SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
Where do ‘ontologies’
   come from?
     Seeking for the missing link




                    Aurélien Bénel, Web & Philosophy, April 17, 2012
“
    A program that wants to compare or combine
    information across (...) two databases has to know
    that (...) two terms are being used to mean the
    same thing. (...)

    Artificial intelligence and Web researchers have co-
    opted the term [‘ontology’] for their own jargon,
    and for them an ontology is a document or file that
    formally defines the relations among terms.

                                (Berners-Lee et al., 2001)
Library of Congress
D: History (general)
DA: Great Britain
DB: Austria
DC: France
DD: Germany
DE: Mediterranean                         Soviet Libraries
DF: Greece
                          A: Marxism-Leninism
DG: Italy
                          A1: Classic works of Marxism-Leninism
DH: Low Countries
                          A3: Life and work of C. Marx, F. Engels,V.I. Lenin
DJ: Netherlands
                          A5: Marxism-Leninism Philosophy
DK: Former Soviet Union
                          A6: Marxist-Leninist Political Economics
DL: Scandinavia
                          A7/8: Scientific Communism
DP: Iberian Peninsula
DQ: Switzerland
DR: Balkan Peninsula
DS: Asia
DT: Africa
DU: Oceania
DX: Gypsies


            As true as thesauri are?
                                                                    (Shirky, 2005)
Coherence   Correspondence   Hypothesis   Intersubjectivity
1900


1910


1920


1930


1940


1950


1960


1970


1980

                     What is truth anyway?
‘Ontologies’

400 000 papers
 in computer
    science

                 (Gruber, 1991)

                                  ???
                                        Vienna Circle
‘Ontology’
                in Google scholar
380

285
                                    1930-1939
190
                               Religious studies
 95                          Philosophy of science

  0
      1930’s
‘Ontology’
                           in Google scholar
1500

1125

 750                                           1940-1959
                                    Analytical philosophy (Quine)
 375

   0
       1930’s   1940’s    1950’s
‘Ontology’
                                  in Google scholar
4000

3000
                                                      1960-1969
2000
                                                 Phenomenology
1000                                            Reflections on art

   0
       1930’s   1940’s   1950’s   1960’s
‘Ontology’
                                 in Google scholar
6000

4500
                                                     1970-1979
3000
                                              Analytical philosophy
1500                                               Linguistics

   0
       1930’s 1940’s 1950’s 1960’s 1970’s
‘Ontology’
                            in Google scholar
15000

11250

 7500                                           1980-1989
                                       Computational linguistics
 3750

    0
        1930’s   1950’s   1970’s
‘Ontology’
                                   in Google scholar
70000

52500

35000                                                  1990-1999
                                              Knowledge representation
17500

    0
        1930’s   1950’s   1970’s     1990’s
‘Ontology’
                                    in Google scholar
400000

300000

200000                                                  2000-2009
                                                  The Semantic Web
100000

     0
         1930’s   1950’s   1970’s    1990’s
The missing link


Vienna                            Semantic
Circle                              Web

                                P. Hayes

          Quine   J. McCarthy
Why it matters

• Debt to Artificial Intelligence
  •   same people

  •   same technologies

  •   same philosophy
Why it matters

• Quine, “On what there is” (1948)
 •   existence: neither discovered nor invented

 •   reference: pronouns rather than names

 •   formal logic as an ‘example of language’



                                       truth as coherence
http://hypertopic.org/

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (6)

Filter Bubble and Enframing
Filter Bubble and EnframingFilter Bubble and Enframing
Filter Bubble and Enframing
 
Reuben Binns: Social Knowledge and the Web
Reuben Binns: Social Knowledge and the WebReuben Binns: Social Knowledge and the Web
Reuben Binns: Social Knowledge and the Web
 
Containing the Semantic Explosion
Containing the Semantic ExplosionContaining the Semantic Explosion
Containing the Semantic Explosion
 
Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.
Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.
Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.
 
