLeft Main (LM) Subset RCT: Enrolled N=705 CABG n=348 PCI n=357 RCT: 1 Year Follow-up N=691 (98.0%) CABG n=336 PCI n=355 RCT: 2 Year Follow-up N=683 (96.9%) CABG n=331 PCI n=352 RCT: 3 Year Follow-up N=674 (95.6%) CABG n=325 PCI n=349
  • 6. Heterogeneity in the Left Main Group Left Main Isolated n=91 (13%) Left Main + 1VD Left Main + 3VD n=258 (37%) n=138 (20%) n=218 (31%) Left Main + 2VD Site-reported data
  • 7. Patient CharacteristicsLM Subset Core laboratory reported unless *Site-reported
  • 8. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 All-Cause Death to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.64 Before 1 year* 4.5% vs 4.2% P=0.88 1-2 years* 1.9% vs 1.5% P=0.68 2-3 years* 2.3% vs 1.8% P=0.67 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 8.4% 7.3% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 9. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 CVA to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.02 Before 1 year* 2.7% vs 0.3% P=0.009 1-2 years* 0.9% vs 0.6% P=0.68 2-3 years* 0.3% vs 0.3% P=1.00 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 4.0% 1.2% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 10. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 Myocardial Infarction to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.14 Before 1 year* 4.2% vs 4.2% P=0.97 1-2 years* 0.0% vs 1.2% P=0.12 2-3 years* 0.0% vs 1.5% P=0.06 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 6.9% 4.1% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 11. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 All-Cause Death/CVA/MI to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.60 Before 1 year* 9.2% vs 7.0% P=0.29 1-2 years* 2.8% vs 3.2% P=0.76 2-3 years* 2.6% vs 3.0% P=0.76 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 14.3% 13.0% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 12. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 Repeat Revascularization to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.004 Before 1 year* 6.5% vs 11.8% P=0.02 1-2 years* 5.0% vs 8.2% P=0.10 2-3 years* 2.6% vs 3.9% P=0.36 20.0% Cumulative Event Rate (%) 11.7% Repeat CABG: 1.7% vs 5.6%, P=0.01 Repeat PCI: 10.0% vs 16.2%, P=0.01 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 13. TAXUS(N=357) CABG(N=348) 40 20 0 12 36 24 MACCE to 3 YearsLM Subset P=0.20 Before 1 year* 13.7% vs 15.8% P=0.44 1-2 years* 7.5% vs 10.3% P=0.22 2-3 years* 5.2% vs 5.7% P=0.78 26.8% Cumulative Event Rate (%) 22.3% 0 Months Since Allocation ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 14. CABG(n=348) TAXUS(n=357) Symptomatic Graft Occlusion & Stent Thrombosis to 3 Years LM Subset P=0.80 Patients (%) n=12 n=14 CABG TAXUS Post-procedure; ITT population
  • 15. MACCE to 3 Years in LM Subgroups TAXUS CABG P=0.20 P=0.52 P=0.33 P=0.09 P=0.20 Patients, % n= 348 357 49 42 122 136 106 112 71 67 All LM LM + 1VD LM Isolated LM + 2VD LM + 3VD Cumulative KM Event Rate; log-rank P value; *Binary rates
  • 16. Distal 7% 4% 11% 35% 27% Nondistal 29% 61% 66% 59% Both Vessel Distribution in LM Population According to Syntax Score Terciles 33+ 0-22 23-32
  • 17. CTO 29.6% Non-CTO Vessel Distribution in LM Population According to Syntax Score Terciles 5.9% 16.5% 33+ 0-22 23-32
  • 18. CABG(N=104) TAXUS(N=118) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile Low Scores (0-22) Left Main > > P=0.33 23.0% < Cumulative Event Rate (%) 18.0% > < Months Since Allocation Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
  • 19. CABG(N=92) TAXUS(N=103) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile Intermediate Scores (23-32) Left Main > > P=0.90 23.4% < 23.4% > < Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
  • 20. CABG(N=149) TAXUS(N=135) 40 30 Cumulative Event Rate (%) 20 10 0 0 12 24 36 Months Since Allocation MACCE to 3 Years by SYNTAX Score Tercile Left Main SYNTAX Score 33 Left Main Left Main < P=0.003 37.3% > < 21.2% < < Site-reported Data; ITT population Cumulative KM Event Rate ± 1.5 SE; log-rank P value
  • 21. SummaryLeft Main Subset At 3 years, overall MACCE in the PCI group was comparable with CABG (22.3% CABG vs 26.8% PCI) Similar overall safety outcomes (Death/CVA/MI) between CABG and PCI at 3 years (14.3% CABG vs 13.0% PCI) There was a higher rate of revascularization in the PCI group (11.7% CABG vs 20.0% PCI), and a higher rate of CVA in the CABG group (4.0% CABG vs 1.2% PCI) PCI outcomes are excellent relative to CABG in LM isolated and LM+1VD
  • 22. Conclusions For patients with left main disease Revascularization with PCI has comparable safety and efficacy outcomes to CABG PCI is therefore a reasonable treatment alternative in this patient population, in particular, when the SYNTAX Score is low (≤22) or intermediate (23-32)

Hinweis der Redaktion

  1. SYNTAX_CSR_Randomized_Unblinded_2008Oct10.docex. 1 title; intent to treat.exhibit 52, 53 % calculated by handRegistry: SYNTAX_CSR_Registry_Unblinded_2008Oct10.doc exhibit 2, 21 QC Comments:Note: Per Kristine, this slide has been QC’ed before. No QC needed.Please check the percents in last 4 boxes at bottom left.
  2. 1 yr data From SYNTAX_CSR_randomized_Unblinded_2008Oct10.doc exhibit 522-Year_Randomized_20090820.doc Exhibits 21SYNTAX 3-Year Report_Randomized_12JUL10.doc exhibits 21 (KM overall rate), 22 (year 2-3)
  3. 1 yr data From SYNTAX_CSR_randomized_Unblinded_2008Oct10.doc exhibit 522-Year_Randomized_20090820.doc Exhibits 21SYNTAX 3-Year Report_Randomized_12JUL10.doc exhibits 21 (KM overall rate), 22 (year 2-3)
  4. SYNTAX 3-Year Report_Randomized_12JUL10.docex.1
  5. 8 anatomic patterns of disease (1 or 2 vd with/without proximal LAD, 3vd being ‘simple or complex,4 categories of left main)CABG is stilll considered IA for all except ½ vd not involving prox LAD (comparable to Appropriateness recommendations by six US organizations)½ vd +prox LAD CABG is IA because of proven durability of IMA graft over decades of follow upFor 3vd PCI had different recommendations depending on complexityFor LM easing of previous ESC recommendations and more than appropriateness recommendations and may change again with further trials