SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 17
The impact of obesity discourses on maternal identities and parenting practices Julia Keenan (UEA)  Helen Stapleton (Australian Catholic University & Mater Mothers' Hospital)  Feeding Children in the New Parenting Culture . British Library, 20 th  March 2011.
Structure ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Critical weight studies and parenting cultures  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
‘ Perils’ to health posed by big mothers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],To an outsider, Rawmarsh sounds like hell; a place where fat stupid mothers fight for the right to raise fat stupid children”  (Hattersley, Times 24th Sept 2006)
Research Objectives ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Research design: sample 60 women Longitudinal Cohort 1 (30 pregnant women) Anticipating motherhood  for the first time  Cohort 2 (30 established mothers) With at least one child  between 9 months – 2 yrs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Interviewed once only
Participants ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
An expanded accounts framework  (Monaghan 2008) Discursive framings…  Accept pejorative status Deny or challenge pejorative status Accept responsibility Contrition (Compliance) Justifications (Critical compliance) Deny (relevance of) responsibility Excuses (Mitigation) Repudiation
Compliance  (accept pejorative status and maternal responsibility) ,[object Object],[object Object]
Mitigation  (accept pejorative status but deny sole maternal responsibility) ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
Critical compliance  (Deny pejorative status but accept sole maternal responsibility) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ even if I won the lottery and had loads of money, I still would not pay for liposuction or owt like that[..] I can’t see the point because that’s just the easy way out isn’t it, you’ve not learned anything by it, you’ve just gone and had all your fat sucked out of you […] If it’s for health problems, fair enough but not just to make themselves look good.  I don’t, what’s the point; you are what you are” C1-O2/Fiona “ because he’s a bit of a slow grower really, erm, he’s sort of in the small range for his age. You know with respect to his weight and size.  So I’m, I’m not forcing stuff down him but I’m encouraging him to eat. What he can but.  He’s just not interested and I’m not physically holding his nose and forcing it down him […] but I am trying to encourage him to be interested in food” C2-O/Gemma
Repudiation  (deny pejorative status and deny sole maternal responsibility) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Utility of accounts framework? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Accept responsibility Deny responsibility Accept pejorative status Deny pejorative status Compliance Critical compliance Repudiation Mitigation Nighat
Conclusion ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

125126772 case-study-in-pph
125126772 case-study-in-pph125126772 case-study-in-pph
125126772 case-study-in-pphhomeworkping9
 
Revised Personal Statement by Camille
Revised Personal Statement by CamilleRevised Personal Statement by Camille
Revised Personal Statement by CamilleCamille Ruiz
 
Psychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyPsychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyReynel Dan
 
Psychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyPsychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyReynel Dan
 
A ideal case presention in psm
A ideal case presention in psmA ideal case presention in psm
A ideal case presention in psmASHWANI123PANDEY
 
Part 2: Body Image
Part 2: Body ImagePart 2: Body Image
Part 2: Body Imagemrodgersjps
 
Eatin g disorder111
Eatin g disorder111Eatin g disorder111
Eatin g disorder111Liz Alire
 
data sheet (bronchiolitis )
data sheet (bronchiolitis )data sheet (bronchiolitis )
data sheet (bronchiolitis )Muna Here
 
Eating disorders
Eating disordersEating disorders
Eating disordersulazari
 
Ppt eating disorders
Ppt eating disordersPpt eating disorders
Ppt eating disorderssandrajan
 
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th year
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th yearRubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th year
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th yearDr. Rubz
 
Eating disorders
Eating disordersEating disorders
Eating disordersAlisha Dias
 
Emotional intelligence and eating disorders
Emotional intelligence and eating disordersEmotional intelligence and eating disorders
Emotional intelligence and eating disordersJames Palfreman-Kay
 
Foot spa detox weight loss
Foot spa detox weight lossFoot spa detox weight loss
Foot spa detox weight lossHeather Bruce
 

Was ist angesagt? (19)

125126772 case-study-in-pph
125126772 case-study-in-pph125126772 case-study-in-pph
125126772 case-study-in-pph
 
Revised Personal Statement by Camille
Revised Personal Statement by CamilleRevised Personal Statement by Camille
Revised Personal Statement by Camille
 
Psychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyPsychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancy
 
Psychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancyPsychological changes of pregnancy
Psychological changes of pregnancy
 
A ideal case presention in psm
A ideal case presention in psmA ideal case presention in psm
A ideal case presention in psm
 
Part 2: Body Image
Part 2: Body ImagePart 2: Body Image
Part 2: Body Image
 
Background questionnaire
Background questionnaireBackground questionnaire
Background questionnaire
 
Eatin g disorder111
Eatin g disorder111Eatin g disorder111
Eatin g disorder111
 
data sheet (bronchiolitis )
data sheet (bronchiolitis )data sheet (bronchiolitis )
data sheet (bronchiolitis )
 
junior paper
junior paperjunior paper
junior paper
 
Eating disorders
Eating disordersEating disorders
Eating disorders
 
Ppt eating disorders
Ppt eating disordersPpt eating disorders
Ppt eating disorders
 
