SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
Download to read offline
Swedbank Analysis                                                                No. 6  18 June 2012




    Post-election Greece: 10 questions and answers
     Although New Democracy has won the Greek
      election by a slight majority, there is still considerable
      uncertainty how a government will be formed. New
      Democracy and Pasok together would have a
      majority, but it is unclear how the reform package will
      be implemented considering that these parties didn't
      previously take ownership of it.
     Signals that the euro countries are willing to ease the
      reform package should be seen largely as a symbolic
      gesture to improve negotiations with the new
      government and strike a softer balance between
      austerity and growth. For the most part, the package
      remains unchanged, though the timetable to meet the
      terms could be expanded. It would be positive if the
      deadline to decide on 11 billion euros in cutbacks
      were delayed slightly.
     Initially positive market reactions are a sign of relief
      that Syriza didn’t win the election, which would have
      increased the risk of a Greek default and exit from
      the euro cooperation. Given the uncertainty still
      swirling around the government, the fact that
      parliament is in no position to decide on cutbacks
      and that a payment default still can’t be ruled out,
      market concerns are likely to increase once again.
      There is also a risk that the government won’t last
      and a new election will have to be called after the
      summer. Even if Greece manages to reverse its
      slide, it will take years to turn the economy around.

              Economic Research Department, Swedbank AB (publ), SE-105 34 Stockholm, tel +46 (0)8-5859 7740
e-mail: ek.sekr@swedbank.com Internet: www.swedbank.com Responsible publisher: Cecilia Hermansson +46 (0)8-5859 7720.
                Magnus Alvesson +46 (0)8-5859 3341, Jörgen Kennemar +46 (0)8-5859 7730 ISSN 1103-4897
Question 1: What do the election results
show?
New Democracy has won the Greek election by a slight margin.          New Democracy has
With practically all the votes counted (99.86%), it took 129 seats    won, but what the
in parliament, with the leftist coalition Syriza winning 71 and       government will look
Pasok 33. Syriza’s leader, Alexis Tsipras, has congratulated his      like is unclear
New Democracy counterpart, Antonis Samaras, on the victory.
In all likelihood, Samaras will be named the new prime minister
of a coalition government, though there is still considerable
uncertainty how a government will be formed.

According to Greek law, the party that wins the most votes
receives an additional 50 seats in parliament, so the difference
between New Democracy and Syriza was actually much
smaller, 29.7% vs. 26.9%, or 79 seats vs. 71 seats without the
extra 50. Pasok received 12.3% of the votes, down from the
May election. The extreme right Golden Dawn party received
about the same share of votes as the May 6 election, 6.9%, and
18 seats. This gives it a place in parliament and underscores a
widespread displeasure with the established parties.

The young – many urban and without work – voted more for the
leftist alternative, Syriza, while more older and wealthier voters
chose the New Democracy center-right alternative. It's worth
noting that a majority of the population didn’t vote for either of
the two parties that are expected to form a government.

Question 2: What do the results mean for
Greece?
It is unclear how the government will turn out. New Democracy         New Democracy and
didn’t receive a majority and has to form a coalition. Pasok          Pasok may eventually
announced early on that unless Syriza was part of the                 govern, but haven’t
government it wouldn’t join, but Syriza prefers to be in              previously taken
opposition (with the possibility of gaining greater support if the    responsibility for the
new government fails).                                                reform process

If New Democracy manages to persuade Pasok, the traditional
parties will have a majority and regain power (162 of 300 seats
in parliament). These two parties have signed the loan
agreement with the so-called troika (the IMF, EU Commission
and European Central Bank, ECB). While they intend to fight for
less onerous terms, there has been no mention of tearing up
the entire package as with Syriza. This increases the likelihood
that Greece will accept austerity and remain in the euro zone.

Pasok and New Democracy haven't previously shown a
willingness to comply with the reform package. Many of the
terms haven’t been met and the measures have been delayed.
This includes liberalizing the guild system and product markets,
privatizing state enterprises and improving tax collection.
Although the major decline in the Greek stock exchange
complicates privatizations, a slightly faster pace of government
sell-offs is possible.




2                                                           Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
The question is how the new government will reform the country
and whether it will be able to stay in power for any length of
time considering the many challenges and the differing opinions
between New Democracy (with a right-leaning ideology) and
Pasok (more leftist) about what has to be done.

Even if a new government is formed, there are still several
challenges before it is certain whether a euro zone exit can be
avoided. A decision first has to be made about 11 billion euro in
austerity before the euro zone will release its next payment. If
this doesn't happen, there is a risk Greece will default on its
payments on July 20, when it says it will run out of money. Until
then bank withdrawals will continue, which could eventually
result in an exit from the currency union if it isn't stopped.

Question 3: What would have happened if
Syriza had formed a government?
If Syriza had won the election, received the extra 50 seats and     Syriza promised voters
found willing coalition partners to form a government, the          they could keep the
situation would have been quite different. Those who voted for      euro – but without
Syriza wanted to see politicians who hadn't previously been         meeting the terms of
responsible for the country’s mismanagement and neglect.            the reform package
They had also hoped that the country could keep the euro, but
without taking the measures associated with budget discipline
and improved competitiveness. Syriza campaigned on keeping
the euro, the emergency loans and the write-offs, but wants to
tear up the austerity package, which they feel is unrealistic.
Instead Syriza would have introduced a national reconstruction
program based on its left-leaning policies.

Had the austerity program been torn up as Syriza promised,
lenders would have probably frozen the emergency loans and
Greece would default on its payments – first in the form of
domestic payments for salaries and pensions and then to
foreign lenders. Syriza had planned to use the interest
payments on the foreign loans to invest in growth.

With even more bank withdrawals, capital flight and bank panic,
Greece would have had to transition back to its old currency,
the drachma, which would probably be valued at 40-50% of the
euro. This would help exports but make imports that much more
expensive. The Greek central bank would have had to print a lot
of money to capitalize the nationalized banks and finance the
government budget, which isn’t yet generating a primary
surplus, i.e., excluding interest payments. With higher import
prices and overheated printing presses, inflation would have
risen to double digits and interest rates would have
skyrocketed.

