Surveon vs COTS NVR Solution Comparison

1. Surveon & Common COTS NVR
Solution Comparison
Surveon Technology, 2011
Complete Megapixel Solutions

2. We all love Megapixel But…

3. How do I select the Hardware?
Are the PC reliable for Megapixel Stream?
Which architecture should I use?
I know nothing on storage.
How do I minimize the common HD failure ?

4. Drop Frame
HD Failure
Storage Selection
Software Integration
Megapixel Optimized
Security’s biggest concerns on megapixel are integration
and reliable storage platform – Seagate GDSF 2009

5. Critical Design Point for Megapixel Solutions
Streaming Decoding
Streaming Recording
I/O Decoding
1 LIVE VIEW
2 Recording & Data Protection
3 Video Retrive & Playback

6. Non Professional Storage’s Problems
Streaming Decoding
Streaming Recording
I/O Decoding
LIVE VIEW
Recording & Data Protection
Video Retrive & Playback
O Using high end CPU
Xunstable system, frame lost,
integration issue, Easy HD Failure,
Extra Maintenance Cost
Xunstable system, system crash,
integration issue, Easy HD Failure,
Extra Maintenance Cost

7. Solutions for High Channel Megapixel
NVR
Solutions Features Ref. Supplier
Application
Notes
Common PC
+ VMS
Not Design for NVR
I/O Loading
Storage Reliability
Entry Level VMS
NUUO, Alnet, Avermedia
Simple
Application.
< 16 CH D1
COTS
PC MB +
Chassis
Less Integration
I/O Storage Quality
Non-pro Design
Local SI, Exacqvision,
NUUO, GVD, VAR
Use in Caution
8 -32CH
Enterprise HW RAID
NVR
Design for NVR
HW RAID
High Performance
I/O Storage
Bosch, Indiovision, Nice
Vision (OEM)
Surveon (Own
Production)

8. 32 CH NVR (Surveon vs. NUUO)
Item Surveon NVR2000 NUUO COTS Our Benefits
Architecture Client Server Standalone
Distributed Architecture for
Stable Recording
NVR In House Production Base
COTS
(Self Assemble Base)
Highly Integration, Full QA
Process Product
Storage I/O, RAID
Built In Infortrend HW RAID
Controller
COTS
The highest level storage
solution for megapixel recording
(Not PC or RAID card)
Storage Capacity From 8 to 100 Disk NA
Truly Scalable Megapixel
Solutions
Hardware Own Design / Production Outsource Commitment & Better Services
VI level Object Base Motion Base Advanced VI
Enterprise VMS Features*
HTML/8 Display/Domin
Management/Bookmark
iPhone/WebClient
iPhone/Web Client For Professional CCTV Project
One Stop Shop Yes (Camera, NVR, Storage) NA
Better Services, Support, Pricing
Bundle
Company Scale (Sales) 80-100 M < 10 M Ideal Long Term Partner
Surveon Web Client & iPhone will be release on 2.4.5 / 2.5

9. Real Time VI Detection
Surveon Exacqvision NUUO
Entry NAS/
IP Cam Bundle
VMS
Indigovision
Technology Object Base Motion Base
Motion
Base
Motion Base Object Base
Motion Detection V V V V V
Movement Detection V V
Tampering Detection V V V V
Missing Object V
V (Motion
Base)
V
Foreign Object V
V (Motion
Base)
V
Forbidden Area V V
Intrusion Detection V V
Virtual Fence V V
Real Object
Counting
V V

10. Solution Comparison– Surveon vs. NUUO
Megapixel
Channels
Recording
Days
Surveon NUUO Benefits
8 14 SMR2000 NAS Mini
All Dedicated NVR
Series Design
Non COTS PC
100% Own Tooling
100% Own Production
Production Base
Hardware RAID
3 Year Warranty
Scalable to 100 Disk
8 30 SMR2000 NAS Mini
16 14 SMR5000 NAS Mini
16 30 SMR5000 COTS/PC
25 14 SMR8000/NVR2000 COTS/PC
25 30 SMR8000/NVR2000 COTS/PC
32 14 SMR8000/NVR2000 COTS/PC
32 30 NVR2000 COTS/PC
64 14 - 100 NVR2000 COTS/PC