Philosophy and the Social Web
Philosophy and the Social WebPhilosophy and the Social Web
Philosophy and the Social Web
 
Harold Boley: RuleML/Grailog: The Rule Metalogic Visualized with Generalized ...
Harold Boley: RuleML/Grailog: The Rule Metalogic Visualized with Generalized ...Harold Boley: RuleML/Grailog: The Rule Metalogic Visualized with Generalized ...
Harold Boley: RuleML/Grailog: The Rule Metalogic Visualized with Generalized ...
 

More from PhiloWeb

Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
PhiloWeb
 
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWebAlexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
PhiloWeb
 
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
PhiloWeb
 
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social WebHenry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
PhiloWeb
 
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective IntelligenceHarry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
PhiloWeb
 
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
PhiloWeb
 
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
PhiloWeb
 
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations. Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
PhiloWeb
 

More from PhiloWeb (17)

Philosophical Foundations for a Services Systems Approach
Philosophical Foundations for a Services Systems ApproachPhilosophical Foundations for a Services Systems Approach
Philosophical Foundations for a Services Systems Approach
 
Le Web a-t-il besoin d'une logique ? Un point de vue aporétique.
Le Web a-t-il besoin d'une logique ? Un point de vue aporétique. Le Web a-t-il besoin d'une logique ? Un point de vue aporétique.
Le Web a-t-il besoin d'une logique ? Un point de vue aporétique.
 
Extending the Mind with Cognitive Prosthetics?
Extending the Mind with Cognitive Prosthetics? Extending the Mind with Cognitive Prosthetics?
Extending the Mind with Cognitive Prosthetics?
 
Michael Wheeler's presentation in Sorbonne, "Philosophy of the Web" seminar, ...
Michael Wheeler's presentation in Sorbonne, "Philosophy of the Web" seminar, ...Michael Wheeler's presentation in Sorbonne, "Philosophy of the Web" seminar, ...
Michael Wheeler's presentation in Sorbonne, "Philosophy of the Web" seminar, ...
 
Common Logic: An Evolutionary Tale
Common Logic: An Evolutionary TaleCommon Logic: An Evolutionary Tale
Common Logic: An Evolutionary Tale
 
Rethinking Realpolitik: The Afterglobalization Movement and Beyond
Rethinking Realpolitik: The Afterglobalization Movement and BeyondRethinking Realpolitik: The Afterglobalization Movement and Beyond
Rethinking Realpolitik: The Afterglobalization Movement and Beyond
 
The Philosophy of Information and the Structure of Philosophical Revolutions
The Philosophy of Information and the Structure of Philosophical RevolutionsThe Philosophy of Information and the Structure of Philosophical Revolutions
The Philosophy of Information and the Structure of Philosophical Revolutions
 
Web Metaphysics between Logic and Ontology
Web Metaphysics between Logic and OntologyWeb Metaphysics between Logic and Ontology
Web Metaphysics between Logic and Ontology
 
Meaning and the Semantic Web
Meaning and the Semantic WebMeaning and the Semantic Web
Meaning and the Semantic Web
 
Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
Henry Thompson : Are Uris really names?
 
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWebAlexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
Alexandre Monnin: W3C TPAC presentation of PhiloWeb
 
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
Alexandra Arapinis : From ontological structures to semantic lexical structur...
 
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social WebHenry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
Henry Story: Philosophy and the Social Web
 
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective IntelligenceHarry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
Harry Halpin: Artificial Intelligence versus Collective Intelligence
 
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
Yuk Hui: What is a digital object?
 
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
Nicolas Delaforge: Modeling the Web resource, extracting the context: stakes ...
 
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations. Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
Pierre Livet: Ontologies, from entities to operations.
 