Syriza, which had promised not to trim the state apparatus, has
at the same time announced that it would raise tax revenues.
The question is whether it would have succeeded in markedly
changing taxpayer behavior in the short term. It is more likely
that little would have come of the party’s election promises.




Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012                                                   3
Turbulence in the financial markets, capital flight and
significantly lower asset values would have also led to corporate
bankruptcies, higher unemployment and the risk of political
instability.

Because the new currency would have cut the wealth of Greek
citizens (and GDP) in half after a euro exit, at the same time
that foreign debt in euro wouldn't have changed in value, a
payment default would have been necessary and led to
increased isolation from investors, lenders and even the EU and
IMF. There would have also been a risk that Greece would have
had to leave the EU.

Geopolitically, Greece’s new friends would have probably
included Russia, China and Venezuela. Tension with Turkey
still exists, and huge cuts in the military budget (from very high
levels) would have increased in the dependence on alliance
partners outside NATO.

Question 4: If the parties don’t manage to
form a government, what will happen?
The parties have already declared that it is crucial a                 A new election after
government is formed fairly quickly, so there is probably room         the summer can't be
for compromise.                                                        ruled out

There is still a possibility, however, that the parties will fail to
form a government. For example, there is a risk that Pasok will
not want to govern with New Democracy, since it could be hurt
by supporting policies that go against its core beliefs. Syriza has
already taken over many of Pasok’s supporters. That makes a
new election a possibility. Until then a caretaker government
could be formed, which would delay any difficult decisions and
increase uncertainty and turbulence in the financial markets.

A new election is also a possibility if a new government fails to
last, one of the parties drops out and a majority is no longer in
place to execute the policy. There are fears this could happen
as soon as after the summer.

Question 5: How likely is it that lenders will
accept renegotiated terms?
Even before the election results were finalized, Germany’s             It is reasonable to
Foreign Minister, Guido Westerwelle, suggested that the                expect that lenders will
austerity could be eased. It is likely, however, that the troika and   ease some of their
the euro countries would have handled a Syriza-led government          terms
differently. If Syriza had won, it would have been harder to see
the troika meet the new government halfway due to Syriza’s
populist rhetoric and the policies it wants to implement,
including nationalizing formerly public institutions and
maintaining the relatively large public sector – contrary to the
bailout package.




4                                                            Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
On the other hand, if New Democracy succeeds in forming a
government with Pasok, there is the possibility that the troika
and the heads of the euro zone will agree to ease their
demands. This could include extending the deadline for meeting
the terms (a delay in deciding on 11 billion euros in spending
cuts would be welcome), as well as investments that facilitate a
transition to economic growth.

It is also important that Germany shows empathy for the
difficulties faced by the Greek people now that unemployment
has risen to over 22% and where measures are needed to
assist the many young unemployed in particular. The troika and
euro countries also have to convince the financial markets that
austerity is realistic. Otherwise concerns will continue to spread
to other crisis countries.

Question 6: What do the election results
mean for the euro zone?
The election results increase the likelihood that Greece will        The euro countries are
abide by the terms of the bailout package and not exit the euro      likely to ease terms
zone. This is provided that the new government supports the          somewhat, but there is
package and we don't see a government crisis in the near term.       still a risk of a Greek
It is also important that the wave of recent withdrawals in the      exit
banking sector can be stopped. The ECB has to support the
Greek central bank and facilitate a capitalization, so that the
bank panic doesn't worsen and spread to other crisis countries.

To receive the next payment, parliament has to find 11 billion
euros in spending cuts, which could prove difficult and create
concerns about a default despite the formation of a new
government. Moreover, it is unclear how the new government
will follow the program, i.e., how quickly reforms can be
implemented and in what way. Without a willingness to reform,
there is a risk that the package will fall apart and spark renewed
uncertainty about Greece’s place in the currency union.

We cannot rule out, therefore, that Greece’s fate will remain
uncertain despite the outcome of the election. In a Greek exit,
the euro zone’s taxpayers would lose over 100 billion euros that
the Greek central bank owes the other central banks through
the Target2 system. Without an exit, it’s more of an accounting
question how the funds will be adjusted between euro countries
within the central banking system, but if Greece is no longer
part of this system the other euro countries (mainly Germany,
which is responsible for about a third) will have to pay the cost.

Lenders will also lose money if Greece exits the currency union.
The ECB has purchased Greek bonds valued at 56 billion euro.
The euro countries have lent Greece 161 billion euros and the
IMF 22 billion. European banks have receivables from Greece
through government bonds they purchased for 55 billion (after
write-offs). International banks still have receivables from Greek
businesses and households worth 69 billion, of which French
banks (37 billion) are most at risk, while British (8 billion) and




Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012                                                     5
German banks (6 billion) are slightly less exposed. This doesn't
include the insurance companies and pension funds that have
purchased Greek corporate bonds.

Another important factor if Greece exits the euro zone is
whether the contagion will spread. The first to be affected would
probably be Cyprus, which has awaited the election results
before formally requesting emergency loans from the EU, ECB
and IMF. It’s possible that the country will need emergency
loans of up to 50% of GDP to capitalize its banks, or about 9
billion euros. Foreign banks have an exposure of 36 billion
euros.

There would also be expectations that Portugal and Ireland
would have to give up the euro, creating further turbulence and
raising risk premiums and financing costs for these two
countries. Even worse is the possibility that this would then
spread to larger countries such as Spain, which already faces
problems in its banking sector, and Italy, whose high debt and
weak competitiveness are worrying markets. Withdrawals from
Greek banks are a problem, but would be even more so if the
contagion spreads to Spanish and Italian banks.