11. COTS/PC Solutions Provider Ref.
All in different design, ID
Common PC, COTS Solutions
Selling PC as a NVR

12. Surveon NVR Series
Series ID, Same HD Tray
Proprietary Outlook
Own Design, In House Production
Not selling the PC but Professional NVR

13. Appendix A
Surveon Complete Solutions

14. Surveon IP Video Solutions
Segment Business Key Features Surveon Solutions Benefits from Surveon
Small
Retail, Hospitality,
Restaurant, SMB,
clinic, small factory,
school
< 16 CH
Simple Installation
All in one
Surveon Cameras
SMR Series
End to End solutions
Built in Professional RAID
Enterprise VMS
3 year warranty
In House Design
In House Production
Middle
Community,
University,
Enterprise, School,
Hospital,
Supermarket,
Factory, Hotel,
Factory
16CH – 200 CH
Client Server
Enterprise RAID
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
NVR 2000
HW RAID NVR
Large
City Surveillance,
Transportation,
Public utility, Casino,
Air port
> 200 CH
Client Server
Centralize Mgt
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
CVST Solutions

15. Smart Megapixel Recorder
SMR Series
SMR2016
8-16 CH
2 BAY SMR
SMR3025
16-25 CH
5 BAY SMR
SMR5032
20-32 CH
8 BAY SMR

16. Surveon IP Video Solutions
Segment Business Key Features Surveon Solutions Benefits from Surveon
Small
Retail, Hospitality,
Restaurant, SMB,
clinic, small factory,
school
< 16 CH
Simple Installation
All in one
Surveon Cameras
SMR Series
End to End solutions
Built in Professional RAID
Enterprise VMS
3 year warranty
In House Design
In House Production
Middle
Community,
University,
Enterprise, School,
Hospital,
Supermarket,
Factory, Hotel,
Factory
16CH – 200 CH
Client Server
Enterprise RAID
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
NVR 2000
HW RAID NVR
Large
City Surveillance,
Transportation,
Public utility, Casino,
Air port
> 200 CH
Client Server
Centralize Mgt
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
CVST Solutions

17. NVR2000 Series
Enterprise RAID Megapixel NVR

18. NVR2032
1 – 20 IP CAMs
NVR2032
– 46 IP CAMs
樓層一 樓層三
GLAN
512 Mbps/1G
…
512 Mbps/1G
Upper
Switch
Monitor A
GLAN
NVR2000 RAID NVR Solutions
Monitor B
A B

19. Surveon IP Video Solutions
Segment Business Key Features Surveon Solutions Benefits from Surveon
Small
Retail, Hospitality,
Restaurant, SMB,
clinic, small factory,
school
< 16 CH
Simple Installation
All in one
Surveon Cameras
SMR Series
End to End solutions
Built in Professional RAID
Enterprise VMS
3 year warranty
In House Design
In House Production
Middle
Community,
University,
Enterprise, School,
Hospital,
Supermarket,
Factory, Hotel,
Factory
16CH – 200 CH
Client Server
Enterprise RAID
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
NVR 2000
HW RAID NVR
Large
City Surveillance,
Transportation,
Public utility, Casino,
Air port
> 200 CH
Client Server
Centralize Mgt
Survoen +
3rd Party Cameras
CVST Solutions

20. Centralize video Storage Solutions
Unlimited Cameras Support
Diskless in Front End

21. Cost Saving on HW, HD & Space
Traditional NVR Solution
(Recording Server)
Surveon CVST
Solutions
12U Total 6U Total

22. Appendix B
COTS vs. Production NVR

23. Surveon NVR vs. COTS NVR -1
Design
Validation
Engineering
Validation
Quality
Validation
Production
Validation
Mass Production
Check Point
Report
Spec.
Thermal
Simulation
Performance
Evaluation
Function Test
Thermal Pre
Test
Reliability
Function, Thermal,
Reliability,
Package, Drop,
Shock, Vibration,
High-Low Temp,
Humility,
Component Approval,
SOP, Yield Rate,
HALT, ORT, Mass
Burning, function
check
Incoming Check,
Process QA, SOP,
T1, T2, Burning, On
line QA, Shuffle
System
Surveon NVR Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
COTS/PC NVR NO NO NO NO NO
ISO: Quality Product Management
Process