ChoicePols
ChoicePolsChoicePols
ChoicePols
 
Ed
EdEd
Ed
 
Data sheet
Data sheetData sheet
Data sheet
 
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th year
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th yearRubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th year
Rubzzzz's Pediatric Hx Chronic gastritis 4th year
 
Eating disorders
Eating disordersEating disorders
Eating disorders
 
Emotional intelligence and eating disorders
Emotional intelligence and eating disordersEmotional intelligence and eating disorders
Emotional intelligence and eating disorders
 
Foot spa detox weight loss
Foot spa detox weight lossFoot spa detox weight loss
Foot spa detox weight loss
 

Andere mochten auch

Response to Emergencies in Wind Turbines
Response to Emergencies in Wind TurbinesResponse to Emergencies in Wind Turbines
Response to Emergencies in Wind TurbinesXtralisSpain
 
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...ParentingCultureStudies
 
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...ParentingCultureStudies
 
St Benedicts Student Stories
St Benedicts Student StoriesSt Benedicts Student Stories
St Benedicts Student StoriesSharonFerguson
 
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...ParentingCultureStudies
 
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and Class
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and ClassBeing a Good Mother: Morality, Age and Class
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and ClassParentingCultureStudies
 

Andere mochten auch (8)

Response to Emergencies in Wind Turbines
Response to Emergencies in Wind TurbinesResponse to Emergencies in Wind Turbines
Response to Emergencies in Wind Turbines
 
Business bavaria 09-2013_fr
Business bavaria 09-2013_frBusiness bavaria 09-2013_fr
Business bavaria 09-2013_fr
 
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...
‘Blaming the parents: school experiences of ‘troublesome’ children and their ...
 
Pam lowe
Pam lowePam lowe
Pam lowe
 
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...
‘What is ‘supportive parenting’? The new ‘Welfare of the Child’ clause in the...
 
St Benedicts Student Stories
St Benedicts Student StoriesSt Benedicts Student Stories
St Benedicts Student Stories
 
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...
Boundaries of care and parenting: How does citizenship and care intersect in ...
 
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and Class
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and ClassBeing a Good Mother: Morality, Age and Class
Being a Good Mother: Morality, Age and Class
 

Ähnlich wie The impact of obesity discourses on maternal identities, early feeding relationships and parenting practices

How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fasting
How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fastingHow to lose weight with keto and intermittent fasting
How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fastingPurveshDesai
 
Group presentation eating
Group presentation   eatingGroup presentation   eating
Group presentation eatingOlga Velazquez
 
Choosing to Breastfeed
Choosing to BreastfeedChoosing to Breastfeed
Choosing to BreastfeedAnn Douglas
 
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docx
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docxEating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docx
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docxsagarlesley
 
Nutrition Writing Example, To Parents
Nutrition Writing Example, To ParentsNutrition Writing Example, To Parents
Nutrition Writing Example, To ParentsCaleb Brown
 
Adolescent Body Image
Adolescent Body ImageAdolescent Body Image
Adolescent Body ImageMcCarty
 
Eating Disorders
Eating DisordersEating Disorders
Eating DisordersNorthTec
 
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival Guide
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival GuideNECO 2016 Fall College Survival Guide
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival GuideLee Levitt
 
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connell
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'ConnellCooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connell
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connellkcsckuldip
 
Dealing with childhood obesity
Dealing with childhood obesityDealing with childhood obesity
Dealing with childhood obesityParentEdge
 
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks Challenge
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks ChallengeLearn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks Challenge
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks ChallengePurveshDesai
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Ian Hamilton
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Ian Hamilton
 
Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...
 Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li... Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...
Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...AnubhavVerma100
 
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...isskiki1
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Ian Hamilton
 

Ähnlich wie The impact of obesity discourses on maternal identities, early feeding relationships and parenting practices (20)

How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fasting
How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fastingHow to lose weight with keto and intermittent fasting
How to lose weight with keto and intermittent fasting
 
Back cover1 original
Back cover1 originalBack cover1 original
Back cover1 original
 
Group presentation eating
Group presentation   eatingGroup presentation   eating
Group presentation eating
 
Choosing to Breastfeed
Choosing to BreastfeedChoosing to Breastfeed
Choosing to Breastfeed
 
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docx
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docxEating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docx
Eating DisordersTOPIC OVERVIEWAnorexia NervosaThe Clinic.docx
 
Nutrition Writing Example, To Parents
Nutrition Writing Example, To ParentsNutrition Writing Example, To Parents
Nutrition Writing Example, To Parents
 
Adolescent Body Image
Adolescent Body ImageAdolescent Body Image
Adolescent Body Image
 
Eating Disorders
Eating DisordersEating Disorders
Eating Disorders
 
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival Guide
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival GuideNECO 2016 Fall College Survival Guide
NECO 2016 Fall College Survival Guide
 
‘Militant lactivism’?
‘Militant lactivism’?‘Militant lactivism’?
‘Militant lactivism’?
 