It is equally important how a Greek exit would affect the euro
collaboration in general. A country cannot officially leave the
currency union, but if one or more did so nonetheless,
confidence in the currency would wane. To date the euro has
lost fairly little against other currencies, although its slide has
accelerated of late. If Greece exits, confidence in the euro
would be affected. On the one hand, the currency union would
be hurt by its increased fragility. On the other, it could be helped
by having a weak member drop out and the stronger ones
remain.

Integration in the euro zone would probably be affected as well.
The crisis has accelerated changes in its institutions, and the
pace of reform could slow if instability is reduced. If more
countries exit the euro zone, however, there is a risk that the
EU will also be affected, which could mean less integration in a
number of areas.

Question 7: What kind of market reaction
can we expect?
The outcome of the Greek collection on June 17 should please           The equity and
the financial markets. Asian stock markets have risen and the          currency markets have
euro has strengthened slightly. The results have to be seen as         initially reacted
a relief, since the party that wanted to tear up the austerity         positively, but their joy
program didn't win. The risk of an exit from the currency union        could be short lived
has temporarily declined, and the new government will provide
a counterparty for the troika to negotiate with. The pace of
reform should increase compared with the caretaker
government and former technocratic government that led the
country in recent months.




6                                                            Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
The focus of the financial markets has already shifted to Spain
and Italy and eventually will turn to France. The serious
situation facing Spanish banks is also affecting French banks,
and by extension the budgets of both countries. The financial
market is carefully monitoring what the euro zone is doing to
strengthen its institutions and to form a banking union with a
single regulator, a deposit guarantee and resolution practices.
Another priority is how support can be transferred directly from
the structural funds to the banks without raising national debts,
as happened in Ireland and now most recently Spain.

Question 8: How serious is the situation in
the Greek economy?
The situation in the Greek economy is grave. The onslaught of       Greece is not in
withdrawals from banks shows a lack of confidence that a euro       recession – it's more of
exit will be prevented. Hospitals and energy companies cannot       a depression
pay their bills, and without new emergency loans the state will
default by the end of next month. Greece is in its fifth year of
recession. Between 2007 and 2011 the economy shrunk by just
over 13%, and an additional loss of 5-6% is expected this year.
It would seem that Greece is actually experiencing a depression
considering its lost production, high unemployment and
collapse of its economic system.

Greece’s GDP growth (%)




Unemployment exceeds 22% for the population as a whole, but
is around 50% for young adults. One in five people work in
tourism, which is being hurt by uncertainty. The election results
could all generate more last-minute travelers if a government
can be formed and stability is achieved.




Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012                                                     7
Unemployment in several euro countries, % of workforce




The Greek economy has been weak for several years.
Competitiveness is clearly trending lower with rising unit labor
costs due to low productivity growth and rapidly rising labor
costs.

Unit labor costs in manufacturing, index 2000 = 100
                                                            180,00
                                                            170,00
                                                            160,00
                                                            150,00        DE
                                                            140,00        ES
                                                            130,00        FR

                                                            120,00        EL
                                                                          IE
                                                            110,00
                                                                          IT
                                                            100,00
                                                            90,00
                                                            80,00
    1996   1998   2000   2002   2004   2006   2008   2010


The low interest rates in connection with the nominal
convergence of the money and bond markets drove real estate
prices higher, which in turn raised consumer prices and reduced
real interest rates. Imports grew substantially, while exports
developed more modestly. The result was a large current
account deficit, which is now being reduced by the slowdown in
the economy and collapse in imports. The key, however, is to
implement reforms that raise competitiveness, not only by
cutting wages and pensions but by improving productivity.




8                                                                    Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
Current account balance in several EU countries, % of GDP
Percent




Question 9: What does Greece have to do
to turn around?
It is important that the new government implements reforms that     Greece has to
improve competitiveness in the economy as a whole and               implement extensive
budget discipline in the state apparatus. According to question     structural reforms – a
8, competitiveness has declined throughout the 2000’s, while        necessity with any
Greece was unable to devalue and costs rose faster than in          currency system
competing countries. Budget discipline was worse than first
reported when Greece entered the euro zone, which means
that the budget deficit was larger and government debt had
increased more. The key now is to balance revenue and
spending, which means a downsizing of the public sector as
well as better tax collection and taxpayer ethics.

Competition in product markets is being held in check by the
guilds that protect various professional groups. Liberalization
would benefit consumers and stimulate growth. State-owned
enterprises have to be privatized in order to increase
productivity and efficiency. To date the pace of reform has been
slow, but it is critical that the austerity package agreed to is
followed at the same time that weak groups are better
protected.

Greece’s politicians haven't supported the reform package yet,
which creates a risk that it will fail. The new government has to
take responsibility and ownership for the economy. This will be




Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012                                                       9
the most important element in the negotiations between the
troika and the government, which means that the troika has to
agree to concessions and the government has to take over the
program. It is uncertain whether this will happen considering
that the parties – the same ones that signed the agreement –
haven’t taken responsibility so far.

Question 10: What do developments in
Greece mean for the Nordic and Baltic
regions?
Only Finland and Estonia, as euro members, are affected by the          The Nordic and
negotiations with the Greek government on terms and loan                Baltic countries are
programs. Although it is unlikely that more money will be given         mainly being affected
to Greece, an extended deadline to meet the terms could make            through export and
the program more expensive.                                             investment markets

If a government is successfully formed and an exit from the
currency union is avoided, the election results could mean a
slight improvement in the euro zone’s situation thanks to
increased stability. This would benefit exports and investment in
the Nordic and Baltic region as well. Less uncertainty would
also help the economy by encouraging households and
businesses to spend and invest.

Many questions still remain, however, and concerns about
Spain and Italy have grown. Greece has taken a small step in
the right direction, but there is still a risk that it may default on
its payments and exit the euro zone – a risk that continues to
create concerns about the euro zone, but also for Europe,
including the Nordic and Baltic regions. It will take many years
to strengthen the institutions in the euro zone, improve
conditions in the crisis countries and create stability and growth.
Until then northern Europe will see its key export markets grow
below their potential. Creating increased political stability is
imperative if the countries are also going to tackle their
economic challenges.

