1. Design Priorities
• Feedback == assessment
• Focus on qualitative feedback to improve projects
• Prompt iteration and resubmission of projects
• Nurture mentorship through sustained feedback
relationships

2. Overview / Map
Badges.p2pu.org: p2pu.org
• Splash: select Badges/Learners/Projects • Attach badge to a course
• Badge creation process
• Badge review / awarding
• Badge gallery [badges.p2pu.org/badges]
• Project gallery [badges.p2pu.org/projects]
• Learner gallery [badges.p2pu.org/learners]
• My Badges / badges created and dashboard
[badges.p2pu.org/mybadges]
• Each Badge has it’s own unique URL
• Each Learner has unique URL

3. Use cases for Badges.p2pu.org
User 1: Domain Knowledge Ace
1
• Has expertise in some area and wants to see if he or she qualifies for a pre-
existing badge
• Intended next action: read About Badges, see gallery, apply for a badge
User 2: Course Creator
• Has created a learning experience on P2PU or elsewhere and would like to
create a Badge for that course
• Intended next action: see gallery, create a Badge, revisit P2PU.org and
associate with their course
User 3: Badge Expert
• Has visited badges.p2pu before to apply for a Badge and has received one
• Intended next action: review 2-3 badges, create a badge

4. Badge UX: badges.p2pu.org 1/3
About Badges Create a1Badge Review a Badge My Badges
All About Badges
At P2PU, badges are a form of feedback that learners give to each other to iterate and improve
their projects. On badges.p2pu.org, you can create a badge, submit work for a badge, or, if you Upon sign-in
are an “expert” and already possess the badge, award it to someone else. Find out more....
“My Badges”
appears
Badge We Love.
Crystal Ball Badge
Note--
This badge signifies that the user has completed the
thumbnails s/b
CrystalBall tutorial in App Inventor.
set to scale
160px x 160 px
Requirements per badges
User must complete the CrystalBall tutorial and specs
upload an image of their app to the comments
section of the task in order to receive this badge.
Apply for Badge Meet the Experts
1
Got Expertise? Apply for a Spiffy Badge.
Most Awarded Newest P2PU Favorites All Search

5. Badge UX: badges.p2pu.org 2/3
Got Expertise? Apply for a Spiffy Badge.
1
Most Awarded Newest P2PU Favorites All Search
“All” kicks to
badges.p2pu.org/
badges
Create a New Badge
Roll Call: Meet the Learners. “All” kicks to
1 badges.p2pu.org/
Experts Newbies Most Active All Search learners
See More

6. Badge UX: badges.p2pu.org 3/3
1
Projects in the Community
Newest Most Active P2PU Favorites All Search “All” kicks to
badges.p2pu.org/
projects
“Most
Active”=revised
and resubmitted
Set
See More “awaiting
review” to newest
so those are
1 seen 1st
Alternate layout
for projects (No
FB tho):

7. Create a Badge: Badges.p2pu.org
1
User is provided with 2 choices:
•Upload your own image
•Functionality: upload, resize or crop image/thumbnail preview (nice-to-have),
success message that image meets requirements
•Output: 160px by 160 px .png file
•Badge-o-Matic
•Functionality: selection of shapes, icons and colors to choose
•Output: 160px by 160 px .png file

8. Badge UX: Create a Badge
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Need to include
checklist:
>200k
Home / Create a Badge 160px x 160 px Can we kick
Need guidance: use to “Create
googledraw Account” from
Create a Badge here and save
badge?
We’ve created a series of tools to help you design and implement your badge easily.
Or use:
Upload Your Own Badge-o-Matic
Save Your Save Your
Badge Badge

9. Badge UX: Create a Badge
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Home / Create a Badge / Enter Requirements
Step 2: Enter Requirements
Here’s where we get to the nitty gritty--the “requirements” of the badge. Things to think about:
• Purpose: What do people need to be able to do in order to get this here Badge you’re making?
• Clarity: Requirements should be clear and easy to understand.
• Appeal: Why would someone want your Badge? Is it adorable? Clever? Succinct? What you say here is as
important as how you say it.
For more help, see our rockin’ badge gallery for folks who do it well.
Badge Headline:
What are you calling your Badge? Grab someone’s attention
and make a learner interested.
Badge Subtitle:
Think about this as a short description. What are experts who
hold this badge masters of?
Signs of Mastery: Rollover popup to
gallery?
What specific skills should people with this badge
demonstrate with their project?
Save and
Preview

