This document discusses the importance and benefits of developing early detection and rapid response networks to combat the spread of invasive species in Oregon. It provides examples of successful EDRR programs that have controlled invaders like yellow starthistle at a small scale before they spread widely. The key components of EDRR networks are outlined, including detection, verification, rapid assessment and response. Partnerships between agencies and organizations are emphasized as the most effective approach. Advice is given on getting started with an EDRR program, including focusing on priority species, utilizing existing resources, and building relationships.
1. Developing Early Detection and
Rapid Response Networks in Oregon
Why, How, and Resources for Getting Started
TA N I A S I E M E N S
SWCD CONNECT
APRIL 28, 2011
2. Fire and Invader: How to
Respond?
a. A new fire is sighted.. b. A small isolated patch of
yellow starthistle found on a
road side.
3. 10 years later…
a. Forest recovery with b. 150,000 acres of land
very little management infested with yellow
intervention starthistle after very costly
control efforts. Population
continues to spread and
cause damage.
7. Now too close for comfort!
May 2010 - Garlic mustard has
spread 5,700 gross acres in the
watershed and along about 20
miles of the Umatilla River!
8. Cost of Invasive
Species
$137 billion per year is the estimated economic
losses in the United States due to invasive species
83 million tax dollars spent on just 21 of the 91
noxious weeds in the state
Costs associated with the introduction of one
invasive mussel infestation in the Columbia Gorge
would exceed $25.5 million a year just for
maintenance of 13 hydropower facilities.
One invasive plant disease (Sudden Oak Death) is
estimated to cost Oregonians $80-$310 million per
year in lost nursery production if it becomes widely
established.
9. It costs more than money
to control invaders!
Bulldozing Invasive Beach Grass is helping the
snowy plover – but what are the unintended
consequences for native plants spices?
10. More than 40% of listed species are
declining due to non-native species.
11. Impacts from Invasives
• Reduce agricultural
production
• Limit recreation
• Degrade wildlife habitat
and forage
• Crowd out native plants THIS?
• Increase soil erosion
• Decrease water quality by
increasing temperature
and sediment
• And more….
Or THIS?Dyers woad
12. Invasive Plant Legacies?
In a recent study, native species grown in soil
conditioned with invasive species did worse
than what gown in soil conditioned with natives.
Leafy Spurge
Although a weed has been removed, it can
leave behind negative effects in the soil.
• Jordan et al. Evidence of Qualitative Differences between Soil-Occupancy Effects of Invasive vs. Native
Grassland Plant Species Invasive Plant Science and Management 2011 4:11–21
13. WHAT CAN
WE DO
ABOUT
THESE
INVADERS?
Earth Day Issue, Eugene Weekly,
April 21, 2011
14. HAVE HOPE!
• Oregon still has a lot of areas that
remain relatively free from harmful
invaders
• It has the lowest percentage of
perennial stream length occupied
by invasive plants compared to
other western states.
• N. Dakota 85%
• California 45%
• Utah 43%
• Washington 42%
• Oregon 38%
16. Early Detection and Rapid
Response (EDRR)!
… is the most low-impact and cost-effective
way to address the problem invasive plants,
short of preventing the problem in the first
place.
21. Yellow Starthistle
LESSON LEARNED?
EDRR PAYS!
$1 spent on prevention is $33
saved on control! (ODA)
22. What are the key EDRR components?
Detection Support for
Networks Interoperable
planning
Preliminary data sets/
Verification risk assessment Maps Adequate and
Species List Vouchering flexible funding
Identification Early Rapid Rapid
Detection Assessment Response
Education Experienced
practitioners
Multiple partners/Coordinated networks with defined roles
Adapted From: National Invasive Species Council. 2003. General Guidelines for the Establishment
and Evaluation of Invasive Species Early Detection and Rapid Response Systems. Version 1. 16
23. NETWORKS! The key to
EDRR success!
• Inter-agency cooperation!
• Share roles and responsibilities!
• Share distribution data!
• Treatment Information!
• Community Agency Connection!
• Improved landowner relationships!
• Added capacity!
25. More and More people and organizations
are starting EDRR networks!
Clackamas Columbia
SWCD Gorge
CWMA
Lincoln
SWCD
26. Determining your priority list
• EDRR = Large Scale!