                                               Cecilia Hermansson




10                                                            Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
Economic Research Department




                 Sweden
                    Cecilia Hermansson                    +46 8 5859 7720       cecilia.hermansson@swedbank.se
                    Group Chief Economist
                    Chief Economist, Sweden
                    Magnus Alvesson                       +46 8 5859 3341       magnus.alvesson@swedbank.se
                    Head of Economic Forecasting
                    Jörgen Kennemar                       +46 8 5859 7730       jorgen.kennemar@swedbank.se
                    Senior Economist
                    Anna Ibegbulem                        +46 8 5859 7740       anna.ibegbulem@swedbank.se
                    Assistant

                 Estonia
                    Annika Paabut                         +372 888 5440         annika.paabut@swedbank.ee
                    Chief Economist, Estonia
                    Elina Allikalt                        +372 888 1989         elina.allikalt@swedbank.ee
                    Senior Economist

                 Latvia
                    Mārtiņš Kazāks                        +371 67 445 859       martins.kazaks@swedbank.lv
                    Deputy Group Chief Economist
                    Chief Economist, Latvia
                    Dainis Stikuts                        +371 67 445 844       dainis.stikuts@swedbank.lv
                    Senior Economist
                    Lija Strašuna                         +371 67 445 875       lija.strasuna@swedbank.lv
                    Senior Economist

                 Lithuania
                    Nerijus Mačiulis                      +370 5 258 2237       nerijus.maciulis@swedbank.lt
                    Chief Economist, Lithuania
                    Lina Vrubliauskienė                   +370 5 258 2275       lina.vrubliauskiene@swedbank.lt
                    Senior Economist
                    Vaiva Šečkutė                         +370 5 258 2156       vaiva.seckute@swedbank.lt
                    Senior Economist




Economic Research
Department                         Swedbank Analysis is published as a service to our customers. We believe
                                   that we have used reliable sources and methods in the preparation of the
SE-105 34 Stockholm                analyses reported in this publication. However, we cannot guarantee the
Telephone +46-(0)8-5859 7740       accuracy or completeness of the report and cannot be held responsible for
ek.sekr@swedbank.se
www.swedbank.se
                                   any error or omission in the underlying material or its use. Readers are
                                   encouraged to base any (investment) decisions on other material as well.
Legally responsible publisher      Neither Swedbank nor its employees may be held responsible for losses or
Cecilia Hermansson,
                                   damages, direct or indirect, owing to any errors or omissions in Swedbank
+46-8-5859 7720.
                                   Analysis.
ISSN 1103-4897




                 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012                                                           11

More Related Content

What's hot

General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI Consulting
General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI ConsultingGeneral Election Briefing 2015 by FTI Consulting
General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI ConsultingJohn Gusman
 
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...Olivier Desbarres
 
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...Mike Betty
 
Political inertia
Political inertiaPolitical inertia
Political inertiaGed Mirfin
 
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalClient Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalDuff & Phelps
 
Investment outlook 2022
Investment outlook 2022 Investment outlook 2022
Investment outlook 2022 LaThoa
 
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18Brian Ducey
 
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary Scrutiny
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary ScrutinyOne Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary Scrutiny
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary ScrutinyHarry Shackleton
 
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018Duff & Phelps
 

What's hot (13)

Tda sample
Tda sampleTda sample
Tda sample
 
General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI Consulting
General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI ConsultingGeneral Election Briefing 2015 by FTI Consulting
General Election Briefing 2015 by FTI Consulting
 
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...
olivier Desbarres: The A-Team had a plan, the British government has a nebulo...
 
UK Industry Report Q216
UK Industry Report Q216UK Industry Report Q216
UK Industry Report Q216
 
16TAP YearEndLetter 2016
16TAP YearEndLetter 201616TAP YearEndLetter 2016
16TAP YearEndLetter 2016
 
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
 
Political inertia
Political inertiaPolitical inertia
Political inertia
 
EU elections snapshot
EU elections snapshotEU elections snapshot
EU elections snapshot
 
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of CapitalClient Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
Client Alert: Brexit - The Impact on Cost of Capital
 
Investment outlook 2022
Investment outlook 2022 Investment outlook 2022
Investment outlook 2022
 
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18
Hammerstone report closing -1-23-18
 
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary Scrutiny
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary ScrutinyOne Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary Scrutiny
One Party State? Select Committees: The Changing Face of Parliamentary Scrutiny
 
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018
Capital Markets Insights Summer 2018
 

Viewers also liked

The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011Swedbank
 
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012Swedbank
 
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011Swedbank
 
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011 Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011 Swedbank
 
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012Swedbank
 
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012Swedbank
 
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012Swedbank
 
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012Swedbank
 
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011 The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011 Swedbank
 

Viewers also liked (9)

The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
 
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012
The Estonian Economy, No. 1 - June 21, 2012
 
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011
Housing Affordability Index for Baltics - December 14, 2011
 
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011 Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011
Energy & Commodities, No. 10 - December 14, 2011
 
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index May 2012
 
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012
Energy & Commodities, No. 6 - June 8, 2012
 
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012
Purchasing Managers' Index Services - February 2012
 
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012
Swedbank Analysis No.8 - June 28, 2012
 
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011 The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011
The Swedish Economy No.9 - December 22, 2011
 

Similar to Swedbank Analysis Post-election Greece: 10 questions and answers

10 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 201510 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 2015123jumpad
 
Greece back from the brink
Greece back from the brinkGreece back from the brink
Greece back from the brinktheodekort
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)Fasanara Capital ltd
 
Example of greece rebellious against financial capital
Example of greece rebellious against financial capitalExample of greece rebellious against financial capital
Example of greece rebellious against financial capitalFernando Alcoforado
 
