SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 15
Nettles
By Vernon Scannell
Background & Context
Vernon Scannell (1922−2007) was originally from West
Yorkshire.

Joined the war at age 18.

His name was originally Bain, but he changed it shortly after World War
II as he had deserted from the army. He did this twice – on the second
occasion, they put him into a mental hospital before being released.

His negative feelings about the effects of war have been a prevailing
influence on his work – he was awarded the Wilfred Owen Association
award for significant contributions to war poetry.

Scannell had 6 children of which 2 died. 1 son died as an infant and 1 son died
in a motor cycle crash.
Key Themes in ‘Nettles’

War

      Violence


                  Danger
The Relationship:
A father protecting his son from the dangers of a
dark, menacing world in which nobody and nothing
can be trusted.

Nature will attack you, be cut down, grow back and
fight you again…just as the military will hunt you
down and find you if you leave without consent.

Scannell is protecting his son from a world he hates
and fears.
‘Nettles’
   My son aged three fell in the nettle bed.
   'Bed' seemed a curious name for those green spears,
   That regiment of spite behind the shed:
   It was no place for rest. With sobs and tears
   The boy came seeking comfort and I saw
   White blisters beaded on his tender skin.
   We soothed him till his pain was not so raw.
   At last he offered us a watery grin,
   And then I took my billhook, honed the blade
   And went outside and slashed in fury with it
   Till not a nettle in that fierce parade
   Stood upright any more. And then I lit
   A funeral pyre to burn the fallen dead,
   But in two weeks the busy sun and rain
   Had called up tall recruits behind the shed:
   My son would often feel sharp wounds again.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/english_literature/poetryrelationships
   /nettlesact.shtml
The full stop at the
                                end of the first line
                                could indicate the
  Possessive pronoun            forcefulness at which
  ‘my’ indicates the            the narrator’s son
  protectiveness of the         ‘fell’. It is also a
  father. His son belongs       moment of
  to him                        contemplation.




My son aged three fell in the nettle bed.



 The first line highlights   The verb ‘fell’
 the sons age – 3 – and      suggests that this is
 immediately implies         an accident
 that he is vulnerable.
Line 2 is the longest
          ‘Bed’ suggests a place of                           line in the poem. The
          comfort and rest which is                           metaphor of ‘spears’
          the complete opposite of                            presents the nettles as
          the ‘nettle’ bed.                                   violent aggressors. He
                                                              is representing them as
                                                              if they are the army.



‘Bed’ seemed a curious name for those green spears,

                                                                         The fact that
                                                                         they are
That regiment of spite behind the shed:                                  ‘behind’ the
                                                                         shed
                                      The nettles are                    suggests
                                      personified – a                    that they are
Suggests that there are               military image of the              planning
a lot of them in contrast             nettles commencing                 their attack.
to the lone boy.                      their war against the
                                      son.
Scannell uses a variety of soft ‘s’
                 sounds using alliteration and
                 assonance to emphasise the soothing
                 of his injured son.




It was no place for rest. With sobs and tears

The boy came seeking comfort and I saw
The alliteration
                          intensifies the reality of
                          the detailed description.
                          The plosive ‘b’ sounds
                          suggest an eruption of
                          blisters.



 White blisters beaded on his tender skin.


The nettles have
                              The careful use of the adjective
painfully decorated the
                              ‘tender’ emphasises the
young boy’s skin.
                              innocence of the boy,
                              contrasted with the violence of
                              the nettles.
‘Soothing’ is an action that
 The boy needs both            is usually carried out with
 parental units to make him    babies. ‘Soothing’ helps
 feel safe and secure.         them to feel calm and
                               comforted.




  We soothed him till his pain was not so raw.

  At last he offered us a watery grin,
                                   The ‘watery grin’ is
An opposing image – the            another emotive
merging of laughter or             description implying that
comfort or relief with the         the child is being helped
tears of the pain from the         to get over his painful
sting of the nettles.              experience by his loving
                                   parents.
The verb ‘honed’ shows
  how the father is preparing
  an attack of his own. He is
  carefully sharpening his
  blade to make it more
  efficient when he faces the
  nettles. It demonstrates a
  careful, calculating manner.

And then I took my hook and honed the blade

                                 Reference to a bayonet?
     Hook = scythe


And went outside and slashed in fury with it
   The father’s actions are            He is relentless in
   as violent as the nettle            his desire to
   stings.                             protect his son.
Again the extended metaphor
                             illustrates his anger at his past
                             and the ongoing battle against
                             them.