10. Badge UX: Create a Badge
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Home / Create a Badge / Preview
Step 3: Preview Badge “Edit” kicks
Check out how your badge will appear to learners. back to step 1,
image input
Crystal Ball Badge
This badge signifies that the user has completed the
CrystalBall tutorial in App Inventor.
Requirements
User must complete the CrystalBall tutorial and
upload an image of their app to the comments
section of the task in order to receive this badge.
Publish
Edit Badge
Badge

11. Badge UX: Create a Badge
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Home / Create a Badge / Success!
Step 4: Success!
Booyah! Your Badge has been created and implemented. Check it out!
Crystal Ball Badge
This badge signifies that the user has completed the
CrystalBall tutorial in App Inventor.
Requirements
User must complete the CrystalBall tutorial and
upload an image of their app to the comments
section of the task in order to receive this badge.
Let folks know!
This Badge has been created and added to your profile. Visit p2pu.org to add it to a
P2PU course.
Create another
Badge

12. Badge UX: Apply for Badge
Learner Modal opens
submits project Submit Project for Content Marketing Badge with questions
for a specific An expert with this badge has created a blog, about the
installed analytics, and created a voice
badge and tone style guide for their site. project
Project Title?
SUBMIT PROJECT FOR:
Project URL?
CONTENT MARKETING BADGE
What steps did youfor your project? this task?
What’s the URL take to complete
What steps did you take to complete this task?
What would you do differently next time? (If anything)
Upload Screenshot (recommended) Learner is asked to
give some context to
Tags associated with project: music, art, literature
help direct the nature
of the feedback
Submit Project:
Content Marketing Submit

13. Review a Badge Review Project for Content Marketing Badge
An expert with this badge has created a blog, installed
analytics, and created a voice
and tone style guide for their site.
Experts are sent to Project title: Robots in Love
Project URL: http://
ilovecharts.tumblr.com/
badges.p2pu.org 160 x 160
Steps Involved: Installed tumblr,
analytics, voice and tone guide.
Reflection for next time: I would
have used another theme.
Experts can see the context of the project, Your Feedback to Mozzadrella
and give personalized feedback KUDOS
What is strong about this project?
QUESTIONS
Expert is prompted to focus on what What is unclear about this project?
works well, unclear areas, and areas to CONCERNS
improve What is incorrect, missing, or doesn’t work about this project?
In your Expert opinion, has this learner earned
Expert either awards badge, or asks the Badge?
Yes, award No, but send
learner to revise and resubmit Badge my feedback

14. Badge UX: Badge Dashboard
Appears in both 1
a learner’s p2pu.org profile
and at badges.p2pu.org
Key Features:
•Badges: Earned, Under
Badges Feedback
Review, Awarded to Earned Under Review Awarded Created Latest Your Projects Peer Projects
others, Badges you Content Marketing
Earned 10/01/2012
Dirk Kahnerelli
resubmitted work
created SoundCloud Maestro
Earned 12/04/2012
Vanessa Browne
•Feedback: latest activity
earned the Music
Hacker badge
from feedback partners,
feedback on your
projects, feedback
you’ve left for others

15. Badge UX: Resubmit for Badge
Revised Project for Content Marketing Badge
An expert with this badge has created a blog,
installed analytics, and created a voice
and tone style guide for their site.
Previous Submission
Project title: Robots in Love
SUBMIT PROJECT FOR: http://
Project URL:
ilovecharts.tumblr.com/
CONTENT MARKETING BADGE
160 xthe URL for your analytics, voice and tone guide.
160
Steps Involved: Installed tumblr,
What’s project?
What steps did you take to complete this task? I would
Reflection for next time:
have used another theme.
Revisions
What have you changed, added, or revised about
your project?
Submit Project:
Content Marketing Do you have a new URL for your project?
Submit