• Look for species that are still not abundant
and possible to control at the county scale.
• Many counties already have species lists
developed.
• Suggest using ODA’s definition, only
applied to the county scale
28. Mapping and Data
Tracking is critical
Why? Because we have to prioritize.
For example: In the Willamette Valley, which
invasive species do we control first?
Giant hogweed? OR Scotch Broom?
32. Public and Staff trainings to
get more eyes on the ground!
• Overall trained over
1092 people!
– 105 people 2007
– 252 people in 2008
– 423 in 2009
– 312 people in 2010
Various Audiences:
1) Volunteers
2) Train the trainer
3) Agency Staff and
managers
(BLM/USFS/ODF)
4) Weyerhaeuser staff
5) Students!
33.
34. Educational Tools
Jackson County
Early Detection
Network Model
EDRR Plan
54. Now will get added to the
iMapInvasives Database!
55. Outcomes of invasive species reports 2010
shared Need to be unknown
info with verified 3%
property 2%
owner contacted
7% not a priority landowner 44 reports
7% 11% (78%) have
had some
level of
response.
mapped control plan in
12% place
26% 27 reports
(48%) have
follow up been
needed
11%
controlled or
controlled there is
14%
in planning some
process planning in
7%
place.
56. Who is responding?
• The following organizations helped respond
to priority species in their area:
– County weed programs
– City weed programs/volunteer programs
– Oregon Department of Transportation
– Oregon Department of Agriculture (for A listed
species)
– SWCD that have weed programs
• Lesson Learned: Established, funded,
weed programs critical to successful
responses !
58. Role of SWCDs in EDRR?
• Reach out to private land owners – this is
one of the biggest gaps in EDRR
networks!
• No one else taking the lead? Use EDRR
to meet your conservation goals!
• CWMA’s are the force behind weed work
when there is no weed district or weed
management area!
59. OK, I want to engage in EDRR
because it will help me reach my
conservation goals and save
money, but how do I get started?
63. Tip 2: Find a Partner in
Crime!
• Find a partner in crime with an agency or
other organization or person that is
involved in your CWMA and has interest in
weed control.
• Share the work load and bounce ideas off
of each other.
• Or even multiple people – a separate
EDRR committee if there that many willing
participants!
64. Tip 3: Baby Steps!
• Take baby steps so you don’t get
overwhelmed!
• Perhaps focus on one species, or one
area, one audience, or one time of year.
65. Think about where can you fit in:
Detection Support for
Networks Interoperable
planning
Preliminary data sets/
Verification risk assessment Maps Adequate and
Species List Vouchering flexible funding
Identification Early Rapid Rapid
Detection Assessment Response
Education Experienced
practitioners
Multiple partners/Coordinated networks with defined roles
Adapted From: National Invasive Species Council. 2003. General Guidelines for the Establishment
and Evaluation of Invasive Species Early Detection and Rapid Response Systems. Version 1. 16
66. Can you…..?
- Help put on a training for your staff or for the
public?
- Work with partners to decide priority species?
- Receive and forward reports from the hotline?
- Provide information to land owners?
- Agree to respond to invaders for certain areas?
69. Tips 5: Take time to build
relationships – EDRR is
working together!
70. It is going to take all of us—land
owners, land
managers, recreationists, and
concerned citizens—working
together and sharing information
as quickly as possible, to keep
ahead of new weed invaders.
71. By working together we can
catch garlic mustard before it
goes to seed…
Thank you! Please feel free to contact me!
tania.siemens@oregonstate.edu
1-541-914-0701
72. Who is reporting?
• In 2010, 39 people submitted 56 reports.
• Most reports come from just a handful of
people.
• Only 26 of the reporters (66%), had
attended a weed watcher training.
• 14 (36%) of those who reported were
natural resource professionals!
Hinweis der Redaktion
Many people agree that Early Detection and Rapid Response offers an approach that will help prevent damaging and costly invasions from occurring in the first place. But, how do you get an EDRR program started? What are the key elements of a successful program? At this session you will learn about The Nature Conservancy and Oregon Sea Grant’s efforts to develop volunteer-based early detection networks in Oregon. We will share our successes, challenges, and provide tips and guidelines on how to start and maintain your own program. Concerning your presentation, I would like you to speak about the weed watchers program: history, successes, areas for improvement (if any), how to start the program in Montana, how to keep the program going once started, and anything else you think is necessary or helpful. I saw that you have materials for starting your own program, maybe you could introduce each of these and we could have them to pass out to anyone interested.