Till not a nettle in that fierce parade
The caesura in the                      Emphasises
     middle of the line                      Scannell’s
     here highlights a                       military past.
     brief pause in the
     father’s ongoing
     battle to protect his
     child.


Stood upright any more. Next task: I lit

A funeral pyre to burn the fallen dead.

                             The full stop indicates that the father
                             thinks that this is the end of the
                             nettles and that he has defeated
                             them. It actually sounds as if he is
                             burning dead bodies of the injured.
You can not fight nature




But in two weeks the busy sun and rain



Had called up tall recruits behind the shed:


                           Suggests that the battle is futile. Re-enforcements
                           have come to replace those who have died. War will
                           go on and on until peace is declared.
The last line emphasises the father’s
realisation of his inability to protect his son
from life’s pain. It is inevitable that his son
will feel ‘wounds’ throughout life, whatever a
parent may do to prevent it.




My son would often feel sharp wounds again.

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Storm on the island
Storm on the islandStorm on the island
Storm on the islandmrhoward12
 
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitage
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon ArmitageExtract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitage
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitagewww.MrSedani.co.uk
 
Out of the Blue annotation
Out of the Blue annotationOut of the Blue annotation
Out of the Blue annotationthemerch78
 
Bayonet charge revision information
Bayonet charge   revision informationBayonet charge   revision information
Bayonet charge revision informationJon Bradshaw
 
Checking Out Me History
Checking Out Me HistoryChecking Out Me History
Checking Out Me Historycbolsover
 
Bayonet Charge
Bayonet ChargeBayonet Charge
Bayonet Chargemrhoward12
 
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysis
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysisPiano by D.H. Lawrence analysis
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysismrbunkeredu
 
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William WordsworthComposed on Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William WordsworthKieran Hamilton
 
The Manhunt Analysis
The Manhunt AnalysisThe Manhunt Analysis
The Manhunt Analysisvfarrimond
 
Kamikaze --beatrice-garland
Kamikaze --beatrice-garlandKamikaze --beatrice-garland
Kamikaze --beatrice-garlandmrhoward12
 
Out of the Blue
Out of the BlueOut of the Blue
Out of the Bluethemerch78
 
Dulce et decorum est
Dulce et decorum estDulce et decorum est
Dulce et decorum estChristineLYA
 
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthologyenglishanthology
 
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies Post modernism In Lord of The Flies
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies sakinaay
 
Checking Out Me History - John Agard
Checking Out Me History - John AgardChecking Out Me History - John Agard
Checking Out Me History - John Agardnten
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Storm on the island
Storm on the islandStorm on the island
Storm on the island
 
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitage
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon ArmitageExtract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitage
Extract from Out of the Blue by Simon Armitage
 
Out of the Blue annotation
Out of the Blue annotationOut of the Blue annotation
Out of the Blue annotation
 
Bayonet charge revision information
Bayonet charge   revision informationBayonet charge   revision information
Bayonet charge revision information
 
Checking Out Me History
Checking Out Me HistoryChecking Out Me History
Checking Out Me History
 
The Tyger
The Tyger The Tyger
The Tyger
 
Bayonet Charge
Bayonet ChargeBayonet Charge
Bayonet Charge
 
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysis
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysisPiano by D.H. Lawrence analysis
Piano by D.H. Lawrence analysis
 
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William WordsworthComposed on Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth
Composed on Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth
 
The Manhunt Analysis
The Manhunt AnalysisThe Manhunt Analysis
The Manhunt Analysis
 
My Last Duchess
My Last DuchessMy Last Duchess
My Last Duchess
 
Kamikaze --beatrice-garland
Kamikaze --beatrice-garlandKamikaze --beatrice-garland
Kamikaze --beatrice-garland
 
Out of the Blue
Out of the BlueOut of the Blue
Out of the Blue
 
Dulce et decorum est
Dulce et decorum estDulce et decorum est
Dulce et decorum est
 
Theme and symbolism
Theme and symbolismTheme and symbolism
Theme and symbolism
 
The discovery
The discoveryThe discovery
The discovery
 
Thank you m'am
Thank you m'amThank you m'am
Thank you m'am
 
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology
"Disabled" by Wilfred Owen - IGCSE Anthology
 
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies Post modernism In Lord of The Flies
Post modernism In Lord of The Flies
 