16. Badge UX: Project Pg--no feedback
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Home / My Badges / Feedback / My Projects
Nav is
awkward, maybe Option appears
Project for Content Marketing Badge put my projects up even if expert isn’t
An expert with this badge has created a blog,
installed analytics, and created a voice
in top nav near signed in, prompt sign-in
and tone style guide for their site. “my badges”? onclick.
Project Submission for Mozzadrella
Button only appears if
the project has yet to
Project title: Robots in Love
Project URL: http:// get badge.
ilovecharts.tumblr.com/
160 x 160
Steps Involved: Installed tumblr,
analytics, voice and tone guide.
Reflection for next time: I would
have used another theme.
Review this
Project

17. Badge UX: Project Pg--w feedback
About Badges Create a Badge
Badge
Create a 1 Review a Badge My Badges
Home / My Badges / Feedback / My Projects
Nav is
awkward, maybe Option appears
Project for Content Marketing Badge put my projects up even if expert isn’t
An expert with this badge has created a blog,
installed analytics, and created a voice
in top nav near signed in, prompt sign-in
and tone style guide for their site. “my badges”? onclick.
Project Submission for Mozzadrella
Button only appears if
the project has yet to
Project title: Robots in Love
Project URL: http:// get badge.
ilovecharts.tumblr.com/
160 x 160
Steps Involved: Installed tumblr,
analytics, voice and tone guide.
Reflection for next time: I would
have used another theme.
Review this
Project
Feedback from Riskycud: Version 1.0
KUDOS
Project artfully uses multimedia, video editing software, and

18. Home / My Badges / Feedback / My Projects
Feedback from Riskycud: Version 1.0
KUDOS
Project artfully uses multimedia, video editing software, and
Soundcloud to create a fascinating experience.
1
QUESTIONS
Did the piece need to be in two parts? Maybe you could share
it within some electronic music groups?
CONCERNS
I didn’t see the re-use of a previous piece on SoundCloud.
Feedback submitted 2/27/2013
Resubmission from Mozzadrella: Version 1.1
CHANGES
Made the piece one part only, shared with the Electronic group
for feedback, reused another piece on SoundCloud.
NEW URL
https://soundcloud.com/loveandradio/jack-and-ellen
Revision submitted 3/1/2013
Feedback from SchmidtPhi: Version 1.1
KUDOS

19. Home / My Badges / Feedback / My Projects
Feedback from SchmidtPhi: Version 1.1
KUDOS
Project artfully uses multimedia, video editing software, and
Soundcloud to create a fascinating experience.
1
QUESTIONS
Did the piece need to be in two parts? Maybe you could share
it within some electronic music groups?
CONCERNS
I didn’t see the re-use of a previous piece on SoundCloud.
Huzzah! Badge Awarded 3/2/2013

20. Badge UX: Add Badge to Course
My Badges
My Badges
Course
organizers can
Upon sign-in
add badge from
“My Badges” Badges
either left nav or
appears
top nav
Modal opens
with search box
to discover
badges
Badge defaults
to last task, but
organizers can
change it in
“Content”
Add a Badge

21. Badge UX: Add Badge to Course
My Badges
Add a Badge to Your P2PU Course
My Badges
Badges are a way for learners to get feedback on
their projects. If you’ve created a badge on
badges.p2pu.org, you can add it from here. You might
also find badges that other folks have created that
Course might suit your course.
organizers can
Upon sign-in
add badge from
“My Badges” Find Your Badge Search
Badges
either left nav or
appears Results Select
top nav
Crystal Ball Badge
Requirements: User must complete the
CrystalBall tutorial and upload an image of their
app to the comments section of the task in order
to receive this badge.
Hack Day Badge
Requirements: The user will get this badge when
they complete the CrystalBall, PaintPot, Invent, and
No Text While Driving tutorials.
Badge defaults
to last task, but
 1 2 ... 4  organizers can
change it in
“Content”
Create my own
Add Badge
Add a Badge Badge

22. Notifications Scheme
Expert
Learner
How often
#1 should this
# 1: 3 folks are notification
Submission awaiting be? Every
Success review month?
# 2a: # 2b:
Badge You have # 2a: #2b
awarded! feedback [Learner X] Folks are still
has revised awaiting
and review--
resubmitted spread the luv
Notification
3a: #3b
Reflection: 3 Reminder to
months ago revise and
you learned resubmit #3a:
[Badge X]. Your feedback
was useful! Mad
See who is props.
earning the
badge.
Create your
own badge.
#4a:
Create a badge