Continental Drift - An analysis of global political risk (2012)
Continental Drift -  An analysis of global political risk (2012)Continental Drift -  An analysis of global political risk (2012)
Continental Drift - An analysis of global political risk (2012)Vikas Sharma
 
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012Swedbank
 
The Global Economy No. 4 - May 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 4 -  May 16, 2012The Global Economy No. 4 -  May 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 4 - May 16, 2012Swedbank
 
Why Obama is wrong
Why Obama is wrongWhy Obama is wrong
Why Obama is wrongdionesius3
 
Why Obama Is Wrong
Why Obama Is WrongWhy Obama Is Wrong
Why Obama Is Wrongdionesius3
 
Greece end of chapter one
Greece end of chapter oneGreece end of chapter one
Greece end of chapter oneMarkets Beyond
 
To the Point, 2010, April 30
To the Point, 2010, April 30To the Point, 2010, April 30
To the Point, 2010, April 30Swedbank
 
Global Powers of Retailing 2013
Global Powers of Retailing 2013Global Powers of Retailing 2013
Global Powers of Retailing 2013Melih ÖZCANLI
 
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017UKinBrazilNetwork
 
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?Olivier Desbarres
 
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?FTI Consulting FR
 
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama QNB Group
 
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plan
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform PlanPortugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plan
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plandotsondtffnizuri
 

Similar to Swedbank Analysis Post-election Greece: 10 questions and answers (20)

10 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 201510 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 2015
 
Greece back from the brink
Greece back from the brinkGreece back from the brink
Greece back from the brink
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook June 2012 (published May 25th)
 
Example of greece rebellious against financial capital
Example of greece rebellious against financial capitalExample of greece rebellious against financial capital
Example of greece rebellious against financial capital
 
Continental Drift - An analysis of global political risk (2012)
Continental Drift -  An analysis of global political risk (2012)Continental Drift -  An analysis of global political risk (2012)
Continental Drift - An analysis of global political risk (2012)
 
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012
To the Point, No.3 - March 30, 2012
 
The Global Economy No. 4 - May 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 4 -  May 16, 2012The Global Economy No. 4 -  May 16, 2012
The Global Economy No. 4 - May 16, 2012
 
Why Obama is wrong
Why Obama is wrongWhy Obama is wrong
Why Obama is wrong
 
Why Obama Is Wrong
Why Obama Is WrongWhy Obama Is Wrong
Why Obama Is Wrong
 
Greece end of chapter one
Greece end of chapter oneGreece end of chapter one
Greece end of chapter one
 
To the Point, 2010, April 30
To the Point, 2010, April 30To the Point, 2010, April 30
To the Point, 2010, April 30
 
Global Powers of Retailing 2013
Global Powers of Retailing 2013Global Powers of Retailing 2013
Global Powers of Retailing 2013
 
Afm
AfmAfm
Afm
 
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017
Brazil Economic Focus | June 2017
 
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?
Olivier desbarres asks are greece in the last chance saloon?
 
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?
Greek elections: anger overcame fear, but is there hope?
 
Greece lightening
Greece lighteningGreece lightening
Greece lightening
 
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama
Little Global Spillover from the Greek Drama
 
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plan
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform PlanPortugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plan
Portugal Struggles to Generate Reform Plan
 
Trying to make sense of economic policy pt1
Trying to make sense of economic policy pt1Trying to make sense of economic policy pt1
Trying to make sense of economic policy pt1
 

More from Swedbank

Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank
 
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Swedbank
 
Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Swedbank
 
Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Swedbank
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank
 
Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Swedbank
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank
 

More from Swedbank (20)

Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation April 25 2017
 
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
Swedbank foretagspresentation 25 april 2017
 
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017Delårsrapport kv1 2017
Delårsrapport kv1 2017
 
Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017Interim report q1 2017
Interim report q1 2017
 
Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016Year end report 2016
Year end report 2016
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016Bokslutskommuniké 2016
Bokslutskommuniké 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
Swedbank företagspresentation, 2 februari 2017
 
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
Swedbank corporate presentation, February 2 2017
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, October 25 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 25 oktober 2016
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, June 30 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
Swedbank företagspresentation, 30 juni 2016
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
Swedbank corporate presentation Q1, 2016
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 1, 2016.
 
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
Swedbank corporate presentation Q4, 2015
 
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
Swedbank företagspresentation kvartal 4,2015
 
Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015Year end report 2015
Year end report 2015
 
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015Bokslutskommuniké 2015
Bokslutskommuniké 2015
 
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
Swedbank Företagspresentation, September 2015
 
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
Swedbank Corporate Presentation, September 2015
 

Recently uploaded

Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendFabwelt
 
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.NaveedKhaskheli1
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeAbdulGhani778830
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkbhavenpr
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest2
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012ankitnayak356677
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkbhavenpr
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsnaxymaxyy
 
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdfGerald Furnkranz
 

Recently uploaded (10)

Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
 
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
 
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
 

Swedbank Analysis Post-election Greece: 10 questions and answers

  • 1. Swedbank Analysis No. 6  18 June 2012 Post-election Greece: 10 questions and answers  Although New Democracy has won the Greek election by a slight majority, there is still considerable uncertainty how a government will be formed. New Democracy and Pasok together would have a majority, but it is unclear how the reform package will be implemented considering that these parties didn't previously take ownership of it.  Signals that the euro countries are willing to ease the reform package should be seen largely as a symbolic gesture to improve negotiations with the new government and strike a softer balance between austerity and growth. For the most part, the package remains unchanged, though the timetable to meet the terms could be expanded. It would be positive if the deadline to decide on 11 billion euros in cutbacks were delayed slightly.  Initially positive market reactions are a sign of relief that Syriza didn’t win the election, which would have increased the risk of a Greek default and exit from the euro cooperation. Given the uncertainty still swirling around the government, the fact that parliament is in no position to decide on cutbacks and that a payment default still can’t be ruled out, market concerns are likely to increase once again. There is also a risk that the government won’t last and a new election will have to be called after the summer. Even if Greece manages to reverse its slide, it will take years to turn the economy around. Economic Research Department, Swedbank AB (publ), SE-105 34 Stockholm, tel +46 (0)8-5859 7740 e-mail: ek.sekr@swedbank.com Internet: www.swedbank.com Responsible publisher: Cecilia Hermansson +46 (0)8-5859 7720. Magnus Alvesson +46 (0)8-5859 3341, Jörgen Kennemar +46 (0)8-5859 7730 ISSN 1103-4897
  • 2. Question 1: What do the election results show? New Democracy has won the Greek election by a slight margin. New Democracy has With practically all the votes counted (99.86%), it took 129 seats won, but what the in parliament, with the leftist coalition Syriza winning 71 and government will look Pasok 33. Syriza’s leader, Alexis Tsipras, has congratulated his like is unclear New Democracy counterpart, Antonis Samaras, on the victory. In all likelihood, Samaras will be named the new prime minister of a coalition government, though there is still considerable uncertainty how a government will be formed. According to Greek law, the party that wins the most votes receives an additional 50 seats in parliament, so the difference between New Democracy and Syriza was actually much smaller, 29.7% vs. 26.9%, or 79 seats vs. 71 seats without the extra 50. Pasok received 12.3% of the votes, down from the May election. The extreme right Golden Dawn party received about the same share of votes as the May 6 election, 6.9%, and 18 seats. This gives it a place in parliament and underscores a widespread displeasure with the established parties. The young – many urban and without work – voted more for the leftist alternative, Syriza, while more older and wealthier voters chose the New Democracy center-right alternative. It's worth noting that a majority of the population didn’t vote for either of the two parties that are expected to form a government. Question 2: What do the results mean for Greece? It is unclear how the government will turn out. New Democracy New Democracy and didn’t receive a majority and has to form a coalition. Pasok Pasok may eventually announced early on that unless Syriza was part of the govern, but haven’t government it wouldn’t join, but Syriza prefers to be in previously taken opposition (with the possibility of gaining greater support if the responsibility for the new government fails). reform process If New Democracy manages to persuade Pasok, the traditional parties will have a majority and regain power (162 of 300 seats in parliament). These two parties have signed the loan agreement with the so-called troika (the IMF, EU Commission and European Central Bank, ECB). While they intend to fight for less onerous terms, there has been no mention of tearing up the entire package as with Syriza. This increases the likelihood that Greece will accept austerity and remain in the euro zone. Pasok and New Democracy haven't previously shown a willingness to comply with the reform package. Many of the terms haven’t been met and the measures have been delayed. This includes liberalizing the guild system and product markets, privatizing state enterprises and improving tax collection. Although the major decline in the Greek stock exchange complicates privatizations, a slightly faster pace of government sell-offs is possible. 2 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
  • 3. The question is how the new government will reform the country and whether it will be able to stay in power for any length of time considering the many challenges and the differing opinions between New Democracy (with a right-leaning ideology) and Pasok (more leftist) about what has to be done. Even if a new government is formed, there are still several challenges before it is certain whether a euro zone exit can be avoided. A decision first has to be made about 11 billion euro in austerity before the euro zone will release its next payment. If this doesn't happen, there is a risk Greece will default on its payments on July 20, when it says it will run out of money. Until then bank withdrawals will continue, which could eventually result in an exit from the currency union if it isn't stopped. Question 3: What would have happened if Syriza had formed a government? If Syriza had won the election, received the extra 50 seats and Syriza promised voters found willing coalition partners to form a government, the they could keep the situation would have been quite different. Those who voted for euro – but without Syriza wanted to see politicians who hadn't previously been meeting the terms of responsible for the country’s mismanagement and neglect. the reform package They had also hoped that the country could keep the euro, but without taking the measures associated with budget discipline and improved competitiveness. Syriza campaigned on keeping the euro, the emergency loans and the write-offs, but wants to tear up the austerity package, which they feel is unrealistic. Instead Syriza would have introduced a national reconstruction program based on its left-leaning policies. Had the austerity program been torn up as Syriza promised, lenders would have probably frozen the emergency loans and Greece would default on its payments – first in the form of domestic payments for salaries and pensions and then to foreign lenders. Syriza had planned to use the interest payments on the foreign loans to invest in growth. With even more bank withdrawals, capital flight and bank panic, Greece would have had to transition back to its old currency, the drachma, which would probably be valued at 40-50% of the euro. This would help exports but make imports that much more expensive. The Greek central bank would have had to print a lot of money to capitalize the nationalized banks and finance the government budget, which isn’t yet generating a primary surplus, i.e., excluding interest payments. With higher import prices and overheated printing presses, inflation would have risen to double digits and interest rates would have skyrocketed. Syriza, which had promised not to trim the state apparatus, has at the same time announced that it would raise tax revenues. The question is whether it would have succeeded in markedly changing taxpayer behavior in the short term. It is more likely that little would have come of the party’s election promises. Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012 3