Checking Out Me History - John Agard
Checking Out Me History - John AgardChecking Out Me History - John Agard
Checking Out Me History - John Agard
 

Mehr von Tpaisey

Poetry across time jan 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time jan 2012 mark schemePoetry across time jan 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time jan 2012 mark schemeTpaisey
 
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paperPoetry across time jan 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paperTpaisey
 
Poetry across time 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time 2012 mark schemePoetry across time 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time 2012 mark schemeTpaisey
 
Poetry across time 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time 2012 higher paperPoetry across time 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time 2012 higher paperTpaisey
 
Writing to infom and explain
Writing to infom and explainWriting to infom and explain
Writing to infom and explainTpaisey
 
Writing to describe poster
Writing to describe posterWriting to describe poster
Writing to describe posterTpaisey
 
Writing to persuade
Writing to persuadeWriting to persuade
Writing to persuadeTpaisey
 
Writing to argue
Writing to argueWriting to argue
Writing to argueTpaisey
 
Sentence variety poster
Sentence variety posterSentence variety poster
Sentence variety posterTpaisey
 
Punctuation poster
Punctuation posterPunctuation poster
Punctuation posterTpaisey
 
Tip top paragraphs
Tip top paragraphsTip top paragraphs
Tip top paragraphsTpaisey
 
Pictures to prompt creative writing
Pictures to prompt creative writingPictures to prompt creative writing
Pictures to prompt creative writingTpaisey
 
Question 2 Andy Murray
Question 2 Andy MurrayQuestion 2 Andy Murray
Question 2 Andy MurrayTpaisey
 
Question 2 simon cowell
Question 2 simon cowellQuestion 2 simon cowell
Question 2 simon cowellTpaisey
 
Swimming the Thames question 1a and b
Swimming the Thames question 1a and bSwimming the Thames question 1a and b
Swimming the Thames question 1a and bTpaisey
 
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundation
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundationSection a questions 1 to 4 for foundation
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundationTpaisey
 
How to answer Q4
How to answer Q4How to answer Q4
How to answer Q4Tpaisey
 
Foundation question breakdown guide
Foundation question breakdown guideFoundation question breakdown guide
Foundation question breakdown guideTpaisey
 

Mehr von Tpaisey (18)

Poetry across time jan 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time jan 2012 mark schemePoetry across time jan 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time jan 2012 mark scheme
 
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paperPoetry across time jan 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time jan 2012 higher paper
 
Poetry across time 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time 2012 mark schemePoetry across time 2012 mark scheme
Poetry across time 2012 mark scheme
 
Poetry across time 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time 2012 higher paperPoetry across time 2012 higher paper
Poetry across time 2012 higher paper
 
Writing to infom and explain
Writing to infom and explainWriting to infom and explain
Writing to infom and explain
 
Writing to describe poster
Writing to describe posterWriting to describe poster
Writing to describe poster
 
Writing to persuade
Writing to persuadeWriting to persuade
Writing to persuade
 
Writing to argue
Writing to argueWriting to argue
Writing to argue
 
Sentence variety poster
Sentence variety posterSentence variety poster
Sentence variety poster
 
Punctuation poster
Punctuation posterPunctuation poster
Punctuation poster
 
Tip top paragraphs
Tip top paragraphsTip top paragraphs
Tip top paragraphs
 
Pictures to prompt creative writing
Pictures to prompt creative writingPictures to prompt creative writing
Pictures to prompt creative writing
 
Question 2 Andy Murray
Question 2 Andy MurrayQuestion 2 Andy Murray
Question 2 Andy Murray
 
Question 2 simon cowell
Question 2 simon cowellQuestion 2 simon cowell
Question 2 simon cowell
 
Swimming the Thames question 1a and b
Swimming the Thames question 1a and bSwimming the Thames question 1a and b
Swimming the Thames question 1a and b
 
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundation
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundationSection a questions 1 to 4 for foundation
Section a questions 1 to 4 for foundation
 
How to answer Q4
How to answer Q4How to answer Q4
How to answer Q4
 
Foundation question breakdown guide
Foundation question breakdown guideFoundation question breakdown guide
Foundation question breakdown guide
 

