WACEC: Supporting Community Development with Broadband
1. Supporting Community Development
with Broadband
June 21 ,2016
Mary Kluz
Will Andresen
Broadband & E-Commerce Education Center
http://broadband.uwex.edu | wibroadband@uwex.edu | @WI_Broadband | 608-890-4255
6. Digitization in US industry sectors
McKinsey Global Institute
Digital America: a Tale of the Haves and Have-Mores, 2015
7. Median Household Income Growth:
High BB Adoption Vs. Otherwise Similar
Whitacre, Galardo, Strover for the National Agricultural
and Rural Development and Policy Center, 2013
10. • Research in the U.S. shows…
• 56% of businesses and organizations say broadband
is essential for remaining in current location
• 56% of households say they would definitely/likely
relocate if broadband was not available
• 32% of households work from home or have a
home-based business
The Internet has become
the highway for technology
Source: SNG Digital Economy Database n = 19,951 businesses and 9,318 households
11. Interaction between factors
affecting broadband development
Internet
service
provider
activity
Availability of
infrastructure
Consumer
demand /
adoption
Consumer
confidence
Potential
public role?
Affordability
Consumer
savvy
Regulations
Potential
public role?
Return on
Investment
12. A framework
for change
1. Increase urgency
2. Build guiding teams
3. Get the vision right
4. Communicate the vision
5. Enable action
6. Create short-term wins
7. Don’t let up
8. Make it stick
14. Compete Co-exist Communicate Cooperate Coordinate Collaborate Integrate
Competition
for clients,
resources,
partners,
public
attention
No systematic
connection
between
agencies /
organizations
Inter-agency
information
sharing (e.g.
networking)
As needed,
often
informal,
interaction,
on discrete
activities or
projects
Organizations
systematically
adjust and
align work
with each
other for
greater
outcomes
Longer term
interaction
based on
shared
mission,
goals; shared
decision-
makers and
resources
Fully
integrated
programs,
planning,
funding
TRUST
TURF
17. The internet today is, at a minimum,
today’s Yellow Pages.
Businesses that don’t have a basic online
presence are less likely to grow, or survive.
E-Commerce Pilot Projects 2014--2015
6pilot counties
96attendees, general sessions
41 individual consultations
Coming Up…
Vernon & Crawford Counties
July 13-14 2016
http://bit.ly/28JjXDR
“I attended the ecommerce
training and was impressed
with the knowledge of the
presenters and the depth of
the material. The audience
was engaged and interested.
This is a very valuable topic
and is just what we need in
rural Wisconsin.”
18. broadband: the players
• Federal level:
– Federal Communication Commission (FCC)
– National Telecommunications and Information
Administration (NTIA)
• http://www.ntia.doc.gov/report/2015/broadbandusa
-guide-federal-funding-broadband-projects
– US Department of Agriculture (USDA), others
who administer grants and loans
19. • State level:
– State Broadband Office
http://www.link.wisconsin.gov/
20. • Local level
– Government (county & municipal)
– Consumers, judge it according to
• Capacity (including speed)
• Cost
• Reliability
broadband: the players
21. Broadband & E-Commerce Education Center
wibroadband@uwex.edu Twitter @WI_Broadband 608-890-4255
Mary Kluz, Community Development, mary.kluz@ces.uwex.edu 608-890-4254
Find this presentation online:
http://www.slideshare.net/WI_Broadband
22. Mary Kluz
Community Development Outreach
mary.kluz@uwex.edu
608-890-4254
Will Andresen
Interim Regional Director
will.andresen@ces.uwex.edu
Editor's Notes
We keep communication open between educators who are closely connected to Wisconsin communities and the specialists who are tracking issues at the national and global level.
State specialists may also work with their Center directors, as we do, to convene advisory groups. The BEC recently finished work with an Advisory Council whose members were drawn from a wide variety of sectors: Wis Towns Association, Public Service Commission, agencies working with the elderly and the low income population, internet service providers, the WEDC, agricultural interests and legilsators.
IN the case of broadband, one can’t HELP but notice that this technology is affecting all aspects of how we live in community. In fact, the internet and its increasing speed has created whole new industries. I think a few decades ago, no one would have imagined that something like Facebook would have any public trading value.
This change in how we live in community is why people are getting engaged around broadband and concerned that people have access and know how to use it well. It has become clear that differing abilities to access this technology leads to disparity.
Companies continue to integrate digital tools into every aspect of business process. MGI created an index of 27 factors; around assets (8 metrics) usage (11 metrics) and labor (8 metrics) to estimate how well digital tools were utilized within a sector. Top sectors: Info/Communication Technology; Media; Professional services: Finance and insurance. This is also blurring lines between sectors: Amazon started selling books, evolved into selling almost everything; now is in publishing, other media.
to note: workers in the most digized industries see wage growth 2X the national average.
RURAL:: Whitacre, Galardo and Strover for the National and Rural Development and Policy Center, 2013 http://www.nardep.info/Broadband_2.html
Researchers from Oklahoma State, Mississippi State and the University of Texas.
They looked at seven factors related to local economics, including median household income, the percentage of people in poverty, the total people employed, non-farm proprietor income, the number of firms with paid employees, the percentage of non-farm proprietors and the percentage of employees classified as “creative class.”
Take Away: “If there were a lot of people without broadband available or not a lot of providers, it negatively impacts all seven economic measures,” said Whitacre.
One thing Will did to learn more about this up and coming issue was to attend a Broadband Bootcamp in 2013.
what is a broadband bootcamp?
As part of the bootcamps, participants take a look at the complex system that drives broadband development, and we try to see the interactions between factors to figure out where to “grease the wheel”
We cover a research-based framework of change as a means to help community members choose the most effective steps they can take, depending upon where they are in the change process. Changing the way we learn, play, work and do business all at once is a complicated change!
Many educators are already familiar because they are well grounded in community development work. The bootcamp is a chance to strategize about how the community development research and tools can be most effectively applied to this latest issue.
At the Center, we help people stay in touch after bootcamp and reach those who have not attended through a weekly electronic news blast, meeting coordination and responses to community requests through our local educators.
Educators share tools from community development research to apply to developing community capacity around a new issue.
What happens when an educator goes back to the community with more information? How did having the collaborative relationship with the BEC help the people in Iron County?
“Bootcamp” has continued to evolve. Our most recent bootcamps involved community partners and internet service providers, along with the educators.
Working with local educators, the Broadband and Ecommerce center has offered e commerce training to local small businesses. First pilot happened in northern part of the state;
First round of trainings, 2014 – held in Ashland/Bayfield counties area and in Oneida/Vilas counties area
Second round 2015 – held in Clark/Wood counties area
This year – Vernon/Crawford counties
Rural broadband supported over $100 billion in e-commerce in 2015.
The largest share was in manufacturing, where a majority of transactions now involve electronic data exchange over broadband networks.
Nearly $10 billion involved retail sales; if broadband had the same reach in rural areas as it does in urban areas, sales would have been at least $1 billion higher
A clearer understanding of the different players in development allows community members to investigate how they what role they might play to improve access and adoption in their community.
A short update on what is going on at the state level
-the applications for state Broadband Expansion Grants were due last week, on June 16.
-the state legislature is convening a study committee on rural broadband. Check the Legislative Council website for more information. Committees made recommendations for committee member, including citizen members, last week.
TO encourage you to learn more about how things work, who is making policy and to join the conversation. We like to remind people that it is not only about access but also helping people learn how to use the internet to improve their lives.
Plug the policy document, with stories of what people are doing to be more proactive on development.