24. Production Base vs. COTS Base
Surveon
Mass Production
Quality Level
COTS NVR
In Office Assembly
Quality Level

25. Enterprise NVR Comparisons
Surveon NVR2000
Series
COTS Server
(NUUO/GEO/GVD)
NAS Solutions
(QNAP)
VMS Enterprise VMS Enterprise VMS SOHO VMS
Max Channels 64 64 64
Design QA Complete NA Complete
Production In House Design/Production Outsource / COTS In House Design
Storage Enterprise RAID Subsystem NA or SW RAID Card SW RAID
RAID HW RAID5, 6 Engine Entry SW RAID
Storage
Expansion
24 TB to 160TB 24 TB 24 TB
Storage
Integration
Built in (Auto) NA NA

26. Appendix C
Product Comparisons

27. Product Comparison – SMR Series
Item
Exacqvision
Toaster
Surveon
SMR Series
Milestone
NVR
NUUO
CH Up to 24 8, 16, 20, 25, 32 8, 16 4, 8, 16
Processor Single Core Dual Core Dual Core SOC
Local Live NA Yes Yes NA
HD 2
2, 5, 8 (Hot
Swappable)
1 Fix HD 2 or 4
RAID NA RAID 0, 1, 5 NA Yes
Hardware Outsource
Own
Design/Production
Standard PC Outsource
Real Time VI NA Object Base NA Motion Base
Hardware Outsource
Own
Design/Production
Outsource Outsource

28. Enterprise NVR Comparison
Surveon NVR2000
Series
ExacqVision
Z Series
IndioVision
Form Factor Rack Mount Rack Mount Rack Mount
Max Channels 64 64 64
Storage
Enterprise RAID
Subsystem
NA (or COTS) NA (or COTS)
RAID HW RAID5, 6 Engine NA NA
Storage
Expansion
24 TB to 160TB Max.40TB 16TB
Storage
Integration
Built in (Auto) NA NA
MSRP 9500 9000 1X000

29. Enterprise NVR/VMS Solutions

30. Appendix D
Centralize Storage Solutions

31. Clustered Video Storage Solutions
• Truly IP Solutions on NVR, VMS & Storage
• Cost Savings of 30% for Projects > 30 IP cams
• Better Reliability & Scalability
• 20% Space, System & Mgt. Cost Savings
• No more HD failure/replacement on NVRs

32. Comparison: Centralize Storage
Solution
Surveon CVST Intransa + VMS NUUO
Max Channels Unlimited Unlimited NA
Storage Solutions iSCSI iSCSI NA
Storage
Enterprise RAID
Subsystem
CTOS NA
RAID
HW RAID5, 6
Engine
RAID Card / SW RAID NA
VMS Enterprise VMS NO (3rd Party) NA
Storage
Integration
Built in (Auto) NA NA
Price Per CH
250 USD
150 USD Kit Price
200 - 300 USD
With 3rd
party VMS
Very High
(Out Source)

33. Appendix E
Megapixel Recording Pattern

34. Common PC Storage Usage Model vs.
Surveillance Usage Model
DAY Night
80%
DAY Night
80%
Common PC Storage Requirement & Design Concept
NVR Application Writing Requirement on common PC
Time
Write
Performance
Write
Performance Time

35. Common PC NVR vs. Surveon Video
Storage
DAY Night
80%
Common PC NVR (HD Fail & No Data Protection)
Surveon (Reliable HD + Data Protection)
Write
Performance Time
DAY Night
80%
Write
Performance Time

36. Megapixel Video Storage Solution
Comparison

37. Appendix F
Design Notes from AXIS
-Hardware RAID Subsystem is the only
recommend solutions from AXIS-

38. Solutions for Mega IP Surveillance
Quote from AXIS Applications Note, Page 31.
http://www.axis.com/files/manuals/gd_ipsurv_design_32568_en_0807_lo.pdf