Analysis of 'Nettles' by Vernon Scannell

  • 2. Background & Context Vernon Scannell (1922−2007) was originally from West Yorkshire. Joined the war at age 18. His name was originally Bain, but he changed it shortly after World War II as he had deserted from the army. He did this twice – on the second occasion, they put him into a mental hospital before being released. His negative feelings about the effects of war have been a prevailing influence on his work – he was awarded the Wilfred Owen Association award for significant contributions to war poetry. Scannell had 6 children of which 2 died. 1 son died as an infant and 1 son died in a motor cycle crash.
  • 3. Key Themes in ‘Nettles’ War Violence Danger
  • 4. The Relationship: A father protecting his son from the dangers of a dark, menacing world in which nobody and nothing can be trusted. Nature will attack you, be cut down, grow back and fight you again…just as the military will hunt you down and find you if you leave without consent. Scannell is protecting his son from a world he hates and fears.
  • 5. ‘Nettles’ My son aged three fell in the nettle bed. 'Bed' seemed a curious name for those green spears, That regiment of spite behind the shed: It was no place for rest. With sobs and tears The boy came seeking comfort and I saw White blisters beaded on his tender skin. We soothed him till his pain was not so raw. At last he offered us a watery grin, And then I took my billhook, honed the blade And went outside and slashed in fury with it Till not a nettle in that fierce parade Stood upright any more. And then I lit A funeral pyre to burn the fallen dead, But in two weeks the busy sun and rain Had called up tall recruits behind the shed: My son would often feel sharp wounds again. http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/english_literature/poetryrelationships /nettlesact.shtml
  • 6. The full stop at the end of the first line could indicate the Possessive pronoun forcefulness at which ‘my’ indicates the the narrator’s son protectiveness of the ‘fell’. It is also a father. His son belongs moment of to him contemplation. My son aged three fell in the nettle bed. The first line highlights The verb ‘fell’ the sons age – 3 – and suggests that this is immediately implies an accident that he is vulnerable.
  • 7. Line 2 is the longest ‘Bed’ suggests a place of line in the poem. The comfort and rest which is metaphor of ‘spears’ the complete opposite of presents the nettles as the ‘nettle’ bed. violent aggressors. He is representing them as if they are the army. ‘Bed’ seemed a curious name for those green spears, The fact that they are That regiment of spite behind the shed: ‘behind’ the shed The nettles are suggests personified – a that they are Suggests that there are military image of the planning a lot of them in contrast nettles commencing their attack. to the lone boy. their war against the son.
  • 8. Scannell uses a variety of soft ‘s’ sounds using alliteration and assonance to emphasise the soothing of his injured son. It was no place for rest. With sobs and tears The boy came seeking comfort and I saw
  • 9. The alliteration intensifies the reality of the detailed description. The plosive ‘b’ sounds suggest an eruption of blisters. White blisters beaded on his tender skin. The nettles have The careful use of the adjective painfully decorated the ‘tender’ emphasises the young boy’s skin. innocence of the boy, contrasted with the violence of the nettles.
  • 10. ‘Soothing’ is an action that The boy needs both is usually carried out with parental units to make him babies. ‘Soothing’ helps feel safe and secure. them to feel calm and comforted. We soothed him till his pain was not so raw. At last he offered us a watery grin, The ‘watery grin’ is An opposing image – the another emotive merging of laughter or description implying that comfort or relief with the the child is being helped tears of the pain from the to get over his painful sting of the nettles. experience by his loving parents.
  • 11. The verb ‘honed’ shows how the father is preparing an attack of his own. He is carefully sharpening his blade to make it more efficient when he faces the nettles. It demonstrates a careful, calculating manner. And then I took my hook and honed the blade Reference to a bayonet? Hook = scythe And went outside and slashed in fury with it The father’s actions are He is relentless in as violent as the nettle his desire to stings. protect his son.
  • 12. Again the extended metaphor illustrates his anger at his past and the ongoing battle against them. Till not a nettle in that fierce parade
  • 13. The caesura in the Emphasises middle of the line Scannell’s here highlights a military past. brief pause in the father’s ongoing battle to protect his child. Stood upright any more. Next task: I lit A funeral pyre to burn the fallen dead. The full stop indicates that the father thinks that this is the end of the nettles and that he has defeated them. It actually sounds as if he is burning dead bodies of the injured.
  • 14. You can not fight nature But in two weeks the busy sun and rain Had called up tall recruits behind the shed: Suggests that the battle is futile. Re-enforcements have come to replace those who have died. War will go on and on until peace is declared.
  • 15. The last line emphasises the father’s realisation of his inability to protect his son from life’s pain. It is inevitable that his son will feel ‘wounds’ throughout life, whatever a parent may do to prevent it. My son would often feel sharp wounds again.