Asher: “Which is the most urgent?” Answer – about the same.Term emergency used easily in fire emergency “Emergency Fire Rehab” analogy.Topic of fire is tricky. He was trained to say that fire was not an “emergency”, they need to approach it without panicking. “Small infestations are just as much of an emergency and attacking small new fires”
New weed infestations need to be treated with the same urgency as new fire.
This Monday, May 3rd, Dan Durfey, Umatilla County Weed Supervisor and Dan Sharratt, ODA Regional Weed Specialist, confirmed a site of garlic mustard along the Umatilla River near Pendleton. They have done an initial delimitation survey and have detected other infestations. It currently looks like garlic mustard is spread over about 5,700 gross aces in the watershed and along about 20 miles of the Umatilla River.
Some native plants, however, were unaffected by the invaders’ detrimental impact on the soil. This knowledge offers land managers some species that can be used positively as cover crops, or “nurse” plants.
This is Rick Hall, Range Conservationist, pulling yellowstar he happened to see while on his regular duties in a Andrews Research Area in the Pubelo Mtns. Burns dist.
Prevention is the most cost-effective. Oregon Department of Agriculture estimates a benefit of $34 for every $1 spentPrevention is developed to change behavior and stop the spread of weeds or other invasives. It can be educational which encourages cooperation or regulatory which mandates compliance with rules.Early Detection- find the invader before it has a chance to rapidly spread and make efforts to eradicate it. When eradication is not possible, then contain the infestation. This not only reduces the cost of control but often prevents the need for expensive site restoration.Established Infestations- control or containment is prescribed for established infestations. Effective control often entails control treatments at the perimeter of an infestation. Control the perimeter and
4. Will we provide staff (who?) representation for on-going and new partnership-projects such as the Middlefork USFS IGO/Middlefork Watershed Council False Brome Working Group, IAE Horton Meadow knapweed Control Work/Partnership, Willamette National Forest Research Project on False Brome, and others (or will we)? These projects provide valuable treatment information, community and agency connection and often added capacity to get work accomplished that we cannot do alone, but we need to invest time and funds to make them work.
False brome Partnership This group is made up of an interagency group of land managers in partnership with the Middlefork Watershed Council, who are focusing efforts within the Middle Fork of the Willamette Watershed to control false brome. The group is now broadening to address all invasive species within the watershed! Also note:MFWWC is launching EDRR programCritical importance of mapping – how can you prioritize if you don’t know what your options are?
Elements of an EDRR network1) Multiple partners2) Agreement on a list of priority species3) Agreement to respond to priority species4) Public educational component5) Priority areas or boundaries identified6) Monitoring by either staff or volunteers7) Mapping and tracking species and reports
Issue: How will we fund an updated invasive plant inventory for the District (or will we)?Our data is getting old and accurate NEPA analysis and control efforts would benefit from new data.
http://whatsinvasive.com/
(excluding Multnomah, Sandy Basin, and Clackamas Weed Watchers)
False brome Partnership This group is made up of an interagency group of land managers in partnership with the Middlefork Watershed Council, who are focusing efforts within the Middle Fork of the Willamette Watershed to control false brome. The group is now broadening to address all invasive species within the watershed! Also note:MFWWC is launching EDRR programCritical importance of mapping – how can you prioritize if you don’t know what your options are?
SWCD’s can have easy access to landowners and the least threatening presence as far as government goes. Landowner agreements can often be built in a matter of days or hours and are more maneuverable. SWCDs have the ability to essentially partner with any landowner in the County to treat or facilitate the treatment of invasives.
Elements of an EDRR network1) Multiple partners2) Agreement on a list of priority species3) Agreement to respond to priority species4) Public educational component5) Priority areas or boundaries identified6) Monitoring by either staff or volunteers7) Mapping and tracking species and reports
Utilize resources available such as Tania’s program materials. Go to meetings outside of your County to see what others are doing. This suggestion may be old-hat but I can tell you I would not have gotten as far as I am without having some sort of outline such as the Upper Willamette CWMA and your materials. The weed guide pamphlet has also been a huge help.