  • 4. Turbulence in the financial markets, capital flight and significantly lower asset values would have also led to corporate bankruptcies, higher unemployment and the risk of political instability. Because the new currency would have cut the wealth of Greek citizens (and GDP) in half after a euro exit, at the same time that foreign debt in euro wouldn't have changed in value, a payment default would have been necessary and led to increased isolation from investors, lenders and even the EU and IMF. There would have also been a risk that Greece would have had to leave the EU. Geopolitically, Greece’s new friends would have probably included Russia, China and Venezuela. Tension with Turkey still exists, and huge cuts in the military budget (from very high levels) would have increased in the dependence on alliance partners outside NATO. Question 4: If the parties don’t manage to form a government, what will happen? The parties have already declared that it is crucial a A new election after government is formed fairly quickly, so there is probably room the summer can't be for compromise. ruled out There is still a possibility, however, that the parties will fail to form a government. For example, there is a risk that Pasok will not want to govern with New Democracy, since it could be hurt by supporting policies that go against its core beliefs. Syriza has already taken over many of Pasok’s supporters. That makes a new election a possibility. Until then a caretaker government could be formed, which would delay any difficult decisions and increase uncertainty and turbulence in the financial markets. A new election is also a possibility if a new government fails to last, one of the parties drops out and a majority is no longer in place to execute the policy. There are fears this could happen as soon as after the summer. Question 5: How likely is it that lenders will accept renegotiated terms? Even before the election results were finalized, Germany’s It is reasonable to Foreign Minister, Guido Westerwelle, suggested that the expect that lenders will austerity could be eased. It is likely, however, that the troika and ease some of their the euro countries would have handled a Syriza-led government terms differently. If Syriza had won, it would have been harder to see the troika meet the new government halfway due to Syriza’s populist rhetoric and the policies it wants to implement, including nationalizing formerly public institutions and maintaining the relatively large public sector – contrary to the bailout package. 4 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
  • 5. On the other hand, if New Democracy succeeds in forming a government with Pasok, there is the possibility that the troika and the heads of the euro zone will agree to ease their demands. This could include extending the deadline for meeting the terms (a delay in deciding on 11 billion euros in spending cuts would be welcome), as well as investments that facilitate a transition to economic growth. It is also important that Germany shows empathy for the difficulties faced by the Greek people now that unemployment has risen to over 22% and where measures are needed to assist the many young unemployed in particular. The troika and euro countries also have to convince the financial markets that austerity is realistic. Otherwise concerns will continue to spread to other crisis countries. Question 6: What do the election results mean for the euro zone? The election results increase the likelihood that Greece will The euro countries are abide by the terms of the bailout package and not exit the euro likely to ease terms zone. This is provided that the new government supports the somewhat, but there is package and we don't see a government crisis in the near term. still a risk of a Greek It is also important that the wave of recent withdrawals in the exit banking sector can be stopped. The ECB has to support the Greek central bank and facilitate a capitalization, so that the bank panic doesn't worsen and spread to other crisis countries. To receive the next payment, parliament has to find 11 billion euros in spending cuts, which could prove difficult and create concerns about a default despite the formation of a new government. Moreover, it is unclear how the new government will follow the program, i.e., how quickly reforms can be implemented and in what way. Without a willingness to reform, there is a risk that the package will fall apart and spark renewed uncertainty about Greece’s place in the currency union. We cannot rule out, therefore, that Greece’s fate will remain uncertain despite the outcome of the election. In a Greek exit, the euro zone’s taxpayers would lose over 100 billion euros that the Greek central bank owes the other central banks through the Target2 system. Without an exit, it’s more of an accounting question how the funds will be adjusted between euro countries within the central banking system, but if Greece is no longer part of this system the other euro countries (mainly Germany, which is responsible for about a third) will have to pay the cost. Lenders will also lose money if Greece exits the currency union. The ECB has purchased Greek bonds valued at 56 billion euro. The euro countries have lent Greece 161 billion euros and the IMF 22 billion. European banks have receivables from Greece through government bonds they purchased for 55 billion (after write-offs). International banks still have receivables from Greek businesses and households worth 69 billion, of which French banks (37 billion) are most at risk, while British (8 billion) and Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012 5
  • 6. German banks (6 billion) are slightly less exposed. This doesn't include the insurance companies and pension funds that have purchased Greek corporate bonds. Another important factor if Greece exits the euro zone is whether the contagion will spread. The first to be affected would probably be Cyprus, which has awaited the election results before formally requesting emergency loans from the EU, ECB and IMF. It’s possible that the country will need emergency loans of up to 50% of GDP to capitalize its banks, or about 9 billion euros. Foreign banks have an exposure of 36 billion euros. There would also be expectations that Portugal and Ireland would have to give up the euro, creating further turbulence and raising risk premiums and financing costs for these two countries. Even worse is the possibility that this would then spread to larger countries such as Spain, which already faces problems in its banking sector, and Italy, whose high debt and weak competitiveness are worrying markets. Withdrawals from Greek banks are a problem, but would be even more so if the contagion spreads to Spanish and Italian banks. It is equally important how a Greek exit would affect the euro collaboration in general. A country cannot officially leave the currency union, but if one or more did so nonetheless, confidence in the currency would wane. To date the euro has lost fairly little against other currencies, although its slide has accelerated of late. If Greece exits, confidence in the euro would be affected. On the one hand, the currency union would be hurt by its increased fragility. On the other, it could be helped by having a weak member drop out and the stronger ones remain. Integration in the euro zone would probably be affected as well. The crisis has accelerated changes in its institutions, and the pace of reform could slow if instability is reduced. If more countries exit the euro zone, however, there is a risk that the EU will also be affected, which could mean less integration in a number of areas. Question 7: What kind of market reaction can we expect? The outcome of the Greek collection on June 17 should please The equity and the financial markets. Asian stock markets have risen and the currency markets have euro has strengthened slightly. The results have to be seen as initially reacted a relief, since the party that wanted to tear up the austerity positively, but their joy program didn't win. The risk of an exit from the currency union could be short lived has temporarily declined, and the new government will provide a counterparty for the troika to negotiate with. The pace of reform should increase compared with the caretaker government and former technocratic government that led the country in recent months. 6 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