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connell
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'ConnellCooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connell
Cooking up ideas report launch - Dr Rebecca O'Connell
 
Dealing with childhood obesity
Dealing with childhood obesityDealing with childhood obesity
Dealing with childhood obesity
 
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks Challenge
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks ChallengeLearn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks Challenge
Learn how to lose 20 pounds in 6 weeks Challenge
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4
 
352
352352
352
 
Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...
 Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li... Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...
Shawn Baker - The Carnivore Diet (2019, Victory Belt Publishing) - libgen.li...
 
G hawkes
G hawkesG hawkes
G hawkes
 
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...
Lower Blood Sugar: Blood Sugar Levels :Top Ways 10 Healthy Foods That Help Yo...
 
Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4Italian Odyssey Part 4
Italian Odyssey Part 4
 

Mehr von ParentingCultureStudies

Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil Bach
Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil BachChanging parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil Bach
Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil BachParentingCultureStudies
 
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...ParentingCultureStudies
 
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...ParentingCultureStudies
 
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from EuropeParentingCultureStudies
 
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...ParentingCultureStudies
 
Brain science and early intervention val gillies
Brain science and early intervention val gilliesBrain science and early intervention val gillies
Brain science and early intervention val gilliesParentingCultureStudies
 
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414ParentingCultureStudies
 
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...ParentingCultureStudies
 
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014ParentingCultureStudies
 
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...ParentingCultureStudies
 
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...ParentingCultureStudies
 
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina john
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina johnThe dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina john
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina johnParentingCultureStudies
 

Mehr von ParentingCultureStudies (20)

Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil Bach
Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil BachChanging parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil Bach
Changing parenting norms in Denmark and Singapore? Dr Dil Bach
 
Policing Birth
Policing BirthPolicing Birth
Policing Birth
 
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...
Dr Raphael P Hammer, Haute Ecole de Sante Vaud, Institute of Health Research ...
 
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...
Professor Robbie Sutton, Professor of Social Psychology, University of Kent: ...
 
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe
‘No drinking’ policy and advocacy: perspectives from Europe
 
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...
Keynote Lecture – Reproductive Justice Across the Pregnancy Spectrum: Lessons...
 
Brain science and early intervention val gillies
Brain science and early intervention val gilliesBrain science and early intervention val gillies
Brain science and early intervention val gillies
 
Introductory comments
Introductory commentsIntroductory comments
Introductory comments
 
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414
Charlotte morris gender equality and intimacy 070414
 
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...
John Bruer Presentation to The Uses and Abuses of Biology: Neuroscience, Pare...
 
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014
Macvarish Uses and Abuses of Biology 28 March 2014
 
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...
Biologising Parenting: Neuroscience Discourse and English Social and Public H...
 
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...
A policy driven by prejudice masquerading as research: brain science and Engl...
 
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina john
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina johnThe dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina john
The dynamics between expertise, parenting norms and politics kristina john
 
Playful hanneknudsene mun
Playful hanneknudsene munPlayful hanneknudsene mun
Playful hanneknudsene mun
 
Parenting science 2011
Parenting science 2011Parenting science 2011
Parenting science 2011
 
Parenting and neuroscience
Parenting and neuroscienceParenting and neuroscience
Parenting and neuroscience
 
Pam lowe empty vessels
Pam lowe empty vesselsPam lowe empty vessels
Pam lowe empty vessels
 
Kent talk pickersgill
Kent talk pickersgillKent talk pickersgill
Kent talk pickersgill
 
Kent paper
Kent paperKent paper
Kent paper
 

The impact of obesity discourses on maternal identities, early feeding relationships and parenting practices

  • 1. The impact of obesity discourses on maternal identities and parenting practices Julia Keenan (UEA) Helen Stapleton (Australian Catholic University & Mater Mothers' Hospital) Feeding Children in the New Parenting Culture . British Library, 20 th March 2011.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. An expanded accounts framework (Monaghan 2008) Discursive framings… Accept pejorative status Deny or challenge pejorative status Accept responsibility Contrition (Compliance) Justifications (Critical compliance) Deny (relevance of) responsibility Excuses (Mitigation) Repudiation
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. “ even if I won the lottery and had loads of money, I still would not pay for liposuction or owt like that[..] I can’t see the point because that’s just the easy way out isn’t it, you’ve not learned anything by it, you’ve just gone and had all your fat sucked out of you […] If it’s for health problems, fair enough but not just to make themselves look good. I don’t, what’s the point; you are what you are” C1-O2/Fiona “ because he’s a bit of a slow grower really, erm, he’s sort of in the small range for his age. You know with respect to his weight and size. So I’m, I’m not forcing stuff down him but I’m encouraging him to eat. What he can but. He’s just not interested and I’m not physically holding his nose and forcing it down him […] but I am trying to encourage him to be interested in food” C2-O/Gemma
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16. Accept responsibility Deny responsibility Accept pejorative status Deny pejorative status Compliance Critical compliance Repudiation Mitigation Nighat
  • 17.