Recently uploaded

Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
PECB
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
QucHHunhnh
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
QucHHunhnh
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
kauryashika82
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
ciinovamais
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
SoniaTolstoy
 
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
fonyou31
 

Recently uploaded (20)

IGNOU MSCCFT and PGDCFT Exam Question Pattern: MCFT003 Counselling and Family...
IGNOU MSCCFT and PGDCFT Exam Question Pattern: MCFT003 Counselling and Family...IGNOU MSCCFT and PGDCFT Exam Question Pattern: MCFT003 Counselling and Family...
IGNOU MSCCFT and PGDCFT Exam Question Pattern: MCFT003 Counselling and Family...
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
 
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf1029 -  Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
1029 - Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa 10 . pdf
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
General AI for Medical Educators April 2024
General AI for Medical Educators April 2024General AI for Medical Educators April 2024
General AI for Medical Educators April 2024
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
 
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writingfourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpinStudent login on Anyboli platform.helpin
Student login on Anyboli platform.helpin
 
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
Advanced Views - Calendar View in Odoo 17
 
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
Código Creativo y Arte de Software | Unidad 1
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
Ecosystem Interactions Class Discussion Presentation in Blue Green Lined Styl...
 
Sports & Fitness Value Added Course FY..
Sports & Fitness Value Added Course FY..Sports & Fitness Value Added Course FY..
Sports & Fitness Value Added Course FY..
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 

Where do "ontologies" come from?

  • 1. Where do ‘ontologies’ come from? Seeking for the missing link Aurélien Bénel, Web & Philosophy, April 17, 2012
  • 2. A program that wants to compare or combine information across (...) two databases has to know that (...) two terms are being used to mean the same thing. (...) Artificial intelligence and Web researchers have co- opted the term [‘ontology’] for their own jargon, and for them an ontology is a document or file that formally defines the relations among terms. (Berners-Lee et al., 2001)
  • 3. Library of Congress D: History (general) DA: Great Britain DB: Austria DC: France DD: Germany DE: Mediterranean Soviet Libraries DF: Greece A: Marxism-Leninism DG: Italy A1: Classic works of Marxism-Leninism DH: Low Countries A3: Life and work of C. Marx, F. Engels,V.I. Lenin DJ: Netherlands A5: Marxism-Leninism Philosophy DK: Former Soviet Union A6: Marxist-Leninist Political Economics DL: Scandinavia A7/8: Scientific Communism DP: Iberian Peninsula DQ: Switzerland DR: Balkan Peninsula DS: Asia DT: Africa DU: Oceania DX: Gypsies As true as thesauri are? (Shirky, 2005)
  • 4. Coherence Correspondence Hypothesis Intersubjectivity 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 What is truth anyway?
  • 5. ‘Ontologies’ 400 000 papers in computer science (Gruber, 1991) ??? Vienna Circle
  • 6. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 380 285 1930-1939 190 Religious studies 95 Philosophy of science 0 1930’s
  • 7. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 1500 1125 750 1940-1959 Analytical philosophy (Quine) 375 0 1930’s 1940’s 1950’s
  • 8. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 4000 3000 1960-1969 2000 Phenomenology 1000 Reflections on art 0 1930’s 1940’s 1950’s 1960’s
  • 9. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 6000 4500 1970-1979 3000 Analytical philosophy 1500 Linguistics 0 1930’s 1940’s 1950’s 1960’s 1970’s
  • 10. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 15000 11250 7500 1980-1989 Computational linguistics 3750 0 1930’s 1950’s 1970’s
  • 11. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 70000 52500 35000 1990-1999 Knowledge representation 17500 0 1930’s 1950’s 1970’s 1990’s
  • 12. ‘Ontology’ in Google scholar 400000 300000 200000 2000-2009 The Semantic Web 100000 0 1930’s 1950’s 1970’s 1990’s
  • 13. The missing link Vienna Semantic Circle Web P. Hayes Quine J. McCarthy
  • 14. Why it matters • Debt to Artificial Intelligence • same people • same technologies • same philosophy
  • 15. Why it matters • Quine, “On what there is” (1948) • existence: neither discovered nor invented • reference: pronouns rather than names • formal logic as an ‘example of language’ truth as coherence