  • 7. The focus of the financial markets has already shifted to Spain and Italy and eventually will turn to France. The serious situation facing Spanish banks is also affecting French banks, and by extension the budgets of both countries. The financial market is carefully monitoring what the euro zone is doing to strengthen its institutions and to form a banking union with a single regulator, a deposit guarantee and resolution practices. Another priority is how support can be transferred directly from the structural funds to the banks without raising national debts, as happened in Ireland and now most recently Spain. Question 8: How serious is the situation in the Greek economy? The situation in the Greek economy is grave. The onslaught of Greece is not in withdrawals from banks shows a lack of confidence that a euro recession – it's more of exit will be prevented. Hospitals and energy companies cannot a depression pay their bills, and without new emergency loans the state will default by the end of next month. Greece is in its fifth year of recession. Between 2007 and 2011 the economy shrunk by just over 13%, and an additional loss of 5-6% is expected this year. It would seem that Greece is actually experiencing a depression considering its lost production, high unemployment and collapse of its economic system. Greece’s GDP growth (%) Unemployment exceeds 22% for the population as a whole, but is around 50% for young adults. One in five people work in tourism, which is being hurt by uncertainty. The election results could all generate more last-minute travelers if a government can be formed and stability is achieved. Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012 7
  • 8. Unemployment in several euro countries, % of workforce The Greek economy has been weak for several years. Competitiveness is clearly trending lower with rising unit labor costs due to low productivity growth and rapidly rising labor costs. Unit labor costs in manufacturing, index 2000 = 100 180,00 170,00 160,00 150,00 DE 140,00 ES 130,00 FR 120,00 EL IE 110,00 IT 100,00 90,00 80,00 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 The low interest rates in connection with the nominal convergence of the money and bond markets drove real estate prices higher, which in turn raised consumer prices and reduced real interest rates. Imports grew substantially, while exports developed more modestly. The result was a large current account deficit, which is now being reduced by the slowdown in the economy and collapse in imports. The key, however, is to implement reforms that raise competitiveness, not only by cutting wages and pensions but by improving productivity. 8 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
  • 9. Current account balance in several EU countries, % of GDP Percent Question 9: What does Greece have to do to turn around? It is important that the new government implements reforms that Greece has to improve competitiveness in the economy as a whole and implement extensive budget discipline in the state apparatus. According to question structural reforms – a 8, competitiveness has declined throughout the 2000’s, while necessity with any Greece was unable to devalue and costs rose faster than in currency system competing countries. Budget discipline was worse than first reported when Greece entered the euro zone, which means that the budget deficit was larger and government debt had increased more. The key now is to balance revenue and spending, which means a downsizing of the public sector as well as better tax collection and taxpayer ethics. Competition in product markets is being held in check by the guilds that protect various professional groups. Liberalization would benefit consumers and stimulate growth. State-owned enterprises have to be privatized in order to increase productivity and efficiency. To date the pace of reform has been slow, but it is critical that the austerity package agreed to is followed at the same time that weak groups are better protected. Greece’s politicians haven't supported the reform package yet, which creates a risk that it will fail. The new government has to take responsibility and ownership for the economy. This will be Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012 9
  • 10. the most important element in the negotiations between the troika and the government, which means that the troika has to agree to concessions and the government has to take over the program. It is uncertain whether this will happen considering that the parties – the same ones that signed the agreement – haven’t taken responsibility so far. Question 10: What do developments in Greece mean for the Nordic and Baltic regions? Only Finland and Estonia, as euro members, are affected by the The Nordic and negotiations with the Greek government on terms and loan Baltic countries are programs. Although it is unlikely that more money will be given mainly being affected to Greece, an extended deadline to meet the terms could make through export and the program more expensive. investment markets If a government is successfully formed and an exit from the currency union is avoided, the election results could mean a slight improvement in the euro zone’s situation thanks to increased stability. This would benefit exports and investment in the Nordic and Baltic region as well. Less uncertainty would also help the economy by encouraging households and businesses to spend and invest. Many questions still remain, however, and concerns about Spain and Italy have grown. Greece has taken a small step in the right direction, but there is still a risk that it may default on its payments and exit the euro zone – a risk that continues to create concerns about the euro zone, but also for Europe, including the Nordic and Baltic regions. It will take many years to strengthen the institutions in the euro zone, improve conditions in the crisis countries and create stability and growth. Until then northern Europe will see its key export markets grow below their potential. Creating increased political stability is imperative if the countries are also going to tackle their economic challenges. Cecilia Hermansson 10 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012
  • 11. Economic Research Department Sweden Cecilia Hermansson +46 8 5859 7720 cecilia.hermansson@swedbank.se Group Chief Economist Chief Economist, Sweden Magnus Alvesson +46 8 5859 3341 magnus.alvesson@swedbank.se Head of Economic Forecasting Jörgen Kennemar +46 8 5859 7730 jorgen.kennemar@swedbank.se Senior Economist Anna Ibegbulem +46 8 5859 7740 anna.ibegbulem@swedbank.se Assistant Estonia Annika Paabut +372 888 5440 annika.paabut@swedbank.ee Chief Economist, Estonia Elina Allikalt +372 888 1989 elina.allikalt@swedbank.ee Senior Economist Latvia Mārtiņš Kazāks +371 67 445 859 martins.kazaks@swedbank.lv Deputy Group Chief Economist Chief Economist, Latvia Dainis Stikuts +371 67 445 844 dainis.stikuts@swedbank.lv Senior Economist Lija Strašuna +371 67 445 875 lija.strasuna@swedbank.lv Senior Economist Lithuania Nerijus Mačiulis +370 5 258 2237 nerijus.maciulis@swedbank.lt Chief Economist, Lithuania Lina Vrubliauskienė +370 5 258 2275 lina.vrubliauskiene@swedbank.lt Senior Economist Vaiva Šečkutė +370 5 258 2156 vaiva.seckute@swedbank.lt Senior Economist Economic Research Department Swedbank Analysis is published as a service to our customers. We believe that we have used reliable sources and methods in the preparation of the SE-105 34 Stockholm analyses reported in this publication. However, we cannot guarantee the Telephone +46-(0)8-5859 7740 accuracy or completeness of the report and cannot be held responsible for ek.sekr@swedbank.se www.swedbank.se any error or omission in the underlying material or its use. Readers are encouraged to base any (investment) decisions on other material as well. Legally responsible publisher Neither Swedbank nor its employees may be held responsible for losses or Cecilia Hermansson, damages, direct or indirect, owing to any errors or omissions in Swedbank +46-8-5859 7720. Analysis. ISSN 1103-4897 Swedbank Analysis No. 6 • 18 June 2012 11